Introduction

The History & Economics of Indian Famines, Alexander Loveday, 1914 · from page 1 · about 9 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

In 1867 the word "Famine" was defined by the Special Commission of that year as "suffering from hunger on the part of large classes of the population." (a) * But the history of famines in India is largely the story of how the meaning of that word has been modified through the force of economic transition and the perfection of administrative organisation. It would at the present day be more accurate to describe these calamities as temporary dislocation of employment amongst large numbers of the population consequent upon failure in the ordinary crops of the season. The word dislocation is purposely used, for the organisation of Relief Works is now such that some form of employment is almost unfailingly provided for those who seek it before a really acute stage of distress has been reached. Deaths from famine, it is true, there are still. But deaths there must always be, when the normal course of economic existence is suddenly revolutionised. A study of the statistics of more recent famines will show that such deaths as have taken place have been in the main amongst the ranks of the aged and infirm, to whom any change in the ordinary climatic conditions, or in the nature of their social life, might well prove disastrous. In but comparatively rare instances have they been the result of local maladministration. Doubtless even in the most recent droughts some have starved and many have suffered. But the decrease in the normal growth of population after a period of deficient harvests, which the Census reports show, is not so much a measure of mortality as a demonstration of the normal effect of the fertility of nature on the fertility of man.

It is difficult to discover even a few generalisations which are applicable to the whole of the great Indian Peninsula, stretching, as it does, from the 8th to the 38th degree of latitude, with its innumerable variations in climatic, political, social, and racial conditions. But perhaps the most striking and, in this connection at any rate, the most important of its peculiarities is the fact that over two-thirds of its population are occupied in an industry, the success of which is almost wholly dependent on a sufficient and well-distributed rainfall. (a)

In order to make clear the real famine problem in India it is necessary, therefore, to give some idea, however rough, of the conditions which govern agriculture in that land. The crops are of course numerous and vary both in kind and season according to the fertility of the soil and the general meteorological conditions. As an official publication states, they are normally sown and harvested in various parts in every month of the year. (a) In some districts, such as Lower Bengal, three crops are harvested in the year. But, taking India as a whole, it is roughly true to say that the population is ultimately dependent for its food on the autumn crops reaped in September and December, and on the so-called dry crops reaped in March and April. With the exception of those districts in which the productivity of the soil is maintained by irrigation, (b) both these harvests are dependent on the regularity and sufficiency of the rainfall at the time of the summer and winter monsoons. Strictly speaking, there is but one monsoon, which sweeps over India from the south-west in June and July and retreats again in October and December. Naturally exhausted as it is by the time of its retreat, the rainfall in these winter months is comparatively light. It is, however, sufficient, especially on the black spongy soil of parts of the Deccan, for the cereals, millets, and pulses, which form the staple food of the greater part of the population, and upon which they ultimately rely for their general prosperity and for the payment of the land revenue. (c) But it is the south-west monsoon of the summer which is the ultimate source of wealth of those rice-producing districts such as Bengal, Burma, Assam, and the land lying between the Western Ghats and the sea. Not only does every deficiency in the actual depth of rainfall mean disaster for the cultivator, but the mere prolongation of the dry season for a week or a fortnight may render vain all hopes of a bountiful harvest for that year. Some parts of the country, of course, are less subject to the vagaries of climatic conditions than others. But only those can be said to be immune from the danger of famine which, like the Punjab or Sind, are supplied with water by vast systems of canal irrigation. For tanks and even rivers may dry up, and wells cease to be of use. This being so, then, the frequency and extent of famines in India should be no cause of surprise. That they are not more extended in area and more tragic in their effects is due on the one hand to the size, and on the other to the varying elevations of that country. History gives no example of a drought extending over the whole of India; and meteorologists declare such an event impossible. Every improvement in the means of communication then must decrease the fatality of local deficiency.

There are, however, many contributing causes, some which no government can remove, and others, the power of which only the gradual evolution of economic and social conditions can be expected to diminish. Of the former perhaps the most important are floods (a) and violent storms of hail, which have in many cases prolonged the stress of famine by destroying the crops of the year subsequent to the drought, the many diseases to which the different cereals are subject, and swarms of locusts. Of the latter there is one of all supreme importance—the extreme poverty of the Indian cultivator, and, indeed, of the whole Indian population. Poverty in England, or America, or Germany is a question of the distribution of wealth. In India it is a question of its production. This is not the place to enter into the controversy as to the exact income per head of the Indian population. Suffice it to say that if it has mounted to any considerable degree since the Commissioners in 1880 estimated it at £2 per caput, it is still infinitely below that of any of the leading nations in Europe, if not actually the lowest in the world. An inquiry into the causes of this poverty inevitably involves a discussion concerning the whole economic problem in India, for which this is not the place.

But famine and poverty naturally react on one another, and where a higher standard of living increases the power of resistance and of recovery, the diminution in wealth consequent on climatic phenomena will be equivalently less.

Beyond this fundamental economic cause there are, however, many others, which, to a greater or less degree, have lent their assistance to the calamities to which India is periodically subject. During the period of Muhammadan supremacy continual wars produced such general exhaustion that the people were vitally sensitive to every variation in the normal annual rainfall; and the purely local famines due to devastation were viewed both by the rulers and historians as the normal result of political rivalry. On the other hand, the changes in the administrative, legal, and economic conditions, which the English rule has effected, though their ultimate goal may be greater industrial efficiency and productivity, have during the period of transition in the last century undoubtedly produced certain temporary effects adverse to those sections of the population which are particularly affected by periodical deficiency. Land tenure has become insecure, (a) home industries have been struck by English competition, prices, and often the standard of living, have risen, and temptation to expense and to borrowing that wealth they could not produce has beset the path of those very classes of society which have morally and mentally developed the least.

But from the numerous contributory causes it is difficult, and perhaps arbitrary, to select one or two as being of more vital importance. Only by tracing the history of the famines of the past is it possible to view the whole subject in its true perspective.

Before closing this brief sketch, however, it is desirable to estimate the value of those criticisms which have been frequently raised against the agricultural methods of the native cultivator. Too often has his inefficiency or his laziness been given as the primary cause of the extent of agricultural calamities. Every expert who has lived long enough in the country to realise the difficulties which he has to face is, in fact, loud in his praises. (a) If the productivity of non-irrigated land is slight (b) it is due to the cultivator's lack of capital and lack of materials suitable for fuel and manure, not to his lack of ability or energy. For wood and coal and iron ploughs are, as a rule, outside the range of his income. There are, moreover, some signs at the moment that the slight increase in his wealth, which he has obtained in recent years in certain districts, is already improving the condition of the land. For if the soil has been exhausted in the past, the increase in the demand for oilcake at the present day seems to indicate the probability of its more adequate feeding in the future. (c) It is, however, absurd to suppose that a speculative increase from new methods of agriculture can weigh heavily in the balance against centuries of inherited knowledge amongst those to whom every penny is at its utmost value. If the productivity of the land is to be materially increased, the whole social and economic basis of society must first be revolutionised. It is not the lack of skill upon the part of the cultivator, but the smallness of his holding, the scarcity of capital, and the decay of domestic industries, which have caused his poverty and his incapacity to withstand the strain of famine and which have hampered the one great industry of India.

But what percentage of the population of Europe would be able to maintain themselves on the savings of their past earnings with enhanced prices and no incoming wages ?

Notes

  1. (a). Orissa Comm., para. 79.
  2. *. Letters refer to footnotes; figures, to the Notes at the end, Appendix B, p. 139.
  3. (a). (a) Census Report, 1891, 62 per cent. ; 1901, 68 per cent.
  4. (a). (a) Imp. Gazetteer, vol. iii. p. 6, 1907.
  5. (b). (b) As, for instance, Sind and Punjab and Rajputana ; and Madras, to a less degree, being irrigated by its rivers.
  6. (c). (c) Vide Sir J. Strachey, India, 1888 edition, pp. 228–9 and 233.
  7. a. The cases in which floods have materially affected the length of famine distress are numerous e.g. 1291, 1345, 1630, [p. 5] 1770, 1783, 1866, 1906–7. The famine of 1776 seems to have been wholly due to excessive rainfall. Scott, vol. ii. p. 47. Calcutta and the S.E. delta districts of Bengal are also peculiarly subject to cyclones. Cf. 1864, 1867, 1876. Orissa is subject to two forms of floods, inundations from the sea, and the overflowing of rivers. Owing to the nature of the country cramped in between the Eastern Ghats and the Deccan, protective measures are peculiarly difficult. For the power of irrigation works to check the destructivity of floods is limited, being dependent upon the elevation and declivities of the land. Cf. Orissa Report, para. 52.
  8. a. Vide infra, p. 115, for a fuller discussion of this point.
  9. (a). Vide e.g. Dr. Voelker, Report on Improvement of Ind. Agric., 1893 ; cp. II. passim.
  10. (b). Sir B. Fuller reckons the normal produce of wheat in non-irrigated and non-manured soil (one-third of the total crop) at ten or eleven bushels per acre. Studies of Indian Life and Sentiment, p. 198.
  11. (c). The increase in the use of manure for agricultural purposes may to some extent be measured by the demand for cake. Vide Report of Irrigation Comm., 1904, sec. 143.