[The Madras Government's reply to Lord Canning's proposal was conveyed in the following letter. Parliamentary Return, 164 (1863), pp. 112 to 115.]
From J. D. Sim, Esq., Secretary to the Government of Fort St George, to W. Grey, Esq., Secretary to the Government of India, No. 241, dated the 8th February 1862.
I am directed by the Honourable the Governor in Council to acknowledge the receipt of your letter, No. 2035, dated 7th October 1861, requesting his opinion "upon the advantages of a Permanent Settlement as applicable to the various districts of the Madras Presidency," and "as to the value of a legislative sanction for terms of years in districts in which his Excellency in Council may not consider the existing settlements of a character to be made permanent."
2. I am to premise that by a Permanent Settlement this Government understand the Governor General in Council to intend no more than fixing the land-tax in perpetuity, in other words to bar the Government in all time to come from increasing the assessment on all land brought under that settlement.
3. The words Permanent Settlement are, however, very generally applied to zemindari settlements under Regulation XXV. of 1802 of the Madras, and Regulation I. of 1793 of the Bengal Code. To any extension of this mode of tenure in this Presidency the Government are wholly opposed, for, among other reasons, the weighty objection, that it alienates from the State all waste land. It is to this source that this Government look for a gradual increase in its land revenue, and it is essential that this source of future revenue should not be lost to the State.
4. This being understood, I am to explain briefly the present state of the land tenure in this Presidency under the prevailing ryotwari system, to which alone the proposals contained in your letter are applicable.
5. This mode of administration was introduced in 1792 by Colonel Read; and was subsequently worked out by Sir Thomas Munro. In 1812, the Home Government ordered it to be generally introduced, and it has since formed the prevalent tenure of this Presidency, the revenue derived from zemindaries being in round numbers half a million sterling, while that drawn from ryotwari estates is three and a half millions.
6. There can be no question that one fundamental principle of the ryotwari system is that the Government demand on the land is fixed for ever.
7. When first settling the Salem district in 1796, Colonel Read issued a proclamation to the ryots, in which the following rule appears :
" The putkut nellum (or holding) being measured and valued, the assessment of every individual field in it, when at the full rate, is fixed for ever, that is to say, the Government is never to require more or receive less, nor you to pay less or more than the present rate, unless when those fields actually 'dry' shall hereafter be converted into wet at the expense of Government, when the rates will be proportionately raised, according to the consequent increase of the produce, and in like manner fixed for ever. But if you carry on such works at your own expense, plant topes, &c., you may depend on receiving the advantages accruing from these and from every other improvement of your lands, while you continue to pay the established rates ; those constituting, except in the case above mentioned, the annual demand upon them on the part of the circar for ever. Upon these principles you may rent out lands, which you may raise in value by tillage and manure, at rates greatly exceeding the circar rates, if there be a demand for them, while you will continue to pay the fixed rates to the circar for ever."
8. Similarly, in 1802, Sir Thomas Munro, when issuing instructions to the Collectors of the Ceded Districts, expressed himself as follows : "When a country has been surveyed, the individual (ryotwari) supersedes both the village and district settlement. The rent of every field being fixed, each cultivator takes or rejects what he pleases, and the rents of all the fields occupied in the course of the year in any one village form what is called the settlement of that village." Again, in 1806, when explaining the manner in which a ryotwari settlement was conducted, he says : "When a district has been surveyed, and the rent of every field permanently fixed, the kulwar (individual) settlement becomes extremely simple ; for all that is required is to ascertain what fields are occupied by each ryot, and to enter them, with the fixed rents attached to them, in his potta : their aggregate constitutes his rent for the year. He cannot be called upon for more: but he may obtain an abatement in case of poverty or extraordinary losses. He has the advantage of knowing in the beginning of the season, when he ploughs his land, the exact amount of what he is to pay; he knows the fixed rents of the different fields which he cultivates, and that the demand upon him cannot exceed their total amount; he knows the utmost limit of his rent, not only for the present, but for every succeeding year; for it cannot be raised unless he takes additional land; and he is thereby the better enabled to provide for the regular discharge of his kists, and against the losses of bad by the profits of good seasons." In 1818 the Board of Revenue issued detailed instructions for the general introduction of ryotwar as ordered by the Home Government. One of the distinguishing characteristics of the system, they said, was, "that the assessment was a permanent maximum rent fixed on each field."
9. At a later period the permanency of the ryotwari settlement has, on several occasions, been acknowledged in unmistakeable terms.
10. In the Madras Administration Report of 1855- 56, ryotwari is thus explained: "Under the ryotwari system every registered holder of land is recognised as its proprietor, and pays direct to Government. He is at liberty to sub-let his property, or to tranfer it by gift, sale, or mortgage. He cannot be ejected by Government so long as he pays the fixed assessment, and has the option annually of increasing or diminishing his holding, or of entirely abandoning it. In unfavourable seasons remissions of assessment are granted for entire or partial loss of produce. The assessment is fixed in money, and does not vary from year to year, except in those cases where water is drawn from a Government source of irrigation to convert dry land into wet, or one into two crop land, where an extra rent is paid to Government for the water so appropriated; nor is any addition made to the assessment for improvements effected at a ryot's own expense. The ryot, under this system, is virtually a proprietor on a simple and perfect title, and has all the benefits of a perpetual lease without its responsibilities, inasmuch as he can at any time throw up his lands, but cannot be ejected so long as he pays his dues: he receives assistance in difficult seasons, and is not responsible for the payment of his neighbours." A similar description of ryotwari was given to the House of Commons by the Home Government in 1857.1
11. The Revenue Board in 1857, in a report to Government on the new survey and settlement, wrote as follows: "It may not here be out of place to notice that a general opinion prevails in England that the Bombay Settlement for thirty years secures a far greater permanency of tenure to the landholder than the present ryotwari tenure of Madras. This is altogether an error, for a Madras ryot is able to retain his land in perpetuity, without any increase of assessment, as long as he continues to fulfil his engagements.”
12. In the same year the Government, in a review of the Hon. Mr Rickett’s report, expressed themselves thus strongly : “The proprietary right of a ryot is perfect, and as long as he pays the fixed assessment on his land he can be ousted by no one ; there is no principle of ryotwari management more fixed or better known than this, and the Government deny that any right can be more strong.”
13. It is thus abundantly clear that the distinguishing feature of ryotwari is the limitation in perpetuity of the demand of the State on the land. The ryots have thus all the advantages of the zemindari tenure, while the State has a valuable reserve of waste land, whence, as cultivation extends, its resources will be augmented so as to meet the increasing demands on its finances which the progress of the country will entail : and in practice this leading principle of ryotwari has never been infringed. The assessments have, as in South Arcot, Bellary, Cuddapah, etc., been reduced, but in no instance have they ever been raised : nor in the recent pressure for money has so obvious a source as increasing the land-tax been even suggested as being open to the Government.
14. Had matters been left in this position, the Government would now have had merely to report that the ryotwari proprietors of this Presidency already possessed the advantages which the Governor-General in Council appears willing to concede, although these were not secured to them under legislative sanction.
15. But in 1855, when the survey and settlement now in progress were introduced, an important modification was made in the tenure of land.
16. The object of these operations was to revise the assessments, which were generally too high. In order to give the ryot in all cases a valuable proprietary interest in the soil, and to induce extended cultivation, thirty per cent. of the gross produce, carefully computed in the manner prescribed, was to be “taken as the maximum of the Government demand,” and it was thought that twenty-five per cent. would be the average. The Government were of opinion that the assessment should be fixed in grain for a term of fifty years, and that the commuted value of the latter should be periodically adjusted every seven or ten years, according to its average money value in those periods. The Home Government objected to this arrangement, and gave the preference to an assessment in money, unalterable for thirty years. The subject was further discussed by the Government, who ultimately decided that the assessment should be revised after fifty years, if then deemed expedient. This decision, however, has not as yet been authoritatively intimated to the people.
17. It will thus be seen that, while the leading characteristic of ryotwari tenure is the permanency of the assessment, the revised assessments now being introduced are subject to revision after fifty years.
18. The alternatives proposed in your letter under reply have received the careful consideration of Government, and I am to state briefly the conclusions at which they have arrived.
19. His Excellency the Governor is favourable to the imposition of a permanent grain rent, but would reserve to Government the power of periodically determining the money value of that rent, if at any future time a material alteration in the value of money should render such a measure expedient.
20. The Honourable Members of Council, on the other hand, support the old ryotwari principle of a permanent money assessment—that is to say, an assessment based on a certain portion of the crop, and converted into a money payment at a fair commutation rate fixed once and for ever.
21. I am to request attention to the minutes which accompany this letter, and contain the views of the President and Members of the Council.
22. The Government are not in favour of settlements under legislative sanction for terms of years. Such settlements would hamper the Government without materially improving the position of the ryot; and it would be better, both for the State and the people, either that the settlements should be in perpetuity, or that the Government should have the power at any time of acting as the exigencies of the State may require. The Government would not alter the assessment except under the pressure of necessity, and that necessity might occur in the course of the series of years fixed by law for the unalterable duration of the Settlement.
Notes
- 1. Return showing under what Tenures, and subject to what Land-tax, Lands are held under the several Presidencies of India (Mr William Ewart); ordered, by the House of Commons, to be printed, 22nd June 1857.