“The Government in India exercises over a great portion of the soil the same rights of property as those which an English landlord exercises over his own estate. The Government in India takes the place of individual landlords, and the cultivators of the soil rent their land from the Government instead of from private landlords. . . . Hence a land tax is no harder upon the cultivator; nor does this impost cause any loss to the rest of the community.”
Thus wrote the late Mr Fawcett in his “Manual of Political Economy”; and as a popular account of the Ryotwari system of Madras and Bombay, the description is intelligible. Public writers and speakers have, however, often chosen to construe this description in a way which is somewhat curious; and they have argued that the land revenue of India—which Mr Fawcett himself calls a land tax—is not a tax at all! It is one of the most favourite fallacies concerning the land revenue of India.
If there is one thing which has come out clearly in the controversies on this subject by responsible officials,1 it is that the land revenue of India is not rent. This was declared by the Court of Directors of the East India Company as distinctly as the English language could express it. The Court of Directors wrote in their despatch of the 17th December 1856 that the “right of the Government is not a rent which consists of all the surplus produce after paying the cost of cultivation and the profits of agricultural stocks, but a land revenue only.” The same thing was repeated by Sir Charles Wood, Secretary of State for India, in his famous despatch of 1864, and he desired to take only a share, generally a half share, of the rent, as the land tax. The question was discussed by Sir Louis Mallet, Sir Bartle Frere, and others in 1875, and Lord Salisbury, then Secretary of State for India, came once more to the conclusion that the land revenue of India was not rent, and was not meant to be rent. Mr Sullivan, a member of the Famine Commission of 1878, has shown that the Government is not the landlord in India, and has to purchase land and pay for it when required for public purposes. And Mr A. Rogers, one of the ablest revenue authorities that the Indian Civil Service has produced, remarks that land revenue in Bombay is a tax on rent.
It would be honest and candid, therefore, to recognise that the land revenue of India is a tax, and a very heavy tax, on the people. But financiers and public men still find it convenient to underestimate the incidence of taxes in India by calling the land revenue a “ revenue not derived from taxation.” And they quote Mr Fawcett to prove that to be not a tax which Mr Fawcett himself called “ a land tax.” An error dies hard, especially when it serves the purposes of partisan controversy !
So far as the poor agriculturists of India are concerned, the dispute is merely a quibble, and often a heartless quibble. Four-fifths of the population of India depend directly or indirectly on the produce of the soil, and if an unduly large share of the produce is taken by the State, so as to leave the cultivators impoverished, it is small comfort to them to learn that some able and ingenious financiers call it a rent and not a tax. The ten thousand cultivators of Madras, who are annually driven from their homes and lands for being unable to pay the State-demand, will derive little satisfaction from the thought that very distinguished and very honourable gentlemen give that demand one name rather than another. The millions of cultivators who are driven to the money-lender within two months after they have reaped their harvest, in order to meet the State-demand, will find little consolation if the curious information be placed before them that learned political economists in Europe give a very special name to that very severe demand. And the six millions of starving men and women and children, who have been unable to save anything after paying the State-demand in past years, and who are crowding to relief centres in this year of drought and failure of crops, will fail to appreciate the kindness of able and eloquent debaters who are ready to prove that the demand was no tax at all. The nation in India depends on the produce of the soil; it is a cruel grievance when the Government demands thirty per cent. of that produce or more, as is done in some parts of Madras and Bombay; and it is a redress of this grievance which the poor and resourceless people are asking for. To them our arguments would appear a hateful quibble, a heartless mockery of their misfortunes. Let us not give them a stone when they are asking for bread. Let us find out if too much of the produce of the soil is demanded from them in any province, and let us, as responsible and reasonable administrators, moderate this demand by whatever name we may choose to call it.
A second fallacy, which is often committed in estimating the incidence of land revenue in India, is to estimate the supposed gross produce of an entire province. As an instance, we quote the following figures from the Report of the Famine Commission of 1878, vol. ii. p. 112 :—
| Province. | Population. | Cultivated Area. | Value of Gross Produce. | Land Revenue. | Percentage of Land Revenue upon Value of Produce. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Food Crop. | Non-food. | |||||
| Acres. | Acres. | £ | £ | |||
| Punjab | 17,600,000 | 18,500,000 | 2,500,000 | 34,150,000 | 1,910,000 | 5·6 |
| N.W.P. and Oudh | 41,000,000 | 31,450,000 | 5,200,000 | 71,750,000 | 5,565,000 | 7·8 |
| Bengal | 60,000,000 | 48,000,000 | 6,000,000 | 103,500,000 | 4,050,000 | 3·9 |
| Central Provinces | 8,200,000 | 12,000,000 | 2,500,000 | 21,250,000 | 600,000 | 3·8 |
| Berar | 2,250,000 | 3,700,000 | 2,800,000 | 11,500,000 | 525,000 | 4·6 |
| Bombay | 16,000,000 | 21,500,000 | 5,500,000 | 39,000,000 | 2,970,000 | 7·6 |
| Madras | 31,000,000 | 26,000,000 | 2,500,000 | 50,000,000 | 3,160,000 | 6·3 |
The value of the gross produce is calculated at £5 per ton for food and £3 per acre for non-food crops. The fallacy in this calculation lies in the fact that it assumes an annual produce for India which India never produces in any single year. All the cultivated area does not bear crops every year. No approximately correct average can be struck, because it is not known, and it has never been reckoned how much of the “cultivated area” in a province like Bengal, for instance, is actually under cultivation and bears crops in any single year or in a series of years. No approximately correct value of food-crops and of non-food crops can be estimated, because it is not known how much of the area under cultivation bears any produce in any year or in a series of years. The entire calculation is based on an assumption which has no basis on actual facts. The percentages shown in the last column show the proportion of revenue to a produce which India might be supposed to bear, but which she does not bear in any single year. The percentages are absolutely valueless for all statistical purposes.
The real percentages which the land revenue bears to the gross produce is shown with a greater approximation to correctness in Appendix A, from the evidence of officers who have tried to arrive at the truth from such facts as were available to them. Their evidence shows that the land revenue in Bengal is between five and six per cent. of the gross produce; in Northern India it is between eight and ten per cent.; in Madras it is between twelve and thirty-one per cent.; in Bombay it is probably higher.
It is a remarkable instance of the tendency to minimise the incidence of taxation in India that the figures placed by responsible administrators before the Famine Commission of 1878 (given in Appendix A) as to the actual proportion of the land revenue to produce, varying from five to thirty-one per cent., are never quoted in speeches and debates. And the figures showing the proportion of the land revenue to the possible produce of India, ranging between three and eight per cent., are seriously relied upon by responsible statesmen !
For the practical administrative purpose of fixing the land revenue evenly and moderately in those tracts and in those individual cases where it presses hard on the population, the supposed average for all India is of little value. When the people of Madras complain that the State-demand of twelve to thirty-one per cent. of the gross produce impoverishes the cultivators, it is no answer to say that the average for all India is less than eight per cent. When the Malguzars of the Central Provinces represent that an enhancement of the revenue, exceeding a hundred per cent. in some districts, has been made by the last Settlement, and is felt as oppressive and severe, it is no satisfaction to them to learn that in Northern India the enhancement by the recent Settlements is not over thirty per cent. It is not in this manner that practical statesmen deal with the grievances of particular localities in the United Kingdom; and when the case of the West-Ireland cottier or the Highland crofter is under consideration, we are not told that farmers in Devon or Lincolnshire pay a reasonable rent. Humane administrators will rather seek to consider the case of each locality and of each individual Malguzar and ryot, instead of flaunting the figures, supposed to represent the average for all India, before our eyes.
A third fallacy which is often made in dealing with the question of land revenue in British India is to compare it with the figures which we possess of the assessments made by the Mahomedan emperors of India.
It is forgotten that the old figures only represent an ideal demand which was never collected in full ; that it was the policy in previous ages to fix the demand at a high figure and to collect as much of it as was possible from year to year ; and that to compare modern figures with these old figures is to compare collections actually made by British administrators with collections which were never made by Mahomedan administrators.
One collector, Mr Dumbleton, pointed out in the early years of this century that British administrators were trying to continue the severe rates of the Government of the Nawab of Oudh, "without the same elasticity in realising."1 And Sir John Strachey, in quoting some supposed figures representing Aurangzeb's land revenue, makes the significant remark, "whether these figures represent the demand or the collections is not stated, but no doubt the former is intended."2
Lastly it is forgotten that the whole of the Moghal revenues derived from the land was spent in the country, fructifying agriculture and the industries, and flowing back to the people in one shape or another. Spent on the army it maintained and fed the people ; spent in the construction of great edifices or in articles of luxury it encouraged arts and industries ; spent in the construction of roads and irrigation canals it directly benefited agriculture. It is obvious that the people of a country can bear the incidence of heavy taxation better if the proceeds of the tax flow back to the people themselves, than if a large portion of it is sent out of the country, adding to the capital and helping the trade and industries of a distant land. We are not here entering into the vexed question of the annual drain from India; we are speaking here only of the pressure of the land tax on the people of India; and it must be obvious to every candid inquirer that the same tax would fall lighter on a people which benefited by the tax, and whose trades and industries and agriculture were directly or indirectly fructified by the proceeds of the tax. It is a fact, however we may explain and defend it, that a very large proportion of the net revenues of India is now sent out of India; and it is therefore incumbent on the present rulers of the country to so moderate the land tax that it may fall lightly on the nation which depends on the land as virtually the sole means of their subsistence.
We conclude this chapter by quoting from the late Sir George Wingate, who saw in its true light the economical results of sending out of India so large a portion of the proceeds of the taxes paid by the Indian people. "Taxes spent in the country from which they are raised are totally different in their effect from taxes raised in one country and spent in another. In the former case the taxes collected from the population . . . are again returned to the industrious classes. . . . But the case is wholly different when the taxes are not spent in the country from which they are raised. . . . They constitute . . . an absolute loss and extinction of the whole amount withdrawn from the taxed country: . . . Might as well be thrown into the sea. . . . Such is the nature of the tribute we have so long exacted from India. . . . From this explanation some faint conception may be formed of the cruel, crushing effect of the tribute upon India." 1
The conclusions to which we arrive therefore are these :
That the land revenue in India is a tax on rent, and should be limited everywhere to a maximum of fifty per cent. of the customary rents, as it is in Northern India. (See Appendices A. and M. to R.).
That the land revenue should be limited to a maximum of ten per cent. of the average produce, as it is in Northern India, and as is consistent with the laws of Eastern nations. (See Appendices S. and T.)
That the land revenue where not permanently fixed should not be revised oftener than once in thirty years ; and no enhancement should be permitted except on the ground of actual increase in the assets of landlords, or in the prices of crops grown by cultivators, as was proposed by Lord Ripon.
That the growing evil of remitting a large portion of Indian revenues out of India should be checked by an honest endeavour to reduce the public debt, the " home charges " and the military expenditure.
Notes
- 1. See Appendices M to R.
- 1. Baden Powell's "Land Systems of British India," vol. ii. p. 14.
- 2. Sir John Strachey's "India" (1894), p. 105. Further on Sir John Strachey remarks, "Little confidence can, in my opinion, be placed in the particular figures which purport to represent the amount of the Moghal revenues."—Ibid., p. 107, note.
- 1. " A Few Words on our Financial Relations with India," London, 1859.