Chapter III

—The Consumption of Opium in India

The Truth About Indian Opium, G. Graham Dixon, 1922 · from page 8 · about 10 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

The attitude of the Government of India towards the general question of opium consumption was well expressed by the following passage in a Despatch addressed to the Secretary of State by Lord Hardinge’s Government in 1911 :—1

“The prohibition of opium-eating in India we regard as impossible, and any attempt at it as fraught with the most serious consequences to the people and the Government. We take our stand unhesitatingly on the conclusion of the Royal Commission which reported in 1895, viz., that the opium habit as a vice scarcely exists in India, that opium is extensively used for non-medical and quasi-medical purposes, in some cases with benefit, and for the most part without injurious consequences ; that the non-medical uses are so interwoven with the medical uses that it would not be practicable to draw a distinction between them in the distribution and sale of the drug: and that it is not necessary that the growth of the poppy and the manufacture and sale of opium in British India should be prohibited except for medical purposes. Whatever may be the case in other countries, centuries of inherited experience have taught the people of India- discretion in the use of the drug, and its misuse is a negligible feature in Indian life. Even if it were possible to suppress the cultivation of opium in India, geographical and political limitations would place it beyond our power to prevent illicit import and consumption on a serious scale”; and again: “The great majority of Indian opium-eaters are not slaves to the habit. They take small doses as required and can and do give up the allowance when the need of it is past. Opium is in virtually universal use throughout India as the commonest and most treasured of the household remedies accessible to the people. It is taken to avert or lessen fatigue, as a specific in bowel complaints, as a prophylactic against malaria (for which its relatively high anarcotine content makes it specially valuable), to lessen the quantity of sugar in diabetes, and generally to allay pain in sufferers of all ages. The vast bulk of the Indian population, it must be remembered, are strangers to the ministrations of qualified doctors or druggists. They are dependent almost entirely on the herbal simples of the country; distance and the patient acceptance of hardships standing in the way of prompt access to skilled medical relief. In these circumstances the use of opium in small quantities is one of the most important aids in the treatment of children’s sufferings. It is also a frequent help to the aged and infirm, and an alleviation in diseases and accidents which are accepted as incurable. To prevent the sale of opium except under regular medical prescription would be a mockery; to many millions it would be sheer inhumanity."

Ever since the logic of events compelled the Government of India over a hundred years ago to recognise that opium-eating could not be entirely suppressed, and that it was a necessary element in the lives of the population, they have steadily pursued a policy of restricting the habit within the narrowest possible limits. The system they have built up is primarily based upon the principle of restricting the consumption to legitimate needs. The abuse of opium is prevented by limiting the amount of opium which an individual may possess at any one time, and by a continuous process of raising the price at which opium is sold to the consumer, only stopping short of the point at which the object in view would be defeated by the attraction of smuggling.

The Opium Act, 1878, prohibits the manufacture, possession, transport, import, export and sale of opium, except as permitted by rules framed under the Act, and provides for the confiscation of any opium in regard to which an offence is committed. Officers of the Excise, Police, Customs, Salt, Opium and Revenue Departments of the proper rank are given powers of search, seizure and detention. There is also a special rule prescribing that in prosecutions for breaches of the Act it shall be presumed, until the contrary is proved, that all opium for which an accused person is unable to account satisfactorily is opium in respect to which he has committed an offence under the Act. The main provisions of the rules made by the different provinces are uniform. The produce of the poppy cultivated on Government account must all be delivered to the Government Opium Department, and such opium can, therefore, only be obtained from Government. The produce of the poppy cultivated by licensed cultivators in the Punjab can only be sold to licensed vendors and cannot be obtained direct by the ordinary consumer. Government, or “excise,” opium, is issued only to licensed wholesale or retail vendors. The wholesale vendor may sell such opium, or opium obtained from a licensed cultivator, only to other licensed vendors or to licensed druggists; the retail vendor and the licensed druggist may sell to individuals. Thus the individual can obtain opium produced in India only from a licensed retail vendor or a licensed druggist. Each stage of the distribution down to the retail vendor is safeguarded by an elaborate system of transport passes, while the conditions governing the licence of a retail vendor are most stringent. He may not sell to any one person at one time more than the quantity of opium which an individual may lawfully possess; he may sell only for cash and only on premises for which he is licensed; he must not allow consumption on such premises, and he must keep correct daily accounts of his sales, which shall be open at all times to inspection by Excise officers. The number of licensed shops in an area is fixed so as not to exceed what is necessary to satisfy the moderate needs of legitimate consumers, and is constantly being reduced as improvements in communications or other changes in local circumstances render centralisation of supply more easy. In the year 1892–93 there were 9,531 opium shops in British India. By 1907–08 these had been reduced to 8,136; and the figure now stands at 6,394. The amount of opium of which an individual may be in possession varies according to circumstances in the different provinces, but in most places is either 360 or 540 grains.

Equally strict control is maintained over the supply of Indian grown opium obtainable from a licensed druggist and the supply of imported opium. A notification under the Sea Customs Act, 1878, No. 720-79, dated the 4th February 1911, prohibits absolutely the import of opium by sea or by land by means of the post, and restricts its import by other means to cases in which it is imported by persons permitted to import it by a Local Government or Administration. The rules as to import made by Local Governments vary considerably in detail, but generally speaking it may be said that only licensed druggists and medical practitioners are permitted to import opium, in quantities of which they may lawfully be in possession by means of a special permit or licence. Exceptions are made in the case of visitors of distinction from countries outside India and foreign horse-dealers, who are allowed to import small quantities for the personal use of themselves and their attendants or for their horses. In the Punjab licensed vendors are also permitted to import on passes opium produced in the Simla Hill States and the Hill States of Chamba, Mandi, Suket and Sirmur. Similarly, in Ajmer-Merwara licensed wholesale and retail vendors may import Malwa opium on pass. The further distribution of opium thus obtained from Indian States is regulated in exactly the same manner as the distribution of excise opium described above. Imports by licensed druggists and supplies obtained by them from licensed vendors can only be sold for medicinal purposes, in quantities not in excess of the amount which the purchaser may legally possess, and correct accounts must be maintained showing the amount of opium in the possession of the licensee from day to day.

The following statistics form a striking commentary on the success of the Government’s policy :—

TBL-006 · FOLIO 15Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Year.Consumption, Excise Chests of 123 3/7 lbs.Excise Revenue (Licence Fees and Duty) converted into sterling at Rs. 15 to the £.
£
1911–128,3341,010,133
1912–138,4961,150,466
1913–148,6101,356,066
1914–158,3111,372,666
1915–168,0661,424,600
1916–178,0991,373,066
1917–188,2621,457,200
1918–197,8931,587,733
1919–207,4801,676,333

During the same period the issue price of excise opium has been raised as shown below :—

TBL-007 · FOLIO 15Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Issue Price Rs. per seer (2·2 lbs.).
Province.1911–12.1921.
Madras2860
Bombay24 and 2745
Bengal29 to 3550
Burma35 to 72 1/270 to 106 1/4
Bihar and Orissa17 to 3555
United Provinces18 to 2055
Punjab13 to 3750
North-West Frontier Province18 to 2650
Delhi13 to 3750
Central Provinces23 1/245
Assam37 and 4050
Coorg3050
Baluchistan1635

and in nearly all provinces the amounts of raw opium which may be in the possession of an individual at any one time have been considerably reduced, as will be seen from the following table :—

TBL-008 · FOLIO 16Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Limit of private Possession of Raw Opium.
1911–12. Tolas (180 grains).1920–21. Tolas (180 grains).
Madras - - -6 a and 1 b3 a and 1 b
Bombay - - -10 c and 4 d3 c and 1 d
Bengal - - -53
Burma - - -33
Bihar and Orissa -53
United Provinces -33
Punjab - - -32
North-West Frontier Province - - -32
Delhi - - -—2
Central Provinces -32
Assam - - -53 and 2
Ajmer-Merwara -53
Coorg - - -31
Baluchistan - -32

The population has risen from 244,267,542 in 1911 to 247,111,563 in 1921, yet it will be noticed that the total consumption over a 10 years’ period shows a slight decrease. In view of the fact that the price has been raised 50 per cent. in the same period, the failure of consumption to decline materially is proof that the Government have succeeded in their policy of confining it to a practical minimum. It may be remarked that the annual per capita consumption is at present 26 grains, slightly less than the figure arrived at by the Royal Commission in 1893, and little more than half the per capita consumption of the United States of America, as estimated by responsible American authority. Indian opium is not exported to the United States. So far as other Eastern countries are concerned, the comparison is more favourable still to India. As regards many of the Far Eastern countries for which statistical information exists, the Indian figure is only a third, a tenth, a thirtieth or a fortieth part of the per capita consumption in one of these countries. These ratios do not pretend to be strictly accurate, but for purposes of comparison they may be taken as approximately correct. It should also be noted that they take into account only the amounts of opium imported into such countries from India. Many of these countries also obtain opium from Persia and Turkey, and if their imports from India were cut off, would have no difficulty in supplying the deficiency from these sources. At the same time, as will be explained in Chapter V., it is the policy of the Government of India to regulate the quantities exported from India to these countries according to the demands made by their Governments for legitimate requirements.

In the face of comparison it is impossible to understand why the finger of criticism should be pointed at opium consumption in India. No estimate can be given as regards China. That country has never ceased to produce opium, though the Indian product was excluded from her shores on account of her alleged determination entirely to extirpate native cultivation, and she has now returned to the position she occupied in the early years of the present century, that of the greatest opium producer and consumer in the world.

Notes

  1. 1. This passage was quoted in the Despatch from the Government of India, dated the 24th March 1921, which was published in the supplement to the Gazette of India, dated the 17th September 1921.
  2. a. Ganjam, Vizagapatam, Godavari.
  3. b. Rest of the Province.
  4. c. Portion of the Thar and Parkar District, east of the Eastern Nara Canal.
  5. d. Rest of the Presidency.