1 1770 is chosen as a convenient date, for then for the first time the E.I.C. acknowledged its responsibility, somewhat grudgingly, it is true, to take some steps to alleviate the calamity.
2 It is related that the assistance which Aurangzib endeavoured to afford to his subjects in 1660–61 was considerably hampered by a corruption and cruelty upon the part of his officials in many ways similar.—Elliot, vol. vii. pp. 246–8.
The famine of 1739 was also not a little aggravated by the exactions of the tax-gatherers.—Scott, vol. ii. p. 211.
3 This famine, it is true, was not the causa causarum of the dissolution of the Afghan Empire. Already in 1340 Bengal and Telingana had become independent. But it made hope of recovery impossible.
4 Not until the seventeenth century is sufficient evidence discoverable to put the exact nature of the disease absolutely beyond doubt.
The visible marks of plague were swellings as big as grape or banana under the arms, and behind the ears, and in the groins, and a redness was perceptible round the pupils of the eyes.—Elliot, vol. vii. p. 337.
(a) Ikhal Nama. Muctamad Khan.
“When it (the plague) was about to break out, a mouse would rush out of its hole as if mad, and, striking itself against the door and walls of the house, expire. If immediately after this signal the occupants left the house and went away to the jungle, their lives were saved; if otherwise, the inhabitants of the whole village would be swept away by the hand of death."—Elliot, vol. vi. p. 406.
(b) The Autobiography of Emperor Jehangir.
"The daughter of the deceased Asaf Khan, who is in the house of Khan-i-Azam, told me a strange and wonderful tale. I made particular inquiries into its truth and write it on account of its strangeness. She said that one day in the courtyard of her house she saw a mouse falling and rising in a distracted manner. . . . She said to one of her female slaves, 'Take it by the tail and throw it before the cat.' The cat, delighted, jumped up from its place and seized it in its mouth, but immediately dropped it and showed aversion to it. By degrees an expression of pain showed itself on its face. The next day it was nearly dead, when it entered her mind to give it a little treacle. When its mouth was open its palate and tongue appeared nearly black. It passed three days in a state of misery, and on the fourth came to its senses. After this the grain of the plague appeared in one of the female slaves."
5 They were composed, roughly speaking, of that section of the central Deccan which lies between the Tapti, Tungabhadra, and Kistna Rivers.
6 In Colonel Etheridge's Report there is also evidence given of a similar legend in reference to the famine in the Poona district, circa 1200. How much reliance should be placed on such purely popular legends is a debatable point, and the evidence seems in this case scarcely convincing. A decade or more of years of comparative drought often terminating in a famine is by no means unknown. Thus in Khandesh the years 1769, 1772–73, 1775, 1779, 1782–83 were all exceptionally dry. A similar series of years of deficient rainfall is mentioned in various parts of the N.W.P., all within a comparatively small radius of Delhi in the first half of the nineteenth century—1824–25–26–27–28; 1832–33–34.
7 Famine in Hindu law is one of the recognised causes of slavery. Vide Naruda; cf. W. Stokes, Hindu Law Books. According to Yajnavalkya (one of the twenty sacred authors of the Smirti) a husband is not liable to make good the property of his wife taken by him during a famine.
8 In the famine of 1290, indefinite mention of assistance is given. In those of 1345, 1396, 1423-24, 1494, 1596, 1630, 1660, the royal-stores were opened, or corn was imported. In 1687 the people were apparently compelled to give up their private stores. Mackenzie MSS., vol. iv. pp. 33-5. In 917 the merchants made fortunes by selling their supplies at excessive rates. Vide supra, p. 7. In 1540 the Portuguese near Santoun "very charitably bought rice, and cocoa-nuts, and jaggery, and millet, and sold them for a much lower price than they could have sold them, had they wanted to."—Correa, Lendas de India, vol. iv. pp. 131-2.
9 The following, which is a translation from a contemporary native document in the Mackenzie MSS., is of interest owing to the curious policy of the Emperor's officials :—
"Then he who held the office of Dasakee, Munna Roosoon and Savarami, named Croostanee Bavanah Mawnu-Karo-yoodoo, began to send his peons to the places where grain was buried in pots, which he took by force with other effects; he also exported money from the merchants and other affluent people: he was joined in this by Narrayana Royoodoo coming sometimes to Patakamoor, his place of residence, and to Condaveed Mamoola Cotah, where his brother Jangannah resided.
"At this time the first of Bahoolun of Badrapala month on the 4th of the Mahomedan month Jalakad, Avarangazaboo arrived; his army then besieging the fort of Golcondah."
Then follows an interesting list of prices, the fluctuations of which have been noted in the text. The famine spread over the "Carnatic, Veedarba, Mucha, Magada, Panda, Roolenda, Andra, Callinga, from the south sea to the east sea as far as Davaradee."—Mackenzie MSS., vol. iv. pp. 33-5.
10 Letter from R. A. Peter Martin, December 10, 1713.
‘‘ Anno 1709.—Hatten wir ein erbarmliche Trückne, woraus ein verderbliche Teurung, Hungersnoth u. Sterben erfolgt ist.’’ Then follows a list of prices showing how the staple food rose from 1s. to 8 markal to 4s. to 1 markal. He adds: ‘‘ Gleichwie aber der gemeine Mann mit dem geld nicht aufkommen kan.’’
NOTES TO CHAPTER II
1 Quoted by T. Morrison, The Industrial Organisation of an Indian Province, pp. 245–6.
2 Vide Scott, vol. ii. p. 454. Shittabory was the Imperial Dewan at Patna.
3 Hunter (Rural Bengal, p. 402) reckons it at 35 per cent.
4 For extent of famine, vide Campbell’s Report on Famines of Last Century, paras. 26, 29, 30.
5 The English had been carrying on a long struggle with Haidar, the usurper of Mysore.
6 This famine (1791–92) spread over the whole of the Bombay district as far as Marwar, as well as over parts of Madras. This territory was, of course, at that date, with the exception of the land lying immediately round the English ports, under native rule.
7 The Government’s efforts in Madras proved of little use, and 1200 are said to have died in the single month of April 1791. An attempt at direct gratuity in the form of doles of food was also made in Ganjam.—Dalyell, Mem., pp. 17, 18.
8 The system adopted was peculiar. The Ameers prepared lists of those other than traders and cultivators for relief. They gave up the Land Revenue and divided it into three and a half portions. Two portions they gave to the Syruds and Muhammadans, who apparently were thus supported for five or six months; one they allotted to strangers and travellers, and the remaining half-portion to the Hindus.—Eth., Report, p. 18.
9 Forbes' figures are given for what they are worth. According to him, at least 50,000 were saved by the public works, and an equal number by the importation of rice.— Oriental Memoires, vol. iv. pp. 291–5.
10 1801. Nawabvizier's assessment, Rs. 1,35,23,474. E.I. Co.'s „ Rs. 1,42,50,140. The oppression of the Nawabvizier's government is undisputed.—Girdlestone's Report, p. 9.
11 The actual figures are 29,010 garce imported, and 5943 consumed.
12 Dalyell asserts that no deaths took place from actual starvation. The following are the vital statistics for Madras alone for the three years 1805–7:—
| 1805 | . | . | . | 3,225 | deaths. |
| 1806 | . | . | . | 4,902 | „ |
| 1807 | . | . | . | 17,207 | „ |
The famine lasted roughly from 1804–7.—Dalyell, Mem., pp. 24–5.
13 At first, instead of a bounty an attempt was made to stimulate trade by lowering the price of salt to exporters of grain into the stricken districts between the Godaveri and Toombudra Rivers. The actual bounty was not declared until August 23.—1880 Comm., pt. iii. p. 7.
14 It was estimated that, in round numbers, 100,000 were employed on relief works at a cost of Rs. 2,00,00,000; and that charitable relief cost Rs. 3,50,000. — 1880 Comm., pt. i. para. 90.
15 “At Bilhour, for example, only eight hundred could be admitted at a time, and there were never less than five thousand clamouring for work.”—1837–38, Mr. Rose's Report; Girdlestone's Report, p. 48.
NOTES TO CHAPTER III
1 The exact figures of these two canals at the two dates given are—
2 Evidence was subsequently given that native craft might have been used.—Orissa Report, pt. iii. p. 146.
3 It is estimated that from one-quarter to one-third of the population perished and nine-tenths of the cattle. The district was surrounded on three sides by desert and had only three roads on the fourth. Ultimately a certain amount of grain was imported on camels.—1881 Comm., pp. 79–80.
4 The association representing the landowners believed that the spring and autumn crops only provided food for two months in the year, where as it was subsequently proved that they sufficed for eight.—1881 Comm., pt. i. p. 109.
5 The famine of 1868 was actually greater in extent, some 300,000 square miles being affected. But the population was smaller, 21 million as compared with 36 million in 1877, and only a small fraction of the territory was under the British Government.—1880 Comm., paras. 76–8.
6 Letter from the Secretary to the Government of India to Sir R. Temple, Jan. 16, 1877.
7 From November 1877 to December 1878 the mortality was 1,250,000 in excess of the average.—1880 Comm., p. 28.
8 Though the ignorance on the part of the local government as to the actual habits of the people in Ganjam is no doubt worthy of remark, the supposition that the price of Ragi would form a proper test of the intensity of the famine was not without justification. According to Church it is commonly used in some districts, as, for instance, the Patna division, Bhagulpur, Santal, etc., by the poorer and lower classes, and although not a popular food, is generally looked upon as a convenient substitute in time of famine. According to Sir G. Watt it is perfectly edible and used in many South Indian jails. Moreover, although its nutrient value is lower (84·) than that of any other cereal, still the rice with which the natives mixed it could scarcely have helped much to compensate the lack of nitrogen. The nutrient ratio (i.e. ratio of albuminoids to starch) of Ragi is 1 : 13, while that of rice, which is the lowest after Ragi, is 1 : 10·8. Thus the only advantage which could be derived from the admixture of rice would be that the surplus of starch necessary in order to obtain sufficient albuminoids would be 14·9 in comparison with 23·2 in the case of Ragi.
9 This was generally the case throughout India; but the greatest difficulty was found in the case of the hill tribes, whose natural occupation was tree-felling and gathering the jungle products.—Cf. Report on the Famine in Madras Pres., 1896–97, p. 148.
10 The year 1893 is taken as being the last year of normal conditions. In view, however, of the irregularity of climatic conditions a certain deduction should be made from the percentage given.
11 The remark is true of almost the whole of India, but applies especially to the Bombay Presidency. Over 39 per cent. of the total expenditure was upon roads. The opinion was subsequently expressed that the need for roads in that Presidency was not urgent, that road metalling was “even less useful,” and “that, speaking generally, the utility of the work was not great.”—Report of Irrigation Comm., pt. i. para. 324.
12 Compare, for example, “Prosperous” India, W. Digby, 1901, p. 137. The calculation is made on the basis of comparison between the increase of population which was actually shown by the Census Reports of 1891 and 1901, and what on the basis of preceding increase he considers “normal.”
13 Special emphasis was laid in the Report on the rise in wages (vide Report on Administration of Famine Relief, 1907–8, p. 152), and in the Memorandum on the Results of Indian Administration (p. 29, Cd. 4956) the opinion was expressed “that there has been a general rise in the standard of wages, and the rise is more than proportionate to the rise in prices, which has necessitated it." "It is no exaggeration to say that labour has been in a position to dictate its own terms."—Ibid. In view of the official statistics on wages and prices the contention needs certain qualifications, and the rise in real wages can only to a limited degree be accepted as a cause of the ease with which the effects of drought on this occasion were met. The following figures will show that the rise in real wages was slight in at least two districts, and that it applied only to the last decade, while the rate in 1888 was considerably higher. The truth of the matter probably is that only in the neighbourhood of towns where the demand had greatly increased, and the supply of suitable labour was comparatively deficient, could labour dictate its own terms.
Rate of Wages in U.P.
1888, Rs. 4·44 monthly. 1899, Rs. 4·42 monthly. 1897, Rs. 3·99 monthly. 1907, Rs. 4·47–4·79 monthly.
| COST OF | WHEAT. | BARLEY. | JAWAR. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cawnpore district | 1888 1907 | 2·471 3·749 | 1·926 1·564 | 2·214 2·474 |
| Meerut district | 1888 1907 | 2·667 3·506 | 1·838 2·398 | 2·145 2·64 |
Vide Statistics, Prices and Wages, 1908.
NOTES TO CHAPTER IV
1 The most noticeable examples of famines largely created by the depredations of locusts in the nineteenth century are 1803 in Kutch, 1812–13 in parts of Bombay, 1834 in Ahmedabad; while in 1869–70 75 per cent. of the crops after the renewal of the rains were devoured in Marwar.— Vide Eth., Report, pp. 22, 78, 39; G., p. 355.
Rats, apart from their danger as infection carriers, caused serious distress, 1814–15, in Kutch and after the famine of 1877 in Bombay.—Vide Eth., Report, p. 21; 1880 Comm., pt. i. para. 62.
2 The 1898 Comm. (p. 287) appropriated the subscription funds to—
- (1) The purchase of small extra comforts.
- (2) The care of orphans till homes could be found for them.
- (3) The relief of the deserving proud.
- (4) Assistance in restoring those who had lost their positions during the famine.
3 The Darbhanga famine of 1906–7 presents certain peculiarities from this point of view, as owing to the floods no relief works were possible during the first weeks of distress. It was subsequently concluded from the majority of women on the works that unexpectedly large numbers of men must have emigrated.—Report on Relief Operations in Delhi Famine, 1906–7, p. 148.
4 1890.—The Government was forced to import corn into the hill districts of Kumaun and Garhwal. Vide Blue Book, 1890, LIX., “Correspondence re Scarcity in K. and G.,” p. 4.
1907.—The Government imported corn in boats to the flooded districts of Darbhanga. Vide supra, op. cit.
5 Resolution :
“The Government of India concurs in the view that large works are preferable to small works as the backbone of famine relief, whenever the necessity arises for employing relief labour on an extensive scale.”—T. W. Holderness, T. Higham, Report on Famine Relief Works, 1897, p. 13; cf. 1898 Comm., pp. 319–23.
It should be noted that the recommendation is limited by the extent of the famine, and the advice of the following Commission is only relative.
6 In Bombay during the Famine of 1899–1900 a minimum wage was paid accompanied by fines which reduced the amount ultimately paid in some cases to 25 per cent. below the minimum. Nash, when travelling through the district, reported on the extreme inadequacy of this dole, and expressed it as his opinion that the small value of the work performed by its recipients was in reality due to inefficient administration.—The Great Famine, pp. 32, 169. His opinion was subsequently corroborated by the Commissioners, who declared that “the minimum wage for able-bodied workers has been the stumbling-block of famine administration.”—1901 Comm., pp. 30, 10.
7 That in the classification used in the codes up to 1898,
- (a) Able-bodied, accustomed to the kind of work given,
- (b) Able-bodied, not accustomed to the kind of work given,
- (c) Able-bodied, but not labourers,
- (d) Not able-bodied, but fit for light labour,
only in the Bombay Presidency was it carried out into practice. Various other systems were adopted elsewhere. But the general effect proved to be a tendency to payment on the basis of the value of the work actually performed. The best reformed classification, in the opinion both of Mr. T. Higham and subsequently the Commissioners, was that adopted in the N.W.P. :
X. Special. Y. Diggers. Z. Carriers.
Below these were grouped the children under twelve years.—Vide T. Higham, Report on Management of Relief Works, 1897, pt. viii. p. 2 ; 1898 Comm., pt. i. p. 112 seq.
NOTES TO CHAPTER V
1 Over-population may, of course, be due either to a more rapid growth of the population than of its productive capacity, or to a decrease in its productive capacity caused by a sudden disaster, or by a diminution in the demand for the commodities produced in any district, or by actual exhaustion of the soil. Examples of excessive rapidity in the growth of population in the past are rare. Dr. Ranken, writing in 1836, said that the inhabitants of the N.W.P. and Marwar, "have advanced within reach of many improvements in the physical conditions of society; but having made no corresponding acquisitions in intelligence, their . . . minds are yet unable to turn the advantage of a better system to account. Hence animal instinct predominating over foresight and enterprise, the population has augmented faster than increasing agriculture and commerce have extended."—Quoted Nathan, Plague in India, vol. i. p. 87.
Evidence was also given in the Papers re Partial Census in Famine Districts, 1878 (p. 14), to show that the inhabitants of South India, owing to peace and tranquillity, had increased up to the limit of the sustaining power of the soil.
But in neither case did the evil prove permanent.
2 "Die Indianer nicht allein alles Regenwasser bis auf den letzten Tropffen in grosse Weyher auffangen, sondern auch Schriffreiche Wasser mittelst unendlich vieler Gräben in eine Menge grosser Teichen dergestalt hauffig verleiten, dass offtmal der ganze Strom hiedurch erschöpfft u. ausgetrüchnet wird."—Der Neue Welt Bott, pt. vi. p. 67.
3 The Report does not assert it as a fact, but as "a common native belief."—Pt. iii. para. 8.
4 Grain was imported in the drought of 1890. The description of the condition of the inhabitants of these districts is important in its bearing upon the problem of the effects of economic transition in India.
“ Their fields produce little more than is required for their sustenance, and throughout the region there is an entire absence of those traders and wholesale grain dealers who are found in every part of the plains. The peasantry have been described by the Commissioner, Sir Henry Ramsay, as probably better off than any peasantry in India. The cultivators and landowners live on the whole of their own stocks, of which they have usually a six months’ supply in hand. The stocks in the regions of G. and K. . . . are almost exhausted ; the people can pay for supplies if they could be procured.”—Extract from Letter from Chief Secretary of Governor of N.W.P. and Oudh ; Correspondence re Scarcity in K. and G., 1890, p. 4.
This report, however, should be contrasted with that of Dr. Rennie, who investigated the conditions of the people in connection with the outbreak of plague in 1850. “ The filth is everywhere—in their villages, their houses, and their persons. . . . Their dwellings are generally low and ill-ventilated, except through their bad construction. . . . The food of the majority is bad and insufficient.”—Quoted Nathan, Plague in India, vol. i. p. 92.
The quotations are not in fact wholly irreconcilable ; nor is it necessary, accepting the truthful relation of impressions, to presume great progress in hygiene or general welfare. The standard of living was, and is, low ; the wants of the people are few. But in bad years and good years alike the people are generally able to maintain that standard and fulfil those wants.
5 As, for instance, in 1873–74, 1877–78, 1898.
“ The revenue derived from the railways during the year 1874 was £770,856 in excess of the previous year. . . . The improvement that took place in the railways during this past year is due principally to the large traffic in grain for the famine-stricken districts.”—Rail. Report, 1874–75, pp. 26–7.
“ The satisfactory results obtained must, to a certain extent, be attributed to the large traffic in grain caused by the famine in South India. It has been calculated that the receipts from this source alone were about £600,000. But, while accepting this estimate, it must be borne in mind that much traffic of a more profitable kind was lost in consequence of the preference given to consignments of grain to the famine-stricken districts, and of the inability of the railways, for want of rolling stock, to take much that was offered."—Rail. Report, 1877–78, sec. 52.
"The increase of the earnings from goods traffic was chiefly due to a larger traffic in 'merchandise general,' mainly in the grain and seed traffic to famine-stricken districts."—Rail. Report, 1895, p. 105.
It is impossible to estimate the extent to which the profits in 1900 were increased owing to famine. For, though for the first time a net gain accrued from railways in that year to the State, and although "the increase in the quantity of goods carried was due to the famine," the net profits in 1901 were considerably greater (Rs. 11,541,000 as compared with Rs. 872,000), and it is impossible to calculate what the profits might have been had no famine occurred.—Cf. Rail. Reports, 1899–1900, p. 104; 1901, pp. 8 and 10; 1902, p. 13.
6 Sir W. Robinson maintained that "no margin is left for extraordinary vicissitudes of season, and the demand is so heavy and searching that little room is left for the accumulation of agricultural capital to meet contingencies such as have overtaken the population."
His assertion was subsequently discussed, and it was concluded that the ryot had improved his position considerably since 1856 and was by no means poor. Figures were also produced to show the incidence of the land revenue per acre and per head of population. It varied from Rs. 3·0 in British Burma to Rs. 1·8 in Oudh per acre, and from Rs. 2·55 to Rs. 1·3 per head in the same districts respectively. Actually the lowest figure was that of Madras, Rs. 1·1 per acre, and Rs. 1·03 per head, for dry land. But including water rent they amounted to Rs. 1·75 and Rs. 1·4.—Acc. and Papers, 1878, LIX., pt. i. pp. 2, 14.
7 The figures of the Census Report of 1901 show, as compared with those of 1891, after systematising the two different plans on which they were drawn up, the following variations in the proportion of the population on the land :— 1891 . . . 645 per mille. 1901 . . . 675 „ But though these figures, the report says, need qualifying, "the net result, however, for India as a whole shows a large shifting from the non-agricultural to the agricultural head." —Census Report, 1901, vol. i. p. 208.
8 Estimated yield of raw cotton— (400 lb. bale) 1901–2 3,566,296. 1910–11 4,303,000. Yarn produced in Indian mills— (000 lb.) 1901–2 572,938. 1910–11 576,996. Woven goods— (000 lb.) 1901–2 119,651. 1910–11 230,861. Statist. Abstract, 1913, pp. 127 and 263.
9 The most important of these Acts are—Bengal Tenancy Act, 1859; Rent Act, 1885; Madras Rent Recovery Act, 1865; Estates Land Act, 1900; Bombay Rent Act, 1879; Agra Province Rent Act, 1881; Tenancy Act, 1901; Central Provinces Tenancy Acts, 1883 and 1898; Oudh Rent Act, 1886; Punjab Tenancy Act, 1887; Land Alienation Act, 1900; N.W.P. Rent Act, 1901; Bundelkhand Land Alienation Act, 1908.
10 There are certain material points of difference between the Land Co-operative Societies in India and those in Germany. The former are at once more democratic and more bureaucratic than the latter. Any society of ten members can be registered, whereas in Germany societies are not usually founded in districts with less than 400 inhabitants. They are in India under the patronage of the Central Government, stamp duties and income tax being usually remitted, and under the direct control of the local government. In Germany only members can be on the Committees, but they are generally the more wealthy ones. Moreover, in that country loans can be called in at four weeks' notice, and at the top of the whole organisation stands a Generalanwaltschaft and Zentraldarlehnskasse. Of more recent growth are the co-operative supply and co-operative insurance departments.
11 The most recent statement of the progress of the co-operative movement in India, 1911–12, shows a growth in the numbers of rural banks from 740 (1906–7) to 7562 (1911–12), and a profit made in 1911–12 of Rs. 6,27,689. The membership of all the various banks together show an increase from 1906–7, 90,844, to 1911–12, 403,318, with a capital of Rs. 3,35,74,162.
12 Financial decentralisation was introduced by Lord Mayo, 1870. To provide for the famine of 1877, Bengal alone raised £300,000 by extra taxation. At this date was introduced the principle of partial Provincial self-responsibility in famine, aided by mutual Provincial assistance, and the enforced contribution of all classes against periodical draughts.
The Indian people's Famine Trust was started by the gift of the Maharaja of Jaipur of 16 lakhs of Government securities, for relief in famine in 1900.
Notes
- *. This is a rough estimate.