The Punjab was annexed in 1849. The Mahomedan tribes occupying its western half were then collectively, each within their own domain, owners and cultivators of the soil. No sanction existing to enable a money-lender to hold land, the limit of an individual cultivator's credit was his willingness to surrender the surplus of a good crop to his creditor. The revenue system of the Sikh Government was to take in kind as much of each crop as it could safely obtain without causing insurrection or discouraging cultivation. Thus the opportunity presented, in 1849, for introducing the best possible revenue and land laws into a newlyconquered country, was unique. The early administrators of the Punjab had practically a tabula rasa to work upon.
Did they, then, with the experience of Bombay, Bengal, and the North-Western Provinces before their eyes, do the best possible for the people of the new Province? We have already seen that they suddenly substituted fixed cash assessments for fluctuating kind payments, and by presenting each individual with the fee-simple of his holding, raised his credit from a few rupees to the market-value of that holding. With a fairly constant yield and prudence on the part of the cultivator, both changes, had they been introduced gradually, might have been productive of excellent results.
Unfortunately, throughout most of the Punjab south of the Himalayan submontane zone, a crop of any sort is never certain—the heavens themselves forbid it. Unfortunately, too, the peasantry are in worldly intelligence as stupid as their own plough-oxen. Thus both measures were fatal gifts; and when subsequently supplemented by a complicated system of civil law and procedure, which presupposes that all men are equally endowed with legal minds, the consequence must be that "the finest peasantry in India" will shortly be reduced into the position of serfs to their creditors. A glance at their present economic condition is necessary, because the highest administrators, from official optimism and their luxurious remoteness from rural facts, still believe in the general prosperity of the Punjab agriculturists.
The inquiries of 1870 demonstrated that an uneasy feeling existed in the minds of many experienced Punjab officers that the indebtedness of the agricultural classes was on the increase. But the absence of reliable statistics as to the transfer of rights in land to non-agriculturists, want of leisure and fear of a snubbing from the Provincial Despots—the Lieutenant-Governor and the Financial Commissioner—sealed most mouths; still the impression was general amongst those District and Settlement Officers who moved about freely amongst the people.
Until the end of 1857 the period of limitation for suits generally had been 12 years. It was then reduced to six years for claims on bonds and accounts. In November 1859, it was further reduced to three years—what it is now— except in the case of suits based on registered bonds, for which six years remained the limit. Each successive diminution of the period brought about a flood of litigation. In the Punjab Administration Report for 1859-60, the enormous increase in the number of civil suits in 1859 is flippantly referred to as "this grand battue of litigation." As the new law forced creditors into the courts every third year, whenever they failed to induce their debtors to renew their bonds with interest and compound interest superadded, the civil courts were soon clogged with arrears, which the institution of Small Cause Courts in large centres could do little to keep down.
In 1866 a further and, perhaps, more important change in the judicial history of the Punjab took place. In that year a Chief Court was established at Lahore in supersession of a Judicial Commissioner: Act VIII of 1859—the Civil Procedure Code of the Regulation Provinces—was extended to the Punjab, and pleaders were admitted to practise in the courts.
By those means the old rule under which "equity and good conscience" excused all irregularities of procedure, was abrogated, and a reign of technical law and of costly and slow litigation inaugurated. In 1866 the number of suits instituted in the Province rose to the hitherto unprecedented figure of 1,65,520, or one suit to every ninety souls or eighteen heads of families. This proportion was about three times that in Bengal and the Central Provinces, four times that in Oudh, and nearly five times that in the North-Western Provinces.
By 1870 the number of institutions had increased to 2,05,606, of which 71 per cent. were for "money due," being 19 per cent. more than in the previous year. In 1871 the long-suffering agriculturist was further burdened by the levy of an additional "local rates" cess of 6 per cent. on the land revenue he paid.
The number of suits disposed of in that year rose to 2,18,390, of which 1,66,679 were for " money due." The number has since continued to rise year by year, and now stands at the enormous figure of 2,71,375, or 52,985 more than in 1871.*
In the Administration Report for the financial year 1872-73, the Lieutenant-Governor complacently referred to the peasant proprietors of his Province as " thriving and industrious cultivators of the soil," and was " not disposed to regard
| Year. | Number of civil courts sitting. | NUMBER OF SUITS DISPOSED OF | + or - on figures of preceding year. | Remarks. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| For money due. | Others. | Total. | ||||
| 1866 | 392 | 96,222 | 70,336 | 1,66,558 | ... | |
| 1867 | 409 | 90,697 | 54,980 | 1,45,677 | - 20,881 | |
| 1868 | 405 | 1,05,506 | 46,321 | 1,51,827 | + 6,150 | |
| 1869 | 434 | 1,21,597 | 48,318 | 1,69,715 | +18,088 | |
| 1870 | 433 | 1,44,958 | 58,856 | 2,03,714 | +33,799 | |
| 1871 | 442 | 1,66,679 | 51,711 | 2,18,390 | +14,676 | |
| 1872 | 505 | 1,68,209 | 50,134 | 2,18,343 | - 47 | |
| 1873 | 497 | 1,69,937 | 53,456 | 2,23,393 | + 5,050 | |
| 1874 | 501 | 1,77,279 | 57,561 | 2,34,840 | +11,447 | |
| 1875 | 595 | 1,73,224 | 62,123 | 2,35,347 | + 507 | |
| 1876 | 596 | 1,87,895 | 59,341 | 2,47,236 | +11,889 | |
| 1877 | 490 | 1,83,421 | 60,561 | 2,43,082 | - 3,254 | |
| 1878 | (?) | 1,91,635 | 59,221 | 2,50,856 | + 6,874 | |
| 1879 | 469 | 2,08,862 | 44,225 | 2,53,087 | + 2,231 | The detail of disposals |
| 1880 | 450 | 2,13,987 | 49,890 | 2,63,877 | +10,790 | |
| 1881 | 438 | 2,12,967 | 51,324 | 2,64,291 | + 414 | |
| 1882 | 444 | 2,09,492 | 60,281 | 2,69,773 | + 5,482 | |
| 1883 | 440 | 2,13,895 | 58,706 | 2,72,601 | + 2,828 | |
| 1884 | (?) | 2,13,297 | 58,078 | 2,71,375 | - 1,226 | |
this comparatively free resort to the courts in petty cases as an unfavourable sign."
One ominous sign of the demoralization caused by the changes effected in 1866, was early noticed by many District Officers—litigants ceasing to trust each other, no longer resorted to arbitration for the settlement of their civil disputes.*
In 1873-74 the consensus of opinion amongst District Officers, on the baneful effect of the system established in 1866, was so strong that the Lieutenant-Governor was constrained to take notice of it. He remarked† that most of the officers who thought special measures of relief were necessary to rescue the peasantry from their alleged indebtedness, presided as Judges in courts sitting in rural tracts, and therefore, owing to their limited means of observation, "took a gloomy view of the financial position of the peasantry." He instanced several amendments in the law—mostly of an enabling character only—which empowered courts to refuse to enforce contracts when "undue influence" had been used, and impeded the execution of a decree directed against ancestral and jointly-held property in land. Further, after illustrating his argument by some comparative statistics, he came to the conclusion that "the state of the peasantry is in general eminently prosperous." Five years later this opinion was emphatically endorsed by Sir Richard Temple. In his evidence before the Famine Commission in 1879, he stated that "throughout the Punjab the condition of the peasant proprietors" was "eminently creditable to British rule."
Returning to the views of the Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab in 1873-74, notwithstanding the official satisfaction with which he received the rising flood of petty litigation, in which agriculturists were chiefly the defendants and Bunniahs the plaintiffs, he frankly admitted that if pessimists could make out their case he would be "prepared to sacrifice, if necessary, a large amount of theory to secure the contentment of the people." Meanwhile, the number of claims on "money due" went on increasing.
In 1874-75, a measure of relief was afforded to the over-worked civil officers of the Province by the creation of two new kinds of purely civil courts, which were called Munsiffs and Judicial Assistants. The change facilitated the disposal of suits, brought courts nearer to the homes of the people, ensured greater attention to the technical provisions of the law than formerly, and gave Executive officers—Tahsildars and District Officers*— more time for the exercise of their proper functions. The change was hailed by money-lenders and village shop-keepers as a further concession in their interests, but was not appreciated by the people at large, amongst whom the feeling of despair, that their interests were being sacrificed to those of Bunniahs, found expression in many terse or scornful sayings, the shortest, yet most comprehensive, of which is perhaps pothi, gawah, digri,—a bond, a witness, a decree,—as descriptive of the three stages in a civil action and its inevitable result.
In his review of the civil administration of his Province in 1882-83, the Lieutenant-Governor remarked that "the number of pleaders is annually increasing, and few cases reach the higher appellate court without the entertainment of advocates, however small the value of the subject-matter." He then went on to observe "whether, in the present state of the Province, it is an unmixed benefit to the people to be able to avail themselves so freely of professional assistance in the prosecution of their claims, may be matter for consideration." There is a ring of helpless regret in the rather impotent conclusion to His Honor's observation. Every officer in the Province knows that "the people,"—i. e., the peasantry, hate the interference of pleaders in their cases, and that in suits between Bunniah-creditor and peasant-debtor, and others of a perfectly simple character, such media obscure justice and ruinously enhance the costs of litigation.
This lengthy digression is justified if it proves that, after faintly echoing the note of alarm, which, in 1873-74, penetrated the sanctuary of the Local Government, the attitude of that Government, with respect to signs and omens of the increasing embarrassment of the people committed to its charge, has since been one of persistent optimism.
The position then is, that the Punjab Government holds that the agricultural classes throughout the Province are in a highly prosperous condition, which, if true, is, as Sir R. Temple says, "eminently creditable to British rule."
As civil officers, whose duties for many years past have made them each—for the districts in which he has served—familiarly acquainted with "the people of the Punjab," have reason to think otherwise, I shall, as briefly as I can, describe what is the true condition of that people.
Adhering to my plan of confining my case to the Musalman half of the Province, I shall only write of the 14 districts west of the Jhelum meridian. I may, however, observe that in many tracts east of Jhelum, particularly throughout the south and south-east of the Province, the peasantry are nearly, if not quite as much, involved as they are south of the Salt Range in the western half of the Punjab.
The conclusion to which the Famine Commission came in 1880* was, in their own words—
We learn from evidence collected from all parts of India that about one-third of the land-holding classes are deeply and inextricably in debt, and that at least an equal proportion are in debt, though not beyond the power of recovering themselves. It is commonly observed that land-holders are more indebted than tenants with occupancy-rights, and tenants with rights than tenants-at-will, —a result obviously attributable to the fact that the classes which have the best security to offer are the most eligible customers of the money-lenders. It does not appear that in this respect one Province greatly differs from another, but certain localities are, from special circumstances, either above or below the average condition. Thus, in the Punjab the canalirrigated tracts are stated to be highly prosperous.
A Commission, then, of unbiassed experts, after carefully considering the best obtainable evidence, gave a verdict directly contrary to that of the Punjab Government and Sir R. Temple.
The officers who know the people best are those who spend five or six months in camp every year, and are left for several years in one district. Settlement Officers generally serve for six or seven years in the same district. If it happens to be a quiet rural district, the chances are, that the officer will knock about in camp for half the year and hold an open levée every day in the week all the year round. Should there be a cantonment in the district, or a popular hill station, the distraction of society and the delights of Himalayan life will probably prove inimical to the acquisition of intimacy with the people. The same causes affect district officers, who are, moreover, generally older men than Settlement Officers, and therefore less inclined for camp life ; and further, they do not, on an average, hold charge of the same district for more than two years. We may presume that such men will generalise more correctly, but have less particular rural knowledge, than Settlement Officers. Of the 14 districts of the Western Punjab, five only are quiet rural districts* without cantonments or hill stations. The head-quarters of the other nine have large garrisons, † and two (Rawalpindi and Hazara) have, in addition, popular Himalayan stations within their limits.
Of the five ungarrisoned districts, two—Gujrat and Shahpur—were settled nearly 20 years ago, in days when cultivators were still comparatively unembarrassed. The other three districts— Montgomery, Muzaffargarh, and Jhang—were settled between 1868 and 1880 by Messrs. Purser, O'Brien, and Steedman, and their reports prove that during their six years' lonely exile in their respective districts, they learnt to know the people as thoroughly as it is possible for English gentlemen to become intimate with uneducated natives. The three districts lie together south of the Salt Range, in the great arid plain described in the opening chapter of this book.
The opinions of the Settlement Officers of those districts, on the condition of the peasantry in them, may be accepted as absolutely correct.
In Montgomery "the revenue and the seed are usually borrowed; and there are few villages that are not seriously in debt."*
For Jhang, Mr. Steedman, writing in 1880, says :—
† From 40 to 50 per cent. of owners, and 60 to 70 per cent. of tenants-at-will, are in debt. There are very few occupancy tenants in this district. I am of opinion that in the case of owners, their average indebtedness is about 25 per cent. of their income, and in the case of tenants, 50 per cent. Owners' debts are usually due to improvident expenditure on marriages and funerals, or to failures of harvests. What keeps the debt from being paid off, is the ruinous rate of interest charged. An ordinary zemindar always, or almost always, lives up to his income. A harvest fails, and he has to borrow money to support himself and pay the revenue.
In illustrating how "our system" enriches Bunniahs and impoverishes peasants, he says :—
‡ When the owner of a good well or a fat piece of sailâb§ deals with a Bunniah who is anxious to hold some land in mortgage, he finds that his credit is unlimited. It is a case of spending made easy. He can have whatever he wants whenever he wishes. All that he is troubled with is his signature or assent to the usual six-monthly statement of accounts, and at harvest time he will make a few payments to the Bunniah in grain. This goes on for four or five years, or often longer. Then the demeanour of the creditor changes. He insists upon a registered bond for the amount due or a mortgage. The debtor temporises as long as he can; perhaps transfers his account to another shop; often takes his chance of a law-suit, trusting in his luck to evade some of the items. All these devices fail, and he makes over a share in his property on a verbal lekha-mukhi contract to his creditor. This is probably the very worst thing he could do. A lekha-mukhidar is as hardly displaced as was the old man of the sea. The zemindar never goes into the account, and is fleeced in every possible way. Instead of growing less, the debt grows larger, and a mortgage is at last gained.
A lekha-mukhi contract is, I should explain, the first step towards ruin, as under it the debtor surrenders his crop to the Bunniah, who pays all expenses for him, deducts interest due to himself, and finally, is supposed to credit the balance, if any, towards the liquidation of the debt—a consummation seldom, if ever, attained. The lekha-mukhi practice is spreading slowly throughout the Punjab. It suits creditors, and lulls the debtors in a false security for a time. It practically reduces him to the position of a tenant, but as in theory he remains the proprietor, he does not grow alarmed. The transaction, moreover, cannot be shown in the annual statement of transfers of land. Thus, debtor and creditor are both pleased. And yet so pernicious is the system, that under it the peasant proprietors of a whole district might be reduced to serfdom without the fact being shown in the agricultural statistics, on which alone the Local Government must form its opinion. After discussing the extent to which expropriation had gone, Mr. Steedman gives his views as to the causes of agricultural indebtedness, and whilst admitting that the revenue system is partly answerable, finds that—
* The real and true cause of all our woe was the mistaken and misplaced gift of full transferable proprietary right in land to the cultivator, and with it of a vast credit, only limited by the value of that proprietary right. It is only of late that there has been an awakening to the true facts of the case, but the cause stated is the true one. I have not the slightest doubt the thrifty and unembarrassed zemindars of this district can be counted upon one's fingers. So long as a zemindar has credit, so long will he borrow; and so long as he borrows, shall we find our annual returns of land transfers slowly but surely and steadily increasing. The sole basis of his credit is his transferable property in the land. Take this away, and all the security that the money-lender has is the annual outturn of the crops. In such a case we should not hear of zemindars being thousands of rupees in debt. Their credit would shrink, and their debts too. There are numbers of villages along-side the Bar, east of Kot-Esashah, in which there is hardly a single mortgage. Why? Because cultivation is uncertain, and the mortgagee might find the mortgaged land well abandoned in a few months, and himself saddled with the revenue. It is not good enough. Here the zemindars have no credit, and they are not in debt, except to a small amount. You do not find tenants-at-will over head-and-ears in debt. They are in debt it is true, but the limit is the amount that the Bunniah considers is pretty certain to be repaid to him at the next harvest.
For Muzaffargarh, Mr. O'Brien writes in 1879:—
† No material difterence in welfare exists between tenants with occupancy rights and tenants-at-will in this district. The average area owned by proprietors is five acres. The average area cultivated by tenants is thirteen acres. Both proprietors and tenants have an area for grazing, which is practically unlimited. Both proprietors and tenants live in what is literally a hand-to-mouth way. Each harvest barely suffices for the wants of the half year, and is almost always forestalled by borrowing. In regard to their economic state and habits, the agricultural classes naturally group themselves into Mahomedans and Hindus, the Mahomedans being five times the number of the Hindus. Of the Mahomedan proprietors, 70 per cent. are in debt. Of the Hindu proprietors, 30 per cent. are in debt. It is very difficult to estimate what proportion the average indebtedness of the proprietors bears to the average yearly income. The lowest estimate in the materials before me says, that the amount borrowed yearly is equal to 30 per cent. of the yearly income of the indebted proprietors.
The highest estimate gives the debts as 80 per cent. of the yearly income. Of Mahomedan tenants 40 per cent., and of Hindu tenants 20 per cent. are in debt. The yearly debts of the tenants are equal to 20 per cent. of their yearly income. The cause of the difference between the numbers of the indebted among Mahomedans and Hindus, respectively, is to be found in the difference of the habits of each class. Mahomedans are mostly spendthrift and improvident : the Hindus are the reverse. Mahomedans are nearly always uneducated : Hindus are always more or less educated. Hindus usually avoid acts that would bring them within the reach of the criminal law, while Mahomedans supply almost the whole criminal population, and so incur the expenses which follow from being suspected by the police and being prosecuted. Mahomedans have only one source of income, viz., agriculture. Hindus, who own and cultivate land, almost always combine money-lending and trade with agriculture. Hindus acquire land as payment for debts. Mahomedans generally borrow money to buy land.
Mr. J. B. Lyall, the late Financial Commissioner of the Punjab, an old and sympathetic Settlement Officer himself, endorsed Mr. O'Brien's opinion in the following words :—
* The indebtedness in this district is greater than in any district with which I am acquainted. I append some very true remarks of Mr. Lyall's on the subject, which he made when reviewing the Assessment Report of the Alipur tahsil :— “I quite agree with Mr. O'Brien's remarks as to the indebtedness of the agriculturists and the faults in their character, which are its main cause. The same faults are attributed generally to the Mahomedan land-holders of all this southern corner of the Punjab, but they are found in this tahsil in a very exaggerated form. The heavy floods and the fever which follows, have something to do with it. The almost universal prosperity of the Kiràr land-holders is a proof that there is nothing crushing in the general pitch of the assessment. But as the Biluches, Syads, and Jats say, it would be folly to expect them to alter their characters and habits, and rival the thrift and frugality of the Kiràrs. These Kiràrs are the Jews of the country, and have a special natural aptitude for earning and saving money. The general character of the agriculturists must be considered in assessing; but from what I have seen here and in Mooltan and Dera-Ghazi-Khan, I do not believe that a very light assessment would tend to get them out of debt.
In the neighbouring districts of Mooltan and Dera-Ghazi-Khan, the general condition of the peasantry is perhaps a shade less unsatisfactory than it is in Muzaffargarh. Throughout most of Mooltan, 50 per cent. of the proprietors are reported to be in debt, but many only temporarily so,—i. e., with thrift and several good harvests in succession—unlikely coincidences—they could extricate themselves. In Dera-Ghazi-Khan two-thirds of the Mahomedan land-owners are estimated to be involved, but I think the proportion is exaggerated, as Government has greatly strengthened the position of the Biluch tribal chiefs, and the district policy has always been to uphold their authority in every way, even to discountenancing the acquisition of rights in land by Bunniahs.
In the Bannu district which I settled, the peasantry in two tracts are seriously, and many hopelessly, embarrassed, namely, in Marwat (Trans-Indus) and in the Mianwali up-lands (Cis-Indus). In both I imposed a very light land assessment. But as the average annual rainfall is only about 9 inches, very uncertainly distributed, drought is frequent, and in some years the crops entirely fail.
In the Dera-Ismail-Khan district indebtedness is general. The alienation of rights in land to non-agriculturists, except in tracts protected by a complicated land tenure and a fluctuating system of land revenue, has been so seriously on the increase since the settlement as to have attracted the attention of Government. Commenting on a remark made by the Settlement Officer (Mr. St. George Tucker), that in the Cis-Indus parts of the district many of the small Mahomedan proprietors would eventually have to be sold up, Mr. J. B. Lyall, already mentioned, wrote as follows when Settlement Commissioner :—
"* All we can do is to amend anything in our revenue system which tends to hurry on the process. Only a minority of these men have proved fit for the improved status which we gave them; the majority will descend in time into the position which suits them—of mere tillers of the soil, with enough to live upon, but no credit to pledge, and no property to lose. Their original position under native governments was little better than this. It is, of course, the too frequent elevation of the despised Kiràr or Hindu money-lender over the heads of a naturally dominant Mahomedan population, which is the worst part of the change.
Whilst admitting Mr. Lyall's sympathy with the struggling agriculturists of the Province and his unrivalled knowledge of their economic condition, I cannot agree with him in holding either that we have done our best to amend our revenue system and assimilate it to the character of the people who pay the revenue, or of the climate which determines the quantity of each harvest. I draw attention to the wailing helplessness with which he seems to accept the inevitable, that small Mahomedan proprietors, though the dominant population, are doomed to sink beneath the superior thrift of the despised Hindu money-lender. When officers in high position, owing to reverence for "our system" and deference to the natural disinclination of Government from what the conservatism of long service regards as retrogressive innovations, throw up the sponge, as Mr. Lyall appears to do here, the chances of wholesome reform in a vicious system become very improbable.
I maintain, however, that we dare not in our own interests, as a handful of foreigners governing many millions, subject the dominant to the weaker classes amongst the people. Mr. Lyall would apparently leave things to drift as at present. If his doctrine is endorsed throughout India, it will eventually lose us India.
There remains only one of the eight districts of the south-western plain to be noticed— Shahpur. As it was settled in 1866, the economic condition of the people has not been closely studied, but recent investigation by the district officer proves that "the peasants are generally in debt."*
Thus there is a consensus amongst those most competent to ascertain facts that south of the Salt Range most agriculturists are in debt; a large proportion, not less than 25 per cent., hopelessly so; that rights in land are passing from them—except in good years—to the money-lending class, in an annually accelerating ratio; and that the causes for indebtedness are ascribable partly to characteristics common to all ignorant Mahomedans, but chiefly to "our system," in which the facility it gives for borrowing up to the market-value of a holding, holds a prominent place.
Now, turning to the districts north of the Salt Range, we find that in submontane tracts, in which the certainty and sufficiency of the rainfall generally ensures good crops, those of the people who are not idle drones are at present fairly prosperous.
The amount and periodicity of the rainfall varies inversely to the distance from the foot of the Himalayas on the north and the western limits of the south-east monsoon on the east. South of the Himalayas a zone of from 30 to 50 miles in width enjoys a fall averaging over 30 inches, distributed with such an exact periodicity that the cultivator is almost as certain of a fair return each harvest as if his lands were irrigated from a perennial canal. Thus throughout a large part of the Gujrat, Jhelum, Rawalpindi, Hazara, and Peshawar districts, when peasant or landlord is seriously involved, the cause is not imputable to the inelasticity of the revenue system. Further south the rainfall gradually diminishes, until from 10 inches immediately south of the Salt Range, it decreases to six in the southern tracts of Muzaffargarh and Dera-Ghazi-Khan, which occupy the extreme south-east corner of the Punjab, and are therefore farthest from monsoon limits and the Himalayas. In them, too, the fall is badly distributed. Half the year's discharge frequently occurs as a deluge in 48 hours in July or August, and is followed by five or six months of cloudless skies.
Considering each district separately and taking the three—Hazara, Peshawar, and Kohat— which comprise the frontier or Peshawar division first, we find that in all the three complicated tenures and the turbulent, revengeful spirit of the wild border tribes who hold the land, coupled with the rarity of failure of crop and politic lightness of the revenue assessments, have hitherto restrained all earth-hunger—except in the vicinity of cantonments and towns—on the part of the money-lending classes. None knows better than a Bunniah the localities in which land is not a safe investment. The arm of the law may be long and strong, but where an asylum in independent hills is near, and the village community a brood of reckless Pathans, fear and prudence in combination make the Bunniah fight shy of the status of mortgagee or proprietor. The levelling effect of the railway now open to Peshawar and the Swat River canal flowing through Yusafzai, will soon encourage the Bunniah to cast aside his timidity, and invest freely in land throughout the Peshawar valley. No close inquiry into the economic state of the people in any of the districts of the Peshawar division has been made; but the late Colonel Hastings, C. B., who settled Peshawar, reported that debts were increasing. For the Hazara district Colonel Wace, now Junior Financial Commissioner, an officer whose 25 years' service has been devoted to land settlements, after six years' observation gave his opinion that though there was "more borrowing than before, there was less real indebtedness." This remark is true for the cultivating classes only. The landed gentry of the district are almost all deeply involved in debt. They deserve no sympathy, their embarrassment being due to their personal extravagance and carelessness. In Appendix A I give in extenso some admirable remarks by Colonel Wace on agricultural indebtedness and its causes before and since annexation. For the Kohat district—which is small, poor, half jagir, and merely a maze of stony hills and narrow valleys inhabited by the wildest Pathans on our frontier— no inquiry has been made, but its wildness and poverty probably largely secure to the people the possession of their own lands. Information on the indebtedness of agriculturists and statistics showing transfers of land to non-agriculturists, are exceptionally imperfect for all the three frontier districts, as indeed they are generally elsewhere, except in the cases of recent settlements, in which the Settlement Officer has made the subjects a special study.
In the other districts of the northern table-land the people are generally believed to be fairly prosperous. Those who are involved are the landlords, who cultivate their lands through tenants, and the peasantry in the outlying southern tracts of the districts in which the rainfall is less in quantity and more uncertain in time of fall than nearer to the Himalayas.
Two causes, both temporary in their effect, in addition to the all-important one of a fair outturn, have combined to preseve a measure of prosperity to the agriculturists of the Sub-Himalayan zone.
No revision of settlement has taken place in Gujrat since 1867-68. The assessment then made was notoriously, even at that time, unreasonably light. The Jhelum settlement of 1880 is moderate. The revision of the Rawalpindi settlement of 1860-61 is still in progress. But early this year the new demand was announced and the assessment raised, including cesses, by nearly 40 per cent. Thus hitherto throughout the Cis-Indus districts of the northern table-land, the people have been far lighter assessed, considering how blessed they are with a fair prospect of an annual crop, than in the rainless districts south of the Salt Range. This exemption from a full half-assets revenue demand has just ceased for Rawalpindi, and cannot continue much longer in Gujrat. In Jhelum the revised settlement, though light, raised the demand, in 1880, 19 per cent. As there have been no bad years since then, the effect of the increased demand has still to be felt.
Then the work on the N.-W. State Railway, completed in 1882, which runs through the whole width of all the districts of the northern table-land, except Hazara and Kohat, for a length of 250 miles, put annually, for several years in succession, lakhs and lakhs of rupees into the pockets of the peasants. The Kabul War, too, (1878-80) brought wealth to people and Bunniahs alike. The present comparative freedom from serious debt of the peasants north of the Salt Range cannot be taken as a criterion for the future. The sources of profits and savings open to them between 1870 and 1885 are one by one closing.
Reviewing all the data available for forming an opinion on the state of indebtedness of the people in the Western Punjab north and south of the Salt Range, we find that the gloomy conclusions of the Famine Commissioners are amply justified for the eight districts south of the range, including the range itself; but that throughout the northern table-land—wherever the crops are fairly good and certain—the peasantry are reasonably prosperous, whilst certain classes of landlords, from their own extravagance and inattention to business, are somewhat involved. We also find that exceptional causes, now at an end or ceasing to operate, have of late years either enriched the peasantry or helped them to meet all expenditure from income. We further find that the condition of the agricultural classes, wherever over-population does not exist, corresponds with the certainty of a fair spring harvest each year, which again depends on the amount and periodicity of the rainfall. Thus the peasantry are generally free from serious indebtedness in the submontane zone, more involved as the Salt Range is approached, and south of it almost universally so. Finally, a close perusal of Settlement Reports establishes that wherever indebtedness does not arise from our revenue system, climatic causes or misfortune (e. g., litigation, loss of cattle, or fine), those who are embarrassed, or have alienated a large part of their ancestral lands, are the least laborious and least thrifty classes in the country.
Notes
- *. The following statement exhibits the increase in civil litigation since 1886 :—
- *. Previously a court had power to accept, refuse, or modify an award by Arbitration. arbitrators. The new law deprived the courts of that power, and compelled them to "give judgment according to the award." The change in the law, as much as the loss of confidence of natives in each other, has operated to make reference to arbitration as a mode of settlement of civil disputes of rare occurrence.
- †. Punjab Administration Report, 1873-74, page 37.
- *. A District Officer or Deputy Commissioner in the Punjab is equivalent to the Collector of the N.-W. Provinces, and a Tahsildar to the Deputy Collector.
- *. Para. 4, page 131 of Report of the Indian Famine Commission, Part II.
- *. Gujrat, Shahpur, Montgomery, Jhang, and Muzaffargarh.
- †. The strength of the garrisons are, in round numbers, Peshawar valley, 8,000 ; Rawalpindi district, 7,000 ; Hazara, 1,800 ; Jhelum, 1,100 ; Mooltan, 1,400 ; Kohat, 3,000 ; Bannu, 2,200 ; Dera-Ismail-Khan, 2,500 ; Dera-Ghazi-Khan district, 1,500 : in all, about 28,000 men.
- *. To save space here, I omit very lengthy quotations from reports by Settlement and District Officers on the condition of the people in each of the 14 districts, but give extracts from them in appendix A.
- †. Page 92 of the Gazetteer of the Jhang district. I may note generally that the contents of the district Gazetteers of the Punjab, as far as revenue matters and the economic condition of the people are concerned, are passages taken from settlement reports. The Gazetteers being handier, I generally quote from them.
- ‡. Page 94 of the Gazetteer of the Jhang district.
- §. Sailâb here means alluvial land subject to river inundation.
- *. Page 95 of the Gazetteer of Jhang district.
- †. Pages 82-3 of the Gazetteer of Muzaffargarh district.
- *. Page 85 of the Gazetteer of Muzaffargarh district.
- *. Page 91 of the Gazetteer of Dera-Ismail-Khan district.
- *. Page 57 of the Gazetteer of Shahpur district.