on the
REVENUE SYSTEM OF INDIA.
Various opinions are entertained by individuals with regard to the perpetual settlement of public revenue, concluded according to Regulation I. of 1793 with proprietors of land in the provinces of Bengal, Behar, and Orissa, and arguments resting on different principles have been adduced for and against this system; no room is therefore left for throwing any new light on the subject. We may, however, safely advance so far as to admit the settlement to be advantageous to both the contracting parties, though not perhaps in equal proportion.
2. To convince ourselves, in the first instance, of the accuracy of the opinion that the perpetual settlement has proved advantageous to government, a reference to the revenue records of the former and present rulers will I think suffice. No instance can be shewn in those records, in which the sum assessed and annually expected from these provinces was ever collected with equal advantage prior to the year 1793. To avoid the demand of an encrease of revenue on the part of government, proprietors in general used then wilfully to neglect the cultivation, which very often proved utterly ruinous to themselves, and excessively inconvenient to government, in managing, farming, or selling such estates for the purpose of realizing their revenues.
3. Such persons as have directed their attention to the revenue records of government, must have been struck with the extreme difference existing between the rate of value at which estates usually sold prior to the year 1793, or even several years subsequent to that period, and the common price which the disposal of those estates now obtains to government or individuals at public or private sales; and it will not, I believe, be alleged that I am far wrong, when I say that this encrease may in general be reckoned tenfold, and in some instances twenty. This enormous augmentation of the price of land is principally to be attributed to the extensive cultivation of waste lands, which has taken place in every part of the country, and to the rise of rents payable by the cultivators, and not to any other cause that I can trace.
4. It is true the common encrease of wealth has an irresistible tendency to augment the price, without any improving change in the property; but when we reflect on the extent of overwhelming poverty throughout the country (towns and their vicinity excepted), we cannot admit that encrease of wealth in general has been the cause of the actual rise in the value of landed estates. To those who have ever made a tour of the provinces, either on public duty or from motives of curiosity, it is well known that within a circle of a hundred miles in any part of the country there are to be found very few, if any (besides proprietors of land), that have the least pretension to wealth or independence, or even the common comforts of life.
5. It has been asserted, and perhaps justly, that much of the encreased wealth of Bengal in late years is to be ascribed to the opening of the trade in 1814, thereby occasioning a greatly encreased demand for the produce of lands. In as far, however, as this cause may have operated to encrease of wealth, it is confined to landlords and dealers in commodities.
6. Besides government appropriates to itself an enormous duty on the transit and exportation of the produce of the soil, which has, since the period of the perpetual settlement, encreased to a great amount, from the exertions of the proprietors in extending and improving cultivation, under the assurance that no demand of an encrease of revenue would be made upon them on account of the progressive productiveness of their estates.
7. In the second place, that the perpetual settlement has been conducive to the interest of the proprietors of land is, in fact, acknowledged by all parties, and is fully evident on reference to the present and former revenue registers. The benefit which the proprietors enjoy is principally owing to two circumstances : First, The extended cultivation of waste lands which formerly yielded no rent : Secondly, Subsequent encrease of rents, much beyond those rates paid by cultivators at the time of the perpetual settlement, in defiance of the rights of Khud-kasht Ryots — that is, such villagers as cultivate on lease the land that belongs to the village.
8. None will, I think, hesitate to rejoice in the augmentation of the incomes of proprietors derived from the extension of cultivation, as every man is entitled by law and reason to enjoy the fruits of his honest labour and good management. But as to the policy of vesting in the proprietors themselves, exempted from any encrease of tax, the power of augmenting rents due from their Khudkasht tenants, I must confess it to be a subject that requires examination.
9. It is too true to be denied that there was no regular system of administering justice, even in theory, under the government of the former rulers, and that there were few instances in which such humble individuals as Khud-kasht Ryots succeeded in bringing complaints against proprietors to the notice of higher authorities; nevertheless their claims to the cultivation of particular soils at fixed rates, according to their respective qualities, were always admitted as their means of livelihood, and inducement to continue to reside in their native village, although proprietors very often oppressively extorted from them sums of money, in addition to their rents, under the name of abwābs, or subscriptions; while, on the other hand, the Ryots frequently obtained deductions through collusion with the managers acting in behalf of the proprietors.
10. The measure adopted for the protection of Khud-kasht tenants in Article 2nd, Sec. LX. Reg. VIII. of 1793, was conditional, and has been consequently subject to violation. Hence they have benefited very little, if at all, by its provisions.
11. The power of imposing new leases and rents, given to the proprietors by Reg. I. and VIII. of 1793, and subsequent Regulations, has considerably enriched comparatively a few individuals—the proprietors of land—to the extreme disadvantage, or rather ruin, of millions of their tenants; and it is productive of no advantage to the government.
12. During the former system of government, proprietors in these and other provinces, contrary to the tenure by which lands are held in England, were required to pay a considerable proportion of their rents to the ruler of the country, whose arbitrary will was alone sufficient to augment or reduce the rates of the revenue demandable from them, and who, by despotic power, might deprive them of their rights as proprietors when they failed to pay the revenue unjustly alleged to be due from them. Under these circumstances, the situation of the proprietors was not in any respect on a more favourable footing than that of the Khud-kasht tenant, and consequently their right was not in any way analagous to that of a landlord in England.
13. In short, there were three parties acknowledged to have had a fixed right in the soil :— 1st, The Ryots to cultivate the land, and receive one half of the produce in return for the seed and labour. 2ndly, The government, in return for its general protection, to receive the other half, with the exception of one-tenth or eleventh. 3dly, The Zamindars, or landholders, to receive the tenth or eleventh for their local protection, and for their intervention between the government and the peasantry.
14. With a view to facilitate the collection of revenue, and to encourage proprietors to improve their estates, government liberally relieved them in the year 1793 from the distress and difficulties originating in the uncertainty of assessment, by concluding a perpetual settlement with them. But I am at a loss to conceive why this indulgence was not extended to their tenants, by requiring proprietors to follow the example of government, in fixing a definite rent to be received from each cultivator, according to the average sum actually collected from him during a given term of years; or why the feeling of compassion excited by the miserable condition of the cultivators does not now induce the government to fix a maximum standard, corresponding with the sum of rent now paid by each cultivator in one year, and positively interdict any further encrease.
15. Some, however, doubt whether government can now assume the power of bettering the condition of this immense portion of its subjects, without violating the long-standing practice of the country, and the principles laid down in their existing regulations, at least for the last forty years. But I am satisfied that an unjust precedent and practice, even of longer standing, cannot be considered as the standard of justice by an enlightened government.
16. With respect to the Regulations, however, there would be no real violation of them; as in Reg. I. of 1793, which is the basis of the permanent settlement, the government thus expressly declares, that “It being the duty of the ruling power to protect all classes of people, and more particularly those who from their situation are most helpless, the Governor-general in council will, whenever he may deem it proper, enact such regulations as he may think necessary, for the protection and welfare of the dependant Talookdars, Ryots, and other cultivators of the soil; and no Zamindar, independent Talookdar, or other actual proprietor of land, shall be entitled on this account to make any objection to the discharge of the fixed assessment which they have respectively agreed to pay."
17. And again in Reg. viii. of 1793 (Sec. 60. Art. 2.), the government recognized the principle of the cultivators of the lands attached to their own village (Khud-kasht Ryots) having a permanent right to retain possession thereof at a fixed rent, and enacted that their title-deeds (Pattāhs) should not be set aside, except in certain specified cases, applicable to that period of general settlement, and not extending to forty years afterwards.
18. I regret to say that in some parts of these provinces the rent is already raised so high, that even an interdict against further encrease cannot afford the Ryots (cultivators) any relief or comfort; consequently, the government might endeavour to raise part of its revenue by taxes on luxuries, and such articles of use and consumption as are not necessaries of life, and make a proportionate deduction in the rents of the cultivators, and in the revenues of the Zamindars to whom their lands belong.
19. Failing this, the same desirable object may be accomplished by reducing the revenue establishment in the following manner :— Under the former government, the natives of the country, particularly Hindoos, were exclusively employed in the revenue department in all situations, and they are still so almost exclusively under the present system. The collectors being covenanted European servants of the Company, are employed as superintendants, at a salary of a thousand or fifteen hundred rupees (100 to 150l.) per mensem. The duties, however, are chiefly performed by the native officers, as they are not of such importance or difficulty as the duties attached to the judicial department, in which one slip might at once destroy the life of the innocent, or alter the just destination of property for a hundred generations.
20. The principal duties attached to the situation of Collector are as follows : 1st. The receipt of the revenue by instalments according to the assessment, and remitting the amount thus collected to the General Treasury; or to one of the commanding officers; or to the Commercial Resident, or Salt Agent, as directed by the Accountant General. 2nd. Advertising and selling the estates of defaulters to realize arrears. 3rd. Taking care of his own treasury (to prevent any mismanagement of it,) and the revenue records. 4th. Making partitions of estates, when joint sharers thereof apply to him for such division.
5th. Preparing a quinquennial register of the estates paying revenue within his collectorship. 6th. Ascertaining what tax-free land has been in the possession of individuals without a valid title. 7th. Furnishing the judicial authorities with official papers required by them, and executing their decrees concerning lands &c. 8th. Deciding cases which the judicial officer has it in his option to refer to the collector. 9th. Officiating as local postmaster under the authority of the post-master-general. 10th. Assessing duties on the venders of liquors and drugs with the concurrence of the magistrate, and collecting the duties payable thereon (receiving five per cent. on the amount of collection for his trouble). 11th. Giving out stampt papers to native venders, and he being responsible for the same, ten per cent., I think, on the sum realized is allowed him for his trouble and responsibility. (The two latter articles produce to the collector an additional monthly income of from not less than 200 to 1000 rupees a month, according to the greater or smaller sale in different districts.) 12th. Regulating the conduct of the native sub-collectors, assessors and surveyors, employed on the estates under the immediate management of government. 13th. Transmitting monthly and annually reports and accounts to the accountant-general and the civil auditor, and corresponding with the Board of of Revenue on the various affairs of his collectorship as well as obeying their instructions.
21. A native of respectability at a salary of about 300 or 400 rupees per month may be appointed in lieu of the European collector, and he should give sureties for his character and responsibility to such amount as government may deem adequate. The large sum that may thus be saved by dispensing with the collectors would not only enable government to give some relief to the unfortunate Ryots above referred to by reducing their rents, but also raise the character of the natives and render them attached to the existing government and active in the discharge of their public duties, knowing that under such a system the faithful and industrious native servant would receive the merit, and ultimately the full reward of his services; whereas under the present system the credit or discredit is attributed to the European head of the department; while the natives who are the real managers of the business are entirely overlooked and neglected, and consequently they seem most of them to be rendered quite indifferent to any thing but their own temporary interest.
22. With respect to the expediency and advantage of appointing native revenue officers to the higher situations in the revenue department, I am strongly supported by the opinions of persons whose sentiments have great weight with the governing party as well as with the party governed. I can safely quote the remarks of many distinguished servants of the Honourable East India Company, such as Sir Thomas Munro, Mr. Robert Rickards, Mr. H. Ellis, and others.
23. The native collectors should be under the immediate and strict controul of the Board of Revenue as the European collectors at present are, and should be made strictly responsible for every act performed in their official capacity. No one should be removed from his situation unless on proof of misconduct regularly established to the satisfaction of government on the report of the Board of Revenue.
24. For the present, perhaps, it would be proper to transfer the duty of selling the property of defaulting landholders to the registers; and the judges, instead of referring causes to the revenue officers, should submit them to the Sudder Ameens (or native commissioners already appointed to decide causes under a certain amount.)
25. In order to prevent the exercise of any undue influence or bribery in obtaining the situation of native collectors of revenue, it is requisite that all the present Serishtadars or head native officers attached to the different collectorships, should each be confirmed, at once, in the situation of collector, and in case of his death or removal, the next in rank should succeed him. In the same manner those under them should be each promoted regularly in succession according to his rank in the revenue department, unless incapacitated from being unable to produce the requisit esecurity, or from other evident disqualification. And no one should be allowed to hold the situation of collector unless he had been at least ten years in the revenue service.
26. The present collectors may be transferred, if found qualified, to the judicial or some other department, or allowed to retire on suitable pensions. Besides, the Board of Revenue, who should exercise a constant superintendance over the revenue branch, there should be six or eight European civil servants of the company, who stand high in the estimation of government, appointed under the denomination of circuit collectors, to examine personally, from time to time, the records kept, and the proceedings held by the native collectors.
27. At all events I must conclude with beseeching any and every authority to devise some mode of alleviating the present miseries of the agricultural peasantry of India, and thus discharge their duty to their fellow-creatures and fellow-subjects
London, August 19, 1831.