Chapter VI

—The Hague Convention

The Truth About Indian Opium, G. Graham Dixon, 1922 · from page 29 · about 16 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

While the Indian trade in opium to China was being terminated, and China herself was in the throes of temporary suppression of cultivation, the opium question began to assume a more widely international aspect. In 1909, on the initiative of the United States of America, an International Opium Commission met at Shanghai and formulated a series of recommendations for the suppression of opium smoking and regulation of the use of opium and morphia. The United States then advanced a further proposal for an International Conference at the Hague, which met on the 1st December 1911.

It cannot be too emphatically stated that the terms of the Convention finally drawn up presented no new ideas to the Government of India. That Government had for long regulated the consumption of opium in its territories in the most complete manner, and had already agreed to export no opium to countries which prohibited its import, and to control export to countries desiring to restrict import. They had already expanded their measures for the suppression of opium smoking to embrace the recommendations of the Shanghai Commission, and they had given the world a signal instance of disinterested self-sacrifice in the matter of discontinuing the China trade. Independently of the China agreement, they had voluntarily cut down the amount of opium allowed to be imported to non-China markets from the average figure of 16,000 chests to 14,000 chests in 1911 and 13,200 chests in 1912, as it was not clear how much non-China opium was being directed to that country owing to the high prices prevailing there. As regards morphia and cocaine, the use of these drugs in India was subject to exceedingly strict regulations long before 1912.

Bearing in mind the fact that, as the Royal Commission of 1893 had pointed out, any attempt to confine the use of opium in India to strictly medical needs vouched for by medical practitioners would be not only inhuman, but absurd, the regulations of the Government of India effected more than was likely to be required of them. Cocaine and morphia, on the other hand, the use of which for other than medical purposes invariably takes the form of dangerous vice, were becoming a menace to the entire world, but were not included within the scope of the proposals submitted by the United States of America for the consideration of the Conference. It was mainly owing to the pressure exerted by the Government of India that these drugs were included within the terms of the Convention finally concluded, and a rigid and universal application of the articles which apply to them would rid the world of the drug evil.

In view of the amount of misapprehension that continues to accumulate round the provisions of the Hague Convention, it is necessary to lay stress on its actual meaning. As regards raw opium, the contracting Powers undertook to control its production and distribution ; to limit the number of ports from which it might be imported or exported ; to prevent its export to countries which prohibit import, and to control export to countries which restrict import ; to mark opium consignments as such ; and to confine its import and export to authorised persons. As regards prepared opium, that is to say, smoking opium, which India does not, and never has, exported, and the sale of which in India is prohibited, the Powers agreed to aim at the gradual suppression of manufacture, internal trade, and use, with due regard to the varying circumstances of each country concerned, unless regulations on the subject are already in existence ; and to prohibit import and export immediately, or as soon as possible. As regards medicinal opium, morphine, cocaine, and allied drugs, it was agreed to enact regulations confining manufacture, sale and use to medical and legitimate purposes, and to pass measures for controlling manufacturers, traders and exporters.

This summary contains the chief provisions of the Convention, which was no less than a complete vindication of Indian policy. The anti-opium party in Great Britain and in the United States of America has, however, completely failed to understand its purport, and has continually attacked the Government of India for not carrying out its provisions.

A second Opium Conference met in 1913 and decided that, although certain Powers who had been invited to sign the Convention had not then done so, the deposit of ratifications might, nevertheless, take place. A third met in 1914, and recommended early ratification by all the Powers who had not yet ratified, in order that the Convention should come into force as soon as possible. Progress was then suspended by the outbreak of war, but finally, under Article 295 of the Treaty of Peace with Germany, it was provided that ratification of that treaty should imply ratification of the Hague Convention and a promise to enact the necessary legislation within a period of 12 months. Similar provisions were included in the treaty with Austria (Article 247), Hungary (Article 230), Bulgaria (Article 174), and in the unratified Treaty of Sèvres with Turkey (Article 280). It is important to note that Turkey, the chief Middle Eastern source of opium, the fountain from which American supplies are drawn, refused to sign the Convention. Persia was among the signatories, but with a reservation of a number of articles, among these Article 3 (a), which requires the contracting parties “to prevent the export of raw opium to countries which should have prohibited its entry."

The preceding chapters have shown how rigidly the Government of India’s practice conforms to, and in many respects goes beyond, the requirements of the Hague Convention. a summary of which was given above, but it may be as well to set out these requirements in detail, and to show categorically how they are satisfied by the law or regulations in force in India.

The principal articles of the Convention are as follows:—

Chapter I.—Raw Opium.

Definition.—By “raw opium” is understood— The spontaneously coagulated juice obtained from the capsules of the papaver somniferum, which has only been submitted to the necessary manipulations for packing and transport.

Article 1.

The contracting Powers shall enact effective laws or regulations for the control of the production and distribution of raw opium, unless laws or regulations on the subject are already in existence.

The laws and regulations in force in India have been described in Chapters II. and III.

Article 2.

Due regard being had to the differences in their commercial conditions, the contracting Powers shall limit the number of towns, ports, or other localties through which the export or import of raw opium shall be permitted.

Opium is only allowed to be exported from British India through the ports of Calcutta and Bombay.

Article 3.

The contracting Powers shall take measures— (a) To prevent the export of raw opium to countries which shall have prohibited its entry, and (b) To control the export of raw opium to countries which restrict its import, unless regulations on the subject are already in existence.

The export of opium from India has been dealt with in Chapter V. Opium is not allowed to be exported to countries which have prohibited its import, and the Government of India would co-operate with any Government that desired to restrict its imports of Indian opium. To prevent the abuse of Indian opium, the Government of India have, in this respect, gone further than the terms of the Convention demand, by arbitrarily limiting the amount of their opium exports to a figure below the ascertained normal demands of countries which permit its import.

Article 4.

The contracting Powers shall make regulations requiring that every package containing raw opium intended for export shall be marked in such a way as to indicate its contents, provided that the consignment exceeds 5 kilog.

All chests of opium for export are packed in gunny and marked with a number, a red stripe and the words “ Benares Opium.”

Article 5.

The contracting Powers shall not allow the import and export of raw opium except by duly authorised persons.

Seventy-seven per cent. of the exports are sent by the Government of India direct to Governments of importing countries. Compliance with this Article in respect of exports by private merchants is secured by notifications issued under the Opium Act of 1878.

The import of opium by post is absolutely prohibited, and import by other means is only allowed to persons properly authorised by Local Governments.

Chapter II.—Prepared Opium.

Definition.—By “ prepared opium ” is understood— The product of raw opium, obtained by a series of special operations, especially by dissolving, boiling, roasting and fermentation designed to transform it into an extract suitable for consumption. Prepared opium includes dross and all other residues remaining when opium has been smoked.

Article 6.

The contracting Powers shall take measures for the gradual and effective suppression of the manufacture of, internal trade in, and use of prepared opium, with due regard to the varying circumstances of each country concerned, unless regulations on the subject are already in existence.

The measures taken by the Government of India for the gradual and effective suppression of the use of prepared opium are explained in Chapter IV. Except in Burma, manufacture is only permitted to private individuals from raw opium lawfully in their possession, and an individual may not manufacture for his own use more than eleven-fiftieths of an ounce at any one time. Burma is the only part of India where opium is habitually smoked, and there the Government of India have waged a long campaign for its suppression. Within a short period of time there will be complete prohibition of the use of opium by Burmans for other than medicinal purposes. The sale of prepared opium is prohibited throughout India.

Article 7.

The contracting Powers shall prohibit the import and export of prepared opium; those Powers, however, which are not yet ready to prohibit immediately the export of prepared opium shall prohibit it as soon as possible.

Article 8.

The contracting Powers which are not yet ready to prohibit immediately the export of prepared opium—

  • (a) shall restrict the number of towns, ports, or other localities through which prepared opium may be exported;
  • (b) shall prohibit the export of prepared opium to countries which now forbid, or which may hereafter forbid, the import thereof;
  • (c) shall, in the meanwhile, prohibit the consignment of prepared opium to a country which desires to restrict its entry unless the exporter complies with the regulations of the importing country;
  • (d) shall take measures to ensure that every package exported, containing prepared opium, bears a special mark indicating the nature of its contents;
  • (e) shall not permit the export of prepared opium except by special authorised persons.

Both import and export of prepared opium are forbidden under section 4 of the Opium Act of 1878. At no time in her history has prepared opium been exported from India.

Chapter III.—Medicinal Opium, Morphine, Cocaine, &c.

Definitions.—By “medicinal opium” is understood—

Raw opium which has been heated to 60° centrigade and contains not less than 10 per cent. of morphine, whether or not it be powdered or granulated, or mixed with indifferent materials.

By “morphine” is understood— The principal alkaloid of opium, having the chemical formula C17 H19 NO3. By “cocaine” is understood— The principal alkaloid of the leaves of erythroxylon coca. having the formula C17 H21 NO4. By “heroin” is understood— Diacetyl-morphine, having the formula C21 H23 NO5.

Article 9.

The contracting Powers shall enact pharmacy laws or regulations to confine to medical and legitimate purposes the manufacture, sale, and use of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts unless laws or regulations on the subject are already in existence. They shall co-operate with one another to prevent the use of these drugs for any other purpose.

Under the rules in force in India, licensed dealers or chemists may manufacture and sell morphia drugs and cocaine, and may sell to other chemical dealers, or chemists, or to approved medical, veterinary and dental practitioners. In fact, however, no morphia is manufactured in India except at the Government factory at Ghazipur. The chemist can only sell on the prescription of an approved practitioner, and the latter may only possess morphia drugs for use in his practice. The ordinary individual may only possess morphia drugs and cocaine as issued to him on medical prescription. The Government of India, who were largely responsible for the inclusion of these drugs within the terms of the Convention, are prepared to co-operate to the fullest possible extent with other Governments to prevent their use for other than medical purposes.

Article 10.

The contracting Powers shall use their best endeavours to control, or to cause to be controlled, all persons manufacturing, importing, selling, distributing, and exporting morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts, as well as the buildings in which these persons carry on such industry or trade.

With this object, the contracting Parties shall use their best endeavours to adopt, or cause to be adopted, the following measures, uuless regulations on the subject are already in existence :—

(a) to confine the manufacture of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts to those establishments and premises alone which have been licensed for the purpose, or to obtain information respecting the establishments and premises in which these drugs are manufactured and to keep a register of them ; (b) to require that all persons engaged in the manufacture, import, sale, distribution, or export of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts shall be furnished with a licence or permit to engage in these operations, or shall make to the competent authorities an official declaration that they are so engaged;

(c) to require that such persons shall enter in their books the quantities manufactured, imports, sales, and all other distribution, and exports of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts. This rule shall not necessarily apply to medical prescriptions and to sales by duly authorised chemists.

These requirements are all fulfilled by the rules in force in India, with the following exceptions. As manufacture of morphia drugs is only carried on at the Government factory, the form of licence granted to dealers and chemists contains no reference to the premises where manufacture may be carried on. The Government of India therefore suggested to Local Governments early in 1921 that this omission should be remedied. The same position exists in respect of cocaine, but as no cocaine whatever is manufactured in India, it has not been thought necessary up to the present to make any amendments.

Article 11.

The contracting Powers shall take measures to prohibit, as regards their internal trade, the delivery of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts to any unauthorised persons, unless regulations on the subject are already in existence.

Article 12.

Due regard being had to the difference in their conditions, the contracting Powers shall use their best endeavours to restrict to authorised persons the import of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts.

The import by post of alkaloids of opium and cocaine is absolutely prohibited, and these drugs may not circulate through the post within India. Morphine drugs can only be imported by persons licensed to possess such drugs, and cocaine only under the authorisation of a special permit. The imports of cocaine for the year 1919–20 amounted to 172 ounces, to supply the needs of 318,000,000 people.

Article 13.

The contracting Powers shall use their best endeavours to adopt, or cause to be adopted, measures to ensure that morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts shall not be exported from their countries, possessions, colonies and leased territories to the countries, possessions, colonies and leased territories of the other contracting Powers, except when consigned to persons furnished with the licences or permits provided for by the laws or regulations of the importing country.

With this object each Government may communicate from time to time to the Governments of the exporting countries lists of the persons to whom licences or permits for the import of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts have been granted.

The fulfilment of this Article requires the co-operation of importing countries, and the Government of India have expressed their readiness to prohibit the export of morphine and cocaine unless the consignment to be exported is covered by an import certificate granted by the Government of the importing country, to the effect that the drug is required solely for medicinal or scientific purposes. In fact, no cocaine has ever been exported from India, and morphia has only been exported in small quantities in the form of by-products obtained from waste materials at the Government factory.

Article 14.

The contracting Powers shall apply the laws and regulations respecting the manufacture, import, sale, or export of morphine, cocaine, and their respective salts—

(a) to medicinal opium;

(b) to all preparations (medicinal and non-medicinal, including the so-called anti-opium remedies) containing more than 0·2 per cent. of morphine, or more than 0·1 per cent. of cocaine;

(c) to heroin, its salts and preparations containing more than 0·1 per cent. of heroin;

(d) to all new derivatives of morphine, of cocaine, or of their respective salts, and to every other alkaloid of opium, which may be shown by scientific research, generally recognised, to be liable to similar abuse and productive of like ill-effects.

Medicinal opium in the past was subject to the same regulations as raw opium, but on the coming into force of the Convention the Government of India drew the attention of Local Governments to the question of amending the definition of morphine drugs contained in their rules so as to include medicinal opium. In fact, medicinal opium is not manufactured in India. Similarly, steps were taken at the same time to examine the lists of preparations excluded from the operation of the rules on the ground of the negligible amounts of morphine or cocaine entering into their composition, in order to comply strictly with the requirements of this article. Heroin is subject to the rules applicable to morphine drugs.

Articles 15 to 19 of the Convention are concerned with China and the Treaty Powers, and relate principally to smuggling into and out of China, and to the leased territories.

Article 20 suggests that the contracting powers should examine the possibility of making it a penal offence to be in illegal possession of any of the substances dealt with by the Convention, and Article 21 provides that they shall communicate to one another, through the Netherlands Government (for which the Secretariat of the League of Nations has now been generally substituted by arrangement) texts of their laws and regulations and statistical information concerning trade. Both these Articles have been complied with by the Government of India. The remaining Articles relate to details of signature and ratification.

It will be observed that a thorough and honest application of the Articles of this Convention would fully secure the objects which the Convention was designed to attain. As regards the morphia and cocaine habits, a far greater danger than opium smoking has ever been, Chapter III., if rigidly interpreted by all the contracting Powers, provides a complete remedy. India cannot be held responsible for the failure of other Powers to control the traffic in their own territories, and the suggestion that the export of opium from India is the fountain of evil that drowns all attempts to eliminate these pernicious habits is merely a confession that some of the contracting Powers are not fulfilling their obligations. It cannot be denied that India has completely carried out her part of the bargain. Her production of opium is small compared with that of China, and she is only one of several exporters of raw opium. The bulk of her exports go direct to responsible Governments, who are in a position to gauge the requirements of their countries and to prevent re-exports, and the remainder goes to countries whose Governments are all signatories of the Convention. She is prepared to co-operate to the fullest possible extent in assisting those Governments to enforce any restrictions they may desire. If they desire to prohibit the import of opium no opium will be sent. If they desire to restrict imports to medicinal needs the Government of India will control export accordingly. There is no case whatever behind the attack on Indian opium. It expresses merely impatience at the slowness with which international action is rendered effective; but though it is possible to sympathise with this attitude, it appears illogical that the Government of India should be attacked by active spirits in the United States of America, because they see or think they see their country drenched with morphia manufactured from Turkish opium. The curse will not be lifted until Turkey has signed the Hague Convention, ratified it and put it into force; until Persia has adhered to Article 3 (a), which regulates the export of raw opium; until production has been effectively controlled in China, and until Governments have realised that they must shoulder their own burdens and attack the vice at home, as the Government of India have done.