Appendix U

Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure: Evidence of Lords Northbrook, Ripon, Lansdowne, Wolseley and Roberts, Sir H. B

Famines and Land Assessments in India, Romesh Chunder Dutt, 1900 · from page 245 · about 48 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

Lord Northbrook on Wars outside India

14,108. Have you paid any attention to the arrangement made for the payment of troops lent by India for service out of that country?—Yes, I have had occasion to give considerable attention to this matter.

14,109. Do you think that fair treatment has been given to India in the apportionment of those charges? —I think that India has been hardly treated.

14,110. Could you go through the various cases and give us your reasons?—The cases will be found in Sir Henry Waterfield’s Memorandum in the Appendix, page 364. I think I might take them in the order in which he gives them there.

14,111-2. I suppose you are going to take them from paragraph 16, are you?—Paragraph 19.

14,113-4. Quite so; I see, 19?—Well, I will not go back to anything before the Abyssinian expedition. I think that in the case of the Abyssinian War it was not right to charge India with the ordinary expenditure of the expedition.

14,119. Do you remember the ground upon which the Government decided at the time that India had an interest in Abyssinia?—No; I should like to see that. I never heard of it. I believe a protest was made at the time.

14,120. I am speaking from memory now. Was it not put forward that the Government of India was concerned in this question, because Abyssinia, being within the purview of India, you may say the prestige of the English name must not be endangered by allowing any English official subjects to be taken prisoners?—The idea may have been put forward. I do not think any impartial person would have paid the slightest attention to it.

14,121. (Mr Courtney.) I think I remember a French critic arguing at the time that the war was for the purpose of discovering a sanatorium for English troops?—That would be a better reason than the reason adduced as regards prestige, in my opinion. Then I come to the next case, the Perak expedition. It was a very small one; but in this Perak case I cannot conceive any one doubting that India has been hardly treated. Here was an expedition beyond the frontier of India, and for which, in order that any portion of the Indian revenue should be applied, it is by statute necessary that there should be an address to the Crown from both Houses of Parliament. I happened to be Governor-General at the time, and I protested against this charge being put upon India. Not only was no notice taken of the protest made by the Government of India, but not even were the statutory addresses from both Houses moved, so that the law was broken, and the charge so made upon India has never been repaid. It has remained charged upon India from that time to this, contrary to the law, and contrary to the protest of the Government of India. That is the case of Perak; that is the second one I have got to deal with, and I think this case is perfectly clear. I do not think that any answer can be given to it. In regard to the expedition sent to Malta, the whole of the expenses, both ordinary and extraordinary, were very properly paid by the Government of England.

14,124. Have you mentioned the Egyptian operation of 1882?—I am coming to that now; that is the next case, the Egyptian campaign of 1882. This was a case with which I individually had a good deal to do. Therefore I should not like to give any very strong opinion against the arrangement that was made. There was no doubt that as regards keeping the Suez Canal open India had a substantial interest. It had an interest. The question was what interest; how much the interest was. In the first instance it was intended that India should pay the whole cost of the expedition that was sent. That was when it was supposed that some very small force would have been sufficient. That was the reason why the Government at that time thought India should pay the whole. The English Government were put to very considerable cost, and we thought that India would be put to a small cost, and we thought she might very fairly pay the small cost of the troops sent to Suez. However, the operations became very extended, and it ended in the expedition from India becoming a large expedition. The whole cost was, I think, £1,700,000, and the ultimate arrangement made between the two Governments, the Government of India and the Government of England, was that India paid £1,200,000 and England paid £500,000. That was the arrangement that was made, and it was accepted by the Government of India, but it certainly was accepted unwillingly. The Government of India thought it had been very hardly treated in the matter, and I think that, looking at it now, I must say that it would have been perhaps better if we had charged India half, that India should have paid £850,000, and England should have paid £850,000. I do not want to press that, because I myself was in the Government at the time; therefore I cannot say that I considered it at the time to be an unfair arrangement.

14,127. [Soudan War.] Would you consider that, if the original plan had been carried out, India was sufficiently interested in the expedition to justify her being called upon to contribute ?—If you ask me my opinion, I should say, “No, certainly not.” I do not think there was a substantial interest of India in any expedition to the Soudan, but my argument rests upon this, that when by a statute the revenues of the Government of India are not to be used excepting after addresses from both Houses of Parliament, it is essential that the terms of that statute should be strictly adhered to, and, in my opinion, the continued employment of the Indian troops at Suakim as a garrison was not covered by the address. It alone could authorise the expenditure of the money; that is my point. As regards the force sent to Suakim last year, I say that certainly India should not have been charged.

14,165. (Chairman.) Now you have gone through and brought before us the grounds for the differences of opinion between the two Governments?—I should like to be allowed to sum it up before you go to the next question.

14,166. Yes, if you please?—To sum up what I have put before the Commission with respect to these cases of troops lent to India, I think certainly that, if the ordinary charges of that Abyssinian war were £600,000, that is a sum of money which India has a fair and equitable ground to claim. The whole of the Perak ordinary charges ought certainly, I think, to be paid. I will take the Suakim charges to be about £200,000, I do not know exactly what they were, but whatever the charges for Suakim were, I think the whole of the garrison charges at Suakim ought to be refunded to India. My opinion is that, on equitable grounds, £350,000 ought to be given to India in respect of the Egyptian Expedition of 1882, so that the charges should be divided between the two Governments, and I think that those sums ought, either directly, or in some other equitable manner, to be allowed to India now. I do not see any reason why it should be considered that because India has been inequitably treated, and in some cases, in my opinion, illegally treated during many years, that that treatment should not be redressed by some action at the present time. That concludes all that I have to say upon that matter.

Lord Ripon on Frontier Wars

16,237. (Chairman.) Since 1885 the number of frontier expeditions has increased. Lord Lansdowne has explained to us that there has been of late years a change of policy in dealing with frontier tribes—a system of employment, I understood him to say, has replaced the system of punitive fines, and he hoped that from that policy would result a smaller number of frontier expeditions in the future. Are you aware of this change of policy, and would you think it likely to have this result ?—I was not aware of it in detail, and I do not feel that I have sufficiently studied the question to be able to give an answer to it. Under the system which prevailed in my time, as I have already told you, we had hardly any frontier expeditions at all. And that again, I venture to think, is a question of policy. I do not think that the Government with which I was connected in India liked frontier expeditions; and I am bound to say that the military authorities of that Government disliked them as much as the civilians.

16,238. It seemed to me, from Lord Lansdowne’s description, that the policy was one of greater interference than heretofore, both in forcing the tribes to keep the peace and in endeavouring to make it their interest to keep the peace; do you think that by this, or by any other means, it would be possible to avoid such a disturbing influence on sound finance as these numerous expeditions?—I do not like a policy of constant interference. My impression would be that it would rather lead to expeditions than the reverse; but I am speaking very much in the dark, because I really do not know what the new arrangements may be.

16,239. Of course, we are looking at it simply from the financial side, the disturbing effect on the Budget of these sums of £200,000 or £300,000 that come constantly on the Budget?—Quite so.

16,240. And the point that struck us particularly in the return of Indian expenditure was, that in the period extending over several years from the date of about 1887 or 1888 forward to 1895 or 1896, the items of frontier expenditure were not only present every year, but were present in comparative numbers 3, 2, 3 and 4 in each year, whereas the previous years had been singularly free from them. That, of course, struck us as showing that, at all events, some change had taken place to cause this. Sir Henry Brackenbury and, I think, Lord Lansdowne, looked upon the present policy of interference, if I may so call it, as more likely to keep the peace than the former one. On the other hand, there is this to be said, that the actual figures did not present any such result?—I should be inclined to judge by the actual figures, and I should not think, from what you tell me, that that policy had proved itself successful; but I speak subject to correction upon that point.

16,241. They expressed themselves as being hopeful for the future?—I hope it may be, I am sure. You know there are always persons who are urging frontier expeditions, and it is sometimes by no means easy for the Government to resist that pressure; but if the Government were determined to resist frontier expeditions, unless they were absolutely necessary, I think you would find that the number of them would very greatly decrease.

Lord Lansdowne on the Indian Army

15,996. (Mr Courtney.) Have you considered, Lord Lansdowne, from the point of view of India itself, whether, supposing she were isolated from the United Kingdom, it would be necessary to maintain a force such as is borrowed from the United Kingdom and in the same degree of efficiency?—I should say certainly not. The Indian Army is organised with a view to the possibility of its employment upon operations which have nothing to do either with the internal policy of the country or with the mere repression of tribal disorders upon the frontier.

15,997. Then would it be a fair suggestion that the difference in the cost of training that force so borrowed, between what would be necessary for Indian purposes and the standard which is kept up for Imperial and home purposes, should be borne by the home exchequer? —It is very difficult to express these things precisely in terms of money; but your question seems to me to point to the principle which I was endeavouring in my answers to the Chairman to enforce.

15,998. That we for home purposes, for Imperial purposes, are keeping the army at a higher standard of efficiency than India, taken by itself, would require, and that we should make that consideration an element in arriving at the settlement of charge between the two countries?—Certainly, an element.

15,999. That cannot be put into figures, but still it is an important element in the spirit in which we should approach this settlement?—That is my view.

Lord Wolseley on the Treatment of India and the Colonies

13,270. And, therefore, the very fact of these reserves being here is a source of great economy to India?—Certainly it is; and the best proof of the necessity of the reserve in India was the war of 1857. Supposing there had been no England to draw upon, and no English army to draw upon in 1857, what should we have done, where should we have been?

13,271. (Mr Buchanan.) That applies, of course, to the whole Empire, does it not? And the difference of the position of India to any other part of the Empire in such an emergency is that, whereas, in the case of a military eventuality in South Africa, we make our whole military reserves available, and we pay the bulk of the charges, we do the same to India, and we make India pay the whole?—India pays nothing for our reserves at all.

13,272. But when they are sent out, we make India pay the whole?—Yes.

13,273. When we send out a military force in the case of an emergency in the colonies, we pay the bulk of the expense ourselves ?—Yes.

Lord Roberts on India as Training Ground for the British Army

15,664. Do you attach importance to the argument that India affords the best training ground for the British Army during peace as a ground for reducing the home charges of British regiments in India ?—I think that everyone who has served in India of late years must admit that it affords by far the best training ground for troops, and this fact should not be lost sight of when the apportionment of charges between England and India has to be considered. I doubt if any country is so peculiarly well adapted for training troops as India is. At all large centres ground can be found where artillery can conveniently carry on practice with the present far-reaching guns. In the immediate neighbourhood of nearly every station, in some places at the very door of the barracks, ranges exist where soldiers can practice with their rifles at any leisure moment. Vast tracts of ground are available for manœuvres on an extended scale, and owing to the amount of transport obliged to be always kept up, these manœuvres can be carried on as nearly as possible on service conditions. Then the general state of readiness for taking the field at a moment’s notice, which is the normal condition of troops in India, renders that country an admirable school of instruction for the Queen’s troops serving in India, and does not in any way cause them to imbibe false notions of what active service in Europe is like. The lives of British soldiers in India are too valuable to be risked to no purpose, and it would be the height of folly to require them to perform such offices as cooking when native labour is cheap. The men are taught to cook, and can look after themselves and their officers when occasion requires, and the fact that life in India is more luxurious than in more temperate climates, does not in any way detract from military efficiency, or make troops less fitted for war in other parts of the world. I think it has been proved that British soldiers from India who have taken part in campaigns in Egypt and South Africa were quite as well able to look after themselves as were their comrades who came direct from England; and as regards efficiency, they were, to say the least of them, not inferior. There is another advantage, too, which India possesses, and that is, that officers, especially young officers, are oftener placed in positions of responsibility than they are in the United Kingdom. This is especially the case as regards Royal Engineers, but it holds good also with all the branches, and only those who know from experience how heavily responsibility weighs upon men when they suddenly find themselves in positions of difficulty can appreciate the value of this kind of training. The fact is, that from a training point of view, India is a very great strength to the army of the United Kingdom.

15,665. Would you agree that England and India are partners, and that India may be expected to pay the charge for her own defence?—Yes, most certainly.

15,666. (Mr Courtney.) Do you deduce any practical conclusion from the answer which you made just now? —I think it should be taken into consideration in the apportionment. What I said was this: “This fact ought not to be lost sight of when the apportionment of charges between England and India have to be considered."

Sir Henry Brackenbury on the Indian Army Expenditure

14,782. It is not the amount that either the War Office or anybody else is proposing to charge India? —I perfectly understand that; but, as I understand it, the basis of these charges generally is that India should repay to England what it can be proved that England would not pay but for the military requirements of India, subject to what, I think, is called some sort of debate. Well, my personal opinion is that it is altogether wrong that there should be any such theory as that at all; and if I might be allowed to give my reasons for that opinion. In the first place, I would say that the army in India is largely in excess of the requirements for the preservation of internal order in India. The strength of the army in India is calculated to allow of a powerful field army being placed on or beyond the Indian frontier, in addition to the obligatory garrisons required for keeping order in India. The necessity for maintaining in India that powerful field army, in addition to the obligatory garrisons, is caused by the approach of a great Military Power into a position which enables her to threaten directly Afghanistan, to which we are under treaty obligations, and indirectly to threaten the security of India. The foreign policy of India is directed entirely from England by Her Majesty’s Government, and it is part of British foreign policy generally. The object of British foreign policy generally, I believe, is to secure British rule over the British Empire. If it were desired to maintain British rule in India only for India’s sake, then I think it would be fair to make India pay to the uttermost farthing everything that could be shown was due to Britain’s rule over India; but I cannot but feel that Britain’s interest in keeping India under British rule is enormous. India affords employment to thousands of Britons; India employs millions of British capital; and Indian commerce is of immense value to Great Britain. Therefore it seems to me that India being held by Great Britain, not only for India’s sake, but also for Great Britain’s sake, Great Britain should pay a share of the expenditure for this purpose; and in estimating what that share should be I think that England should behave generously, because, in the first place, England is a rich country, and India is poor country. It is not altogether a fair basis of comparison of their comparative richness and poorness, but it is one that is worth bringing to notice, and that is the income tax of India, as compared with the income tax of this country. In India you have an income tax of two and a half per cent, about 6d. in the pound. I cannot lay my hand exactly on what that income tax produces, but I believe that the 6d. in the pound produces less than £1,000,000 sterling; in England every 1d. produces considerably over £2,000,000 sterling. Moreover, Indian taxation is chiefly derived from land revenue and salt duties, and those fall ultimately on the poorest classes. Another reason why I think England should be generous to India is that India has no representation. I believe that it is an absolute necessity that she should have no representation under her present conditions; but it seems to me that where a nation is practically arbitrarily governed, the governing power should behave generously to the nation it so governs.

14,805. (Mr Courtney.) That force includes the 75,000 British soldiers?—That includes the 75,000 we have now. In the days of the Mutiny I do not remember what the proportions were, but they were something like six to one of native troops to British troops. The artillery was in the hands of the natives, the arsenals were in the hands of the natives. Now the proportion throughout the whole of India is two and a half to one of native troops to British troops. The natives have not got a gun, a single artillery gun, in their hands, with the exception of a few little mountain batteries; and the whole of the arsenals are in the hands of the British troops. To my mind you have got a condition of safety now in India which makes it utterly improbable that India should require soldiers from England to maintain internal order in India. The occasion when India would require soldiers from England is on the occasion of her northern frontier being threatened by a great power; and that is the occasion when England would not be able to send them; and therefore it is that I say it is not right to say that England contributes by keeping a reserve for India.

14,886. You seemed to think that the rule of India by England was much more in her own interests than in the interests of the Indian people?—No, I again most distinctly disclaim having said that. There is no one who holds more strongly than I do the immense advantage to India of British rule. I hold it as an article of my faith, but I hold, and I used the expression, that it is an enormous advantage to England to have India.

14,887. You gave, as one of the reasons, the occupation that it gave to English people?—Yes.

14,888. To what extent do you think it gives occupation to English people? What is the English population in India?—The British population in India? I cannot say offhand what it is.

14,889. Including the army?—I cannot say what it is.

14,890. Two hundred thousand? — It may be 200,000.

14,891. Including the 73,000 military forces?— Yes, I do not know really what it is.

14,892. The military forces comprise, of course, the local forces, which include a large number of Europeans. I suppose the European population may roughly be taken at about 80,000 or 90,000 military and 100,000 civilians?—I do not really know what the population is.

14,893-4. That is not a very large number to be personally benefited?—Well, that is a matter of opinion. I should say it was a very large number to be employed.

14,895. (Chairman.) Perhaps it would be hardly worth while for the British taxpayer to pay £1,000,000 to keep those 200,000 persons in employment, would it?—That was only one of many things. I was stating the advantages to England, and I said India employs a large number of Englishmen. Look at all the hundreds and thousands of people that we know whose sons have gone out to India and got employment there; and the great commerce which we have with India; and with regard to that what I would point out is that if India, for instance, were to fall into the hands of Russia, we know perfectly well that our commerce there would become practically extinct, because, if she did not actually prohibit the importation of British goods, Russia would put on such differential duties on them that she would make it practically impossible for them to be imported, as she does in Central Asia and elsewhere.

14,896. Unless there is any other point that you would wish to call attention to, these are all the questions we have to ask?—I have nothing else. But I should like to express my opinion that if this Royal Commission could see its way to recommending the abolition of all these accounts for military and naval services, for the Secretary of State’s salary and the expenses of the India Office, for diplomatic and consular charges in Persia, China, and elsewhere, and to substitute for them a fixed contribution from India, as her return for the advantages she derives from Her Majesty’s Government and Her Majesty’s Navy, treating India more generously than she is at present treated in these accounts, the acceptance of such a recommendation would remove many constant causes of irritation, and would do much to convince all classes in India of the desire of this country, which rules India, to treat India justly and generously.

Sir Edwin Collen on the Apportion of Military Expenditure between Great Britain and India

6167. (Mr Buchanan.) Has not the principle of this charge been laid down by the Government of India Act of 1858 in which it says that :— “Except for preventing or repelling actual invasion of Her Majesty’s Indian possessions, or under other sudden and urgent necessity, the Revenues of India shall not, without the consent of both Houses of Parliament, be applicable to defray the expenses of any military operation carried on beyond the external frontiers of such possessions by H.M. forces charged upon such Revenues?"—That principle has been laid down; but then I suppose the House of Commons ratified the charge.

6170. Would you say this parliamentary control, however, has not been as effectual as the Government of India would like ?—Yes.

6171-2. I mean, looking at the list of expeditions, we find that the Abyssinian expedition, the Perak expedition, and the two Egyptian expeditions have all been charged upon the Government of India. Still, looking at it from the point of view of the Government of India Act, would you agree with me in saying that, in accordance with what appears to be the intention of that Act, India should not have been charged with the ordinary expenses, much less with the extraordinary expenses, of any of these expeditions?—That is my personal opinion; but I can hardly express the view of the Government of India on those points.

6197. Then I think at the close of your memorandum you say: “The general principles should be determined which should regulate the division between the British and Indian Treasuries of the charges on account of the European troops in India, with special reference to the fact that the military forces of the United Kingdom are organised to meet the requirements of the whole Empire, that India has no voice in deciding on the nature of such organisation, and that she, as a poor country, is made to enter into a general partnership with England, one of the wealthiest countries in the world. The contribution to be paid by India should be decided with special reference to the relative positions and wealth of India and England, to the fact that India supplies a great training ground for the British portion of the Indian army. Further, it is considered that a contribution should be made by the Imperial Exchequer towards the cost of the fortifications which have been erected on the frontier, or to defend the ports of India against attack by great European Powers, and that England should bear a share of the cost of Aden which is practically an Imperial fortress.” I read those paragraphs in order to ask you whether you would wish to amplify them in any sense? —No, I think that that represents in brief what I wish to say.

6619. . . . Further in the memorandum inclosed in the Government of India letter of the 25th March 1890, the following passages occur ; “ India is incurring great expenditure in the increase of the army, and in armaments and defences for the maintenance of British supremacy in the East. It is surely not unreasonable to consider that England should bear a share of this burden, the principle should be that of true reciprocation, and India should not be charged on account of expenditure which must necessarily be incurred by England for the maintenance of her army and the Empire at large.” . . . “ That India should be considered as affording a training ground for the officers and men of the British army, that the relative financial capacities of the two countries should be considered, and the whole matter adjusted on broad and statesmanlike views of public policy.” Well, I apply all these, in the words of the Government of India, to the general question of all the relations between Britain and India in regard to charges in both countries for their common interests. It was suggested by Mr Ryder that the Government here, or the British Exchequer, was requested and prayed to show mercy and pity to a poor partner, and that it is only in that way that we are asking from Great Britain not to charge this and not to charge that. Well now, I maintain, as Mr Fawcett did very distinctly state—he said (Hansard, vol. 250, p. 454) distinctly he wished to explain (this was on account of the Afghan war that he said this), that so far as India was concerned, this was not to be regarded as a matter of generosity, but of justice and legality; and he again repeated the words, “the matter must be decided on grounds of strict justice and legality.” And then Mr Gladstone (p. 932) completely adopted all that Mr Fawcett had urged, both with regard to the principle upon which the expenses of the Afghan army should have been apportioned between the two countries, viz. that of a very substantial contribution from Britain; but not on the ground of generosity or pity, but on the ground of simple justice and legality; and that is what I ask should be done. Do you not think so?—I think certainly that the principles of justice and legality should be followed.

Lord Cromer on a Court of Arbitration

13,642. That is what we should like to hear?—My view of the question of the home charges is this: I believe there is a very general wish in this country, in Parliament, and amongst Ministers of whatsoever party, to deal not only justly, but even generously, with India; but I think it would be an extremely good thing if you could arrange in some way a Court of Arbitration to deal with these matters. It is not only that the settlement should be just, it is of the highest importance that everybody in India should think it is just, not only the natives, but the European public, who have also to be considered, and the Government of India themselves. Under the present system, although I am not alluding to any special point, or saying that the distribution has been unjust, there is no means of making the people in India think it is just. It is supposed to be arranged between the various departments and the India Office, and the general impression, rightly or wrongly, is that the English view is advocated with greater strength, and more successfully, than the Indian view. Whether that be right or wrong, the mere fact that such an opinion exists is an evil, and therefore I should be very glad indeed if something could be done to have some court of arbitration to settle these matters. That is all the more desirable, because a great many of these matters must be rather the subject of equitable compromise than anything else. Take the case of Aden, to which somebody alluded in the course of these discussions: it is perfectly impossible for anybody to make any precise calculation as to what contribution India should pay for Aden. India is very much interested in Aden, and so are Ceylon, Hong Kong, and the Straits Settlements, and English commerce generally. It is a matter of judgment how much India should pay; and it would satisfy Indian opinion, and do a great deal of good in that way, if there were some court of arbitration instituted to settle these matters.

13,650. (Mr Buchanan.) Would you give power to either party to refer any question on which there was apportionment of charge to the board of arbitration?— I think I should. I should make them the court of appeal; in fact, I almost think they ought to be constituted by Act of Parliament with the necessary powers laid down specifically.

13,651. Something like the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council?—Very much of that nature, yes.

13,652. And when a question arose between Home Departments and the Indian Government as to the apportionment of any charge, would you give the power to either party to refer it to the board of arbitration, or would it necessarily go there?—No; I think I would give either of them the power of referring; of course, restricting myself to financial questions—nothing else but pure finance.

13,653. And in regard to these charges which have permanently to be apportioned between England and India, the military charges, and the capitation grant, would you say that they, at intervals of five or ten years, should be referred to this board of arbitration?—I think so. My inclination certainly would be to give the utmost possible guarantee to the Indian taxpayers and the Indian public, that all these questions are decided by some body of men who are quite independent, and who are not in any way biassed against them. I repeat that I am not saying that in the past the decisions have been unjust, but what I want is to satisfy the Indian public that that is not the case, which I think is of great importance.

Sir Auckland Colvin on the Viceroy’s Council as representing Spending Departments

3216. May I ask you one or two questions which Sir Ralph Knox wished to ask you, and which I shall be glad to put to you even in an imperfect way. They referred to the constitution of the Council of the Viceroy. Am I not right in thinking that the number of the Council, the Executive Council, I think you call it, is eight?—Not so many as that.

3217. Seven?—There are the Viceroy, the Commander - in - Chief, the Military Member, the Home Member, the Public Works Member, the Finance Member, and the Legal Member—seven. It varies, it is not necessarily the same; the Public Works Member is not always there.

3218. Out of that number we may say that all represent spending departments, except the Viceroy himself and the Financial Member?—I should not make that exception there; I should make no exception there. The Viceroy is in charge of the Foreign Department, which has a very large political area beyond the Indus, which causes very considerable expenditure.

3219. Unless the Viceroy throws his weight on the side of economy, the Financial Member stands quite alone?—Yes.

Sir David Barbour on the weakness of Financial Check in India

2224. I think I am right in saying that in many respects the Financial Member stands alone as against the whole of the other Members of Council, in respect that he is the one to furnish the funds, and the others want to spend funds?—That is the case, of course; that is necessarily the case. The different departments want money, and he has to keep some check upon them, if he can.

2225. So that, though he may be stronger in his department individually as against any particular department, he is not strong enough to resist the whole of the Council ?—He cannot resist the majority.

2226. And the general feeling is that he has got to provide the funds for the necessary requirements of the others, so that he finds himself rather in antagonism with the general feeling of the Council ?—Of course he must have continual controversies going on as regards particular items of expenditure ; that is inevitable.

2227. And therefore, supposing the Viceroy is inclined to some military operation and the Military Member of the Council is not actively opposed to the Commander-in-Chief, there would be at once a very large majority against the Financial Member ?—Oh, yes, of course.

2301. And in the whole arrangement of the Budget and of expenditure the Indians themselves have no voice whatever ?—Of course, they have no direct and immediate voice; but there is no doubt that the Government of India does pay a certain attention to public opinion in India ; every Government does.

2302. But they have no direct voice in the matter ? —No direct voice as far as I can see.

2303. By the Act of 1861 (19), without the permission of the Governor-General no member can introduce any measure (which virtually amounts to exclusion) about matters affecting the public debt or public revenues or for imposing any charge on such revenues, or the discipline and maintainence of any part of Her Majesty’s military or naval forces. This means that, as far as the spending of our money is concerned, the Legislative Council is simply as if it did not exist at all?—I do not think the Legislative Council as it is now constituted has no influence, but it has not much direct influence upon expenditure.

2304. The Legislative Council is, of course, the primary source and the authority for expenditure. It is in the Legislative Council that the Budget of India is settled?—No, it is not passed in the Legislative Council.

2305. It is first passed by the Executive Council, and then it is legalized?—No, it is never legalized at all. It is merely read and discussed.

2344. Therefore the ultimate force is the personality of the Viceroy?—Yes, but there are two forces. The tendency is ordinarily for pressure to be put on the Financial Department to incur expenditure. It is practically pressure. The other departments are always pressing to spend more money; their demands are persistent and continuous. It is uncertain whether the Viceroy will support the Financial Member of the Council or not. If he does not give him support, the Financial Department is weak; if he does give that support, the Financial Department is strong.

Mr S. Jacob on the increase of the Public Debt and the Home charges

7244. (Chairman.) Perhaps we may now take the debt as a whole. I see that the total debt of the Indian Government in 1875 consisted in India of Rx.69,850,000, and in England of £48,600,000, making a total, accepting for the moment the valuation of the rupee at one-tenth of a pound, of £118,450,000 ?—Yes, those are the correct figures in round numbers.

7245. In 1895 the debt in India was Rx. 104,373,000, and in England it was £116,005,000 Putting them together on the same basis they amount to £220,378,000 ?—That is so.

7246. Therefore the increase is in round figures Rx.102,000,000?—Yes.

5431. Then perhaps you will turn to Table X. Table X. shows an increase of net expenditure in England from Rx.12,501,000 in 1875-6 to Rx. 15,681,000 in 1895-6, and that is exclusive of the charge involved in exchange?—(Mr Jacob.) Yes, that is the total charge in England ; that is not the charge for the army only.

5432. Yes; I am taking the total first of all: Sir Henry has separated the army charge in Table X., and I shall next call attention to the columns in the Table X. which refer to the army?—Yes.

5433. That increase on the whole therefore is a little over Rx.3,000,000 ?—Yes.

Mr S. Jacob on Irrigation Works and the absence of a Sinking Fund in India

8757. Can you tell us what is the total capital outlay on irrigation works for the period we have usually taken, namely, 1874-75, 1875-76 and 1892-93, or 1893-94, whichever year is convenient ?—The total capital expenditure has increased from Rx.12,897,901 at the beginning of 1875-76 to Rx.30,343,404 at the end of 1894-95. The total capital expenditure incurred up to the end of 1896-97 is estimated at Rx.31,921,000 ; that includes estimates for 1895-96 and 1896-97.

8758. (Mr Jackson.) For what period is that ? —That is the total capital expenditure up to date.

8759. £31,000,000 ?—Rx.31,921,000.

8760. The amount of Rx.12,897,000 which you gave us, then, was the amount expended up to the period of 1875-76 ?—That was the total expenditure incurred at the beginning of 1875-76.

8761. (Chairman.) How long before that year, 1875-6, had there been capital outlay upon irrigation ?—I do not remember when first capital expenditure was incurred, but it was certainly before 1859.

8762. Am I not right in thinking that Colonel Cotton’s work was considerably anterior to the Mutiny ?—It must have been.

8763. And, therefore, irrigation works have been carried on over a long period, though they were not charged to capital in the early days in this form ? or would the 12,897,000 include such capital expenditure as was made by Colonel Cotton ?—It would include any expenditure by Government on those works which are classed as major works, at whatever period it had been incurred. When the present system was introduced, the account was carried back to include all past capital expenditure.

8764. And may we take it that that Rx. 12,897,000, which we will call 13,000,000, really includes all anterior expenditure on major works?—Yes, all the expenditure which had been incurred by Government. At that time there were companies in the field.

8765. Which have since been bought up?—Yes, at least there was a company, I should say.

8766. Can you tell us how much of these sums of 12,897,000 and of 30,343,404 are represented by loans borrowed either in England or in India?—Of the Rx. 30,343,404, about Rx. 22,000,000 have been incurred from loan funds.

8767. And 8,000,000 would represent about the amount advanced out of revenue?—Yes; that includes the old expenditure which was incurred entirely from revenue. The expenditure which was first brought to account when the present system was introduced was Rx. 5,293,000; when we first began to keep separate capital accounts, Rx. 5,293,000, which had been incurred out of revenue previous to 1867-68, was brought to account against the capital.

8768. Up to that time there had been no borrowing for the purpose?—No.

8769. Then, in reality, the amount advanced of late years out of revenue has been comparatively small?— Yes.

8770. Not above three millions?—That is all.

8771. And all the rest has been borrowed?—Yes.

8772. (Mr Jackson.) Is there any sinking fund, or any provision for repaying the borrowed money?—No, there is no sinking fund 8773. (Chairman.) As we have understood from your evidence on the subject of the debt, the settled policy of India, inasmuch as it is a constantly borrowing power, is not to set any sinking fund against the debt?—Yes. There have been proposals at various times to have sinking funds for certain portions of the debt, but they have invariably been disallowed, upon that principle, that, as long as we are borrowing, we should merely borrow a larger amount with one hand, in order to create a sinking fund to pay off other debt with the other.

Mr S. Jacob on the loss to the Government incurred by Railway Construction

8123. Perhaps, in conclusion to the questions which I shall have to ask you on the subject, you would give us a resumé of the mileage, the capital outlay, the gross earnings, the working expenses, and the net earnings in the years 1876 and 1894, beginning with the open mileage?—In 1876 the open mileage was 6862; and in 1894 it was 18,841; in 1876 the capital outlay to date was Rx.112,000,000, and in 1894 it was Rx.246,880,000; in 1876 the gross earnings were Rx.8,794,000, and in 1894 Rx.25,510,000; in 1876 the working expenses were Rx.4,229,000, and in 1894 they were Rx.13,530,000. In 1876 the net earnings were Rx.4,565,000, and in 1894 they were Rx.11,980,000.

8124. That is a summary of the condition of rail-roads in 1894 in India?—Yes.

8125. The Rx.246,880,000 practically covers all capital expenditure?—Except that Rx. 8,000,000, which I mentioned before.

8126. Which, at all events, it is open to argument that it ought to be included?—Yes.

8142. (Mr Buchanan.) With reference to the last point, whilst you can show that on railways there has been a return in rupees of about four and three-quarter per cent. on the amount of rupees spent on railway construction, has the construction of railways by the Government of India been a source of profit to the Exchequer as a whole?—No, it has been a loss upon the whole.

8143. It has been upon the whole a loss?—Yes, I mean leaving out all indirect advantages, and looking merely at the actual direct result upon the finances.

8144. Financially it has been a loss?—Yes.

8145. Mainly due to the fall in exchange?—Yes, and the high rates of sterling guaranteed interest.

8153. Then you are really embarking further in the policy of railway extension?—Yes, and we are constructing some large railways, which only gradually come into working.

8154. And has the Government satisfied itself that there is a fair prospect that these will not throw an increased financial burden upon the exchequer?—In the case of every individual railway, except in the case of those which are constructed as military or protective lines, the Government does ascertain, before construction is commenced, that there is a reasonable prospect of the railway producing a net return of at least four per cent. upon the capital expenditure.

Sir Henry Waterfield on Local Cesses imposed on Land

605. Are the Provincial Governments allowed to impose any local duties for their own local use, and have they done so?—Such of the Provincial Governments as have legislative councils have, with the consent of the Government of India, imposed provincial or local rates since the alteration of the system made in 1877.

606. How would you describe those provincial rates?—They are rates or cesses on the land, collected generally with the land revenue, and applied either exclusively to local purposes, or under certain rules to the general purposes of the province. A proportion not exceeding ten per cent. may be taken for public works in the province generally, but not necessarily for the district in which it is collected. The bulk of it is entirely for local purposes.

607. Are they at all analogous to what they call in France centimes additionels?—I do not know the French system.

608. Under that system, as I understand it, there is a certain rate of tax, and then for local purposes there is levied in addition, we will say, to every five francs, five centimes, which they call centimes additionels. Would it resemble that, or would it be an entirely fresh tax upon the land?—In the first inception of these local rates it was very much of the nature that you have described. There was a three per cent. levied for general purposes, and then one per cent. more for local public works, but I do not think now that it is levied in the same fixed manner; it varies according to the province, and according to the Act that is in force in the province.

609. But it is a percentage on the land tax?—It is a percentage on the land.

610. On the land tax?—I see your point.

611. (Mr Courtney.) Does it run throughout the whole province, or is it attached to districts or municipalities?—I think the local rate is the same for each district throughout the province. I think there is no variation in that, but it is levied on the land. (Mr Jacob.) In some cases it is an actual percentage on the land revenue, and in some provinces before legislation was undertaken it was levied under the settlement arrangements; as a part of the settlement arrangement the land revenue was fixed, and then a percentage upon that of so many annas in the rupee, as we put it generally in India, was fixed for education, roads and schools.

612. Education and schools?—(Sir Henry Waterfield.) Yes, and hospitals.

Mr D. E. Wacha on the Growth of Expenditure

17,743. Looking at the evidence you have given us on the increase of expenditure generally, may I ask you whether you have arrived at any conclusions on the strength of the facts so stated, which you would like to place before us?—From the foregoing examination of the progress of expenditure it will be evident to the Commission :—

  • (1) That the financial embarrassments which prevailed during the decade owe their origin principally to the enormous growth of military expenditure, which has led to the imposition of additional taxation, which now amounts, including the customs duties on cotton goods, to nearly 6 crores.
  • (2) That the growth in civil expenditure is also very considerable. But so far as this is concerned there is not much cause of complaint save in one respect, namely, that the costly foreign agency absorbs a large portion of the revenue which could be considerably saved if there was more extensive employment of Indians in the higher grades of the administration. It may be observed that adequate civil expenditure of a productive character is much to be desired. I mean such as gives the taxpayers a fair quid pro quo, such as education for the masses, more efficient administration of justice, greater village and town sanitation, and all other works of public utility which contribute to the expansion of provincial resources and prosperity of the people.
  • (3) That the burden of exchange might easily have been borne, without resort to fresh and enhanced taxation, had the military expenditure been on the basis of 1884-5.
  • (4) That a similar growth, if allowed to go unchecked in future, is liable to plunge the Government into fresh embarrassments, leading to further taxation, which is neither desirable in the interests of good and stable government, nor in the interests of the people, among whom there prevails sullen discontent, inasmuch as their capacity to bear further burdens has been greatly crippled. The Secretary of State writes imperative despatches for strict economy, and for exercising utmost care in public expenditure, for the danger of increasing the burdens of taxation has to be borne in mind. (Vide Despatch 12th April, 1888, vol. ii., Appendix, p. 141; Despatch of 3rd November, 1892, vol. ii., Appendix, p. 154.)

These warnings seem to fall on deaf ears, and Secretaries of State do not enforce what they enjoin, and the despatches only remain pious intentions. At any rate the Commission must have noticed how in spite of them expenditure has grown apace. Since 1892 taxation to the extent of about 3 crores has been added, while the military activity beyond the frontiers was even greater in consequence of the acquisition of Gilgit, which ultimately led to the occupation of Chitral at a cost of 1½ crore and with a permanent annual charge of 25 lakhs! The State Secretary himself is a silent or originating party to this kind of expenditure, so that it may be truly observed that the despatches are practically of no effect, and that both the Secretary of State and the Government of India must be held equally responsible for that expenditure.

It is a well-known fact that India has no true surplus to speak of. It lives at the best from hand to mouth, and is oftener than not in a condition of embarrassment from which it relieves itself only by windfalls or borrowing or by enhanced taxation which every time that it is imposed diminishes the capacity of the taxpayer, whose income does not exceed Rs. 27 per annum.

From 1849-50 to 1894-5 there has been a net deficit of 37·62 million Rx. In other words, during the forty-six years, Indian finances have exhibited an annual deficit of Rx. 800,000 on an average. The most essential fact seems to have been invariably lost sight of, that India is made a poor country by the “bleeding” it has been subjected to, and can, therefore, have but a poor revenue. That a system of administration, however well-meaning, which takes no cognisance of this essential fact but goes on adopting a western system of Government, a system of an alien Government in which the people have no voice and which is besides known to be costly, must in the long run end in financial disaster, however long it may be coming in. I go further and say it is a system unnatural and foredoomed to failure. Under the circumstances Indians cannot but view with the gravest apprehension any further increase of expenditure.

Mr G. K. Gokhale on the exclusion of the people of India from high appointments in India

18,331. I think you were going to offer some observations on the services?—Yes. In every department of Indian expenditure the question of agency is one of paramount importance. According to a Parliamentary return of May, 1892, we have in India in the higher branches of the civil and military departments a total of 2388 officers drawing Rs. 10,000 a year and upwards, of whom only 60 are natives of India, and even these, with the exception of such as are judges, stop at a comparatively low level. And they are thus divided:—

TBL-021 · FOLIO 304Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
In Thousands of Rupees.
Natives.Eurasians.Europeans.Total Salaries of Natives.Total Salaries of Eurasians.Total Salaries of Europeans.
Civil Department.55101,21194715125,274
Military . . . .11854121113,268
Public Works . .3423933453,415
Incorporated Local Funds . . . .1—910—113
Total . . .60152,3131,00220742,070

In addition to these the railway companies employ 105 officers, drawing Rs. 10,000 a year and more. They are all Europeans, and their total salaries come to 16 lakhs 28 thousand rupees. If we come down to officers drawing between Rs. 5000 and Rs. 10,000 a year, we find that we have 421 natives in the civil department, as against 1207 Europeans and 96 Eurasians. In the military department there are 25 natives, as against 1699 Europeans and 22 Eurasians. In the public works department there are 85 natives as against 549 Europeans and 39 Eurasians. And in the Incorporated Local Funds there are 4 natives as against 22 Europeans and 3 Eurasians. The total salaries of officers of this class are thus divided: Civil Department, natives, Rs. 2,905,000; Eurasians, 650,000; and Europeans, 8,830,000. In the Military Department, natives, 164,000; Eurasians, 139,000; and Europeans, 13,698,000. In the Public Works Department, natives, 537,000; Eurasians, 278,000; and Europeans, 3,962,000. And in the Incorporated Local Funds, natives, 25,000; Eurasians, 17,000; and Europeans, 146,000. In addition to these there are, under the railway companies, 258 officers of this class, of whom only 2 are natives, 8 being Eurasians and 248 Europeans. Their salaries are thus divided: natives, 12,000; Eurasians, 50,000; and Europeans, 17,10,000. In England £125,360 is paid as salaries by the Indian Government, and £54,522 by railway companies, all to Europeans. The financial loss entailed by this practical monopoly by Europeans of the higher branches of the services in India is not represented by salaries only. There are besides heavy pension and furlough charges, more than three and a half millions sterling being paid to Europeans in England for the purpose in 1890. The excessive costliness of the foreign agency is not, however, its only evil. There is a moral evil which, if anything, is even greater. A kind of dwarfing or stunting of the Indian race is going on under the present system. We must live all the days of our life in an atmosphere of inferiority, and the tallest of us must bend in order that the exigencies of the existing system may be satisfied.

Mr G. Subramania Iyer on admitting Indians to some share in the control over Financial Administration

18,767. Perhaps you would run through them, would you ?—Yes. Before proceeding to express my views on the subject of the system of provincial finance, which is an important wheel in our financial machinery, I shall point out my remedies thus far. 1. There can be no doubt that one way of strengthening the financial position of India would be as Sir Auckland Colvin says : “ In some way without undue interference with the authority of the Government of India, to establish a control emanating from what theoretically is at present the last Court of Appeal, Parliament. A committee of the Members of Parliament, such as Sir William Wedderburn has suggested, to scrutinise the financial statement every year and to submit a report to the House of Commons before the financial statement is brought up for discussion, would in some measure secure this end. The Committee would of course pay due attention to the opinions of the non-official Members expressed in the Legislative Council of the Viceroy.” It came out fully in the evidence before the Commission that the present system, by which disputes regarding the apportionment of certain charges between the two Governments are kept up for years and finally decided to the satisfaction of neither party, should be put an end to. It has been suggested that the principles which should be the general basis of apportionment should be laid down in a Treasury Minute, and that the application of these principles to instances where the two Governments might not agree, should be left to an arbitrator, or a body of arbitrators, chosen by both the Governments. This suggestion commended itself to the Marquess of Ripon and the Marquess of Lansdowne. It would be a better system, I think, to rest the power of final decision in the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. The Privy Council is a tribunal well known in India and would command from the people greater confidence than any arbitrators chosen from time to time. I have already pointed out the importance of the Members of the Secretary of State’s Council being men in touch with the actual financial conditions of the day in India. To secure this end, the present system of appointing them for ten years, and keeping them on for a further period if the Secretary of State chooses, should be abolished. Their term of office should extend only to five years like the Members of the Government of India and the Provincial Governors, and they should not be eligible for re-appointment. Among the Members of the Council there should always be several Indians possessing necessary qualifications and not necessarily official. They should be appointed on the recommendation of the elected Members of the Legislative Councils. They would take care to put before the Secretary of State the Indian view, which he has no means of knowing under the existing system. Coming to the constitution of the Government of India in India, I have already pointed out the desirability of the Governor-General being divested of control over any particular department, so that he may have more time than he has at present to attend to internal affairs of the country, which unfortunately do not receive the same attention that they used to receive in years previous to 1885. The Members of the Governor-General’s Legislative Council should be empowered to vote on the Budget, although any decision adverse to the Government of India may be overruled by the President. There should be given greater scope for interpellation, and, whenever any measure of legislation affecting finance is in contemplation, the views of public bodies should be obtained beforehand as far as possible.

The Hon. Surendra Nath Banerjea on Apportionment of Military Charges and wider Employment of Indians in Civil Offices

19,320. You are going to proceed to give us your opinion on the growth of expenditure?—Yes. The question of the wider employment of the people of India in the public service of their own country is more or less a financial problem. The expenditure has gone on increasing, especially in the military department; and Indian public opinion regards the growth of military expenditure as utterly beyond what the country can bear, and as seriously interfering with legitimate expenditure on the most necessary domestic improvements. The people of India who are capable of forming a judgment on the subject are at one with Sir H. Brackenbury in the opinion that the cost of the portion of the Indian Army in excess of what is necessary for maintaining the internal peace of the country should be met from the British Exchequer, and the expenses of the salaries of the European portion of the Army ought to be fairly apportioned between England and India. Until this is done, the resources of India will not be found equal for the purposes of good and progressive government, and no improvement is possible in the condition of the masses. By the wider employment of the people of India in the public service economy would be introduced, and an impetus imparted to the intellectual and moral elevation of the people. Ten years ago, the Public Service Commission, presided over by the late Sir Charles Aitchison, at that time Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab, and consisting of some of the most distinguished officials and non-official representatives of the day, reported upon the question of public employment in India. The gist of their recommendations may be summarised as follows : That indigenous agency should be more largely employed in the public service, that the recruitment of the official staff in England should be curtailed, and advantage taken of qualified agency obtainable in India. In other words, the provincial service recruited in India should be the backbone of the administrative agency, subject to European supervision and control. “Considerations of policy and economy alike require,” observed the Commission in their Report, “that, so far as is consistent with the ends of good government, the recruitment of the official staff in England should be curtailed, and advantage taken of qualified agency obtainable in India.” As a matter of fact, however, the higher appointments in almost all branches of the public service are held by Europeans, although more than ten years has elapsed since the Commission have submitted their Report.