My Lord,—I respectfully submit that with such a radical change for the worse in the economic condition of the country, a change is called for in the principles which have hitherto regulated the re-settlement of the land revenue demand. Almost the whole population depends, directly or indirectly, on agriculture. The only other important occupation of the people, weaving, is a decaying industry, and the mills, we have, give employment to a small fraction only. Thus agricultural profits constitute almost the sole funds from which any addition to the resources of the people can be effected. The question of assessment, therefore, is with them a question of life and death. The slightest excess beyond what they can pay with ease is sure to have disastrous after-consequences. For it is not possible that a people, raising only coarse agricultural produce, possessed of no large capital, no resources for improved methods of cultivation, in fact the majority of whom are in debt, should be able to meet with ease a revenue enhanced even to a fraction of a degree beyond what their existing condition warrants, and should, under its continual strain, recover even with a succession of good years from the depressing effects of a series of bad seasons. In some distressed tracts, where the payment of the enhanced demand had almost become an impossibility, a change in the shape of an abatement has already been introduced. Liberal remissions have also been given. But something more than such makeshifts as temporary remissions or reductions is, I submit, now needed in the best interests of the country. In making this appeal, I only echo what has been suggested in some of the revenue reports for 1897-98. The Commissioner of Jubbulpore writes: "But the revenue management of certain tracts will require careful handling. In the Khurai Tehsil and in the open country of the Domah district, very liberal general remissions will be required this year, and a re-settlement will be necessary as soon as there are signs of an upward turn. The abatements granted last year have proved inadequate." Regarding Hoshungabad, a district once thought to be one of the richest in the province, the Deputy-Commissioner writes that the tenants owe heavy arrears and large sums on account of takavi in addition to their ordinary debts, that a considerable area of land has become overgrown with "Kans," grass which it is difficult and expensive to extirpate, and that the Malguzars have not been able to realise fifty per cent. of the current rental demand. His conclusions are tersely summarised in the words, "the district is bankrupt and requires at least two good crops to become solvent." The Deputy-Commissioner of Balaghat remarks that a large percentage of tenants and Malguzars are heavily in debt, and that it is greatly to be regretted that a few years could not have been given to the district, before the imposition of the new Settlement, to give time to the people to recover themselves and to prevent the transfer of malguzari rights to the money-lending classes. The Deputy-Commissioner of Bilaspore points out that it would require at least two or three good harvests (perhaps more) before normal conditions would be restored. The C.P. Famine Report concludes with these weighty words, “But the ground lost during the last four years will not all be recovered in a season or two. It is a popular saying among cultivators that three good years are necessary to make up for one bad one. The saying may be tinged by the over-despondent tone which the farmer in all parts of the world uses in speaking of the prospects of his agriculture. But it is not unlikely that three years may pass before the province throws off the last signs of the greatest famine of the century.” All this was said in 1898. Since then the country has been smitten with the full force of an even greater famine, and unless a liberal revenue policy, the benefits of which will permeate all classes, be adopted, it is difficult to see how the people will be able to recover themselves. The new Tenancy Act arms the revenue officer with power to make the tenants share in the benefits of any concession that may be made in favour of the proprietors.
Within the last few months and while yet the province is in the throes of the famine, it has, I am told, been announced in the Bhadara District that the new assessments just completed there will come into force from the next year. The order will perhaps be reconsidered, but still its promulgation at this juncture is apt to make the people lose heart.
Proceedings with a view to a second new Settlement are also in progress in Bilaspur and Raipur. These districts, especially the former, were very hard hit during the last famine. They are no less so this time. They were both newly assessed only about ten years ago. The enhancement in Bilaspur was 102 per cent. in some groups and 105 per cent. in others. Including two cesses introduced in the interval between the two settlements, the enhancement under the head of cesses was, if I mistake not, nine per cent. in addition to the consequential enhancement on account of enhancement of land revenue. There was besides a full valuation on "Sir" land as compared with the half assessment of the old Settlement. This process represented an increase in the assessable assets of about Rs. 66,000. The percentage of assets taken as land revenue at the new settlement was also higher. At the old Settlement, the total assets, including full valuation of "Sir," was Rs. 526,391 (Para 302 of the report). The Government demand being Rs. 250,934, the proportion it bore to the total assets was thus about forty-eight per cent. As prospective profits from progress of cultivation and miscellaneous sources, for which there were large openings at the time, were not taxed, the burden of the Government demand became lighter year after year, until in the year preceding the new settlement, it was only forty per cent. of the Ryot's rents, leaving the remaining sixty per cent. and the whole of the "Sir" and miscellaneous profits to be enjoyed by the Malguzars. At the new Settlement, the total assets were fixed at Rs. 877,950, and the land revenue at Rs. 474,648. Thus the proportion which the latter bear to the former is fifty-four per cent., or six per cent. more than at the old Settlement. The large reduction in the profits hitherto enjoyed, which these operations involved, must have been keenly felt. At the new Settlement the rise in prices from the opening of the B.N. Railway was presumably taken into account, the tenants' rents being raised by Rs. 70,000. Since then, the district, instead of prospering has distinctly deteriorated. It is difficult, therefore, to conceive on what ground a second new Settlement can, under existing conditions, be justified so soon after the first. A new Settlement, however carefully conducted, must unsettle men's minds, make them suspicious of the intentions of Government, and subject them to the harassments inseparable from the visits of official underlings. I am afraid, even with a good season next year, in place of stimulus of hope, there will be discouragement of uncertainty, and this feeling will paralyse all exertions to recover from the effects of the famine.
Under these circumstances I venture to hope that there will be a readjustment of both revenue and rent charges of land on a basis more in consonance with existing facts. In order that the agriculturists may reap the benefit of such a policy, if generously adopted, the next step needed is to relieve them of their present burden of debt. In some tracts they were so swamped with debt that no measure which did not bring about a settlement of their existing liabilities could save them from a position of virtual serfdom to their creditors. Mr Commissioner Fuller, with the approval of the then Chief Commissioner, the Hon. Mr Ibbetson, elaborated a scheme which has been most successfully worked in some of the worst tracts. The scheme involved a settlement of debts through Panchayats working under control of Government officers. As would appear from the Government Resolution of November last, the creditors were found so reasonable that in one tract they gave up debts amounting to about ten lakhs.
In addition to these measures, if irrigational facilities be increased, the position of the landholders will be much assured. Your Excellency was pleased to say last year, “the subject of irrigation is one that appeals very closely to my concern. We are all familiar with the aphorism about the service of the statesman who can make two blades of grass to grow where only one grew before; and in India we need not be reminded of the direct and almost immediate benefit to the agrarian class that results from an increase in the area of cultivation.” One noteworthy fact that has struck me in connection with irrigation expenditure, is, that the Central Provinces do not appear to have participated in its benefit. Up to the end of 1896-97, the sum spent under the two main heads of productive and protective works was nearly thirty-three crores and a half, but as far as I can make out, the Central Provinces are conspicuous by their absence in the accounts relating to this expenditure.
| Productive | Rs. 31,25,29,480 |
| Protective | 2,09,92,530 |
| Total | 33,35,22,010 |
It may be that rivers which can serve as source of supply for canals are wanting, but what I am unable to make out is, why the question of having storage tanks has never attracted attention. It cannot be said there is nothing in the country to suggest the utility of such works. We have many such tanks, made mainly in pre-British days, in what is known as the lake regions in the Central Provinces. Here an irrigation tank is an irregular sheet of water, its bank formed by hills, and its dyke shaped out of spurs from them, thrown athwart the hollow. The largest of them has a circumference of seventeen miles. By two short bunds the waters of scores of hills have been impounded into a lovely lake which spreads its fertilising streams over large areas of surrounding cultivation. Where the crude, untrained village headmen succeeded, British scientific skill is bound to attain greater success. In a question like this I speak with great diffidence, but I believe that the tract of highlands and valleys, which abound in the Central Provinces would, if looked into, furnish suitable sites for several such tanks. Two or three of them have been made of late years to supply drinking water to municipal towns, but the importance for irrigation does not appear to have received consideration. Probably the omission may be due to the fact that as enjoying the benefit of both the Bombay and Bengal monsoon current, agriculture in the Central Provinces was until within recent years considered immune. But now that this belief has been dispelled, I would respectfully draw attention to the importance of tank irrigation. As pointed out by the Famine Commission of 1898, the true value of these works should not be measured by their financial success, but account must also be taken of the protection they give in years of drought, while in seasons of average rainfall they give certainty to agriculture, increase the crop outturns, and enable more valuable crops to be grown. These works would, I submit, be a legitimate charge on the Famine Insurance Grant. Under the scheme now in force, when the exigencies of famine relief permit it, half the grant is to be applied to the reduction or avoidance of debt, and the other half, or three quarter of a crore, to protective works. Against the latter the charge to make up the guaranteed interest upon I.M. and B.N. Railways is about 30 lakhs, leaving a balance of 45 lakhs for works, and I submit the Central Provinces have a legitimate claim on this money. In the Budget for 1900-1901 the irrigation grant has been fixed at a full 26 crores, and I may be permitted to hope that the Central Provinces will not be forgotten when the distribution of the grant takes place. In connection with this subject it is gratifying to find that more attention is being paid to irrigation works as a measure of famine relief. These works show better results for the money spent than roads which are taken in hand merely to create employment for the people, but which the country does not need, or which for want of repairs disappear in a few years after their construction.