To the Editor of the “Times”
Sir,—Even at a time when public attention is mainly confined to the incidents of the Transvaal war, Englishmen have not lost sight of the grave disaster which has overtaken their suffering fellow-subjects in India. Over three millions of my countrymen are on relief works, and English administrators, from the highest to the lowest, are straining every nerve to save human lives in the midst of a calamity almost unexampled in its intensity even in India.
Permit me, as an old and faithful and retired servant of the Indian Government, to speak a few words at this juncture. For the present system of relief operations I have nothing but praise; from all accounts that I have received and am receiving from the tracts most seriously affected, I am convinced that all that is humanly possible is being done to save life. I wish, therefore, to confine my remarks to the subject of preventing such famines in the future, and making the cultivators of India more resourceful, more prosperous, more able to tide over bad years which must come from time to time.
In Bengal the cultivators are, generally speaking, prosperous and resourceful. It is within my experience that when the entire crops of a year were destroyed in certain tracts by a cyclone and storm-wave (in 1876) the people helped themselves out of their savings of previous years, and I scarcely opened any relief works except for a small number of orphans and old men and women. The old Hindu rule that one-sixth the gross produce of the soil is due as rent is virtually observed in Bengal; in no district of Bengal is the average of rent higher, and in many districts it is considerably lower. This permits the cultivators to save, and, except in Orissa, which is not permanently settled, there has been no serious and disastrous famine in Bengal within this century.
In Northern India the mistakes made in land settlements in previous years have to a great extent been rectified. The old practice of the Government settling the rent payable by every village and every cultivator has been abandoned, and landlords are permitted, under certain restrictions, to make their own arrangements with cultivators. The old rule of demanding two-thirds of the landlords’ rental as Government revenue has also been abandoned since 1855 ; the Government has considerately limited its demand to one-half the rental. You will see from Sir Anthony MacDonnell’s replies to questions 5727 to 5740 of the Currency Committee, which lately sat in London, that under the present arrangements the cultivators generally pay one-fifth of the gross produce of the soil as rent to landlords, and one-half of what the landlord receives is claimed by the Government as its revenue. This arrangement is satisfactory, and I would only fix this one-fifth of the produce as the maximum limit of rent, in order to permanently prevent undue enhancement, which must necessarily impoverish the cultivators.
It is in Southern India and in the Central Provinces of India that land settlements are harsh and unsatisfactory, and necessarily render the cultivators resourceless and helpless in years of bad harvests. In Madras the Government is virtually the landlord in most parts of the province, and demands as revenue one-half of the net produce of the soil, which, it is explained in Government orders, should not exceed one-third the gross produce. The “net produce” is ascertained by deducting from the “gross produce” the cost of cultivation; the calculations are made by subordinate and low-paid Government officials who are not always fair to cultivators; and distinguished and honourable Madras gentlemen have placed facts before me, showing that in some cases the Government assessment approximates to one-half the gross produce of the soil. I shall be able to lay these facts before the authorities and the public on my return to Europe; but what I wish to urge now is that either one-third or one-half the gross produce is a high and ruinous limit of land revenue, and necessarily reduced the cultivators to a state of perpetual poverty and indebtedness. Such a limit of land revenue is unexampled in Bengal and Northern India; it disables cultivators from saving in good years; it renders them subject to inevitable famines and deaths by the million in bad years. The Madras famine of 1877 swept away five millions of the population.
The worst case, however, is that of the Central Provinces of India. There the Government fixes the rents payable by cultivators to landlords, and also fixes its own share of revenue out of the landlords’ receipts. The principle on which the rents are fixed is the same as in Madras, theoretically one-half of the net produce of the soil was fixed as rent; practically the assessments have been even harsher than in Madras. I have carefully ascertained facts from the best authorities; it was only yesterday that a distinguished gentleman, now a member of Lord Curzon’s Legislative Council, was kind enough to place documents and facts in my hands; and this morning I have received a letter from another well-informed gentleman, who writes thus from the Central Provinces :
“ The rent payable by every class of tenants in these provinces has been enhanced by the Settlement Officers at the recent Settlement. The rent so fixed is generally high, and can only be recovered, even in good years, with difficulty. Since the year of the recent Settlement (1894) a good portion of the land which was cultivated before has become fallow. The Government revenue is still in arrears, notwithstanding the hard measures adopted last year for its recovery.”
While the rents payable by cultivators to landlords have thus been fixed unduly high, the revenue demanded by the Government from landlords has also been fixed high. In Northern India, as Sir Antony MacDonnell informed the Currency Committee, the Government claims one-half, but does not really take more than forty per cent. of the landlords’ assets. In many districts in the Central Provinces the Government demands and obtains sixty per cent., plus twelve and a half per cent., as rates, of the landlords’ supposed assets. And as the landlord never gets the high rents which the Government has fixed, it comes to pass that the Government demand amounts sometimes to eighty, or even a hundred per cent. of the landlords’ real income. I have instances before me in which landlords have offered to surrender their property because the Government revenue demanded from them was really more than all they collected from cultivators.
I lay these facts before you, sir, in the sincere desire that this over-assessment may be rectified, and that the people of Southern India may be saved from poverty, famines, and deaths. The Government revenue itself will not be increased by such over-assessment; the proceeds of indirect taxes will decline with the poverty of the people; the land revenue will fall off as lands are thrown out of cultivation. It is no reflection on honest administrators if they sometimes make mistakes in administration; the mistakes made in Northern India have been rectified since 1855, and the time is come when the very principle of assessments in the centre and south of India should be rectified in order to give the population some real relief and some opportunity to save.
Adopt the old Hindu rule, a rule which answered well in India for thousands of years, a rule which is virtually observed in Bengal and Northern India to this day with the most happy results. Make one-sixth or even one-fifth the gross produce of the soil the maximum limit of rent payable by the cultivator under all forms of settlements and all methods of land administration, and the southern cultivator will learn to save, as the Bengal cultivator has learnt to save. Famines in India will be less frequent and less disastrous if the condition of the cultivators is improved by considerate assessments; there is no other permanent remedy for this terrible and recurring disaster.—Yours faithfully,
Romesh Dutt.
24th Jan. 1900.