The enquiry made by Colonel Baird Smith into the causes of the famine of 1860 led to a proposal to extend the Permanent Settlement of the land revenue into all parts of India. The history of the controversy on this proposal, which went on for twenty-two years, is one of the most remarkable episodes in the history of British administration in India. The brief narrative and the extracts given below are from Parliamentary Returns 431, 431—I., 164, and 174.
Colonel Baird Smith’s proposals were circulated by Lord Canning’s Government to the Governments of the different Provinces in 1861 for opinion. The Madras Government replied in its No. 241, dated 8th February 1862. In this remarkable letter, which is given in full in Appendix K, the Madras Government explained that the Ryotwari Settlement of Madras was meant to be a Permanent Settlement, " the leading characteristic of ryotwari tenure is the permanency of the assessment."
The Bombay Government replied in its No. 1627, dated 23rd April 1862, embodying a minute recorded by the Governor of Bombay, and minutes by Messrs Reeves and Frere. The Minute of the Governor of Bombay is given in Appendix L. While disapproving of a Permanent Settlement for Bombay, the Governor looked forward to increase in land revenue mainly from " increased prices " of the produce of the land.
The Government of the Central Provinces declared itself in favour of a Permanent Settlement in its letter No. 532, dated 22nd July 1862, given in full in Appendix J.
In Northern India the Lieutenant of Bengal was in favour of extending the Permanent Settlement ; the Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab was against it ; and the Lieutenant-Governor of the N.W. Provinces was in its favour with due caution and reservations. The following paragraphs from the Minute recorded by the Lieutenant-Governor of the N.W. Provinces contain his general views on the subject :
" 7. I do not, in the least, doubt that the gradual and cautious concessions of a guarantee of permanency to the settlement of the land revenue in the North-Western Provinces, generally, will be productive of all the advantages which Colonel Baird Smith and Mr Muir, in even greater detail, have depicted. Judging by the effect of settlements for long periods, it may be safely anticipated that the limitation of the Government demand in perpetuity will, in much larger degree, lead to the investment of capital in the land. The wealth of the agricultural classes will be increased. The prosperity of the country and the strength of the community will be augmented. Land will command a much higher price. The prospective loss which the Government will incur by relinquishing its share of the profits, arising from extended cultivation and improved productiveness, will be partly, if not wholly, compensated by the indirect returns which would be derived from the increased wealth and prosperity of the country at large.
“ 8. Nor should the minor advantages of freeing the people from the vexation and exaction which are inseparable from a periodical settlement of the land revenue ; of saving the large expenditure which each revision of settlement entails upon the Government ; and of removing the temptation which the approach of each such revision holds out to land proprietors of temporarily deteriorating their property, be disregarded. These are all burthens which bear, with more or less severity, on the Government and on the people, and if they can be got rid of without lasting detriment to the revenues of the State, few will be found to offer any opposition.
“ 9. It must also be admitted, I think, that the settlement of the Government demand in perpetuity will be politically wise. It is true that in Behar, and also in some of the districts of the Benares Province (notably Ghazeepore), which are permanently settled, the rebellion of 1857-58 was not less general, or less determined, than in other parts of these provinces which are under temporary settlement. But these manifestations of feeling must be regarded as having been the result of exciting causes, having but a transient influence, and can hardly detract from the force of the conviction that the absolute limitation of demand upon their land will be received by an agricultural people with the highest satisfaction, and will produce, if anything can, feelings of attachment to the Government, and of confidence in its desire to promote the best interests of the country.
“10. But it certainly appears to me that the introduction of a Permanent Settlement must be subject to certain conditions, exceptions, and reservations, and that some years must pass away before the measure can be consummated. Precipitancy in a matter of this vast importance is to be deprecated, as pregnant with injury both to the Government and the people.”
On the 5th July 1862 Sir John (afterwards Lord) Lawrence recorded his opinion entirely in favour of a Permanent Settlement for India. The following extract will show the spirit in which Sir John Lawrence wrote :
“15. I recommend a perpetual settlement, because I am persuaded that, however much the country has of late years improved, its resources will be still more rapidly developed by the limitation of the Government demand. Such a measure will still further encourage the investment of money in the land, and will give still greater security to the land revenue itself, which, in years of great calamity, occurring every now and then, has suffered largely, though the loss has been more or less of a temporary character. It is also very desirable that facilities should exist for the gradual growth of a middle class in India, connected with the land, without dispossessing the present yeomen and peasant proprietors. There are many men of much intelligence, spirit, and social influence among those classes, who are yet so poor that they find it difficult to maintain a decent appearance. It is no remedy for this state of things to confer great and exclusive benefits on a few individuals, especially when these very benefits are conferred at the expense of the rest of the community. What is really wanted is, to give the intelligent, the thrifty, and the enterprising among them, the opportunity of improving their own condition by the exercise of such qualities, and this can be best done by limiting the public demand on the land. When such men acquire property, and are in a thriving state, they are almost certain to be well affected to the Government, and will use their influence, which will generally be considerable, in its favour. Feelings of race and religion have great influence on the people of India ; but love for their lands has still greater. Thousands, probably millions, of the people of northern India, the most warlike of its races, are descended from ancestors who gave up their religion to preserve their land. It is on the contentment of the agriculturists, who form the real physical power in the country, that the security of British rule, to a large extent, depends. If they are prosperous, the military force may be small, but not otherwise." On the 9th July 1862 Sir Charles Wood, then Secretary of State for India, wrote the memorable letter in which he entirely approved of the proposal of a Permanent Settlement of the land revenues of India. It is a long letter of seventy-seven paragraphs, and we extract only a few of the most important :
" 47. Her Majesty’s Government entertain no doubt of the political advantages which would attend a Permanent Settlement. The security, and it may almost be said, the absolute creation of property in the soil which will flow from limitation in perpetuity of the demands of the State on the owners of land, cannot fail to stimulate or confirm their sentiments of attachment and loyalty to the Government by whom so great a boon has been conceded, and on whose existence its permanency will depend.
" 48. It is also most desirable that facilities should be given for the gradual growth of a middle class connected with the land, without dispossessing the peasant proprietors and occupiers. It is believed that among the latter may be found many men of great intelligence, public spirit, and social influence, although individually in comparative poverty. To give to the intelligent, the thrifty, and the enterprising the means of improving their condition, by opening to them the opportunity of exercising these qualities, can be best accomplished by limiting the public demand on their lands. When such men acquire property, and find themselves in a thriving condition, they are certain to be well affected towards the Government under which they live. It is on the contentment of the agricultural classes, who form the great bulk of the population, that the security of the Government mainly depends. If they are prosperous any casual outbreak on the part of other classes or bodies of men is much less likely to become an element of danger, and the military force, and its consequent expense, may be regulated accordingly.
" 53. That this general improvement will be accelerated by a Permanent Settlement Her Majesty’s Government cannot entertain any doubt. A ready and popular mode of investment for the increasing wealth of the country will be provided by the creation of property in land, and all classes will benefit by the measure. On the agricultural population the effect will be, as pointed out by Colonel Baird Smith in the able paper already referred to, the elevation of the social condition of the people, and their consequent ability, not only to meet successfully the pressure occasioned by seasons of distress, but in ordinary times, to bear increased taxation in other forms without difficulty; the feeling of ownership, or, in other words, the absolute certainty of the full enjoyment of the reward for all the labour and capital which they may invest in the land, will be sure to call out all their energies for its improvement. Her Majesty’s Government confidently expect that a people in a state of contentment and progressive improvement will be able without difficulty to contribute to the revenue in other ways to such an extent as more than to compensate for the disadvantage of foregoing some prospective increase of that from land.
" 58. After the most careful review of all these considerations, Her Majesty’s Government are of opinion that the advantages which may reasonably be expected to accrue not only to those immediately connected with the land, but to the community generally, are sufficiently great to justify them in incurring the risk of some prospective loss of land revenue in order to attain them, and that a settlement in perpetuity in all districts in which the conditions absolutely required as preliminary to such a measure are, or may hereafter be, fulfilled, is a measure dictated by sound policy, and calculated to accelerate the development of the resources of India, and to ensure, in the highest degree, the welfare and contentment of all classes of Her Majesty’s subjects in that country.
" 59. They consider that the direct mode of making a permanent settlement is preferable to the indirect one of obtaining a similar result by conceding to the landholders the right to redeem their assessment. They do not believe that the power to redeem the land revenue is necessary to induce the landholders to incur expenditure in the improvement of their property. What is really required, in order to call into effective action their enterprise and capital, is not an exemption from all payments to the Government on account of their estates, but the fixing those payments in perpetuity, at a moderate and certain amount. In Bengal, where a Permanent Settlement was made with the Zemindars seventy years ago, the general progress of the country in wealth and prosperity, notwithstanding the depressed condition of the peasantry, caused by errors and omissions in the mode of making the settlement, has been most remarkable. Such errors in the existing state of our knowledge regarding the rights and interests of the subordinate occupants of the soil would not be permitted to recur.
“63. Her Majesty’s Government have, therefore, determined to limit the power of redeeming the land revenue to such cases as are referred to above in paragraph 26; but they have resolved to sanction a Permanent Settlement of the land revenue throughout India. It will, however, still remain to be determined how far any particular district is in a condition to warrant the practical application of the measure at the present time.”
On the 8th June 1864 the Viceroy in Council submitted, in reference to the above despatch of the Secretary of State, an account of the steps taken in furtherance of the object in view. A Minute recorded by the Viceroy himself (Sir J. Lawrence) was forwarded with this letter. The Minute ends thus :
“43. Such, in general terms, is the manner in which I should wish to see the Permanent Settlement carried out in those portions of the Bengal Presidency which are not yet permanently settled, such as the North-West Provinces, the Punjab, Oudh, and other places; and I believe that by these means we shall best be able to apply the principles, so justly insisted on by Her Majesty’s Government, to the actual circumstances and condition of this country. The 5th March 1864.”
On the 24th March 1865 the Secretary of State for India, Sir Charles Wood, replied to the Viceroy, and laid down the rules for the introduction of the Permanent Settlement. He divided all districts into
- (1) Districts in which agriculture was backward.
- (2) Districts in which the estates were fairly cultivated and resources fully developed.
- (3) Districts which contained estates fairly cultivated, and also estates with resources imperfectly developed.
He decided that the Permanent Settlement should be introduced at once into the second class of districts and refused in the first class of districts. In regard to the third class of districts, he stated that Her Majesty’s Government “are prepared to authorise an immediate settlement on perpetuity, after revision, for all estates in which the actual cultivation amounts to eighty per cent. of the cultivable or malgoozaree area.” Estates not so fully cultivated “should be treated in the ordinary manner, and settled for a term not exceeding thirty years.”
On the 3rd August 1865 the Viceroy in Council forwarded copy of correspondence with the Government of the N.W. Provinces on the question of Permanent Settlement in relation to canal irrigation.
On the 17th March 1866 the Secretary of State for India, Earl De Grey and Ripon recorded his reply, approving of the instructions given by the Indian Government to the Lieutenant-Governor for the Permanent Settlement of the N.W. Provinces, and suggesting the following rule with regard to canal irrigation :
“A rule might be laid down that no Permanent Settlement should be concluded for any estate, the assets of which would, when canal irrigation shall have been carried to the full extent at present contemplated, exceed, in the opinion of the Officers of the Settlement and Irrigation Departments, the existing assets in a proportion exceeding twenty per cent."
On the 20th November 1866 the Viceroy in Council pointed out certain objections to the rule suggested by the Secretary of State for India.
On the 23rd March 1867 the Secretary of State for India, Sir Strafford Northcote, reaffirmed the decision of Her Majesty’s Government to introduce a Permanent Settlement. Her Majesty’s Government, he wrote, were prepared to sacrifice the prospect of an increase in land revenue “in consideration of the great importance of connecting the interests of the proprietors of the land with the stability of the British Government.” And he laid down two rules to restrict Permanent Settlement in undeveloped tracts and estates :
" First. No estate shall be permanently settled in which the actual cultivation amounts to less than eighty per cent. of the cultivable or malgoozaree area ; and
" Secondly. No Permanent Settlement shall be concluded for any estate to which canal irrigation is, in the opinion of the Governor General in Council, likely to be extended within the next twenty years, and the existing assets of which would thereby be increased in the proportion of twenty per cent."
Inquiries went on with a view to ascertain what districts or parts of districts in Northern India could be permanently settled under the conditions laid down by Sir Strafford Northcote. In 1869 some cases were reported in which it was shown that a Permanent Settlement, even under the conditions laid down, would cause prospective loss to Government. This was not a new argument; for Sir Strafford Northcote had foreseen such loss and had declared it to be the final and deliberate decision of Her Majesty’s Government that “this sacrifice they were prepared to make in consideration of the great importance of connecting the interests of the proprietors of the land with the stability of the British Government.” But every passing year seems to have weakened the desire to make the sacrifice, and the objection which had been foreseen and disregarded in 1867 seemed to have greater weight in 1869. A third condition was accordingly recommended in addition to the two laid down in 1867, and this third condition practically amounted to this, that the Permanent Settlement should be deferred as long as the land continued to improve in value.
A fourth difficulty was then presented by the depreciation of the rupee. This too had been foreseen by Sir Charles Wood; but the difficulty appeared more formidable to the authorities in the Seventies than it had appeared in the Sixties. And, for a time, the idea of a Permanent Settlement was dropped.
At last came the final and fatal decision. The Secretary of State for India, in his despatch No. 24, dated 28th March 1883, gave the coup de grace to the recommendation made by Lord Canning twenty-one years before. The despatch said: “I concur with your Excellency’s Government that the policy laid down in 1862 should now be formally abandoned."
It will appear from the preceding narrative that the final rejection of the proposal of a Permanent Settlement of the Land Revenue of India was due, not to any new difficulties discovered in course of the inquiries made, but to a change in the spirit of the Government policy. The proposal was first dictated by a desire to improve the material condition of the people, “to encourage,” in the words of Lord Lawrence, “the investment of money in the land,” to promote “the gradual growth of a middle class in India,” to lead to the accumulation of some capital and some resources in the country which would help the people in years of difficulties, droughts and distress. These benevolent objects were lost sight of by a newer generation of administrators, who lived less among the people under the altered circumstances of later days, knew less of their wants and wishes, and necessarily sympathised less with their aspirations, than Englishmen of the generation of Canning and Lawrence; and the proposal calculated to promote the material wellbeing of the people was abandoned in the interests of the Government Revenue. In the years succeeding the Sikh wars and the wars of the Indian Mutiny, Her Majesty’s Government desired to sacrifice a prospective rise in the Land Revenue, “in consideration,” as Sir Strafford Northcote put it, “of the great importance of connecting the interests of the proprietors of the land with the stability of the British Government.” The years of peace which followed, and the loyal devotion of the people of India to Her Majesty’s Government, unfortunately weakened this desire, and in 1883, after a period of uninterrupted peace of twenty-five years, it was no longer considered worth while making the sacrifice. Never has the loyalty of a nation been worse rewarded than in India within the last forty-two years. Proposals favourable to their material welfare have been abandoned ; pledges have remained unredeemed ; taxes and the public debt and military expenditure have been raised ; the cultivators are more subject to famines than before ; and the people of India are as far from getting any real share of control over the administration of their own concerns as they were when Her Majesty assumed the direct administration of India in 1858.
To conclude our story : While the proposal of a Permanent Settlement was abandoned, the Marquis of Ripon, then Viceroy of India, made some fresh proposals to prevent the cultivators of Southern India from the harassment of frequent enhancements at recurring Settlement operations. In his despatch of the 17th October 1882, Lord Ripon laid down the principle that in districts which had once been surveyed and assessed by the Settlement Department, assessments should undergo no further revision except on the sole ground of a rise in prices. The principle was a counsel of moderation ; it was a compromise between a scheme of Permanent Settlements (Zemindari or Ryotwari) and the harassing practice of frequent enhancements on vague and uncertain grounds. It left the door open for an increase of the Land Revenue on the equitable ground of a rise in prices; and it gave the cultivators some security of assessments, some protection against harassing operations and unjust enhancements.
Unfortunately even this moderate and equitable proposal was rejected by the Secretary of State for India in his despatch of the 8th January 1885. And thus it happens that the cultivators of Madras and Bombay, who pay the Land Revenue direct to the State, are to this day unprotected by any equitable rule against excessive enhancements and harassing settlement operations. India is a great agricultural country; but agriculture cannot flourish without some adequate protection to agriculturists; permanent improvements cannot be made without some adequate security against uncertain enhancements at recurring settlements.