# Some Aspects of Indian Commerce and Industry
*G. Findlay Shirras* (1911)
> Akshara Machine Checked Edition · Collection: `indian-economic-history`


## INDIAN COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY


<!-- page: 1 | folio: 1 -->

### INDIAN COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY

SHIRRAS


## SOME ASPECTS OF INDIAN COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY


<!-- page: 5 | folio: 5 -->

### SOME ASPECTS OF INDIAN COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY

BY

G. FINDLAY SHIRRAS, M.A., I.E.S

(ON SPECIAL DUTY)

*Finance Department, Government of India, Calcutta*

1911


<!-- page: 6 | folio: 6 -->
PRINTED BY
G. A. NATESON & CO.,
MADRAS.


## SOME ASPECTS OF INDIAN COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY.


<!-- page: 7 | folio: 1 -->

### SOME ASPECTS OF INDIAN COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY.

THE title which I have chosen for this paper admits of numerous forms of treatment. I might describe to you the vast trade of this great empire—an empire which is a land of many countries, I might dilate on the numerous expansion of Indian trade during the last few decades especially with Great Britain, the United States, Germany and China. I am, however, not to expatiate on this topic except incidentally. My aim is rather to devote myself to Indian industrial developments and to the question of Indian tariffs. My chief aim is to show how the future of India is inseparably bound up with its industrial developments. India will require in the near future a systematic development of its resources and the organisation of a trained industrial population. After one tours in all parts of India, he cannot but come to five conclusions :—

*Firstly.*—That India perhaps more than any other country in Asia is in the throes of a great transition and this transition is marked in questions affecting industrial developments. [p. 2] The village in India is no longer a self-contained economic community and the impact of the West is responsible for this change. In Bengal, Madras, Bombay and in the United Provinces one sees vast industrial enterprises being undertaken. India’s wealth is now, if ever, being produced by the organisation of industry. Organisation has been seen to be imperative ; the industrial regeneration of India can be effected by no other means.

*Secondly.*—Agriculture is and must remain by far the most important of Indian industries and the essential basis of India’s prosperity. Two-thirds of the population subsist on agriculture.

*Thirdly.*—Indian agriculture is in a distinctly backward position ; there is much waste, and production is not what it might be. It is impossible to generalise about Indian agriculture. Dr. Voelcker some 20 years ago contested the popular belief that Indian agriculture is primitive and backward. One cannot deny that Dr. Voelcker was rather optimistic, and in every country of the world the application of modern scientific principles has been exceptionally beneficial, and there seems no reason why Indian methods of agriculture should lag behind those of other countries. In the United States, in Australia and in [p. 3] many European countries enormous advances have been made in recent years. We have, it is true, greater difficulties than those countries, because we are not dealing with a population of four millions dependent on the soil but with a population of two hundred millions, and the co-operation which is essential to success is not always forthcoming. There is the additional difficulty of the ryots’ holdings being small and in most cases their being scattered over different areas in the same village, or even in different villages.

*Fourthly.*—This is the labourer’s day. Labour is scarce, and the scarcity is felt in all parts of India, especially in the Punjab. Labour too in the long run is expensive ; I mean in proportion to its result labour is not cheap. Everyone hears Indian employers complaining of the scarcity of labour. I think the real cause is unquestionably the state of transition to which so many of India’s present difficulties must be ascribed. Factory labour is not yet popular, and the recruitment of this labour is not very well organised. An employer of Indian labour has pointed out that the object of the factory hand first and foremost is to get to pay day by the easiest possible route. Added to this is the habit of the men to throw themselves recklessly out of employment, because they know [p. 4] that the joint family or friends will support them when in need. We must remember that the Indian labour is inefficient not so much from lack of capacity or inherent laziness, but because the workers will not regard the work in the mills as their permanent calling in life. The factory system in other words is entirely alien to Indian ideas and tradition.

*Fifthly.*—There must be a much more efficient and widespread system of technical education, and men are required with high qualifications who are capable of controlling big factories and even of starting industries on their own account. There are, it is true, admirable institutions such as the Engineering Colleges of Poona, Roorkee, the Sibpur Civil Engineering College near Calcutta, the Engineering Schools of Dacca and Bankipore, the Victoria Jubilee Technical Institute in Bombay and the Indian Institute of Science at Bangalore which is a magnificent project of the late Mr. Jamsetjee Tata. The need for elementary technical education suitable for boys and girls who do not aspire to be more than working artisans is essential.

These are the axioms which we must premise before dealing with any question of Indian Commerce and Industry. It is necessary also to add [p. 5] that these topics must be approached with a clear gaze and a good conscience. Now-a-days we take too pessimistic a view of Indian economic problems, and not a few of us are of the firm belief that human ingenuity and energy cannot solve them. We require a more sympathetic treatment of Indian economic questions and at the same time we require statements, undisfigured by those vote-catching sophisms which make current literature such unprofitable reading. Statistics are the straw out of which economists have to make the bricks. “ The Statistician,” says Mr. D. E. Wacha, “ is the great purveyor who supplies the Economist with the facts on which to build his sound and sure economic postulates and economic arguments, apart from fresh hypotheses and corrected or new theories. The Economist mainly treats of phenomena relating to groups of facts, each group being a watertight compartment by itself. But he has to go to the statistician for his fundamental materials.” The chief drawback in Indian economic discussion to-day is the utter lack of reliable statistical data which have been treated scientifically ; facts must be scientifically collected, sifted and analysed and from these facts only can a theory be formulated. Fragments of pure theory, only true under certain ideal conditions, must not [p. 6] be paraded as actual facts, easily realisable in every-day commerce and industry. For example, how many there are who forget that the most important portion of the data from which the science of Economics reasons, is human character and human institutions, and everything consequently which affects that character or these institutions must create new problems. In India, the labourer is usually his own master, and in addition to supplying labour necessary for production of wealth he undertakes also the risks of production which in Europe are borne by the employer. It is obvious that such a country cannot compare with that of countries in which industry is directed by technical skill, administrative ability and ample capital. The religious ideals of life preclude the Indian from an ardent pursuit of wealth, and moreover the laws of inheritance among the Hindus encourage the subdivision and not concentration of wealth. Peace and security, rather than accumulation and possession of wealth, are what the average Indian wants. In dealing with questions of Indian economic conditions we must not jump at hasty conclusions. If a fur coat is good for a Canadian winter, it is not equally so for an Indian cold weather, nor is a dhoti (so suitable for India) equally suitable for Canada.


<!-- page: 13 | folio: 7 -->
Yet curiously enough she is the one country which most requires strong Free Traders who will analyse this uncritical protectionism in order to discern whether or not, if protection did come, tariffs would not bolster up industry after industry at the expense of the community. Conservatism in production—the chief weakness of Indian industry—may be perpetuated by an indiscriminate protective tariff. We must be careful, for protection is often found to rest less on reasoning than on sentiment.


#### EXPORT DUTIES.

Two essentials in discussing export duties are frequently omitted, *viz.*, (1) that an export duty cannot be supported by a corresponding excise duty as in the case of imports and (2) the outside country is practically the whole commercial world. If a protective duty is levied, the outsider or foreigner will pay the whole or in part, provided he does not manage to obtain substitutes, and provided the demand is intense. To-day the possibility of finding substitutes is increasing rapidly. In discussing the economic propriety of export duties we may lay it down as a general rule that export duties should not be levied by India except where she has a monopoly of supply of the commodity [p. 8] on which the duty is put, or such advantage in its production as to approximate to a monopoly. The export duty of cinnamon in Ceylon is of importance as illustrating the case in point. When Ceylon had a monopoly of that spice it was very profitable. It was dropped in 1833, too late to save the Colony's pre-eminence in the export of cinnamon. Similarly in India in 1857 there were export duties levied chiefly on grain, rice, indigo, lac, opium, silk, tobacco and native manufactures. Since 1860 these have been abolished with the exception of rice, opium and and a few other commodities. The duty on rice is economically justifiable, owing to exceptional producing power possessed by India, the exporting country. Almost the entire supplies of the cereal sent to foreign countries are drawn from Burma, the granary of India, and it is employed not merely as a food grain but also for distillation and in the manufacture of starch. Great economies are effected in the production particularly in the Burma rice mills, *e.g.*, the husk is conveyed by special contrivances to furnaces and there consumed while a stream of water below carries off the ash. We owe much to European capitalists, for, it is to them that the credit of this prosperous industry is due. Another advantage in production [p. 9] is due to the fact that the monsoon never fails in Burma. Bad seasons, however, in other parts of India are apt to cause the diversion of rice which ordinarily would have been exported to foreign markets. Some hold that the case for rice export duty to-day is hardly so good as formerly, owing to the fact—firstly, that there are several substitutes for rice in starch manufacture and, secondly, that the value of raw jute exports is much greater than rice and therefore a monopoly (*e. g.* jute) might be a more fit subject for an export duty. If there is, as some argue, a probability in the future of the supply not proving equal to the demand, an export duty would be still more advantageous to the producers (*i. e.* to India) generally.


#### IMPORT DUTIES.

Import duties are generally supposed to be paid ultimately by the consumer, as was ostensibly the case recently in the new duties on tobacco. In the United States of America and other productive countries, it is argued that the exporting country abroad pays. Most usually the import duty falls on the consumer. Suppose protective duties on cotton were to be re-imposed, as previous to 1879, without an accompanying excise duty ; what would be the result if there were free markets in [p. 10] other parts of the world where Lancashire could send her cotton? Less cotton would be sent to India, unless India paid the duty, which is unlikely. The paying of the duty would check the demand ; hence the reaction on the production of manufactured cotton in Lancashire. But so far as Lancashire supplies so much cotton manufacture, she will bear part of the duty. The price of cotton manufactures in India will rise, but in view of the modern system of production, the price will never rise to the full extent of the tax. Should an import duty be put by India on a commodity which she takes only in small quantities relatively, and if the supply can be readjusted easily, and if there are other free markets, India will pay as consumer the whole of the tax, and the price may rise more than by the amount of the import duty.

It is impossible to concede without a detailed examination of Indian industries whether any or all of them would be better off under a system of protective tariff. After a somewhat detailed analysis of the various industries I find that no protection is possible at present for our jute manufactures, our paper-making, coal, tea, indigo, and coffee interests. Protection or bounties, however, may be possible on iron which is important [p. 11] to other industries, cotton, tobacco and petroleum. I am uncertain with regard to silk and sugar. It is impossible to arrive at these conclusions except after careful deliberation as it is always dangerous to dip into India’s purse on the ground of manifest simplicity of assisting Indian industry. During the last 10 years the petroleum industry has developed to an astounding degree; in 1898, 190 lakhs of gallons were produced of which Burma produced 184 lakhs or 97 per cent. of India’s produce; ten years later the production had increased to 1,520 lakhs, of which Burma produced 1,488 lakhs gallons. This means an increase of 700 per cent. Almost the whole supply comes from Burma and Assam, and very little from the Punjab. In spite of the progress that has been made, it is curious that India imports mineral oil to a value equivalent to two and a half times of her own output. There seems good chance of expanding an industry at the expense of the United States, Roumania, the Straits Settlements, Sumatra and Russia.


#### INFANT INDUSTRIES.

England has certainly prospered under Free Trade and she has been free from many of the incidental dangers of protection. Still, however, there is no need of adding in view of this, “Free [p. 12] Trade ” as an eleventh commandment to the Decalogue. India, it must be remembered, is not pre-eminently fitted to become a great manufacturing country in the British or American sense of the term. There is, however, scope for diversified industries which she already possesses potentially. To the infant industries argument, economists have always conceded the greatest weight whether the argument is urged in a special or general form. There are, as you know, risks and difficulties which always attend the domestication of new branches of production. If a country like India is agricultural and has no large and important classes of artisans and factory workers, the skill required for commencing any kind of mill will be exceedingly difficult. Competition with established foreign rivals will be impossible in spite of the fact that the country has great natural advantages. Once the industry which is being domesticated has been wisely chosen and the initial difficulties have been overcome, the duty should be withdrawn. Such a policy will mean a burden on those who consume what is produced by that industry, but the supporters hold that once the infant is vigorous, there will be more than a compensating gain, or in other words, the crutches to teach the new manufacturers to walk, [p. 13] may teach them very much earlier than the industries should otherwise have learned to do. Accordingly, the cost of the crutches is more than repaid There are many difficulties as, for example, the length of the period for such protection. In India one industry may require even 30 years, while another but 15 or 20. Moreover, it is most difficult for a Government to use the argument fairly and honestly. Behind a tariff wall, there will be a number of industries which can never exist without it, and it is a far wiser policy to let these die than be a burden. Protection is, as the term itself implies, and as the American tariff on woollens, and the French and German agricultural tariffs have demonstrated too often, a policy for the weak and not for the strong. Ah ! Gentlemen, how often do we find the motive power behind a tariff, a chronic clamour of self-seeking classes without any spirit of philosophic contentment !


#### THE “ DRAIN.”

There is an aspect of Indian commerce and industry which during the last few years has been of special interest to many Indian gentlemen. I refer to the so-called “ Drain ” which ostensibly means that there is an excess of exports over imports annually and, *ipso facto*, a drain of wealth is [p. 14] taking place. It is inopportune to weary you with economic reasonings (sometimes exasperatingly dull) as to how imports and exports balance one another and how there are many more imports and exports, than are dreamt of in the philosophy of our commerce and industry returns. During the last few years, the United States, probably the richest country in the world, has an excess of exports over imports of Rs. 142 crores, Russia Rs. 51 crores, Australia Rs. 23 crores, Brazil Rs. 22 crores and Argentine Republic Rs. 17 crores ; India’s excess of exports over imports averages Rs. 27 crores ; on the other hand, Persia imports more than she exports and yet she is certainly not rich nor does she enjoy successful foreign trade. Indian statistics are frequently misread and how frequently are they the real spawning ground of much misunderstanding and of much vilification of economic problems to-day ! The reason of exports over imports is due, in the first place, to economic status and not to political status. Of these countries mentioned above the majority consisted of young countries whose stores of wealth have just been tapped while the others (pre-eminently among which are India, Servia and Roumania) had an *effete* industrial organisation which was now being displaced by a more [p. 15] up-to-date organisation that will go far to make competition fairer. Again, there is an increase of wealth to the owners of land and to workers themselves, as well as to capitalists. Australia fully realising the truth of this, willingly pays to Great Britain annually Rs. 23 crores as interest and she has but 40 lakhs of population—and 1/100th part of the accumulated wealth of India. Some may argue that so far as the excess of exports over imports represents interests or capital invested no objection can be taken. It was to the sums paid owing to India’s political connexion that exception is taken. The sum is no longer Rs. 27 crores but Rs. 9¾ crores.


| Col 1 | Col 2 | Col 3 | Col 4 |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Payments in connexion with Civil Departments in India | Rs. | 26. | lakhs. |
| Army and Marine effective charges | „ | 127 | „ |
| India Office | „ | 32 | „ |
| Furlough allowances | „ | 127 | „ |
| Pensions and gratuities | „ | 666 | „ |
|  | Rs. | 9¾ | crores. |

This sum of 9¾ crores is not tribute because a tribute is payment exacted without equivalent services but this sum in question is a payment for work done, for services rendered. As a distinguished [p. 16] Indian (Mr. Justice Ranade) said addressing his own countrymen: “It cannot well be a mere accident that the destinies of this country have been entrusted to the guidance of a nation whose characteristic strength is opposed to all our weaknesses, whose enterprise in commerce and manufactures knows no bounds, whose capital overflows the world, whose view of life is full of hope, and whose powers of organisation have never been surpassed.”

Let me say a few words more as Parthian shots. Great Britain’s credit enables India to borrow in the money market on terms which she could not do otherwise and this saving more than compensates for the cost of services. Japan with all its infinite capacity for taking pains, and with all its hard study of that branch of economies (which is called Finance) cannot borrow so cheaply as India. Japan pays for her loans 8 per cent. while India were she independent could not borrow at a lower rate than 6 or 7 per cent. This saving of 2½ per cent. on her present permanent debt would be a little over 9 crores of rupees, equivalent almost to the sum which forms the Home charges for the services which India receives. Again, India enjoys free of charge the use of the Ambassadors as well as Consuls of His [p. 17] Majesty’s Government, throughout the world. This huge saving cannot be estimated with accuracy, but it is indeed great. Lastly, India enjoys the services of the British Navy. The Navy costs some Rs. 44½ crores a year (for 1909, the estimates were Rs. 54 crores) India contributes but a modest lakh. At the same time we admit with the heartiest satisfaction and deepest sense of pride that the Indian Army is a source of strength to the British Empire, when, however, we total up the debits and credits we certainly find India receives more than she gives. I hope then that this, although one of the most curious of paradoxes, will appear to be one of the most transparent of fallacies.


#### INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT.

I come now to the question of industrial development and though I shall treat it briefly, I hope I shall not be considered dogmatical. The development of industrial undertakings and industrial education is certainly one of the foremost of administrative problems, especially in these provinces where there are rich resources not yet systematically developed and where too, unfortunately there is little aptitude or enterprise shown in utilising them. Gentlemen, we must not be blind to this principal cause of the failure of Indian industry [p. 18] There is an awful lack of enterprise in agriculture, hand-loom weaving, sugar production, oil-pressing, not to mention the production of manufactured articles of a complex character. Cotton weaving, *e. g.* is conducted on archaic and exceedingly wasteful lines. I have already referred to Indian agriculture and it being the principal industry of India no consideration of the industrial development can be complete without a reference to a topic which roughly requires special treatment.


#### AGRICULTURE.

Agriculture means the culture of the people who live on the soil, as well as the cultivation of the soil itself. Our chief difficulty lies in the fact that Indian agriculture is in the hands of small men, the capital is required in small sums, and it is supplied by small capitalists to men of small commercial intelligence at anything but a small rate of interest. During my tours in the United Provinces, Bengal, Eastern Bengal and Assam, Central Provinces and the Bombay Presidency I was much struck by the lack of real practical knowledge amongst the ryots who are conservative to a fault. Many conclusions arrived at Agricultural Colleges in this country are never heard of even by the better class cultivators. We [p. 19] perhaps are to be blamed slightly in this matter. There is only one way of improving the ryots’ welfare and that is the eternal truth of getting into their skins, of realising their ideas and feelings. When once we see their point of view we shall guide them with greater ease to adopting improved methods of agriculture. Then will they take to improving their jute crops, *e. g.* in cultivating a whiter fibre, in growing jute in rotation with paddy—a very profitable and economical enterprise—in planting and transplanting paddy more carefully and cheaply and in cultivating new staples. The soy bean, for example, has undoubtedly enormous interest for India and a struggle between bean oil and cotton oil in the soap countries in the world has already begun. If its introduction into this country is successful there should be little difficulty in competing with Manchuria. Dry Farming which has been so successful in America might be introduced in a larger degree. Dry Farming means roughly the cultivation of drought resisting plants and also the most advantageous use of rainfall on the soil by careful preparation. A great deal can be done in the way of co-operation whether in the form of credit societies or of supply societies, *e. g.* for providing the materials of [p. 20] agriculture, productive societies, *e.g.*, co-operative dairies and sale societies such as lac or grain societies. When in Eastern Bengal and Assam I found some startling rates of interest. Three villagers borrowed a maund of rice when the market price was Rs. 6 per maund. Not being able to pay in cash they made a bond for Rs. 7 stipulating for interest at 150 per cent. compounded every three months. In less than three years they were sued for Rs. 200 and the Munsiff decreed the entire claim. In another case three villagers executed a bond for Rs. 9 for cloth purchased stipulating for interest at 187½ per cent. every quarter. The same Munsiff gave a decree for the principal with simple interest at 75 per cent. I know of another case where 2 men took a a loan of Rs. 15 at Re. 1 interest a day which comes to 2,433⅓ per cent. yearly. At the end of three years an *ex-parte* decree for a claim of Rs. 999 was given. There is scope for a more extensive use of agricultural machinery, but sufficient attention will have to be paid to the peculiarities of local agricultural methods. The work of Mr. W. H. Moreland, Director of Agriculture, United Provinces, has been very successful in this respect. Co-operative rural societies may own jointly agricultural implements and [p. 21] will decrease the limitations imposed by the scarcity of capital in agriculture. Bengali ryot like his frater in the Deccan is supremely critical of any machine containing unnecessary parts or whose utility is not obvious. Superficial finish of machines, *e. g.* highly varnished and coloured metal surfaces so attractive to the European is not desired by the Indian cultivator. There are local peculiarities, *e. g.* the ryot of Eastern Bengal and Assam does only about ½ or ⅔ of the work of an efficient English labourer, his pair of bullocks can do but ½ the work of an English pair of horses. His oxen are trained to go counter-clockwise and gears must be designed accordingly. The flexor muscles are better developed than the extensors, so the ryots work more effectively with a drawing than with a thrusting stroke. Lastly, he would rather sit down to turn a horizontal wheel, than stand up and turn a vertical wheel for a much shorter period.


#### WEAVING.

Of industries closely allied to agriculture, weaving is the most important. 80 per cent. of the weavers in Eastern Bengal and Assam are engaged in agricultural pursuits. Dacca has always been famous for its muslins—Abrawan or “running water,” Bafthwa or “woven air,” Shabnam or [p. 22] “evening dew,” though these are almost a thing of the past; and the demand in Europe for the old cotton flowered and sprigged muslin has almost entirely fallen off; when Burke prepared his impeachment of Warren Hastings the output of muslins and silks of Dacca was declared to have an annual value of Rs. 52,50,000. Though this sum is probably exaggerated yet in Europe there was an exceptionally huge demand for these celebrated goods. To-day, European taste has entirely changed and chiffon and similar substitutes have taken the place of Dacca muslins. Another reason for the decline is that there is an increasing sale of Japanese silks. A few years ago, I got three grades of chiffons from London and the prices were roughly-/12/-, 1/-and 1/7/-. Prices of similar grades of Dacca muslins are about 13 or 14 annas and one rupee thirteen annas to 3 rupees, ten annas a yard. The chiffon indeed looks even better than the local muslins. The salvation of weavers does not lie in the adoption of large and often expensive looms. It will be more expedient, firstly, to utilise existing looms to better advantage by slight alterations which will increase the yield in many cases to 30 per cent. and, secondly, to assist the weavers to buy yarn cheap and to sell their products dear. There is no use at present [p. 23] for a central weaving school in Dacca until we have first looked to these points. In Eastern Bengal and Assam quite 75 per cent. of the weavers are dependent on Mahajans. In many provinces that I have visited, a weaver gets very little more than the cost price in good seasons and very much less than this price in bad years. What is wanted is an organisation to enable the weavers to dispose of their wares as economically as possible. There is no need at present for large expenditure on bricks, mortar, and laboratory appliances. Our industrial development is not, as many are apt to think, a matter that can be hustled and hurried.


#### **SUGAR.**

The most striking fact of Indian Commerce in recent years has been the tremendous and unparalleled expansion in our sugar imports. This is specially phenomenal when we remember that India is probably the largest producer of sugar in the world and sugar is indispensable for a warm country like that we live in. It, however, cannot be said that the cultivation of sugar cane in India is contracting seriously because of these imports. We have to remember that the sugar cane in India is often grown in small patches which defy estimate and moreover the great mass of the sugar cane of this [p. 24] country is not converted into crystalline sugar but is consumed in the form of crude sugar or gur which is more nutritious than refined sugar. It is at the same time impossible not to believe that this huge importation of foreign sugar at the rate of 107 lacs of cwts. yearly or nearly 2 seers per head of population can be continued without affecting the internal industry as a whole. You ask then what is to be done ? We are not taking pains enough in the struggle for markets. We ought to develop the central factory system, *i.e.* factory situated in the centre of a tract of land reserved for sugar and its rotation of crops only. The cane is then as near the mill as possible and cultivation, cutting, etc. can be done with the least possible waste. The complete triumph of this system is seen in the regeneration of the sugar industry in Formosa by the Japanese, and in Porto Rico. The Java planters according to the British Consul in the island, are devoting a large portion of their profits to improving their methods of production, while steps are being taken to provide better transport and machinery of the latest type. The price of imported sugar will fall probably as a result of this and Indian sugar will be subject to serious competition in its own markets. A protective tariff, I do not think, will cure this lack of [p. 25] enterprise. The ryots are strongly averse to using effective crushing mills. The most suitable mills are the three roller mills and these might be purchased by some of our rural co-operative societies. At the Allahabad Exhibition, the Hadi plant proved its excellence and sugar making by this process among better-class cultivators would be profitable. In some provinces, there is great need for the Central Factory system. In Eastern Bengal and Assam, the East India Company had extensive mills and even to this day, there still remain some large sugar factories. In Rangpur especially as the district has a belt of country on both banks of the Jamuneswari suited for cane cultivation there are special advantages for a central factory.

I cannot go into details in the present paper with regard to the production of goods of a complex character on a large scale by up-to-date methods. It is necessary, nevertheless, to refer to the importance of choosing a good locality in which raw material and fuel can be obtained cheaply, and from which goods produced can be readily transported to the consuming markets. There is need also of obtaining well-paid skilful artisans as the results of the experiments of employing captains of industry on this basis has [p. 26] been exceptionally successful in Japan. We must not forget that Indian industry is limited by capital. Without capital, land cannot be cultivated, mines cannot be worked, nor can factories be constructed. We are apt to think that laws and governments can create industry. This is seen in the argument for protection to native industry as the sole panacea. Government is playing a noble and generous part in increasing the efficiency of labour by education and sanitary legislation and it is thus enabling capital to do more work. When all is said and done it still remains true that one of the real limits to industry is capital.


#### CAPITAL.

The investment of British Capital in India has been discussed at length in two interesting papers read by Mr. George Paish before the Royal Statistical Society in 1909 and in 1910 respectively. Mr. Paish remarks : “ No one can doubt the beneficent effect upon the prosperity of India of this expenditure of British capital for the development of the natural resources of the country, and the linking up of district with district, which has so powerfully helped to diminish the severity of famines. The great sums shown below have been lent to India at an exceptionally [p. 27] low rate of interest, and having regard to the immense increase in the wealth of the Indian people which has resulted, and is resulting, from the construction of railways, the burden of the low interest charge is quite negligible.” The details are as follows :—


| Item | £ (000’s omitted). |
| --- | --- |
| Government | 178,995 |
| Municipal | 3,522 |
| Railways | 136,519 |
| Banks | 3,400 |
| Commercial and Industrial, etc. | 2,647 |
| Electric lighting and power | 1,763 |
| Financial, land and investment | 1,853 |
| Gas and water | 659 |
| Iron, coal and steel | 803 |
| Mines | 3,531 |
| Motor traction and manufacturing | 90 |
| Oil | 3,184 |
| Rubber | 4,610 |
| Tea and coffee | 19,644 |
| Telegraphs and telephones | 43 |
| Tramways | 4,136 |
| Total | 365,399 |

It is interesting to note that Australasia has [p. 28] borrowed 380 millions, Canada and Newfoundland 373 millions and South Africa 351 millions, the United States 688 millions and Argentine 270 millions, followed by Brazil, Mexico and Japan with 94, 87, and 54 millions respectively. Mr. R. N. Mukerjee, C.I.E., an eminent Indian business man, in the course of his Presidential Address at the Indian Industrial Conference in 1910, said in words which must be repeated : “Indian capital is proverbially shy and unenterprising, but this I ascribe largely to a want of industrial and commercial knowledge on the part of Indian capitalists, and consequent failure to realise the potentialities of the various schemes placed before them, coupled with a disinclination to depart from those time-honoured methods of investing and lending money, which have been in force for so many centuries and, in many instances, bring in a return which can only be considered as usury. India, generally speaking, is a poor country, that is to say, the majority of the population are poor. But there is wealth in India, and the possessors of it could, with but a fractional part of their amassed wealth, not only develop many of the industries that are dormant to-day, but make India industrially equal to any other country in the world. We often see articles in Indian newspapers, or hear [p. 29] speeches from public platforms, condemning the use of foreign (English) capital for the development of Indian industries. But, I am afraid, those who hold such views do not seriously consider the question in all its aspects. Apart from the fact that foreign capital is only attracted by signs of peace and prosperity, and that we know that foreign capital is welcome in any other country for the development of her industries, an important consideration for us in India arises from the fact that, for our own good, it is wise to allow British capitalists to interest themselves in our industries, and thus take an active part in their development. That industrial enterprise can be successful in India is amply proved by the many large and thriving industries, representing millions of capital which already exist, and it is a reproach to us, as a people, that practically the whole of these, with the exception of a certain number on the Bombay side, have been financed and developed by English capital and energy. It is true that when these industries were first started, our countrymen had little interest in, or knowledge of, such enterprises, but that attitude is rapidly changing, and it should be our aim and endeavour to emulate the example set us by our English fellow-subjects and to join with them in [p. 30] the industrial development of India.” It is the fashion in some quarters to protest against the incoming of British capital. India could well do with more of it. Canada and the Argentine Rupublic are having their railroads constructed for them and are increasing their trade in a way they could never do without this capital. The bulk of the Canadian and Argentine shares have gone into railroad construction. India is credited with the comparatively small sum of Rs. 4½ crores for her railways including the much-required feeder railways for developing new centres of industry. The opening up of communications has had a great deal to do with the increase of incomes of ryots and the industrial classes. Between 1875 and 1895, agricultural income rose from Rs. 26 to Rs. 35 or 39 per cent., the non-agricultural income from Rs. 28 to Rs. 34 or 18 per cent. and as these two classes were 97 per cent. of the population the average annual income of the masses had risen from Rs. 27 to Rs. 35 or 28 per cent. The income of all classes taken together had risen from Rs. 30 to Rs. 39 or an increase in the average income of 29 per cent. These figures have been carefully compiled and deserve high respect. The increased prosperity consequent on the opening up of the country is seen in an [p. 31] increased consumption per head of salt in a large development of excise revenue during the period, in the great increase of Savings Bank Deposits and in the decreasing severity of famines.


#### LABOUR.

I have already referred incidentally to Indian labour and, I am afraid, I have wearied you with some ostensibly cryptic observations. I had intended to show you how production was hungering for labour which is at present like an army without leaders. I should have liked to show you a very practical scheme of my own, *viz.*, the formation of labour exchanges. This exchange would be concerned with the numbers, movements, and condition of labour. There is, of course, always the risk that Government might appear to guarantee the terms of employment, but this disadvantage could be easily overcome. It would be to the interest of the Government itself to furnish information which may guide it in legislation and it would be in the direct interest of the labourers so that employers and employed may be brought together without the evils of the present Arkati system. Similar schemes have been successful in the United States of America, in Switzerland and more recently in the United Kingdom.


<!-- page: 38 | folio: 32 -->
A great deal remains to be done with regard to our industrial development. As I have said a protective tariff has often been put forward as the best means to tend to an effective development. It is a contentious matter on which there is at present no necessity to enter into, but it may be observed that tariffs alone will not expand the industries of India. The Bombay mill-owners handicapped their own industry by unwise methods of finance and control which militate against prosperity far more than the excise duty. A pressing need for India to-day is the unlocking of hoarded capital which ought to be put to reproductive uses. The process has begun and its continuance is imperative to the industrial development of India. Twenty years ago, hardly any manganese ore was produced in India, but last year the quantity exported was 572,979 tons and the value was Rs. 91·9 lakhs. The advance on the previous year was therefore 14·5 per cent. in quantity and 16·2 per cent. in value. No attempt has yet been made to manufacture ferro-manganese. Again nothing has been done in regard to the manufacture of sulphuric acid on a large scale, as everyone knows that sulphuric acid is the key to most economic and to many metallurgical industries. This has been frequently manifested [p. 33] by Sir Thomas Holland. India pays 30 crores annually for products obtained in Europe from minerals identical with those lying idle in her own soil. A great deal is to be done in the utilisation in India itself of raw materials, such as oil seeds which are utilised in Europe and America for the manufacture of various articles of commerce. In the last two years, the share of seeds in the total value of raw produce exported, has been successively 17·4 per cent. and 22·4 per cent. In 1910-11, it rose to 26·7 per cent. If well organised oil mills are established, there is no doubt that the export of cotton seed would decrease but there is every likelihood of a ready sale for the manufactured article in the form of articles of food, and the edible oil might also form a suitable substitute for ghee of which the supply is now falling short of demand. Then again there is the case of paper. The raw materials for paper-making are available in the country though not in an exactly accessible form. Large supplies of wood-pulp and wood-meal could be made available from the forests of spruce, and silver fir in the mountains, and fibrous grass from the forests at the foot of the Himalayas. Vast quantities of hides and skins are exported which ought to be manufactured into leather and enormous consignments [p. 34] of cotton cloth which might be made within India itself if the staple of her cotton was systematically improved. It is surprising to find that in the classical days of Greece and Rome three products of India attracted the notice of curious enquirers—a tree from which the Indians made cloth (the cotton plant)—a reed from which a sweet juice was expressed (sugar cane) and a plant yielding a dark blue dye known as Indicon (indigo). These are the very industries which are in jeopardy to-day. These plants were not known to the ancient agriculture of Egypt and Mesopotamia. India has found herself surpassed by America and Egypt in growing crops that were peculiarly her own. In Egypt, the cotton plant produces fourfold, in the West Indies, the sugar cane produces nearly threefold the return that they yield in India. And the cultivation of indigo now appears to be doomed by the manufacture of artificial dye in German laboratories. The Indian industrial progress has certainly been great during the last three decades but during the next two decades remarkable development will take place. We have to remember that the foundations of India's industrial prosperity have already been laid, her productive power is capable of infinite expansion, and the time is now at hand to improve [p. 35] Indian Agriculture by strictly practical means so that its products can compete in the markets of the world, to extend her railways and irrigation, to coax British capital and, above all, to foster a strong spirit of co-operation. We must do away with hasty sentiment ; we must go forward with a high heart and sober self-reliance. Let us hasten with caution, for, as some one has said, the most tragic miscarriages in history have been due to the impatient idealist and surely he is not absent from our midst.
