The first-known attempt at a record of the revenue, population, produce, or similar statistics of any considerable portion of India was made, during the latter half of the sixteenth century, by Akbar, and the inquiries he then set on foot may be said to constitute the earliest step towards the formulation of geographical knowledge in India. He divided his territories into twelve sūbahs or provinces, which practically included the whole of India north of a line drawn from Calcutta to Bombay, with the addition of Kābul, while later conquests added three more sūbahs in the Deccan. The boundaries and extent of these provinces were laid down with as much accuracy as was consistent with the vague standards of measurement then available. Akbar, while giving fairly concise descriptions of the boundaries of his sūbahs, did not embody them in the form of a map, but caused them to be recorded in writing, together with full statistical details of their resources, and these particulars may be found in the Ain-i-Akbarī. To the sea captains of the East India Company, those ‘noted seamen of Wapping,’ are due the earliest plotted and recorded surveys of India. Their work naturally took the form of coastwise charts, or ‘plotts,’ as they termed them, around their chief ports of call, such as Surat and others on the Malabar coast, and the earliest examples thereof date from the first decade of the seventeenth century. Unfortunately most of the log-books of voyages prior to 1855 were either burnt in Calcutta about that year, or were similarly destroyed in 1860 at the India Office, so little light can now be thrown on the work of the gallant seamen of those early days, though the Hakluyt Society has preserved certain portions from oblivion1.
The earliest attempt at a modern and accurate map of India was that of the French geographer D’Anville, who, in 1751–2, compressed into that form all the available knowledge of the time, whether derived from the routes of travellers or from rough coast charts. In this map he also incorporated the work of certain Lāmas between China and Tibet and around the sources of the Ganges, as well as the information derived from early travels of the eighteenth century in those parts. Major James Rennell, who had served under Clive, made a further advance both by his personal exertions in surveying, continued until 1782, and by the publication of his Memoir of a Map of Hindoostan, which first appeared in 1788. His Bengal Atlas, based on his own work, was published in 1781, on the scale of five miles to the inch, covering an area of about 27,000 square miles in Bengal, Bihār, and the Upper Provinces. The value of this map is now only historical, but his large-scale surveys of the Ganges and Brahmaputra are still of interest as showing the changes which have taken place in the courses of those rivers. The method of surveying adopted by Rennell was to fix the positions of a considerable number of stations by astronomical observations for latitude and longitude, and to measure the intervening distances with the chain or with the ‘measuring-wheel.’ The correct determination of longitudes was his chief difficulty; and although he utilized the results of the work of several independent observers at Madras, Calcutta, and elsewhere, his maps, judged by later standards, can only be considered as approximations to accurate cartography. Rennell was certainly the ‘Father of Indian Geography,’ and his Memoir is a laborious attempt to reconcile a vast array of conflicting geographical data. His field-work was continued in Madras, the Deccan, and Western India by his assistants and successors, Colonels Call, Pearse, Wood, and Reynolds. As materials accumulated, attempts were twice made to compile a general map of India. In 1787 Colonel Call of Madras had nearly completed such an atlas in twenty sheets, but returning home in 1788, he died soon after, and his map was lost. Colonel Reynolds of Bombay completed and sent home a Great Map of India, in 1798. It was never published, and was, presumably, destroyed on the dissolution of the East India Company.
But at the end of the eighteenth century a man was found in India destined to revolutionize the survey methods then in vogue and to place them on a scientific basis. This was William Lambton—then Captain in the 33rd Regiment, commanded by Colonel Arthur Wellesley, afterwards Duke of Wellington —who had studied mathematics under Charles Hutton. Towards the close of 1799, Lambton, with the approval of his commanding officer, submitted a project for a geographical survey of Southern India to the Governor of Madras. In the following year a more definite scheme was called for, and Lambton's reply is the earliest document in the records of the Trigonometrical Branch of the Survey of India. In this letter he points out the fallacy of the systems of survey then followed in India, which ignored the curvature and form of the earth. He advocates the measurement of a base-line as a ‘datum’; triangulation and its correct computation; measurements to determine the length of a degree on the meridian and perpendicular; and he refers to pendulum experiments and Newton's investigations regarding the figure of the earth. He proposes to carry out his work with a view to the requirements of geodesy, and to follow the method adopted in the English Ordnance Survey which had been commenced by General Roy in 1784. Lambton's project was favourably received, and he commenced work in 1800, the instruments available being a steel measuring-chain of 100 feet divided into forty links of 2½ feet each, a 5-foot zenith sector, and a transit instrument by Troughton. The first base of 7·43 miles was measured near Bangalore with the chain; and for the next two years Lambton was employed in fixing, by triangulation, a large number of points in Mysore, to serve as a basis for the topographical survey then in progress under Colonel Colin Mackenzie. April 10, 1802, is the date of the actual commencement of the Great Trigonometrical Survey of India, when Lambton, with new instruments, including a 36-inch theodolite, started the measurement of a base-line near Madras for the determination of the length of an arc of meridian. Between 1800 and 1823 Lambton was continuously employed, practically single-handed, on triangulation; and during that period he threw a network of triangles, verified by several chain-measured base-lines, over the Peninsula south of latitude 18° N., omitting the plains of Tanjore. He also carried a chain of principal triangulation, approximately along the meridian 78° E. from Cape Comorin to near Ellichpur, through thirteen degrees of latitude; and this chain, which now extends through twenty-two degrees of latitude from Cape Comorin to the Himālayas, is known as the Great Arc Series. Lambton's series of triangles along the parallel 13° N., from Mangalore to Madras, was the first attempt at a longitudinal arc. By its means he detected an error of 40 miles in the breadth of that part of the Peninsula as laid down by Rennell, and found great inaccuracies in the positions of the chief towns.
In 1818 the Trigonometrical Survey, which had up to that date been under the Madras Government, was transferred to the immediate control of the Governor-General, and the records and plans were removed from Madras to Calcutta. Colonel Lambton died in 1823, aged sixty-seven, at Hinganghāt, 50 miles from Nāgpur, engaged to the last on the prosecution of the great work he had initiated. His death marks the close of the first period of the Trigonometrical Survey, as his work has little in common with subsequent operations. For geodetic purposes it has shared the fate of similar contemporaneous operations in Europe, since all the measurements have had to be revised as instruments and methods improved; but for geographical requirements, as bases for topographical and other surveys, it is still, and will remain, most valuable.
Lambton was succeeded in the charge of the Great Trigonometrical Survey by Captain (afterwards Sir) George Everest of the Bengal Artillery. In 1830 Captain Everest, who had spent five years in England studying the best methods of prosecuting the survey, returned to India, bringing with him new instruments of the latest pattern and Colby compensation bars for the measurement of base-lines. The greater portion of the principal triangulation in India proper has been carried out with the 36-inch and 24-inch theodolites then procured, and the ten verificatory base-lines have been measured with the Colby apparatus. Lambton had proposed to cover India with a network of triangulation, utilizing the Great Arc Series for geodetic measurements, but Everest, in 1830, recommended the substitution of the ‘gridiron’ system. This, briefly, consists of meridional and longitudinal chains of triangles, the former at intervals of one degree apart, the latter following the parallels of Calcutta, Bombay, and Madras across India. The external chains or series were to follow the coast-line and the British frontiers. The whole of this triangulation in India proper rests on ten base-lines, of which five are in the Great Arc Series and the others at Karāchi, Attock, Sonakhoda (near Jalpaigurī), Calcutta, and Vizagapatam. The standards of length with which the Colby bars were compared during the measurement of the base-lines, were two 10-feet iron standards, a standard steel foot, and two 6-inch brass scales. One of these iron standards was employed at the measurement of all ten base-lines between 1832 and 1869, while the other has been compared with the Ordnance Survey standard in England and with several continental standards of length. Everest's programme of operations, based on the ‘gridiron’ system, received the approval of the Government of India and the Court of Directors, and its main principles have been followed in all subsequent operations of the great Trigonometrical Survey. Everest further completed the Great Arc Series, closing it on the Dehra Dūn base by continuing the main triangulation northwards from the point near Ellichpur to which Colonel Lambton had brought it. He likewise completed the Bombay Longitudinal Series, and revised a considerable portion of Lambton’s work on the Great Arc, remeasuring the bases. The design and partial completion of the meridional series of the ‘gridiron’ in Bengal and Bihār are also due to him.
Sir Andrew Waugh, who became Surveyor-General and Superintendent of the Trigonometrical Survey in 1843, on the retirement of Sir G. Everest, designed a great quadrilateral figure of chains of triangulation, which was to enclose and intersect the lately-conquered territory of the Punjab. It was between the years 1845 and 1850, while the main chain of triangles which runs along the base of the Himālayas from Dehra Dūn to Jalpaigurī was in progress, that the correct heights of the main Himālayan peaks were determined. Rennell, in his Memoir, notices their great elevation, but the first attempts to measure them were those of Colonel Crawford (Surveyor-General in 1814–6) while in Nepāl in 1802, and again in 1805, during the course of a route-survey from Bihār to Rohilkhand.
General J. T. Walker succeeded Sir Andrew Waugh as Superintendent of the Trigonometrical Survey in 1861, when the two offices held by the latter were separated, and Colonel H. L. Thuillier was appointed Surveyor-General. Under the guidance of Walker the geodetic work of Lambton and Everest was widely expanded. The Vizagapatam, Bangalore, and Cape Comorin base-lines were remeasured, while portions of the Great Arc and of the Calcutta-Karāchi Longitudinal Arc were revised. The execution of sixteen principal series of the ‘gridiron,’ and the complete revision of the Great Arc, saw the practical close of main triangulation in India proper, and supplied fresh data for determining the figure of the earth. The deduction of the work as a whole entailed the most elaborate calculations that have ever been undertaken in geodesy. The time had arrived for determining the procedure by which the fallible values of the several angles and base-lines, as obtained by actual measurement on the ground, were to be rendered consistent; and final values had to be determined for the lengths and azimuths of the sides of the triangles, and also for the latitudes and longitudes of the stations. The chains divide the triangulation into five sections, four of which (two on either side of the Great Arc) may be termed quadrilaterals, the fifth in the South being trilateral. At the corners of the quadrilaterals and apex of the trilateral figure are the base-lines. The four quadrilaterals meet at Kaliānpur, in Central India, on the Great Arc, in approximate lat. 24° N. long. 78° E. This point was employed by Everest as the central or reference station of the triangulation1; and hence the quadrilaterals are distinguished as North-east, South-east, North-west, and South-west, from the corresponding cardinal points, the trilateral figure being known as the Southern Trigon. Walker decided to treat the reduction of these figures separately, commencing with the North-west quadrilateral, since it was not considered possible, from the extent of the operations, to reduce the whole work in one mass as theoretically required. The reductions were commenced under Walker in 1869, and completed for the five figures in 1890. Their results are embodied in the volumes of the Account of the Operations of the Great Trigonometrical Survey of India. Nine of these volumes were published by General Walker, containing full reports of the nature and general procedure of the survey, descriptions of all the instruments employed, complete details of the actual facts of observation and methods of reduction, and the results arrived at after the final reduction of the operations. General Walker was also largely responsible for the initiation of the Pendulum, Longitude, Tidal, and Levelling Operations, and in 1873 he brought out a map of Turkistān and Central Asia compiled from every available source. At the time of his retirement in 1883, the principal triangulation had been extended down the coast of Burma, and an eleventh base-line measured at Mergui. It may here be noted that the difference between the measured length of this base-line, and its length as computed through nearly 1,000 linear miles of triangulation, amounted to only 3·4 inches. The main triangulation is now being carried on in Burma, but the large 36-inch theodolites have given place to lighter and more modern 12-inch instruments, while for the measurement of base-lines the Colby bars will probably be replaced by the apparatus devised by M. Jäderin. By this method distances are measured with a fine nickel-steel wire, which suffers practically no expansion or contraction under varying temperatures.
A brief description may be given here of the general methods adopted in carrying on the Great Trigonometrical Survey. For the principal triangulation the 36-inch or 24-inch theodolites were used, and the stations of observation were made as solid and permanent as possible. On hills they were generally masonry or brick platforms surrounding, but detached from, a central pillar on which the instrument rested. In the plains the stations at first took the form of brick towers from 20 to 60 feet in height with a central isolated core or pillar. Mark-stones, engraved with a minute dot inside a small circle, were placed on the ground-level and on the top of the central pillar, vertically above one another; but after 1852 the towers were made hollow and only a mark-stone at ground-level was embedded. During Lambton's time, the objects marking the stations were opaque, such as flags or poles, and he invariably carried out his angular observations in the daytime and during the rainy season owing to the greater clearness of the atmosphere at that period. Everest introduced the system of observing at night to lamps, and during the day to heliostats, and changed the season for field-work to the cold weather. These methods have since been invariably followed. A careful preliminary triangulation, known as the approximate series, with a smaller instrument invariably precedes the advent of the great theodolite; and by its means the positions of stations are determined, towers built if necessary, and everything prepared for the final rigorous determination of the angles. In addition to the principal chains of triangulation, others, known as secondary series, were largely employed: they were executed with smaller instruments, and started from one side of a principal triangle of a series, closing on another, possibly of a different series. Their stations, and the large number of subsidiary points fixed therefrom, served as a basis for topographical and revenue surveys.
The principal operations of the Great Trigonometrical Survey have, from their commencement, furnished data for investigating the figure of the earth, and the results have proved of the greatest value, as they have been obtained within parallels of latitude which are much nearer to the equator than those within which any other geodetic operations have been undertaken in other parts of the globe with the exception of the small arc in Peru. The earliest operations of a geodetic nature in India were Lambton's and Everest's, and these were necessarily meridional, owing to the difficulty of determining the longitude instrumentally with sufficient accuracy. For measurements of the meridian it was necessary to determine only the correct latitudes of the terminal stations, an operation which can be carried out with the greatest accuracy. It is needless to describe in detail the various instruments employed, beginning with Ramsden's original zenith sector and ending with the present-day zenith telescope, as all these are designed for the same purpose, namely, the determination of the absolute zenith distance of a star. The success of such operations depends either on a plumb-line or on a level. Herein lies their weakness, for the plumb-line is attracted by mountain masses, and it is therefore practically impossible to determine an absolute latitude. To avoid, as far as possible, this cause of uncertainty, the latitude observations in the neighbourhood of the Himālayas were, until recent years, left out of any discussion on the figure of the earth; but recent investigations have shown that this is a mistaken policy, and at the present day latitude observations are being carried into the heart of those mountains.
The advent of the electric telegraph allowed of the measurement of differential longitudes between certain stations of the survey which contribute determinations of a number of longitudinal arcs to supplement and combine with the meridional arcs. The general procedure for the determination of differences of longitude by telegraph is as follows: An observer is employed at each of two stations connected by wire. Each observer, provided with a transit telescope, a chronograph with accompanying electrical apparatus, and an astronomical clock, first makes the most accurate determination possible of the error of his clock. Then at certain times (both observers working in concert) they determine, by means of electric signals transmitted between the stations, the absolute differences between their clocks at a given instant; thus the difference of longitude between the stations, or the 'arc of longitude,' becomes known. The system adopted by General Walker was to select three stations of the main triangulation—A, B, C— near the telegraph, and so placed as to form a symmetrical triangle. After measuring the arcs CA and AB, the arc CB was measured independently as a check. In this way, a network of fairly symmetrical longitude triangles has been thrown over India; and in 1894–6 the arc Madras-Greenwich was measured through Karāchi, Bushire, Teherān, and Potsdam, thus giving a final value to the longitude of Madras. The previous value, depending mainly on astronomical observations, was found to be about two and a half minutes of arc in error, which had the effect of placing India nearly three miles too far from Greenwich.
With a view to determining as accurately as possible the latitudes, longitudes, and azimuths of the stations of any system of triangulation, it is necessary that the polar and equatorial axes of the terrestrial spheroid should be correctly known, while a certain ratio must be adopted for its ellipticity. This last may be determined by observing the pendulum. As the force of gravity increases from the equator to the poles, a pendulum which makes a given number of vibrations in a given time at the equator will make a greater number as the latitude increases. The operation consists in determining the number of vibrations which a given pendulum makes in twenty-four hours at selected stations. Previous experiments had been made near the coast or on islands, and it was desirable that they should be continued in the interior of a continent. These operations were initiated by Captain Basevi, R.E., of the Trigonometrical Survey, in 1865, and during the course of the next five years he continued them at a large number of stations all over India, nineteen of them being on the Great Arc. He sacrificed his life in the cause of science, dying of exposure (1871) while engaged in continuing his observations in high latitudes on the Tibet frontier. One result of these experiments was to prove that the density of the strata of the earth’s crust under and near the Himālayas is less than that under the plains, and another that the force of gravity appears to be in defect at inland stations as compared with coast stations in similar latitudes.
In 1856 Sir A. Waugh instituted a series of spirit-levelling operations with a view to determining the heights of the terminal stations of the interior base-lines directly from sea-level. These, as well as the heights of the stations of the principal triangulation, had been measured by vertical observations with the large theodolite, and had been referred to Lambton’s datum, the sea-level at Madras, but owing to the length of the chains of triangles a check was necessary. The earliest spirit-levelling work, about 1860, was the connexion of the Attock, Dehra Dūn, and Sironj (Central India) base-lines with the sea-level at Karāchi1. Since then lines of levels have
| At Attock | 3 ft. 2 inches. |
| „ Dehra | 5 ft. 1 inch. |
| „ Sironj | 2 ft. 1 inch. |
been carried along the principal railways and roads over the greater portion of the peninsula, and are still in progress, affording a vast number of accurately determined heights which are of the greatest value to canal, road, and railway engineers. Levelling work has of late years been combined with tidal operations. Tidal observations had previously been taken at Kidderpore dockyard (Calcutta) from 1806 to 1827, in Bombay harbour from 1832, and at Karāchi from 1857 until 1865 ; but the first systematic record of their results dates from 1874. Such work, while enabling a datum level to be fixed for survey purposes and aiding navigation, is also of great scientific interest. The results of the Indian observations were largely used by Professor Darwin in his numerical estimate of the rigidity of the earth. The tidal stations extend completely around the coasts of Burma and India and up to the Red Sea1.
The Magnetic Survey of India and Burma, now being undertaken, was initiated by Professor Rücker, F.R.S., through the Royal Society in 1897. The work was commenced in 1901, and will be completed about 1907. Observations of dip, declination, and horizontal force are being taken at stations which are, on an average, forty miles apart, while self-recording magnetographs are being established at Dehra Dūn, Barrackpore, Rangoon, and Kodaikānal, and the Magnetic Observatory at Colāba is co-operating. In addition, the secular change will be studied at some twenty-five stations symmetrically situated.
Prior to the year 1800, topographical work was as a rule confined to the results of road and route sketches of the roughest description, though Rennell had produced a detailed survey of the Ganges and Brahmaputra rivers. Early in the nineteenth century Colonel Colin Mackenzie introduced, in Southern India, a system of detailed topographical survey, based on a triangulation of some sort ; and while Lambton was engaged on his work in Madras, Mackenzie had independently measured bases in Mysore and connected them by triangulation. Mackenzie's labours resulted in a topographical survey on the 1-inch scale of over 40,000 square miles in Mysore and the adjacent districts, and it was on this survey that the plane-table was first employed in India. Its form, however, and method of use differed materially from those now in vogue.
The present shape and methods of employing the plane-table were initiated by Captain D. Robinson of the Topographical Survey in 1860. The invention of the plane-table is ascribed to Pretorius, in 1537; but the first published description appears to be that of Leonhard Zubler, in 1625, who ascribes the ‘beginning’ of the instrument to one Eberhart, a stone-mason1. This instrument in its rougher form (practically a drawingboard 30 inches by 24, connected to a tripod stand by a clamping screw) has been employed for the insertion of all topographical detail on the Indian surveys. A ruler 30 inches long with upright sights, a clinometer for measuring angles of elevation or depression and thus determining the relative height of each ‘fixing’ of the table, and a pencil are the only instruments used with it. In America, and elsewhere, its form has been greatly elaborated, and it is even employed for triangulation, but in India it has never been allowed to trench on the legitimate use of the theodolite. From the period of the early Madras surveys until 1860 it was a smaller instrument, 16 inches square, and the principles of interpolation and intersection as introduced by Robinson were not known, nor were the capabilities of the instrument fully developed or understood.
The earliest surveys were generally accompanied by ‘Memoirs,’ heavy volumes which contained a mass of details, statistical, historical, and descriptive, for the area embraced in the map. By 1820 full materials for a map of the Peninsula south of the Kistna river, based chiefly on Lambton’s trigonometrical survey, were available. In Bombay, route surveys by compass and ‘perambulator’ (measuring-wheel) were carried out, between 1813 and 1820, in Gujarāt, Cutch, and Kāthiāwār, and in portions of the Deccan, but none of this work was based on triangulation. In Northern India the question of the sources of the Ganges led, in 1808, to a careful survey of that river, in continuation of former work, from Hardwār to near Gangotrī. The only knowledge available, at that time, of the Upper Himālayas and of Tibet was derived, through the Jesuit missionaries, from Chinese sources and the travels of Lāmas. This information, embodied in the maps of D’Anville and Rennell, remained the only authority until the journeys of the native explorers, the first of whom were trained and sent out by Captain Montgomerie of the Great Trigonometrical Survey in 1861. The breaking out of the Burmese War in 1824 led to the acquisition of much valuable geographical knowledge, which was not materially improved in the north of the Province until after the annexation of Upper Burma sixty years later.
The Court of Directors determined in the year 1823 on the publication of a complete Indian Atlas, and, when the plan of a general survey was under discussion, invited the opinion of the veteran geographer Rennell as to the most suitable basis and form thereof. He advocated a continuance of the old method, i.e. the astronomical determinations of latitudes and longitudes at selected spots and the insertion of detail by compass and measuring-wheel. Fortunately for the Indian surveys this view was not upheld, and Lambton's triangulation was selected as the framework on which all future topographical and revenue surveys were to be based. Major Rennell subsequently changed his views and agreed to the trigonometrical basis of survey work.
Up to 1830 the prosecution of topographical surveys in India was, save in Madras, desultory and spasmodic. There was no definite organization or combination between the different Presidencies; and, although in that year Sir G. Everest combined the appointments of Surveyor-General and head of the Trigonometrical Survey, the absorbing nature of the more exact description of work somewhat militated against the progress of topographical operations for the next thirteen years. The period of Sir A. Waugh's administration of the combined offices (1843–61) marks a great advance in this respect. The revenue surveys, too, of that period, which were all connected with the Great Trigonometrical Survey and based on a more rigorous system of traversing initiated by Major Thuillier, very nearly approached topographical work in the results of their final mapping. The ideal revenue survey should be one which, executed throughout on accurate principles and supplying complete information for settlement purposes, should also furnish materials for the compilation of general or topographical maps. Unfortunately, the earlier revenue surveys were conducted on varying principles in different parts of India and did not comply with this standard. The early topographical surveys were carried out in the Native States and the non-regulation British Provinces, and were confined to hilly or broken ground where the chain was useless, while the revenue surveys on larger scales were extended over the richer lands of the plains. Such topographical surveys, based on or extended from the main series of triangulation, were those of the Nizām's Dominions (1816–56), of Ganjām and Orissa (1853–77), of Kashmīr (1855–64), of the Punjab Salt Range (1851–59), and of the Simla Hill States (1847–54), which last was carried on as the main triangulation progressed. Though the standard scale of the topographical survey maps is 1 inch to the mile, the areas above mentioned were mainly surveyed on the ½-inch scale, while in British territory the scale is at times increased to 2 inches to the mile, and to 4 inches for forest surveys. The scales of the revenue and cadastral surveys vary between 4, 16, and 32 inches to the mile, the 16-inch scale being generally adopted.
It is not necessary to attempt, nor will space allow, a detailed description of the progress of topographical surveys over the 2 million square miles of India. A short account of the methods of work and organization of a topographical survey party, with examples of surveys carried out over mountainous and forest-clad tracts, may however prove of interest. The initial elements given for each topographical survey station are its latitude, longitude, height of ground above sea-level, and height of platform or tower. Moreover, the lengths of the sides of every triangle are given in miles and feet; the logvalue of distance in feet is also given, as well as the mutual azimuths or true-bearings of the stations from each other, and of all other stations visible therefrom. These details are to be found in the Synoptical Volumes prepared for each series or chain of triangles. A topographical party consists of one or more triangulators, with computers, draftsmen, and several plane-tablers. The triangulator, basing his work on the initial elements of the Great Trigonometrical Survey, after a preliminary reconnaissance for the selection of his stations of observation and intersected points, throws a network of triangles over the ground to be surveyed, thus providing a large number of fixed points, with their heights, from which the plane-tablers fill in all topographical details. Various styles have been adopted in the Indian surveys for the representation of mountainous and hilly ground. On the smaller scales vertical or horizontal hill-shading, or ‘hachuring,’ is employed; and on the larger scales contouring, based on a number of heights determined by the clinometer at each fixing of the plane-table, the vertical distances of the contours varying with the scale. In the earlier surveys, such as those of the Salt Range or Kashmīr, the hill features were shown, in an artistic and realistic manner, by means of ‘brush-shading’ in Indian ink; but on the introduction of photozincography for map reproduction in 1866 this method was discontinued, as the brush-work could not be reproduced by photography. Now all hills are represented by pen lines whether the detail be contoured or hill-shaded.
The earlier topographical parties (1850–80) consisted of an officer in charge, one or two military assistants, and a dozen or so European, and one or two native, surveyors. The introduction of the native element into such parties has been of gradual growth. At the period now mentioned the triangulation and its computation were usually carried out by the officer in charge or by his military or civil assistants, the plane-tabling and fair-mapping being entirely the work of the European surveyors. But the number of native surveyors was gradually increased; and the present organization of a topographical party may be described as one officer in charge, one or two junior military officers, four or five officers of the Provincial service1, and twenty to thirty native sub-surveyors, who are traversers, plane-tablers, and draftsmen. The duties have correspondingly changed, the triangulation being now carried out by an officer of the Provincial service, while the time of the officer in charge is wholly occupied in testing and checking the work of the plane-tablers, in which work the officers of the Imperial and Provincial service also assist, each of the latter having charge of a detachment of plane-tablers.
In early days the parties usually assembled at Dehra Dūn, and thence marched the whole way to the district allotted for survey. A typical case may be taken of a party ‘recessing’ at Mussoorie, whose work lay in Rājputāna, on or near the Arāvalli hills. Towards the end of September it would assemble at Dehra, and, after collecting its transport of two or three elephants and seventy to eighty camels, would start on its two months’ journey. The early mornings were devoted to the day’s march and the subsequent hours would be utilized for regular office work, when the computations (purposely left incomplete) of the previous season’s triangulation were finished, boards projected and plotted, and all details prepared for field-work. In November field-work would be commenced, and carried on until early April, when the scattered members of the party met again for the long hot march back to the hills, which they reached towards the end of May. Nowadays the railway usually conveys a party from its ‘recess’ quarters, where results are worked out during the hot weather, to the sphere of its field operations.
The Kashmīr survey affords a good illustration of work carried on at high altitudes. It was entrusted to a young officer, Lieutenant T. Montgomerie, R.E., who, in 1855, with two assistants, commenced the main triangulation from the edge of the hills near Siālkot, observing with a 14-inch theodolite. From the outset the greatest physical difficulties were encountered ; some of the first stations on the Pīr Panjāl were at an elevation of 13,000 to 15,000 feet, and this altitude increased as the work progressed northward. During one season the average height of the stations exceeded 17,000 feet ; and it was frequently necessary for the observers to remain for days together at these great altitudes, waiting for the cessation of violent snow-storms or the clearing away of fog and mist, while all supplies and fuel had to be brought up from far below. With Montgomerie were associated several civil assistants and some officers of the Quartermaster-General's department, who carried on the detail survey with the plane-table, on the 1/2 inch to the mile scale, as the triangulation progressed. In five years the triangulation had been extended over 93,000 square miles and the map of the Kashmīr valley completed. The greatest height at which the theodolite was set up was 20,866 feet, though a mark was erected on, and luminous signals read from, a point at 21,480 feet, while the highest point fixed by the triangulation was K2 (Mount Godwin Austen), 28,290 feet above sea-level. The plane-tabler just reached the height of 22,000 feet, and the native khalāsi who carried the instrument must have ascended to that altitude with a load of 18 lb. on his back. The survey was completed in 1864, by which time the triangulation had covered an area of over 110,000 square miles, and the detail survey about 92,000 square miles, of the highest, most rugged, and most desolate mountains on the face of the globe. The work had been extended over the Karakoram range to lat. 37° N. and included the Pangong Lake and the Changchenmo Valley. It is noteworthy that this survey was carried on, without cessation, during the troubled period of the Mutiny.
Mention may be made of another topographical survey, in progress from 1853 until 1877, which for nearly twenty years was superintended by a single man—Colonel Saxton. The scene of his labours lay in the deadly jungle-covered tracts from Chotā Nāgpur to the Godāvari, and embraces the Ganjām and Vizagapatam Agencies, and a portion of the Central Provinces with Bastar, Jeypore, and their dependencies, an area of over 70,000 square miles. The history of this survey is one continuous tale of sickness and death due to fever, and of active opposition to its progress by the wild tribes who inhabit that area. Of the many persons employed on it Colonel Saxton alone appears to have passed, though not unscathed, through the long ordeal. The season for field-work was limited, owing to the unhealthy nature of the country, to less than four months in the year, and but little relief was obtained from the move to ‘recess’ quarters, which, until 1886, were invariably established at coast ports on the Bay of Bengal. In 1862, in a review of nine years’ work, Saxton gives the names of seventeen European assistants or surveyors who had taken part in it; and of these seven are reported as having died, while eight had been transferred, chiefly owing to sickness.
These two topographical surveys may, however, be considered as extreme examples of the difficulties which attend the surveyor’s life. Between them lie many a pleasant record and experience of work performed under ideal conditions of country, climate, and scenery. Such are the surveys in Bombay, Rājputāna, Mālwā, and Central India, and among the outer Himālayas. The life of a surveyor, though solitary, affords, in its intervals of leisure, varied opportunities to the artist, the archaeologist, and the sportsman, and leads him into tracts of country rarely visited by Europeans.
During the last thirty years topographical surveys have been pushed on throughout India, more especially in Burma; and now, with the exception of portions of the latter Province and certain tracts in Madras, there is hardly any part of the Indian empire which has not been topographically mapped. Unfortunately no provision was made for keeping the older maps up to date, and in consequence there are very considerable areas in which these have become practically obsolete.
The need for accurate topographical maps of the areas which came under reservation as forests had been felt as the organization of the Forest department extended over India, and in 1872 a special Forest Survey branch was constituted. The surveys were mainly carried out on a topographical basis, and subsequently some regular parties of the Survey of India were employed on similar work in the Central Provinces, and in the Madras and Bombay Presidencies. In October, 1900, the Forest Survey branch was amalgamated with the Survey of India, and an officer of the latter department was placed in charge of the entire work. The forest surveys will probably be completed by the end of 1906 in India proper; but for Burma a considerably longer period will be required, as the total area of forest reservation in that Province is not yet known.
Next in order to the regular topographical surveys, based on the main triangulation and carried out by accurate plane-tabling, come those which are the results of the work of smaller survey detachments, or at times even of single officers, while attached to the numerous boundary commissions or frontier expeditions, which are of frequent occurrence in every direction beyond the borders of India. Their range may be said to extend from Nyassaland, Uganda, and Abyssinia in Africa, through Persia and Afghānistān, with a break for the greater part of Tibet and Nepāl, over the northern and eastern limits of Burma into China, since officers or subordinates of the Survey of India have at various times been employed in all these countries. With the perfection of modern instruments and a full appreciation of the powers of the plane-table, the majority of these small-scale surveys have attained a high degree of accuracy, especially when tied together by triangulation. Though the scale adopted does not admit of the delineation of intricate detail, yet for geographical purposes, or as bases for boundary demarcation, they serve their purpose well. Such surveys are invariably on smaller scales than that of 1 inch to the mile, and during their progress the surveyor is frequently called upon to utilize the various shifts and expedients that are open to him if he wishes his survey to progress with the advance of the commission or force to which he is attached. A detailed account of all such work, which may be considered as ranging in value between an accurate topographical survey and a rough geographical or exploratory sketch, would be the history of every boundary commission and military expedition that has been organized by the Government of India during the last half-century. It will suffice to take as illustrations the surveys carried out during the Afghān Wars of 1878–80, and in the course of the Afghān Boundary Commission.
During the first Afghān War a large amount of route surveying had been carried out by the old methods, but few attempts had been made to acquire any geographical knowledge of the country. Some of the route surveys were of good quality; but when they were combined large gaps were discovered, and, as usual, considerable errors were found in the longitudes assigned to the principal places. Thus Kābul and Kandahār, in the early maps, were placed seven and fifteen miles respectively west of their true position. During the Afghān War which commenced in 1878, survey officers with native assistants were attached to the various columns which penetrated into the country, and their orders were that efforts should be directed towards obtaining as much general geographical knowledge as possible, while survey work was not to be confined to the lines of communication. With this view, plane-tabling on the scale of a half or quarter inch to the mile was adopted, and triangulation was largely utilized to connect and strengthen the detail surveys. It was of course not possible in every case to keep the triangulation ahead of the detail work, owing to the rapidity of the marches; and when this occurred, dependence had to be placed on the plane-table and on traversing. The prolonged occupation of the country, and the various routes of the columns engaged, allowed of the mapping on various scales of the greater portion of area comprised in the operations. The services of the field engineers and of such staff-officers as could be spared were utilized for large-scale work and route surveys, and their results were reduced and incorporated in the general map. At the close of the war the area surveyed more or less in detail amounted, in Afghānistān and Baluchistān, to about 48,000 square miles, while an additional area of 7,000 square miles was explored by native agency.
The Commission which was engaged, in conjunction with Russian colleagues, in laying down the northern boundary of Afghānistān in 1884–6 allowed of a very considerable extension of geographical knowledge in Central Asia. The work was mainly carried out by three officers and three native surveyors of the Survey of India, subsequently assisted by officers of the Intelligence Branch. The results are noticeable in that the enormous area covered by the topography, about 110,000 square miles, was almost entirely dependent on triangulated points. The extension of this triangulation was a matter of some difficulty, as the surveyors were unable to leave the line of march when first entering the country, but the method adopted gave very satisfactory results. Briefly, this consisted in observing for latitude at every camp, and for azimuth to all peaks in the line of march, which in this case lay nearly north and south. When camping abreast of any of these peaks, their position was fixed with reference to the camp by means of a short base, with the usual observations for latitude and azimuth. The difference of longitude was thus obtained, and the work kept pace without a break with the advance, which at one period covered 310 miles in nineteen days.
The plan of training natives in the elements of surveying with a view to their employment in exploration, and for the purpose of acquiring geographical information of countries beyond the Indian frontiers into which no British officer could penetrate, originated with Captain Montgomerie while engaged on the Kashmīr survey. His idea was to employ Pathāns for explorations in the Hindu Kush, the Oxus Valley, and Turkistān, and Bhotiās or Tibetans for work in Tibet and on the borders of the Chinese Empire. These men were taught how to make and keep records of route surveys by compass and pacing, the method of observing for latitude by meridian altitudes with the sextant, and the use of the thermometer and barometer; but they were purposely not taught how to reduce their observations, nor supplied with astronomical tables, with a view to preventing any fabrication of work. The earliest journeys of this nature dated from 1861, and were made in the direction of Yārkand and in the hill ranges around Chitrāl. One Nain Sing, known as ‘the Pundit,’ who was sent on a journey into Tibet in 1864, was the first explorer to reach Lhāsa, residing there for three months; and, after an absence of over two years, he brought back to India a very large amount of information concerning the course of the great river of Tibet, the Tsan-po, which he roughly followed for 600 miles from its source. ‘The Pundit’ subsequently made several journeys into Tibet and Nepāl, of which the most important was that which occupied him in 1874 and 1875, on the vast lacustrine plateau of Tibet. He again visited Lhāsa, and continued his previous exploration down the Tsan-po. His work covered 1,200 miles of country entirely unknown before, defined the eastern limits of the Pangong Lake, and proved the existence of a system of numerous lakes and rivers, and of the vast snowy range of the Northern Himālaya. ‘The Pundit’ retired in 1875, and was subsequently rewarded with the C.I.E., a grant of land, and the gold medal of the Geographical Society. Another very adventurous journey was made by ‘A. K.,’ also a trained explorer. He was employed for over four and a half years, traversing about 3,000 miles of country in Tibet, and made determined efforts to ascertain the course of the Tsan-po beyond the point where it was last seen by ‘the Pundit.’ The most important result of this journey was to establish the fact that the Tsan-po does not flow into the Irrawaddy basin, and that it has no other possible exit than through the channel of the Dihāng into the Brahmaputra. ‘A. K.’ likewise received rewards from the Government of India, and two gold medals from Geographical Societies. Several attempts have since been made to map as much of the course of the Tsan-po as still remains unknown, a length of considerably less than 100 miles. Other journeys yielding less important results have been carried out from time to time by trained explorers over large areas on and across the north-west frontier, and the maps available for the military expeditions of the last thirty years may be said to have been based largely on the information thus obtained. On more than one occasion subordinate officers of the Survey of India have penetrated in disguise beyond the frontier, returning with valuable information. Thus M‘Nair, disguised as a hakīm, managed to cross the Malakand Pass and to traverse Lower Swāt, Dīr, and Chitrāl, reaching the Dorāh Pass in the Hindu Kush, and returning to India through Kashmīr. The map issued before the Chitrāl Expedition of 1895 was based on the information gained during the course of this adventurous journey.
The journeys in Tibet and Central Asia of such explorers as Ryder, Bower, Deasy, and Stein have, from time to time, added considerably to our geographical knowledge; and it is interesting to note that in several cases the mapping work and route surveys then executed are mainly due to the labours of native surveyors of the Survey of India whose services were temporarily lent to these travellers by the Government of India. Surveys in Africa, Siam, and China, though beyond the official scope of the Survey of India, have also been carried out by officers and subordinates of that department.
The revenue surveys, which form the basis of all settlement operations and of the entire fiscal administration of the country, were commenced as early as 1822, west of the river Jumna, in the Delhi, Pānīpat, and Rohtak Districts. Measurements were made of the boundaries of estates and villages by means of the theodolite and chain, and the work was based upon the traverse system. The topographical details on these old surveys appear to have been well-executed, but a retrograde step was introduced after a conference of surveyors held at Allahābād in 1834 by order of Lord W. Bentinck. At this conference it was decided that the maps furnished by surveyors were in future to show accurately only the boundary line of each village and its site, all topographical details such as roads, rivers, &c., being roughly sketched in. But this rough work, which preceded the Great Trigonometrical Survey and was never properly connected therewith, soon became obsolete, and by the year 1850 the greater part of it had been revised. In 1838 the ‘main circuit’ system was introduced, which completely changed the old methods of revenue surveys. Roughly speaking, the earliest system may be said to have been that of working from the less to the greater. The map of any District was the result of the fitting together of a large number of independent village boundary surveys; and in such work, if extended over any considerable area, large errors necessarily accumulated, especially if no check or tie was afforded by frequent connexions with the principal triangulation. The ‘main circuit’ system involves the running of main traverses which, connected with the triangulation, enclose areas of one hundred to two hundred square miles. These areas are then further subdivided by minor traverses which, as a rule, approximate closely to the village boundaries. The entire work is thus kept within certain clearly defined limits of error, and, where these are exceeded in either angular or linear measurements, a resurvey is necessary. This system has remained in vogue up to the present day, though the methods of filling in the interior details have varied; and when strictly followed it affords a perfectly satisfactory basis for all land measurements for settlement purposes. The effective prosecution of a revenue survey is dependent, to a very great extent, on the co-operation of the Collector or Settlement Officer of the District, who is responsible for the early demarcation of all village boundaries and the issue of the necessary orders regarding assistance to the surveyors, &c. The revenue surveys under the Government of India are divided into Upper and Lower circles, the former comprising the Punjab, the United Provinces, and Sind, the latter comprising Bengal (with Bihār and Orissa), Assam, and Burma. The Madras and Bombay Presidencies have carried out their revenue surveys with separate establishments.
The period of Colonel Thuillier’s administration of the revenue survey, which dates from 1847 and lasted for thirty years, was, as previously stated, marked by great advances in the accuracy and general utility of its results, and excellent surveys of the Punjab, Oudh, Sind, the Central Provinces, and Bengal were executed under his direction. The work in the Province of Agra had unfortunately been finished before his time; and most of the original plans of this survey, bound up in folio volumes, were destroyed during the Mutiny.
In 1876 the success of the professional surveys in Bengal came under discussion, and the Board of Revenue expressed the opinion that the surveys necessary for settlement purposes might be done at far less cost by non-professional agency. This led General Walker, who was then Surveyor-General, to prepare an elaborate statement concerning the different classes of land surveys. These were the topographical surveys on the 1-inch scale, based on triangulation and carried out with the plane-table; the village surveys on the 4-inch scale, based on traverses with details filled in by the plane-table; and the cadastral surveys on the 16-inch to the mile scale. These last were introduced in 1871; and they differed from the others in the fact that, while based on the traverses, the interior measurements were made by systematic chaining, of which full details were kept in field-books, thus providing permanent records always available for subsequent reference. General Walker expressed the opinion that cadastral surveys, though initially expensive, are really the cheapest considering the amount of information they give for topographical purposes. This system has since been followed in all revenue surveys carried out by the Survey of India.
But in several Provinces and Districts of India settlement operations have at times been based on surveys carried out by local native agency, wholly or partially independent of professional aid. Thus the settlement work in the Punjab which is now in progress, depends on large-scale surveys carried out on what is known as the 'square system.' In this the local native surveyor measures a base of 1,100 feet in each village, marking the ends by dressed stones, and from this lays out on the ground a succession of squares of similar sides, and refers the positions of all boundary marks, fields, roads, and canals determined from actual chain measurements to the sides and diagonals of corresponding squares ruled on his field-sheets. This method, which is sufficient for settlement purposes, fails when attempts are made to compile a geographical or topographical map over a considerable area by combining the surveys of a large number of villages, as it is based neither on triangulation nor on traverse, while the main topographical features are omitted by the local surveyors. In the Central Provinces also the latest settlements have been based on surveys carried out by local agency, but in this case a traverse party of the Survey of India, working on the 'main circuit' system, supplied skeleton plots of each village boundary to the local surveyors, who filled in the field measurements and other details thereon. As a result these revenue surveys can be fitted together and, after reduction of scale, combined into topographical maps of the area which they cover.
The present method of bringing the topographical maps up to date consists in utilizing, as far as possible, the cadastral surveys, and those executed by patwāris or other local agency, and the system undoubtedly costs less than would a new topographical survey. The pressing need at present over a very large part of India and Burma is revisionary survey which shall bring up to date the obsolete work, in many cases over fifty years old.
The 16-inch cadastral surveys executed by professional agency are, as a rule, sufficiently good for direct reduction to the 2-inch scale, and for the compilation of maps on that scale which may be further reduced by photography into standard, or 1-inch to the mile, topographical sheets. But all work executed by local agency alone, as in the Punjab, requires to be first connected by traverses starting from the main triangulation in untraversed Districts, or, where the traverse data of fifty years ago are still forthcoming, to be connected therewith by supplementary traversing. It requires, in short, some geodetic basis or starting-point which it does not now possess. Moreover, when the patwāris' maps are reduced and fitted together by traverse, it is still necessary for such reductions to be sent into the field again, to have the topographical details inserted thereon by means of the plane-table, many such details being invariably omitted by the patwāris.
Prior to the organization of the Madras Survey department, a topographical survey of the Presidency had been made by officers of the Quartermaster-General's department or of the Madras Military Institution. The results of that survey are embodied in twenty-three sheets of the Atlas of India. These sheets are revised from time to time in the Surveyor-General's Office, Calcutta, as the materials of later cadastral and topographical surveys become available. From the year 1858, when the revenue survey was commenced by Captain Priestley, the Madras Presidency has continued to maintain a Survey department of its own, whose work has been generally based on Colonel Lambton's triangulation and carried out on the 'main circuit' system of traversing. Of the total area of 140,000 square miles to be dealt with, more than half has up to the present date been cadastrally surveyed by the Madras Survey department, whilst 56,000 square miles have been surveyed topographically. The cadastral survey, which applies chiefly to ryotwāri villages, and in special cases to proprietary estates, is carried out on the usual scale of 16 inches to the mile, while the scale of topographical work, which includes the hilly tracts, large zamīndāris, and small proprietary estates, varies from 4 inches to half an inch to the mile. Of the area still remaining for survey, about 10,000 square miles comprising hill tracts will be topographically surveyed by the Survey of India, the balance being either surveyed cadastrally by the Madras Survey department, or included in the forest surveys.
In the Bombay Presidency, the revenue surveys date from 1836, and their original design is due to Sir George Wingate. They are not based on triangulation, and are chiefly executed with the chain and cross staff. As in Madras, they have been carried out by a local Revenue Survey department which works independently of the Survey of India. The field operations of the village surveys are conducted by native measurers, whose work is supervised and tested by a European assistant. The revenue assessment, which in Bombay has been carried out by the Survey department, is based on an elaborate system of classification of the nature, depth, and productive capability of the soil in each field, and the character of the water-supply available. The work is now finished and the Bombay Survey department has been gradually disbanded. This revenue survey, though amply fulfilling the administrative requirements of the Settlement officers, was not conducted with a view to its possible utility for the compilation of topographical maps, and hence topographical surveys of the whole of the Bombay Presidency became necessary. These were carried out, chiefly on the 1-inch scale, by several parties of the Survey of India at various periods between the years 1864 and 1896.
Rennell's Memoir of a Map of Hindoostan, published in 1788, was followed, in 1816, by Arrowsmith's map, which was also based on route surveys, comprised in nine sheets on the scale of 16 miles to the inch. In 1822 Arrowsmith published the surveys of the early topographers, whose work was based on Lambton's triangulation, in a map of eighteen sheets on the scale of four miles to the inch, containing the area between the Kistna river and Cape Comorin. About the same time the Court of Directors decided on incorporating the results of the various trigonometrical and topographical surveys into one Atlas of India, to be engraved on the scale of four miles to the inch. The work was entrusted to Arrowsmith; but he died after making the projection and publishing a few of the sheets, and Mr. J. Walker, who came of a family of engravers, was appointed to carry on the work. The projection for the sheets of the Atlas, as devised by Arrowsmith and still followed, is a modification of the conical development, in which a cone is assumed to roll over the spheroid tangentially to an adopted central parallel of latitude. The Atlas was designed to occupy 177 sheets, 40 inches by 27, and the scheme embraces the area from Karāchi to Singapore and includes Ceylon. Walker was employed in England for more than forty years on the engraving on copper and publishing of the Atlas sheets. By the time of his retirement in 1868 eighty-four of the sheets had been published, and arrangements were then made by the Surveyor-General for the continuation of the work in India. A staff of qualified engravers was recruited in England, and since 1869 the remaining sheets of the Atlas have been engraved and printed in Calcutta, new editions being brought out as materials become available from fresh surveys. The materials for a first edition of the Indian Atlas were practically complete by the year 1875, but their quality naturally varied very considerably, as even at that time several of the surveys were more or less obsolete and required revision. The work of the field parties, revenue and topographical, on various scales was at first reproduced by lithography; but in 1866 the process of photozincography was adopted, and printing offices were then established at Dehra Dūn and Calcutta, where the maps are still published. A new map of India and adjacent countries on the scale of 1 : 1,000,000, or approximately 16 miles to the inch, is in course of preparation, and its limits, extending between lat. 4° and 40° N., and long. 44° and 112° E., will far exceed those of the Indian Atlas.
The principal publications of the Indian Surveys are, however, standard sheets on the scale of 1 inch to the mile. These are complete for considerable portions of India proper, but new editions are continually brought out as materials become available from fresh surveys. A large number of these sheets, such as those of the Bombay Presidency, Mysore, and a considerable part of Burma, are reproduced from topographical surveys carried out on the 1-inch scale, while those of the Punjab, the Central Provinces, and parts of the United Provinces are compilations or reductions from the large-scale cadastral and revenue surveys.
The three Survey branches, Trigonometrical, Topographical, and Revenue, formed at different dates, were at first virtually separate departments, each with its own superintendent and distinct cadre of officers and establishment of European and native surveyors. Both Everest and Waugh, as Surveyors-General, exercised control over the Trigonometrical and a portion of the Topographical branches; but the Revenue Survey remained a distinct department, though its Superintendent supervised the work of several Topographical parties. In 1866 the Survey department received its first regular organization, when establishments were revised and uniform grades and scales of pay allotted to the three branches, which, however, still retained their own Superintendents. During the next few years the duties of the three departments began to overlap and intermingle. The Great Trigonometrical Survey was approaching its completion in India proper, and for many years a considerable proportion of its officers had been employed on purely topographical work. The Topographical Survey, though originally intended for the primary general Survey of India, had had to undertake in many cases detailed large-scale surveys; and the Revenue Survey had, in addition to its own special functions, been largely employed on the topography of hill districts on a trigonometrical basis. Accordingly, in 1878 the three branches were amalgamated under the designation of the Survey of India, whose officers were to be available for any description of survey work that might be required of them, and were all placed under the orders of the Surveyor-General.
In 1904 a Committee was appointed to report on the state of the maps in each Province, and the measures required to bring them up to date. This Committee reported in 1905. Among the more important recommendations were : (1) that the preparation of a modern map of India on the scale of 1 inch to the mile should at once be undertaken according to a definite programme, by which fifteen topographical field parties would be employed and the whole work would be completed in twenty-five years, and further that the scale of survey should generally be at least double that of publication; (2) that for the production of this map an improved process of heliozincography should be employed, a few selected standard sheets being engraved on copper; (3) that the Atlas of India sheets should be superseded by ‘degree’ sheets on the 1/4-inch scale, to be engraved on copper; (4) that, in place of the 1/16-inch Provincial maps, a general map of India on the international scale of 1 : 1,000,000 should be prepared and engraved; (5) that the staff of the Imperial Service for trigonometrical and topographical work should be increased from forty to seventy officers; (6) that, in place of the existing Provincial Service, a new Provincial Service should be established on better pay, and another Service formed intermediate between this and the present Subordinate Service, one quarter of the appointments in the former and one-half in the latter being given to natives of India; (7) that cadastral and other large-scale surveys should be left entirely under the control of Local Governments, who should provide for the expense of the work and also for the production of the maps; (8) that village boundaries should not be shown on the ordinary topographical maps, but that if these are required for administrative purposes, a special edition showing them should be issued under certain conditions; and (9) that the cost of special forest surveys, when required, should be debited to the Forest department.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Rennell's Memoir of a Map of Hindoostan (1788).
The early volumes of Asiatic Researches contain articles by Lambton on his work.
An Account of the Operations of the Great Trigonometrical Survey of India. These volumes, of which seventeen have as yet been published, contain exhaustive details of the triangulation, astronomical latitudes and longitudes, pendulum, and tidal and levelling operations.
The Synoptical Volumes of the Great Trigonometrical Survey contain full details of the data furnished by the triangulation.
The Annual Reports of the Trigonometrical, Topographical, and Revenue branches published separately until 1878, but since then combined into one volume, are records of the work of the several parties in each branch, with extracts from the narrative reports of executive officers, &c.
Geodesy, by Colonel Clarke, R.E. (Oxford, 1880). In this volume the geodetic results are discussed and combined with those of other surveys in determining the probable figure of the earth.
Rapport sur les Triangulations, by General A. Ferrero (Association Géodesique Internationale); contains tabulated results comparing the chief systems of triangulation of the world (1899).
A Memoir on the Indian Surveys, by Clements R. Markham (1871 and 1878), with continuation by C. E. D. Black (1891). These give a summary of the various operations of the surveys from their commencement up to the year 1890.
Major James Rennell, by Clements R. Markham (1895), containing an account of Rennell's work as surveyor and geographer.
Report of the Indian Survey Committee, 1904-5 (Simla, 1905).
An Account of the Scientific Work of the Survey of India, and a comparison of its progress with that of foreign surveys, by Lieut.-Col. S. G. Burrard (Calcutta, 1906).
APPENDIX
Marine Surveys
As stated on p. 481, the survey of Indian waters commenced, with coast charts, in the early days of the East India Company. About 1770, Captain John Ritchie began a systematic survey of the coasts of the Bay of Bengal and the outlets of the Ganges. This, the first survey of importance in Indian waters, was followed by others, so that when the Indian Navy was abolished in 1862, the whole seaboard of India, and the adjoining waters from the Red Sea and the Persian Gulf to the Straits of Malacca, had for the most part been surveyed as far as was practicable with the imperfect appliances available. Little more was done until 1873, when the Duke of Argyll, then Secretary of State for India, brought to the notice of the Indian Government the necessity for greater accuracy and more minute attention to detail by marine surveyors, in order to keep pace with the requirements of modern navigation. The Government of India accordingly established a special Marine Survey department in 1874, and procured some officers from the Admiralty to serve in it. The Marine Survey thus constituted failed, however, to produce the desired results; and in 1881 the department was reorganized, under a Commander from the Royal Navy, with a staff of four naval and eight Indian Marine officers. Since 1881 this staff has been slightly reduced, and all its members except the officer in command are now drawn from the Indian Marine, to which the Marine Survey is administratively attached. Survey work is carried out from the Indian Marine paddle-steamer Investigator (515 tons), assisted by the steam tender Nancowry (70 tons).
The object of marine surveying is to provide charts for the purposes of navigation, and as these are intended only for the use of mariners, extreme trigonometrical accuracy is not attempted or required. A theodolite larger than 6 inches is rarely employed, and triangles that close to within one or two minutes answer every purpose. The usual method adopted is to measure a base three or four thousand feet long on some level ground or sand-flat, and extend it by means of triangulation. The positions of the initial and terminal points of this triangulation (usually 50 or 60 miles apart) are determined astronomically, and the scale is adjusted to agree. Should Great Trigonometrical Survey points be available, they are of course used. Astronomical observations are made with a sextant, fitted with a stand and an artificial horizon. The coast-line and its salient points, landmarks, summits of hills, dangers, &c., are charted with the utmost accuracy, and the positions of these on a modern chart can be implicitly relied on.
Sounding is the most tedious, and at the same time one of the most important, of the duties a marine surveyor is called upon to perform. The depth of water is measured by means of an ordinary lead and line marked to feet, unless exceptional accuracy is required, when a pole is employed marked in feet and inches. All soundings are reduced to Indian spring low-water mark, which is a compromise between the heights of the lowest tides of the dry and wet seasons, fully explained in the Tide Tables for Indian Ports, published by the Tidal and Levelling branch of the Survey of India; and the depth of water is shown on the charts by figures (denoting feet or fathoms according to the accuracy required) at the positions where the soundings were taken. When water shallower than the surrounding soundings indicate is struck, the locality is carefully examined in order to discover hidden dangers which, when found, are shown on the charts by conventional symbols.
The output of marine survey work naturally depends enormously on the conditions of wind and weather; but the normal out-turn for a surveying season (October to April) is a chart of from 100 to 120 miles of coast-line, on a scale of 1 inch to the nautical mile, sounded off to 100 fathoms, with perhaps two or three large-scale plans in addition.
The sphere of the Marine Survey extends from Baluchistān to Siam, but its services have on more than one occasion been utilized outside these limits. All the principal and most of the secondary ports in India and Further India have been surveyed recently, and 1,500 miles of coast had been accurately charted up to 1904. The survey of the Burma coast is that which now requires most immediate attention.
The Investigator is fitted with appliances for sounding and trawling in any depth. These operations are carried out in transit from one coast to another and, when depths are suitable, on the surveying ground itself. Considerable additions to our knowledge of oceanic depths and deep-sea zoology have thus been obtained. An officer of the Indian Medical Service is attached to the Marine Survey as surgeon-naturalist, for the express purpose of examining and classifying zoological specimens.
The results of survey work are forwarded to the hydrographer of the Royal Navy, who has charts engraved on scales most suitable for the purposes of navigation. Some photozincograph records of the work done are, however, first made in India and issued locally, and all records of natural history work are published through the Calcutta Museum.
The following paragraphs, supplied by Major Alcock, I.M.S., give a brief summary of the zoological results of about 200 dredgings made from the Investigator in the Arabian Sea, the Bay of Bengal, and the Andaman basin:—
(1) Protozoa.—Outside the limits of the ‘continental slope’ (or great submarine ‘shoot’ of river-borne sediment) and of the Andaman and Laccadive coral formations, the sea-bottom consists of the well-known foraminiferal ooze, in which 277 species have been identified. Off the Andamans there occur large arenaceous Foraminifera, described by H. B. Brady as Masonella.
(2) Porifera.—The Triaxon sponges, so characteristic of the deep sea, have been found at all depths up to 1,997 fathoms. F. E. Schulze has described thirty-one species, of which twenty-six were new to science. They include numerous species of glass-rope sponges (Hyalonema) and Venus’s flower-basket (Euplectella), as well as Atlantic species of Farrea and Aphrocallistes.
(3) Coelenterata.—Characteristic deep-sea forms, such as Conopora, Cryptohelia, Atolla, encrusting Palythoa, Umbellula, Calypterinus, have all been found; and the precious coral (Corallium rubrum) has once been dredged in mass off Ceylon, but in water too deep for profitable working. Of Madrepore corals, twenty-five species have been described by Alcock, some of them being identical with fossils from the tertiary rocks of Sicily and Calabria.
(4) Echinodermata.—Starfishes, brittle-stars, and sea-urchins live in shoals on the continental slope, and the oozy depths of the Bay of Bengal are thickly peopled with strange Holothurians. More than 250 species of Echinoderms have already been dredged, of which about three-fourths were new to science: these have been dealt with by Koehler, Wood-Mason, A. R. S. Anderson, Walsh, and Alcock. Many characteristic deep-sea genera have been recognized, such as Pontaster, Porcellanaster, Zoroaster, Hymenaster with its brood-pouch, Brisinga and Freyella; Phormosoma, Pourtalesia, Homolampas, and Palaeopneustes; Benthodytes and Deima.
(5) Crustacea.—About 250 species have already come to light. Most of them belong to the groups Caridea (shrimps), Galatheidea (hermit-lobsters), Peneidea (prawns), and Astacidea (lobsters), and many are of primitive mould; the crabs are rare, and include a large proportion of archaic forms—Homolidae and Dromidae. Some of them have a most suggestive geographical range: such are Homola, Maia, Trichopeltarium; Nephrops, Phoberus, Calocaris; Pylocheles, Nematopagurus, Lithodes; Pasiphaea; and the Brobdingnagian isopod Bathynomus giganteus. Many display wonderful adaptations to the severe conditions of deep-sea life: species, such as Munida and Glyphocrangon, with enormous eyes like those of nocturnal animals; forms, like Parapandalus, with accessory eyes; forms, like Heterocarpus alphonsi, that can secrete their own light. On the other hand we find species with eyes in every stage of degeneration, from Munidopsis and Galacantha, which have eyes devoid of the pigment requisite for vision, through Nephropsis, which has eyestalks but no eyes, to Polycheles, whose bare eyestalks are not easily recognizable. Some species, such as Encephaloides and Parilia, have the gills and gill-chambers magnified, to overcome the difficulty of breathing at great depths. Some, such as Psathyrocaris, lay a small number of enormously large eggs, thus illustrating the argument that, where the conditions of life are rigid, births must be checked, and ample provision for the young made, if the species is to hold its own. Instances of commensal adaptations between Crustacea and zoophytes are common, each party unconsciously rendering the other vital assistance while pursuing its own independent ends: such are the cases of Parapagurus pilosimanus and Paguropsis typica, both of which live with seaanemones. The majority of deep-sea Crustacea are simply coloured—usually red or orange, occasionally milk-white, protective and other pattern-markings being useless where there is little or no light. The chief local workers upon this group have been Wood-Mason, A. R. S. Anderson, and Alcock.
(6) Mollusca.—About 150 species of molluscs have been described, chiefly by Smith (the cuttle-fishes by Goodrich), and a large proportion were new to science. Among the gastropods we find Astralium, Solariella, Bathybembix, Xenophora, Puncturella, many species of Pleurotoma, and the remarkable Pontiothauma—a large, blind form; and among the bivalves Lima, Limopsis, Nucula, Yoldia, Crassatella, Cryptodon, and numerous species of Cuspidaria and Amussium.
(7) Fishes.—Of fishes, 172 species have been added to the list, 128 being new to science. They include spiny dogfishes, true rays, numerous berycoids, and curious frogfishes (Pediculati), pleuronectoids, scopeloids, and eels; as well as many species of the characteristic deep-sea families Ophidiidae, Macruridae, Sternoptychidae, Stomiatidae, Alepocephalidae, and Halosauridae. Many of them are conspicuously adapted to their environment: such are Aulastomomorpha, Leptoderma, and Bathyclupea, with their enormous eyes; Lamprogrammus, Neoscopelus, and Polyipnus, with their rows of large luminary organs; the purblind Onirodes, and Benthobatis (the only electric ray yet known from the depths), with their luminous lures; the defective-eyed Bathypterois, with its streaming compensatory feelers; and Tauredophidium, with rudiments of eyes buried beneath the bones of the head. In another direction, illustrating the need for special parental care in the sullen bottoms of the deep, we find viviparous Teleostei, such as Saccogaster, Diplacanthopoma, and Hephthocara. Lastly, we have Chiasmodus, Chauliodus, Photostomias, Malacosteus, and Astronesthes, all proclaiming, with fang and gape that would have startled even the poet of evolution, the unlovely fact that the fishes of the sunless abysses, where plant-life (bacteria perhaps excepted) is interdicted, are ravenous beyond imagination.
Notes
- 1. Marine surveys are treated in an Appendix to this chapter.
- 1. Up to the year 1840 the Madras Observatory was adopted as the datum to which the latitudes and longitudes of all stations of triangulation were referred.
- 1. The discrepancies between the heights, as determined by spirit-levelling and trigonometrically, were :— In the line which connects Karāchi with False Point, the error is under 9 inches per 1,000 miles.
- 1. Full details regarding the tidal observations, with descriptions of the tide gauges, are to be found in vol. xvi of the Account of the Operations of the Great Trigonometrical Survey of India.
- 1. Report, United States Coast Survey for 1865.
- 1. The Survey of India, like other departments, is now divided into an Imperial and a Provincial branch. The former is as a rule recruited from the Royal Engineers or the Indian Army; the latter consists of men enlisted in India, to whom some of the higher posts of the department are open. There is also a Subordinate, and practically native, branch.