Sources.
§ 1. The Mughal Sovereign’s legal position and powers.
According to the theory of the Quranic law, the sovereign is only the commander of the true believers (amir-ul mumnin) and is responsible to the general body (jama‘t) of the Muslims for the proper discharge of his duties. But no constitutional machinery for controlling or judging him, such as a parliament or council of ministers responsible to the people, was in existence in any Muhammadan country or even conceived of. The Muslim State was essentially a military State, and depended for its existence on the absolute authority of the monarch, who was also the supreme general. The Roman Imperator’s functions were similar, but according to the constitution of Rome, the sanction of the Senate to important measures of State and the popular election of the chief officials were devised as checks (however futile in practice) on the Emperor’s absolutism. No such check existed in the Islamic world even in theory, though in practice the sovereign’s action was often influenced by his fear of the Muslim soldiery and his reluctance to incur social odium.
No doubt, it was open to a number of theologians (ulema) to issue a decree deposing the sovereign as a violator of the Quranic law and therefore unfit to reign. But the only means of enforcing such a decree was a rebellion. There was no constitutional body that could peacefully depose one king and set up another. In fact, the successful removal of a tyrannical Sultan always implied the rise of a pretender with a superior military force at his back. The regular forces of the State were bound to obey the king de facto and not the ulema nor the council of ministers.
The Mughal Emperor had no regular council of ministers. The wazir or diwan was the highest person below the Emperor, but the other officers were in no sense his colleagues. They were admittedly inferior to him and deserved rather to be called secretaries than ministers, because nearly all their work was liable to revision by the wazir, and royal orders were often transmitted to them through him.
As a matter of practice, when the Emperor held his private consultation or diwan-i-khas, the other high officers (viz., the chief Paymaster, the chief Qazi, the High Steward and the Commander-in-chief, if any), usually attended along with the wazir, and were consulted. But many important questions were decided by the Emperor and the wazir alone without the knowledge of the other ministers. It need hardly be said that neither the lower ministers nor even the wazir could serve as a check on the royal will. They could advise but never vote, and the insecurity and dependence of their position made it impossible for them to contradict the king even when he was clearly going wrong. The Mughal government was, therefore, a one man rule, and Aurangzib, like his contemporary Louis XIV., was really his own prime-minister.
From this it will be seen that the Mughal Emperor had no Cabinet in the modern sense of the term. His ministers were mere secretaries who carried out the royal will in matters of detail ; but they could never influence his policy except by the arts of gentle persuasion and veiled warning ; they never resigned if he rejected their counsels. In short, the ministers directed the administration only when the Emperor slept. Such ministerial control was really a violation of the spirit of the constitution (if I may use the name, where the thing did not exist) ; it indicated a state of anarchy like the periods when the Witenagemot effectively controlled the royal government of Anglo-Saxon England.
The immensity of the Mughal Emperor’s power can be judged from the fact that he was the head of the Church and the State alike. Every Muslim sovereign is, in strict theory, the Khalif of the age, or the latest successor of the Prophet in the command of the faithful, and so long as he is not deposed by the verdict of the Quranic lawyers, his power is supreme.
The Mughal Emperors, like all other Islamic sovereigns, had to play a twofold part, viz., to govern all the people in their dominions as their king, and also to be the missionary defender and agent of the creed of a section of their subjects. Therefore, from the Muhammadan portion of their subjects they levied the zakat or tithes, amounting to one-fortieth of every man’s annual increase, which they were bound to spend for the benefit of the faithful only,—by building mosques, subsidising pious men and theological teachers, endowing saints’ tombs and monasteries, relieving Muslim paupers and providing dowries for Muslim maidens. This zakat passed into the public treasury in the same way as the land-tax or the custom duty. The best illustration of the Emperor’s headship of the Church and the State alike is furnished by the fact that in later ages the Muhammadan rulers abused their trust by spending the zakat on their personal needs or for the general purposes of the Government.
2. The chief departments and their heads.
So much for the sovereign's power, the position of his ministers and the aims of the Government. We shall now study the administrative system in detail.
The chief departments of the Mughal Government were :—
- 1. The Exchequer and Revenue (under the High Diwan.)
- 2. The Imperial Household (under the Khan-i-saman or High Steward.)
- 3. The military Pay and Accounts Office (under the imperial Bakhshi.)
- 4. Canon Law, both civil and criminal (under the Chief Qazi.)
- 5. Religious endowments and charity (under the chief Sadr.)
- 6. Censorship of Public Morals (under the Muhtasib.)
Inferior to these, but ranking almost like departments, were :—
- 7. The Artillery (under the Mir Atish or Darogha-i-Topkhanah.)
- and 8. Intelligence and Posts (under the Darogha of Dak Chauki.)
The innumerable karkhanahs (i.e., factories and stores), each under a darogha or superintendent, were not departments. Most of them were under the Khan-i-saman.
§ 3. The Wazir or Chancellor.
‘ Wazir ’ or prime-minister seems to have been an honorific title, without necessarily implying the charge of any particular branch of the administration. He was, no doubt, always the head of the revenue department, but it was in his capacity of diwan. All diwans, however, were not wazirs, and we read of no Hindu diwan being given the high title of wazir.
Originally, the wazir was the highest officer of the revenue department, and in the natural course of events control over the other departments gradually passed into his hands. It was only when the king was incompetent, a pleasure-seeker or a minor, that the wazir also controlled the army. Thus, in its origin the wazir's post was a civil one, and his assumption of the supreme military direction was abnormal and a mark of imperial decadence. No doubt, the wazir, like every other high official of the Mughal Government, was expected to command an army and often did actually lead a short expedition, but the necessity of his constant attendance on the Emperor prevented him from taking charge of military operations for a long time or at a distance from the imperial camp.
The wazir’s office received all revenue papers and returns and despatches from the provinces and the field armies. He also acted as the king’s representative on many ceremonial occasions. He wrote letters “ by order ” (hasb-ul-hukm) in his own person though under the Emperor’s directions. All orders for payment except for small sums or money previously allotted had to be signed by the diwan, and the payment (except to the field army and the workmen of the State factories) was made through his department only. So, too, all questions connected with the collection of the revenue were decided by the diwan, who consulted the Emperor in important cases and frequently reported to him the state of the Treasury. Some of the famous wazirs of the Mughal period were also masters of Persian prose and they acted as secretaries in drafting royal letters to foreign rulers on behalf of their masters.
It was only under the degenerate descendants of Aurangzib that the wazirs became virtual rulers of the State, like the Mayors of the Palace in mediæval France.
§ 4. The Bakhshi or Paymaster.
Every officer of the Mughal Government was enrolled as a commander of so many horsemen. This title was only a convenient means of calculating his salary and status. It did not mean that he had actually to maintain so many horsemen in his service. Thus, theoretically even the civil officers belonged to the military department, and therefore the salary bills of all officers had to be calculated and passed by the paymasters of the army. These paymasters (bakhshis) were increased in number with the growth of the empire, till at the end of Aurangzib’s reign we have one chief Bakhshi, called the Mir Bakhshi or Imperial Paymaster and popularly as the First Bakhshi, with three assistants called the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Bakhshis.
Each field army of the Mughal Empire was placed under a general appointed for the occasion, being usually a prince of the blood (when available) under the guardianship of a senior noble. Though on several occasions we have officers invested with the title of sipah-salar or ‘ commander of troops,’ it was only a mark of honour and they did not really command the entire Mughal army. The Emperor was the only commander-in-chief.
The artillery branch was, however, placed in charge of an officer called the Mir Atish or, popularly, darogha-i-topkhanah. Not only the artillery-men but also the musketeers were under his command. As the artillery of the Turks of Europe was much more advanced and efficient than that of the Mughal Emperors, the latter tried to get for their Mir Atish any good officer of the Turkish empire or even Persian that they could secure. On the whole the Indian Muhammadans were remarkably incompetent in handling artillery, and this department was filled with Turkish and Feringi gunners and cannon-founders, while the musketeers were mostly recruited from certain Hindu tribes, such as the Bundelas, the Karnatakis, and the men of Buxar. Each field army had its own special chief of artillery.
I shall not discuss the military department any further, as it has been fully treated in William Irvine’s Army of the Indian Moghuls.
§ 5. The Khan-i-saman or High Steward.
The High Steward was a very important officer of the Mughal times, as he was the head of the Emperor’s household department* and accompanied him during his journeys and campaigns. All the personal servants of the Emperor were under this officer’s control, and he also supervised the Emperor’s daily expenditure, food, tents, stores, etc. Naturally the Khan-i-saman enjoyed great trust and influence, and there are examples of wazirs being appointed from among the Khan-i-samans.
§ 6. The Judiciary.
The Emperor, as “the Khalif of the Age,” was theoretically the highest judge and used to hold courts of justice and try select cases personally on Wednesdays. But the court held by him was a tribunal of the highest appeal rather than a court of first instance. The Qazi was the chief judge in criminal suits, and tried them according to Muslim law. Not only all cases between Muhammadans, but also all important criminal cases in which one of the parties was a Muhammadan, had to be instituted in the Qazi’s court. Assisted by a mufti, who consulted the old Arabic books on jurisprudence and stated the abstract law bearing on the case, the Qazi pronounced sentence.
Naturally the great power and irresponsible position of the Qazi enabled him to turn his office into a vast field of corruption, and all the Qazis of the Mughal period, with a few honourable exceptions, were notorious for taking bribes. (History of Aurangzib, iii. 84-86.) The supreme Qazi of the empire was called the Qazi-ul-quzat and also "the Qazi of the imperial camp," and he always accompanied the Emperor. Every provincial capital had its local Qazi, who was appointed by the Chief Qazi. These posts were often sold for bribes, and the Qazi's department became a byword and reproach in Mughal times.
The following is the customary charge of the diwan to a newly appointed Qazi : " Be just, be honest, be impartial. Hold trials in the presence of the parties and at the court-house and the seat of Government (muhakuma.)
" Do not accept presents from the people of the place where you serve, nor attend entertainments given by anybody and everybody.
" Write your decrees, sale-deeds mortgage-bonds and other legal documents very carefully, so that learned men may not pick holes in them and bring you to shame.
" Know poverty (faqr) to be your glory (fakhr) " [Manual pp. 41-42.]
The Mufti is urged to spend his days and nights in reading books on jurisprudence and the reports of cases from which one can learn precedents. When he finds the judgment proposed in a case by the Qazi under whom he serves to be opposed to all precedent, he should tell him politely, " Sir, in a similar case, reported in such and such a book, the judgment is given thus. It would be better if you pronounce your own judgment after reading that book. "
The Mufti should train himself during his leisure-hours by copying learned legal decisions and discussions of judicial principles from authoritative text-books. [Manual, 43-44.]
The Sadr was judge and supervisor of the endowments of land made by the Emperor or princes for the support of pious men, scholars and monks. It was his duty to see that such grants were applied to the right purpose and also to scrutinize applications for fresh grants. Assistance was often given in cash also. The rent-free land granted bore the names of sayurghal (Turkish), madad-i- mash (Arabic), aima, etc. The Sadr was also the Emperor's almoner and had the spending of the vast sums which the Emperors set apart for charity in the month of Ramzan and other holy occasions,—amounting to 1½ lakhs of rupees in the reign of Aurangzib, and Court ceremonies. The Sadr's position offered him boundless possibilities of enriching himself by means of bribes and peculation, and the Sadrs of Akbar's reign were notorious for their venality and cruel spirit.
The Chief Sadr of the empire was called the Sadr-us-sadur, the Sadr-i-Jahan, or popularly the Sadr-i-kul. In addition every province had its local Sadr. Practically the Sadr was exclusively a civil judge, but not of all civil cases. For the posts of Qazi and Sadr, men of high Arabic scholarship and reputed sanctity of character, where available, were chosen.
The Chief Sadr, when sending the provincial Sadrs to their charges, is instructed to give them lists of the recipients of rent-free lands and daily allowances in their respective provinces, and copies of the Emperor's regulations concerning the death or flight of the servitors [of the mosques], aimadars, rozinadars, students and other persons in receipt of stipends (both hereditary and new), and urge them to act according to the imperial orders. [Manual, 39-40.]
§ 7. The Censor of Public Morals.
According to Muslim law, it is the king's duty to appoint an Inspector or Censor of Public Morals (Muhtasib) to regulate the lives of the people in strict accordance with the scriptural rules. The Censor's functions are to enforce the Prophet's commands and put down the practices forbidden by him (amr wa nihi),—such as drinking distilled spirits and fermented beer, bhang (i.e., hemp or Cannabis sativa) and other liquid intoxicants, gambling and certain kinds of immorality. Dry intoxicants were not condemned, and we find both opium and ganja (i.e., dried hemp plant) allowed. The punishment of heretical opinions, blasphemy against the Prophet, and neglect of the five daily prayers and the fast of Ramzan by Muhammadans also lay within the province of the Censor. He used to go through the streets with a party of soldiers demolishing and plundering liquor-shops, distilleries and gamblingdens wherever he found them, breaking with blows the pots and pans for preparing bhang, and enforcing the strict observance of religious rites on the part of the Muhammadan population. Sometimes his retainers had armed conflicts with the bold sinners who showed fight. The demolition of newly built temples was one of this officer's duties in Aurangzib's reign. (History of Aurangzib, iii. 93-94, 323.)
The following instructions are given to a newly appointed Muhtasib (Censor) as to his duties :—
“ To those Muhammadans who do not know the rules of worship according to the true faith and Musalmani conduct or ceremonies you should give instructions in these matters. If they plead inability, reprimand or chastise them.
“In the bazars and lanes observe if any one, contrary to the regulations and custom, has screened off (abru) a part of the street, or closed the path, or thrown dirt and sweepings on the road,—or if any one has seized the portion of the bazar area reserved for public traffic and opened his shop there ; you should in such cases urge them to remove the violation of regulations.
“In the cities do not permit the sale of intoxicating drinks nor the residence of ‘professional women’ (tawaif, literally dancing girls), as it is opposed to the Sacred Law.
“Give good counsel and warning to those who violate the Quranic precepts. Do not show harshness [at first], for then they would give you trouble. First send advice to the leaders of these men, and if they do not listen to you then report the case to the governor.” [Manual, 45-46.]
§ 8. Our sources of information.
I shall now describe and critically examine the original sources of information that we possess about the Mughal system of administration.
The best known of them and the one most accessible to English-speaking readers is Abul Fazl’s Ain-i-Akbari, of which a scholarly translation in 3 volumes by Blochmann and Jarrett is available. But this work, though it was the progenitor and in certain respects the model, of later official handbooks, has many defects. It was the first work of its kind in India and was written when the newly created Mughal administration was in a half fluid condition. Abul Fazl, therefore, tells us what an officer ought to aim at doing, rather than what the experienced servants of a long-settled government were in the habit of doing ; that is to say, he draws an ideal picture instead of giving us a faithful description of the administration in its actual working. Moreover, he is an insufferable rhetorician, and even when he intends to tell a fact, he buries it under a mass of figures of speech and round-about expressions. His work, therefore, does not give us much real help in drawing a correct and detailed picture of the administrative machinery, though in the statistical portion he is detailed and correct. We are oppressed by a sense of the vagueness and unreality of the picture as we go through the descriptive parts of the Ain.
The immense size of the book and the unreality or rather the practical uselessness of much of its contents, made it undesirable to write similar works or to bring the Ain-i-Akbari up to date in the reigns of Akbar’s successors. The needs of their officials were met by compiling a class of handbooks called Dastur-ul-aml, written in the exact antithesis of the style of Abul Fazl. These are highly condensed abstracts, full of facts, figures and lists, with no descriptive matter and hardly any complete sentence. (They remind us of the sutras or strings of short rules in the post-Vedic Sanskrit literature.) Such small handbooks could be easily revised and brought up to date in successive reigns. But the revision took the form of making additions at the end of each section, bringing the work up to date. For this reason the latest Dastur is the one most useful to us ; it includes its predecessors, and we miss only a few old statistics which have been replaced by more recent information.
Such Dastur-ul-amls were composed in the reigns of Shah Jahan and Aurangzib, and several MSS. of them are known to exist. Thomas* used five of these works. I have used one of these five, (namely, D. 163 of the Asiatic Soceiety of Bengal) along with other sources in writing my India of Aurangzib : statistics, topography and roads (1901.)
But a better Dastur-ul-aml has since then been copied and studied by me. One MS. of it is the India Office Library (London) No. Pers. 370, which is defective at both ends and the other is the British Museum Oriental No. 1641, complete but entitled Zawabit-i-Alamgiri or the Regulations of the Emperor Aurangzib. The two MSS. are copies of the same work, in spite of the difference in their titles and the fact that they were transcribed from different manuscripts. They give figures up to the 33rd year of the Emperor's reign, i.e., 1690 A.D., when the Mughal Empire had reached its climax after the capture of Bijapur, Golkonda and Raigarh (the Maratha capital) and the annexation of these three kingdoms to the territory of Delhi. Mere statistics of a later date, down to about the middle of the 18th century, can be found in the works of Jag-jivan Das aud Rai Chatar-man, the latter of which I have given in English in my India of Aurangzib. But as they do not treat of the administrative system, they must be left out of our present study.
§ 9. Contents of Dastur-ul-aml.
These Dastur-ul-amls or official handbooks tell us, in the fewest words possible, about the revenues of the different provinces, the number of their subdivisions, the distances between different cities of the empire, the rules for sending official papers to Court, the records that should come to the different diwans' offices, the total expenditure of the State, the number of mansabdars and other military forces, the usual titles of Muslim and Hindu nobles, musicians and caligraphists, the distribution of work among the bakhshis and diwans, the functions and official procedure of the Khan-i-saman Bayutat Mir Atish Mushrifs of the barqandazes and other special classes of troops, as well as of the bakhshi of the Ahadis, details of the High Diwan’s office-work and the papers to be received, replied to, prepared or signed or submitted to the Emperor by him, minute rules about the cash salaries of the princes and mansabdars, the rules of branding and shoeing cavalry horses, the classification of officers according to their equipment, rules about leave and overstaying leave, minute regulations about adjusting the jagir to an officer’s rank, payment of retainers, grant for the fodder of the transport cattle of the different grades of mansabdars.
Then we have tables of weights (as current in different parts), the exchange value of the coins of different countries outside India, a list of the forts in the empire, the number of the mansabdars grade by grade, rules about promotion, dismissal and sick-leave—in short all kinds of salary-rules ; the special salaries, of European gunners, sappers and cannon-founders (Z. 60b—62b), powdersupply to musketeers (Z. 63a), classification of arms, rates of jaziya, list of seasons appropriate for voyages (Z. 67 a—68 a), the revenue of Persia, the escheated properties of various princes, princesses and nobles, lists of presents received from Persia, the amounts in the imperial treasure-rooms (Z. 132b), lists of karkhanahs (Z. 132b—133a), lists of the abwabs abolished by Aurangzib and of the practices declared by him as illegal (Z. 135a —137a), details about Aurangzib’s armaments at the sieges of Bijapur, Golkonda, etc., with descriptions of some of the Deccan forts of his time,—and many more details about the Emperor’s Deccan campaigns and statistics about his Deccan provinces.
It will be seen from the above what a vast mass of useful and absolutely new information is compressed into this Dastur-ul-aml. Without it a thorough study of the Mughal administration would have been impossible. Unfortunately both the MSS. are badly written, and in several places the minor technical official terms can be read only by conjecture ; the figures too are written not in Arabic numerals but by means of peculiar signs called raqam, which when written with the least negligence may make a difference of tenfold or hundredfold. No distinctly-written old and reliable copy of the Dastur is likely to be discovered.
Hence, we cannot extract the fullest benefit from this valuable source. Part of our reading of it must be conjectural, and in a few places the text must be given up as hopelessly unreadable.
Happily, in some respects we can correct and supplement the Dastur from a later work, which is unique of its kind in Indo-Persian literature. I mean the Mirat-i-Ahmadi or History of Gujrat written in 1748 by Muhammad Ali Khan, the diwan of the province. The author has given full copies of as many of the imperial farmans addressed to the officials of this province as were preserved in his office. In this respect the book is a veritable mine of accurate information based upon authentic State papers. A comparison with the versions of a few of these farmans given in other works proves the honesty and industry of Muhammad Ali Khan.
This book has been lithographed at Bombay by a man who wrote a beautiful hand, no doubt, but whose knowledge of Persian historical prose was limited. He has left several gaps in the text, reproduced the mistakes of the original copy without correction, and written the obscure words without any attempt to make them intelligible;—evidently he himself did not understand them. A correct and reliable old MS. of this work, if discovered, would greatly add to our knowledge exactly where we are most in need of light.
§ 10. Manual of Officers' Duties.
A secondary source of information on the Mughal administration is a curious Persian manuscript, written not later than the early 18th century, which I secured from an old Kayastha family of the Patna district. It is a small book, 138 pages of 11 lines each, with the beginning, end and two leaves in the middle missing. I shall call it the Manual of the Duties of Officers.
We know that Egypt under Arab rule produced a number of works written by officials which are of the highest value to a student of administration. “Musabbihi gives a wealth of official documents......The very minute descriptions of etiquette at the Fatimid Court in Ibn Tuwair seem to be copied from a book of Court ceremonial. Ibn Mammati gives from personal knowledge rules for the diwans, and later al-‘Omari a chancery-manual, the most perfect work on the latter’s model being Kalkashandi’s...... Finally writers like Ibn Dukmak and Ibn Dji‘an use or reproduce bodily records of official surveys.”—[Encyclopædia of Islam, ii. 22.]
My last-named MS. gives minute directions as to how the different officials of the Mughal government should conduct themselves, what functions they were expected to discharge, what precautions they should take, and what records they should draw up or keep in duplicate. It is in the form of a dialogue. Each section begins with the statement that an aspirant for some office (let us call it fauzdari), asks an expert in the work “How should I act in order to satisfy my master, please the people, and secure a good name and prosperity for myself?” He receives a reply giving a long list of the special virtues that the newly appointed functionary must practise, the exact nature of his office-work, his temptations and dangers. A part of the reply is, no doubt, abstract or general good counsel, but much of it is based on actual experience and the long-observed practice of the Mughal administrators. Here we get an inside view of that administration which mere theoretical treatises cannot give us.
The information supplied by these sources can be supplemented from the long Court annals of the Mughal Emperors beginning with the Akbarnamah of the 16th century and ending with the Bahadur Shah-namah of 1709. But the information on changes and innovations in the administrative rules or procedure given in them is diffused over a vast area, and it takes a life’s study through these long annals to pick the necessary facts out, piece them together and reconstruct the history of the growth of the administration through the course of two centuries. I have collected together such scattered information for a half century only, namely the reign of Aurangzib.
Certain other MSS. (such as the Nigarnamah-i-Munshi and the Insha-i-Harkaran) give blank forms of the letters-patent appointing diwans, bakhshis, amins and most other officers to their posts. From these we can learn the nature of the work they were expected to do.
Notes
- *. Manucci writes :— “He had charge of the whole expenditure of the royal household in reference to both great and small things.”—(Storia do Mogor, ii : 419.) See, also, my History of Aurangzib, iii. 79.
- *. Revenue Resources of the Mughal Empire, p 14 and footnote, p. 33 and footnote, esp. 40 n,—I.O. L, 1387, Br. Mus. Addl. 6598 and 6599, A.S.B. MS. (D. 163), and another MS. copied for Elliot.