THE “people of India” are the dumb toiling millions of peasants inhabiting the villages, hamlets, and scattered homesteads of the land. The town-bred exotics who are annually forced through in our educational hot-houses, and glibly mouth the phrase, whilst posing as representatives of that people, have less claim to the title than the puny operatives of our manufacturing towns have of being typical specimens of John Bull.
Before further considering the position of the section of the “people of India” who occupy the western half of the Punjab, a general survey of that of their fellow agriculturists elsewhere throughout the Peninsula will be useful.
Modern British India dates from the Sepoy Mutiny of 1857. That revolution changed an estate managed on purely business principles into an Empire governed for the good of its inhabitants. The history of the growth of the Hon’ble East India Company’s power in India closely resembles that of Russia in Central Asia. The morality of a transaction was little considered when it clashed with personal interests. In pre-Mutiny days the situation in Northern India was always critical and the treasury generally empty. How to keep what had been acquired and get more on opportunity, were the ever-present problems, the answers to which depended upon a full treasury and a quiet people. In those stirring times there was no leisure for the elaborate niceties of the administration of to-day. It thus happened that as territory after territory was absorbed, we blindly divested ourselves of the immediate ownership of the soil, and conferred it upon its actual occupants, or, when it suited us, upon local chiefs or useful middlemen, exacting in return a quit-rent in cash, which now amounts to £ 22,000,000 annually, or about one-third of the Imperial revenue of India.
Throughout three-fourths of the Madras Presidency and two-thirds of that of Bombay, the "ryot," as the cultivator is called, has been directly settled with. His tenure is very simple, and only wants elasticity to be ideally perfect. Each parcel of land has a fixed quit revenue imposed on it: the cultivating ryot may alienate his occupancy rights or throw them up when he pleases. Throughout the rest of Madras and Bombay, interposed between the Government and the cultivator are large landlords with whom the settlement has generally been made. In Bengal the muchabused and short-sighted permanent settlement was made about 1790 with large middlemen and landlords. In Oudh the same classes have been settled with.
In the N.-W. Provinces and the Punjab, small peasant proprietors who cultivate their own land in whole or in part, and who are collectively responsible for the payment of the land revenue, form the bulk of the proprietary class. In most cases the assessment, whether by fields or estates, is fixed for 20 or 30 years, and is frequently not revised until some years after the term has expired. Throughout India where the cultivators are not also the proprietors, Government has, since the Mutiny, been slowly raising the status of a considerable proportion of the former into that of occupancy tenants at fixed rent-rates, consequently the mass of tenants of old-standing, who have brought waste land into cultivation, have now a major share in the largely divided landed interest known as proprietary right. All such tenants can alienate their rights in their holdings under certain equitable conditions. By creating this vast transferable property, we everywhere raised the credit of the husbandman from a few rupees to the market-value of his holding. We, in short, admitted him at one bound to all the rights of citizenship—sua si bona norit. He, however, was a conservative, and preferred old ways to new, and ignorance to enlightenment. Naturally he had no objection to spend money, and as the land revenue he paid half-yearly bore no proportion to the crop he had just reaped, he had in bad years to make free use of his credit.
The village Bunniah had under former Governments been his friend and servant, working in harmony with him, and sharing humbly in his prosperity or adversity. As their interests were now conflicting, the ancient alliance between the two was broken. The ex-servant soon aspired to be master, having acquired all the attributes of a Jew or Greek, plus the right to hold land. Under former Governments, arable land had been practically inalienable except amongst cultivators. The satisfaction of a debt could not be claimed as a right; its payment was merely a moral obligation.
With the advent of British rule—British institutions, Civil Courts, Civil Procedure Codes, Contract, Limitation, Legal Practitioners and other Acts were introduced, and a bond or a debt secured on the mortgage or conditional sale of land became a sacred instrument, to be construed according to its terms. A debtor became liable to his creditor to his last farthing. In the eyes of the law the two were equal. In sober truth, the peasant was in money-matters a crass and hardly-intelligible simpleton ; the money-lender, a sharp, unscrupulous business-man, whose sole study was self-interest. With their opposing interests and their widely-different intelligencies, it soon became abundantly evident to those civil officers, whose duties caused them to have much direct intercourse with any of "the people of India," that under the ægis of British "justice," that "people" was being reduced into a state of prædial slavery by a small but ever-increasing class of shop-keepers and money-lenders. It was also clearly foreseen by such officers that in time of political disturbance the new class of proprietors and mortgagees would be, if not positively a source of weakness to us, in any case without influence in the cause of order.
From time to time Local Governments were warned of the popular odium in which agriculturists regarded our system of civil law, and of the evils to which a persistence in an attitude of watchfulness—alias indifference—would give rise. But in pre-Mutiny days, as now, Governors, High Court Judges, and Chief Secretaries were composed of middle-aged importations from home, and senior members of the Indian Civil Service who had risen to high positions from scholarly ability rather than from practical knowledge of "the people of India."
To such men proposals involving interference with the freedom of contract or class legislation *—that stumbling block for doctrinaire statesmen—were unpalatable, and though never treated with absolute indifference, were either criticised and shelved till a more convenient season, or disposed of by a non possumus, on arguments drawn from first principles.
In the Bombay Presidency the growing indebtedness of agriculturist to Marwari and other foreign traders and usurers, engaged the attention of the Government so far back as 1843. The mode of procedure of those foreigners was described in 1852. The Marwari is to the Deccan peasantry what the Bunniah is to the Punjabi cultivator. The procedure followed by the two is identical. What was written in 1852 of the Marwari, might be written to-day of the Bunniah in Punjab villages seldom visited by British officers. The following is the account *:—
Generally when a Marwari first comes to the district, he enters into the service of one of his relations or country-men, and when he has saved a little money, he sets up a small shop in some village, where he thinks he can improve his circumstances. At first he is very meek and forbearing in his transactions with the ryots, and sometimes induces the patels or other influential parties to lend him money to enable him to enlarge his business, and provide for the wants of the villagers. By degrees he extends his operations, until he has got the royts completely into his hands, and by dint of usury and of any oppressive dealings in which he may be able to obtain aid from the civil court, he collects, say, from Rs. 3,000 to Rs. 4,000, and returns to his country for the purpose of marrying. On his return he plays the same game, other members of his family join him, and with his assistance set up separate shops.
In a statesman-like report written in 1852 by Captain, afterwards Sir, G. Wingate, Revenue Survey Commissioner, the whole subject was succinctly discussed. As the state of relationship between creditor and debtor and the causes conducing to enslave the latter to the former, are still— with some ameliorations and exceptions to be noticed hereafter—universally true in India to this day, I shall quote extensively from Captain Wingate's remarkable report.
He begins by remarking that it was unnecessary for him—
to bring forward proof of the general and deplorable indebtedness of our agricultural population. The fact is universally admitted. It is familiar to the experience of all public officers, whether Revenue or Judicial. The grinding oppression of the ryot by the village Bunniah or money-lender has become proverbial, and forms a subject of anxious consideration to all who take an interest in the welfare of the agricultural classes.
After referring to a class of agrarian crime growing annually more familiar to district officers in the Punjab— that of peasant debtors, when goaded into desperation, murdering their creditors—he proceeds :—
It remains to be shown how it is that the creditor in our Provinces has acquired a degree of power over his debtor, which is wholly unknown in Native States. This power, it is clear to me, has been conferred by our laws, which enable the creditor to obtain a decree against a debtor, for whatever may be written in his bond, and an enforcement of that decree by the attachment and sale of whatever property, moveable or immoveable, his debtor may possess or acquire. Under our predecessors—the Mahrattas—a creditor, it may almost be said, had no legal means of enforcing payment from his debtor at all. There was, as stated by Mr. Frere in the 5th paragraph of his report on the administration of civil justice in Satara, no court of civil justice to which a man who had suffered some wrong could resort as a matter of course and of right. Creditors and debtors were, in fact, left to settle their claims, as best they might, with little or no assistance, in most instances, from public authorities. Even in Satara, where the system of civil justice was considerably influenced by our ideas, it is clear from Messrs. Frere and Coxan's reports that a creditor had very limited means for enforcing his claims. It was no easy matter to obtain a hearing for his case at all; but if he succeeded in securing a decree in his favour, and, what was more difficult still, in obtaining an order for the attachment of the person or property of the debtor, a single attachment was, in ordinary cases, held to be a sufficient satisfaction.
It may then be affirmed that, for all practical purposes, the relations between debtor and creditor were determined under the Mahrattas without reference to any legal means of enforcing payment of debts. The creditor trusted chiefly to the honesty and good faith of his debtor, and it followed, as a matter of necessity, that loans were sparingly granted unless upon the security of property, such as jewels left in pawn, or a mortgage on land or houses, or standing crops. In agricultural villages, the relations between the money-lenders and the cultivators were those of mutual interest and confidence. The Bunniah advanced the cultivator as much as he felt satisfied that he could and would pay, but no more, and at no higher rate of interest than was sanctioned by usage and public opinion. If the Bunniah insisted on a higher rate than was deemed equitable, it is not probable that his debtors would have paid up their instalments with the usual regularity, and he had no means of compulsion at command. Under these arrangements, the village money-lender and the ryot worked in harmony, and both alike shared prosperity and adversity together.
Under our system this happy and mutually advantageous state of affairs has been completely overturned. The prosperity of the ryot is no longer necessary to the prosperity of the village money-lender. The latter has no longer occasion to trust to the good faith or honesty of the former. Mutual confidence and good-will have been succeeded by mutual distrust and dislike. The money-lender has the ever-ready expedient of a suit at law to obtain complete command over the person and property of his debtor. It becomes the interest of the former to reduce the latter to a state of hopeless indebtedness in order that he may be able to appropriate the whole fruits of his industry beyond what is indispensable to a mere existence. This he is enabled without difficulty to do. So long as a ryot is not much involved, the money-lender is ready to afford him the means of indulging in any extravagance and without troubling him at all about future re-payment. The debt may lie over, and he may choose his own time for re-payment. The simple and thoughtless ryot is easily inveigled into the snare, and only becomes aware of his folly when the toils are fairly around him and escape is impossible. From that day forward he becomes the bondsman of his creditor. The latter takes care that he shall seldom do more than reduce the interest of his debt. Do what he will, the poor ryot can never get rid of the principal. He toils that another may rest, and sows that another may reap. Hope deserts, and despair possesses him. The virtues of a freeman are supplanted by the vices of a slave. He feels himself to be the victim of injustice, and tries to revenge himself by cheating his oppressors. He cannot get into a worse position than he already occupies, and becomes reckless. His great endeavour is to despoil his enemies—the money-lenders —by borrowing continually. When he has got all that he can from one, it is a triumph to him if, by any amount of lies and false promises, he can get something more from another. When he has two creditors there is a chance of their fighting with each other, and that during the fray he may be able to snatch a portion of the spoil from both.
This miserable struggle between debtor and creditor is thoroughly debasing to both. The creditor is made by it a grasping hard-hearted oppressor. The debtor, a crouching, false-hearted slave. It is disheartening to contemplate, and yet it would be weakness to conceal the fact that this antagonism of classes and degradation of the people, which is fast spreading over the land, is the work of our laws and our rule. The corruption and impoverishment of the mass of the people for the enriching of a few has already made lamentable advance in some districts, and is in progress in all, and the evil is clearly traceable, in my opinion, to the enormous power which the law places in the hands of the creditor.
The facilities which the law affords for the realization of debt have expanded credit to a most hurtful extent. In addition to the ordinary village bankers, a set of low usurers is fast springing up, by whom small sums are lent for short periods at enormous rates of interest to the very lowest of the population, who have not credit enough to obtain advances from the more respectable of the village bankers. All grades of the people are thus falling under the curse of debt, and should the present course of affairs continue, it must arrive that the greater part of the realised property of the community will be transferred to a small monied class, which will become disproportionately wealthy by the impoverishment of the rest of the people. No greater misfortune could befall any nation than this, by which the many are made miserable in order that the few may be pampered. And yet this is the inevitable tendency of the existing relations between debtor and creditor in our Presidency.
There is, in my humble opinion, but one remedy, and that is to withdraw many of the facilities now afforded to the creditor for the realization of his debts, whether just or unjust. To place extortion beyond the pale of law, and to prevent the latter being used by a remorseless creditor as an instrument of torture for wringing out of his victims sums of money which the latter had never borrowed, but which their necessities or thoughtlessness had induced them to acknowledge as debts in a bond. What is wanted is to restrict credit; to make the money-lender more chary of his advances; to make the people look to their own industry rather than to loans for the purpose of carrying out their projects or gratifying their inclinations; to afford encouragement to forethought and thrift, and to throw discouragement in the way of thoughtlessness and improvidence.
If for the words “Marwari” and “ryot,” “Bunniah” and “peasant” be substituted, Captain Wingate might have been writing of facts of the Punjab in 1872 instead of the Deccan in 1852.
When inquiries were completed the Bombay Government, on September 5th, 1855, after referring to the “almost universal bondage into which the agricultural classes have fallen from their indebtedness to these foreigners,” calmly shelved the question by concluding :—
This is a subject which has been so often brought to the notice of Government, and received so large a share of its anxious consideration on former occasions, that it is unnecessary to discuss it in this place. The proposed introduction of Small Cause Courts will, it is hoped, place some check upon the usurious practice of the Marwaris, and the gradual spread of education will eventually render the ryots less facile victims to the unfair practices of these usurers (over-reaching petty capitalists) than they have hitherto been.
But the Executive subordinates of the Government who lived among the people would not permit the matter to be dropped so easily. In 1858 the Revenue Commissioner again returned to the charge. Quoting from the Collector of Ahmednagar, a Mr. Tytler, well known as an earnest and competent officer, he wrote* :—
The ryots cannot write or read, and provided they have their urgent wants supplied, be it for a marriage or anything else, they care not what document they sign. The Marwaris take advantage of this state of things, and they care not what document they forge, or how extravagant the terms entered in the bond. Yet documents thus framed pass as mutual agreements between the parties. The aid given by law to money-lenders and borrowers is all on the side of the former; the latter have no protection whatever. They should have all; the former require none, being well able to take care of themselves. I believe that nine-tenths of the disturbances in India are attributable to this source. * * * *
The aid given by our courts is all on the side of the Marwari, who alone knows how to turn that aid to his own advantage. The position of the litigants is not therefore simply of debtor and creditor; it is the fraudulent Marwari, backed by civil courts versus the helpless ryot signing any bond without even a true knowledge of its contents, and powerless to oppose any decree that may be passed.
This matter keeps up a constant irritating sore throughout the society, and the whole onus is thrown by the people on the civil courts, whereas it is the law which is at fault, in assuming debtor and creditor in this country to be equal, while they are rather in the position of master and slave.
The question is one of vital importance both to Government and the people. Even the passive society of the East cannot bear so great a burden without making from time to time convulsive efforts to shake it off. These efforts must increase in frequency and strength, unless the Legislature seriously takes up the evil and applies the knife to it.
In illustration of the present working of our usury laws, I shall give one instance which is on record. A man borrowed four maunds of jowari, value about Rs. 6. Two or three bonds followed, and in 16 months the borrower was sued for Rs. 72, which the lender got with costs. The adjudicating authorities considered the thing iniquitous, but there was a bond, and this covers all such iniquity. Thousands of parallel cases could be collected. Every division and almost every village teems with them.
This subject has been brought forward repeatedly during the last thirty years, and has always been laid aside in the vain hope that the evil would cure itself, and that the improved condition of the people resulting from the low survey rates would lessen the evil. This hope has not been realized. On the contrary, the evil is greatly on the increase, eating into and irritating the entire mass.
Again were papers on the subject laid before the Bombay Government, when the following Resolution was recorded :—
His Lordship in Council entertains no doubt of the fact that the labouring classes of the native community suffer enormous injustice from the want of protection by law from the extortionate practice of money-lenders. He believes that our civil courts have become hateful to the masses of our Indian subjects from being made the instruments of the almost incredible rapacity of usurious capitalists. Nothing can be more calculated to give rise to widespread discontent and disaffection to the British Government than the practical working of the present law. The attention of the Legislative Council on the subject should be requested, and a copy of the Revenue Commissioner's letter forwarded for their consideration.
Naturally the Legislative Council, being scholarly men and only accustomed to study the ryots from the windows of palatial offices in Bombay and Poona, let the matter drop. For the next 10 years the subject was presumably engaging the "anxious consideration of Government" as it had during the preceding twenty. The policy of drift-and-do-nothing was continued until, in 1870, the Revenue Commissioner, Northern Division, drew the attention of the sleeping Government
"to a very threatening state of matters in the north and west of the Province * * * * in consequence of the relations brought about by the action of the courts of civil justice between the money-lending classes and superior holders cultivating by means of hired labour, and Bheels and members of other rude tribes who are indebted to the former under various forms of obligation."
In the papers submitted, Government was significantly reminded—
"that the Sonthal Rebellion arose out of a state of things precisely similar to that now existing in the west of Khandesh, and that though no indications of an approching outbreak may have presented themselves here, neither did the Sonthals give a word of warning before they burst over the plains of Beerbhoom with an army 30,000 strong, to avenge themselves on the usurers who had robbed and enslaved them under the tacit sanction of our civil law."
That set an inquiry on foot once more; but though none denied the disease, few agreed upon the remedy.
The field of investigation was extended to Sind, the N.-W. Provinces, and the Punjab, in all of which the same deplorable state of things was found to exist. In the Punjab the acute stage had not yet been reached. A healthy peasantry requires more than a decade of mistaken treatment to show signs of serious disease. In Sind—a country of large landlords—it was found that it was
"almost equally unhappily circumstanced with the Presidency Proper. A series of unfavourable seasons and calamities has forced the zemindars of many districts into the hands of money-lenders, who exact a very high rate of interest, and with the aid of the courts deprive them of their lands. Extravagance no doubt has assisted the fall of these Mahomedan gentry : still Government cannot but look with great solicitude on the ruin of the heads of society in a frontier country, conquered but 31 years ago, who have hitherto been conspicuous for their loyalty and good behaviour. The great Sind jagirdars are also, with but a few exceptions, deeply encumbered with debt."
In the N.-W. Provinces inquiries had been progressing since 1858. The Mutiny had given dispossessed proprietors an opportunity of destroying the auction-purchasers of their estates and holdings.
Regarding those new men and the policy which permitted them to supplant old proprietors, Sir W. Muir, in 1859, recorded :—
I need not say that my opinion of the injury done by these sales has received grave confirmation from the events of the intervening period. The passing of landed estates into the hands of mere speculators without any local influence or connexion with the soil, was always regarded as a serious disadvantage. It ousted from their ancestral lands those who by their natural position could best manage them, and be made instrumental in aiding the administration, and it substituted a set of men who were often unable, even in times of peace, to maintain themselves in secure possession, and for all administrative purposes, were far less responsible and less useful proprietors. In addition to this we have now had universal proof that the moment the authority of Government is suspended, the old proprietors will re-assert their foregone rights and oust the upstart intruders.
This has been equally the case, I believe, where the sale has been a direct transaction by consent of the former proprietors. It is not therefore an indubitable proof that such sales are regarded by the natives as unjust. It is simply a fresh illustration of the tenacity with which mankind all the world over cling to their ancestral acres, and, when the check of authority is removed, a proof of the temptation that exists to resume the alienated birthright. The new owners brought in by our system were generally, as I have said, men without local power or influence ; they could often hold their own position only with difficulty in times of peace ; and when all restraint was gone, they were naturally the first objects of lawless outrage.
But whether regarded by the natives to be right or to be wrong, the practical result of these sales has been equally disastrous. They contributed seriously to the embarrassment of Government, and to the confusion and disorder of the days of anarchy. They proved an eminent source of weakness. This is a fresh argument against the present system, superadded to the evils that were already felt, to call for the adoption of all possible means for checking the frequency of sales and permanent transfers.
Sir John Strachey in the same year wrote :—
Before our Government was established, there was practically no such thing in the possession of individuals as proprietary rights in land, according to our ideas of what property is.
This is probably true in every primitive state of society, and it was especially the case in India. Such rights of property as did not appertain to the Sovereign, belonged, as a general rule, rather to a community than to an individual.
It is clear that this state of things must pass away with progress in civilisation, and it is no reproach to our system that it has recognised this fact. But the principle has been carried out too rapidly and too rigidly to its logical conclusions.
I have stated my opinion that the origin of the debts which lead to these frequent transfers of property is, in the great majority of cases, the pressure of our revenue system. Although the main principles of that system are sound, it has, I think, been administered in a very harsh and unbending manner. Collectors and their subordinates have far too much become mere machines for grinding revenue out of the people. But no amelioration or relaxation of our revenue administration will give any real relief so long as the landholders find it impossible to obtain advances of money on fair and reasonable terms.
No one who has not had the matter brought practically and directly to his notice, can have the least conception of the knavery and rapacity of the money-lenders to whom the land-holders of these Provinces are obliged to have recourse. Whatever ought to be the case in theory, it is very certain that questions of abundance or scarcity of money, of greater or less demand for loans, of good or bad security of competition, and the like, have in practice comparatively little to do with the settlement of the terms on which agriculturists in this country ordinarily obtain advances of money. The conditions depend far more upon the degree of simplicity in the borrower and of rapacity in the lender than on anything else.
Our civil courts have unhappily been the ready instruments for these dishonest operations, and our system of judicial procedure, instead of checking, has stimulated and exaggerated them.
No reform of our courts will alone meet this great evil, and I believe it to be of the highest importance that the Government should not continue to shut its eyes to the ruin in which this widespread system of fraud, or of something little better, is involving the proprietors of the land. They are incapable of protecting themselves, and the Government must interfere in their behalf, or bear, in the opinion of the people, all the discredit of their ruin. There is nothing in the simple alienation of landed property which is in itself distasteful to the people of this country. I believe that in the great majority of cases, in which the old proprietors during the late disturbances resumed possession of their estates, they were enabled to do so, not because the people considered that they held an indefeasible right to the soil, but because the transfer of the land to a stranger was only the final step in a long course of dishonest proceedings by which the former proprietor had been undeservedly brought to ruin.
In the Punjab the question of agricultural indebtedness for the first time discussed treason for any member of the administration of the model Province to doubt the general prosperity of the agricultural classes, or the perfection of the institutions with whose inception and development the senior civil officers serving in the Commission had identified themselves. The majority of the superior appointments in the Province were then, and still are, held by what are euphemistically termed “military officers,”—i.e., men who, after serving a year or two with their regiments, had interest enough to be appointed Assistant Commissioners in the Punjab. A spirit of discipline and obedience to orders pervaded all ranks. When officers’ opinions were called for, they were given without that impressiveness of earnest conviction which characterised those of Executive officers in the Bombay Presidency. The subject was not treated as immediately grave and urgent, but rather as one which would probably become so in the distant future. The Financial Commissioner of the day asserted bravely that he believed “the people now to have emerged into rigorous manhood,” by which hyperbole he probably meant that he thought they were quite capable of taking care of themselves. The Lieutenant-Governor (the late Sir Donald MacLeod), finding “most of the Judges of the Chief Court, the Financial Commissioner, and the High Court of the N.-W. Provinces, opposed to the prohibition of sales of land by law,” felt that legislation in that sense was improbable, but recorded his protest against a continuance of the drift policy in the following words :—
It is, in His Honor’s opinion, beyond a doubt that under no native rule has the forced sale of hereditary land for debts been ever recognised, and it is equally certain, in his opinion, that the principle of selling such lands in execution of decrees is, at the present time, entirely abhorrent to the feelings and opinions of the majority of the people of the Punjab. That it is equally distasteful to the people of the North-Western Provinces, was sufficiently testified, in 1857, by the scenes witnessed on the banks of the Eastern Jumna Canal by English refugees from Delhi—villages in flames in all directions, and their auction-purchasers ejected and dispersed, while their women flung themselves into wells to escape dishonour.
So far had those responsible for the solution of the most serious problem created by a responsible Government in the East, progressed in their leisurely inquiry in 1870-74, when, towards the close of the latter year, some Deccan villagers—grown desperate by 30 years of resultless inquiry, banded themselves together as a Mahratta Land League and—boycotted their creditors. The contagion spread rapidly. In the following May the cultivators in a large village near Poona rose and gutted the shops of their oppressors. Similar riots and disturbances took place in a score of other villages, the object in every case being the destruction of bonds and decrees in the hands of Marwari and Guzrati money-lenders. The immediately exciting cause—for the risings were believed to be unconnected—was in each case the circulation of a story that usurious bonds had, with the approval of Government, been extorted from a debtor. That the most docile and lawabiding agriculturists in India should almost within site of Poona—the summer capital of the Bombay Government— riotously rebel against the justice of that Government's laws—ungratefully forgetful that for upwards of 30 years their grievances had been subjected to “anxious consideration”—took that Government by surprise. Urged on by apprehension of a general Mahratta uprising, a Commission of Inquiry was immediately appointed, and the excited peasantry pacified by promises of redress of grievances.
The Commission did its work leisurely but thoroughly. Finally, after great opposition, the Deccan Ryots Act, 1879,* was passed. So sweeping were the changes made by that measure, that it may be called revolutionary. Besides cheapening and simplifying litigation between peasant and creditor, and compelling the registration of all instruments between them, it required a civil court in debt cases, after separating the true principal from the interest, to decree only reasonable interest and fix instalments for the payment: the period of limitation for debts secured by registration was extended from six to twelve years, and debts on account and on unregistered bond, from three to six years: debts under Rs. 50 could be extinguished at once, the court exacting payment of as much as the debtor was able to pay: agriculturists were exempted from liability to arrest or imprisonment in execution of a decree for money; and the attachment and sale of their land, unless specifically mortgaged, was forbidden: in cases of usufructuary mortgage on registered deeds, agriculturists were empowered to redeem on payment by instalments of the ascertained principal with moderate interest superadded: creditors were required, under penalty of fine, to grant written receipts for payments, to render annual statements of account, and even to provide agriculturists with pass-books.
This drastic measure has been in force five years over an area 21,523 square miles with a population of 32,96,686. It has worked well, restored the cultivator to life and hope, and up to the end of 1884, had enabled more than ten thousand mortgagors to redeem their lost fields.
As for the money-lenders, some have gone back to their own country, some have been absorbed into the general population, and taken to honorable trading, and even to agriculture as the sole occupation, and many of the best class still engage in banking in a legitimate way, only lending to solvent cultivators on good security and on reasonable terms, and have given up land-grabbing as a bad speculation.
In the report for 1884 of the Special Judge who superintends the working of the Act, the fact that creditors as well as debtors freely litigate in the courts specially constituted by the Act, is prominently noticed as confuting the old charge levelled against the Act, that it would scare money-lenders out of the courts. The results of five years’ working of the Act are summed up in the following words :—
Solvent ryots can borrow as readily as before within the limit of their true means; but agriculturists of doubtful solvency find it more difficult than of yore to obtain accommodations. Money-lenders are everywhere more chary of lending and more cautious in their procedings. They are learning to contract their dealings within the limits that prudence dictates. Debts of old standing are being rapidly compromised by means of conciliatory agreements; decrees of the courts and private adjustments, and the work of liquidation, is gradually and steadily progressing; while comparatively few new liabilities are being contracted; the result being a vast diminution in the aggregate of the ryots’ indebtedness. Meantime the ryots are becoming more prosperous and more contented. They continue to regard the Act as the great charter of their rights and liberties. Agrarian crime is almost unknown. The season was, on the whole, a fairly prosperous one. No land was thrown up from inability to pay the assessment or other causes. On the contrary, the area under cultivation considerably increased during the year, specially in some talukas of the Sholapur and Ahmednagar districts. Agricultural stock has likewise increased. I have not heard of any difficulty having been experienced in the realization of the assessment. Nearly all the Subordinate Judges report that the ryots are much more thrifty, prudent, and self-helpful. They no longer find it necessary, at every turn, to have resort to the money-lender for loans to buy seed or to pay assessment. They are learning themselves to dispose of their surplus produce to the best advantage, and they take timely measures to provide for the demands that are made upon them. They are also learning to combine for mutual aid with a view of dispensing, as far as may be, with that of the saukars.
The general inquiry instituted in 1870 did not alone benefit the Deccan peasantry. In 1876 an Act called " The Sindh Encumbered Estates Act" was passed for the relief of the indebted landlords of that country.
As this volume specially concerns the peasant proprietors of the western half of the Punjab, and will contain no proposals for the relief of the few large landlords in those parts, it is unnecessary for me to notice the provisions of the Act, which gave that class in Sindh an opportunity of clearing their estates from debt. For similar reasons the analogous case of the Jhansi landlords, who were relieved by " The Jhansi Encumbered Estates Act, 1882," requires no comment.
I may, however, notice that all such Relief Acts agree in withdrawing suits between money-lenders and agriculturists from the jurisdiction of the ordinary civil courts, in compelling creditors to be satisfied with reasonable interest, in enabling mortgagees to redeem on easy terms, and in substituting a system of cheap and simple equity, suitable to the character of the agriculturists concerned, for the expensive and complicated technical justice administered by the ordinary civil courts of the land.
Notes
- *. In many matters the "class" question is the vital point which determines the shaping of a law. The statute book is full of "class legislation." The very fact that by Section 266 of the Civil Procedure Code the houses of agriculturists are exempt from attachment and sale in execution of a decree, whereas those of non-agriculturists are not exempt, is a pertinent example. Again, certain persons are exempted from personal appearance in a civil court, whilst others are not.
- *. Superintendent Revenue Survey's Report, para. 22, No. CXXIII, Bombay Selection.
- *. Opinion of the Collector of Ahmednagar, para. 1, No. 1636, dated 23rd June, 1858, from Revenue Commissioner, S. D., to Chief Secretary to Government.
- *. That is the familiar title, but correctly it is “The Dekkhan Agriculturists Relief Act, 1879.” It was amended in 1881 and again in 1882.