Appendix O

Lord Salisbury on Indian Land Revenue

Famines and Land Assessments in India, Romesh Chunder Dutt, 1900 · from page 194 · about 10 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

This discussion has arisen upon a proposal, by the Governor of Madras, which is not concurred in by his Council, that the expenditure of the Settlement Department should be so materially diminished that its operation would be virtually suspended. Among the reasons he advances for this proposal is that, partly in consequence of an original understanding, and partly in pursuance of orders from home, the Local Government are practically debarred from increasing the assessment, and that consequently the outlay brings no return. The Council do not accept Lord Hobart's reason or the conclusion, and the papers are sent home in the form which Madras papers now frequently assume—a resolution of the Government passed over the head of the Governor. Sir Louis Mallet writes an important Minute upon these papers, to draw attention to "the absence of any kind of common understanding or agreement between the local authorities as to the relation of the Government to the occupiers of the soil," and further on, to "review the inconsistencies of the authorities at home upon the same subject." These inconsistencies are established by citations, and upon these he bases the contention that a definite principle must be arrived at and acted upon in the matter of land revenue, and that a careful distinction must be made between rent and revenue. Though he does not say it in so many words, the drift of his argument is to press not only for an explicit official declaration that our land dues are revenue, not rent, but for a practical application of the doctrine, by levying a uniform percentage on "the economic rent." As there is not, in most parts of India, any separation between profits and rent, both being enjoyed by the same person, this tax would resolve itself into a uniform percentage on the produce. Several members of Council have written instructive Minutes upon Sir Louis Mallet's paper, but they mostly shrink from the general discussion to which he has invited them. Sir Henry Montgomery considers the discussion useless. Sir Erskine Perry looks upon it as a speculation oisive. Sir George Campbell considers it a question of words.

In this latter view Sir Henry Maine concurs, but does not on that ground regard the debate as idle; for, in his experience, questions of words have had a large influence on Indian policy.

I cannot see how the question can be described as one of words. The practical difference between the word rent and revenue is very palpable to the cultivator. Under the rent theory his payments are a portion of his gross produce, limited by the condition of his first paying his wages and profits; under the tax theory they are unlimited either way, save by the power or mercy of the Government. It speaks loudly for the character of British rule that the advocates of the ryot call for the application of the tax theory. Under the Mogul they would have welcomed the rent theory as heartily as they would the tax theory now.

Nor can I regard it as a question oisive. The fiscal relations of the Government to the cultivator is a question which I should rather accuse of obtrusiveness than of indolence. We may, it is true, discuss it under different forms. We may use the terms of political economy, or we may use the less accurate but more flexible language of unscientific men. Sir Bartle Frere has shown how difficult it is to classify under . two sharply defined headings a series of facts differing only by small degrees. One mode of describing them may be more convenient and more complete than another. But the essential point is that the language used should be understood by those to whom it is addressed. Now it is our function to address Indian officials, and— speaking of the generation now coming into office— their vocabulary is derived with more or less fidelity from the writings of political economists. They have been required to study the science closely before they could undertake our service, and their minds were fresh from a close application to it when, for the first time, they came into contact with Indian life, and were trusted with a share of Indian Government. To the modern Indian statesman the refined distinctions of the economical school are a solid living reality, from which he can as little separate his thoughts as from his mother tongue. To us it may seem indifferent whether we call a payment revenue or rent, so we get the money; but it is not indifferent by what name we call it in his hearing. If we say that it is rent, he will hold the Government in strictness entitled to all that remains after wages and profits have been paid, and he will do what he can to hasten the advent of the day when the State shall no longer be kept by any weak compromises from the enjoyment of its undoubted rights. If we persuade him that it is revenue, he will note the vast disproportion of its incidence compared to that of other taxes, and his efforts will tend to remedy the inequality, and to lay upon other classes and interests a more equitable share of the fiscal burden.

I prefer the latter tendency to the former. So far as it is possible to change the Indian fiscal system, it is desirable that the cultivator should pay a smaller proportion of the whole national charge. It is not in itself a thrifty policy to draw the mass of revenue from the rural districts, where capital is scarce, sparing the towns, where it is often redundant and runs to waste in luxury. The injury is exaggerated in the case of India, where so much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent. As India must be bled, the lancet should be directed to the parts where the blood is congested, or at least sufficient, not to those which are already feeble from the want of it.

I agree, therefore, with Sir Louis Mallet in desiring that our present nondescript land dues should tend to the form of revenue rather than that of rent. But the question for present decision is whether, supposing we have all agreed in that wish, we should take any decisive step in furtherance of it. Sir Louis does not state precisely what measure or series of measures he would take. I presume it would be a fresh and more elaborate declaration of principle, followed by an instruction to limit all land payments to fifty per cent. on the gross produce,1 ascertained, presumably, by an average of past years. There are, to my mind, two fatal objections to this course; the first is, that we cannot afford it; the second is, that we have not the power to secure its being followed out.

As to the first, I need not enlarge on the state of Indian finance. Our expenses grow annually, and almost the only part of our revenue which can be trusted to grow is that which comes from land. For many years to come we could not part with this increase without endangering our surplus. Nor can we look for any early succour from the effects of the remission itself. As far as we can judge by the experience of the past, relief from taxation applies no appreciable stimulus to the Indian producer. The recuperative force which plays so large a part in the calculations of Western financiers seems to be wholly wanting in the East. At the end of a long span of years our lost land revenue might begin "to fructify in the pockets of the people"; but what is the Exchequer to do in the meantime?

The other and more serious difficulty is, that we have not the power to give permanent force to a new policy. Can we enact that our successors shall do exactly that which we are not doing—forbear from altering their predecessors' work. Sir Louis Mallet notes a long series of inconsistencies in the course of the Indian Government. Have we any grounds for thinking they will cease? They are not merely subjects of reproach; they are a warning of the fashion after which our Indian Government is made. By the law of its existence it must be a government of incessant change. It is the despotism of a line of kings whose reigns are limited by climatic causes to five years. Whatever power exists in England is divided between a council of which the elements are necessarily fluctuating, and a political officer whose average existence amounts to about thirty months. It would be absurd to expect from this arrangement a persistent and systematic policy, if the policy is to depend on the will of the Government. We might indeed commence a new policy with some confidence, if the state of opinion in the service and among Anglo-Indians here was such as to give assurance that it would be sustained; but of that security there is no appearance. Any sharp change of measures would not be a natural development. It would be “octroyé” by the present Government, and would be at the mercy of any succeeding Government to set aside; and another link would be added to the chain of inconsistencies that would present themselves to future criticism.

We must be content to contribute our mite towards a gradual change. We can favour, as we have opportunity, leniency and regularity of assessment; we can discourage attempts to take advantage of inflated prices; we can avoid and disavow language belonging to the rent theory. In this, I think, we shall meet with sufficient support from existing Indian opinion to hope that our acts and language may be accepted as precedents by our successors. Sir George Campbell appears to dread this gentle mode of progression, which he denounces under the name of drifting. I cannot accept the metaphor in its entirety, for I believe that there is still left some, though not a very important, influence for the helm. But with this reservation, I see no terror in the prospect of "drifting." On the contrary, I believe that all the enduring institutions which human societies have attained have been reached, not of the set design and forethought of some group of statesmen, but by that unbidden and unconscious convergence of many thoughts and wills in successive generations to which, as it obeys no single guiding hand, we may give the name of "drifting." It is assuredly only in this way that a permanent solution of these difficult questions will be given to the vast communities of India. The vacillation of purpose, the chaos of opinion we are now deploring, only indicate that the requisite convergence has not yet been attained.

Certainly the English land tenure, which is in the minds of most Englishmen who argue about that of India, is a very remarkable achievement of the process of drifting. It assuredly has not been created by a definite policy. No one man or Council thought it out, put it on paper, and proclaimed it. It has been the work of many successive persons, who acted without conscious co-operation or continuity, and mostly thought they were doing something very different from that which they actually did. It has grown partly out of an unmarked change in usages, partly out of measures adopted from time to time to meet temporary exigencies. Yet, whatever its merits or defects, it undoubtedly has these two qualities, that it is pretty firmly rooted, and it is consistent with a high degree of material prosperity. We have no right, therefore, to speak disrespectfully of drifting. It is as likely to conduct India to a safe issue as England.

In the draft to Madras, therefore, though it ought to be framed with the utmost consideration for Lord Hobart, I would abstain from any detailed discussion of general principles, nor would I give any corroboration to his premature declaration in favour of a fixed land-payment. At the same time, I think we may fairly discourage any scientific refinements in the work of assessment, which are a natural exercise of the intellect in highly cultivated officers, but which worry the ryot, distribute the burden of the State with needless inequality, and impose a costly machinery on the State.

Salisbury.

26th April 1875.

Lord Hobart died the day after this paper was written. I circulate the various minutes because the subject is one that will probably recur; but for the present I should recommend a draft noting that half the Madras Council has been changed, and saying that we should be disinclined to enter upon the discussion of any proposed changes until the new Government should have had an opportunity of examining them.

S.

29th April 1875.

Notes

  1. 1. Or rather fifty per cent. on the rent.—R. C. D.