Appendix R

Mr Rogers on Settlements in Madras

Famines and Land Assessments in India, Romesh Chunder Dutt, 1900 · from page 212 · about 17 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

[The following letter with enclosure is published by the kind permission of the writer.]

The Under Secretary of State for India.

3rd February 1893.

Sir,—I have the honour to forward, in continuation of my letter of the 12th ultimo bringing to notice the state of matters in the Madras Presidency with regard to the coercive processes that appear to be necessary in the collection of the land revenue, a Memo. showing in detail the method of settlement in that Presidency and comparing it with the Bombay system.

If I were not convinced from long experience of settlements in Bombay that the Madras system lay at the root of the evils I have endeavoured to expose, I think the following figures, taken from the Land Revenue Settlement Report for 1887-88 (page 25) and those for the two subsequent years, the latest procurable, would be sufficient to prove my point.

In the eleven years from 1879-80 to 1889-90 there were sold by auction for the collection of land revenue the occupancy rights of 1,963,364 acres of land held by 840,713 defaulters, in addition to personal property of the value of Rs. 29,65,081. Of the 1,963,364 acres, 1,174,143 had to be bought in on the part of Government for want of bidders, that is to say, very nearly sixty per cent. of the land supposed to be fairly and equitably assessed could not find purchasers, and only the balance of 779,142 acres was sold. It is true that the area of land sold for arrears has steadily diminished down to the amount shown in my previous letter, but looking to the very imperfect system of assessment now commented upon, it would seem that this must be due to the gradual elimination of all land that cannot find men to cultivate it in consequence of the unfairness of its assessment. The evils of the Mahratta farming system has been pointed out in my “History of the Bombay Land Revenue,” but I doubt if that system at its worst could have shown such a spectacle as that of nearly 850,000 ryots in the course of eleven years sold out of about 1,900,000 acres of land.

Extracts from the Madras Manual of Administration, 1885.

In Madras the field surveys take the form of a complete cadastral, combined with a topographical, survey. The next step consists in the inspection of villages and the classification of villages and soils. Inspection extends to the whole tract of country immediately under Settlement, and the Settlement Officer visits as large a proportion as possible of the villages contained in it, so as to make himself acquainted with the general features of the tract and the condition of each village. In Madras the extent of the tract settled sometimes comprises a whole subdivision of a district, with an area of 1000 square miles.

In the classification of soils in Southern India, natural soils alone are looked to in the first instance, and manure is considered subsequently.

Remarks.

The only classification of villages for settlement possible under a proper system is one of arrangement in classes with reference to climate and proximity to markets for disposal of produce. If their existing condition is looked to, and those that are apparently prosperous are rated higher than others, and vice versâ, the system acts as a deterrent to industry and the expenditure of capital on agricultural improvements, and an incentive to sloth and slovenly cultivation. This was one of the objections taken in Bombay to a similar departure from right principle in the N.W. Provinces’ settlements. The two points noted above must, of course, be considered by the settling officer, as well as the greater or smaller value of fields according to nearness to or distance from village site and water, in fixing the rates of individual villages; but all other points connected with value according to natural fertility should be provided for in the classification of soils.

The theory as to the natural soils alone being looked to in the first instance, and manure being subsequently considered, is apparently at variance with the practice, for in the description of the fourth “order” of soils given below, viz. the “alluvial and permanently improved,” it is stated that that “order” provides for rich islands of extraordinary fertility, and for garden and other soils per-

Madras System.

By the time that the stage of assessment is entered upon, the Settlement Officer has before him a number of general statistics collected during the survey, inspection and classification of each village, and especially a scale showing the relative value of fields. The revenue rate per acre is thence determined. The Madras method of doing this is as follows :

From time immemorial the “field” has been the unit of landed estate and the public demand on the ryot is the sum of the assessments on his several fields, the assessment on the field being the money value of the Government share of its produce. To

Remarks.

manently improved. Now there is no such thing as a soil permanently improved by manure, for the effect of the highest artificial manure, such as no native of India uses, must be but temporary, and, were there such soils in existence, to tax them more heavily would be to lay a direct impost on private enterprise. It is another matter to rate a field close to a village site higher than one at a distance on account of the facility for procuring manure possessed by the occupant of the former, and has nothing to do with the proper classification according to natural fertility.

Here the Bombay system joins direct issue with that of Madras, and maintains that it is not only unnecessary to a proper assessment to know or estimate the actual grain produce of a field, but that the attempt to arrive at any reliable estimate of the average produce per acre in any considerable tract of country is illusory and misleading. This was substantially the system originally adopted in Bombay by Mr Pringle (as described at pages 101 to 107, vol. ii., of the lately published “History of the Bombay Land Revenue”), which was proved to be so faulty that the Bombay Government finally came to the conclusion that the whole must be set aside, and, being satisfied that it could not even be made the basis of any revision, directed that the whole operation should be commenced de novo. What system was substituted for this in Bombay will be described hereafter, but attention may here be profitably

Madras System.

assess a field it is necessary to know either on the one hand the quantity of its produce without reference to its area, or on the other hand its area and the quantity of produce of a given part of it or of an equal portion of other fields of similar quality and condition. A Settlement based on the former of these methods would be interminable, and necessity compels the adoption of the latter. The determination of areas being the province of the Survey Department, that of produce alone is that of the Settlement Department.

Remarks.

called to the inherent improbability of the practicability of any such scheme as that still in force in Madras, notwithstanding its known failure in Bombay.

The most superficial observer passing over a few acres of standing crops in any part of the world cannot fail to see the great differences there are in those crops even in adjoining fields, notwithstanding the apparently identical geological and climatic circumstances. Anyone walking over the same ground when bare of crops could see at a glance sufficient to account for such differences in the marks of rivulets of water caused by the natural flow of the drainage, and variety in colour of soil, which would be accentuated if he examined its texture on the surface, or digging a little deeper found a substratum, more or less near to that surface, of stone, or impervious clay, or sand, or other unfertile substance.

If in a space of a few acres there are such differences to be seen, those to be found in thousands of square miles of country, in which geological and climatic circumstances would vary immensely, must be altogether beyond calculation. Notwithstanding this, the Madras system of assessment is to this day based on the supposed average produce of soils, complicated after deduction of from one-fourth to one-sixth, to allow for vicissitudes of seasons, by conversion of that produce into money at an average of prices of the principal varieties of grain for a period of twenty years, and by deduction from the

Madras System.

Remarks.

money value thus arrived at of the average expense of cultivation per acre, such as the cost of agricultural cattle and of their keep, seed, hire of labour, permanent and temporary, implements, manure, and transplanting. Some of these, such as the cost of cattle and farm tools, have even to be subdivided and spread over more than one year.

The mere enumeration of the elaborate processes of calculation, gone through on experiments of crops to the number of 2000 or 3000 in a district, is sufficient to convince anyone not under the influence of the magic of figures of the impracticable nature of the system of thus assessing the proper rents of individual fields, which are taken at half the residue, called the net produce, after the deductions noted above.

Each series is divided into classes, the exceptional into two, the others into three each ; the class of a soil is determined by the quantity of “clay” it contains, meaning by “clay” that impalpable matter which is formed by the combination of minute particles of the primitive earths with organic matter in a state of decay. The three soil classes are “clay,” “loam,” and “sand.” Clay soils of each series are those containing more than sixty - six per cent. of clay ; loamy soils

In order to decide to what category for assessment each field belongs, classifiers, checked by head classifiers and supervisors, examine it, and record it as of one of three or five “sorts,” of one of two or three “classes,” of one of five series or “orders” of land. The five orders are (1) the “regar” or black cotton, (2) the “red ferruginous,” (3) the “arinaceous,” (4) “the alluvial and permanently improved,” and (5) the “calcareous.” On the other side of the page are the methods of classification adopted. The classes are said to be few, and based on tangible differences. The former can hardly be said to be the case, when there may be three or five sorts multiplied by two or three classes multi-

Madras System.

are those with one-third to two-thirds clay, and the rest sand; sandy soils those with more than two-thirds sand. In selecting samples the soil is turned up to a depth of 6 or 8 inches, and the proportions of sand and clay, where doubtful, are tested by dissolution in water. The classes again are subdivided into “sorts,” the “sorts” being determined on the same consideration as the “class.” From the first Government has deprecated any attempt at making an accurately scientific classification of soils. . . . The classes adopted are few, and based on tangible differences of soil; for the most part eye, finger, and thumb are the classifier’s only guides, and the nearest approach to a scientific method that is allowed him is when in cases of doubt he tests for clay by simple methods which give its bulk or weight, but do not indicate its chemical composition.

Remarks.

plied by five orders to be taken into consideration, and it is recorded in the same paper (see p. 109, paragraph 112 of vol. i. of the “Madras Manual of Administration,” 1885) that as many as thirty-five different money rates are sometimes struck for a single revenue district, ranging from 4 annas to Rs. 20 per acre. Again, if liberty to decide to what “sort” a field may belong, a palpably dangerous liberty, is allowed to a lowly paid classifier, by testing for “clay” with water, why should he not equally be allowed to test by fire, a quasi-chemical method by which the quantity of organic matter in a sample of earth would be more accurately ascertained than by that of dissolution in water? (This is, of course, a reductio ad absurdum of the system.) What, again, becomes of the element of depth, most important in determining the fertility of a soil, especially in a rocky country where in one part of a field rock may be close to the surface, and in other parts the earth may be several feet deep? Should not also a sloping surface, which causes the rain to wash away the fertilising properties of the so-called “clay,” be taken into consideration in fixing “class” and “sort”? Is such a serious deterioration in soil as that caused by impregnation with salt from salt springs, or occasional overflow of the tide, not looked to?

This leads to a consideration of the method adopted in Bombay to arrive at the relative values of fields by the classification of their soils. According

Madras System.

Remarks.

to the principles originally laid down in 1840, and acted upon up to the present time, the most naturally fertile soil in a district is ascertained from local inquiries, and that being taken as the best, or 16 annas in the rupee, faults taking from their productive qualities, such as want of depth, a mixture of sand or stones, a sloping surface, want of cohesion amongst the constituent particles of the soil, the mixture of soil impervious to water, liability to be swept over by running water, excess of moisture from surface springs, and impregnation with salt, are given proportionately to the degree of such deteriorating influences, so as to reduce the classification by one or more classes. Of these there are nine, found to be a sufficient number for all practical purposes, to lower the classification to 14 or 12 or more annas down as low as 2 annas.

All faults found to exist in any field are shown on the face of its sketch-map drawn in the classer’s book by conventional signs. On the sketch-map must also be shown the segments into which the field is divided by him to ascertain depth of soil and deduction on account of unarable portions (such as on account of rock or of a road crossing it) and for other classification purposes, so that the supervising officer, in most cases an European assistant superintendent, can at any time test for himself the accuracy of the reasons given for the classer’s relative value in annas assigned to the field. In Madras apparently the classifier only records

TBL-017 · FOLIO 244Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Madras System.Remarks.
against a field “3rd Class 2nd sort Regar” or some similar entry, a vague method which renders any trickery of which he may have been guilty very difficult of detection by his supervising officer. That this may well be the case is apparent from the remark at page 107 of the Manual, that when it is known that the ryot’s field is of such a sort geologically and agriculturally (what the latter term signifies it is difficult to understand), and that for his neighbourhood the assumed amount of net produce of that sort is so much, he knows how much he has to pay to Government; for Government ask in every case half of the value of the net produce. A method such as this must open a wide door for fraud, for if the ryot knows beforehand what he will have to pay for a certain description of land, he and the classer will not be long in coming to terms as to the nature of the entries to be made with regard to his field, and the slight existing chance of detection will be run. In Bombay no man can tell beforehand what the rent of certain land will be, for the maximum rate is not fixed until all classification has been completed, and even after this none but the settling officer can tell whether it will be lowered or raised on account of greater or less distance from village site or water, or on account of the maximum of the whole village being raised or lowered for climatic and market considerations. There is, of course, a risk of collusion under both systems, but this explanation demon-

Madras System.

A revenue system based on field assessment seems to demand naturally and necessarily the separate classification of each individual field, and this is the sanctioned method of the department; it is at the same time laid down that “though the details of classification extend to each field, the wider com-

Remarks.

strates how infinitely smaller it is under that of Bombay.

It will be seen from what has been stated above that the separate assessment of fields is graduated down from a maximum rate from the highest to the lowest qualities of soil according to a regular classification in annas or classes determined by faults causing fertility to diminish in consequence of qualities existing or wanting which are perceptible to the eye, a matter that can be tested by a subsequent examination. The idea that the amount of clay (as technically defined above) can be ascertained by dissolving earth in a test-tube—such is the method reported to be adopted—is chemically inaccurate, for there are many chemical ingredients, both fertilising and deteriorating, that are soluble in water, and that would accordingly elude detection by this test, to let alone the absurdity of expecting classers to estimate with any accuracy the amount of any residum that might be left in a test-tube in the case of the hundreds of fields in any village.

How far this system of arranging land in blocks is permitted to effect the assessment of individual fields is not apparent from the description quoted from the Manual. The concluding remarks are, however, sufficient of themselves to condemn the system if it has been and is allowed in any way to influence that assessment, for it follows of neccessity that the assessment is unfair, and this may account for the unwillingness shown

Madras System.

Remarks.

parative view of the operations should never be lost sight of, as it is most desirable that the land should be viewed in a comprehensive way by the classifier. . . ."

As a method of work the Government have disapproved of the plan, but encourage blocking as a sequel to field classification, and as, in fact, an office arrangement made for the purpose of check and revision. Under this system it is evident that the average run of soils must determine the classification of a block, and that isolated fields and tracts of better or worse quality than the average of the block must gain or lose by inclusion within it.

by people to bid for lands put up to auction by the collectors of late years, as proved by the annual revenue reports.

In fixing rates of assessment, objection is raised in Madras to former collections being looked to. This objection can only apply to an attempt to assess individual fields according to what may have been levied from them in the past, and in that case is right, inasmuch as if records were in any case in existence showing grain rents levied from fields under the old division of produce system, they would be untrustworthy for various reasons, and especially because the old recorded areas would be merely estimated and not actually measured. But for the purpose of determining the general level of assessment likely to lead to a successful settlement, no more reliable data than returns of former levies of revenue (and area as far as procurable) could be made use of. No more certain criteria exist of the general success or failure of previous revenue systems than such returns, which prove by increase or decrease of cultivated area, and consequent advance or falling off of land revenue, the suitability or otherwise of the general level of assessment to the condition of the people and the circumstances of the times. Taken into consideration with prospects of rising or falling prices of agricultural produce, with the opening up of new, and deterioration of old, markets, improvement in the means of communication, and other circumstances

Madras System.

Remarks.

tending to show the general condition of the agricultural population, such returns of previous assessments, taken over a sufficiently large area and for a series of years, are an infallible guide to what the level of assessment should be in future. They have invariably been so taken in the Bombay Revenue Survey Settlements, of which the success is undoubted. Compared with the complicated Madras process, already described, of endeavouring to ascertain the gross and net produce of land, the system, to a man of ordinary judgment, is simplicity itself, and may be confidently recommended for adoption in that Presidency, where the very slow advance in land revenue, notwithstanding a generally dense agricultural population, is a clear proof of the unsuitableness of the present method of assessment. It must be remembered that inequality of assessment, to which the system has been shown to be particularly liable, is almost as fertile a cause of the non-success of a settlement as an excessive rate of assessment. The fact of large areas of land, nearly 40,000 acres in the years 1887-8 to 1889-90, not being taken up by private purchasers when offered for sale by the revenue authorities goes far towards proving that the former is one of the faults of the existing assessments.

In addition to all this, it must be evident that the Madras assessments amounting to the full rent and not being a tax on that rent, as those of Bombay professedly are, the land will not acquire that marketable value

TBL-018 · FOLIO 248Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Madras System.Remarks.
which it is proved in many ways the settled lands in Bombay have acquired. There can thus be no doubt that the whole system of assessment in the Madras Presidency requires a complete investigation. Such an investigation, considering that there are believed to be about 3,000,0001 acres of arable land still available, which might under a better system be brought into cultivation and add largely to the land revenue, would be undertaken with a fair prospect of results satisfactory both to the State and its subjects. A. Rogers.

Notes

  1. 1. Since ascertained to be over 6,000,000 acres.