The forests of the Indian Empire extend between the eighth and thirty-fifth degrees of north latitude, and flourish at elevations varying from sea-level to 12,000 feet and more. Although the changes in the characteristics of the vegetation between these limits must necessarily be of considerable importance, yet those due to differences in latitude alone are not so marked as might be expected from comparison with similar circumstances in Europe, nor is any abrupt demarcation of species apparent. While some trees are characteristic of Southern or Northern India, others are distributed in suitable localities over the whole area of the country; and it becomes evident that the forest vegetation cannot be classified by distance from the equator alone, but that other and more effective influences have to be considered. Of these the principal is the rainfall, which by quantity and distribution, regulated chiefly by the geographical position and physical features of the locality, decides to a great extent the character of the most important forest growths.
For practical purposes Indian forest tracts may be divided into the following four zones: the Wet with a rainfall of over 75 inches, the Moist with a rainfall of over 50 inches, the Intermediate with a rainfall of over 30 inches, and the Dry with a rainfall under that amount. Within these zones the Evergreen, the Deciduous, and the Dry forests of India may readily be located, while, influenced even to a greater extent by elevation, tides, and inundations than by rainfall, we get Alpine, Tidal, and Riparian forests to complete the classification.
Of these classes by far the most important, as regards both extent and value, is that comprising the Deciduous forests. From the foot of the Himālayas they extend throughout the length and breadth of the Peninsula, and recur farther east in Burma wherever rainfall and soil is suitable to their growth. They furnish the valuable timbers of sāl, ironwood, teak, red sanders, sandal, rosewood, and ebony, as well as other important genera, such as Terminalia, Anogeissus, Acacia, Sterculia, Eugenia, and Hardwickia. Here also are found the Indian padauk (Acacia Catechu), noted as yielding ‘cutch,’ and other trees that supply the wood oils and varnishes so largely used in the domestic life of the inhabitants of the country.
Next in importance to the Deciduous forests must be ranked those thriving in moister climates, and known as Evergreen. These forests occur chiefly on the west coast of India, in Burma, in the Andamans, and to some extent in the sub-Himālayan tracts. Not that all species found in these areas retain their foliage throughout the year; for, as before remarked, the changes in the character of the vegetation are nowhere abrupt, and hence teak, ironwood, Dipterocarpus, Albizzia, and padauk, with other species, may be found in the Evergreen as well as in the Deciduous forests. Among trees characteristic of the Evergreen forests may be mentioned Terminalia, Cedrela Toona, the wild mango, Calophyllum tomentosum, Artocarpus, and species of Pterocarpus.
The Dry forests are found in the Punjab and in Central India. Their produce is not of much value. Acacia, Sterculia, Butea, Terminalia, Albizzia, Melia, and Dalbergia are all represented, but the trees are mostly stunted or ill-grown.
The Alpine forests of Northern India, Burma, and Assam comprise roughly the tree vegetation between 12,000 and 3,000 feet of elevation; and the sequence of species may approximately be stated as juniper, birch, spruce, fir and cedars, cypress and oak, and rhododendron, while Pinus longifolia, and P. Khasya farther east, flourish at lower elevations, and finally mix with the Deciduous forests of the plains. In the Alpine forests, in suitable conditions of soil, aspect, and temperature, may be found many trees well known in Europe, such as yew, box, and walnut, while ivy, mistletoe, and roses are abundant.
The Tidal forests occur on those alluvial lands which are subject to overflow of the tide, and are largely represented on the coast of Burma and in the Sundarbans of Bengal, as well as in the northern coast districts of Madras. They contain great store of valuable fuel, and also excellent timber, as represented by the ‘sundri’ wood of Bengal; while a comparatively new product, the ‘Borneo cutch’ of commerce—a powerful tanning agent extracted from the bark of several species of mangrove—now adds to their importance.
The Riparian forests of India are typically represented in the Punjab and in Burma. In the former the principal constituents of these forests consist of Acacia arabica and Tamarix, interspersed with Dalbergia Sissoo and poplar, which, however, gradually give way to scrub and grass as the distance from the water-supply increases. In Burma the forests spring from a muddy soil, which at certain seasons is deeply inundated. Species of Anogeissus and Mangifera are frequent, while Eugenia and Elaeocarpus are also found. The forest vegetation merges gradually into that typical of the area affected by tidal influences.
The foregoing description presents a very brief general view of the forests of the Indian Empire. Considered in detail, it will be found that the forest growth is influenced by climate, by aspect, by the composition of the soil, by the depth of the permanent water-supply, and that these influences account for the unexpected appearance of species (covering, it may be, large areas) in zones generally deemed unsuitable to their growth.
The influence of forests on the climate of the country and the fertility of the soil is of special interest in India. As forests are dependent for existence on water supplied by precipitation, by percolation, or by inundation, so are they locally responsible, in India even more than in the more temperate countries of the West, not only for the storage of rainfall water in the soil, given off subsequently by gentle flow, but also for the supply, by transpiration from the foliage, of moisture to the air. In those vast deciduous forests of Upper India where the leaf flush occurs in the early hot weather, the effect of the rapid unfolding of the new foliage in reducing the temperature is so marked as to be at once perceptible; and indeed these areas continue, so long as the leaves retain their vigour, cooler than the surrounding country. On the other hand, the harmful effects of heavy rainfall in localities denuded of forest growth have necessitated costly works of afforestation even in Europe, while in India, with its heavy tropical downpours, the disastrous consequences are far more serious. The water flows off the bare soil without benefiting the surrounding country, and may cause disastrous floods many miles below; while the change in climate following on the withdrawal of moisture from the air may alter the whole character of the vegetation, and thus annihilate some cultural industry. In short, the forests form the head-works of Nature's irrigation scheme in India; and if these are injured or destroyed, the advantages of a regular water-supply may be replaced by the tempestuous action of sudden floods until such time as man, with the aid of costly appliances, intervenes to restore equilibrium.
Forests in India have therefore a value to the state far in excess of their mere financial profits. The grazing which they annually afford to countless herds assumes a special value in years of drought, when it renders material assistance in saving from starvation the cattle upon which the agriculture of the country depends. They afford to the villagers who inhabit their vicinity a ready supply of material for house-building and thatching, of fuel, and of minor forest products, which add substantially to the comforts of their life. And the use of forest leaves as manure for the cultivator's fields has already assumed large dimensions, and is steadily spreading as the increasing pressure of population renders agricultural practice more intensive. Enough has been said to emphasize the value of forests, indirectly as regulating the water-supply and moderating the climate ; directly as providing those products which in the tropical, sub-tropical, or temperate portions of the country are essential to the welfare of the inhabitants. Of the Indian forests as a source of revenue to the state, as providing timber and other products which are utilized throughout the world, and as, in some cases, creating and maintaining special industries, more will be said hereafter ; but it is first desirable to note what extent of forest land is under the direct management of the state, and to judge therefrom to what degree the beneficial influences of forests can affect the country as a whole.
Statistics compiled in 1901 show that 208,369 square miles may be thus classified, representing nearly 22 per cent. of the total area of British India. At first sight it might be inferred that the proportion between forest and other land had been duly maintained, and this would indeed be the case if the distribution of forest areas were at all uniform. Provincial statistics show, however, that the percentage of forest land varies from 3·86 in the United Provinces to 44·06 in Assam, 61·19 in Burma, and 97·55 in the Andamans ; and it may be generally said that the denser the population and the more urgent the demand for the local advantages that forests confer, the less the extent to which these advantages can be enjoyed. The difficulty is one which has been caused by the increase of population and the wasteful practices of former generations. To burn the forest for the welfare of the cattle of nomadic tribes, to clear it for the purpose of temporary tillage, to destroy it for the creation of permanent cultivation, has been the rule in past centuries, and indeed still holds good wherever the Government has not intervened to prohibit such practices. From the distant forests in the far east of India, where wild tribes still practise shifting cultivation, and where the peasant in the more settled lands holds in contempt all timber save that afforded by the 'royal tree' (teak), to the civilized districts of the west where the cultivator and the trader eagerly accept timber of species elsewhere despised; from a density of 6 persons to one of 600 to the square mile—amid these extremes may be noticed the influence of man on the forests of the Empire, and the tardily learned lesson of the necessity of protection.
The forests under the direct control of the state are classified as 'Reserved,' 'Protected,' and 'Unclassed' or 'Public' forest land. The Reserves are forests intended to be maintained permanently for the supply of timber, fuel, and other produce, or for the protection of the water-supply or other similar reasons. The Protected forests may be either in a state of transition to Reserves or intended to remain permanently in the second class. In the former case it has been found necessary to prohibit within these areas certain acts harmful to the forest until such time as careful examination permits of a decision whether more stringent rules shall be enforced; in the latter, the object in view has been to provide for the more beneficial exercise of rights by local communities. The Unclassed or Public forest lands are those given over with even fewer restrictions (in some cases to the extent of exemption from the operation of forest law) for the use of the public. Out of the 208,369 square miles under state management in 1901, 88,140 square miles had been reserved, 10,488 were protected, and the remaining 109,741 were unclassed. It will be surmised, and rightly, that the largest area of unclassed forests must occur in those Provinces where the population is scantiest; in fact Burma claims 80 per cent. of the total area under this head, while Assam appropriates the bulk of the balance. In Burma exploration is still incomplete and each year brings an increase of hundreds of square miles to the Reserves; and thus, owing to the fortunate possibility of intervention before the destruction or deterioration of the forest had been accomplished, a forest estate is being built up in that Province which in the future will be unique in organization and value.
To the Indian Forest department is entrusted the duty of carrying out the policy of Government in forest management, first with a view to the welfare of the country as a whole, secondly for the benefit of the individuals in the more immediate vicinity of the forest, and lastly with the object of utilizing to the utmost such products as the forests supply and thereby increasing the revenues of the state. The creation, growth, and organization of this department will now be briefly described.
At the beginning of the nineteenth century the attention of the British Government was directed to the importance of maintaining the timber supply of the country, but there is no record to show that the value of the forests was recognized save as furnishing sufficient teak for the construction of the fleets or public buildings of the future. Appointed as Conservator of Forests in Malabar in 1806, Captain Watson, during the following fifteen years, protected the teak forests by the method of declaring that timber a Government monopoly. His retirement without a successor was followed by an energetic renewal of those abuses which he had prohibited, and for many years subsequently immense damage was caused by unrestricted felling over large areas. In 1847 Dr. Gibson was appointed Conservator of Forests in Bombay, and nine years later Dr. Cleghorn received a similar appointment in Madras; but although both these officers insisted on the physical value of the forests, and pointed, as results of denudation of the hills, to the silting up of the beds of navigable rivers and the diminution of the water-supply of the country, forest conservancy continued for many years to be regarded mainly as a direct source of revenue to the state. Further east the supply of teak from the forests of Tenasserim had attracted attention as early as 1827, but here also many years elapsed before efficient measures were taken to protect the timber resources of the country against the recklessness of irresponsible contractors. The annexation of Pegu in 1852 opened a new field for the spoliation of Government forests by private individuals, but this was happily checked when three years later Lord Dalhousie inaugurated a permanent forest policy.
In 1856 Dr. (now Sir) Dietrich Brandis was summoned from Germany to be Superintendent of Forests in Pegu. He remained in Burma till 1862, engaged in organizing forest management in that Province; and, after having been placed on special duty to perform the same work in other parts of India, he was in 1864 selected to be the first Inspector-General of Forests to the Government of India, a post he retained for nineteen years. To him and to his successors and pupils, Messrs. Schlich and Ribbentrop, is due primarily the credit for the creation and organization of the Forest department, and for the introduction of methods of management adapted from the best European schools to suit the varied circumstances of the vast forests of India.
The first Inspector-General of Forests found himself for some time without an organized controlling or executive staff, for no trained officers were available and those already in the Forest service had been selected from other departments. It was not until 1869 that the first graded list of the Indian Forest service was published, containing the names of 57 officers, with aggregate salaries of about Rs. 95,000 per annum.
The increase in the operations of the department since that date may to some extent be gauged by the increase in establishment, which will ultimately comprise an Imperial and a Provincial service, with a staff of 175 and 134 officers respectively, having under their orders a body of 14,824 subordinates, of whom 10,465 are permanently and the remainder temporarily employed. This forest staff draws in salaries an annual sum amounting to nearly 45 lakhs of rupees.
Subject to the general supervision of the Government of India, the control of Forest administration rests in each Province with the Local Government, which holds the Forest Conservator responsible not only for the proper application of the correct principles of forestry suitable to the conditions of the Province, but also for the departmental and financial management of his Circle. This responsibility is defined in the lower grades by the formation of Divisions, corresponding as far as may be to revenue Districts and held in charge by officers of the Imperial or Provincial services; and of Ranges and Beats in charge of members of the Subordinate service. Forest operations are, however, subject to the control of the local executive officers (Collectors, &c.), in matters which directly affect the people, such as the reservation of grazing, the levy of grazing fees, the supply of minor forest products, and the like.
The officers of the Imperial service are recruited in England, where, after passing a competitive examination, they receive a technical education extending over nearly three years, the forestry course at the Royal Indian Engineering College, Cooper's Hill1, being supplemented by extensive tours and some months' residence in typical continental forests. The recruitment of the Provincial service is effected from among those members of the Subordinate service who have obtained the higher certificate of the Imperial Forest School at Dehra Dūn; while the members of the Subordinate service are appointed by Divisional Forest Officers, who are held responsible that suitable men possessing a fair elementary education are selected, in the first instance, for forest guards.
In addition to the Forest School at Dehra Dūn, an institution established in 1878 which annually receives over fifty pupils, opportunities for the acquisition of a forest education are afforded by the Government at Poona in the Bombay Presidency; and in Burma, where special difficulties exist, a secondary school has of late years been opened. At these institutions all students are provided with a technical education, free of cost, by the state, while members of the Forest service under training receive the pay and allowances of their grade; and thus every inducement is offered for the acquisition of a knowledge of practical forestry by the natives of the country. At the same time a forest education in English is now much more readily obtained than was the case some years ago, for works on Indian botany, engineering, forestry, sylviculture, and other sciences intimately connected therewith, have from time to time been published by the officers of the Forest service.
It is not therefore surprising that the officers of the department, provided with an excellent technical education and fortified with the varied experience that service in India supplies, should be in demand to conduct the management of forests in other parts of the world or to report on the best system for their organization. In Cape Colony, in Uganda, in the Sūdān, in Nigeria, and in Siam, Forest officers supplied by the Indian Government are now applying the lessons learnt in the jungles of India; in the Straits Settlements, in Mauritius, Cyprus, Ceylon, the West Indies, and elsewhere advice has been given or organization effected by the same agency; while the forests of the more important Native States are often managed by officers deputed from the department or trained in the Forest schools of the country. The forests of the Indian Empire have also been visited, and the methods applied in them professionally studied, by officials from France, Germany, Japan, and other countries.
The basis on which Indian forest law proceeds is that all uncultivated tracts in which private rights have not been acquired, either by the individual or by a local community, are the property of the state. The position of the Government as owner of forest lands carries with it great responsibilities, and it was soon recognized that unless these areas were brought under some control they would in many cases be so diminished or ruined by wasteful use as to become incapable of supplying the legitimate demands of the population for timber and other products. In fact, with the growth of population, it became impossible to continue the ancient system by which each man took from the jungle all that he required to a great extent without supervision, and in many cases free of charge. On the other hand, the areas over which the state claimed proprietary rights, and the extent to which such rights required to be tempered by the recognition of local claims and usages, needed to be defined; there was no adequate machinery by which the settlement or reservation of forest areas could be carried out or control assumed over their management; and thus the necessity for forest legislation became apparent. The first Indian Forest Act was passed in 1865, and under its authority a large number of local rules were issued in the Central Provinces, the Punjab, Burma, Berār, Coorg, and the United Provinces. Although defective in many respects, this Act remained in force till 1878, when it was replaced by the Forest Act of that year (Act VII of 1878), which extended to all parts of British India save Madras, Burma, and a few minor Administrations. In 1881 a Forest Act was passed for Lower Burma, and in 1887 a Forest Regulation for Upper Burma, then newly annexed; these two Acts have been amalgamated in the Burma Forest Act of 1902. In 1882 the Madras Forest Act was passed, and between that date and 1891 those Provinces to which Act VII of 1878 did not extend received by separate legislation the benefits of forest law.
The first step in applying this law was to discriminate between : (1) forest lands absolutely the property of Government; (2) forests which were state property but burdened with private rights; and (3) forests which were the property of private individuals or communities, but over which it was expedient to exercise a measure of control. It then became necessary to define the limits of the areas to be controlled, and to prepare, where necessary, a settlement record to prevent subsequent encroachment, illegal utilization, or the growth of new rights. The classification of forests into Reserved, Protected, and Unclassed has already been noticed. In those areas to which Act VII of 1878 extends, two classes only of forest are recognized, the Reserved and Protected ; and in Unclassed forests no forest law is operative. In the Madras and Burma Acts, on the other hand, only one class of permanent state forest, the Reserved, is specially dealt with, but power is taken to extend a certain amount of legal protection to all other forest lands.
When it is desired to create a Forest Reserve, three months' notice of the intention is given to all likely to be interested in the proceedings, and after the expiry of that period a local inquiry is instituted by a specially deputed Revenue official, styled the Forest Settlement Officer, who is usually accompanied by an officer of the Forest department. All claims advanced for exercise of rights within the area to be reserved are duly considered, and if acknowledged are recorded in detail in the manner prescribed by law. The Forest Settlement Officer can recommend but not finally record privileges. These require the sanction of Government, for among them is included a practice most destructive to forest growth, that of shifting cultivation, which is still permitted over large areas to the descendants of those who for centuries have existed by means of this thriftless agriculture. After the settlement record is complete, a period for the presentation of appeals to a competent court follows; and when these have been decided and recognized, when local rights have been confirmed or bought up, there remains nothing but the sanction of the Local Government to constitute the Forest Reserve. For the creation of Protected Forests a somewhat similar procedure, but in much simpler form, is adopted. Such inquiry as may be considered adequate is made, and rights may be recorded or regulated, but the record so compiled is not deemed to be conclusive. The main essential in both cases is that all interested shall have an opportunity of advancing their claims; that these claims should be fully considered in an impartial court; and in the case of Reserves, that the record shall be in such detail that the demands on the forest shall be absolutely defined, and that the settlement, once completed, shall be final. The regulations for Unclassed Forest lands are usually framed with a view to permitting free, but not wasteful, utilization of produce for domestic use, and to taxing, by the imposition of a royalty, all articles removed for trade purposes; and by this means the people dwelling in the vicinity of the forest benefit, while a considerable revenue is collected for the state.
After constitution of the forest estate, the duties of the Forest officer commence with the protection and improvement of the areas brought under his management. In the first place, permanent demarcation must be effected for the prevention of encroachment or trespass, and the method in which this is carried out varies with the value and position of the forest. In Provinces where these are a source of important revenue, and where the pressure of population is marked, more expenditure can be legitimately sanctioned than in areas differently circumstanced. All methods, however, agree in the two details of numbering the boundary marks and of constructing a footpath between them. The cost of new demarcation work and repairs to former boundaries amounted in 1901 to Rs. 1,11,000.
Following on demarcation comes the detailed survey of the forest area. It was found in the early days of forest organization that the maps then available were too small in scale, and possessed too little topographical detail, to be of much use in forest work, and in 1872 a special agency was created in the Forest Survey Branch which was under the control of the Inspector-General of Forests until its absorption in 1899 into the Survey of India. The maps now issued for the use of the department can hardly be surpassed in accuracy, in topographical detail, and in the amount of information they afford : there appears to be nothing from classification of forest growth to the depth of the permanent water-supply that cannot be recorded if timely application be made to the Survey officer.
When it becomes desirable to control the working of a forest, to regulate its out-turn, and to provide for the yield of the future, a report is drawn up, and generally forwarded to the Inspector-General of Forests, which describes the area, the vegetation, and the past management, and contains proposals for a fixed and amended management in the future. The Provincial Government then deputes an officer who, after thorough inquiry into the condition of the forest, the prospects of reproduction and improvement, the facilities for export, and the demand for the produce, compiles a ‘working-plan.’ This plan regulates the amount and removal of out-turn, and prescribes the other requisite operations, such as sowing, planting, thinning, and cleaning. The measures necessary to ensure protection from fire or cattle are also detailed ; and the construction of roads, bridges, and buildings is systematically prescribed. Working-plans are generally compiled for periods of twenty to forty years, after which revision, or possibly the introduction of an entirely new system of management, will be necessary. The latest available statistics show that 22,679 square miles, or a little over one-fourth of the area of Reserved forests, are worked under regular plans.
In regard to the improvement of communications for the purpose of export, much has been accomplished since the organization of the department. The expenditure necessary under this head varies enormously with the physical configuration of the country. In the hills the construction of timber slides or road-making must always be costly; less so in the plains, where, however, the building of tramways or narrow gauge railways is sometimes justified by the promise of a regularly sustained out-turn. In some Provinces, such as Assam, Bengal, and Burma, forest produce is conveyed along the magnificent river waterways which Nature provides, and in Burma the Forest officer has to pay special attention to the utilization of the feeders of the main rivers as floating-streams. The protection of the forest staff against the inclemencies of the climate by the provision of suitable rest-houses has also received attention. The expenditure on communications and buildings amounted in 1901 to Rs. 4,64,000.
Statistics setting forth the results of the application of forest law and regulations are interesting, as showing the protection these afford against petty depredations or more serious attempts to injure or appropriate state property. In 1900 the Forest cases decided by Magistrates numbered 11,270, of which nearly 87 per cent. resulted in convictions. The majority of cases are, however, not brought into the courts at all, the Forest officers being empowered to compound minor delinquencies for cash payments if the offenders so desire—-32,803 cases were so disposed of in 1900. Taking prosecution and compounded cases together, about 26,000 referred to illegal felling of timber or removal of produce, 17,000 to illicit grazing, and the remainder to injury by fire or other offences. The number of reported cases in which the offenders remained undetected amounted to over 6,000, of which one-third were on account of injury to the forests from fire, an offence the most necessary to punish but the most difficult to prove. Considering the extent of the Indian forests and the ease of evading detection, it may be said that the commission of only one offence annually in each four square miles of area goes to prove that forest law does not press hardly on the people.
The protection of the forest area from fire is one of the most important and arduous duties of the Forest officer. It is true that in these days he has not to contend against the belief that fire is not harmful to forest growth : that in spite of its yearly recurrence the forest will still flourish. Such opinions had necessarily to give way when the opportunity occurred for comparison between similar forests in adjacent areas, protected and unprotected. It is at the present time agreed that, if a soil suited to the maintenance and improvement of the forest is required, and also reproductive growth sufficient to assure a full and regular out-turn, it becomes indispensable to protect the forest from the effects of fire, and that if this is not successfully accomplished other efforts towards improvement will have little result. But in carrying out this policy of protection the difficulty arises that the customs of the country are in direct opposition to it. From time immemorial fire has been, in the hands of uncivilized man, the most powerful agent in destroying the permanent vegetation of the country with a view to obtaining more readily food for himself and his cattle ; and even in those areas where there is no necessity to continue the struggle with the exhausted forest, this ancestral weapon is still employed, though it be but to clear a few acres of waste or to isolate an insignificant patch of shifting cultivation, at the risk of destroying the adjoining forests. Only after the mischief has been done is it realized that the forests have been unnecessarily sacrificed to accomplish a result that a few hours’ mechanical labour and a little care would equally well have brought about. The Indian forester has therefore to contend not only against accidents as understood in civilized countries, but also against the thoughtlessness and ignorance of the people ; he has to uproot old and introduce new habits, and his efforts in this direction must be gradual and adapted to the slow absorption of novel ideas by the peasantry of the East. On the other hand he has rarely to combat popular ill-will. Incendiarism is uncommon, and when it occurs may often be traced to some petty malice against an individual or community. The system of fire-protection may be described generally as consisting in the isolation of the protected area by removing all inflammable material from the vicinity of its boundary, and in regulating the kindling of fire in its neighbourhood ; and this is effected by means of fire-lines on which all vegetation is cut and burnt, combined with the enforcement of simple rules by means of a staff of patrols who prevent, save under certain restrictions, the kindling or carrying of fire. Meanwhile, inside the Reserve, other fire-lines have been prepared with a view to localizing any conflagration that, in spite of all precautions, may cross the boundary or may be produced wilfully or by accident within the forest ; such lines are designed with a view to form bases for counterfiring, or in more moderate climates to permit of other methods of controlling the flames. Fire conservancy operations in British India extended in 1901 over 34,000 square miles and involved an outlay of Rs. 12 per square mile. The extension of fire conservancy is hampered not by financial reasons, for the outlay has been small in proportion to the value of the property insured, but by the local difficulties of the work and the necessity for an executive staff numerically and physically strong enough to carry out successfully this arduous duty. At present, having in view the large areas of valuable Reserves still unprotected, no effort has been made for the welfare of the Unclassed forests ; but the day cannot be very far distant when, as already foreshadowed by the action of the owners of private forests, all those to whom the utilization of forest produce is of importance will, from motives of self-interest, unite in its protection.
The protection of the forests from cattle is a matter of less difficulty though hardly of less importance. As a rule the residents in forest districts have been liberally provided with pasturage in state forests, in some cases to such an extent as to make the production of timber a matter of secondary importance. Much of the trouble caused by cattle trespass may be traced not to the agricultural but to the pastoral classes, who find their operations restricted by the increase of cultivation and by the forest conservancy that naturally follows such increase. It is of course admitted that grazing is inimical, and browsing fatal, to forest regeneration ; that one and the same area cannot at the same time provide unrestricted grazing and a normal out-turn in timber. If therefore the forest is managed for the benefit of the people, it is necessary to decide whether they require grazing or timber, or if both, then in what proportions. As a rule such questions are settled by the alternate and periodical opening and closure to cattle of fixed areas ; otherwise separate tracts must be permanently allotted for the supply of timber and of pasture. In this regard the vital necessity of detailed definitions in the settlement record is indicated, for generosity in forest grants that extends beyond the capabilities of the forests readily defeats its own object by imposing on the forest capital a tax which should be levied only from its annual yield. The regulation of grazing has, more even than fire conservancy, an influence in preventing the denudation of hill slopes and catchment basins. It is probable, however, that the burden necessarily imposed on state forests in the matter of grazing will hereafter rather diminish than increase, for forest grazing is ill adapted to the maintenance of valuable cattle or to the improvement or purity of any special breed. It may therefore be that in course of time the demand for pasturage will be converted into a demand for fodder, not only to the benefit of the cattle, but with a resulting increase of out-turn in both grass and timber from the forest. The area closed to grazing amounted in 1901 to 35,000 square miles, of which nearly 15,000 square miles were in Burma, where cattle are few and vast tracts of waste land are still available outside Reserves. The area closed to browsers, principally goats, amounted to 33,000 square miles, situated chiefly in Madras and the Central Provinces. The value of pasturage granted free or at reduced rates during the year is estimated at Rs. 11,00,000. It should be noted that in times of famine the ordinary restrictions on grazing are often relaxed.
By far the largest portion of the Deciduous forests in India was, when taken over by the Forest department, in a ruined condition, for not only had the sound mature timber of the more valuable kinds been extracted, but the younger growth had been so maltreated by axe and fire as to be unfit to provide a reliable crop in the future. In these circumstances the removal of existing stock as speedily as might be consistent with the prevention of soil deterioration was the task set before the forester, who was, moreover, responsible that his efforts should result in the reproduction of a healthy growth : these conditions explain the prescription of improvement fellings so frequent in the earlier working-plans. These operations varied necessarily in intensity and method with the circumstances of each individual case, but always had the object of increasing the productive power of the soil by adequate protection, while replacing the injured and useless stock with a healthy growth. The labours of the forester were, however, far from complete when this preliminary treatment had been successfully carried out. It was, it is true, subsequently easy to regulate the out-turn by limiting future selection-fellings by quantity, by area, or by both ; but of the numerous species composing the forest only a few are valuable, and in order to derive a full yield from these, while stimulating their production at the expense of the less valuable trees, the most careful treatment is constantly necessary. This is the case not only in the ruined forests which have passed through a preliminary treatment, but also in those where adverse influences have not sufficed to injure the growing stock to any serious extent. The difficulty here indicated is further emphasized by the fact that the exercise of local rights and grants of free produce frequently cause an almost total absence of demand in the neighbourhood for timber of the inferior kinds, so that the removal of such trees becomes a source of expenditure instead of profit. Nor do these drawbacks cease when the forest has been brought into that condition where the most desirable species are well represented in number and quality, for the pressure of the numerically stronger, and probably quicker-growing, inferior species still continues to be felt and to require the interference of the forester. The natural regeneration of the valuable teak forests in some parts of India is for these reasons a difficult matter to promote, in spite of the experience that the study of years has brought. Even less is known of the production of padauk and ironwood; in fact, in most cases where the species in demand are scattered throughout a mixed forest of which they form but a small proportion, though much has been learned more yet remains to be ascertained. As a general rule, in such circumstances, the principal fellings may be preceded, accompanied, or supplemented by other operations, having in view both the girdling and removal of inferior trees and the diminution of the under-growth, in order, by the admission of light, to permit of the germination and continuance of seedlings of the more important species. Although the cost of these operations, and the necessity for carrying them on under the strictest supervision, limit their extension, they have in many instances been successfully accomplished. In the sāl forests this has been the case in a most marked manner, due possibly not only to the fact that this tree forms a larger percentage of the total forest stock than the teak, but also that it responds more readily to the advantages of protection than the other species with which it is associated. In the Alpine forests such aid to natural reproduction is not usually required, as this follows as a general rule with certainty on adequate conservancy and judicious treatment of the canopy. But though it is necessary to rely almost entirely on natural reproduction in order to maintain the forest stock, occasions arise when Nature can be assisted, not only in the preparation of a suitable seed-bed, but also in conveying seed to the desired locality. The broadcast sowings on barren hill slopes in Bombay, the dibbling of teak and cutch seed in Burma in areas where flowering bamboos have been cleared by fire, are instances in point.
Of natural reproduction by means of coppice growth there are many excellent examples to be found in India, chiefly in those districts where the demand for small timber and fuel is intense, but also on areas where the local conditions are unfavourable to the growth of large trees. In such forests it is usual to retain a certain number of seed-bearers of the more important species, so that natural seedlings may aid in the regeneration of the forest. The financial return under this system of management is often very high.
The operations undertaken for the good of the growing stock, in addition to felling and girdling, are chiefly confined to climber-cutting and thinning or weeding. The latter serves to remove such stems as may be interfering with the more valuable immature trees and, as this requires constant professional supervision, can be carried out only over limited areas. The cutting of climbers and killing of epiphytes may, on the other hand, be mechanically performed by members of the protective staff, and in consequence large areas are yearly treated for the destruction of these pests. Thinnings and weedings in natural forests are not generally carried out as a separate work; they progress side by side with other cultural operations and are included in their cost.
Artificial plantations in the forests of India extend over 102,000 acres. One-half of this area is situated in Burma and one-third in Madras, the remainder being distributed in comparatively small patches throughout the other Provinces. Teak, sissū, catechu, casuarina, eucalyptus, rubber, and deodār are the principal species cultivated. The oldest teak plantation is that at Nilambūr in the Malabar District of the Madras Presidency. Started in 1842, it has already repaid its original cost and is expected to yield a large income in the future. The plantations in Burma consist chiefly of those described as ‘taungya,’ where the practice of shifting cultivation is permitted provided that teak is sown with the field crop. This system was adapted to the customs of the country, and a large area has thus been stocked with this valuable species. The advisability of supplementing the supply of rubber from natural forests by creating plantations has not been lost sight of. For the past thirty years there has been an important rubber plantation in Assam, while from experience gained there and in smaller experimental gardens elsewhere it has been decided to extend systematically rubber planting in Burma on a large scale. The expenditure on plantations in 1901 amounted to Rs. 1,30,000. Although the areas under artificial reproduction can represent only an insignificant proportion of the vast forests of India, yet in cases where it may be requisite to restock speedily denuded tracts, to provide for pressing requirements in some special forest product, to utilize waste lands, or to extend the area under some valuable species, these operations are often necessary and, at the same time, remunerative.
The out-turn from the forests of India is for the sake of convenience generally classified under Timber, including fuel ; Bamboos ; and Minor Produce, including grass and grazing, besides all those numerous products found or manufactured in a forest. Of the timbers the most important are teak, deodār, sāl, sissu, ebony and rosewood, blackwood, cutch, sandal, babūl, red sanders, ironwood, and padauk. There are hundreds of other species possessing admirable technical qualities ; but few of these have any value save for local consumption, being as yet unrecognized by trade, or not occurring in sufficient quantities to secure for them a permanent footing in industries that could utilize them. The total out-turn of timber and fuel from state forests amounted in 1901 to 232,000,000 cubic feet ; the average out-turn per square mile varies considerably in the different Provinces, being dependent on the intensity of working and the density of the population. Over 3,500,000 cubic feet of teak, valued at Rs. 87,00,000, were exported during the year to foreign countries, whither sandal, ebony, and other ornamental woods were also sent to the value of Rs. 10,70,000. The yield of bamboos numbered 185,000,000; of these about one-third were supplied by Burma—Bengal, Assam, and the Central Provinces coming next on the list. The yield of minor produce from state forests was valued in 1901 at nearly 50 lakhs of rupees, the chief items being grazing and grass, caoutchouc, lac and dyes, cutch and gambier, cardamoms, myrabolams and other tanning material. The minor forest produce exported from India during the same period represented a value of 175 lakhs, derived probably to the extent of two-thirds or more from forests not under state management.
Inquiries instituted into the economic possibilities of Indian forests are gradually bringing to notice the value of new products and directing attention to others heretofore only locally utilized ; while the efforts made towards the improvement and protection of the forests are resulting in a larger out-turn of those products for which there is already an assured market. The importance of the Indian forests from an economical point of view must primarily depend on the demand for their yield in India. Thus, increased prosperity among the rural population, or the establishment of new industries, is always accompanied by an increase in forest revenue; and it is only when the forest yield is in excess of local requirements or, for special reasons, commands abroad a higher price than is justified by its local importance, that the unutilized balance is made available for export. For these reasons the valuable timbers of the red padauk and teak are now only sparingly used by the inhabitants of the country, while various articles of minor forest produce, such as lac, silk, wax, tanning materials, catechu, wood, oil and varnishes, and resin, which are produced in excess of the local demand, form important items in the trade returns with foreign countries. With regard to these by-products of the forest it appears probable that the full yield is seldom used to advantage save in areas under carefully regulated management. Where the population is dense and utilization of the forest unrestricted a sustained yield becomes impossible. Where, on the other hand, the population is scanty compared with the extent of the forest, the inhabitants are unable to reap fully the scattered crop which lies at their disposal. It thus becomes evident that both the economic value and the yield of Indian forests must at first increase with the increase of population, while ultimately the restriction of the forest area consequent on the spread of cultivation must be counterbalanced by ever-increasing forethought in the management of those areas which are permanently set aside by the state or by private owners for the supply of forest produce. In this way alone can the economic value of the Indian forests be maintained, first with the object of satisfying the growing needs of the people, and thereafter with a view to the commercial advantages which must result from regulated protection and exploitation.
The methods of exploitation are ruled by the requirements of the different Provinces, and a broad classification under the heads of removal by Government agency, by purchasers, and by right-holders, is generally found to give sufficient detail combined with desirable simplicity. The regulation of the out-turn by means of working-plans has already been described, and those forests as yet not specially provided for by these schemes are controlled by means of annual plans of operations, which, among other details, fix the method of exploitation. But this regular system is only of comparatively recent introduction. In former times, in the absence of departmental organization, the forests were opened to private traders who neither attended to the future welfare of the forests nor afforded to the state an adequate return for the produce extracted. In the hill forests of the Punjab, in Burma, and in parts of the Central and United Provinces the ill effects of this system may still be traced. Government agency in exploitation is at present chiefly confined to controlling the removal of produce by contractors from the forests to the place of sale ; but, though to a less degree than formerly, it is still sometimes necessary that the Forest department should set an example in inaugurating some new industry, should undertake the construction and working of tramways and timber slides, or arrange for the direct supply of timber or fuel. Removals by Government agency in 1901 comprised 10 per cent. of the total extractions of timber and fuel, 1 per cent. of the out-turn in bamboos, and 4·4 per cent. of that of minor produce.
The removal of timber by purchasers is also regulated in various ways adapted to the customs of the country. In the case of large purchasers (such as the Bombay-Burma Trading Corporation in Burma) whose trade is dependent on the supply of mature timber, permission to fell and remove trees of the more valuable kinds is granted under the conditions of a contract that provides for the payment of royalty at fixed revenue stations ; in the case of smaller purchasers of the less important kinds of timber, felling and removal is allowed under the authority of a pass or licence, the cost of the produce being generally paid in part at the time of its issue. Both these systems, though not affording an ideal degree of protection, are suited to the requirements of the trade and to the amount of supervision available, and special care is taken in checking the removal of the more valuable timber. As regards the collection of minor forest produce, a similar system of passes is adopted, or the productive areas are leased, or personal collecting licences are issued for a fixed period. The collection of grazing dues is often made through the agency of the Land Revenue department, sometimes also by the Forest officer.
The measure of control exercised over the enjoyment of free grants by right-holders depends almost entirely on the demands upon the forest. In some Provinces those so privileged have up to the present seldom exercised their full rights in Reserves, having ample provision for their needs in the adjoining Unclassed areas ; in others the greatest care is necessary to prevent excessive removals of timber from a forest taxed perhaps to the full extent of its yield. Between these two extreme cases the necessity of restrictive rules is determined in the one case registers and permits are not called for, in the other, care is required in their upkeep or issue. It is, however, impossible to give briefly any but the faintest outline of the schemes for regulating the exploitation of timber and produce throughout India, for they differ in each Province and are controlled by a multiplicity of rules adapted to the customs of the inhabitants.
The direct value of forests to the state may be gauged by the financial results of their working. In 1901 the gross revenue collected through the agency of the department amounted to Rs. 1,97,70,000, and the value of grants to right-holders and others was estimated at Rs. 33,10,000. More than 40 per cent. of the total revenue is derived from Burma, while next in importance in this respect come the forests of Bombay and Madras. The sale of timber and fuel produced Rs. 1,47,00,000, minor produce Rs. 29,00,000, and receipts from grazing Rs. 12,00,000. The steady improvement in forest revenue is worthy of note: between 1864 and 1867 it averaged Rs. 36,29,000; by 1887 the quinquennial average had risen to Rs. 1,10,59,000, and by 1897 to Rs. 1,74,50,000. During the same periods the expenditure had increased from Rs. 13,99,000 to Rs. 71,42,000 and Rs. 96,57,000 respectively, while in 1901 it amounted to Rs. 1,11,60,000. The proportion of expenditure to gross revenue is now about 57 per cent.; and of this nearly 26 per cent. is spent on administration, 28 per cent. on working, protection, and improvement, while the remainder represents capital expenditure upon the constitution of new Reserves by settlement and upon their demarcation and survey.
The net revenue of the Indian forests has between 1865 and 1901 risen from Rs. 14,00,000 to Rs. 86,00,000; and the yield of the state forests will, as the result of protection and improvement, be more than sufficient to meet increased demands on their produce hereafter.
In comparing the Government receipts from Indian forests with the gross out-turn and the total exports, it has to be remembered that timber and other produce from state forests is given free (or at reduced rates) in large quantities to the people resident in the vicinity. In 1901 the value of these grants amounted, at a very low estimate, to about 16 per cent. of the gross revenue collected in the state forests, while the enormous quantities of timber and produce removed free of royalty from Unclassed forest land have further to be taken into consideration. It has also to be borne in mind that there are in India immense forest areas outside the direct control of the British Government, being the property of Native States or of private individuals. The statistics regarding these forests are difficult to obtain, as in many cases the areas are unsurveyed or their administration is not separately controlled, but the following details are of interest.
Taking first the most important Native States, where a more or less complete system of forest management has been introduced, the following may be mentioned :—
Hyderābād possesses an area of about 5,000 square miles of State forests, which produced in 1900 a revenue of about Rs. 2,80,000, against an expenditure of one-half that amount. These results will probably be much improved when the forests are demarcated and settled; at present there is much to be done in these directions.
Mysore possesses about 2,000 square miles of Reserves, with a gross revenue in 1900 of about 13½ lakhs and a net revenue of nearly 9 lakhs. Nearly three-fourths of the revenue is derived from the sale of sandal wood. Fire-protection extends over 1,500 square miles.
Kashmīr has 2,180 square miles of settled State forests where fire-protection is well established. The revenue in 1901 amounted to Rs. 8,80,000, with an expenditure of Rs. 5,80,000.
Jodhpur, on a forest area of 343 square miles, collected in 1901 a revenue of about Rs. 20,000 and expended nearly the same amount.
Travancore has 1,800 square miles of Reserves, nearly all being fire-protected. The revenue in 1901 was about 5½ lakhs and the expenditure a little in excess of 2 lakhs.
Besides these States there are others of less importance that possess large forest areas amounting on a very rough estimate to about 42,000 square miles; while the forests owned by private individuals in the British Provinces are supposed to extend to at least 77,000 square miles. Not that the whole of these areas are covered with tree growth. Some contain merely scrub jungle on hill slopes; in others the principal yield is grass or some other minor product. But there are also tracts carrying valuable timber; and as there is, ordinarily speaking, no state interference with private forests, and no special law for their protection, it depends on the owners whether they are treated rationally, with a knowledge of their influence on the welfare of the people and the future income from the estate, or regarded merely as a source of immediate wealth to the individual possessor. The latter case is gradually becoming more rare; the example set by the Government of India, in regulating the management of state forests, and the results of that management in increasing the prosperity of the country and its revenues, are too manifest to be overlooked. The advantages of forest conservancy are accordingly now being recognized not only by the more enlightened Indian princes but by private proprietors throughout the country.
The foregoing paragraphs present a brief account of the creation and management of the state forests of India, but afford no insight into the conditions that have in the past regulated progress in these respects. In the creation of state forests the forester, first as an explorer and then as a pioneer, finds his sphere of action in advance of the wave of civilization caused by increased prosperity in the more settled lands. In his preparations for the requirements of the future he comes in contact with forest tribes who, whether timid or ferocious, simple or cunning, all possess the common characteristic of viewing with intense jealousy any interference with the habits and customs of their primitive life. To them, though perhaps they only dimly realize it, the advance of civilization must mean either extinction or absorption into a population possessing a stronger vitality. The policy of the Government of India is to permit no sudden imposition of restrictions that may alter the accustomed mode of life of these tribes, but rather to win confidence by kindness, and thus gradually to create self-supporting communities, acknowledging the state as arbitrator of those questions hitherto decided by might rather than by justice. It is on the manner of giving effect to this policy that the success of the inauguration of forest conservancy often depends; for here, even more than in the comparatively civilized parts of the Empire, the work of the Forest department can only commence with the acquiescence of the inhabitants, and only progress with their assistance.
With very few exceptions all forest tribes depend to a certain extent on agriculture to supplement their food supply, even though hunting, fishing, and the collection of forest products may form the most important part of their occupation. Most of them are nomadic of necessity; they move in quest of game and practise shifting cultivation at their temporary head-quarters; all are armed with the best weapons they can manufacture or procure; and as a rule tattooing in red or blue, or other methods of permanently impressing the tribal marks on the skin, are largely resorted to. It is evident that, with the restriction of the large areas over which these tribes are wont to roam, and the resulting diminution in the supply of food that the forests can afford, the formation of village communities possessing permanent cultivation must gradually ensue; and though in the first instance such villages are self-supporting even to the smallest detail of domestic requirements, yet in time many savage customs and arts no longer necessary in a settled life will entirely disappear.
Probably the most primitive of all forest tribes are the Jarawas of the Andaman Islands. They are true forest folk, who never leave the deep shade of the evergreen forest and subsist solely on the vegetation and animal life around them. Totally ignorant of agriculture, they have only recently made acquaintance with the value of metals and are now ready to take life, or to risk their own, in order to acquire an iron implement which shall make its possessor superior to his fellows. With them it has hitherto been impossible to open up friendly relations, and the armed escort that must accompany the workers in their forests is not always successful in protecting men and elephants from their arrows.
Numerous tribes, such as the Chins and Nāgās, still exist in the wild hill forests of Burma and Assam, who though warriors and hunters yet have permanent villages, more useful as tribal strongholds than as centres of agriculture. It is but a few years since entry into their territory meant death or slavery, and still more recently their well-organized raids were a terror to the surrounding country. To-day they are gradually renouncing their savage life; for a knowledge of the power to punish followed by confidence, first in the individual and then in the Government, works wonders even in a single generation.
More directly under these restraining influences are the Kachins and Karens of Burma. The former possess no written language, they are worshippers of demons with whom imagination thickly peoples the forests, hospitable but revengeful and unforgiving, and delighting in the most persistent blood feuds; the latter are more advanced, reserved, and suspicious, yet mixing with the people around them and tending largely to Christianity in the place of a lost religion. Both practise shifting cultivation; both are hunters who also hold human life of small account.
Other tribes, less in number and of smaller importance either politically or to the Forest officer, are found surviving in almost every Province in India. Under a less gentle rule they would long ago have disappeared; at the present time their protection and maintenance is often a first charge on the forest estate of the Empire, and in many localities the extension of forests and their management must continue to depend to some extent on the treatment and requirements of these jungle dwellers.
In the successful management of the forests one of the most important details is the method by which the produce can be extracted and conveyed to a profitable market. However excellent the main system of communications may be, there yet remains the problem of bringing timber or other material from the forest to the road, railway, or river that leads to the place of utilization. In very few cases can the use of costly appliances be justified in the extraction of a widely scattered crop, and hence the large employment of bullocks, buffaloes, and elephants in forest operations, not only in wheeled traffic but also by the more interesting method of carrying or dragging. In some parts of India the extraction of produce is almost entirely dependent on the aid of bullocks and buffaloes, and long files of these animals, under the control of wild Banjārās or Muhammadans, may be met on forest paths laden with bamboos or scantlings; in others cattle are yoked to larger timber and drag it by sheer strength to the desired locality. Farther east the employment of elephants in the working of large timber is almost universal. Here heavy logs of from 2 to 6 tons are dragged to those creeks where good floods may be expected in the monsoon months, and are thence attended in their passage to the main river by elephants, who push the stranded timber into the stream, or, at the peril of their lives, relieve a ‘jam’ in some dangerous turn. The work of these sagacious animals does not, however, end in the forest; for on the arrival, perhaps after many months of adventure, of the timber rafts at the sale dépôt the elephant is again ready to drag the logs from the water, and is responsible for the methodical arrangement of the various lots, for piling the heavy timber of the reserve stock, and for the accurate stacking of the sawn scantlings. It is not surprising that the value of these intelligent and willing animals should have increased with the extension of forest operations. Their price has in fact more than doubled during the past few years; and the protection of the wild herds against the hunter, and the introduction of ‘kheddas,’ have become necessary if the supply of these valuable workers is to be maintained. Without elephants it would, under present circumstances, be impossible to meet the demand for teak timber throughout the world. Later on they too will disappear, for the conditions of forestry in India are undergoing the most rapid changes, and when man interferes to assign the limits of the forest and regulate its growth he interferes also with the freedom so essential to the existence of its former inhabitants.
APPENDIX
Since the closing of the Royal Indian Engineering College, Cooper's Hill, at the end of the session in 1906, probationers for the Indian Forest Service are appointed by the Secretary of State upon the results of a competitive examination conducted by the Civil Service Commissioners. The period of probation extends over three years, two of which are spent at Oxford and the third on the Continent. Those who pass through the course satisfactorily receive the diploma of forestry from the University of Oxford, and it is expected of them that they should also obtain a degree in the Honour School of Natural Science. They are then appointed Assistant Conservators in the Indian Forest department.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
J. S. Gamble.—Bambusae of British India (Calcutta, 1896). W. E. D'Arcy.—Preparation of Forest Working-Plans in India, 3rd edition (Calcutta, 1898). Baden-Powell.—Forest Law (1893). W. R. Fisher.—Manual of Indian Forest Botany, Pt. I (Roorkee, 1888). J. S. Gamble.—Manual of Indian Timbers (1902). W. Schlich.—Manual of Forestry, vols. i to v (1889–96). E. C. Cotes.—Indian Forest Zoology (Calcutta, 1893). E. P. Stebbing.—Injurious Insects of Indian Forests (Calcutta, 1899). Sir D. Brandis.—Indian Forestry (Woking, 1897). B. Ribbentrop.—Forestry in British India (Calcutta, 1900). Annual Provincial Reports on Forest Operations : printed at the Government Presses of the respective Provinces.
Notes
- 1. See appendix at end of chapter.