Chapter X

restrictions on the free transfer of land.

Musalmans and Money-Lenders in the Punjab, Septimus Smet Thorburn, 1886 · from page 99 · about 8 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

I.—Land Tenure.

There is at present free trade in land. The claims, if any, of pre-emptors being satisfied, landlord, peasant-proprietor, occupancy-tenant, and tenant-at-will, may sell or mortgage any or all of their respective rights to whomsoever they please. Conveyancing is cheap and expeditious. If the transfer be in writing, a small stamp duty is charged, and if the consideration is over Rs. 100, registration is compulsory, if under optional. If the parties prefer it the transaction can be carried out by verbal agreement only. In every case when possession is given, what is called a “mutation of names” must be effected in the annual village papers through the Tahsildar or his Naib. This operation now takes place where the land is situated, costs nothing, and is completed in a few minutes.

Since the last settlements of rights and of land revenue in the different districts of the Punjab, Bunniahs have acquired rights in many lakhs of acres as proprietors by purchase as mortgagees or lekha-mukhídirs,* or simply by having, after the Government revenue has been paid, a first claim on the produce as interest-in-kind on a debt due. Some charges of this latter kind have their origin in a practice common amongst poor proprietors and tenants, according to which the cultivator is advanced seed-grain at sowing time, and repays it with interest at harvest, either by the surrender of a share of his crop or of a certain measure of it. No reliable statistics have yet been prepared, showing for each locality what percentage of the cultivated area has been acquired since annexation by men of the trading and money-lending classes. In some localities, such as in parts of Muzaffargarh, Khatri Bunniahs farm as well as lend money, but the number of such men is inappreciably small.

Speaking generally, land owners are most miscellaneous, though still chiefly confined to persons belonging to agricultural tribes and castes, wherever population is dense, sub-division of land minute, and husbandry, by reason of the application of capital on irrigation or other works for increasing the productive power of the soil, good. Thus, in the rich Bannuchi tappahs (parishes) of the Bannu district, in parts of the Chhach plain, in the Rawalpindi district, and in the vicinity of Peshawar city, although the original Pathan proprietary families are still dominant, the buying and selling, mortgaging and bartering, of land in small plots has been for more than a generation so great that a large proportion of the cultivating owners are of mixed castes. Similarly, in the neighbourhood of towns and large, rich villages, the original owners no longer hold the greater part of the land,—Arains, Khatris, and men of the village,—menial and artisan castes being frequently found as full or part owners and as occupancy tenants.

In the case of wells used for irrigation and the cultivated area attached thereto, Bunniahs (Khatris) are often the sole owners, or hold shares, and where they do so, will sooner or later acquire the whole. Whenever a man of the money-lending class secures an interest in a well, the other shareholders, if men of an agricultural caste, feel that their shares will some day be absorbed too. Formerly a peasant wishing to sink a well had to associate a monied man with himself in order to raise the necessary capital, and the well and lands attached thereto were shared between them equally. This is the commonest origin of the adhlapi tenure.

Since 1871, Government has encouraged landlords to take advances for agricultural improvements, particularly for well sinking. This wise measure is now well known. Large sums have, for the last 12 years, been advanced ; * hence the landlord, if not in debt already, has no longer occasion to go to the money-lenders for means to sink a well. With the exception of isolated plots and villages, the above are the only localities in which the representatives of the original proprietary body have succumbed before the superior means and energy of outsiders. The proportion of all such lands in which money-lenders as owners, mortgagees or receivers of rent, have rights, is probably under 30 per cent. of their whole area. It may be laid down as a general proposition that wherever natural advantages have been great, over-population has caused the minute sub-divisions of estates, and has consequently so

TBL-005 · FOLIO 113Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Rs.a.p.
Agricultural improvements4,51,81400
Seed-grain19,46800
Bullocks41,92500
5,13,20700

operated as to freely admit outsiders as purchasers and mortgagees ; and further, that in tracts suitable for the profitable working of irrigation wells, until recently the capital of the money-lender was generally required to help the land-owner to sink a well. Giving due weight to the above considerations, and fully recognising the necessity of imposing no unnecessary restrictions on the investment of capital in land, whenever such investment will be spent on increasing the productive power of the land, I proceed to state the reform in land tenure which I recommend for adoption.

I would make it illegal for any person deriving profits from a shop or from money-lending, to acquire any interest in arable or pasture land, other than land in the immediate vicinity of a town or large village, or manured and irrigated land anywhere, or irrigated alone if from a well.

To this general rule I would add two exceptions, namely, I would permit seed-grain to be advanced, to be repaid at the next harvest only, and I would empower the District Officer to sanction a sale or mortgage in favor of a person of the proscribed class, whenever security was given that capital not less than a sum equal to ten times the annual land revenue of the land, would be invested in improving its productiveness within a reasonable time.

Such an alteration in the law, whilst leaving ample incentive for the further investment of capital in land, would effectually stop the further degradation and expropriation of the agricultural by the money-lending and shop-keeping classes, except in localities in which property has already so largely changed hands that tribal and village predominance and cohesion no longer exist. The depreciation of land in areas closed to shop-keepers and money-lenders would be almost inappreciable. Agriculturists would look upon the change as a just and wholesome measure in their interests; and as to money-lenders, some would concentrate their earth-hunger upon the more and better protected localities still open to them, whilst others would take to agriculture as a sole pursuit. Many of the smaller Marwari money-lenders, whom the Deccan Ryots Act deprived of their occupation, took to agriculture as their sole livelihood.

If arguments from outside are required in support of some restrictive measure, such as I am proposing, we have the practice of all native governments, ancient and modern. No State of the present day—unless it be some with institutions recently remodelled on our own—countenances the acquisition of land by its trading and money-lending classes. Popular opinion, which is all-powerful in such States, would not permit it. Looking further abroad, I believe I am correct in asserting that the Jews in Russia, and throughout the east of Europe generally, are disqualified from holding arable land. The peasantry in those countries are ignorant and prejudiced no doubt; but if they are so, they are as grown men to babes when compared with the peasantry of the Punjab.

It will be objected that my proposal, whilst leaving credit unshackled in rich localities, kills it in poor tracts, where it is most wanted. The answer to such an objection is simple. There is, in the first place, no comparison between the worldly intelligence and wisdom of the cultivators in the areas I would leave open to free competition and reserve for agriculturists alone. The former are generally clever enough to hold their own, whereas the latter are unsophisticated yokels who cannot. But besides this, these latter are so utterly improvident that when hard times come they prefer to live on in idleness on money lent, rather than to curtail their expenditure or work as labourers. The best possible discipline for such men in hard times is to constrain them to economise and live laborious days by contracting their borrowing power. When the season of distress is over, State aid can be furnished in the rare cases in which it may be necessary under the Agriculturists Loan Act already referred to. The money-lenders' apologists, who maintain that at such times the village usurer is a necessity, speak nonsense. It is clearly better to compel the Indian peasant when his crops fail to live sparingly, work hard, and, if absolutely necessary, borrow from the State at 6 per cent. interest, than to, as at present, encourage him to eat the bread of idleness, and borrow from an unscrupulous Bunniah at 18 to 36 per cent. interest. There is always plenty of work to be found at remunerative wages for willing hands, if not at home, at a reasonable distance from it.

In order to illustrate the possible effect of the alterations in the law which I have proposed, I have prepared a statement (Appendix C), from which it will be seen that in the 14 Musalman districts of the Punjab, 4,544 square miles of the most productive and cultivated land will remain open to the capitalist, whilst the remainder, or 57,248 square miles of inferior productiveness, will be reserved for agriculturists alone. From an examination of the statement, it will be seen that in each district a reasonable quantity of unreserved area is available for the investments of the capitalist; and from a personal knowledge of the districts, I may add that that area is generally fairly distributed amongst the different tahsils or sub-collectorates. Thus persons wishing to invest in land will never have to go far afield to find a suitable locality :- moreover, if prepared to immediately sink capital on permanent improvement, calculated to increase the productive power of the land, unreserved areas will be open to their enterprise.

Notes

  1. *. For definition of the term, see page 83.
  2. *. See Land Improvement Acts XXVI of 1871 and XIX of 1883 ; also Agriculturists Loan Act XII of 1884 and its predecessor Act X of 1879. In 1871-72 the amount of advances made to agriculturists in the Punjab was nearly a lakh and a quarter, and has since that year been steadily increasing, and now aggregates over five lakhs in each year. The detail for 1884-85 was—