Chapter XII

— Police and Jails

The Imperial Gazetteer of India, Vol. IV, The India Office, 1907 · from page 384 · about 43 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

I. Police

The most interesting feature of the modern Indian Police system is that, along with a regular police formed on the model of the Royal Irish Constabulary, it comprises as an essential part of its organization the ancient institution of the village watch. It is now generally admitted that the village community in its most complete form is of non-Aryan origin ; and it is in the parts of India which have least felt Aryan influence, that is, in the country lying to the south of the Vindhya mountains, that this form of self-government has retained the greatest vitality. In many tracts within this area the old complement of village officials still exists, and, though all are not now embodied in the British system of administration, every village has retained a headman and a watchman. These officers have been from ancient times, and are still, though to a somewhat less degree, the backbone of the police machinery of India. The headman occupied the position of a police magistrate and the watchman worked under his orders. The latter's functions are thus graphically described by Mountstuart Elphinstone in his report (1819) on the territories conquered from the Peshwā :—‘ His [the watchman's] duties are to keep watch at night, to find out all arrivals and departures, observe all strangers, and report all suspicious persons to the pātel [headman]. He is likewise bound to know the character of every man in the village ; and in the event of a theft committed within the village bounds, it is his business to detect the thief. He is enabled to do this by his early habits of inquisitiveness and observation, as well as by the nature of his allowance, which being partly a small share of the grain and similar property belonging to each house, he is kept always on the watch to ascertain his fees, and always in motion to collect them. When a theft or robbery happens, the watchman commences his inquiries and researches. It is very common for him to track a thief by his footsteps ; and if he does this to another village, so as to satisfy the watchman there, or if he otherwise traces the property to an adjoining village, his responsibility ends, and it is the duty of the watchman of the new village to take up the pursuit. The last village to which the thief has been clearly traced becomes answerable for the property stolen, which would otherwise fall on the village where the robbery was committed. The watchman is obliged to make up this amount as far as his means go, and the remainder is levied on the whole village1.’ Sir Thomas Munro, who was an ardent supporter of the indigenous police, thus described that institution as it existed in the Madras Presidency : ‘There is already an ancient system of police in India which answers every useful purpose. In every village there are hereditary watchmen whose business it is to guard the property of the inhabitants and travellers from depredation, and to exert themselves in recovering it when lost or stolen ; and there is, perhaps, no race of men in the world equally dexterous in discovering the thieves. They are maintained by the produce of an inām [free grant] land, by a trifling tax on each house, and by a small allowance from travellers when they watch their property at night. No war or calamity can make them abandon their heritage. If driven from it, they always return again ; and often live in the village when every other person has forsaken it. This long and constant residence, together with their habits of life, make them perfectly acquainted with the character and the means of livelihood of every person in it. When, therefore, a robber is to be apprehended the new police officers apply to them, and seldom give themselves any further trouble than merely to carry the criminal, when the village watchmen have secured him, to the judge.’ In the Tamil country the village police were supervised by an official styled the men kāvalgār ; and it is probable that this was originally the practice everywhere, the office being eventually appropriated by the petty local chieftain or superior landlord.

In Northern India the village system was less complete. There was no headman, and though every village had its watchman, he was the servant of the landowners rather than of the whole community, and the landowners were held responsible for losses occasioned by crime committed on their land.

The Mughals made no change in the system of village police, but the duty of supervising them was entrusted to the revenue officers, who were also magistrates. In the South this involved but little change, as there the petty chiefs were retained and allowed to collect the revenue from the villagers; and even where the appointment of revenue officials was the rule, the tendency was for the office to become hereditary and for the tax-gatherer to merge in the landed proprietor. Each superior landlord was required to maintain a quota of troops, and these forces were utilized as police to suppress internal disorders and to deal with serious outbreaks of such crimes as dacoity and robbery. The system of spies was also developed, and Haidar Alī in Mysore used his postal officials as an elaborate police intelligence department.

With the decline of the Mughal power the system of police fell into great disorder, and the petty chiefs and zamīndārs, no longer dreading punishment from above, used their adherents to ravage and plunder the lands of their neighbours. 'They extorted and amassed wealth which was dissipated in a jealous rivalry of magnificent pageantry. The weapons which were intended for the enemies of the state were turned against the state itself, and against each other, and were used for plans of personal aggrandizement, mutual revenge, or public plunder1.' This evil example was followed by the village headmen and the village police. Most of the latter became thieves themselves, and many of the former harboured criminals and connived at crime for a share of the booty. The liability of the watchmen to restore the stolen property or make good its value was disregarded, and it was impossible to enforce the old village responsibility, that 'coarse but effectual remedy,' as Mountstuart Elphinstone calls it, 'against the indifference of the neighbourhood to the sufferings of individuals.'

This was the state of things which the British found in the early days of their rule, and as a first step towards reform the zamīndārs were relieved of their police duties, which were transferred to the District Magistrates, each District being divided into small police jurisdictions with an area of about 20 square miles. This formed the charge of a daroga, who had under him twenty to fifty armed men, and was also given authority over the village watchmen. This system, which entirely disregarded the village headman and converted the watchman from a servant of the village into an ill-paid and disreputable subordinate of the daroga, proved to be an expensive failure; and, owing largely to the representations of Elphinstone and Munro, it was abolished, under orders issued by the Court of Directors in 1814, in all the Company's possessions except Bengal, in many parts of which Province the village system did not exist. An endeavour was made there in 1807 to re-establish the landlords in their police functions by giving them authority to act as amīns or commissioners of police. But the old establishments had been dissolved and the scheme did not meet with great success.

It was many years before the police administration advanced much beyond this initial stage. It remained, as a rule, in the immediate charge of the District Magistrate, who had under his control a loosely organized body of civil police and the indigenous local agency. Much of the guard and escort duty incident to the work of civil government was performed by the native army, a costly and inconvenient arrangement. As work increased the Magistrate was unable to devote sufficient time to purely police duties, and his magisterial and police functions were found to clash. In the time of Lord William Bentinck, 1828–35, complaints of the inefficiency and corruption of the police were universal. The first measure of reform was the appointment of separate Superintendents for the police of the Presidency towns1. In the country generally the earliest important attempt at improvement was made by Sir Charles Napier in Sind. He drew up a plan on the model of the Irish Constabulary, the main characteristics of which were separate organization, severance of police and judicial functions, and a reasonable degree of discipline; and this was extended a few years later to the Bombay Presidency proper. Shortly after the annexation of the Punjab a double system was introduced into that Province, consisting of a detective force on existing lines and a semi-military force for escort and guard duty. Similar arrangements were made on a more extensive scale in the Province of Agra immediately after the Mutiny. In Oudh a large body of military police had been raised during the Mutiny, and, after the pacification of the country, it was reduced in numbers and reorganized on a civil basis, unconnected with either the military or judicial authorities. Smaller battalions of military police were also raised in Bengal. In the meantime the appointment of a Commission to investigate the alleged practice of torture by native officials in Madras had drawn prominent attention to the condition of the police force in that Province. It was reorganized by an Act passed in 1859, the main features of which were similar to those of the Act which was shortly afterwards passed for India generally. The cost of the double police force in the Province of Agra and the Punjab proved prohibitive, and it was eventually decided to introduce the Oudh system of a single body for detective, protective, and miscellaneous duty. In 1860 a Commission which had been appointed to inquire into the whole subject of police administration recommended the establishment of a well-organized and purely civil constabulary, supervised by European officers, and capable of carrying out all ordinary civil duties, including the provision of guards and escorts. The village police should, the Commission advised, be retained on their existing footing, being brought, however, into direct relationship with the general constabulary. The proposals of the Commission formed the basis of an Act passed in 1861, which, with some amendment, still regulates the administration of the police throughout the greater part of India, and which permitted a considerable reduction in the native army. In Madras the Act of 1859 (amended in some particulars) is still in force. A separate Act was passed for the Bombay Presidency in 1867, and was replaced in 1890 by a fresh Act, which was extended to Sind in 1902. Further legislation will be required to carry out the orders of the Government of India on the report of the recent Commission.

The police establishment under each Local Government forms in most Provinces a single force, and is formally enrolled. In Bombay there is a separate force for each District. The Provincial police is under the general control of an Inspector-General, who is in some Provinces a member of the Indian Civil Service. In most cases he is assisted by Deputy-Inspectors-General, who hold subordinate charge of portions of the Province. Police administration throughout a District is under an officer styled the District Superintendent. He is responsible for the discipline and internal management of the force, and is the subordinate of the District Magistrate in all matters connected with the preservation of peace and the detection and suppression of crime. In Madras the control exercised by the District Magistrate is less detailed than in other Provinces. In large Districts the Superintendent has an Assistant, who sometimes works under him at head-quarters and sometimes (usually in Madras) holds charge of a portion of the District. An officer of the superior police department enters as an Assistant, rises in due course to the post of District Superintendent, and may be selected to be Deputy-Inspector-General and, in some Provinces, Inspector-General. The controlling staff is composed almost entirely of Europeans.

Recruitment has hitherto been partly by open competition in England, partly by examination after nomination in India, and partly by the promotion of subordinate officers; but it was decided in 1905 that appointments in India should henceforth be made only with the special sanction of the Government of India. A new grade of Deputy-Superintendents, with similar duties to those of Assistant-Superintendents, is to be created, the members of which will be exclusively natives of India. In some Provinces, and notably in Bombay, where there are no Deputy-Inspectors-General, the Commissioner of the Division has special control over the police, apart from his position as administrative head of the Districts within his jurisdiction. This principle is to be extended to all parts of India where there are Commissioners.

At the head-quarters of each District a reserve is maintained under the command of an Inspector (a chief constable in Bombay). This reserve supplies men for escort, guard, and miscellaneous duty, and serves to strengthen the police in any part of the District where disturbance may be apprehended or other emergency may arise. Recruits pass some time in the reserve for the purpose of learning their duties. The reserve is trained to act in concert and to shoot, but is not drilled up to a standard of military efficiency. The reserve and a portion of the general-duty police are armed with breech-loading smooth-bore guns or carbines, and a small number, in tracts where they are likely to encounter armed resistance from dacoits and other law-breakers, carry rifles. The subordinate officers wear swords, and the truncheon is the general arm of the constable. About 2,600 are mounted. The proposals of the recent Commission involve an increase of the reserves in several Provinces.

A force of military police, the total strength of which is about 20,000, is still maintained in unsettled frontier tracts in Bengal, Assam, and Burma, and in the North-West Frontier Province. Three-quarters of this force is maintained in Burma, and, though under the Local Government, it is organized in battalions under military officers and largely recruited from the martial races of Northern India.

The general peace of the country is secured by the provisions of the Indian Arms Act, which restricts the possession of fire-arms and other weapons within narrow limits; and the occasions on which the military have to be called on to suppress riots (mostly arising from religious or caste questions) are comparatively rare.

Each District is subdivided for police purposes into sections under Inspectors. In Madras and Bengal the Inspector is placed in executive charge of a subdivision, and is directly responsible for the working of its police. In Bombay and the United Provinces he is stationed at the District head-quarters and tours through his circle. To keep the police on the alert by constant inspections is everywhere his duty, and he does not, as a rule, personally investigate cases of crime. The Inspector's division is split up in all Provinces into areas in each of which is a police station under the charge of a subordinate officer, generally a sub-inspector in Bengal and the United Provinces, a head constable in Madras, and a chief constable in Bombay. This officer is primarily responsible for the working of the police within his charge, and is assisted by a body of petty officers and constables. It is his duty to inquire personally into cases of serious crime. It is now (1906) proposed to recruit sub-inspectors as far as possible direct, the proportion of vacancies to be filled by promotion from petty officers being fixed separately in each Province. On the other hand, Inspectors are to be recruited mainly by promotion, and not more than one-tenth will be appointed direct. In most Provinces there are subsidiary police stations known as outposts. In Bengal and Bombay these outposts are very numerous and are minor reporting and detective centres, while in the United Provinces they serve the special function of guarding the routes of traffic.

Each police station has within its jurisdiction a number of villages, and for each village there is, as already explained, a chaukīdār or watchman. South of the Vindhyas the watchman is under the immediate control of the headman, on whom rests the obligation to report crime and aid the execution of justice; but in the greater part of Bengal there are no headmen, and the chaukīdārs are there virtually a low-paid regular police, while elsewhere in Northern India they are, as a rule, partly subordinate to the village elders or lambardārs, and in part directly responsible to the officer in charge of the police station. In 1905 the policy of strengthening the control and responsibility of the village headmen was reaffirmed. Village watchmen are remunerated in some Provinces by allotments of land and payment of fees: in others this system has been abolished, and monthly salaries are paid from a fund formed by a cess on land or houses, and from the revenue derived from the old landed endowments. Under either system hereditary claims are, whenever possible, respected.

The foremost duty of the chaukīdār is to report crime; but his functions are various, and extend to the arrest of offenders, general aid to the police, the maintenance of a watch over bad characters and suspicious persons, and the general supply of local information. He is appointed by the District Magistrate under various systems of local nomination, and may be punished and removed by the same authority. The village watchmen are often members of the criminal classes, a circumstance which was of little importance when they were held personally responsible for losses, but which now often obstructs the course of justice. That it is still possible to enforce the old responsibility is shown by the fact that in many parts of the country private persons employ members of the classes to which most of the village watchmen belong in order to ensure themselves against loss by theft or burglary. If a theft is committed, these private watchmen seldom fail either to restore the property or to make good its value. On the other hand, persons who refuse to employ such watchmen, or to pay the fees prescribed by custom, are quickly made to feel the power of these rivals of the regular police.

In towns the organization is on much the same lines as in the rural areas: there is a system of police stations, outposts, and beats, with careful arrangements for night patrol. Sometimes the duty of watch and ward is performed by town watchmen, subsidiary to the regular police, and corresponding in a measure to the village watch. The police in each of the Presidency towns, and in Rangoon, is organized as a separate force under a Commissioner, and European as well as native petty officers and constables are enrolled in it.

The railway police is organized separately from the District police, but acts in co-operation with it. The railway police charge under the Government of the Punjab includes the railway systems in the North-West Frontier Province; elsewhere these charges are, as far as possible, conterminous with the territorial jurisdiction of the Local Governments. The command of the railway police has hitherto been generally held by an officer immediately subordinate to the Inspector-General, but it has now been decided to place the force in each Province under a Deputy-Inspector-General. The railway police are, as a rule, concerned only with the maintenance of law and order, watch and ward over railway property being provided for by the railway administrations.

In most Provinces recruits are trained at the head-quarters of the District, where they receive instruction in drill and are taught the elements of the law relating to their powers and duties. The difficulty of ensuring a proper training was pointed out by the recent Commission, and it has now been decided to form central schools in all Provinces but Burma. Except in Madras and Burma, the great majority of the rank and file are illiterate, and their instruction in subjects other than drill is, therefore, a matter of some difficulty. Madras, Bengal, the United Provinces, and the Punjab possess police training-schools (at Vellore, Bhāgalpur, Morādābād, and Phillaur) for the instruction of candidates for the post of investigating officer, and other Provinces have recently (1906) arranged to open similar institutions. The students consist of youths specially recruited for this post as well as of men already in the force. Probationary Assistant-Superintendents are also attached to these schools for a period of training, which in future will extend to eighteen months.

The Code of Criminal Procedure divides offences into ‘cognizable’ and ‘non-cognizable,’ according as the culprit may or may not be arrested without a warrant. The police are mainly concerned with cases of cognizable crime. The following is an example of the ordinary procedure on the occurrence of a case of serious cognizable crime, such as burglary. Information having been brought to the police station by the village watchman, accompanied very likely by the complainant, the statements are reduced to writing and the officer in charge of the station proceeds to the locality to take up the investigation. Every stage in the proceeding, and its result, is recorded in a diary, in which are also set down the statements of the persons examined. These may not, however, ordinarily be used in evidence. If necessary the investigating officer may search any house for stolen property or other articles throwing light on the crime. If the accused person confesses his guilt, his statement has to be recorded by a magistrate, who must certify that, to the best of his belief, the confession is voluntary. These precautions are taken to guard against the extortion of confessions by torture or undue influence. If the investigation results in the detection of the supposed criminal, the police officer arrests him and sends him to the local magistrate, who either remits him to custody or releases him on bail. The police may not detain an accused person for more than twenty-four hours without a magistrate’s special orders. When the case is complete, the papers are sent to the magistrate (very often they accompany the accused), and the prisoner is tried or committed to sessions. If the investigating officer finds no case for trial, he sends up the papers marking the case as true1, false owing to mistake of law or fact, or maliciously false, as the case may be. The magistrate then orders further proceedings or records the case under one or other of the above heads. In maliciously false cases the complainant may be prosecuted.

The prosecution of cases before magistrates is an important portion of police work. In special cases a pleader may be engaged, or the work may be performed by the District or Assistant Superintendent; but ordinarily the prosecution of important cases is conducted by an Inspector, sub-inspector, or other police officer who has not himself been engaged in the investigation of the case. In minor cases the proceedings are directly conducted by the magistrate, with such assistance as he may think fit to take from the investigating police officer. Cases which come before the Courts of Session are conducted by a Government Pleader, who may also on occasion be employed in the lower courts.

A register is kept at each police station of habitual offenders, suspected characters, and released convicts sentenced for grave crime, and a watch is maintained over their movements by the police and the village watchmen. A chaukīdār should, for instance, report any change of address, and should know if a bad character is in the habit of being out on dark nights. Special supervision is exercised over convicts guilty of heinous crime and released before the expiry of their sentence under the mark system2. Vagrants, persons concealing their presence in order to commit an offence, and persons proved by repute or otherwise to be habitually concerned in the commission of crimes, such as robbery, theft, and receiving stolen property, may be called on to furnish security for good behaviour or be imprisoned in default. Frequent recourse is had to this salutary provision of the law. Persons convicted of, or likely to commit, a breach of the peace may be bound over to keep the peace. Throughout India there are castes and tribes who live largely by the commission of crime, especially thefts, robberies, and cattle-lifting, and whose operations have been facilitated by the development of road and railway communications. In their case the operation of the caste system leads them to regard their practices as a normal and quite respectable means of livelihood. They commit offences against property ‘not only with no thought of criminality, but in the belief that in following the custom of their forefathers they are acting in the only way that is right1.’ A special watch is kept over the doings of these sections of the community, and various Acts have been passed for the purpose of reclaiming the most dangerous among them, and of protecting society against their depredations. A powerful agency for the detection of habitual offenders has been secured in the system of recording and classifying the finger-tip impressions of persons guilty of grave crime. This system owes its inception to an Indian magistrate (Sir W. Herschell), and its extension to the identification of old offenders was rendered possible by the labours of Mr. Henry, Inspector-General of Police, Bengal, in which Province it was first introduced. The method has been skilfully elaborated and is now used with considerable effect. In Bengal, in 1899, successful search was made in over 45 per cent. of the cases sent for comparison to the central office where the classified records are kept.

The crime of thagī2 has practically ceased to exist in India; and although robbery and house-breaking by armed gangs are offences with which the authorities have still to cope, the peaceful villager of the present day has throughout the greater part of the country almost lost recollection of the times when his forefathers were harassed and pillaged by marauding bands of freebooters or dacoits (dakaits)3. The existence, till very lately, of a ‘Thagī and Dakaiti department’ bore testimony to the manners of other times, but although the department long retained its old title, its duties changed with the progress of peace and civilization. Systematic measures for the suppression of thagī were begun in 1830, during the Governor-Generalship of Lord William Bentinck, and the name of Sir William Sleeman is associated with the successful conduct of these operations. The department organized for the suppression of thagī was entrusted in 1839 with the additional duty of suppressing dacoits. When the police was reorganized in 1860–3 this special department was no longer needed for British territory; and it became mainly concerned with the suppression of organized dacoity in Hyderābād, Central India, and Rājputāna, and the capture of dacoits who had fled from British to native territory. It did not interfere with the authority of the Native States in the suppression of ordinary crime, but, at the request of the political officers, it investigated inter-statal cases. At the head of the department was an officer styled the General Superintendent, immediately subordinate to the Government of India in the Foreign Department, and under his control was a staff of officers and men, stationed at various places in the Native States, and working under the supervision of the political officers and in conjunction with the local police. In 1887 the department was further entrusted with the work of collecting and comparing intelligence regarding organized crime, but its machinery was not well adapted for this purpose.

In 1904 the Thagī and Dakaiti department as thus constituted was abolished, its establishments at Hyderābād being merged in the police force of that State, while those in Rājputāna and Central India were transferred to the control of the Agents to the Governor-General. The former central office was replaced by a department of 'Central Criminal Intelligence,' working under the Home Department of the Government of India. The object of this new department is to collect and communicate information regarding such forms of organized crime as are committed by offenders operating along the railway system, and by criminal tribes, wandering gangs, organized dacoits, professional poisoners, forgers, coiners, and the like, whose operations extend beyond the limits of a single Province. Railways, posts, and telegraphs have enabled astute criminals to disperse or concentrate in a manner that baffles purely local authorities: this central agency has become necessary to procure the knowledge and co-operation requisite for dealing with them, and it will work in connexion with the police of Native States as well as with those of British Provinces. The new department is under the control of a Director, with an experienced Deputy to assist him. The officers to be appointed Deputy-Inspectors-General of Railway Police (see p. 391) will also be the heads of Provincial Criminal Investigation departments which it is proposed to constitute.

The existing police organization is a great improvement on the system which it replaced, and it has done much useful work. It is, however, notorious that it has not been in all respects satisfactory. The detective agency has too often proved incompetent, supine, or dishonest, and the old Eastern traditions of extortion and the maltreatment of prisoners have never been entirely eradicated. The history of crime, especially of late years, has not shown the improvement which the general progress of the country should have brought with it, while the police have failed to secure that degree of popular confidence which is necessary for thoroughly efficient work. In 1888–9 the Government of India, in conjunction with the Local Governments, made a searching inquiry into the history of crime since 1875 and into the working of the police force. The investigation did not lead to the conclusion that there had been any serious increase of crime, except perhaps in the Punjab; but the detective work of the police appeared to have suffered deterioration in some Provinces, and it was generally admitted that there were defects in the system needing reform. The evidence also showed that the emoluments and prospects of the force, and especially of the detective agency, were sometimes insufficient to secure intelligence and to encourage probity and zeal. The Government of India suggested various improvements, and the Local Governments worked out careful schemes in accordance with these suggestions. Although financial exigencies did not permit of the changes recommended being carried out in their entirety, the position of the subordinate officers and men of the police has been improved at considerable cost. In 1888 the total strength of the organized civil police force was about 129,000 men, and the cost 242 lakhs; in 1901 the strength was about 145,000 men, and the cost 328 lakhs. The local village watchmen aggregate about 700,000 men.

During recent years, though the people at large still maintain their law-abiding character, there has been a considerable increase of serious crime in the principal Provinces of the Indian Peninsula, and the increase has been specially marked in the case of heinous offences, such as murder, dacoity, and robbery. Repeated seasons of famine and high prices have exerted an important influence on the statistics of crime, but this cause cannot be regarded as solely responsible for the phenomenon. In most Provinces there has been some advance in the detection of the worst forms of crime, but on the whole it would seem doubtful whether there has been adequate improvement since the reforms inaugurated in 1888. The Government of India recently considered the whole question, and, with the approval of the Secretary of State, appointed a Commission in 1902 to inquire into the police administration. The report of this Commission embraced a wide field, covering every branch of the subject. In addition to the reforms which have been already referred to, the Government of India has approved of substantial increases in the pay of all grades, besides other measures to improve the condition and efficiency of the police. The budget for 1905–6 included grants of 50 lakhs to Local Governments for the purpose ; and directions were issued that this sum should be devoted, in order, to the increase in the armed reserves rendered necessary by the proposed redistribution of the army, to the improvement in the pay of constables, and to increasing the number of investigating officers, who will now invariably be sub-inspectors.

II. Jails

The criminal law of the Muhammadans, which prevailed largely in India prior to British rule, is characterized by the cruel nature of its penalties. The Korānic law punishes adultery with death by stoning, highway robbery accompanied by murder with death by the sword or crucifixion, simple highway robbery with loss of hands and feet, theft with amputation of the right hand, wine-drinking and false accusation of adultery with a flogging of eighty stripes. For minor offences the prescribed punishments included stripes, imprisonment, and jarr. A culprit sentenced to the last penalty was dragged to the door and exposed to public contumely. The extreme rigour of the Korānic law was mitigated in practice, and the spirit in which it was administered in India depended in a measure on the character and inclinations of the sovereign. During the reign of the humane Akbar the severity of the penalties was modified by instructions drafted by the emperor or his advisers. A mandate to the governor of Gujarāt restricted his punishments to putting in irons, whipping, and death. He was to be sparing in capital punishments, and, unless in case of dangerous sedition, to inflict none without the emperor's confirmation. Nor was he to permit executions to be accompanied by mutilation or other torture. The comparative leniency of Akbar's criminal system was not, however, maintained under his successors. When the proceedings of the Muhammadan criminal courts came within the sphere of the Company's administration, impalement, mutilation, and flogging were ordinary forms of punishment. In the England also of those days the criminal law retained much of its early barbarity. The public hanging of thieves and other felons was a common spectacle, the pillory was in constant use, and men and women were still whipped through the streets at the cart's tail. Accustomed as they were to the infliction of such penalties, the cruelty of the Muhammadan law did not outrage the feelings of the early administrators of the Company. In Calcutta, where the English law obtained, flogging with a rattan was the penalty commonly inflicted on petty offenders of both sexes. Outside the Presidency towns criminal justice was at first administered under the Muhammadan law, and for some years the Muhammadan system of punishment was suffered to continue. The old records of Chittagong District show that the punishment of impalement was inflicted on dacoits as late as the year 1782, and that the civil officers applied to the military authorities for guards to attend the execution. In Madras the punishment of mutilation was in common use up to the end of the eighteenth century.

The change of sentiment which had occurred in England before the beginning of the nineteenth century made the continuance of such barbarous penalties impossible. About 1790 the punishment of mutilation was forbidden by law in Bengal, and the criminal courts were directed to inflict imprisonment with hard labour in its stead. By this time jails had been established under the control of the magistrates, and more modern notions regarding the treatment of criminals began to prevail.

The early Indian jail system was, like its English prototype, insanitary, demoralizing, and non-deterrent. All classes of male criminals were mixed together, and convicts were, in many cases, better clothed and fed, and more lightly worked, than free labourers. Prisoners were often employed in gang-labour on the roads under the magistrate or under public works officers. In such jails as existed the discipline was lax, and, except in some places in the Madras and Bombay Presidencies, intra-mural labour was in a rudimentary condition. The mortality, especially among those who laboured on the roads, was very high.

In 1834 a regulation was passed for the improvement of prison discipline, and shortly afterwards the first great measure of prison reform was inaugurated at the instigation of Lord Macaulay. He pointed out the defective condition of jail discipline, and suggested the appointment of a committee to collect information and prepare an improved plan. This suggestion was adopted, and the report of the first Prisons Commission, which was presented to the Government in 1838, recommended a series of radical reforms. The Commission condemned the system of road-gangs, and proposed that convicts should be confined and put to labour in large central prisons, supplemented by smaller District jails in which adequate arrangements should be made for classification and discipline. In accordance with the notions prevailing in those days, they advised that labour should be enforced by ‘machines which render the working at them a dull, wearisome, and disgustful exertion.’ The Commission further recommended that one or more prison inspectors should be appointed for each Province. Lord Auckland’s Government accepted generally the views of the Commission, but, having regard to the great expense which they entailed and the many difficulties that beset the introduction of a complete jail system in India, enjoined caution in carrying them out. In point of fact much progress had not been made when Sir John Lawrence reviewed the position in 1864 and appointed the second Prisons Commission. Their report proceeded on the lines of that of 1838, and laid down a well-considered system which in its essential features is still in force. It was followed by more effective action and a large increase in jail accommodation. Separate Acts were passed for the regulation of prisons in Madras, Bombay, Bengal, and the Provinces having no legislature of their own, and under these Acts considerable differences grew up in the practice prevailing in different parts of India. In 1876 Lord Lytton appointed a third Commission to make a general review of the subject, and in particular to suggest means for introducing more uniform regulations and for making short sentences more deterrent. A Bill was prepared on the basis of the Commission’s report, but it never became law, and the question was allowed to drop for several years. In the time of Lord Dufferin attention was again directed to the diversity of practice, and two officers of experience were appointed to visit the jails of the different Provinces, and to investigate on the spot questions regarding health, discipline, and general administration. They made an exhaustive inquiry, and their report, submitted in 1889, dealt with prison discipline and management in all its aspects. It was supplemented by a conference of experts on the subject of prison offences and punishments. A general Prisons Act for British India (IX of 1894) was then passed, and regulations were issued under it by the Governor-General-in-Council and the Local Governments.

The forms of imprisonment authorized by the Indian Penal Code are transportation, penal servitude, rigorous imprisonment (i. e. with labour), and simple imprisonment. When rigorous imprisonment is inflicted, the court may also order solitary confinement during a portion of the sentence. Accommodation in the jails has also to be provided for civil and under-trial prisoners.

There are several grades of Indian jails. In the first place, large Central jails for convicts sentenced to more than one year's imprisonment; secondly, the jails at the head-quarters of Districts; and, thirdly, subsidiary jails in the interior of Districts for under-trial prisoners and convicts under short sentences of imprisonment. In 1903 British India contained forty Central jails, 192 District jails, and 498 subsidiary jails and lock-ups.

The Jail department in each Province is under the control of an Inspector-General, who is generally an officer of the Indian Medical Service with jail experience, and the Superintendents of Central jails are usually recruited from the same service. The District jail is under the charge of the Civil Surgeon and is frequently inspected by the District Magistrate. The staff under the Superintendent includes, in large Central jails, a deputy superintendent to supervise the jail manufactures, and in all Central and District jails one or more subordinate medical officers.

The executive staff is divided into two classes. The higher class consists of jailors and deputy and assistant jailors, who form a single Provincial service with promotion from one grade to another. The lower class comprises the warders for the supervision and guard of prisoners; they also form a graded local service. Convict petty-officers are employed in all Central and District jails. This practice is suited to the conditions of India, where the majority of prisoners are not professional criminals, and can be placed over their fellow-convicts without demoralizing them. The rules under which the convict officers are selected preclude the appointment of degraded criminals and prescribe a high standard of conduct in jail, while the prospect of promotion to one of these posts is a strong inducement to good behaviour. Arrangements for guarding convicts follow the principle that the prisoner, in his workshop or sleeping ward, should be watched rather than the walls of the jail. In olden days prisoners were generally fettered for better security; this system has long been abandoned, and fetters are now used only as a punishment or to restrain violence.

The general characteristic of the Indian prison system is confinement in association by day and night. The desirability of separate confinement by night, and of cellular confinement during the first part of long, and the whole of short, sentences, is recognized, and the Government of India has repeatedly drawn attention to the subject. There are, however, difficulties attending this : the cost of providing cellular accommodation is very great, and free ventilation is essential in a jail in the Indian plains. Steady progress has been made during recent years, and many sleeping wards have been fitted with cubicles. The provision of cells for separate confinement has been carried farthest in Madras, where a special penal routine has been introduced for the first stage of confinement. Discipline is maintained by a parade system, and the life of the convict is controlled by rule in its minutest details. Prisoners are kept separate under the following classes : persons under trial, females, juveniles, civil prisoners, ordinary convicts, habitual offenders, and sick prisoners. Prisoners under sentence of labour rise at daybreak, take their early meal, work through the morning, are allowed a mid-day interval for rest and food, work again until evening, and, after a third meal, are locked up for the night. The hours of work amount to about nine a day. The dietary varies in different parts of the country with the staple food of the people. Great pains have been taken in all Provinces to regulate it on a scale which is sufficient to maintain good health without being lavish or extravagant. The disease and mortality statistics of the jail population have been discussed in chap. x of Vol. I; and it need only be observed here that the jail death-rate has been reduced until it compares favourably with that of the general working population—a great achievement, considering the large proportion of criminals who are physically as well as morally below the average.

There are three classes of labour—hard, medium, and light ; and a prisoner is employed on one or another class according to his physical capacity. Work is mostly carried on within the jail walls, but convicts are sometimes employed near the jail, and extra-mural employment on a more extensive scale is approved in the case of projects so large as to make it worth while to erect special accommodation. These conditions do not often exist, but a large number of convicts have recently been employed in excavating the Jhelum Canal in the Punjab. Within the walls prisoners are employed on jail service and repairs, and in workshops. The main principle laid down with regard to jail manufactures is that the work must be penal and industrial. The industries are on a large scale, and multifarious employments are condemned, while care is taken that the jail shall not compete with local trade. As far as possible industries are adapted to the requirements of the consuming public departments ; and printing, tent-making, and the manufacture of clothing are among the commonest employments. Other forms of manufacture are allowed in some jails : there is, for instance, a large and successful carpet manufactory in the Central jail at Agra. Schooling is confined to juveniles ; the experiment of teaching adults has been tried, but literary instruction is unsuitable for the class of persons who fill an Indian jail.

A list of jail offences and punishments has been drawn up under the authority conferred by the Prisons Act. Punishments are divided into major and minor according to their severity. The offences have reference mainly to discipline, the introduction or possession of forbidden articles, food, clothing, sanitation, the care of jail property, work, assaults, mutinies, and escapes. The number of desperate characters among the convicts is small, and their conduct in jail is generally good. Failure to perform the allotted task is by far the most common offence. The principal punishments are formal warning, deprivation of privileges, penal diet, various forms of separate confinement, handcuffs, fetters, coarse clothing, and whipping. Female prisoners are exempted from whipping, fetters, and handcuffs. During 1903 the number of punishments inflicted averaged two per head of the average convict population—see the table at the end of this chapter, which gives statistics for the jail population, and shows also the cost of keeping and guarding prisoners, and the profits of jail manufactures.

The jail regulations provide a system of reward as well as of punishment. The principal rewards are promotion to the post of convict warder and remission of sentences under the mark system. Daily and special marks are awarded for industry and good conduct, and a certain number of marks earn a day's remission. This has been found to work well, and the convicts appreciate its benefits.

Female prisoners are confined in separate wards of the ordinary jails, under the charge of female warders. They are subjected to the same discipline as male convicts, the tasks being apportioned to their smaller strength. They are not transferred to Central jails so freely as males, as it is considered inadvisable, except in the case of long-term convicts, to send women to places at a distance from their homes. Lahore contains a special jail for female convicts.

Boy convicts are confined in special wards, and are divided into children and adolescents. The latter class are kept separate, sleep in cubicles, and are provided with schooling and industrial education. In 1903, 1,114 boys under sixteen were admitted to the various jails in British India. It is strictly enjoined that boys shall not be sent to jail when they can be dealt with otherwise. The alternatives provided by law are detention in a reformatory school for a period of three to seven years, but not beyond the age of eighteen; discharge after admonition; delivery to the parent or guardian on the latter executing a bond to be responsible for the good behaviour of the culprit; and whipping by way of school discipline.

In 1903 there were 1,168 boys in reformatory schools. At the beginning of that year there were seven such schools in British India, and another was opened at Delhi in October. Until 1899 these schools were, except in Madras, under the administration of the Jail department, and it was found that they were conducted too much on jail principles and without sufficient regard to reformation. To remedy these defects the control of the schools has been transferred to the Education department; and the authorities have been directed to improve the industrial education of the inmates, to help the boys to obtain employment on leaving school, and as far as possible to keep a watch over their careers.

Only 290 girl criminals were admitted to jail in 1903. The social conditions of native life do not permit of girls being detained for considerable periods in reformatory schools, and no such schools have therefore been established for them. Magistrates have been directed to apply, when possible, the power conferred on them by law to discharge on admonition or to deliver to the parent or guardian. In Bengal and the United Provinces a special dépôt for girl criminals has been established in a Central jail as an experimental measure.

Transportation is an old punishment of the British Indian criminal law. Bengal Regulation IV of 1797 authorized the nizāmat adālat (or superior criminal court) to sentence criminals to transportation beyond the seas. Several places were appointed for the reception of Indian transported convicts, and in 1838 Singapore, Penang, Malacca, Tenasserim, and the Mauritius were used for this purpose. The treatment of the convicts was lenient, and the discipline lax. The Prisons Commission of 1838 approved of the transportation of life convicts, largely on the ground of the terror inspired by banishment to a distant and unknown land. This terror has in a great measure disappeared, but on the other hand the rigour of the system has been much increased. Port Blair in the Andaman Islands is now the only penal settlement. It was first used in 1858 for Mutiny prisoners, and was opened to general convicts in 1863. In 1902–3 the daily average convict population amounted to 12,182 men and 740 women. Under existing rules male convicts sentenced to transportation for life, or for a term of years of which six have still to run, are transported to the Andamans provided that they are medically fit. Females are transported if sentenced to transportation for seven years or upwards. The convicts are dispatched to Port Blair in batches during the calm season of the year. Under a scheme which has been sanctioned by the Government of India there will, hereafter, be five stages in the life of a male transported convict. The first six months will be passed in a cellular jail, the next eighteen months in association in a jail similar to those of the Indian mainland, and the following three years as a convict of the third class kept to hard gang-labour by day and confined in barracks by night. Having thus completed five years, a convict may be promoted to the second class, in which he is eligible for various posts in the barracks and jails, and for employment in the convict police or other Government service, or in the capacity of servant to a private resident. After five more years so spent, a well-behaved convict enters the first class, in which he labours under more favourable conditions, or is granted a ticket entitling him to support himself, with the grant of a plot of land on which to build a house. He may now send for his family or marry a female convict. The three later stages of this discipline have been in force for many years, but the two earlier have not yet been introduced in a complete form as the accommodation is not ready. The main portion of the cellular jail has been completed, and is already occupied, but the building of the associated jail for the second stage has not yet been begun. Females are kept at intra-mural work under strict jail discipline for three years, for the next two years they are subjected to a lighter discipline, and at the end of five years they may support themselves or marry a male convict. Promotion from class to class is dependent on good conduct, and bad behaviour may lead to degradation. The convicts are employed in jail service; in the erection and repair of jail buildings; in the commissariat, medical, marine, and forest departments; in tea-gardens, and at other agricultural work; and in various jail manufactures. At the end of 1902–3 there were 1,817 convicts in the semi-free or self-supporting stage out of a total of 12,724 in the settlement. For breaches of discipline and other jail offences convicts are punished by reduction to a lower class, withdrawal of indulgences, transfer to a punishment-gang or ward, with extra hard labour and penal diet (and, in the case of females, with liability to have their hair cropped and to wear a refractory dress), solitary confinement, and corporal punishment (in the case of males only). Ordinary male convicts sentenced to transportation for life are released, if they have behaved well, after twenty years' imprisonment, and persons convicted of dacoity and other organized crime after twenty-five; but in both cases it is generally essential that fifteen years of the period should be passed in the settlement. Thags and professional poisoners are never released. Well-behaved female convicts are released after fifteen years, and in the case of local marriage husband and wife are liberated at the same time. The release is sometimes absolute and sometimes, especially in the case of dacoits, subject to conditions, e.g. in regard to residence. In some cases the released convicts prefer to remain in the settlement as free persons: they then earn a livelihood by agriculture, as shopkeepers, and in other ways. The settlement is administered by a Superintendent, aided by a staff of European assistants and native subordinates.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Sleeman's Report on the Depredations of the Thags (1840). Report of the Madras Torture Commission, 1855. Report of the Indian Police Commission of 1860. Report of the Police Commission of 1902–3. Report of the Prisons Commission of 1838. Report of the Prisons Commission of 1864. Report of the Prisons Commission of 1876–7. Report of the Prisons Committee of 1889. Also, the annual Administration Reports on Police and Jails in the several Provinces, and the Annual Reviews of Jail Operations by the Government of India (published in the Gazette of India).

TBL-053 · FOLIO 444Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Jail Statistics
Average, 1885–90.Average, 1891–1900.1901.1903*.
Males.Females.Males.Females.Males.Females.Males.Females.
Daily average population . . .76,0082,76899,3432,994107,6103,09790,9442,149
Admissions.
For one year and under .125,5088,940147,13410,314141,8659,898124,8547,471
Above one and up to five years .16,63438221,81645919,77439918,843379
Above five and up to ten years .1,633322,286352,217371,87328
Over ten years . .74…109…108…1852
Transportation for a term .75495087566677313
Transportation for life .1,022801,024959939887289
Death sentences .47820598245461862018
Punishments . . . .82,966151,665193,887190,429
Net expenditure on jails † . .56,1872,9091,8782,37
Net profits from jail manufactures † .4,416,549,088,99

Notes

  1. 1. G. W. Forrest’s Selections from the Minutes of Mountstuart Elphinstone (1884), pp. 303-4. .
  2. 1. East India Judicial Selections, vol. i, p. 154.
  3. 1. Calcutta had a Superintendent of Police as early as 1808, but up to 1829 his jurisdiction included a large portion of the surrounding country.
  4. 1. A ‘true’ case, under these circumstances, would be one in which a crime was found to have been committed, but there was held to be no adequate evidence implicating any particular person.
  5. 2. See p. 402.
  6. 1. Sir J. Strachey’s India, 1903 edition, p. 399.
  7. 2. Thags were professional assassins, united by obedience to the goddess Kālī, in whose honour they strangled their victims.
  8. 3. Under the technical definition in the Indian Penal Code the commission or attempted commission of robbery by five or more persons constitutes the crime of dacoity.
  9. *. The decrease in jail population and admissions in 1903, as compared with 1901, is due to releases in celebration of His Majesty's Coronation, and to the prosperous conditions of the year.
  10. †. These figures, which are taken from the Finance Department's accounts, are in thousands of rupees, and are for the official year ending March 31.