Appendix D

The Famine Commission on Relative Advantages of Fixity and Elasticity of Demand.

Musalmans and Money-Lenders in the Punjab, Septimus Smet Thorburn, 1886 · from page 180 · about 6 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

3. It is asserted that the present rigid system of collection is not only productive of temporary hardship to the agricultural classes, but often inflicts permanent injury by plunging them into indebtedness, from which it is rare for them to recover. The depressed condition of the land-owners in Jhansi and in the Deccan districts is held by some authorities to be due in part to the too severe enforcement of the payment of the land revenue in unfavourable seasons; and it is the belief of many experienced officials that there is no more effectual form of relief in times of pressure than a postponement of the Government demand.

4. These opinions command great respect from the weight of authority by which they are supported. They have of late been the subject of special inquiries on the part of the Government of India with a view to ascertaining from local officials, practically familiar with the working of the revenue system, the results of their experience as to the reality of the evils alleged to arise from a system of unvarying collections, and the feasibility of the plans suggested for its reform. We have not had access to the information thus collected. The evidence, however, at the disposal of the Commission suffices to show that there is considerable divergence of opinion as to the degree in which the depression of the agricultural classes in parts of India is connected with the system of collecting the land revenue, and as to how far it would be safe or expedient to modify in any material respect the existing arrangements. Moreover, when we come to consider the practical measures suggested, we find that very different degrees of elasticity are advocated by different persons. Some would make the annual demand vary in the case of individual land-holders or individual villages, according to the estimate made of the harvest reaped in each instance; some would make it vary uniformly over large tracts according to the general character of the harvest in each tract; some would limit this variation by fixing absolutely the amount to be collected in a cycle of years, but permitting a larger or smaller fraction of the total to be demanded in each year, according to the seasonal circumstances of the year; some would allow a variation based on a consideration of the area cultivated in each year, not of the quality of the crop raised on that area; some would adhere to the rule of a uniform moderate demand in ordinary years, allowing variations only in the case of almost complete failures in which so great a proportion of the crop is destroyed over a large area that Government is compelled to set on foot measures of relief.

6. With regard to the general question of introducing more elasticity into the demand for the land revenue, we must also bear in mind that although it has some of the characteristics of rent, as distinguished from taxation, and although the State to some extent stands in the position of landlord to those who pay land revenue, yet this analogy is in the nature of the case but partial. So far as the land revenue partakes of the character of rent, it is wholly impossible that the State, through its officers, can obtain the intimate knowledge of the condition of individual cultivators which is possessed by an ordinary landlord, and nothing but mischief could come of the attempt to regulate State action by the presumption that such knowledge could be obtained. So far again as it is of the nature of ordinary taxation, the collection of the State demand will necessarily be largely governed by the principles which apply to such taxation, and among these certainty and inflexibility are universally recognized as most important.

11. Where local conditions make the possibility of cultivating the land unusually precarious, as in the case of tracts habitually flooded by river inundation, which may fail to take place, or be excessive, or may subside too soon or too late for agricultural operations to be carried on, an exceptional procedure would appear desirable. We approve the system, successfully adopted in the Punjab in such cases, of carrying out a yearly rough measurement, according to the results of which a fixed rate of revenue per acre actually cultivated is levied. This plan would probably be found more suitable for Sindh than the Bombay form of settlement now being introduced there, and we think it possible that the application of a similar principle might be beneficial in any exceptionally dry upland tracts, such as exist in some parts of India, where the rainfall is very precarious and frequently insufficient.

12. It has been suggested that, although a system of varying assessment is not generally advisable, it may be suitable to the case of tracts of country where the landed class, either from want of thrift or skill in husbandry, or from other causes, are in a condition so depressed as to call for special treatment. The plan of a fixed assessment, regularly collected, is based on the assumption that the people by whom it is to be paid are, on the whole, of a sufficiently thrifty and far-sighted character to lay up in good years the means of meeting the demand for revenue in years of less prosperity. But there are populations where such qualities exist, if at all, only in a rudimentary form ; and with these the rigid enforcement of the payment of revenue may tend to an indebtedness leading on to complete insolvency. The Government of India not unfrequently is called on to deal with particular districts where indebtedness and insolvency have assumed serious proportions, and where the general condition of the community is so unsatisfactory that it cannot be restored to prosperity without resort to exceptional measures. It has been suggested that the Government in such cases should apply a system of revenue collections so graduated at the discretion of the revenue authorities, with reference to the character of the season, as to produce in the long run a prescribed average, the collections being heaviest in the most prosperous years, and lessened or altogether remitted in seasons when little or no margin of profit has been yielded by cultivation. Such a system might work beneficially, along with other remedial measures, for the relief of an exceptionally involved or incapable agricultural community which has been proved to be unable to maintain itself without such interposition ; but as it would necessarily involve a supervising establishment largely in excess of that ordinarily employed in a district, the expense and other evils attendant on it are such that the experiment would only be justified by very extraordinary circumstances, and as a temporary expedient, so long as the community is held to be incompetent. It is questionable, however, whether in such an extreme case it might not be simpler and preferable to revert to the old practice of taking the revenue in kind by partition of the crop.

As regards the views enunciated in para. 6, they are, I think, partly due to want of practical knowledge of the subject. I have answered the objection raised in the last four lines of the para. in page 115 of this book. As to the alleged impossibility of a Collector's acquiring sufficient individual acquaintance with the condition of such cultivators, a morning's ride will give an officer all the knowledge necessary for assessment purposes over the whole of the observed area. Crops do not vary field by field, but circle by circle.

As to para. 11, if lands subject to river inundations require a fluctuating system, à fortiori the cultivated area in barani tracts of short and uncertain require it much more.

As to para. 12, the "cyclical system" therein indicated is impracticable for reasons given at page 110. The difficulty of supervision noted by the Famine Commissioners no longer exists, as the field establishments have lately been largely increased, as stated at page 113.

Notes

  1. *. See pages 127-30 of Report of Indian Famine Commission (1880), Part II.