The following statement ranges the eight Provinces of India in order of size and shows their area and population, excluding the dependent Native States :—
Burma is about the size of Sweden, with nearly twice its population, and contains great tracts of forest and jungle. The territories administered by the Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal, though smaller in extent than Burma, contain more than eight times the number of inhabitants and form the most onerous of the Provincial charges. This Province nearly doubles the population of France, though only three-quarters of its size. The United Provinces of Agra and Oudh are almost as densely populated as Bengal, and contain more people than Austria-Hungary in an area less than that of Austria alone. The population of Madras and the area of Bombay approximate to the population and area of the United Kingdom.
In the last chapter it was explained that the legislative distinction between regulation and non-regulation Provinces has become obsolete. The administrative systems still differ, however, in several particulars; and it will be convenient in the first place to describe the government of the regulation Provinces, and afterwards to explain the special features of the administration of the more recently acquired territories. Madras, Bombay1, Bengal, and Agra are the four regulation Provinces. The principal non-regulation Provinces are the Punjab, Burma, Oudh, the Central Provinces, and Assam.
As stated in the last chapter, the old Presidencies of Madras and Bombay retain their Governors-in-Council, while Bengal, the United Provinces, and Eastern Bengal and Assam are administered by Lieutenant-Governors. Business is conducted in the executive Councils of Madras and Bombay in much the same manner as in the Council of the Governor-General. The Departments are divided between the Governor and his two colleagues, and important matters are dealt with by the Council collectively. The Governor has the right of overruling his Council in special cases. The Lieutenant-Governors are solely responsible for the administration of their Provinces, and their powers are limited only by the law and the control of the Supreme Government. In all Provinces, as mentioned in the preceding chapter, questions of policy or of special importance are submitted for the orders of the Governor-General-in-Council, and the financial powers of the Local Governments are limited by definite and strict rules. The Secretariats of the Provincial Governments are divided into departments, each under a Secretary with subordinate officers, as in the case of the Supreme Government. Each of the principal departments of the civil service is under the charge of an officer who is attached to and advises the Local Government. Frequent tours of inspection keep him in touch with local work. The principal executive departmental heads, outside the revenue and general administrative departments, are much the same in all the large Provinces. In Bengal they are the Inspectors-General of Police, Jails and Registration, the Director of Public Instruction, the Inspector-General of Civil Hospitals, the Sanitary Commissioner, and the Superintendent of the Civil Veterinary department. There are also Chief Engineers, for Irrigation and Marine and for Buildings and Roads, who are likewise Secretaries to Government. In nearly all the regulation Provinces the revenue departments are administered, under the Government, by a Board of Revenue. In Bengal, and till recently in the United Provinces, the Board consists of two members2 who are the highest officers in the administrative branch of the service. In Bengal one of these is at the head of the great department of land revenue, and the other at the head of the departments of excise, opium, income-tax, &c.; and they meet together as a board only for the hearing of certain classes of appeals. The United Provinces Board acts more as a collective body, all important questions being considered by the whole Board. Immediately subordinate to the Board in both Provinces are the Director of Land Records and Agriculture, and the Commissioner of Excise; and, in Bengal, the Collector of Customs and the Opium Agents1. In Madras the Board of Revenue has four members, two of whom are Land Revenue Commissioners, one is Settlement Commissioner, and the fourth is Commissioner for Salt, Excise, Income-tax, and Customs. There is no Board of Revenue in Bombay; and the Director of Land Records and Agriculture, and the Commissioner of Customs, Salt, Opium, and Excise, are there immediately subordinate to the Local Government. Law officers are employed by each Local Government to advise it on legal questions and to conduct cases in which it is interested.
The system of administration in both regulation and non-regulation Provinces is based on the repeated subdivision of territory, each administrative area being in the responsible charge of an officer who is subordinate to the officer next in rank above him. The most important of these administrative units is the ‘District’; and the most accurate impression of the system may be gained by regarding a Province as consisting of a collection of Districts, which are usually split up into subdivisions and these again into smaller circles.
British India contains more than 250 Districts. The average area of a District is 4,430 square miles, and the average population 931,000. The average District is thus about three-fourths of the size of Yorkshire, and its inhabitants number considerably more than half the population of that county. The actual Districts vary greatly in size and density of population. For instance, the Upper Chindwin District of Burma has an area of 19,000 square miles and a population of 153,000; Mymensingh, in Bengal, has an area of over 6,000 square miles and a population of nearly 4,000,000; and Vizagapatam, in Madras, has an area of more than 17,000 square miles and a population of nearly 3,000,000. Among the major Provinces the Districts are largest in Burma and Madras, and smallest in the United Provinces.
In Madras there is no local officer above the head of the District. Elsewhere a Commissioner of Division is intermediate between the Collector and the Government or the Board of Revenue. A Division is a group of several Districts, usually from four to six, of which the Commissioner has the general superintendence and in which he also acts as a court of appeal in revenue cases. In the regulation Provinces the Commissioner is always a senior officer of the Indian Civil Service. The Commissioners of the regulation Provinces, when first appointed in 1829, under the government of Lord William Bentinck, exercised judicial as well as administrative and revenue functions, and held periodical jail deliveries in the Districts under their supervision. These judicial duties were eventually transferred to the District Judges.
The head of the District is styled in the regulation Provinces Collector and Magistrate. He is the representative of the Government in the large area under his charge; in the eyes of the people he embodies the power of the state or ‘Sarkār,’ and it is to him that they primarily look to redress their grievances and to promote their welfare. His twofold appellation indicates that he is both the principal revenue official and the chief magistrate. At one time the two offices were separate. Under the system established by Lord Cornwallis in Bengal, which was gradually extended to the other regulation Provinces as they came under British rule, the offices of District Magistrate and Civil Judge were united in the same person, the jail deliveries being made by a court of circuit. Subsequently the duties of the magistrate were separated from those of the judge, and he was vested with limited judicial powers in criminal cases. The Collector dates from the time of Warren Hastings, when the British first took over the fiscal administration of Bengal, Bihār, and Orissa. Many years ago, in the United Provinces, Madras, and Bombay, the magisterial and revenue functions were combined in the same hands, and the same process took place at a later date in Bengal.
The Collector is concerned in the first place with the land and the land revenue. The nature of his duties in this connexion varies with the character of the tenure under which land is held. They are specially onerous in Madras and Bombay, where the ryotwāri (cottier) tenure prevails and the revenue is paid by many thousands of cultivators ; they are comparatively light in Bengal, where landlords pay a revenue fixed by Lord Cornwallis’s permanent settlement. But even in Bengal there are large government estates which are managed by the Collector, and he also has charge of the private estates held by the Court of Wards in trust for minors and other persons1. Apart from the duties immediately connected with the assessment and collection of land revenue and with the village establishments, the Collector is concerned with all matters affecting the condition of the peasantry; he supervises the compilation of the periodical returns of produce and prices ; he adjudicates in several Provinces on rent and other disputes between landlord and tenant ; and he makes loans on behalf of the Government for agricultural purposes. The Collector has also charge of the local administration of excise, income-tax, stamp duty, and other sources of revenue ; and he is responsible for the management of the District treasury, into which the revenue and other public receipts are paid, and from which all local disbursements are made.
Magistrates are divided into three classes according to their powers. As a magistrate of the first class the Collector, in his capacity of District Magistrate, can imprison for two years and fine up to Rs. 1,000; but in practice he does not try many criminal cases, though he supervises the work of all the other magistrates of the District. But his magisterial functions extend far beyond the domain of the criminal court. He is responsible for the peace of the District and the suppression of crime, and has general control over the working of the police. He also supervises the management of the District jail in which short-term prisoners are confined, convicts sentenced to long terms of imprisonment being sent to large Central jails, of which there are several in each Province.
In addition to these two main departments of work, the Collector has to interest himself in all matters affecting the well-being of the people. In some branches of the administration his functions are, in consequence of the formation of special departments, such as those of Public Works, Forests, Jails, Sanitation, and Education, less direct than was formerly the case. But even in the matters dealt with by separate departments his active co-operation and counsel are still needed. The municipal government of all considerable towns is vested in a committee of the inhabitants, who raise taxes and expend the proceeds on roads, sanitation, water-supply, medical relief, education, and other public needs. It is the duty of the Collector to guide and control the working of these municipal institutions. He is also, usually, the Chairman of the District Board which, with the aid of subsidiary local boards, maintains roads, schools, and dispensaries, and carries out sanitary improvements in rural areas with funds derived from local rates. The ordinary day's work of the Collector-Magistrate entails many other miscellaneous duties, which vary in accordance with circumstances and of which it would be difficult to give a complete list. The Government looks to him for information on all important occurrences which take place in his District, he is called on to advise on general schemes which may be under consideration, and he is expected to explain to the people any new orders of the Government which they may not readily understand. In times of stress and difficulty his duties and responsibilities are increased tenfold. If a collision is apprehended between Hindus and Muhammadans, or if an agrarian difficulty is likely to result in outrage, it is to his tact and firmness that the Government looks to prevent violence, and, if necessary, to quell disorder. Should the District be attacked by famine he is responsible for the lives of the people; he must watch minutely, and keep the Government informed of, the progress of events, and must organize and carry out measures of relief. For the proper discharge of his many duties he must be accessible to and intimately acquainted with the inhabitants. This acquaintance cannot be gained at the desk or on the bench, and accordingly the Collector-Magistrate spends several months of the year in camp. During his tours he inspects the working of the various departments with which he is concerned, satisfies himself as to the manner in which his subordinate officers are carrying out their duties, and advises and encourages them in their work. At the same time he gets to know the people of all parts of the District, and they have a ready opportunity of discussing their affairs with him. The local magnates will visit his tent with some ceremony; the village elders will come and chat with him about the prospect of their crops, the assessment of their lands, the opening of a new school, some local quarrel regarding a right of way, the dacoity which occurred in the village during the preceding summer, and the many other details in which the ‘Sarkār’ touches their daily life. A Collector of strong and sympathetic character and with the gift of insight may gain the strongest hold over the affections and imagination of the peasantry, and tales of his sagacity and good deeds will be told in remote villages many years after his name has ceased to be borne on the civil list of his Province.
Two of the most important executive officers of the District are the Superintendent of Police and the Civil Surgeon. The former, who is almost always a European, is responsible for the discipline and working of the police force. In matters relating to the detection and suppression of crime and the peace of the District he is under the control of the District Magistrate, but he is directly subordinate to his departmental head in so far as the internal management of the force is concerned. The Civil Surgeon is (except in Bombay) the head of the medical and sanitary administration of the District as well as of that of the head-quarters town. He supervises hospitals and dispensaries, has charge of the vaccination establishment, and is the adviser of the Collector in all matters connected with the health of the people. He is also, as a rule, in direct charge of the District jail. Another important official is (in Madras and Bengal) the District or Local Fund Engineer, who is a servant of the District Board and looks after its roads and other engineering works. The local organization of Government Public Works, Forests, Education, and other special departments varies in different parts of the country, and the jurisdiction of their principal local officers—Superintending and Executive Engineers, Conservators and Deputy Conservators of Forests, Inspectors of Schools, &c.—does not always correspond with the limits of revenue Districts. Each District has its law officer, styled the Government Pleader, who conducts the prosecution in session trials and sometimes appears for the Government in other cases.
When not on tour the Collector-Magistrate and the other principal officials reside at the head-quarters station, which usually adjoins the principal native town. Here are collected the Government offices and court-houses, thronged on a busy day with a motley crowd of suitors, pleaders, clerks, constables, shopkeepers, and peasants. In the head-quarters town will also be found the principal hospital and the District jail; probably also the largest English school, and perhaps a college affiliated to the University of the Province.
The Collector-Magistrate is aided in his multifarious duties by a large staff of subordinate officers, some of whom are his assistants at head-quarters and others hold charge of portions of the District. In general the Districts are split up into ‘subdivisions’ under junior officers of the Indian Civil Service, or members of the Provincial Service styled Deputy Collectors, and these again into minor charges bearing different names and held by officers of the Subordinate service. The large Madras Districts contain as a rule four or five subdivisions ; in other Provinces the number is usually smaller. In Madras and Bengal the Subdivisional officers reside within their jurisdiction and have court-houses, offices, a sub-treasury, and a sub-jail at their head-quarters ; but as a rule the largest subdivision of a Bengal District is directly administered by the Collector. In Bombay and the United Provinces, where the component areas of the subdivisions are subject to alteration, the Subdivisional officers, when not touring through their charges, live at the head-quarters of the District. The Subdivisional officer has, under the control of the Collector, general charge of the executive and magisterial administration of his subdivision. In Madras, Bombay, and the United Provinces there are smaller sub-district units styled tāluks or tahsīls, and administered by tahsīldārs (in Bombay māmlatdārs), who belong to the Subordinate service and are assisted in large tāluks by deputy or naib tahsīldārs. In Madras and Bombay these officers are under the immediate control of the Subdivisional officer. In Bengal the lowest unit is the subdivision, and the Sub-Deputy Collectors assist the Collector and Subdivisional officers but have no separate charge of their own. The area of an ordinary tahsīl or tāluk is from 400 to 600 square miles : in the United Provinces it is smaller than in Madras or Bombay. In Madras the tahsīldār is generally confined to revenue and general work, magisterial duties being performed by a separate officer styled the ‘stationary sub-magistrate’; elsewhere the tahsīldārs (or officials who occupy a corresponding position) have magisterial as well as revenue functions. The tahsīldār is assisted by subordinate officers styled revenue inspectors or kānungos, and the village officials, who are largely hereditary, complete the list. The most important of these are the headman, who collects the revenue, and in Madras is also a petty magistrate and civil judge ; the karnam, kārkun, or patwāri1, who keeps the village accounts, registers of holdings, and in general all records connected with the land revenue ; and the chaukīdār or village watchman, who is the rural policeman. As will be shown in a subsequent chapter, the Indian village organization is of great antiquity, and it still finds its place, with the modifications necessitated by the greater control and complexity of our governmental system, in the fabric of British rule.
The judicial administration of the country is described in the chapter on Legislation and Justice, and it will suffice here to mention, in descending gradation, the principal classes of courts in the regulation Provinces. These are:—
(1) For both Criminal and Civil Justice:—
(a) The High Court, which consists of Indian Civilians, British barristers, and native lawyers.
(b) The District and Sessions Courts, manned by Indian Civilians and members of the Provincial Service.
(2) For Criminal Justice only:—
(a) The Courts of the District Magistrate and his Assistant and Deputy Magistrates, nearly all of whom are, like himself, magistrates of the first class.
(b) The Courts of subordinate magistrates, who are of the second and third class, and who as a rule exercise also revenue jurisdiction as tahsīldārs, &c., and are, almost without exception, natives of India.
(3) For Civil Justice only:—
(a) Subordinate Judges' Courts.
(b) Courts of District Munsifs.
The Subordinate Judges stand to the District Judge in much the same relation as other magistrates of the first class do to the District Magistrate, while the position of the Munsifs corresponds roughly with that of the subordinate magistracy on the criminal side. Subordinate Judges and District Munsifs are almost invariably natives of India and are frequently recruited from the native bar.
The extent to which the non-regulation system diverges from that just described varies in different Provinces in accordance with their importance and the progress which they have made. The head of the administration is a Lieutenant-Governor in the Punjab and Burma1, and a Chief Commissioner in the Central Provinces1. He governs with the aid of a Secretariat, departmental chiefs, and a gradation of local officers. The superior officers of the general branch of the service form the ‘Commission’ of the Province. In former times members of the Commission were drawn from a variety of sources, but recruitment is now in general confined to the Indian Civil Service and officers of the Indian Army2. It is thus an important point of difference from the regulation system that the higher posts are not wholly reserved to the Indian Civil Service. The executive head of the District is styled ‘Deputy Commissioner’ and not Collector: those of his subordinates who belong to the Commission are called ‘Assistant Commissioners,’ and members of the Provincial Service ‘Extra Assistant Commissioners.’ With the exception of Oudh, which is under the United Provinces Board, none of the non-regulation Provinces has a Board of Revenue. In the Punjab and Burma the functions of the Board are exercised by a single officer called the Financial Commissioner. In the Central Provinces the Commissioners of Divisions and the head-quarters revenue officers are immediately subordinate to the Local Government. The District administration—revenue, general, and magisterial—runs on the same lines as in the regulation Provinces; but the District Magistrates and some of their first-class subordinates exercise more extensive criminal jurisdiction. They may be invested with power to try all cases not punishable with death and to inflict sentences of imprisonment or transportation up to seven years. Moreover, in the less advanced Provinces administrative and judicial functions are frequently combined. Thus in Burma the Commissioner of the Division has hitherto been the Court of Sessions and the principal local Civil Judge, though in some Divisions he is assisted by an additional Sessions Judge. Below his court come in order the District court, the subdivisional court, and the court of the township which corresponds to the tāluk or tahsīl of India proper. These courts are usually presided over by the executive head of the area which they serve, though in some localities there are separate District Judges. In the Punjab, on the other hand, the system approximates to that in force in the regulation Provinces, save that the judicial functions exercised elsewhere by a District Judge are divided between a Divisional Judge, in charge of one or more Districts, and a local District Judge who discharges less important functions. In the Punjab and Lower Burma there are Chief Courts, consisting of several judges appointed by the Governor-General-in-Council, and approximating in their constitution and powers to the High Courts of the regulation Provinces. In Upper Burma, the Central Provinces, Oudh, and Sind the ordinary functions of a High Court are exercised by one or more officers styled Judicial Commissioners.
It remains to give a brief description of the character of the administration in the minor Provinces which have not been included in the above account. The following is a list of these :—
| Thousands of square miles. | Thousands of inhabitants. | |
|---|---|---|
| North-West Frontier Province | 16 | 2,125 |
| British Baluchistān (British and Administered territory) | 46 | 308 |
| Coorg | 1.6 | 181 |
| Ajmer-Merwāra | 2.7 | 477 |
| The Andaman and Nicobar Islands | 3 | 25 |
The first two Provinces are divided into Districts, administered by Deputy Commissioners as in the larger non-regulation Provinces. The Agents to the Governor-General in Baluchistān and Rājputāna, and the Resident in Mysore, are ex-officio the Chief Commissioners of British Baluchistān, Ajmer-Merwāra, and Coorg respectively. The Superintendent of the Penal Settlement of Port Blair is Chief Commissioner of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, while Berār, formerly a separate Province under the charge of the Resident at Hyderābād, has since October, 1903, been attached, for administrative purposes, to the Central Provinces.
The North-West Frontier Province is administered on the lines of the parent Province of the Punjab. The Chief Commissioner is also Agent to the Governor-General for political relations with the frontier tribes, and is assisted by a small Secretariat. His principal officers are a Revenue and a Judicial Commissioner, who correspond, in a measure, with the Financial Commissioner and Chief Court of the Punjab. The various departments under the control of separate officials, such as the Inspector-General of Police and the Administrative Medical Officer, are less in number than in a more considerable Province. Public Instruction in this Province and in Baluchistān is supervised by a single Inspector-General. For judicial purposes the Province is divided into two civil and sessions divisions.
The Province of Baluchistān is made up of (1) British Baluchistān, comprising three Districts; (2) the Agency territories, which consist of districts held on lease; and (3) the Native States of Kalāt and Las Bela. Under the Chief Commissioner is an officer who is both Revenue and Judicial Commissioner.
For the District of Coorg the Resident in Mysore is both Chief and Judicial Commissioner. The highest local authority is the Commissioner, whose duties extend practically to every part of the administration. The internal organization is similar to that of an ordinary British District. Ajmer and Merwāra are administered by a Commissioner under the Agent to the Governor-General in Rājputāna. Each of the small component Districts is managed by an Assistant Commissioner.
The Andaman and Nicobar Islands derive their administrative importance from the circumstance that the Penal Settlement of Port Blair is situated in the former. The Superintendent of the Settlement is also entrusted with the general administration of the islands, and maintains relations with their wild aboriginal inhabitants. He is assisted by a Deputy Superintendent and several Assistants, who form the ‘Port Blair Commission.’
Notes
- 1. In 1905, Assam, with a large portion of Bengal, was constituted a new Lieutenant-Governorship, under the style of ‘Eastern Bengal and Assam.’
- 1. Sind, which is a part of the Bombay Presidency, is however a non-regulation area, and its Commissioner has somewhat larger powers than those mentioned below as appertaining to the ordinary Commissioners of Divisions.
- 2. A third member was added in 1902 to the Board of the United [p. 48] Provinces, for a period of four years, mainly for the purpose of dealing with Settlement work.
- 1. The production of opium in Bengal and the United Provinces is under the Bengal Board of Revenue, which works in the latter Province through an agent at Ghāzīpur.
- 1. In Provinces where there is a Board of Revenue that body acts as Court of Wards. In Burma it has not hitherto been found necessary to establish such a court. In the Punjab the functions of a Court of Wards are discharged by the Financial Commissioner ; and in the Central Provinces, and in Bombay (since 1905), by the Divisional Commissioners.
- 1. In Northern India one patwāri usually serves a group of villages.
- 1. And, since 1905, also in Assam, which remains 'non-regulation' in the new Province of Eastern Bengal and Assam.
- 1. Oudh is under the Lieutenant-Governor of the United Provinces of Agra and Oudh; and Sind, as already stated, under the Governor of Bombay.
- 2. Recruitment of military officers has been discontinued in the Punjab since 1903, and in Assam since 1906. Burma is thus the only major Province in which military as well as civilian officers are now recruited for the Commission.