India Under British Rule

Speeches and Writings of Dadabhai Naoroji, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1918 · from page 251 · about 5 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

[The following speech was delivered by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji at the annual dinner of the London Indian Society, 22nd March 1902.]

I can hardly express in adequate terms what I feel at the generous manner in which my health has been proposed and the cordial reception which you have given to the toast. I feel it very deeply. (Hear, hear.) Talking of my views towards British rule I wish to say that they have been largely misunderstood. The pith of the whole thing is that not only have the British people derived great advantage from India but that the profit would have been more than ten times as great had that rule been conducted on the lines of policy laid down by Act of Parliament. It is a pity as much for England herself as for us that that policy has not been carried out, and that the matter has been allowed to drift in the old selfish way in which the Government was inaugurated in earlier times. When I complain, I am told sometimes very forcibly, that the connexion of Britain with India is beneficial to India herself, I admit that it might be, and it is because of that that I urged over and over again that the connexion should be put upon a righteous basis—a basis of justice and liberality. It has been proved by the fact of the coming into existence of a body like the Indian National Congress that the British connexion might be made more beneficial, and I believe that if you fail to direct the force of that movement into proper channels the result will be most disastrous, for it must ultimately come into collision with British rule. It does not require any great depth of consideration to se e that. It has been repeatedly admitted by every statesman of consequence that the welfare of India depends upon the contentment of the people, and that that contentment cannot exist unless the people feel that British rule is doing them good, is raising their political status, and is making them prosperous. (Hear, hear.) The fact is quite the reverse, and it is no use denying that the system which has existed in India is one which has been most foolish; it has neither increased Indian prosperity nor raised her political status. If only you could make her truly imperial and unitedly in favour of British rule I defy a dozen Russias to touch India or to do the slightest harm to the Empire. (Cheers.) Mr. Caine has expressed regret that Indian troops were not sent to South Africa. It is quite true you cannot expect to maintain a great Empire unless you use all its imperial resources, and among those imperial resources there are none so important and so valuable as the resources of India in physical strength and in military genius and capability. There you will find that, by a simple stamp of the foot on the ground, you can summon millions of men ready to fight for the British Empire. We only want to be treated as part and parcel of the Empire, and we ask you not to maintain the relationship of master over helot. We want you to base your policy on the lines already laid down by Act of Parliament, proclaimed by the late Queen, and acknowledged by the present Emperor, as the best and truest policy towards India for the sake of both countries. Unless that is done the future is not very hopeful. As far as I am concerned I have ever expressed my faith in the British conscience. As far back as 1853, when the first political movement was started in India, and when associations were formed in Bombay, Calcutta, and Madras in order to petition Patliament with regard to improvements necessary to be made in the Company's Charter, I expressed my sincere faith in the British people, and said I was convinced that if they would only get true information and make themselves acquainted with the realities of India they would fulfil their duty towards her. That faith, after all the vicissitudes and disappointments which have marked the last half century, I still hold. If we only do our best to make the British people understand what their duty is, I venture to prophesy that England will have an Empire the like of which has never before existed, an Empre of which any nation may well be proud. (Cheers.) After all, India is the British Empire. The colonies are simply so many sons who have set up establishments of their own, but who retain their affection for the mother country, but India is an Empire which, if properly cultivated, will have a wondrous success. All we want is that there shall be a true loyal, and real attachment between the people of the two ccuntries. I am glad to see you young men around me. I and the older men who have worked in this movement are passing away. We began the work, we had to grope in darkness, but we leave you a great legacy, we leave you the advantages of the labours of the hundreds of us during the last 50 years, and if you only study the problem thoroughly, if you spread over the United Kingdom the true merits and defects of British rule you will be doing a grat work both for your own country and for England. I rejoice at having had something to do in that direction. I have stuck to my own view that it would be good for India if British rule continues. But it must not be the British rule which has obtained in the past ; it must be a rule under which you treat us as brothers, and not as helots. (Loud cheers.)