Appendix G

Suggestions for an Insolvency Law for Rural India.

Musalmans and Money-Lenders in the Punjab, Septimus Smet Thorburn, 1886 · from page 196 · about 2 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

In a paper I submitted to Government on agricultural indebtedness in June, 1884, I wrote as follows on the amendment of Chapter XX of the Civil Procedure Code, which contains the existing insolvency law, and suggested the passing of an Act to comprise, inter alia, the following provisions :—

  • (a) requiring courts to discharge judgment-debtors owing Rs. 50 or less, when hereditary agriculturists, at once on payment of as much as the court thinks they can pay— see Section 19, Deccan Ryots' Act; also Section 358 of the Civil Procedure Code;
  • (b) legalising a declaration of insolvency in favor of hereditary agriculturists owing Rs 50 or upwards, upon their simple application and proof of indebtedness, and enabling the Collector to receive and manage as much of their immoveable property as is not required for the support of the insolvent and of his family for the benefit of the creditors, for a period not exceeding 14 years—(see Sections 25-29, Deccan Ryots Act).

" The existing insolvency rules contained in Chapter XX of the Civil Procedure Code are, I think, faulty and inequitably harsh, because --

  • (1) none but a judgment-debtor can benefit by them;
  • (2) when the debts are over Rs. 200, the discharge is not a discharge in full, all property subsequently acquired being liable to attachment and sale for 12 years;
  • (3) no property is exempted from disposal for the benefit of the creditors, and so the insolvent and his family are stripped and left destitute.

The unpopularity of the law as it stands is exemplified by the fact that, in 1882, only 283 persons applied for its 'benefit' throughout the Province (see Statement No. 7, Civil Report, 1882). Persons would almost daily file schedules of their debts before me, and seek an arrangement with their creditors by temporary alienation of their lands, but that in very few cases I am able to help them. As the creditors are often enjoying a share of each harvest as interest, they prefer not to sue their debtors. I have tried various expedients in order to settle debtors' outstandings, but only in a few cases have I succeeded. I have summoned the creditors and used pressure to make them come to terms. I have repeatedly urged the debtor to get a decree passed against himself, and arranged to leave him enough to save him and his family from starvation when declaring him an insolvent. I am endeavouring to arrange several heavy cases now: but the creditors know the advantages the law gives them, and I find it very difficult to settle fair terms with them. I have at present throughout the district, but chiefly in the Dera and Leiah tahsils, 274 lambardars, owing, in the aggregate, Rs. 5,81,157, whose debts I could easily arrange were a liberal insolvency law passed. Until it is passed, debtors from very hopelessness are precluded from any honorable exertion to free themselves. Many of their debts are inherited, and a large percentage have been liquidated over and over again in interest alone. Many are due to former over assessment, or former rigidity of assessment, particularly in the Indus tracts of the Leiah tahsil."