The Legacy of Lord Curzon's Regime

Speeches and Writings of Dadabhai Naoroji, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1918 · from page 271 · about 14 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

[A great meeting of Indians resident in the United Kingdom was held in May 1905 at the Caxton Hall, Westminster, to protest against Lord Curzon's aspersions upon the Indian people and their sacred writings, and against the reactionary legislation that has characterised his administration. Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji presided and made the following speech] :—

We are met together to-day for a very important purpose. A unique event has happened, showing significantly a sign of the times. We have had in India a great uprise, and in the chief towns there have been held monster meetings of Indians, denouncing and protesting against the sayings and doings of the highest authority there, making a protest in clear, unmistakable terms against the policy under which India is ruled. It is, indeed, a unique event. I, at any rate, do not remember anything similar having ever taken place in the history of British India. The Indians have very unanimously, very earnestly, and very emphatically declared that the system of rule they are now under should not continue to be. (Loud cheers.) Let us consider what that means. More than 50 years ago— I will not go back to an earlier period of our history— Mountstuart Elphinstone said :—

It is in vain to endeavour to rule them (the Indians) on principles only suited to a slavish and ignorant population.

And 40 years after—in the last 10 or 12 years— we find, not only a continuance of the same old system, but we find it brought to bear on the people with even more energy and more vigour. (“Shame.”) Some 11 years ago Sir Henry Fowler distinctly and decidedly showed us that India was to be governed on the principles condemned by Elphinstone, for, by his conduct in refusing to give effect to the resolution regarding simultaneous examinations, passed in 1893, he proved that it was intended to continue the same evil system under which the country had been governed so long. Then followed Lord George Hamilton as Secretary of State, and what did he tell the whole world? He said :—

Our rule shall never be popular. Our rule can never be popular.

These were his own words, in one of his early speeches, and he has taken very good care that his prophecy shall be fulfilled. But his doings were not so serious as Lord Curzon’s, although he managed to go quietly on issuing regulation after regulation with the object of depriving Indians as far as possible of an opportunity of making any further progress. But then comes Lord Curzon, and he out-Herods them all. In the first resolution you have enumerated a number of his measures—and not a complete list, for there are some more of them—which he passed with the declared and clear intention of continuing to govern India only on principles suitable to slavish and ignorant populations. Here, then, we have a clear and distinct issue. Our rulers—the officials—tell us we shall have no chance of ever becoming a self-governing country—that they will not give us an opportunity of preparing ourselves for it. Undoubtedly, the character of the whole of the measures passed within the last 10 years points towards such an intention, and to the retraction of the generous mode which was adopted on some occasions in the time of Lord Ripon. Now, the Indian people have, for the first time, risen up and declared that this thing shall not be. (Loud cheers.) Here is a clear issue between the rulers and the people : they are come face to face. The rulers say : “ We shall rule, not only as foreign invaders, with the result of draining the country of its wealth, and killing millions by famine, plague, and starving scores of millions by poverty and destitution.” While the ruled are saying for the first time, “ That shall not be.” I regard the day on which the first Calcutta meeting was held as a red-letter day in the annals of India. (Cheers.) I am thankful that I have lived to see the birthday of the freedom of the Indian people. (Renewed cheers.) The question now naturally arises, what will be the consequences of this open declaration of war—as you may call it—between the rulers and the people ? I will not give you my own opinions or my own views. Anglo-Indian officials, who have told us that persistence in the present evil system of government will lead to certain consequences. Sir John Malcolm, a well-known Governor of Bombay, who had a very distinguished career as a political agent and as an official, after describing the system that obtained in the government of India, prophesied what would be the necessary consequences, and said :—

“ The mcral evil to us does not stand alone. It carries with it its Nemesis : the seeds of the destruction of the Empire itself.”

Again, Sir Thomas Munro said :—

It would be more desirable that we should be expelled from the country altogether, than that the result of our system of government should be such an abasement of a whole people.

Bright spoke on many occasions, always denouncing the existing system of government. He always regarded it as an evil and a disgraceful system, and, after describing the system, he wound up with these words :—

You may rely upon it that if there be a judgment of nations—as I believe there is—as for individuals, our children, in no distant generations, must pay the penalty which we have purchased by neglecting our duty to the populations of India. ......I say a Government like that has some fatal defect which at some distance time, must bring disaster and humiliation to the Government and to the people on whose behalf it rules.

Sir William Hunter, you know, was a very distinguished official, and while he spoke as favourably as he possibly could of the existing system, he did not fail to point out the evil part of it, and he summed up one of his lectures in these words :—

We should have had an Indian Ireland multiplied 50-fold on our hands.

Again, Lord Cromer—(cheers)—said :—

Changes should be taking place in the thoughts, the desires, and the aims of the intelligent and educated men of the country, which no wise and cautious Government can afford to disregard, and to which they must gradually adapt their system of administration, if they do not wish to see it shattered by forces which they have themselves called into being, but which they have failed to guide and control.

Then, Lord Hartington, when Secretary for India, pointed out that the exclusion of Indians from the government of their own country could not be a wise procedure on the part of the British people, as the only consequence could be to

make the Indians desirous of getting rid, in the first instance, of their European rulers.

I have read to you only these four or five opinions of men of position—of high position in the Government, and of official Anglo-Indians—opinions to the effect that if the present evil system is to continue the result will be to bring disaster to the British Empire—that, in fact, the British Empire in India will vanish. That is the position in which we are at the present time, under an evil system of rule. Either that evil system must cease or it must produce disastrous results to the British Empire itself. (Cheers.) The issue before us is clear. Is India to be governed on principles of slavery or is she to be governed so as to fit herself as early as possible to govern herself ?

Anyone who reads the items enumerated in the first resolution will see that Lord Curzon has set himself most vigorously and most earnestly to the task of securing that Indians shall be treated as slaves, and that their country shall remain the property of England, to be exploited and plundered at her will. ("Shame.") That is the task to which Lord Curzon has set himself with a vigour worthy of a better cause. Now, that being the case, there is a duty on the Indians themselves. (Cheers.) They have now broken the ice; they have declared that they will not be governed as slaves; and now let them show a spirit of determination, for, I have very little doubt that, if the British public were once satisfied that India is determined to have self-government, it will be conceded. I may not live to see that blessed day, but I do not despair of that result being achieved. (Cheers.) The issue which has now been raised between the governors and the governed cannot be put aside. The Indian people have as one body and in a most extraordinary way, risen for the first time to declare their determination to get an end put to the present evil system of rule. (Cheers.) Now, I come to the first part of the first resolution—the aspersions and attacks Lord Curzon has thought proper to make—in, I am afraid, a little spirit of peevishness—against the character and religion of the East. I do not need, however, to enter into any refutation of what he has said, for the simple reason that, as far as I am concerned, I performed that task 39 years ago, when Mr. Crawford, the President of the Ethnological Society, wrote a paper full of the very same ignorant and superficial charges. I replied to that, and I find that the Oriental Review of Bombay has reprinted my reply for the present occasion. (Cheers.) There are one or two other aspects of the matter I should like to dwell upon. It is very strange Anglo-Indian officials should throw stones in this matter. Let us have some enquiry about the manner in which the British Government have behaved towards India. Again, I will not give you my own views or ideas. I will give you those of Englishmen themselves—of men of the very highest authority. A Committee was formed in the year 1860, of five members of no less a body than the Council of the Secretary of State, in order to enquire what the Government of the day should do with regard to the Act of 1833, by which all disqualification of race and creed was abolished. This Committee of five men—all high Anglo-Indian officials, who had done much work in India, and whose names were all well-known, gave a very decided opinion that the British Government had exposed itself to the charge of “ having made promises to the ear and broken them to the hope.” This was in 1860. In 1869, the Duke of Argyll clearly acknowledged what had been the conduct of the British Government towards the Indian people in these words :—

I must say that we have not fulfilled our duty or the promises and engagements which we have made.

That does not look very like sincerity and righteousness on the part of the British Government. (Cheers.) Then comes Lord Lytton. Something like 18 years after the Committee had given their opinion—an opinion of which we knew nothing because the report was pigeonholed—Lord Lytton, in a private despatch to the Secretary of State, used these words :—

No sooner was the Act (1833) passed, than the Government began to devise means for practically evading the fulfilment of it .... all so many deliberate and transparent subterfuges for stultifying the Act, and reducing it to a dead letter..... I do not hesitate to say that both the Government of England and of India appear to me, up to the present moment, unable to answer satisfactorily the charge of having taken every means in their power of breaking to the heart the words of promise they had uttered to the ear.

Lastly, no less a personage than Lord Salisbury summed up the whole thing in two words. He declared that the conduct of the British Government to the Indian people was “political hypocrisy.” It does not, then, lie very well in the mouth of Anglo-Indian officials to talk of lapses of Indian character and morality. (Cheers.) They forgot that they themselves had a very large beam in their own eyes when they were pointing to a little mote which they fancied was in the eyes of others. (Renewed cheering.) They ought to remember that they are living in glass houses, and should not throw stones. The next aspect of Lord Curzon’s charges on which I wish to speak is this: He does not seem to realise the responsibility of the position in which he has been placed. He is there representing the Sovereign of the Empire—as Viceroy or Second King—the head of a great people, 300 millions in number, who had possessed civilisation for thousands of years, and at a time when his forefathers were wandering in the forests here. (Cheers and laughter.) He had a special mission. His duty as Viceroy is to attract as much as possible and to attach the good feeling of the Indian people to the rule of the British Sovereign. What does he do? By his acts he deals a deadly blow to British rule, and then, by a peculiarly ignorant and petulant speech, he creates almost a revolution in the whole of the Empire. It is really very strange that he should do so. But I am not surprised at what he has done, and I will give you the reason why. But, first, I will certainly mention one circumstance in his favour and to his credit. As we all know, he made a very firm stand against any brutal treatment of the Indian people by Europeans, and, in so doing, caused dissatisfaction to his own countrymen. In that he really did a service, not only to Indians, but to the whole British Empire. (Cheers.) That one act of his shall not be forgotten by Indians, for it showed his sense of the justice he as a Viceroy should exercise. (Renewed cheering.) But by all the acts and measures mentioned in the first resolution he has tried to Russianise the Indian Administration, and with that narrow statesmanship with which he has all along associated himself, he has forgotten that while Russianising the Indian administration, he is Russianising also the people of India, who live at a distance of 6,000 miles from the centre of the Empire, and who, consequently, are in a very different position from the Russians themselves, who are struggling against their own Government in their own country. (Hear, hear.) It is remarkable that Lord Curzon, when he was first appointed Viceroy, said that India was the pivot of the British Empire, that if the Colonies left the British Empire it would not matter much, whereas the loss of India would be the setting of the sun of the Empire. What does he do? How does he strengthen that pivot? One would think he would put more strength, more satisfaction, and more prosperity under the pivot, but, instead of that, he has managed to deposit under it as much dynamite as he possibly can—dynamite in the form of public dissatisfaction, which, even in his own time, has produced the inevitable explosion. Surely, that is a remarkable way of strengthening the connexion between the British and the Indian peoples. But, as he had said, he was not surprised at the Viceregal career of Lord Curzon: he was only disappointed and grieved that the fears he entertained when Lord Curzon was appointed had been fulfilled. It had been a great disappointment to him, because he had hoped against hope for something better. The announcement of his appointment was made in August, 1898, and in the following September he wrote to a friend in these terms:—

I am hoping against hope about Mr. Curzon, for this reason. Lord Salisbury was at one time not a little wild. When he came to the India Office he seemed to have realised his responsibility, and proved a good Secretary of State, as things go—at least, an honestly outspoken one. Will Curzon show this capacity? That is to be seen.

My disappointment is that he did not show this capacity, and did not realise the responsibility of his position—he did not know how to govern the Indian Empire. I will not take up more of your time. The crisis has come; the people and the rulers are face to face. The people have for 150 years suffered patiently, and, strange to say, their patience has been made a taunt as well as viewed as a credit to them. Often I have been taunted with the fact that 300 millions of Indians allow themselves to be governed like slaves by a handful of people. And then it is stated to their credit that they are a law-abiding, civilised, and long-suffering people. But the spell is broken. (Cheers.) The old days have passed, and the Indian of to-day looks at the whole position in quite a different light. New India is becoming restless, and it is desirable that the Government should at once realise it. I hope that the next Government we have will reconsider the whole position, and will see and understand the changes that have taken place in the condition, knowledge, and intelligence of the Indian people. (Cheers.) I hope that steps will be taken more in conformity with the changes that have taken place, and that things will not be allowed to go on in their present evil way, to the detriment of the Empire itself as well as the suffering of the people. (Loud cheers.)