In reprinting the following documents as an extra number of the Journal the Council of the Association desire to point out that, while the author’s (Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji) statements and conclusions must be taken on his personal responsibility, the facts set forth and the arguments advanced are entitled to most careful consideration alike by statisticians, economists, and politicians. Readers will readily perceive the nature of each paper or table, and its place in the whole review here presented of the great question of what is really the Condition of the People of India. Substantially, the series consists of—(a) Mr. Dadabhai’s elaborate analysis and summary of statistics of production in use of the large province of India—the Punjab; (b) three memoranda, the first of which, being in full rejoinder to a reply on the Punjab paper, issued with the authority of the India Office, relates to the economic and industrial condition of India as a whole. Of the others, No. 2 treats of the “Moral Poverty of India,” deepened, as the author seeks to show, by the people of the country being so largely excluded from the higher walks of administrative work and responsibility. This essay is well worthy of close examination by any thoughtful politician into whose hands these papers may fall. The No. 3 Memorandum offers searching criticism on certain of the conclusions recorded by the Famine Commissioners of 1880, more especially those relating to the actual incidence of taxation, and the very grave difficulties caused by the inevitable withdrawal of India’s resources consequent on its being a dependency. Mr. Dadabhai’s arguments under this head are put forward with all the earnestness of a sincere patriot, but in such form that both skilled economists and practical politicians are bound to take account of them. The Council believe that it will be for the true advantage, both of England and India—of the ruling and dependent country—that these essays, by a Native of India, should be widely disseminated and dispassionately examined.
The Council would wish to take this opportunity of expressing their high estimation of the ability, zeal, and labour which Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji has devoted to the composition of his valuable and important treatise.
Edward B. Eastwick,
December 16th, 1882.
Chairman of Council.
32, Great St. Helens, London. 24th May, 1880.
To the Right Hon. the Marquis of Hartington, the Secretary of State for India, India Office.
My Lord,—I beg to submit a series of tables, working out in detail the total production of the Punjab for the year 1876-7.
My objects in troubling your Lordship are as follows :—
In 1876 I read some papers on the “ Poverty of India ” before the Bombay Branch of the East India Association. These papers are published in the Journals of the Association, and I send herewith a copy (Vol. IX, pages 236 and 352 ; Vol. X, pages 83 and 133). At pages 237-9 I have explained how the mode of taking the averages adopted in the various Administration Reports of India was quite wrong. When preparing my papers on the “ Poverty of India ” I had not sufficient time to work out all the averages for all the provinces in detail. I have now worked out in detail the averages of all the production tables of the Administration Report of the Punjab for 1876-7. I request now that the different Governments in India may be directed to supply their tables of production as fully as are prescribed by the Statistical Committee of Calcutta, that the averages may be correctly taken, as I have done in the enclosed tables, and that, in addition to the tables prescribed, may also be given a summary of the total agricultural production, like the one given at page 166 of my tables, a summary of the whole production (agricultural, manufactures, and mines), like that at page 168, and a table of the absolute necessaries of life for an agricultural labourer, like that at pages 171, 172.
It is only when such complete information is furnished by the Indian authorities that any true conception can be formed of the actual material condition of India from year to year, and our British rulers can only then clearly see, and grapple with effectually, the important problem of the material condition of India, and the best means of improving it.
I have also to solicit your Lordship to submit my tables to the Statistical Department of the India Office, and to direct it to oblige me by pointing out any mistakes of facts or figures there may be in them.
In troubling your Lordship with these requests, I have no other object than to help, as far as my humble opportunities go, to arrive at the real truth of the actual material condition of India ; for it is only natural that without the knowledge of the whole truth on this most important subject, all efforts, however well and benevolently intentioned, must generally result in disappointment and failures.
I also earnestly desire and solicit that your Lordship will kindly take into your consideration the representations I have urged in my papers on the “ Poverty of India.”
I remain, my Lord, Your Lordship’s most obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
Administration Report of Punjab, 1876-7.
Page 77.—“ Upon the whole, the character of the weather during the year 1876-7 was favourable for agriculture.”
I have taken one seer, equal to 2·057 lbs., from the compilation entitled “ Prices of Food Grains throughout India, 1861-76,” compiled in the Financial Department of the Government of India, Calcutta, 1878.
The prices I have adopted are the average of the prices given in the report for 1st January, 1876, 1st June, 1876, and 1st January, 1877 ; the last being the latest price that is given in the Report.
For all such particulars or figures as are not given in the Report, I have consulted a Punjab farmer, and adopted such information as he has given me.
There are some figures in the Report which are evidently mistakes, and are much in excess of probability ; but I have not altered them ; though by retaining them as given in the Report, the quantity and value of some of the articles become much higher than what they must most probably really be.
Excepting such mistakes, the farmer thinks the tables of the Report give a fair representation of the produce of Punjab, the averages being worked out in the right way they should be, and not as they are given in the Report, worked on a wrong principle.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 27,900 | 920 | 25,668,000 | 13·71 | 18,72,210 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 1,591 | 720 | 1,145,520 | 19·2 | 59,662 |
| 3 Karnál | 53,113 | 1,152 | 61,186,176 | 21·94 | 27,88,795 |
| 4 Hissar | 10,506 | 745 | 7,826,970 | 23·31 | 3,35,777 |
| 5 Rohtak | 5,326 | 670 | 3,568,420 | 25·37 | 1,40,655 |
| 6 Sirsa | 8,285 | 869 | 7,199,665 | 21·94 | 3,28,152 |
| 7 Umballa | 117,941 | 880 | 103,788,080 | 19·88 | 52,20,728 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 3,963 | 1,096 | 4,343,448 | 16·45 | 2,64,039 |
| 9 Simla | 1,875 | 620 | 1,162,500 | 18·51 | 62,804 |
| 10 Jullundar | 9,192 | 1,085 | 9,973,320 | 16·45 | 6,06,281 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 28,835 | 752 | 21,683,920 | 17·82 | 12,16,830 |
| 12 Kángra | 147,766 | 415 | 61,322,890 | 29·48 | 20,80,152 |
| 13 Amritsar | 20,128 | 974 | 19,604,672 | 18·51 | 10,59,139 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 81,583 | 755 | 61,595,165 | 15·77 | 39,05,844 |
| 15 Siálkot | 74,100 | 1,029 | 76,248,900 | 30·85 | 24,71,601 |
| 16 Lahore | 22,415 | 861 | 19,299,315 | 30·17 | 6,39,685 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 9,925 | 759 | 7,533,075 | 19·88 | 3,78,927 |
| 18 Firozepore | 6,543 | 795 | 5,201,685 | 20·91 | 2,48,765 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 1,093 | 970 | 1,060,210 | 12·34 | 85,916 |
| 20 Jhelum | 233 | 943 | 219,719 | 11·65 | 18,860 |
| 21 Gujrát | 6,969 | 586 | 4,083,834 | 17·82 | 2,29,171 |
| 22 Shahpur | 990 | 790 | 782,100 | 22·63 | 34,560 |
| 23 Mooltan | 9,800 | 750 | 7,350,000 | 13·71 | 5,36,105 |
| 24 Jhang | 127 | 281 | 35,687 | 13·71 | 2,603 |
| 25 Montgomery | 7,870 | 1,145 | 9,011,150 | 13·71 | 6,57,268 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 10,178 | 852 | 8,671,656 | 16·45 | 5,27,152 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 1,366 | 196 | 267,736 | 12·85 | 20,835 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 14,001 | 513 | 7,182,513 | 18· | 3,99,028 |
| 29 Bannu | 125 | 880 | 110,000 | 12·85 | 8,560 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 10,325 | 894 | 9,230,550 | 13·45 | 6,86,286 |
| 31 Hazára | 12,274 | 1,152 | 14,139,648 | 28·8 | 4,90,960 |
| 32 Kohát | 2,361 | 1,507 | 3,558,027 | 14·83 | 2,39,920 |
| Total | 708,699 | Average 796 | 564,054,551 | Average 20·42 | 2,76,17,270 |
I take produce of rice as 25-fold, and deduct 4 per cent. for seed. The quantity will then become 541,492,369 lbs., and value Rs. 2,65,12,580. Again, the price of rice given in the Report is for “first sort” only. The medium or second sort forms the bulk, and there is a lower sort still. The second sort is generally about 75 per cent. of the first sort. I take upon the whole 85 per cent. The value, then, for the whole bulk will be Rs. 2,25,35,693.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 159,900 | 913 | 145,988,700 | 53.82 | 27,12,536 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 132,425 | 856 | 113,355,800 | 49.37 | 22,96,046 |
| 3 Karnál | 113,110 | 1,319 | 149,192,090 | 48.68 | 30,64,751 |
| 4 Hissar | 39,048 | 548 | 21,398,304 | 48.34 | 4,42,662 |
| 5 Rohtak | 99,428 | 732 | 72,781,296 | 49.37 | 14,74,200 |
| 6 Sirsa | 56,310 | 255 | 14,359,050 | 49.02 | 2,92,922 |
| 7 Umballa | 296,322 | 1,000 | 296,322,000 | 51.25 | 57,81,892 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 137,012 | 1,013 | 138,793,156 | 51.08 | 27,17,172 |
| 9 Simla | 3,610 | 550 | 1,985,500 | 38.39 | 51,719 |
| 10 Jullundar | 269,010 | 1,339 | 360,204,390 | 49.37 | 72,96,017 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 349,863 | 692 | 242,105,196 | 48.68 | 49,73,401 |
| 12 Kángra | 144,170 | 460 | 66,318,200 | 37.02 | 17,91,415 |
| 13 Amritsar | 263,265 | 1,038 | 273,269,070 | 52.11 | 52,44,081 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 325,529 | 856 | 278,652,824 | 50.74 | 54,91,778 |
| 15 Siálkot | 197,000 | 910 | 179,270,000 | 49.02 | 36,57,078 |
| 16 Lahore | 368,000 | 557 | 204,976,000 | 50.39 | 40,67,791 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 203,745 | 793 | 161,569,785 | 50.74 | 31,84,268 |
| 18 Firozepore | 241,180 | 736 | 177,508,480 | 58.97 | 30,10,148 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 424,135 | 776 | 329,128,760 | 68.9 | 47,76,905 |
| 20 Jhelum | 480,273 | 933 | 448,094,709 | 64.45 | 69,52,594 |
| 21 Gujrát | 268,316 | 736 | 197,360,576 | 57.42 | 34,37,139 |
| 22 Shahpur | 199,325 | 790 | 157,466,750 | 58.62 | 26,86,229 |
| 23 Mooltan | 186,040 | 655 | 121,856,200 | 41.83 | 29,13,129 |
| 24 Jhang | 161,169 | 674 | 108,627,906 | 49.37 | 22,00,281 |
| 25 Montgomery | 263,494 | 1,252 | 329,894,488 | 53.48 | 61,68,558 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 201,363 | 1,248 | 251,301,024 | 43.88 | 57,27,006 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 176,055 | 777 | 136,794,735 | 69.42 | 19,70,537 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 156,594 | 765 | 119,794,410 | 44.57 | 26,87,781 |
| 29 Bannu | 262,728 | 523 | 137,406,744 | 88.28 | 15,56,487 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 232,975 | 600 | 139,785,000 | 57.47 | 24,32,312 |
| 31 Hazára | 100,570 | 993 | 99,866,010 | 58.97 | 16,93,505 |
| 32 Kohát | 97,533 | 816 | 79,586,928 | 70.89 | 11,22,682 |
| Total | 6,609,497 | Average 840.4 | 5,555,014,081 | Average 53.48 | 10,38,75,022 |
I take produce of wheat 25-fold, and deduct 4 per cent. for seed. The quantity will be 5,332,813,517 lbs., and value will be Rs. 9,97,20,021. The price given in the Report is for first sort only. The second sort forms the bulk, and is generally about 12 per cent. lower in price. I take only 8 per cent. lower for the whole bulk.
The value of the whole will then be Rs. 9,17,42,419.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 13,900 | 1,500 | 20,850,000 | 72· | 2,89,583 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 1,344 | „ | 2,016,000 | 75·42 | 26,730 |
| 3 Karnál | 6,215 | „ | 9,322,500 | 67·19 | 1,38,748 |
| 4 Hissar | 89 | „ | 133,500 | 51·42 | 2,596 |
| 5 Rohtak | 73 | „ | 2109,500 | .. | .. |
| 6 Sirsa | 466 | „ | 2699,000 | .. | .. |
| 7 Umballa | 100,736 | „ | 151,104,000 | 62·4 | 24,21,538 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 62,802 | „ | 94,203,000 | 66·51 | 14,16,373 |
| 9 Simla | 1,282 | „ | 1,923,000 | 45·94 | 41,859 |
| 110 Jullundar | 86,392 | 11,544 | 133,389,248 | 63·08 | 21,14,604 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 105,651 | 1,500 | 158,476,500 | 55·54 | 28,53,375 |
| 12 Kángra | 65,093 | „ | 97,639,500 | 39·77 | 24,55,104 |
| 113 Amritsar | 44,426 | 11,412 | 62,729,512 | 65·14 | 9,62,995 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 49,977 | 1,500 | 74,965,500 | 53·48 | 14,01,748 |
| 15 Siálkot | 33,000 | „ | 49,500,000 | 58·28 | 8,49,450 |
| 16 Lahore | 34,150 | „ | 51,225,000 | 65·82 | 7,78,258 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 16,535 | „ | 24,802,500 | 61·02 | 4,06,465 |
| 18 Firozepore | 42,428 | „ | 63,642,000 | 81·59 | 7,80,022 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 66,392 | „ | 99,588,000 | 94·62 | 10,52,504 |
| 20 Jhelum | 2,423 | „ | 3,634,500 | 64·45 | 56,392 |
| 21 Gujrát | 16,507 | „ | 24,760,500 | 68·57 | 3,61,098 |
| 22 Shahpur | 884 | „ | 1,326,000 | 63·08 | 21,020 |
| 23 Mooltan | 142 | „ | 213,000 | 50·05 | 4,255 |
| 24 Jhang | 2,317 | „ | 3,475,500 | 65·82 | 52,803 |
| 25 Montgomery. | 2,512 | „ | 3,768,000 | 49·37 | 76,321 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | .. | .. | .. | .. | .. |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 17 | 1,500 | 25,500 | 90·85 | 280 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 30 | „ | 245,000 | .. | .. |
| 29 Bannu | 37,069 | „ | 55,603,500 | 124·27 | 4,47,441 |
| 30 Pesháwar. | 80,542 | „ | 120,813,000 | 84·42 | 14,31,094 |
| 31 Hazára | 198,025 | „ | 297,037,500 | 95·09 | 31,23,751 |
| 32 Kohát | 12,920 | „ | 19,380,000 | 97·92 | 1,97,916 |
| 1130,818 953,521 | Average 1,499·17 1,500· | 196,118,760 1,430,281,500 | Average 68·4 2add for 853,500 lbs. | 2,37,64,323 12,478 | |
| Total | 1,084,339 | 1,626,400,260 | 2,37,76,801 |
For Makai I take 50-fold, and therefore deduct 2 per cent. for seed. The total quantity will then be 1,593,872,255 lbs., and value will be Rs. 2,33,01,265.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 61,290 | 503 | 30,828,870 | 73.02 | 4,22,197 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 197,145 | „ | 99,163,935 | 69.94 | 14,17,842 |
| 3 Karnál | 29,856 | „ | 15,017,568 | 72.68 | 2,06,625 |
| 4 Hissar | 30,312 | „ | 15,246,936 | 83.65 | 1,82,270 |
| 5 Rohtak | 42,353 | „ | 21,303,559 | 75.42 | 2,82,465 |
| 6 Sirsa | 101,408 | „ | 51,008,224 | 108.33 | 4,70,859 |
| 7 Umballa | 35,787 | „ | 18,000,861 | 72. | 2,50,011 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 106,202 | „ | 53,419,606 | 86.39 | 6,18,354 |
| 9 Simla | 3,134 | „ | 1,576,402 | 50.74 | 31,068 |
| 10 Jullundar | 25,211 | 1856 | 21,580,616 | 75.42 | 2,86,139 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 21,602 | 503 | 10,865,806 | 76.79 | 1,41,500 |
| 12 Kángra | 56,831 | 1250 | 14,207,750 | 52.11 | 2,72,649 |
| 13 Amritsar | 36,509 | 503 | 18,364,027 | 84.34 | 2,17,738 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 123,635 | „ | 62,188,405 | 63.08 | 9,85,865 |
| 15 Siálkot | 122,000 | „ | 61,366,000 | 83.65 | 7,33,604 |
| 16 Lahore | 57,181 | „ | 28,762,043 | 82.96 | 3,46,697 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 64,082 | „ | 32,233,246 | 88.45 | 3,64,423 |
| 18 Firozepore. | 195,298 | „ | 98,234,894 | 100.1 | 9,81,367 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 43,383 | „ | 21,821,649 | 77.48 | 2,81,642 |
| 20 Jhelum | 17,879 | „ | 8,993,137 | 76.11 | 1,18,159 |
| 21 Gujrát | 67,094 | „ | 33,748,282 | 82.28 | 4,10,163 |
| 22 Shahpur | 15,657 | „ | 7,875,471 | 78.16 | 1,00,760 |
| 23 Mooltan | 11,832 | 1800 | 9,465,600 | 59.65 | 1,58,685 |
| 24 Jhang | 6,083 | 503 | 3,059,749 | 74.74 | 40,938 |
| 25 Montgomery | 21,802 | „ | 10,966,406 | 69.94 | 1,56,797 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 10,987 | 1679 | 7,460,173 | 60.34 | 1,23,635 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 19,203 | 503 | 9,659,109 | 94.28 | 1,02,451 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 5,925 | „ | 2,980,275 | 60.42 | 49,325 |
| 29 Bannu | 26,282 | „ | 13,219,846 | 133.7 | 98,876 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 238,161 | „ | 119,794,983 | 104.30 | 11,48,561 |
| 31 Hazára | 70,079 | „ | 35,249,737 | 102.98 | 3,42,296 |
| 32 Kohát | 10,014 | „ | 5,037,042 | 109.28 | 46,092 |
| Total | 1,874,217 | 942,700,207 | Average 82.76 | 1,13,90,053 |
For barley I take 16-fold. Deducting for seed 1/16, the total quantity will be 883,781,444 lbs., and the value will be Rs. 1,06,78,175.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1, | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 57,500 | 645 | 37,087,500 | 72· | 5,15,104 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 101,184 | 1620 | 62,734,080 | 71·65 | 8,75,562 |
| 3 Karnál | 119,935 | 1680 | 81,555,800 | 72·34 | 11,27,395 |
| 4 Hissar | 76,534 | 645 | 49,364,430 | 80·22 | 6,15,363 |
| 5 Rohtak | 119,240 | 1790 | 94,199,600 | 78·16 | 12,05,214 |
| 6 Sirsa | 37,762 | 645 | 24,356,490 | 102·85 | 2,36,815 |
| 7 Umballa | 175,094 | „ | 112,935,630 | 76·11 | 14,83,847 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 171,984 | „ | 110,929,680 | 77·82 | 14,25,464 |
| 9 Simla | 5 | „ | 3,225 | 51·08 | 63 |
| 10 Jullundar | 65,158 | 11,233 | 80,339,814 | 73·37 | 10,94,995 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 46,324 | 645 | 29,878,980 | 61·02 | 4,89,658 |
| 12 Kángra | 370,802 | 1290 | 107,532,580 | 51·08 | 21,05,179 |
| 13 Amritsar | 103,350 | 11,394 | 144,069,900 | 84· | 17,15,117 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 31,347 | 645 | 20,218,815 | 73·37 | 2,75,573 |
| 15 Siálkot | 21,500 | „ | 13,867,500 | 74·05 | 1,87,272 |
| 16 Lahore | 171,216 | „ | 110,434,320 | 89·82 | 12,29,507 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 31,682 | „ | 20,434,890 | 83·65 | 2,44,290 |
| 18 Firozepore | 255,898 | „ | 165,054,210 | 96·68 | 17,07,221 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 38,263 | „ | 24,679,635 | 76·79 | 3,21,391 |
| 20 Jhelum | 34,115 | „ | 22,004,175 | 65·14 | 3,37,798 |
| 21 Gujrát | 34,728 | „ | 22,399,560 | 68· | 3,08,194 |
| 22 Shahpur | 23,817 | „ | 15,361,965 | 74·05 | 2,07,453 |
| 23 Mooltan | 8,404 | „ | 5,420,580 | 57·25 | 94,682 |
| 24 Jhang | 12,026 | „ | 7,756,770 | 73·37 | 1,05,721 |
| 25 Montgomery | 81,616 | „ | 52,642,320 | 77·48 | 6,79,431 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 12,679 | 11,942 | 24,622,618 | 55·54 | 4,43,331 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 11,922 | 645 | 7,689,690 | 95·13 | 80,833 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 1,961 | „ | 1,264,845 | 47·74 | 26,494 |
| 29 Bannu | 53,037 | 1286 | 15,168,582 | 106·28 | 1,42,722 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 947 | 645 | 610,815 | 44·05 | 13,866 |
| 31 Hazára | 222 | „ | 143,190 | 61·71 | 2,320 |
| 32 Kohát | 1,984 | „ | 1,279,680 | 70·36 | 18,187 |
| Total | 2,272,236 | Average 645 | 1,466,041,869 | Average 75·89 | 1,93,16,062 |
I take gram 30-fold. Deducting for seed accordingly, the total quantity will be 1,417,173,807 lbs., and the value will be Rs. 1,86,72,194.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 114,677 | 522 | 59,816,394 | 66·85 | 8,95,458 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 404,175 | 447 | 180,666,225 | 66· | 27,37,367 |
| 3 Karnál | 196,787 | 521 | 102,526,027 | 64·79 | 15,82,436 |
| 4 Hissar | 1,256,158 | 393 | 493,670,094 | 76·79 | 64,28,833 |
| 5 Rohtak | 441,437 | 412 | 181,872,044 | 64·79 | 28,07,100 |
| 6 Sirsa | 680,225 | 118 | 80,266,550 | 104·39 | 7,68,910 |
| 7 Umballa | 195,893 | 680 | 133,207,240 | 66·16 | 20,13,410 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 214,111 | 1,355 | 290,120,405 | 68·91 | 42,10,135 |
| 9 Simla | 3,406 | 520 | 1,771,120 | 40·11 | 44,156 |
| 10 Jullundar | 165,767 | 395 | 65,477,965 | 62·05 | 10,55,245 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 111,933 | 685 | 76,674,105 | 58·41 | 13,12,687 |
| 12 Kángra | 30,366 | 362 | 210,992,492 | .. | .. |
| 13 Amritsar | 71,937 | 590 | 42,442,830 | 67·88 | 6,25,262 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 154,306 | 648 | 99,990,288 | 48· | 20,83,131 |
| 15 Siálkot | 94,070 | 745 | 70,082,150 | 65·14 | 10,75,869 |
| 16 Lahore | 141,579 | 374 | 52,950,546 | 69·94 | 7,57,085 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 123,515 | 449 | 55,458,235 | 64·45 | 8,60,484 |
| 18 Firozepore | 477,728 | 608 | 290,458,624 | 82·11 | 35,37,433 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 287,941 | 554 | 159,519,314 | 92·91 | 17,16,923 |
| 20 Jhelum | 209,379 | 722 | 151,171,638 | 70·28 | 21,50,990 |
| 21 Gujrát | 239,640 | 632 | 151,452,480 | 80·91 | 18,71,863 |
| 22 Shahpur | 68,819 | 1,100 | 75,700,900 | 66·16 | 11,44,209 |
| 23 Moolton | 98,847 | 468 | 46,260,396 | 51·08 | 9,05,646 |
| 24 Jhang | 55,474 | 218 | 12,093,332 | 60·17 | 2,00,986 |
| 25 Montgomery | 63,883 | 686 | 43,823,738 | 55·54 | 7,89,048 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 76,969 | 693 | 53,339,517 | 49·37 | 10,80,403 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 43,618 | 485 | 21,154,730 | 89·13 | 2,37,346 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 178,113 | 640 | 113,992,320 | 54·17 | 21,04,344 |
| 29 Bannu | 105,488 | 536 | 56,541,568 | 111·42 | 5,07,463 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 107,183 | 550 | 58,950,650 | 59·48 | 9,91,100 |
| 31 Hazára | 52,074 | 960 | 49,991,040 | 74·05 | 6,75,098 |
| 32 Kohát | 69,465 | 770 | 53,488,050 | 112·28 | 4,76,380 |
| Total | 6,534,963 | Average 510·5 | 3,335,968,007 | Average 69·78 | 4,76,46,800 |
| Add | 1,57,530 | ||||
| 4,78,04,330 |
It should be noted that the prices of jowár, bájrá, másh, múng, and arhar are nearly the same generally, but of the remaining five kinds of grain—viz., moth, kangni, chiná, matter, masúr—the prices are generally nearly 25 per cent. lower. The prices I have used in the table are as given in the Report for jowár and bájrá only, though the acreage of the lower priced grains is 1,409,893 acres out of 6,534,963 acres, or above 20 per cent. If the allowance for the lower price of the five kinds of grain mentioned above were made, the value will evidently be much lower than I have given above. It requires also be noted that out of the inferior grains a portion goes for the feed of animals in about the following proportions:—
| Grain. | Proportion for Human Use. | Proportion for Animal Use. |
|---|---|---|
| Bájrá. | ½ | ½ |
| Jowár | ⅓ | ⅔ |
| Moth. | ¼ | ¾ |
| Másh. | ⅔ | ⅓ |
| Also Jow | ¼ | ¾ |
| Gram | ½ | ½ |
So that out of the total acreage of grains of all the above kinds, viz.:—
| Gram | 2,272,236 × ½ | = 6,000,512 acres, are for animal use, or nearly three-fifths of the total acres, 9,903,457. |
| Bájrá | 2,339,796 × ½ | |
| Jowár | 2,221,535 × ⅔ | |
| Jow. | 1,874,217 × ¾ | |
| Moth | 982,208 × ¾ | |
| Másh | 213,465 × ⅛ | |
| 9,903,457 |
And out of the whole acreage of all kinds of grain—i.e., 19,083,971 acres—about 30 per cent. is used for producing food for animals.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. |
|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | ||
| 7 Umballa | 3,620 | 18 | 65,160 |
| 8 Ludhiána. | 69 | .. | .. |
| 9 Simla | 244 | 3 | 732 |
| 10 Jullundar. | 578 | .. | .. |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 163 | .. | .. |
| 12 Kángra | 1,539 | 3 | 4,617 |
| 13 Amritsar | 877 | 19 | 16,663 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 278 | .. | .. |
| 15 Siálkot | 140 | .. | .. |
| 16 Lahore | 770 | 5 | 3,850 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 147 | 10 | 1,470 |
| 18 Firozepore | 263 | .. | .. |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 53 | 15 | 795 |
| 20 Jhelum | 81 | 14 | 1,134 |
| 21 Gujrát | 336 | 15 | 5,040 |
| 22 Shahpur | 2,182 | 10 | 21,820 |
| 23 Mooltan | 25 | 6 | 150 |
| 24 Jhang | 27 | 10 | 270 |
| 25 Montgomery. | 94 | 9 | 846 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 40 | 11 | 440 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 23 | 8 | 184 |
| 28 D. G. Khan. | 535 | 20 | 10,700 |
| 29 Bannu | 15 | .. | .. |
| 30 Pesháwar | 67 | 3 | 201 |
| 31 Hazára | 182 | 9 | 1,638 |
| Total | 12,348 | Average 12·51 | 135,710 for 10,842 acres. add 18,840 „ 1,506 „ 154,550 „ 12,348 „ for which no crop per acre is given, at 12·51 average. |
Government pays Rs. 5 per seer, or Rs. 2½ per lb. to the producer. The total value will therefore be Rs. 3,86,375.
The additional value at which Government sells opium is a part of the national income, as it is chiefly paid by a foreign country as profit of trade, and therefore (as I have done in my “Poverty of India ”) the net opium revenue will have to be added to the total production of the country. The particular provinces only from which this revenue is derived —viz., Bengal, Bombay, and other opium-producing places— cannot be credited with this income. It belongs to the whole nation, as every place is not quite free to cultivate opium.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 7,472 | 888 | 6,635,136 | 5·14 | 12,90,882 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 2,424 | 600 | 1,454,400 | 14·4 | 1,01,000 |
| 3 Karnál. | 917 | 525 | 481,425 | 16·45 | 29,266 |
| 4 Hissar | 2,812 | 582 | 1,636,584 | 16·45 | 99,488 |
| 5 Rohtak | 1,851 | 514 | 951,414 | 16·45 | 57,836 |
| 6 Sirsa | 381 | 850 | 323,850 | 14·4 | 23,489 |
| 7 Umballa | 4,661 | 560 | 2,610,160 | 12·34 | 2,11,520 |
| 8 Ludhiána. | 1,550 | 925 | 1,433,750 | 27·25 | 52,614 |
| 19 Simla | 5 | 846 | 4,230 | 9·6 | 440 |
| 10 Jullundar. | 2,793 | 1,561 | 4,359,873 | 24·68 | 1,76,656 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 3,782 | 1,733 | 6,554,206 | 19·88 | 3,29,688 |
| 12 Kángra | 776 | 532 | 412,832 | 12·34 | 33,454 |
| 13 Amritsar | 2,169 | 984 | 2,134,296 | 18·51 | 1,15,305 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 3,973 | 1,040 | 4,131,920 | 16·45 | 2,51,180 |
| 15 Siálkot. | 5,785 | 917 | 5,304,845 | 16·45 | 3,22,483 |
| 16 Lahore | 3,460 | 461 | 1,595,060 | 16·45 | 96,964 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 3,259 | 669 | 2,180,271 | 17·14 | 1,27,203 |
| 18 Firozepore | 5,879 | 651 | 3,827,229 | 13·03 | 2,93,724 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 1,380 | 1,080 | 1,490,400 | 16·45 | 90,601 |
| 20 Jhelum | 622 | 792 | 492,624 | 17·83 | 27,628 |
| 21 Gujrát | 2,389 | 593 | 1,416,677 | 12·34 | 1,14,803 |
| 22 Shahpur | 838 | 1,700 | 1,424,600 | 12·34 | 1,15,445 |
| 23 Mooltan | 1,839 | 656 | 1,206,384 | 6·51 | 1,85,312 |
| 24 Jhang | 1,173 | 820 | 961,860 | 12·34 | 77,946 |
| 25 Montgomery. | 851 | 1,042 | 886,742 | 16·46 | 53,872 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 978 | 780 | 762,840 | 15·09 | 50,552 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 2,029 | 615 | 1,247,835 | 12·68 | 98,409 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 783 | 740 | 579,420 | 7·28 | 79,590 |
| 29 Bannu | 452 | 870 | 393,240 | 20·6 | 19,089 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 1,250 | 880 | 1,100,000 | 21·85 | 50,343 |
| 31 Hazára | 27 | 480 | 12,960 | 17·83 | 726 |
| 132 Kohát | 3,307 | 846 | 2,797,722 | 10·97 | 2,55,033 |
| Total | 71,867 | Average 846 | 60,804,785 | Average 12·58 | 48,32,541 |
No deduction is made for nursery or seed. The average of 12·58 lbs. per rupee is rather a high price. It is considered 12 seers or 24 lbs. per rupee would be nearer the average. I have, as above, kept the Report’s price though it is considered so high.
Turmeric.
Neither produce per acre nor price is given in the Report. I take 10 maunds for green, which gives 2 maunds dry or 164 lbs. dry per acre. The price is taken at, say, 10 lbs. per Re. 1.
4,130 acres × 164 lbs. = 677,320 lbs.; at 10 lbs. per Re. = Rs. 67,732.
Coriander Seed.
As above, neither produce per acre nor price is given in the Report. I take as follows:—
6,934 acres × 330 lbs. dry per acre = 2,288,220 lbs. at 16 lbs. per Re. = Rs. 1,43,014.
Ginger.
As above.
286 acres × 205 lbs. per acre (dry) = 58,630 lbs.; at 7 lbs. per Re. = Rs. 8,376.
Chillies.
Produce per acre given for four districts only, viz.:—
No. 2 acres 774 × 600 lbs. = 464,400 lbs. 13 611 × 410 „ = 250,510 „ 18 3,604 × 924 „ = 3,330,096 „ 30 77 × 640 „ = 49,280 „ Average Total.. 5,066 808 „ 4,094,286 „ Add for 18,452 at „ „ 14,909,216 „ 23,518 19,003,502 „
Other Kinds of Drugs and Spices.
These are chiefly ajmá, bádián, jeree, and sowá. Neither produce per acre nor price is given in the Report. I take as follows:—
Acres 35,074 at 330 lbs. per acre = 11,574,420 lbs.; at average of 14 lbs. per Re. = Rs. 8,26,744.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. |
|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 10,260 | 293 | 3,006,180 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 11,506 | 237 | 2,726,922 |
| 3 Karnál | 13,018 | 500 | 6,509,000 |
| 4 Hissar | 21,582 | 242 | 5,222,844 |
| 5 Rohtak | 12,304 | 297 | 3,654,288 |
| 6 Sirsa | 79,160 | 801 | 6,332,800 |
| 7 Umballa | 27,229 | 560 | 15,248,240 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 11,172 | 668 | 7,462,896 |
| 9 Simla | … | … | … |
| 10 Jullundar | 11,392 | 715 | 8,145,280 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 25,911 | 310 | 8,032,410 |
| 12 Kángra | 18,442 | 352 | 6,491,584 |
| 13 Amritsar | 35,996 | 582 | 20,949,672 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 24,923 | 408 | 10,168,584 |
| 15 Siálkot | 23,806 | 777 | 18,497,262 |
| 16 Lahore | 81,894 | 260 | 21,292,440 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 17,952 | 307 | 5,511,264 |
| 18 Firozepore | 70,315 | 601 | 42,259,315 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 69,294 | 311 | 21,550,434 |
| 20 Jhelum | 60,169 | 481 | 28,941,289 |
| 21 Gujrát | 50,375 | 291 | 14,659,125 |
| 22 Shahpur | 4,712 | 750 | 3,534,000 |
| 23 Mooltan | 9,541 | 462 | 4,407,942 |
| 24 Jhang | 3,473 | 252 | 875,196 |
| 25 Montgomery | 29,076 | 477 | 13,869,252 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 24,453 | 288 | 7,042,464 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 17,660 | 464 | 8,194,240 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 20,473 | 492 | 10,072,716 |
| 29 Bannu | 4,004 | 136 | 544,544 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 30,244 | 460 | 13,912,240 |
| 31 Hazára | 21,005 | 533 | 11,195,665 |
| 32 Kohát | 5,348 | 251 | 1,342,348 |
| Total | 846,689 | Average 392 | 331,652,436 |
Districts, 32; total acres, 846,689; average per acre, 392 lbs.; total quantity, 331,652,436 lbs.
The price of these seeds is not given in the Report. I take as follows: Linseed and sarso, Rs. 3 per maund, or 27 lbs. per Re. 1; til seed, Rs. 4 per maund, or 20 lbs. per Re. 1; taramira, Rs. 2½ per maund, or 32 lbs. per Re. 1.
The quantity of these seeds is about in proportion of 55 per cent. of linseed and sarso, 15 per cent. of til, 30 per cent. of taramira. The price then will be—
55 per cent. × 27 lbs. = 1,485 ) 15 „ × 20 „ = 300 } Average, 27·45 lbs. per Re. 1. 30 „ × 32 „ = 960 ) Taking 27 lbs. per Re. 1, the total value will be Rs. 1,22,83,423.
Linseed . . 6 lbs. for seed per acre } × 55 per cent. } Average 7·15 Sarso . . 8 „ „ „ } lbs. per acre. Til . . 6 „ „ „ × 15 „ } Taramira . 8 „ „ „ × 30 „ }
Taking 7 lbs. of seed required per acre for produce of 392 lbs. gives 56-fold. Deducting 56th part, the total quantity will become 325,730,071 lbs., and total value will become Rs. 1,20,64,076.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 24,565 | 186 | 4,569,090 | 6·51 | 7,01,857 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 47,855 | 164 | 7,848,220 | 6·51 | 12,05,563 |
| 3 Karnál | 21,510 | 140 | 3,011,400 | 6·43 | 4,68,336 |
| 4 Hissar | 20,323 | 87 | 1,768,101 | 6·17 | 2,86,564 |
| 5 Rohtak | 49,073 | 70 | 3,435,110 | 7·2 | 4,77,098 |
| 6 Sirsa | 77 | 64 | 4,928 | 6·17 | 798 |
| 7 Umballa | 27,332 | 72 | 1,967,904 | 6·34 | 3,10,395 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 11,488 | 85 | 976,480 | 6·34 | 1,54,019 |
| 9 Simla | … | … | … | … | … |
| 10 Jullundar | 26,093 | 122 | 3,183,346 | 5·14 | 6,19,328 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 24,420 | 136 | 3,321,120 | 5·49 | 6,04,940 |
| 12 Kángra | 6,733 | 22 | 148,126 | 5·14 | 28,818 |
| 13 Amritsar | 23,597 | 64 | 1,510,208 | 5·65 | 2,67,293 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 37,474 | 50 | 1,873,700 | 5·14 | 3,64,533 |
| 15 Siálkot | 11,425 | 65 | 742,625 | 5·65 | 1,31,438 |
| 16 Lahore | 25,305 | 138 | 3,492,090 | 5·49 | 6,36,082 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 33,376 | 129 | 4,305,504 | 5·49 | 7,84,244 |
| 18 Firozepore | 9,680 | 158 | 1,529,440 | 6·17 | 2,47,883 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 33,745 | 128 | 4,319,360 | 4·46 | 9,68,466 |
| 20 Jhelum | 25,557 | 122 | 3,117,954 | 5·27 | 5,91,642 |
| 21 Gujrát | 24,716 | 43 | 1,062,788 | 4·63 | 2,29,543 |
| 22 Shahpur | 26,029 | 50 | 1,301,450 | 5·49 | 2,37,058 |
| 23 Mooltan | 16,550 | 82 | 1,357,100 | 5·65 | 2,40,194 |
| 24 Jhang | 16,881 | 87 | 1,468,647 | 5·27 | 2,78,680 |
| 25 Montgomery | 15,838 | 149 | 2,359,862 | 5·31 | 4,44,418 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 29,632 | 124 | 3,674,368 | 6· | 6,12,394 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 11,175 | 115 | 1,285,125 | 6· | 2,14,187 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 29,739 | 84 | 2,498,076 | 5·7 | 4,38,259 |
| 29 Bannu | 7,544 | 73 | 550,712 | 5·36 | 1,02,744 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 16,468 | 105 | 1,729,140 | 5·23 | 3,30,619 |
| 31 Hazára | 8,280 | 100 | 828,000 | 4·11 | 2,01,460 |
| 32 Kohát | 6,396 | 121 | 773,916 | 4·41 | 1,75,491 |
| Total | 668,876 | Average 105 | 70,013,890 | Average 5·66 | 1,23,54,344 |
The average of 105 lbs. per acre is evidently too high ; 80 lbs. will be nearer the mark. If so, the above quantity and value are nearly 36¼ per cent. above the right quantity and value.
Very probably some of the figures of produce per acre are for uncleaned or seed cotton. The report uses the word “cotton” only in the column of produce per acre, while in the column for prices it uses the words “cotton (cleaned).”
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. |
|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 2,100 | 11,158 | 2,431,800 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 516 | 116 | 59,856 |
| 3 Karnál | 1,085 | 450 | 488,250 |
| 4 Hissar | 2,788 | 153 | 426,564 |
| 5 Rohtak | 16,146 | 465 | 7,507,890 |
| 7 Umballa | 1,619 | 220 | 356,180 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 1,637 | 305 | 499,285 |
| 10 Jullundar | 3,655 | 398 | 1,454,690 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 6,424 | 192 | 1,233,408 |
| 12 Kángra | 5,263 | 312 | 1,642,056 |
| 13 Amritsar | 1,002 | 444 | 444,888 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 1,622 | 352 | 570,944 |
| 15 Siálkot | 3,205 | 177 | 567,285 |
| 16 Lahore | 537 | 306 | 164,322 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 355 | 406 | 144,130 |
| 18 Firozepore | 1,649 | 218 | 359,482 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 417 | 120 | 50,040 |
| 20 Jhelum | 203 | 360 | 73,080 |
| 21 Gujrát | 971 | 286 | 277,706 |
| 22 Shahpur | 2 | 250 | 500 |
| 25 Montgomery | 225 | 366 | 9,150 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 39 | 240 | 9,360 |
| Total | 51,260 | Average. 366 | 18,770,866 |
In the Report the figures of crop per acre are given under the heading “Fibres.” In the columns per “acres cultivated,” cotton and hemp are given under the heading of “Fibres;” and as produce per acre of cotton is given separately, the produce per acre under the heading “Fibres” applies to hemp. The prices are not given in the Report. I take ordinarily prepared fibre as 20 lbs. per rupee. The value of 18,770,866 lbs. at 20 lbs. per rupee will be Rs. 9,38,543.
Kassamba (Safflower).
Neither produce per acre nor price is given in the Report. I take 40 lbs. per acre of dry prepared stuff, and price 2½ lbs. per Re 1.
Acres, 24,708 × 40 lbs. = 988,320 ; at 2½ lbs. per Re. 1 gives Rs. 3,95,328.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. |
|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 100 | 30 | 3,000 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 56 | 100 | 5,600 |
| 3 Kárnal | 588 | 30 | 17,640 |
| 4 Hissar | 1785 | … | … |
| 5 Rohtak | 11,526 | … | … |
| 7 Umballa | 1,798 | 62 | 111,476 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 2,647 | 33 | 87,351 |
| 10 Jullundar | 754 | 41 | 30,914 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 1,162 | 44 | 51,128 |
| 18 Firozepore | 26 | 24 | 624 |
| 21 Gujrát | 47 | 101 | 4,747 |
| 23 Mooltan | 75,364 | 26 | 1,959,464 |
| 24 Jhang | 2 | 29 | 58 |
| 25 Montgomery | 8 | 20 | 160 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 20,603 | 50 | 1,030,150 |
| 28 D. G. Kahn | 23,999 | 29 | 695,971 |
| Total | 129,465 | Average. 31·44 | 3,998,283 1add 72,658 |
| 4,070,941 |
The price is not given in the Report. I take Annas 12 per lb., which will give the total value to be Rs. 30,53,205.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 11,700 | 4,753 | 55,610,100 | 43·88 | 12,67,322 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 19,387 | 16,000 | 56,322,000 | 28·8 | 19,55,625 |
| 3 Kárnal | 846 | 4,753 | 4,021,038 | 39·77 | 1,01,107 |
| 4 Hissar | 3,485 | „ | 16,564,205 | 28·8 | 5,75,146 |
| 5 Rohtak | 920 | „ | 4,372,760 | 35·65 | 1,22,658 |
| 6 Sirsa | 677 | „ | 3,217,781 | 27·43 | 1,17,308 |
| 7 Umballa | 3,495 | „ | 16,611,735 | 35·65 | 4,65,967 |
| 8 Ludhiána. | 7,560 | „ | 35,932,680 | 30·17 | 11,91,006 |
| 9 Simla | 7 | „ | 33,271 | 60·34 | 551 |
| 10 Jullundar | 7,731 | „ | 36,745,443 | 27·43 | 13,39,607 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 3,586 | „ | 17,044,258 | 32·91 | 5,17,905 |
| 12 Kángra | 6,551 | „ | 31,136,903 | 49·37 | 6,30,684 |
| 13 Amritsar | 15,175 | „ | 72,126,775 | 36·34 | 19,84,776 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 6,790 | „ | 32,272,870 | 27·43 | 11,76,553 |
| 15 Siálkot | 3,000 | „ | 14,259,000 | 32·91 | 4,33,272 |
| 16 Lahore | 5,746 | „ | 27,310,738 | 24·68 | 11,06,593 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 56,988 | „ | 270,863,964 | 39·77 | 68,10,761 |
| 18 Firozepore | 14,274 | 12,015 | 8,612,110 | 32·91 | 2,61,686 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 4,660 | 4,753 | 22,148,980 | 40·45 | 5,47,564 |
| 20 Jhelum | 3,709 | „ | 17,628,877 | 31·54 | 5,58,937 |
| 21 Gujrát | 21,904 | „ | 104,109,712 | 28·8 | 36,14,920 |
| 22 Shahpur | 11,072 | „ | 52,625,216 | .. | .. |
| 23 Mooltan | 29,239 | „ | 138,972,967 | 26·74 | 51,97,194 |
| 24 Jhang | 23,203 | „ | 110,283,859 | 20·57 | 53,61,393 |
| 25 Montgomery | 1,423 | „ | 6,763,519 | 27·43 | 2,46,574 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 3,095 | „ | 14,710,535 | 21·25 | 6,92,260 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 803 | „ | 3,816,659 | 33·42 | 1,14,202 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 794 | „ | 3,773,882 | 20·57 | 1,83,465 |
| 29 Bannu | 4,152 | „ | 19,734,456 | 45·25 | 4,36,120 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 3,631 | „ | 17,258,143 | 32·05 | 5,38,475 |
| 31 Hazára | 598 | „ | 2,842,294 | 45·25 | 62,813 |
| 32 Kohát | 599 | „ | 2,847,047 | 31·45 | 90,526 |
| Total | 256,800 | Average 4,753 | 1,220,573,777 | Average 30·98 | 3,77,02,970 for 1,167,948,561 lbs. |
The prices I have taken above are given in the Report for potato only, and the average comes to, say, 31 lbs. per Re. 1. This is a high average price. The average price of potato will be nearer 60 than 31 lbs. I take, however, the average of 31 lbs.
Now out of the vegetables grown, about one-eighth only will be potato, and seven-eighths other kind of general vegetables. This will give, out of 1,220,573,777 lbs., seven-eighths of general vegetables = 1,068,002,055 lbs.
The price of vegetables is not given in the Report. It may be taken as 1½ maunds per Re. 1 or 124 lbs., say 100 lbs. per Re. 1, which will give the total value of vegetables to be about Rs. 1,06,80,020.
Again, the average of 4,753 lbs. is of vegetables, but potato will be only about 30 maunds or 2,460 lbs. per acre; and as potato will be about one-eighth of the acreage planted with vegetables, or about 32,100 acres, the total quantity of potato will be 32,100 × 2,460 = 78,966,000 lbs. This, at the price of 31 lbs. per Re. 1, will give Rs. 25,47,290. I make no deduction for seed potato, or seed for vegetables.
Tea.
The produce per acre is given for one district only; but the Report, at page 78, takes the general average to be the same —viz., 96 lbs. The price is not given. I take 3 lbs. per Re. 1.
Total acres, 8,884 × 96 lbs. 852,864 lbs.; at 3 lbs. per Re. 1 will give Rs. 2,84,288.
| Districts. | Acres. | Per Acre. | Total Quantity. | 1st sort. Price per Re. 1. | Total Value. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| lbs. | lbs. | lbs. | Rs. | ||
| 1 Delhi | 34,881 | 1, 21,500 | 52,321,500 | 5·49 | 95,30,328 |
| 2 Gurgaon | 1,125 | 646 | 726,750 | 6·68 | 1,08,795 |
| 3 Kárnal | 14,309 | ,, | 9,243,614 | 7·03 | 13,14,881 |
| 4 Hissar | 34 | ,, | 321,964 | .. | .. |
| 5 Rohtak | 33,324 | ,, | 21,527,304 | 8·14 | 26,44,631 |
| 6 Sirsa | 6 | 1389 | 2,334 | 6·34 | 368 |
| 7 Umballa | 25,540 | 1280 | 7,151,200 | 5·83 | 12,26,620 |
| 8 Ludhiána | 14,400 | 661 | 9,518,400 | 6·86 | 13,87,521 |
| 9 Simla | .. | .. | .. | .. | .. |
| 10 Jullundar | 43,963 | 1531 | 23,344,353 | 6·51 | 35,85,922 |
| 11 Hoshiarpur | 42,015 | 1597 | 25,082,955 | 6·51 | 38,52,988 |
| 12 Kángra | 8,139 | 1494 | 4,020,666 | 6·43 | 6,25,297 |
| 13 Amritsar | 36,579 | 646 | 23,630,034 | 7·11 | 33,23,492 |
| 14 Gurdáspur | 41,375 | 1360 | 14,895,000 | 5·65 | 26,36,283 |
| 15 Siálkot | 29,009 | 646 | 18,739,814 | 6·51 | 28,78,619 |
| 16 Lahore | 2,527 | ,, | 1,632,442 | 5·65 | 2,88,927 |
| 17 Gujránwála | 26,625 | ,, | 17,199,750 | 7·2 | 25,27,743 |
| 18 Firozepore | 1,916 | 1410 | 785,560 | 6· | 1,30,926 |
| 19 Ráwalpindi | 2,381 | 646 | 1,538,126 | 6·34 | 2,42,606 |
| 20 Jhelum | 414 | ,, | 267,444 | 5·83 | 45,873 |
| 21 Gujrát | 7,221 | 1660 | 4,765,860 | 6·51 | 7,32,082 |
| 22 Shahpur | 1,312 | 646 | 3847,552 | .. | .. |
| 23 Mooltan | 3,726 | ,, | 2,406,996 | 6·17 | 3,90,112 |
| 24 Jhang | 260 | 1261 | 67,860 | 5·91 | 11,482 |
| 25 Montgomery | 113 | 646 | 72,998 | 6·17 | 11,831 |
| 26 Mazaffargarh | 4,355 | ,, | 2,813,330 | 5·83 | 4,82,560 |
| 27 D. I. Khan | 88 | ,, | 56,848 | 5·65 | 10,061 |
| 28 D. G. Khan | 55 | ,, | 35,530 | 5·23 | 6,793 |
| 29 Bannu | 5,443 | ,, | 3,516,178 | 5·36 | 6,56,003 |
| 30 Pesháwar | 9,914 | ,, | 6,404,444 | 6·08 | 10,53,362 |
| 31 Hazára | 561 | ,, | 362,406 | 5·49 | 66,022 |
| 32 Kohát | 20 | ,, | 12,920 | 5·74 | 2,250 |
| Total | 391,630 | Average 646 | 253,012,132 | Average 6·34 | 3,97,74,378 for 252,142,616 lbs., excluding the two quantities marked 3. |
The average price, as obtained on the basis of the prices given in the Report, is for “first sort,” or what is called “misri.” But there are different qualities of sugar—viz., gól, red sugar, ordinary second sort sugar, and best or first sort sugar. Taking the price of first sort as averaging 6 lbs. per rupee, the prices of the other kinds are :—
Gól . . . . . 24 lbs. per rupee } Of these the first two form Red Sugar . . 16 „ „ } nearly two-thirds, and the last Ordinary Second 7 „ „ } two form one-third of the First sort . . 6 „ „ } whole quantity. Taking in this ratio, we get Two-thirds at 20 lbs. = 13⅓ } One-third „ 6½ „ = 2⅙ } or 15½, or say 15 lbs. per rupee.
The whole quantity, being 253,012,132 lbs., will, at 15 lbs. per rupee, give the total value Rs. 1,68,67,475.
For seed, to deduct cane equal to 40 lbs. of sugar per acre. This gives 16-fold, and taking the higher average of 646 lbs., I deduct, say, 6 per cent.
The whole quantity is then 237,831,405 lbs., and the whole value is then Rs. 1,58,55,427.
If, as I have pointed out above, the average of Delhi were taken at 500 lbs. instead of 1,500 lbs., which would make the average produce of the whole of Punjab 487 lbs. instead of 646 lbs., the above quantity and value will prove some 30 per cent. higher than they should be.
It may be noted here that the Report itself makes the average 449 lbs. only, on the fallacious principle of simply adding up and dividing by the number of districts ; while, when properly calculated, the figure should be 646 instead of 449. This is an instance of how misleading and incorrect the averages are as they are generally calculated in the Administration Reports.
| Produce. | Acres. | Total Quantity lbs. | Average per Acre. lbs. | Total Value. Rs. | Average Price per Re. 1. lbs. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rice | 708,699 | 541,492,369 | 796 | 2,25,35,693 | 20·42 |
| Wheat | 6,609,497 | 5,332,813,517 | 840·4 | 9,17,42,419 | 53·48 |
| Makai (Indian Corn) | 1,084,339 | 1,593,872,255 | 1,500 | 2,33,01,265 | 68·4 |
| Jow (Barley) | 1,874,217 | 883,781,444 | 503 | 1,06,78,175 | 82·76 |
| Gram | 2,272,236 | 1,417,173,807 | 645 | 1,86,72,194 | 75·89 |
| Inferior Grains | 6,534,963 | 3,169,169,607 | 510·5 | 4,54,14,114 | 69·78 |
| Poppy (Opium) | 12,348 | 154,550 | 12·51 | 3,86,375 | ·4 { Rs. 2½ per lb. paid by Govt. |
| Tobacco | 71,867 | 60,804,785 | 846 | 48,32,541 | 12·58 |
| Turmeric | 4,130 | 677,320 | 164 (dry) | 67,732 | 10 |
| Coriander Seed | 6,934 | 2,288,220 | 330 „ | 1,43,014 | 16 |
| Ginger | 286 | 58,630 | 205 „ | 8,376 | 7 |
| Chillies | 23,518 | 3,800,700 (dry) | { 808 (green) } { 161·6 (dry) } | 4,75,100 | 8 |
| Other kinds of drugs and spices | 35,074 | 11,574,420 | 330 | 8,26,744 | 14 |
| Oil Seeds | 846,689 | 325,730,071 | 392 | 1,20,64,076 | 27 |
| Cotton | 668,876 | 70,013,890 | 105 | 1,23,54,344 | 5·66 |
| Hemp | 51,260 | 18,770,866 | 366 | 9,38,543 | 20 |
| Kassamba (Safflower) | 24,708 | 988,320 | 40 (dry) | 3,95,328 | 2·5 |
| Indigo | 129,465 | 4,070,941 | 31·44 | 30,53,205 | 1⅓ |
| Vegetables | 256,800 | { 1,068,002,055 78,966,000 | 4,753 2,460 | 1,06,80,020 25,47,290 | 100 Green Vegetables 31 Potato |
| Tea | 8,884 | 852,864 | 96 | 2,84,288 | 3 |
| Sugar | 391,630 | 237,831,405 | 646 | 1,58,55,427 | 15 { Average of four qualities |
| Total | 21,616,420 | 27,72,56,263 |
| Goods. | Value given in the Report. | Deduct for raw Material already calculated and included in the Produce, or imported and paid from Produce. | Balance representing Labour. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rs. | Rs. | Rs. | ||
| Silks | 19,62,049 | Say half for material (imported) | 9,81,024 | 9,81,024 |
| Cottons | 1,75,05,556 | „ 40 per cent. „ „ | 70,02,222 | 1,05,03,334 |
| Wool | 9,42,329 | 9,42,329 | ||
| Fibres | 6,41,578 | „ 20 „ „ „ | 1,28,315 | 5,13,263 |
| Paper | 1,58,565 | „ 25 „ „ „ | 39,641 | 1,18,924 |
| Wood | 67,28,686 | 67,28,686 | ||
| Iron | 43,26,132 | „ One-third „ „ | 14,42,044 | 28,84,088 |
| Brass and Copper | 6,38,573 | „ 40 per cent. „ „ | 2,55,429 | 3,83,144 |
| Building | 43,22,867 | 43,22,867 | ||
| Leather | 63,21,802 | 63,21,802 | ||
| Gold and Silver Lace | 56,27,054 | „ Two-thirds „ „ | 37,51,370 | 18,75,685 |
| Dyeing | 7,38,926 | „ Materials not stated | 7,38,926 | |
| Oil | 12,45,966 | „ Two-thirds, or say one-half Material | 6,22,983 | 6,22,983 |
| Shawls | 8,96,507 | „ One-twelfth Material imported | 74,709 | 8,21,798 |
| Other Manufactures | 30,81,205 | Not Described | 30,81,205 | |
| Total | 4,08,40,058 | |||
Mines.
There is no clear statement of the value of the produce of mines given in this report. The chief article is salt. The Report does not give any account of the cost of salt.
Parl. Return No. 176 of 1878 gives (page 30) “the quantity manufactured, excavated, or purchased” during the year (1876-7) as 1,795,956 maunds. In the statistics published by the Government of India (1875) at Calcutta, Part III, page 79, it is said : “Since 4th July, 1870, one anna per maund has “been charged as the cost price of the salt, in addition to the duty.” At this rate the above production of salt—viz., 1,795,956 maunds—will cost Rs. 1,12,247. Duty is paid from the produce of the country.
For other minerals I can get no estimate. I roughly, and as a very outside estimate, put down the whole product of mines at Rs. 3 lakhs.
Stock.
I am unable to make any estimate of the annual addition to stock during the year. All that portion, however, which is used for agricultural or manufacturing purposes need not be estimated, as its labour, like that of the agriculturist and the manufacturer himself, is included in the agricultural or manufacturing produce. The portion of the annual produce or addition, which is used for other than agricultural and manufacturing purposes, such as carriage and food and milk, needs to be added to the production of the year. Though I cannot estimate this, still it will not matter much, for, as I have shown in the table for inferior grains, a certain portion of them goes in the feed of animals, and as this portion supplies the feed of the whole stock that requires grain and not merely that of the annual addition, the non-estimate of that portion of the annual addition to the stock which is used for carriage and for food may be more than covered by the value of the grain used for animals. Moreover, as I also give a margin upon the total estimate for any omission, any such item will be fully provided for.
| Value. | |
|---|---|
| Agricultural Produce | Rs. 27,72,56,263 |
| Manufactures | 4,08,40,058 |
| Mines. | 3,00,000 |
| Rs. 31,83,96,321 |
In order to meet any omissions (fish, etc.), I allow a further margin of above 3½ crores of rupees, making, say, the whole produce of Punjab 35⅓ crores of rupees, or at 2s. per rupee = £35,330,000, which for a population of 17,600,000 gives £2 per head per annum at the outside for the year 1876-7.
The approximate estimate I had made out for the year 1867-8 in my paper on the “Poverty of India” was 49s. 5d., showing that either my calculation for the year 1867-8 was too high, or the production of the Province has diminished in value. The truth most likely is between both.
At all events, unless any error of importance is pointed out, it seems clearly established that the value of the production of one of the best provinces in India is Rs. 20 per head per annum at the outside.
FOOD PRODUCE, 1876-7.
| Total Quantity. lbs. | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Rice | 541,492,369 | ||
| Wheat | 5,332,813,517 | ||
| Makai (Indian Corn) | 1,593,872,255 | ||
| Jow (Barley) | 883,781,444 | ||
| Gram | 1,417,173,807 | ||
| Inferior Grains | 3,169,169,607 | ||
| Total | 12,938,302,999 | ||
| Quantity Raised for Animals. | About | ||
| Gram | 1,417,173,807 lbs. | × ½ = | 708,586,903 |
| Jow | 883,781,444 ,, | × ¾ = | 662,836,083 |
| Jowár | 2,221,535 acres | × ⅔ = 1,481,023 | |
| Bájra | 2,339,796 ,, | × ½ = 1,169,898 | |
| Moth | 982,208 ,, | × ¾ = 736,656 | |
| Másh | 213,465 ,, | × ⅓ = 71,155 | |
| Total | 3,458,732 × 484 = 1,674,026,288 | ||
| Total | 3,045,449,274 | ||
| Balance remaining for human use | 9,892,853,725 | ||
Or 562 lbs. per annum, or 1 lb. 8·65 oz. per day per head for a population of 17,600,000.
Even taking the whole quantity of grain as for human use, and thus not allowing any portion at all for animals (which would, of course, not be right to do), the quantity per annum will be 735 lbs., or 2 lbs. per day per head.
In the value I have calculated for grain I have taken the whole grain— i.e., including the portion for animals.
Vegetables.
General Vegetables.
Total quantity, 1,068,002,055 lbs., gives 60·7 lbs. per annum, or 2·66 oz. per day per head.
Potato.
Total quantity, 78,966,000 lbs., gives 4·48 lbs. per annum, or 2 oz. per day per head.
| Revenue. | Population. | Revenue per head. | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rs. | Rs. | a. | p. | ||
| Bengal | 3,77,65,067 | 60,502,897 | 0 | 10 | 0 |
| Punjab | 2,00,15,260 | 17,611,498 | 1 | 2 | 2 |
| N.-West Provinces | 4,24,57,444 | 30,781,204 | 1 | 6 | 0¾ |
| Madras | 4,54,50,128 | 31,672,613 | 1 | 6 | 11 |
| Bombay (including Sind) | 3,69,43,563 | 16,302,173 | 2 | 4 | 3 |
Notes
- 1. In the Report crop per acre is given for two districts only, marked1. The average for these two—viz., 1499·17—say 1,500 lbs., is applied to all other districts by me.
- 2. No price is given in the Report for the three districts marked2. The average of the others—viz., 68·4 lbs.—is applied to these.
- 1. Crop per acre is given for only these four districts, the average of which for 104,861 acres is 503 lbs., and this average is applied to all the other districts for 1,769,356 acres.
- 1. Crop per acre is given for these districts only. The average from them is applied to others—viz., 645 lbs.
- 1. Seed required per Acre. for Acres. Joár, per acre 40 lbs. × 2,221,535 Bájrá . . 16 „ × 2,339,796 Kangni . . 8 „ × 58,434 Chína . . 16 „ × 74,842 Moth . . 24 „ × 982,208 Matter . . 20 „ × 106,865 Másh . . 16 „ × 213,465 Múng . . 16 „ × 263,324 Masúr . . 32 „ × 187,544 Arhar . . 16 „ × 86,950 6,534,963 The total of the products of these —168,694,604 divided by the total 6,534,963 of acres, will give an average of 26 lbs. per acre of seed for a crop of average 510 lbs.—say 20-fold. Deducting, then, 5 per cent. for seed, the total quantity will be 3,169,169,607 lbs., and total value will be Rs. 4,54,14,114.
- 2. The price for this is not given.
- 1. The produce per acre for these is not given in the Report. I have applied the average of the other districts—viz., 846 lbs.—to these.
- 1. This evidently is some mistake. It may be 280.
- 1 · [Unlinked note, p. 160] The produce per acre for this is not given in the Report. The average of the others (652 acres) is applied to this.
- 1. This is apparently a mistake. The figure is too high.
- 2. The crop per acre for this district not being given in the Report, I have given it the average, 366.
- 1. For these (2,311 acres) produce per acre is taken of the average for the others—viz., 31·44.
- 1. Produce per acre is given for vegetables for these two districts only, and the average of these—viz., 4,753—is applied to all others.
- 1. For these districts only is the produce per acre given in the Report. I have applied the average of these to others.
- 2. This is evidently a mistake. Though other districts, such as [p. 165] Ludhiána, are better than Delhi, and while 661 lbs. is considered a fair average for Ludhiána, 1,500 for Delhi cannot be correct. It is more likely 500 than 1,500. If 500 be adopted, the average will become 487 instead of 646 lbs. And it is also considered that an average of about 489 lbs. will be near the mark. I have allowed the figure 1,500 to remain, though this increases the average above 487 lbs. nearly 32 per cent.
- 1. I have taken 1875-6, for, on account of the famines in the Bombay and Madras Presidencies in the year 1876-7, a comparison for the year 1876-7 will be an unfair one.