VI. Appendix

The Judicial and Revenue Systems of India, Rammohun Roy, 1832 · from page 113 · about 14 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

Since the foregoing evidence has been circulated, a gentleman of high literary repute, connected with India, has expressed doubts regarding the policy or expediency of the suggestions, I made in reply to Queries 71, 72, on the Judicial System, in the following words :

“ No civil servant should be sent to India under twenty-four or at least twenty-two years of age, and no candidate among them should be admitted into the judicial line of the service, unless he can produce a certificate from a professor of English law to prove that he possesses a competent knowledge of it.” (vide p. 47 supra.)

In addition to the reasons there advanced in support of this position, and also in reply to Query 77, (vide p. 52) I beg here to quote (with deference to that gentleman's extensive oriental acquirements), the authority of Sir William Blackstone, given in his introduction to the celebrated “ Commentaries on the Laws of England,” an authority which stands very high in the estimation of the British public.

“ Should a judge in the most subordinate jurisdiction be deficient in the knowledge of the law, it will reflect infinite contempt on himself and disgrace upon those who employ him. And yet the consequences of his ignorance is comparatively very trifling and small: his judgment may be examined and his errors rectified by other courts. But how much more serious and affecting is the case of a superior judge, if without any skill in the laws he will boldly venture to decide a question upon which the welfare and subsistence of whole families may depend, where the chance of his judging right or wrong is barely equal, and where if he chances to judge wrong, he does an injury of the most alarming nature, and injury without possibility of redress." Sec. 1. No. 12.

It should not be overlooked that the Company's district Judges and young Registrars who have the decision of minor causes, are afterwards made judges of the provincial courts of appeal, and also of the Sudder Dewanee and Nizamut Adawlut (the highest civil and criminal tribunals), whose decision is final in all criminal causes, as well as in civil causes under 50,000 rupees; and that even in regard to causes above that sum, very few have the means of appealing to the king and council in England. The peculiar difficulties and discouragements attending such appeals have been already pointed out in my evidence, (Judicial System, Q. 51. page 36.)

No. II.

In my paper on the Revenue System I expressed an opinion that the permanent settlement has been beneficial to both the contracting parties, i. e. the government and the landholders. This position, which, as regards the former, was long much controverted, does not now rest upon theory; but can be proved by the results of about forty years’ practice. To illustrate this, I subjoin the annexed statements, Nos. I. & II., shewing the failure of the whole amount of the public revenue at Madras under the Ryotwary system as contrasted with the general increase of the revenues of Bengal under Zumeendary permanent settlement; the latter diffusing prosperity into the other branches of revenue, whereas the former (or Ryotwary system), without affecting any material increase in that particular branch, has, by its impoverishing influence, tended to dry up the other sources of Revenue: a fact which must stand valid and incontrovertible as a proof of the superiority of the latter, until a contrary fact of greater or at least equal weight can be adduced.

Statement 1st.—Bengal, Behar and Orissa.

By a comparative view of the Revenues of Bengal, Behar and Orissa, from the period of the Perpetual Settlement, it appears that, in the thirty-five years, from 1792-3 to 1827-8, there was a total increase on the whole amount of the Revenue of above 100 per cent. (101·71), and that this increase has been steady and progressive up to the present time; in the first seventeen years (from 1792-3 to 1839-10), it was about 42½ per cent.; in the next eighteen years (from 1809-10 to 1827-8) 43 8⁄10 per cent., and in the last ten years of that period (from 1817-18 to 1827-8) it was nearly 30 per cent.

These results are extracted from The Second Report of the Select Committee on the Affairs of the East India Company in 1810, p. 80; The Second Report of 1830, p. 98.

In 1815-16, the revenue of Cuttack was incorporated with that of Bengal, but in 1822 the revenue of this Province did not exceed 185,000l.

Statement 2nd.—Madras.

By a comparative view of the revenue of the old British territory in Madras, it appears that during the same period of thirty-five years (i. e. from 1793 to 1828, there was an increase of only about 40 per cent. (40·15.) on the total amount of the whole revenue. That the increase during the first seventeen years (from 1793 to 1810) was 43 23⁄100 per cent.; that in the next eight years the increase was only about 3½ per cent.; and that in the last eighteen years, (i. e. from 1810 to 1828) there has been a decrease of 2 15⁄100 per cent.

These results are extracted from the Second Report of the Select Committee on the Affairs of the East India Company in 1810. (p. 88.); Second Report of 1830, (p. 98) and Minutes of Evidence, 1830-31.

No. III.

A doubt has been expressed with regard to the policy and advantage of acting on the principle suggested in my paper on the Revenue System (paragraph 14 to 17), in which I expressed my opinion as to the propriety (on grounds of justice and humanity) of fixing a maximum rent to be paid by each of the cultivators, that their rents, already raised to a ruinous extent, might not be subject to further encrease. I shall therefore here offer a few additional remarks on that point, shewing the policy of such a measure.

Since the establishment of the permanent settlement in the lower provinces of the Bengal Presidency, the landholders (whose rents have been secured by it) are well known to have been firmly attached to the existing government (as I noticed in reply to No. 13 of the Additional Queries). This cannot be said of the same class in the ceded and conquered provinces, whose estates have not been secured by a similar arrangement; and it is not the case with regard to the people of a large proportion of the Madras presidency, where no similar attachment can be reasonably expected. Hence we may be justified in inferring that if the benefit of a permanent settlement were also extended to the cultivators, the farmers and labourers in every part of the country, both in the upper and lower provinces (who form the largest portion of the population of India) would be equally attached to government, and ready to rise in defence of it, as a militia or in any other shape that might be required; so as to secure the British rule in a foreign and remote empire, alike from internal intrigue and from external aggression, without the necessity of keeping on foot an immense standing army at an enormous cost. This consideration is of great importance in respect to the natives of the upper and western provinces, who are distinguished by their superior bravery, and form the greater part of the British Indian army. If this race of men, who are by no means deficient in feelings of personal honor and regard for family respectability, were assured that their rights in the soil were indefeasible so long as the British power should endure, they would from gratitude and self-interest at all times be ready to devote their lives and property in its defence. The saving that might be effected by this liberal and generous policy, through the substituting of a militia force for a great part of the present standing army, would be much greater than any gain that could be realized by any system of increasing land revenue that human ingenuity could devise. How applicable to this case is the following line of the Persian sage (Sadi). “ Be on friendly terms with thy “ subjects, and rest easy about the warfare of thine ene- “ mies; for to an upright prince his people is an army.”

Bā rayat sulh kun wa’z jang i khasm aiman nishīn
Z’ānki shāhinshāh i ādil rā rayat lashkar ast.

On the other hand, the same confidence could not be produced by any periodical settlement (be it quinquennial, decennial or even centennial) formed on the narrow policy of securing a temporary advantage or remote problematical gain to the government; since the love of offspring and the desire of continuing name and lineage in connection with the place of nativity and of residence, and with hereditary property, are the same in a peasant as in a prince.

No. IV.

An idea has gone abroad that the permanent, or Zamindary system, though undeniably beneficial to Government, has proved too advantageous to the landholders; and the vast wealth which they are supposed to have derived from it has excited an anxiety in the minds of some to devise a plea for overturning it. The fact, however, is, that even the greatest landholder in the country, such as the Rajah of Burdwan, who pays a landtax of between 30 and 40 lakhs of rupees to Government, does not receive more than six or eight lakhs, about 20 per cent. on the amount collected, for his own share as proprietor. For this sum they incur an immense responsibility to the Government; they are punishable for thefts and robberies committed within their estates, when suspected even of negligence in preventing or detecting such offences, and subject to loss by inundations and failure of crops. Some may have about an equal sum with that payable to government, and a very few double; these almost exclusively in the eastern parts of Bengal. But the generality are by no means so favourably situated as is generally supposed; a fact clearly proved by the estates which come into the immediate management of Government in the Court of Wards, and which may be easily inferred from the frequent sales of estates for arrears of revenue.

Supposing these landholders of Bengal to stand in the place of the farmers in England, who are considered to pay about one-third of the produce of their farms as rent; is there any thing so unreasonable, if the Zamindars receive 15 or 20 per cent.; a very few 30 per cent. of the produce of their estates? If the persons above alluded to, who suppose the Zamindars too well off, will only wait a little, as the law of primogeniture is not established or observed, the effect of hereditary succession will soon so subdivide the estates, and reduce the incomes of the landholders, that very few, if any, rich Zamindars can be found in the country.

No. V.

In illustration of the statement made in my reply to Query 52, on the Revenue System, that as a sum of money is drawn from India by Europeans retiring from it with fortunes realized there, a different system, calculated to encourage Europeans of capital to become permanent settlers with their families, would necessarily greatly improve the resources of the country; I here subjoin some tables showing the amount paid to the principal European Civil Officers of the Government in the General, Judicial and Revenue Departments in India in 1826-7. The Military Establishment, of course, is not included. Besides, such Europeans as are barristers, solicitors and law officers paid by fees, merchants, agents, and planters also, not being permitted to settle in the country, retire from it with their fortunes; and these, likewise, are not included in the Statement. Moreover, many miscellaneous and minor officers are not enumerated in the subjoined List; I also annex a note shewing the amount of the Revenues of India expended in England.

TBL-001 · FOLIO 144Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
BENGAL CIVIL OFFICES.
I. GENERAL BRANCH.
Per Annum. Indian Money.Per Annum. Sterling.
Governor General's Salary .. Rupees.2,44,181£24,418
3 Members of Council, in all2,93,01729,301
6 Secretaries to Government2,74,00027,400
3 Judges of the King's Supreme Court1,95,34419,534
Lord Bishop of Calcutta50,3035,030
Archdeacon and 31 Chaplains3,00,22230,022
Advocate-General, Company's Attorney, and Standing Counsel80,5818,058
7 Residents at Native Courts, (Delhi, Lucknow, Gualior, Nagpoor, Hyderabad, Indore, Nepaul)6,81,50968,150
9 Local (Political) Agents, with 6 Assistants and 6 Surgeons2,37,57323,757
5 Do. Do. (at Joypore, Harowtee, for Sikh and Hill Affairs—Serowhee, Mhairwarra)95,2419,524
18 Assistants1,29,00012,900
11 Surgeons and Assistant Do.86,6408,664
Postmaster-General60,6356,063
Accountant-General44,4004,440
Sub Treasurer36,0003,600
4 Mint Masters60,9936,099
4 Assay Masters60,6006,060

II. Judicial Branch.

TBL-002 · FOLIO 145Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
II. Judicial Branch.
Supreme Civil and Criminal Courts (Sudder Dewanee and Nizamut Adawluts.)
5 JudgesRs. 2,80,000£28,000
1 Registrar and Deputy39,6003,960
4 Assistants27,6832,768
2 Translators9,600960
Four Provincial Courts of Appeal and Circuit, viz. Calcutta, Dacca, Moorshedabad, and Patna.
17 JudgesRs. 6,55,000£65,500
6 Surgeons at 4,80028,8002,880
Two additional Provincial Courts of Appeal and Circuit of Benares and Bareilly, 9 Judges; also Benares City Adawlut, Gazeepoore, Juanpore, and Mirzapoor, 4 Judges and Magistrates.
13 JudgesRs. 4,71,196£47,119
5 Registrars, and Registrars and Joint Magistrates51,0825,108
8 Surgeons and Assistant Surgeons38,4003,840
Three City Adawluts—Dacca, Moorshedabad, Patna.
3 Judges with Magisterial powerS. Rs. 84,000£8,400
5 Registrars37,2003,720
Forty Zillah Adawluts.
49 Judges, Magistrates and Assistant Do.12,13,762121,376
57 Registrars (or Registrars and Joint Magistrates)S. Rs. 4,39,893£43,989
49 Surgeons and Assistant Surgeons2,26,39322,639
Superintendents and Assistant Do...138,12013,812
5 Commissioners and Assistant Do..118,51011,851
III. Revenue Branch.
Lower Provinces.
Board of Revenue, 3 Members1,40,00014,000
Secretary26,7842,678
Sub-Secretary and 2 Assistants20,4002,040
3 Commercial (or Opium) Agents in Behar, Benares, Malwa1,56,09115,609
Board of Customs, Salt and Opium,
2 Members1,05,00010,500
Secretary29,4492,944
8 Salt Agents2,89,35428,935
20 Collectors of Customs and Duties4,30,69543,069
5 Superintendents of Stamps and of Salt
1,22,09912,209
28 Collectors in the Lower Provinces6,06,28860,628
Commissioner in the Sunderbunds..22,8002,280
10 Revenue Officers for Calcutta, Hooghley, Jungal Mehals, N. E. of Rungpore, Kumaoon, Cuttack, Balasore, Kherdah1,99,42419,942
Secretary of Presidency Committee of Records and Registrar10,8001,080
Western Provinces.
Board of Commissioners, 3 Members1,44,48714,448
Secretary, Sub ditto, and Assistant..42,7444,274
12 Collectors, 2 Deputy-Collectors, and 1 Sub-Collector4,14,79241,479
Central Provinces.
Board of Revenue, 3 Members ....1,45,00014,500
Secretary and 5 Assistants ........58,1795,817
16 Collectors and Sub-Collectors....3,53,12935,312
Agent to Gov. General in Saugor and Nerbuddah50,0005,000
9 Assistants in charge of Districts ..1,23,76512,376

The allowances of the Civil Officers on the Presidencies of Madras and Bombay, are similar to those of Bengal; the chief difference exists between the salaries of the Governors and Members of Council in these Presidencies, and those of the Governor-General in Bengal and the Members of his Council. I shall therefore only subjoin an Abstract of the Total Amount of the Civil Service of the Three Presidencies.

TBL-003 · FOLIO 149Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Abstract of the Total Number of Covenanted Assistants, and Military and Medical Officers employed in the Civil Department of Bengal, Madras and Bombay, distinguishing the different Branches and total Expence of the same in the year 1827. (Extracted from Official Returns, ordered to be printed, 25th Feb. 1830.)
1827. BRANCHES.BENGALMADRASBOMBAYTOTAL
NOS.ALLOWANCES. Rs.NOS.ALLOWANCES. Rs.NOS.ALLOWANCES. Rs.NOS.ALLOWANCES. Rs.
General30242,47,91412414,25,7358113,34,39150770,08,040
Judicial23640,48,26810116,53,975669,68,73340366,70,976
Revenue17737,11,2098513,95,052657,82,37032758,88,631
Marine161,42,7402278,078201,60,596583,81,414
Commercial.........61,25,97851,04,981112,30,959
Totals7311,21,50,13133846,78,81823733,51,07113062,01,80,020

Total number of persons, One thousand, three hundred and six. Total amount of money, Two crores, one lakh, eighty thousand and twenty Rupees; nearly two millions English money.

N. B.—By the evidence of Messrs. Lloyd and Melville, (the former the Accountant-general, and the latter the Auditor-general of the East India Company,) recorded in the Minutes of Evidence taken before the Select Committee of the House of Lords, 23d February 1830, it appears that the proportion of the Indian revenues expended in England on the territorial account amounts, on an average, to 3,000,000l. sterling annually. It includes the expences at the Board of Controul and India House; pay, absentee allowances, and pensions to Civil and Military Officers in Europe for services in India, with interest of money realized there, &c. &c. besides 453,588l. for territorial stores consigned to India.

In a letter of the Court of Directors to the Government of Bengal, dated the 20th of June 1810, and quoted in the work “ On Colonial Policy as applicable to the Government of India,” by a very able servant of the Company, holding a responsible situation in Bengal, the Directors state that “ it is no extravagant assertion to advance, that the annual remittances to London on account of individuals, have been at the rate of nearly 2,000,000l. per annum for a series of years past.” (p. 70.) From these and other authentic documents the author calculates the amount of capital, or “ the aggregate of tribute, public and private, so withdrawn from India from 1765 to 1820, at 110,000,000l.” (p. 65.)

Notes

  1. Note. Note.—In the above Statement the Rupee is taken at two shillings for the convenience of calculation; the real rate of exchange, however, has varied considerably, and of late years may be taken at an average, perhaps, of 1s. 10d., consequently 10 or 11 Rupees will constitute a Pound Sterling.