My Lord,—In continuation of my letters of the 12th and 20th February last, on the subject of Land Settlements in the Central Provinces and in Madras, I take the liberty to submit for Your Excellency’s consideration the facts and circumstances narrated below relating to Settlements in the Bombay Presidency. The distressed condition of the agriculturists of the Deccan and Southern India has often received the attention of Your Excellency’s predecessors, and I feel convinced that in the present year of famine the subject will receive Your Lordship’s attention, and that every suggestion made with the honest desire of improving the condition of the peasantry of Bombay, Madras, and the Central Provinces will receive Your Lordship’s consideration.
2. Land System in the Deccan under Mahratta Rule.—The prevailing tenure in the Deccan under the Mahratta rule was the Miras tenure, under which the Land Tax was fixed in perpetuity in money or in kind in proportion to the net produce, and settlements were made with village communities through their headmen on the joint and several responsibility of the Miras holders. When additional contributions were required by the State for prosecuting wars or other purposes, they were levied in the shape of extra cesses or special demands from the village communities, and did not disturb the unity of village life and the permanence of the Land Tax. Extraordinary contributions were frequent in the last years of the Mahratta rule; village communities were harassed with unending demands and went largely into debt to meet them; but even then the unity of village life and the permanence of the land assessments were seldom disturbed.
3. Early Land Settlements under British Rule.— The dominions of the last Mahratta Peshwa passed under British Rule in 1817; and from that year the land revenue was continuously raised. In 1817 the revenue realised in the newly-acquired territories was eighty lakhs, in 1818 it was raised to 115 lakhs, and in a few years more it came up to 150 lakhs, or a million and a half tens of rupees. The village community system broke down under this pressure, and the Ryotwari system, introduced in Madras by Sir Thomas Munro, suggested the introduction of a similar Ryotwari system in Bombay, i.e., a system of separate settlements with individual cultivators.
4. Settlement of Pringle and Cruickskank.—Settlement on the Madras principle was ordered by the Government of Bombay in 1825, and was undertaken by Mr Pringle, C.S., in the Deccan, and by Captain Cruickshank in Gujerat. But the estimates of produce made were incorrect, the share demanded as revenue was therefore unfair, and the cultivators were reduced to poverty and distress. The settlement operations, both in the Gujerat and in the Deccan, were stopped in 1829-30. "Every effort was made—lawful and unlawful—to get the utmost out of the wretched peasantry, who were subjected to torture—in some instances cruel and revolting beyond description—if they could not or would not yield what was demanded. Numbers abandoned their homes and fled into neighbouring Native States ; large tracts of land were thrown out of cultivation, and in some districts no more than a third of the cultured area remained in occupation." (Administration Report for 1892-93, p. 76).
First Regular Settlement from 1836.—The Government then ordered a general inquiry into the subject, which was conducted by Mr Goldsmid, C.S., who was subsequently joined by Captain Wingate and Lieutenant Nash. Their Joint Report, submitted in 1836, proposed a new Land Revenue Settlement on an improved plan. The proposal was accepted, and forms the basis of what may be called the first regular Settlement in this Presidency, which commenced in 1836. The principles of this Settlement were these: in the first place, it continued the old system of separate settlements with individual cultivators ; secondly, it instituted leases of thirty years for the short leases which had preceded ; and thirdly, it abandoned the basis of produce estimates and substituted the estimated value of lands as the basis of assessment. The Settlement, commenced on these principles in 1836, was completed, or nearly completed, by 1872, and showed an increase of land revenue from Rx. 1,533,000 to Rx. 2,031,000, an increase of thirty-two per cent., exclusive of Poona, etc., then under a second Settlement. (Administration Report for 1872-73, p. 49.)
6. Second Regular Settlement from 1866.—The leases granted at the first Settlement began to fall in from 1866, and a second regular Settlement commenced, and is still proceeding. Out of 27,781 villages in the Provinces, 13,369 villages have up to date been resettled, and the total land revenue of these villages has increased from Rx. 1,446,000 to Rx. 1,886,000, showing an increase of thirty per cent. (Administration Report for 1898-99, Appendix II. (i., p. 2.)
7. Third Regular Settlement from 1896.—The leases granted at the second Settlement began to fall in from 1896, and a third regular Settlement has commenced and is still proceeding. Seventy-eight villages in the Poona Collectorate have been resettled, and the revenue of these resettled villages has increased from Rx. 10,353 to Rx. 13,359, showing once more an increase of thirty per cent.
8. Undue Enhancements of Land Revenue.—My Lord, the brief history of Land Settlements in Bombay given above will indicate to Your Excellency one principal reason of the impoverished condition of the Deccan cultivators. The produce of the soil does not increase, either in quantity or in value, thirty per cent. every thirty years, and the endeavour to obtain such an increase in land revenue necessarily leaves the cultivators in a state of greater helplessness and poverty after each Settlement. Much of the best lands in the Deccan was under cultivation in 1836, i.e., after the first twenty years of British rule in that country; new lands brought under cultivation since are less fertile and less productive; and the disproportionate enhancements of land revenue obtained at each successive Settlement have necessarily impoverished the peasantry and made them more resourceless and helpless in years of bad harvests. The late Sir William Hunter, speaking in the Viceregal Council in 1879 about the Bombay Settlements, said that "the fundamental difficulty of bringing relief to the Deccan peasantry . . . is that the Government assessment does not leave enough food to the cultivator to support himself and his family throughout the year." This fundamental difficulty has not been removed since, and the assessment commenced after 1896 is more severe, and is likely to leave the cultivator more impoverished and resourceless than the assessment commenced after 1866.
9. No Check on Enhancements provided in the Revenue Law.—My Lord, the revenue law of the Province provides no adequate check on these assessments. The assessment made is not based on estimates of the produce of the fields, but on a scientific but thoroughly unpractical appraisement of the intrinsic value of the land, and an examination of the fiscal history of the Talooka. Enhancements are made not merely on the equitable grounds of extension of cultivation and rise of prices, but also on the vague and indefinite ground of improvements effected by the State. A new road constructed, a new line of railway opened, and even the general advance of the country in times of peace, may be, and are, included under this third head as a ground of enhancement; and it will be obvious to Your Lordship that the condition of the Deccan peasantry can never improve so long as the Deccan Settlement Officer is armed with this comprehensive power to raise the rental with the general advance of the country. So far as the cultivator of the Deccan is considered, the blessings of peace and the benefits of a civilised administration add to his impoverishment, because improved roads and communications, and the general advance of the country are made a ground of enhancement of his rent. If such roads and communications have increased the prices of the produce, an enhancement of the rental on this definite ground is just and fair. If the roads and communications have not increased the prices of food grains, wherein is the cultivator benefited ? and why should his rental be increased because his richer neighbour can travel by rail, or his money lender has a civil court nearer at hand ? All the real advantage which the cultivator secures from the general advancement of the country is shown in the rise of prices, and that is a just and legitimate ground of enhancement of rents.1 To provide an additional ground for enhancements when the prices have not risen is to tax the cultivator for a benefit which he has not derived, and makes him poorer after each Settlement.
10. No Equitable Limitations on Enhancements.— My Lord, there are no equitable limitations to the enhancements which the Settlement Officer is empowered to make. The rule is that (1) the increase of revenue in the case of a Talooka, or group of villages, should not exceed thirty-three per cent. ; (2) the increase of revenue in the case of a village shall not exceed sixty-six per cent. ; (3) the increase of revenue in the case of an individual holding shall not exceed one hundred per cent. I beg that these checks on the powers of the Bombay Settlement Officer may be compared with the limitations prescribed in the Tenancy Act for the Bengal Zemindar. It is undesirable that the Government should take wider powers of enhancement with respect of cultivators living under the State, than it allows to private landlords in respect of cultivators living under such landlords.
11. No Judicial Checks on Enhancements.—Lastly, My Lord, there are no judicial checks on the action of the Settlement Officer. In 1873, an appeal in an assessment suit was preferred in the High Court of Bombay, and the High Court decided the case against the Settlement Officer, and in favour of the plaintiff. Immediately after, a Bill was introduced in the Council to exclude the jurisdiction of the High Court and of all Civil Courts in matters relating to assessments, and the Hon. Mr Ellis explained the object of the Bill in these memorable words: "It was not expedient that the general policy of Government in relation to the land revenue should be questioned, or that the details of revenue assessments should be questioned by the Civil Courts." The Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act of 1873 was accordingly passed, excluding the jurisdiction of Civil Courts in matters of assessment; and if the assessment is severe or unfair, or the Settlement Officer commits a blunder, the aggrieved cultivator has no independent tribunal to appeal to from his decision. My Lord, I do not wish to make any reflection against Revenue Officers. I have been a Revenue Officer myself all through my official career, and I speak from personal knowledge when I state that Revenue Officers endeavour to perform their difficult and onerous duties as justly and conscientiously as Judicial Officers, or as any other class of officers in India. But it will appear from a moment's reflection that in the matter of assessment suits the Revenue Officer and the Settlement Officer are virtually a party to the suit, and it cannot meet the ends of justice if they are made the final judges in such suits. The failure of justice which often results from this inequitable system is illustrated by the facts I have mentioned in paragraph 8 of my letter to Your Lordship of the 20th of February last; the cost of cultivation in Madras is underestimated by the revenue authorities; and the Madras raiyat obtains no redress from this injustice because he cannot ask a Civil Court to determine the actual cost of cultivating his field. In Bengal, the Tenancy Act of 1885 permits the cultivator to take his case to Civil Courts; all over India the private citizen and the private trader are permitted by the British Government and by British laws to seek redress, even against the Government itself, in the impartial Civil Courts of the land. But the cultivators of India, the poorest, the most ignorant, and the most helpless class of the Indian population, are debarred (except in Bengal) from seeking redress against the assessment of Revenue Officers; and the assessment becomes necessarily unfair and excessive because it is unchecked by an appeal to an independent tribunal.
12. Sir Charles Wood's Despatch of 1864.—It will appear to Your Lordship from what has been stated in the four preceding paragraphs that there is no real check against undue enhancements made by Settlement Officers; that enhancements out of all proportion to the increase of produce and the rise of prices are made in the absence of effective checks; and that this is the real reason of that distressed condition of the Deccan cultivator which Sir William Hunter deplored in 1879 and which every beneficent English administrator in India deplores at the present day. The check on enhancements which was generously provided by Sir Charles Wood, Secretary of State for India, as far back as 1864, has turned out to be ineffective in practice. In his memorable despatch of that year Sir Charles Wood laid down the principle that assessments on lands should not on any account, and under any circumstances, exceed one-half of the net produce of the land, i.e., one-half of the produce after deducting the cost of cultivation. This rule, laid down with the most benevolent intentions, has completely broken down in its application. In Madras the cost of cultivation is underestimated in many cases, and no appeal is allowed to Civil Courts against such underestimation; in Bombay the cost of cultivation is not estimated at all, lands being assessed with an eye to their intrinsic value and their fiscal history.
13. My Lord, it has been a painful task for me to place all these facts and circumstances relating to Land Assessments in India before Your Excellency; and I have done it because I feel convinced that Your Excellency's Government is animated by a sincere desire to materially improve the condition of the Indian cultivator. There is no race of cultivators on earth who are more loyal, more peaceful, more willing to pay their proper contribution to the State, and more provident and capable of helping themselves if they are allowed the chance. But the continuous enhancement of the rental at each recurring Settlement, not merely on just, and equitable, and real grounds, but on vague, shadowy, and unreal grounds, precludes the possibility of any improvement in the condition of the cultivator, and takes away from him all motive and all power to effect permanent improvements. It is possible, my Lord, without interfering with the steady increase of the Land Revenue of India, to make that increase commensurate with the improvement in the condition of the cultivator ; and I trust and hope Your Excellency’s Government will adopt measures to secure this desirable object, viz., to make the increase of the public revenues dependent on the improvement in the condition of the people.
14. We do not ask for anything that is unreasonable or impracticable ; we ask for those rules and limitations which experience has proved to be practicable and beneficial in some parts of India. In Bengal the rent does not generally exceed one-sixth of the average gross produce in any district; in the North-West it is about one-fifth of the average gross produce, according to Sir Antony Macdonnell’s evidence before the Currency Committee. We beg, my Lord, in the first place, that this limitation, which is generally observed by private landlords in Northern India, be introduced in the Central Provinces, Madras and Bombay, where Government Settlement Officers fix the rental. In the North-Western Provinces again, the Government is satisfied, according to Sir Antony Macdonnell's evidence before the Currency Committee, with forty per cent. of the rents received by landlords from cultivators. We beg, therefore, in the second place, that this healthy rule be extended to other parts of India, and that wherever the Land Revenue is obtained from the landlord, one-half of the landlord's assets be fixed as the maximum State-demand. Thirdly, in the North-West and in Bombay also, Settlements are made for thirty years; we beg that this rule may be invariably adhered to in all provinces of India, and that no shorter terms of settlement, involving frequent harassment to the people as well as frequent enhancements, be sanctioned under any circumstances. Fourthly, we beg that where the Settlement is made directly with cultivators, the rule proposed by Lord Ripon in 1882 with the concurrence of the Madras Government be adopted, and that in districts which have been completely surveyed and settled, no enhancements of rents be made in subsequent Settlements except on the sole ground of a rise in prices. Fifthly, where water-rates are imposed for irrigation, we beg that the rates be optional, as it is now in all parts of India; and that it may not be made compulsory until there are stronger grounds for doing so than have yet been shown to exist in the Bill recently introduced in Madras. And, sixthly and lastly, we consider it fair, both in the matter of water-rates and of land assessments, to permit the cultivator an appeal to a civil tribunal against the action of the Revenue Officer who is virtually a party to such suits. I do not think that such a permission is likely to foster litigation ; the Indian cultivator is not often likely to question the action of the Revenue Officer unless the Revenue Officer has committed a mistake. Such an appeal is necessary to guard against unfairness and undue assessments, for the best and most conscientious amongst us are not free from blunders, and it cannot be the desire of the British Government that such blunders should remain unchecked precisely in those cases which affect the interests and the well-being of the helpless and voiceless peasant population of India.
6th April 1900.
Notes
- 1. This was practically the only ground of enhancement contemplated by the Governor of Bombay in 1862. See Appendix L.