<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" standalone="yes"?><rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"><channel><title>Essays, Speeches, Addresses and Writings (on Indian Politics) of the Hon'ble Dadabhai Naoroji on Akshara</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/</link><description>Recent content in Essays, Speeches, Addresses and Writings (on Indian Politics) of the Hon'ble Dadabhai Naoroji on Akshara</description><generator>Hugo</generator><language>en-IN</language><lastBuildDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</lastBuildDate><atom:link href="https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/index.xml" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/><item><title>Frontmatter</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/01-frontmatter/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/01-frontmatter/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-1"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="1" data-folio="1" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n0_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 1"&gt;[p. 1]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project to make the world’s books discoverable online.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that’s often difficult to discover.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>PREFACE</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/02-preface/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/02-preface/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-14"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="14" data-folio="14" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n13_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 14"&gt;[p. 14]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;PREFACE.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;In&lt;/span&gt; placing this book, containing the writings and speeches of Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, before the public, I do not think it is necessary for me to say much by way of preface. Mr. Dadabhai is one of our most distinguished public men. Both by Natives and Europeans, his ability and the moderation of his views have been recognized and appreciated. There is perhaps no other native in India who has made statistics his study so well and so carefully, and who has used them to such eminently useful purpose in discussing some of the weightiest problems of Indian finance as Mr. Dadabhai. His language is marked by charming simplicity. There is in his speeches and writings not the slightest attempt at what is termed an embellished style; and hence the greatest merit of them is that when you read them, you not only find it easy to understand what he has written or said, but you feel that you are in the presence of an earnest man, whose sole purpose is to convince you, and who, actuated by that purpose, means what he says and says what he means.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>CONTENTS</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/03-contents/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/03-contents/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-15"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="15" data-folio="i" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n14_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page i"&gt;[p. i]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;CONTENTS.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;PART I.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;ESSAYS.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;CHAPTER I.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;I.—The European and Asiatic&#10;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;Races ... ... ... 1&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;II.—England's Duties to India . 26&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;III.—Expenses of the Abyssinian&#10;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;War ... ... ... 51&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;IV.—Mysore ... ... ... 60&lt;/p&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;CHAPTER II.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Essays&lt;/span&gt;—(&lt;em&gt;continued&lt;/em&gt;).&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;V.—Admission of Educated&#10;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;Natives into the Indian&#10;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;Civil Service ... ... 75&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;VI.—The Wants and Means of&#10;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;India ... ... ... 97&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;VII.—On the Commerce of India . 112&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p class="printed-toc-line"&gt;VIII.—Financial Administration of&#10;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;&#9;India ... ... ... 137&lt;/p&gt;</description></item><item><title>BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/04-biographical-sketch/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/04-biographical-sketch/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-20"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="20" data-folio="1" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n19_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 1"&gt;[p. 1]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;of the&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;HON'BLE DADABHAI NAOROJI.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“Mr Dadabhai Naoroji is one in a million—we might almost say one in a hundred and fifty millions.”—&lt;em&gt;Oriental&lt;/em&gt;, 1873 (England).&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It is usual in publishing the writings and speeches of a man that has made his mark as a sound thinker and able writer, to give an account of his life. Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji's life may be described as the life of a man from which the younger generation of the natives of India may derive many profitable lessons. Those lessons may be summed up in the language used by Mr. N. G. Chandavarkar in the article on “New life in Bombay,” which appeared in the &lt;em&gt;Indu Prakash&lt;/em&gt; over the signature of “A Political Rishi.” Writing of Mr. Dadabhai, Mr. Chandavarkar truly said :—“All agree in saying that if there is one man more than another, who now fills the gap between the old and the new, it is he—this venerable gentleman, who can work under any disadvantages and has the wonderful knack of bringing together conflicting forces so as to make them operate towards one end—and that is, the public good. No one can come across him without feeling the charm of his presence, and drawing some inspiration from his example. To see him is to see Carlyle's picture of ‘the holiness and sanctity of work’ personified. He labours and others feel ashamed not to go and do the same. And such is his quiet influence that without him Bombay would be like the sheep that had no shepherd.” Mr. Dadabhai's has been a life of unostentatious, honest, and yet active work, done with no higher aim than that of promoting the welfare of his country and making the connection between England and India a source of mutual advantage and glory to both. He has never cared for the smiles of office or the applause of the multitude; and where they have come to him, they have come uninvited and unsought. His private life has been as pure and unblemished as his public career has been distinguished and useful. Simple in his habits, punctual in his engagements, true to his word, and industrious in his work, he has afforded to all those who have known him and come in contact with him, a fair illustration of what the poet Wordsworth calls “plain living and high thinking.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>CHAPTER I: The European and Asiatic Races</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/05-chapter-i-the-european-and-asiatic-races/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/05-chapter-i-the-european-and-asiatic-races/</guid><description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span id="page-28" class="sec-page-anchor" aria-hidden="true"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Chapter I.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;I.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;THE EUROPEAN AND ASIATIC RACES.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(Read before the Ethnological Society, London, March 27th, 1866, Observations on the Paper read by John Crawfurd, Esq., F.R.S.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I &lt;span class="sc"&gt;feel&lt;/span&gt; very thankful to Mr. Crawfurd and the Council for allowing me to make a few observations upon Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s paper, &amp;ldquo;on the European and Asiatic Races.&amp;quot;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Crawfurd tells us, in illustration of the mental inferiority of the Asiatics, that in the seminaries at eighteen the native is left far behind by the European, and never after recovers his lost ground. What are the facts? Only a few mails ago, &lt;em&gt;The Friend of India&lt;/em&gt; tells us, that at the Calcutta University there were then above 1,200 candidates for entrance; that 447 underwent the first examination, and that 120 had applied to compete for the B.A. degree. The &lt;em&gt;Friend&lt;/em&gt; remarks, &amp;ldquo;These examinations are assuming a Chinese magnitude, and present a spectacle at once curious and gratifying.&amp;rdquo; The result of my own experience as a teacher and professor for ten years in the Elphinstone Institution, and of my observations for ten years more, is entirely contrary to Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s statement. Gambier, Perry, Lewin, Sims, Warden, and others, have given similar opinions in their evidence before Parliament. The mistake made by Mr. Crawfurd is one of those which foreign travellers and writers are very apt to fall into from superficial observation and imperfect information.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;When English seminaries were first opened in India, boys were principally sent there with the object of acquiring a sufficient knowledge of the English language to enable them to get a situation in government offices, or to talk and write English. The consequence was, that for some time these seminaries did not produce any scholars, the pupils generally leaving on attaining their main object. With the imperfect &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-29" data-page="29" data-folio="2" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n28_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 2"&gt;[p. 2]&lt;/button&gt; education with which they usually left school, and falling again in the society of their own equally or more ignorant countrymen, they were not able to continue their studies. Those Englishmen, however, who watched their progress, but did not understand the cause, wondered at such a result, and concluded that the native youth was incapable of progress after eighteen. There is another circumstance which unfortunately aggravated the mischief; the custom of early betrothal and marriage among the natives. The pupils, therefore, were often fathers before they were eighteen or twenty, and the necessity of supporting a family soon drove them from school to service.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;For those who take a real interest in the natives of India, I cannot do better than refer them to that mass of interesting evidence given before Parliamentary Committees by interested and disinterested persons, and I have no doubt that any impartial and candid inquirer will find that the natives of India are not below the average of the head and heart of any other nation in the world.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This evidence was given in 1853 and 1858; but since that time the progress in education and several other matters has been so marked, though not very great, that even this evidence has become obsolete in some particulars. No careful observer will now make the statement that the Hindu is not capable of keeping up his studies after leaving college, much less that he falls back at eighteen and never regains his lost ground. The very fact that the Hindus were even capable of producing a vast and varied literature in all departments of human knowledge, shows beyond all doubt that the capacity to study all life is not wanting. The fertile soil is there, but neglected. Let it have its proper cultivation, and it will again show the same fruit.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Lastly, as Sir C. Trevelyan very justly remarks, what is said about the natives takes place in some degree in all countries, even in England, and as a remedy, he says,—“The main thing required is to open to them a proper field of mental and moral activity in after life . . . and we should encourage a wholesome mental activity in the pursuits of literature, science, and the fine arts . . . all the avenues of employment in the service of the state should be opened to them.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-001" href="#sec-05-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; They have very considerable administrative qualities, great patience, great industry, and great acuteness and intelligence.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-002" href="#sec-05-fn-002" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-002" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I do not know whether the remarks made by Mr. Crawfurd on Asiatic literature and the dearth of great names are based upon his own personal &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-30" data-page="30" data-folio="3" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n29_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 3"&gt;[p. 3]&lt;/button&gt; knowledge of all these literatures or on the authority of others who possess such knowledge, or on the assumption that, because Mr. Crawfurd does not know them, therefore they do not exist. Mr. Crawfurd himself admits that there have been some conquerors, lawgivers, and founders of religious sects. I suppose such names as Christ, Mahomed, Zoroaster, Manu, Confucius, Cyrus, Akbar, Fardoosi, Hafiz, Sady, Calidas, Panini, Abool Fazil, and a host of others, are such as any nation may be proud of. The Royal Asiatic Society has a descriptive catalogue of 163 manuscripts in their library of 100 distinct Persian and Arabic works on the single subject of history. Sir W. Jones thinks&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-003" href="#sec-05-fn-003" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-003" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Persia has produced more writers of every kind, and chiefly poets, than all Europe put together. He mentions a manuscript at Oxford of the lives of 135 of the finest Persian poets.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-004" href="#sec-05-fn-004" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-004" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Crawfurd speaks disparagingly of the &lt;em&gt;Shanameh&lt;/em&gt;, as consisting “ of a series of wild romances of imaginary heroes, and of such slender merit that no orientalist has ever ventured on presenting it in a European translation.” I hope Mr. Crawfurd has read it, or has authority for what he says. In my humble opinion, from what little I know of it, it is a work of great poetic merit.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-005" href="#sec-05-fn-005" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-005" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Sir W. Jones, after giving the palm of superiority to Homer, asserts a very great resemblance between the works of these extraordinary men; and admits that both drew their images from nature herself, and both possessed, in an eminent degree, that rich and creative invention which is the very soul of poetry.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-006" href="#sec-05-fn-006" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-006" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‖&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;He considers the characters in it as various and striking; the figures bold and animated, and the diction everywhere sonorous, yet noble; polished, yet full of fire.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-007" href="#sec-05-fn-007" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-007" role="doc-noteref"&gt;§&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Sir J. Malcolm thinks that the most fastidious European reader will meet with numerous passages of exquisite beauty in the noble epic poem of Firdoosi; that some of the finest scenes are described with simplicity and elegance of diction, and that to those whose taste is offended with hyperbole, the tender part of his work will have most beauty.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-008" href="#sec-05-fn-008" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-008" role="doc-noteref"&gt;¶&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Sir W. Jones considers that the Persian language is rich, melodious, and elegant; that numbers of admirable works have been written in it, by historians, philosophers, and poets, who found it capable of expressing, with equal advantage, the most beautiful &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-31" data-page="31" data-folio="4" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n30_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 4"&gt;[p. 4]&lt;/button&gt; and the most elevated sentiments.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-009" href="#sec-05-fn-009" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-009" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; With reference to the ridiculous bombast of the Persian style, he remarks, that though there are bad writers, as in every country, the authors who are esteemed in Persia are neither slavish in their sentiments, nor ridiculous in their expressions.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Upon Mr. Crawford&amp;rsquo;s remarks as to the absence of any literature or history among the Persians before the Arabian conquest, let us see what Sir John Malcolm says. He says, the Arabs, in their irritation at the obstinate resistance of the Persians for their independent religion, destroyed their cities, temples, etc. etc. And the books, in which were written whatever the learned of the nation knew, either of general science, or of their own history and religion, were, with their possessions, devoted to destruction. He refers, as a parallel, to the fate of Greek and Roman manuscripts, to show how few of the works of a conquered and despised nation like Persia, would be saved amid the wreck to which that kingdom was doomed.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;He further says—&amp;ldquo;We know from sacred history, that the deeds of the kings of Persia were written in a book styled the chronicles of that kingdom; and we are told by a Grecian author, who was at the court of Artaxerxes Mnemon, that he had access to volumes which were preserved in the royal archives.&amp;quot;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-010" href="#sec-05-fn-010" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-010" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-32"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="32" data-folio="5" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n31_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 5"&gt;[p. 5]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I need not take up your time with more extracts on the merits of other poets. Mr. Fraser, after naming Nizami, Omar Keyormi, Oorfi, and Rudki, says he might cite a hundred others as high examples of genius. Lastly, we must bear in mind, that a large amount of Asiatic and European literature may have been lost in that deplorable act of destruction of the Alexandrian Library by Omar.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In Arabic literature, to the &lt;em&gt;Arabian Nights&lt;/em&gt;, at least, I hope Mr. Crawfurd accords some merit; for according to his test of merit the work is translated in European languages, and extensively read, too. Chrickton&amp;rsquo;s &lt;em&gt;History of Arabia&lt;/em&gt; gives an account of a varied and vast Arabian literature. He thinks Europe indebted to the Arabs for some of her most valuable lessons in science and arts. He also gives the names of more than half-a-dozen female poetesses and philosophers.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Professor Max Müller thinks that the achievements of the Brahmins in grammatical analysis, which date from six centuries before Christ, are still unsurpassed by any nation.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-011" href="#sec-05-fn-011" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-011" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Colebrook thinks that among the infinity of volumes on Nyaya, there are compositions of very celebrated schoolmen,&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-012" href="#sec-05-fn-012" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-012" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; and that the Hindu writings abound in every branch of science. Sir W. Jones strongly recommends to Europeans the study of Indian medical works. He says there are many works on music, in prose and verse, with specimens of Hindu airs in a very elegant notation, that the Sanscrit prosody is easy and beautiful, that there are numerous astronomical works, and that wherever we direct our attention to Hindu literature, the notion of &lt;em&gt;infinity&lt;/em&gt; presents itself, from which we may gather the fruits of science without loading ourselves with the leaves.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;No doubt there may be much leaves and branches, or much trash, in this vast forest of literature, but we know also what amount of trash is daily poured upon us in the present day.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Sir W. Jones ventures to affirm that the whole of Newton&amp;rsquo;s &lt;em&gt;Theology&lt;/em&gt;, and part of his &lt;em&gt;Philosophy&lt;/em&gt;, may be found in the &lt;em&gt;Vedas&lt;/em&gt;, which also abound with allusions to a force of universal attraction.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-013" href="#sec-05-fn-013" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-013" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; With regard to the Sanscrit language, he says, whatever be its antiquity, it is of &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-33" data-page="33" data-folio="6" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n32_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 6"&gt;[p. 6]&lt;/button&gt; wonderful structure, more perfect than the Greek, more copious than the Latin, and more exquisitely refined than either.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-014" href="#sec-05-fn-014" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-014" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; With all the above opinions of Sir W. Jones Dr. T. Goldstucker concurs.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Horace Wilson thinks it probable that in fiction much of the invention displayed on the revival of letters in Europe was referable to an Indian origin;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-015" href="#sec-05-fn-015" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-015" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; that enough has been ascertained to determine the actual existence in Sanscrit or in vernacular translations from it of a very extensive literature of fiction, in which many of our European acquaintances are at once to be recognised,&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-016" href="#sec-05-fn-016" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-016" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; and that the Hindus occupy an early and prominent place in the history of fiction;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-017" href="#sec-05-fn-017" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-017" role="doc-noteref"&gt;§&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; that in speculations upon the nature of the superior being and man, the Hindus traverse the very same ground that was familiarly trodden by the philosophers of Greece and Rome.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-018" href="#sec-05-fn-018" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-018" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‖&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; He also remarks :—“ That in medicine, as well as in astronomy and metaphysics, the Hindus once kept pace with the most enlightened nations of the world; and that they attained as thorough a proficiency in medicine and surgery as any people whose acquisitions are recorded, and as indeed was practicable, before anatomy was made known to us by the discoveries of modern inquirers. That surgery (as well as other departments of medical science) was once extensively cultivated and highly esteemed by the Hindus.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Lastly, I appeal to Professor Goldstucker, whether Sanscrit literature was not important enough to warrant the formation of the Sanscrit Text Society, headed by his Royal Highness the Prince of Wales.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Further development was checked by the frequent invasions of India by, and the subsequent continuous rule of, foreigners of entirely different character and genius, who, not having any sympathy with the indigenous literature—on the contrary, having much fanatical antipathy to the religion of the Hindus—prevented its further growth. Priesthood, first for power and afterwards from ignorance, completed the mischief, as has happened in all other countries.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Crawfurd tells us that the Asiatics are untruthful, very inferior in morals, and have no fidelity to engagements.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-019" href="#sec-05-fn-019" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-019" role="doc-noteref"&gt;¶&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Beginning with the &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-34" data-page="34" data-folio="7" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n33_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 7"&gt;[p. 7]&lt;/button&gt; ancient Persians, Zoroaster, hundreds of years before Christ, taught, “I understand truth-telling exalted; all the days of the holy man are with thoughts of truth, words of truth, and deeds of truth. Those that tell untruths and do wicked actions shall not receive the reward of life from Hormuzd. To speak true words is true excellence; in the treasures of religion exalt truth above all. What is the high religion?— That which promotes my holiness and truth, with good thought, word, and deed. In this house may &amp;hellip; prevail words of truth over words of lie.—Punish the breakers of promise, and those that induce others to break their promise.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-020" href="#sec-05-fn-020" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-020" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Coming down in the course of time to the third century of the Christian era, Ardai Viraf, a high priest, holds out the punishment of hell, among others, to the following:—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“The man who used false weights and measures, took full weight and returned false, who adulterated his goods by mixing water with milk, to men who were liars and talebearers. The crime of lying being the most displeasing in the sight of God; even the most trivial and innocent falsity being a heinous sin. The man who was a bearer of false witness; who was fraudulent and deceitful; who, though he kept his word and rigorously performed his agreement with those of his own sect and faith, yet held it no sin to break his faith with those of a different persuasion; this, in the eye of Omnipotence, being a heinous sin, and the keeping of a promise even with an enemy being a duty inculcated.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Pope, the translator of Ardai Viraf, concludes with the following remark, “that the philosophers will rejoice to find them (the modern Parsees) neither deficient in virtue or morality.” Mr. Rawlinson says, “that in their (Zoroastrian) system, truth, purity, piety, and industry were the virtues chiefly valued and inculcated.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Coming down to the latest times, the Parsee children are taught as a religious lesson to speak the truth, and not to tell untruths nor to commit treachery.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-35"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="35" data-folio="8" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n34_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 8"&gt;[p. 8]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The above is the testimony of the religious literature of the Persians. Let us see what the foreigners have said of them. Greek testimony about Persians is to be taken with care and caution. When we see that in the nineteenth century, gentlemen of learning and authority, with every means of obtaining correct information available, commit such mistakes as the one I have pointed out before, about the educational capacity of the natives of India, and make statements contrary to well known facts, how much more necessary is it to sift carefully the testimony of a hostile people given at a time when intercommunication was rare and difficult, and the character and manners of the two people very different. Even good Greek testimony, however, is in the favour of the Persians. Herodotus says, &amp;ldquo;Their sons are carefully instructed &amp;hellip;. to speak the truth.&amp;rdquo; He also says, &amp;ldquo;They hold it unlawful to talk of anything which is unlawful to do; the most disgraceful thing in the world they think is to tell a lie, the next worse to owe a debt, because, among other reasons, the debtor is obliged to tell lies.&amp;quot;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-021" href="#sec-05-fn-021" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-021" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Next, there is the testimony of the inscriptions in which lying is taken as the representative of all evil. Darius&amp;rsquo;s successors are exhorted not to cherish but to cast into utter perdition the man who may be a liar, or who may be an evil doer.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-022" href="#sec-05-fn-022" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-022" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; The modern Parsees are admitted by Mr. Crawfurd himself, as well as others, as a trustworthy and truthful race.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Of the modern Mahommedan Persians of Persia I do not know much. But I may say this much, that if they be truthful, Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s statement, then, is incorrect; if untruthful, Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s conclusion of his paper is so far upset. For, the present untruthful Persians, being the descendants of an old truth-speaking race, the difference in the character is no proof of difference of race, and that external circumstances have great influence in modifying a nation&amp;rsquo;s character.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;About the Hindus I can speak, both from personal knowledge and from other testimony, that Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s charge against them is unfounded. This mistake also arises from causes I have alluded to before—superficial observation and hasty conclusions. Fortunately there are many who have studied the native character more carefully. Not to take up much of your time, I refer you to the evidence given before Parliament, 1853 and 1858, and I think that a careful and candid examination of that evidence will satisfy anybody, that the general character of the natives of India is as good as that of any other people.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-36"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="36" data-folio="9" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n35_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 9"&gt;[p. 9]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I shall very briefly refer to some of this testimony here. Beginning with the early writers, Strabo testifies to the truthfulness and virtue of the Hindus.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-023" href="#sec-05-fn-023" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-023" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Arrian also describes the Hindus as truthful, saying, &amp;ldquo;and indeed none of the Indians were ever accused of that crime (falsehood).&amp;quot;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-024" href="#sec-05-fn-024" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-024" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Coming down to later times, Abool Fazil, the celebrated Mahommedan minister of Akbar, describes the Hindus in the sixteenth century as lovers of justice, admirers of truth, grateful, and of unbounded fidelity.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-025" href="#sec-05-fn-025" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-025" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Coming down still later to the present time, Sir G. Clerk thinks the morality among the higher classes of Hindus of a high standard, and of the middle and lower classes remarkably so. He thinks there is less immorality than in many countries of Europe.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-026" href="#sec-05-fn-026" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-026" role="doc-noteref"&gt;§&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Sir E. Perry tells us, that offences against property and crimes generally are less frequent in the island of Bombay than in any similar community in Europe, and that it is the opinion of the Hindus that native morality suffers by coming into close contact with the English—the pristine simplicity and truthfulness of the native village disappears in drunkenness, intrigue, and a litigious spirit supervening,&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-027" href="#sec-05-fn-027" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-027" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‖&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; and that their commercial integrity has always been famous.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-028" href="#sec-05-fn-028" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-028" role="doc-noteref"&gt;¶&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This commercial integrity is mentioned by Strabo also, who says that &amp;ldquo;they make their deposits, and confide in one another.&amp;quot;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-029" href="#sec-05-fn-029" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-029" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;strong&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; It is a fact at the present day, that transactions of great value take place between natives, for which there is no further evidence than the entry in the books of the seller. I do not suppose there is any parallel to this in Europe.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Colonel D. Sims considers the natives not inferior to the people of other countries in point of honesty, and even veracity, and says that people are apt to judge of the natives of India by those whom they find about the precincts of the different courts of justice, where, temptations to mendacity being many, the atmosphere is unfavourable to truthfulness, as is probably the case in any other countries under the same circumstances.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-030" href="#sec-05-fn-030" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-030" role="doc-noteref"&gt;††&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; When Mr. Fowler, a planter, gained the confidence of his labourers by his fair dealings with them, everything went on &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-37" data-page="37" data-folio="10" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n36_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 10"&gt;[p. 10]&lt;/button&gt; smoothly, and he was never in any part of the world where he had less trouble with his labourers.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-031" href="#sec-05-fn-031" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-031" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Horace Wilson tells us not to imagine that the Hindus are ignorant of the foundations of all morality, or that they do not value truth, justice, integrity, benevolence, charity, to all that lives, and even the requital of evil with good ; that these duties are all repeatedly enjoined, and Hindu authorities commend as earnestly as those of any other language.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-032" href="#sec-05-fn-032" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-032" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The complaint often made about untruthfulness of natives, has, I think, this cause. There are several professional experts about the courts who sell their evidence. The judge is very often not sufficiently familiar with the vernacular ; some of the subordinates in the court being most wretchedly paid, yield to the temptation of bribery, and these three causes combined together make the task of the judge sometimes difficult, and every instance of successful perjury naturally encourages it more. The obvious remedy, one would think, would be that if proper severe examples were made of the perjurers, instead of merely raising up the cry of untruthfulness against the whole nation, their number, if at all unusual, would soon be reduced.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The other cause of the Hindus being sometimes denounced as untruthful, is the following clauses in the &lt;em&gt;Institutes of Menu :&lt;/em&gt;—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Chap. iv., 138. “Let him say what is true, but let him say what is pleasing ; let him speak no disagreeable truth, nor let him speak agreeable falsehood. This is a primeval rule.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;139. “Let him say ‘well and good,’ or let him say ‘well’ only ; but let him not maintain fruitless enmity and altercation with any man.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Chap. viii., 103. “In some cases, a giver of false evidence from a pious motive, even though he know the truth, shall not lose his seat in heaven : such evidence wise men call the speech of the gods.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;104. “Whenever the death of a man, &lt;em&gt;who had not been a grievous offender,&lt;/em&gt; either of the servile, the commercial, the military, or the sacerdotal class, would be occasioned by true evidence, &lt;em&gt;from the known rigour of the king, even though the fault arose from inadvertence or error,&lt;/em&gt; falsehood may be spoken : it is even preferable to truth.” (The italics in all extracts from Menu are from the commentators on Menu.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-38"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="38" data-folio="11" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n37_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 11"&gt;[p. 11]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It must be remembered that these are laws for a state of society entirely different from your present one; the will or wisdom of the sovereign is the practical law of the land. I do not propose here to read a dissertation on truth, but I may simply, as parallel to the above extracts from the works of a Hindu legislator, refer to what is said by some of the European thinkers of modern times. Bentham allows, 1, falsehoods to avoid mischief, the case of misdirecting a murderer; 2, falsehoods of humanity, the case of physicians; 3, falsehoods of urbanity, an exaggerated compliment. In these cases, or at least in the first two, he says, “falsehood is a duty; in other cases it may be allowable, as in all those in which the person addressed has no right to know the truth. This would embrace most of the cases discussed by Grotius and Puffendorf.” Instead of making any further quotations, I refer you to an article in the &lt;em&gt;Saturday Review&lt;/em&gt; of July 2nd, 1864, on “ Lying,” from which the above extract is taken.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I give in a note below extracts from the &lt;em&gt;Institutes of Menu&lt;/em&gt; to show how highly truth and virtue are valued among the Hindus.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-033" href="#sec-05-fn-033" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-033" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Dr. Goldstucker kindly writes to me to say, that in Rigveda and Jagurved “the necessity of speaking truth and avoiding untruth is emphasised in the most beautiful language, but unfortunately there are as yet no translations of these texts.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-39"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="39" data-folio="12" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n38_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 12"&gt;[p. 12]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Crawford admits the commercial integrity among native merchants. Dealings in money, however, produce the greatest temptations to dishonesty, and when the commercial portion of a nation can stand this ordeal well, one would think it must tell much in favour of the general character of a people.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Crawfurd denies integrity even to the educated classes. I do not hesitate to give a direct contradiction to this statement. From my actual acquaintance and experience of the educated natives in the&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. viii., par. 79. The witnesses being assembled in the middle of the court-room, in the presence of the plaintiff and the defendant, let the judge examine them, after having addressed them altogether, in the following manner:— Par. 80. What ye know to have been transacted in the matter before us between the parties reciprocally, declare at large and with truth, for your evidence in this cause is required. Par. 81. A witness, who gives evidence with truth, shall attain exalted seats of beatitude above, and the highest fame here below: such testimony is revered by Brahma himself. Par. 82. The witness who speaks falsely, shall be fast bound &lt;em&gt;under water&lt;/em&gt;, in the &lt;em&gt;snaky&lt;/em&gt; cords of Varuna, and be wholly deprived of power to &lt;em&gt;escape torment&lt;/em&gt; during a hundred transmigrations: let mankind, therefore, give no false testimony. Par. 83. By truth is a witness cleared from sin; by truth is justice advanced: truth must, therefore, be spoken by witnesses of every class. Par. 84. The soul itself is its own witness; the soul itself is its own refuge; offend not thy conscious soul, the supreme internal witness of men! Par. 85. The sinful have said in their hearts: “None sees us.” Yes; the gods distinctly see them; and so does the spirit within their breasts. Par. 89. Whatever places of torture have been prepared for the slayer of a priest, for the murderer of a woman or of a child, for the injurer of a friend, and for an ungrateful man, those places are ordained for a witness who gives false evidence. Par. 90. The fruit of every virtuous act, which thou hast done, O good man, since thy birth, shall depart from thee to dogs, if thou deviate in speech from the truth. Par. 91. O friend of virtue, that supreme spirit, which thou believest one and the same with thyself, resides in thy bosom perpetually, and is an all-knowing inspector of thy goodness or of thy wickedness. Par. 92. If thou beest not at variance, by speaking falsely, with Yama, or the subduer of all, with Vaivaswata, or the punisher, with that great divinity who dwells in thy breast, go not on a pilgrimage to the river Ganga, nor to the plains of Curu, for thou hast no need of expiation. Par. 93. Naked and shorn, tormented with hunger and thirst, and deprived of sight, shall the man, who gives false evidence, go with a potsherd to beg food at the door of an enemy. Par. 94. Headlong, in utter darkness, shall the impious wretch tumble into hell, who, being interrogated in a judicial inquiry, answers one question falsely. Par. 95. He who in a court of justice gives an imperfect account of any transaction, or asserts a fact of which he was no eye-witness, shall receive pain instead of pleasure, and resemble a man who eats fish &lt;em&gt;with eagerness&lt;/em&gt;, and swallows the sharp bones. Par. 96. The gods are acquainted with no better mortal in this world, than the man of whom the intelligent spirit, which pervades his body, has no distrust, when he prepares to give evidence. &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-40" data-page="40" data-folio="13" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n39_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 13"&gt;[p. 13]&lt;/button&gt; Bombay Presidency, I can with confidence assert, in Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s own words, that integrity is most prevalent among them as among the educated in Europe. This mistake about the integrity of the educated is also like that about the capacity for education. There are many youths who know how to speak and write English without being educated, and Englishmen often confound them with the educated.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;em&gt;Polygamy.&lt;/em&gt;—The Parsees are strictly monogamists. The old and young, the most bigoted orthodox and the most liberal, all agree in their abhorrence of bigamy. They prevailed with government to make bigamy criminal among them. I am not able to refer to the books, but I have a strong impression that there is nothing in the religious literature of the Old Persians indicative of the prevalence or sanction of polygamy among them. It is the most universal belief among the modern Parsees that they have always been monogamists, and they consider concubinage, also, a sin. Greek testimony, however, is against the Persians in this matter. But at the same time, the Greek best authority lays the blame upon the Greeks themselves, for Herodotus&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Par. 97. Hear, honest man, from a just enumeration in order, how many kinsmen, in evidence of different sorts, a false witness kills, or incurs the guilt of killing.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Par. 193. That man who, by false pretences, gets into his hands the goods of another, shall, together with his accomplices, be punished by various degrees of whipping or mutilation, or even by death.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Par. 257. Veracious witnesses, who give evidence as the law requires, are absolved from their sins; but such as give it unjustly, shall each be fined two hundred panas.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. x., par. 93. Avoiding all injury to animated beings, veracity, abstaining from theft, and from unjust seizure of property, cleanliness, and command over the bodily organs, form the compendious system of duty which Menu has ordained for the four classes.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. iv., par. 170. Even here below an unjust man attains no felicity; nor he whose wealth proceeds from giving false evidence; nor he who constantly takes delight in mischief.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. v., par. 109. Bodies are cleansed by water; &lt;em&gt;the mind is purified by truth&lt;/em&gt;; the vital spirit, by theology and devotion; the understanding, by clear knowledge.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. ii., par. 97. To a man contaminated with sensuality, neither the Vedas, nor liberality, nor sacrifices, nor strict observances, nor pious austerities, ever procure felicity.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. vii., par. 13. Let the king prepare a just compensation for the good, and a just punishment for the bad: the rule of strict justice let him never transgress.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Chap. viii., par. 111. Let no man of sense take an oath in vain, that is, not in a court of justice, on a trifling occasion; for the man who takes an oath in vain, shall be punished in this life and in the next.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;Par. 86. The guardian deities of the firmament, of the earth, of the waters, of the human heart, of the moon, of the sun, and of fire, of punishment after death, of the winds, of night, of both twilights, and of justice, perfectly know the state of all spirits clothed with bodies. &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-41" data-page="41" data-folio="14" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n40_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 14"&gt;[p. 14]&lt;/button&gt; tells us, “as soon as they (Persians) hear of any luxury they instantly make it their own, and hence, among other novelties, they have learnt unnatural lust from the Greeks. Each of them has several wives and a still larger number of concubines.” It appears, then, that we have to thank our good friends, the European Greeks, for this unnatural lust. The magi of the Medes are charged with worse institutions than polygamy by some Greek authorities, but Mr. Rawlinson says, “whether it had any real foundation in fact is very uncertain.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-034" href="#sec-05-fn-034" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-034" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The &lt;em&gt;Desatir&lt;/em&gt;, which in some parts is, according to some, of great antiquity, and according to others only a work about three hundred years old, but, withal, the work of an Asiatic, says, “Marry only one woman and do not look with a wicked eye on or cohabit with any other woman.” This fact deserves much consideration. Had the Persians been originally polygamists, it is strange that, during their residence in India for 1,200 years in the midst of the Hindus and Mohammedans, who are more or less polygamists, they should have so strictly preserved their monogamic character.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I asked Professor Spiegel to point out any texts in the religious literature of the Parsees for or against polygamy.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;He replied, “As far as my knowledge goes, there is no instance of polygamy in the religious literature of the Parsees. It is said that Zerdusht had three wives, but he had them successively. I share with you the conviction that the majority of the Parsees were at all times monogamists, although, perhaps, indulgences have been granted to kings and other individuals of high station.” In another reply to further inquiry from me, about these indulgences, he repeats that there is not a single text of the &lt;em&gt;Avesta&lt;/em&gt; or the later &lt;em&gt;Parsis&lt;/em&gt;, which alluded to polygamy, and that the indulgences he referred to were upon Greek and Latin authority.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Moreover, Sir J. Malcolm thinks, “There is every reason to believe that the manners of the ancient inhabitants of Persia were softened, and in some degree refined, by a spirit of chivalry which pervaded throughout that country from the commencement till the end of the Kayanian dynasty. The great respect in which the female sex was held was no doubt the principal cause of the progress they had made in civilization; these were at once the cause of generous enterprise and &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-42" data-page="42" data-folio="15" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n41_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 15"&gt;[p. 15]&lt;/button&gt; its reward. It would appear that in former days the women of Persia had an assigned and an honourable place in society, and we must conclude that an equal rank with the male creation, which is secured to them by the ordinance of Zoroaster, existed long before the time of that reformer.&amp;rdquo; I can say, in confirmation of this, that even among the old and most orthodox in the present Parsee society, the above remarks on the respect to the female sex are true, and to the best of my recollection, I can confirm the remark of the equality of rank of the female and male creation by the ordinance of Zoroaster.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Rawlinson also thinks the Aryan races seem in old times to have treated women with a certain chivalry, which allowed the development of their physical powers, and rendered them specially attractive alike to their own husbands and to the men of other nations.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The existence of polygamy among the Hindus cannot be denied, but on reading the &lt;em&gt;Institutes&lt;/em&gt; of Menu, I think that any one will be satisfied that, short of a perfect equality with man, and strict monogamy, woman has high consideration shown her. Menu says, &amp;ldquo;When females are honoured then the deities are pleased; but when they are dishonoured, then religious acts become fruitless&amp;rdquo; (cha. iii. 56). The duties enjoined to husbands and wives are as good as those of any other people. They are summed up in the following words :—&amp;ldquo;Let mutual fidelity continue to death (chap. ix. 101); this, in few words, may be considered as the supreme law between husband and wife.&amp;rdquo; I give below a few more extracts.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-035" href="#sec-05-fn-035" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-035" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Strabo says of the Hindus, &amp;ldquo;and the wives prostitute themselves unless chastity is enforced by compulsion.&amp;rdquo; This bears evident mark of a hasty conclusion from some partial observation. Domestic matters are always most difficult to be ascertained by a foreigner. Certainly the people who not only considered chastity a high virtue, as I have already shown, but even a power, and represented it so in the drama, cannot be charged with such degradation.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-43"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="43" data-folio="16" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n42_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 16"&gt;[p. 16]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Damayante, on being insulted by a hunter in the forest, uttered loud her curse of wrath :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;div class="verse-stanza"&gt;“ As my pure and constant spirit swerves not from Nishadha’s Lord,&lt;br&gt;&#10;Instant so may this base hunter lifeless fall upon the earth !&lt;br&gt;&#10;Scarce that single word was uttered, suddenly that hunter bold&lt;br&gt;&#10;Down upon the earth fell lifeless, like a lightning-blasted tree.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-036" href="#sec-05-fn-036" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-036" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;On the subject of chivalry among the Hindus, Sir Bartle Frere, in a speech at the distribution of prizes to the girls’ schools of the Students’ Literary and Scientific Society of Bombay, says to the natives around him, after alluding to the spirit of chivalry and its effects in Europe, “ There is no doubt that our ancestors regarded the female portion of the community as the great, almost the chief instruments in bringing back civilisation to Europe. I wish all my native friends to recollect, that this spirit, although if manifested chiefly there, was not confined to Europe. If they read any history of Rajpootana, they will see that this spirit was a desire to make them as far as possible equal to this. This spirit is essentially the spirit of the old Hindu races—a spirit which subdued India and drove out the barbarous tribes of those days, and formed such communities that they are now, after the duration of many centuries, still vigorous and still able to oppose to us a vital power, which in spite of this government and its forces, can command the respect of all who go among them.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-037" href="#sec-05-fn-037" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-037" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Lastly, I beg to draw Mr. Crawfurd’s attention to the phenomenon of Mormonism among European races of the nineteenth century.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It is a matter much to be regretted that gentlemen, like Mr. Crawfurd, make sweeping denunciations against the character of the Asiatics. They naturally provoke recriminations like the following, with all their mischievous consequences.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;A Parsee gentleman, during his residence in this country for nearly eight years, disgusted with these sweeping charges, used to say:— ‘ Look at all the mass of untruths in the daily advertisements and puffs; in the daily language of shop-keepers; how much swindling is there in the concoction of companies for the benefit of the promoters only ; see what the book on facts, failures, and frauds discloses ; what extremely watchful care one is obliged to have in his dealings in the city, where every kind of scoundrelism is so rife; how many manufacturers always &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-44" data-page="44" data-folio="17" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n43_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 17"&gt;[p. 17]&lt;/button&gt; give you the best article only, at any price; how cleverly flaws are found in contracts; how artizans always require more time for wage-work than for job; how often you get goods different from patterns and samples; and he asked what grounds are there for Europeans to boast of higher commercial morality than that of the natives of India?&amp;rsquo; He asked;—&amp;rsquo; Look at the number of immoral haunts in London, read the account of &lt;em&gt;Life in Liverpool&lt;/em&gt;, see the social evil and street immorality, cases of unfaithfulness in domestic life, great immorality wherever numbers of the two sexes work together, the amount and character of crime disclosed by police and law reports, and election corruption, and all this among a highly civilised people? Is there not more reason for humiliation than boasting on the part of Europeans as to their morality? See the constant changes of views in the papers about Indian matters as it suits the purpose of the writer at the moment; the mode in which India has been acquired:—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;div class="verse-stanza"&gt;“ War, disguised as Commerce, came;&lt;br&gt;&#10;Won an empire, lost a name.”&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;‘When it suits their purpose the Hindus are described as most loyal obedient, civilised, etc.; at other times they are cowardly wretches, disloyal, ungrateful, barbarous. They first give a bad name, and then cry out to hang them. They draw millions every year from India, and in return abuse its people, caring not so much for it as for a rotten English borough. They yield with the greatest reluctance and difficulty any of the just rights and privileges demanded by the natives. Look at that iniquitous annexation policy in spite of treaties; see how the cost of the Afghan war is clapped on the shoulders of India; their whole aim being how to get most money from India.’ Reasoning in this way he concluded, ‘the only God the English worshipped was gold; they would do anything to get it,’ and he illustrated this by saying, ‘that if it were discovered that gold existed in human blood, they would manage, and with good reasons to boot, to extract it from thence.’&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;He said ‘the English boast of fair play, etc., and yet see with what different measures they deal it out sometimes to the European and native; with what flagrant injustice was Dr. Colah treated; how bullying they are towards the weak, and very polite and reasonable with the strong. Coercion alone, it seems, makes them do what is right.’ He said that as long as an Englishman wanted anything he was the very embodiment of politeness, but the object gained, he was no more the same person, and pointing to the treatment of India generally, he thought gratitude was not a very prominent trait in the English character. &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-45" data-page="45" data-folio="18" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n44_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 18"&gt;[p. 18]&lt;/button&gt; They pay native officials most wretchedly, and yet claim from them as efficient and honest service as they get from the highly-paid English officials, forgetting how rife corruption was among themselves in the days of small pay and much service. They complain of the untrustworthiness of native servants, but in their innocence they do not know how cleverly English landladies and servants manage to have their pickings and discounts.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Studying the English character in this manner, the gentleman formed his opinion that the English were the most hypocritical, the most selfish and unprincipled people, and had no right to boast of higher morality and integrity. Now, if such evidence as Mr. Crawfurd relies upon be conclusive as to the character of the natives of India, I do not see how this Parsee gentleman&amp;rsquo;s conclusions cannot be also admitted as proved. Strange to say, the principal argument that was flung at our face against our attempt some sixteen years ago to establish female schools, was the state of English society, which the objectors, from superficial observations, urged was not highly moral, as female education afforded opportunities of secret intrigue and correspondence. I trust it is not such kind of evidence that will be considered sufficient by any thinking man to traduce whole nations.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;When we left India in 1855 to come over here to open the first Parsee firm, the principal advice given by our European friends was to be exceedingly careful in our business in the city against the many rogues we should meet with there. “In India,” said some one, “we keep one eye open; in England, you must keep both eyes wide open.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In the cause of truth and science I do not in the least object to the proclamation of truth regardless of consequences; but I appeal to Mr. Crawfurd himself, and to Englishmen, whether, in the instance of the natives of India, the case at the worst is but doubtful, such wholesale abuse of the whole nation from persons of position and authority in science is not much to be deplored; it creates ill feeling and distrust, excites recrimination, and engenders a war of races.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;India, gentlemen, is in your power and at your mercy; you may either give it a helping hand and raise it to your political and enlightened condition, to your eternal glory, or keep it down with the foot of the tyrant upon its neck, to your eternal shame! The choice is in your power, and, as I am happy to believe that, true to English nature, the first course is chosen, though not yet very energetically &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-46" data-page="46" data-folio="19" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n45_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 19"&gt;[p. 19]&lt;/button&gt; pursued, is it not very necessary, for men of weight or influence, not to say or do anything to mar this great and good work?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Abuse from persons like Mr. Landon of Broach, or Mr. Jeffries of the East Indian Association, natives care not for. The natives know the men and their motives; but disinterested gentlemen of weight and authority ought to ponder well upon their responsibilities. I do not mean to say that you should not point out to the natives of India their real faults and shortcomings—in fact, you cannot do a better act of friendship; but pointing out real faults is different from traducing indiscriminately. I may demand, in the words of Horace Wilson, “Let whatever they urge be urged in charity.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In my remarks about the general moral character of the Parsees and Hindus, I do not mean to be understood that they are models of perfection; they have no doubt their fair share of black sheep also, and their faults arising from centuries of foreign rule and more or less oppression; but, judging from the experience of some past years, there is every hope of these faults being corrected by education.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The intercourse between the Europeans and natives is not, except in few instances, of that frankness and confidence which alone can enable them to judge of each other rightly. Coupled with this, they very often misunderstand each other; and the Englishman, generally being an educated man, judges of every native by the high standard of his own enlightenment and civilization. The result is often anything but a right conclusion, and hasty generalisation. Every wrong act of the native is at once condemned as innate in the native; similar acts of Europeans are of course only individual delinquencies, or capable of explanation!&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;There is nothing strange in the natives feeling shy and misunderstanding the rulers. The other day the Welsh farmers did not fill up government returns about cattle, after deliberation, on the ground that government wanted to tax cattle.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;There is no doubt that owing to a colder and more bracing climate, the enjoyment of free institutions for centuries, the advantages of high educational establishments and high moral culture, free public opinion, and the advancement in material prosperity and mode of life by the discoveries of physical science and mineral resources, the modern Englishman is, in his physical and mental development, in his pluck and public spirit, in literature, science and arts, superior to the modern &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-47" data-page="47" data-folio="20" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n46_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 20"&gt;[p. 20]&lt;/button&gt; Hindu ground down and depressed as he is by centuries of foreign rule and oppression, and possessing less advantages of climate and food for personal vigour. But the very fact that the Hindu has under all such unfortunate circumstances preserved his character for morality and virtue, for high commercial integrity, for his bravery and military aptitude, and that he has at one time produced his vast ancient lore, shows that there is no want of capacity, and that, under the influence of British rule rightly administered, and re-invigorated by modern western civilization, he may once more regain his former high position among mankind.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;At present he has not yet fully recovered from the staggering blow of the most extraordinary revolution by which a small nation in the far West has become a ruler of his vast country. He does not yet quite understand his new rulers. He is only just beginning to see dimly that after all he has perhaps some reason to congratulate himself for the change. The higher classes, the rulers now displaced or still remaining, are in a bewildering state of mind. They lying prostrate, with all their energies fled, and smarting at their fallen condition, cannot be naturally expected to reconcile themselves suddenly to the loss of their power, and to find themselves, once rulers of millions, now of less importance than an ordinary English official, and sometimes treated with injustice or indifference. The revolution in all its aspects, military, political, social, or intellectual, is so extraordinary and unparalleled in the history of mankind, that it cannot but be a work of time before a people, numbering two hundred millions, though now a fallen, but once a highly civilised nation, can be reconciled and assimilated to the new order of things. Under these circumstances, coupled with some unfortunate social barriers between the rulers and the ruled, the ignorance of each other’s language, and the little interest shown by Englishmen, the Englishman and the native of India are still at a wide distance from each other, and know therefore little of each other’s true merits and faults. The time, however, I hope will come, when, as some who have taken a real interest in the people have already done, the English people will with better knowledge think well of the natives of India. It will be the fault of the rulers themselves if they do not find the Hindus a loyal and a grateful people, and capable of the highest degree of civilisation. Even Abool Fazul, the minister of the greatest Mohammedan ruler of India, has borne high testimony for them. Unfortunately, the mischief of distance between the Englishman and natives is aggravated by the conduct of a class of Englishmen in India, who, either from interested &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-48" data-page="48" data-folio="21" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n47_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 21"&gt;[p. 21]&lt;/button&gt; motives or from pride of superiority, always run down the natives, and keep up an ill feeling between the races. Sometimes some English gentlemen claim ten or twenty years&amp;rsquo; experience who have hardly been on intimate terms, or have familiarly conversed, with as many natives, or have hardly learnt to speak as many sentences in the language of the natives as the number of years they claim experience for; and such gentlemen constitute themselves the infallible judges of the character of the people. Perhaps a parallel to this to some extent is to be found in the accounts about Englishmen themselves given by European foreigners. When Englishmen are incorrectly described by these foreigners, they of course open their whole artillery of ridicule upon such ignorance, and yet it does not always occur to them that in their judgment on natives of India, with less mutual acquaintance, they may be as much, if not more, egregiously mistaken.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;There are several peculiar difficulties in India in the way of rapid progress. Education permeates the mass very slowly on account of many different languages; the efforts of the educated to improve their countrymen remain confined within small limits, while in this country an idea in the &lt;em&gt;Times&lt;/em&gt; is known over the whole length and breadth of the land within twenty-four hours, and the whole nation can act as a man.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The natives are sometimes charged with want of moral courage. We have only to look at the difference of treatment by the Bombay Government between a native and an English judge—I mean Mr. Manockjee Cursetjee and Mr. Anstey—and one may ask what result can be expected from such circumstances.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;However, though such unfortunate circumstances do now and then occur, the educated are beginning to learn that the rights of intellect and justice are the same for all, and that, though often snubbed and discouraged, they may rely upon the ultimate triumph of truth and justice.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Lastly, I think Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s treatment of this important subject is one-sided, and not judicial and scientific. The paper professes to draw a conclusion from certain facts, but to me it seems the facts are selected for, and adapted to, a foregone conclusion. All explanatory causes of difference are made light of and thrown into the background, and all tending to prove the conclusion brought most forcibly into the foreground. The whole reasoning is that, because there is a diversity in the intellectual, moral, and physical character of various nations, &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-49" data-page="49" data-folio="22" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n48_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 22"&gt;[p. 22]&lt;/button&gt; they must therefore have separate origins, but the premises do not warrant the conclusion; moreover, there are several assumptions which are not correct.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In one place a comparison is made between different countries, and it is assumed that the greater the natural resources the greater must be the development; while a most important feature in human nature, —&amp;ldquo;necessity the mother of invention,&amp;quot;—greater difficulties compelling greater exertions, and calling forth the exercise of higher powers, and the bracing effects of colder climates, are ignored. In one place the Phœnicians, Jews, and Mamelukes are taken over to the European side as they seem to disturb the argument.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Crawfurd alludes to the bad governments in Asia as their own creation, as if bad governments had never existed in Europe, and no European kingdoms or empires had to thank bad governments and degeneracy for their fall.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-038" href="#sec-05-fn-038" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-038" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;One principal objection to Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s paper is an unfair comparison between the old Asiatic civilisation and the modern European civilisation, with all the impetus given to its material advancement by the discoveries of physical science, both in the arts of war and peace. The ancient civilisation of both continents may be a legitimate subject of comparison. The Asiatics, after their fall from the first civilisation, had not new blood and vigour brought to them. The Goths and other wild tribes, mainly derived from Asiatic races, permanently settled in and brought new vigour to Europe, and created a new civilisation in it with the advantages of a ground-work of the old civilisation. It would be interesting to make a fair comparison between the old civilisations of the two continents and between the modern condition of the people among whose ancestors the old civilisations prevailed. But to compare a hand armed with an Armstrong gun with an unarmed one, and thence to draw the conclusion of superior strength and warlike spirit of the former, may be complacent, but does not appear to me to be fair.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Differences in the conditions of nations and their various peculiarities, arising from differences of political, physical, and social circumstances, and these circumstances reacting upon each other, require careful study and due allowance before attributing any share to innate difference.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-50"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="50" data-folio="23" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n49_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 23"&gt;[p. 23]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I do not mean to undertake here the solution of the most difficult problem of the unity or plurality of races, or of maintaining or denying what may legitimately follow from Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s conclusions, that there are as many distinct races with distinct origins as there are countries or even provinces with peculiarities of their own. I leave to ethnologists to say whether the present philological and physical researches which Mr. Crawfurd has altogether ignored, and other ethnological inquiries, lead to the conclusion of the unity or plurality of races, or whether more light is still necessary upon the subject.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I shall only make a few remarks suggested by the paper. The races of Europe present a large variety in their size, from the Highlanders to the Laps. The Asiatic races have their Afghans, of the large size, and other races of different sizes. Herodotus writes :&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-039" href="#sec-05-fn-039" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-039" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; “For in boldness and warlike spirit the Persians were not a whit inferior to the Greeks ;” in another place he says :&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-040" href="#sec-05-fn-040" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-040" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; “And in the mid battle, when the Persians themselves and the Sacæ had place, the barbarians were victorious, and broke and pursued the Greeks in the inner country.” In the comparison between the Greeks and Persians, Herodotus accounts for the inferiority of the latter in deficiency of discipline and arms only.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Rawlinson, in his &lt;em&gt;Five Monarchies&lt;/em&gt;, judges from the sculptures that the ancient Aryan race is a noble variety of the human species—tall, graceful, and stately ; physiognomy handsome and somewhat resembling the Greek ; and that on the authority of Xenophon and Plutarch the Median and Tromen Persians were remarkable for their stature and beauty. Palgrave calls the Arabs of inhabited lands and organised governments one of the noblest races of earth.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-041" href="#sec-05-fn-041" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-041" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; A large portion of the Sikhs and Afghans, and large numbers of Bramans in Central India, have fair complexions and fine features.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;We must not also forget, in comparisons of nations, the part which accident, or commonly called luck, plays. We know what part storms played in the defeat of the navy of Xerxes and of the armada of the Spaniards.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-05-fn-042" href="#sec-05-fn-042" data-fn-target="sec-05-fn-042" role="doc-noteref"&gt;§&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; The European lives in a colder and bracing climate. I do not suppose the innate physical character of any European race will enable it to preserve its vigour and strength intact on the plains of India for &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-51" data-page="51" data-folio="24" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n50_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 24"&gt;[p. 24]&lt;/button&gt; a long time. The European, says Mr. Crawfurd, enjoys walking, the Asiatic prefers sitting. The Asiatic, when here, enjoys walking as much as any European can do, for he must walk in this climate to preserve his health. The European in India, after the fatigue and heat of the day, often prefers sitting in a cool breeze. With the European dress, and in this climate, sitting with his legs tucked up under him, becomes irksome to the Asiatic also. The rigidity of the muscle of the European is much modified in India. I suppose it is a well known fact to ethnologists that animals are capable of acquiring a large variety of physical characters in different climates, though originally of the same stock. Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s statement, that the Jews of Asia are substantially Persian among Persians, Arab among Arabs, and difficult to distinguish from Hindus among Hindus, and that their social advancement in Europe is with the people of the community among which they dwell, tends rather against his theory, showing that external circumstances have modified the character of a people within historic times.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In estimating the character of a people, we must not forget that sometimes single events have given a peculiar direction to their character and history. Had it not been for taxed tea, we do not know whether there would have been a United States now. Had the confederates been victorious, what would have been the future history of the United States and of Slavery? Had Britain been connected with the continent of Europe, it is probable that it might have had a different history, either a large European empire, or a province of some other. What change was wrought in the character of the Britons when they complained, “The Picts drive us to the sea, and the sea drives us to the Picts?” Was that change in character, the result of external influence of the Roman civilisation and Government, or not?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The one-sided and partial treatment of the subject by Mr. Crawfurd is best illustrated by the comparison made between Greece and the Island of Java. The wide difference between the climate and products of the two countries is admitted, but the legitimate conclusion of its effects in stimulating or checking exertion are ignored; the rest of the comparison might as well not have been made.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The Guzerati-speaking Hindus are eminently commercial, and carry on the most extensive foreign commerce, while just on the other side of the Ghauts and in Concan the Maratha-speaking Hindus are quite uncommercial, except so far as some inland trade is concerned. Whether these may be considered as two distinct races by Mr. Crawfurd or not I &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-52" data-page="52" data-folio="25" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n51_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 25"&gt;[p. 25]&lt;/button&gt; cannot say, but there is this marked difference in their character, arising, to a great extent, from local and historical circumstances, the Guzerat people having commercial connections with Arabia and the West from ancient times.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Again, in Western India there is even now a marked difference in the educational, and therefore intellectual condition of the Mahommedans and Hindus of Concan ; though they have the same physiognomy, speak the same language, and, in fact, are originally the same people, there are not half a dozen of these Mahommedans attending the English seminaries, while the Hindus swarm in numbers. Should this state of things continue for some length of time, the difference in the characters of these two portions will be so great that, according to Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s theory, I suppose they will have to be put down as two distinct races.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I wish I had more time to examine more fully the several points I have touched upon, and also to examine a few more statements of Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s paper, especially about Hindu astronomy, music, and architecture, and Chinese literature and character. The ethnologist should study man in all his bearings, and make due allowances for every cause of disturbance. Mr. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s conclusion may be right or wrong, but, with every deference to him, all I wish to submit to the Society is that the evidence produced is not only not sufficient but defective in itself, inasmuch as it is superficial, and several statements are not quite correct.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I have not made these remarks for the pleasure of objecting, or simply for the sake of defending the Asiatics ; truth cannot be gainsaid, and I hope I shall be the last person to deny it wherever it is proved to exist, no matter in howsoever unpleasant a form. The sole business of science, as I understand it, is to seek the truth and to hail it wherever it is found, and not to bend and adapt facts to a foregone conclusion.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;section class="apparatus-zone" aria-label="Footnotes"&gt;&lt;h2 class="apparatus-heading"&gt;Critical Apparatus &amp;amp; Notes&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;ol class="apparatus-list"&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-001" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-001" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Lords&amp;rsquo; Committee, 1853, ques. 6644.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-002" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-002" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Ib. 6605.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-003" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-003" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. x., p. 349.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-004" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-004" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;I have given the opinions of others as closely as possible in their own words.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-005" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-005" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Dr. Julius Mohl informs me that he has already published four volumes of the text and translation; the fifth is nearly ready for publication, and the sixth is printing.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-006" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-006" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‖.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. x., p. 355.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-007" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-007" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;§.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Ibid. 354.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-008" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-008" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;¶.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. ii., p. 539.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-009" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-009" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. v., p. 165.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-010" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-010" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Mr. Ed. B. Eastwick, in reply to my inquiries as to his opinion upon the extracts I have given from Sir W. Jones and Sir John Malcolm on Persian Literature, &amp;amp;c., says :— &amp;ldquo;I thoroughly agree in the opinions expressed of Firdausi, and of the Persian poets, by Sir W. Jones and Sir J. Malcolm. The narratives of events in the &lt;em&gt;Shanaméh&lt;/em&gt; are not so unnatural, hyperbolic, or absurd as those in the &lt;em&gt;Iliad&lt;/em&gt;, and the &amp;lsquo;curiosa felicitas verborum&amp;rsquo; of the Persian poet is little, if at all, inferior to that of Homer. Mr. C. cannot be aware that M. Mohl has translated the &lt;em&gt;Shanaméh&lt;/em&gt; into French and that Atkinson has rendered some portions into English. If Arabic and Persian were taught in our schools, as Greek and Latin are, we should have as many and as careful translations of the &lt;em&gt;Shanaméh&lt;/em&gt; as of the &lt;em&gt;Iliad&lt;/em&gt;. It is not the slender merit of the poet, but our ignorance of Persian, that has made the dearth of translations. As yet we have only dipped into Persian poetry. No European can pretend to have explored that ocean of literature.&amp;rdquo; I am sorry that my very slight knowledge of French prevents me from studying, for the present, the annual reports of Dr. Julius Mohl; but I give below, an extract from his letter to me, which I think gives the Eastern literature its proper place in the history of man. &amp;ldquo;Oriental literature can only take its place in the universal literature of mankind, when intelligent historians show its value for history in its largest sense— history of the development of the human race, its ideas, its manners, etc.; and show, too, how large has been the past of the East, and how great in some respects its influence. This is gradually being done, in proportion as translations and researches on special subjects put the materials in the hands of thinking people. It is, above all, the history of religion, of legislation, of philosophy, and of poetry, which will show the importance of Oriental literature; but it is slow &lt;span class="folio-turn"&gt;[p. 5]&lt;/span&gt; work, and cannot be otherwise, by the nature of the case. Greek and Latin literature will always prevail in Europe; our minds have been moulded upon them, and they are nearest to us; but this does not extinguish the claim of the East to take its place. I have said this over and over, in my annual reports to the Asiatic Society.&amp;quot;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-011" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-011" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Science of Language, p. 80.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-012" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-012" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Religion and Philosophy of the Hindus, p. 167.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-013" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-013" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 246&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-014" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-014" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 34.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-015" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-015" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 156.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-016" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-016" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. v., p. 108.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-017" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-017" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;§.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 159.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-018" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-018" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‖.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. ii., p. 115.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-019" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-019" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;¶.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Mr. Crawfurd says, “In morals there has ever existed a wide difference between Europeans and Asiatics. Truth, the basis of all morality, has never distinguished the races of India. In Europe fidelity to engagements has been in esteem even in rude times, and increased with the advance of civilization. Not so in Asia, for it may safely be asserted that there the most civilized nations are found to be the least truthful, among whom may be named the Persians, the Hindus, &lt;span class="folio-turn"&gt;[p. 7]&lt;/span&gt; and the Chinese. Integrity is most prevalent among the educated classes in Europe; but with the more civilized, the want of it pervades all classes in Asia. The European maxim that ‘honesty is the best policy’ is not recognised by the more civilized people of Asia; on the contrary, finesse is substituted. It is only among Asiatic nations of the second order of civilization (Mr. C. knows only them, it appears), such as Burmese, Malays, &amp;amp;c., that we find an adherence to truth, and even they become demoralised in the attainment of power. The difference in morals between Europeans and Asiatics seems to have belonged to all ages.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-020" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-020" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;My paper on the Parsee religion read before the Liverpool Literary and Philosophical Society.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-021" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-021" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Rawlinson&amp;rsquo;s Herodotus, vol. ii., p. 222.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-022" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-022" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Ib. note 7.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-023" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-023" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;*.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 106.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-024" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-024" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. ii., c. xii., p. 206.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-025" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-025" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;J. Crawfurd&amp;rsquo;s Researches, vol. ii., p. 139.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-026" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-026" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;§.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Report of Select Committee, 1853, Ques. 2278.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-027" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-027" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‖.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Bird&amp;rsquo;s-eye View of India, p. 77.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-028" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-028" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;¶.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Report of Select Committee, 1853, Ques. 2582.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-029" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-029" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/strong&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 105.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-030" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-030" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;††.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Report of Select Committee, 1853, Ques. 8548-9.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-031" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-031" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Colonization Committee, Ques. 5742-4.—In Mr. Justice Phear&amp;rsquo;s opinion, “the character of the average oral testimony in the Guildhall of London, and that of the same in the townhall of Calcutta, were on a par.” And the Hon. Mr. Campbell fully admits that it was the courts which were to blame for the character of native testimony. (&lt;em&gt;Native Opinion&lt;/em&gt;, Bombay, 25th March, 1866.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-032" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-032" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. ii., p. 109.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-033" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-033" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Chap. iv., par. 175. Let a man continually take pleasure in truth, in justice, in laudable practices, and in purity; let him chastise those whom he may chastise, in a legal mode; let him keep in subjection his speech, his arm, and his appetite. Par. 237. By falsehood the sacrifice becomes vain. Par. 256. All things have their sense ascertained by speech; in speech they have their bases; and from speech they proceed; consequently, a falsifier of speech falsifies everything. This is somewhat similar to Bentham’s description of truth, in his &lt;em&gt;Theory of Legislation&lt;/em&gt; (p. 260): “ Every instant of our lives we are obliged to form judgments and to regulate our conduct according to facts, and it is only a small number of these facts which we can ascertain from our own observation. Then results an absolute necessity of trusting to the reports of others. If there is in these reports a mixture of falsehood, so far our judgments are erroneous, our motives wrong, our expectations misplaced. We live in restless distrust, and we do not know upon what to put dependence. In one word, falsehood includes the principle of every evil, because in its progress it brings on at last the dissolution of human society.” Par. 255. For he, who describes himself to worthy men, in a manner contrary to truth, is the most sinful wretch in this world: he is the worst of thieves, a stealer of minds. Chap. vi., par. 92. Content, returning good for evil, resistance to sensual appetites, abstinence from illicit gain, purification, coercion of the organs, knowledge of Scripture, knowledge of the Supreme Spirit, veracity, and freedom from wrath, form their tenfold system of duties. Chap. vii., 26. Holy sages consider as a fit dispenser of criminal justice, that king who invariably speaks truth, who duly considers all cases, who understands the sacred books, who knows the distinction of virtue, pleasure, and riches.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-034" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-034" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 131.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-035" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-035" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Par. 58. On whatever houses the women of a family, not being duly honoured, pronounce an imprecation, those houses, with all that belong to them, utterly perish, as if destroyed by a sacrifice for the death of an enemy. Par. 60. In whatever family the husband is contented with his wife, and the wife with her husband, in that house will fortune be assuredly permanent. Par. 28. From the wife alone proceed offspring, good household management, solicitous attention, most exquisite caresses, and that heavenly beatitude which she obtains for the manes of her ancestors, and for the husband himself. Par. 165. While she who slights not her lord, but keeps her mind, speech, and body devoted to him, attains his heavenly mansion, and by good men is called sádhirè, or virtuous.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-036" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-036" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Story of Nala, p. 35.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-037" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-037" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Stud. Lit. and Scientific Society’s Report, 1864-5.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-038" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-038" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;In the nineteenth century, and in the very heart of Europe, a king claims &amp;ldquo;divine right,&amp;rdquo; and a minister sets all law and justice at defiance. Poland and the Duchies are a strange commentary upon the political justice of Europe. Has not Italy till very lately groaned under bad governments?&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-039" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-039" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;*.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iv., p. 354.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-040" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-040" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. iii., p. 405.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-041" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-041" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Vol. i., p. 24.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-05-fn-042" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-05-fn-042" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;§.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Now a single law sometimes fixes the character of a nation for a time for good or evil. What extraordinary changes have been wrought since the recognition of free trade by this nation! I do not suppose Mr. Crawfurd means the English of the past generation were a different race, because they were protectionists, less tolerant, and in several other respects different from the present generation.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;/ol&gt;&lt;/section&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</description></item><item><title>II.—England's Duties to India</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/06-ii-england-s-duties-to-india/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/06-ii-england-s-duties-to-india/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-53"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="53" data-folio="26" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n52_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 26"&gt;[p. 26]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;II.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;ENGLAND'S DUTIES TO INDIA.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote class="epigraph-block"&gt;&lt;p&gt;(Read before a Meeting of the East India Association,&lt;br&gt;&#10;London, May 2nd, 1867.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Gentlemen,—I propose to discuss the following three questions—Is the British rule in India a benefit to India and England? If so, what are the best means to make it endure the longest time possible? Are such means adopted?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The political condition of India before the consolidation of the British rule was the usual Oriental despotism, with all its regular attendants of disorder, want of law, want of security of property and life, and general ignorance. True it is that now and then monarchs appeared who made the welfare of the country their anxiety and duty. Well may India rejoice in some great names. But it cannot be denied that India was for a long time politically a degraded nation. The intrigues and murders in the families of the many rulers in the different parts of India, their imbecility and their utter incompetence to understand their duties towards their subjects, left the people of India without that powerful political aid which is so vital to the growth and welfare of any nation; added to this, the constant internal wars between the dif ferent rulers completed the obstacles to healthy development. War, oppression, and exaction may be said to have been the normal political condition of India.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>III.—Expenses of the Abyssinian War</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/07-iii-expenses-of-the-abyssinian-war/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/07-iii-expenses-of-the-abyssinian-war/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-78"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="78" data-folio="51" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n77_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 51"&gt;[p. 51]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;III.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;EXPENSES OF THE ABYSSINIAN WAR.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(Read before an Afternoon Meeting of the East India Association, London, Friday, November 29th, 1867. Lord William Hay, M.P., in the chair.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;My Lord and Gentlemen&lt;/span&gt;,—In our views on Indian matters we shall sometimes agree and sometimes differ with the Indian Government. When we agree, we shall be only too glad to express our views accordingly. When we differ, either from looking at the subject from a different point of view, or from more or less information, we shall respectfully lay before the Government our views. In doing so, it cannot be supposed that our object is to set up an opposition party. On the contrary, our object is co-operation, as the aims both of the Government and of ourselves are the same, viz. the good government and welfare of India. I believe that Government would rather be glad than otherwise to know our independent views, provided we always confine ourselves to a dispassionate and careful examination of their acts, and lay our reasons of difference before them in a becoming manner, especially making "measures, not men—arguments, not abuse," our rule of conduct. I hope, therefore, I shall not be misunderstood for laying before you my views, and you for expressing yours on the subject of this paper.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>IV.—Mysore</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/08-iv-mysore/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/08-iv-mysore/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-85"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="85" data-folio="60" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n84_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 60"&gt;[p. 60]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;IV.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;MYSORE.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(Read before a Meeting of the East India Association, London, Friday, July 5th, 1867. Sir James Fergusson, Bart., M.P., in the Chair.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I trust the meeting will make some allowance for the imperfections of this paper, hurriedly prepared within two days ; and by their own temperate, disinterested, and judicious discussion, make up its deficiencies.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It is discovered by Lord W. Hay that Lord Wellesley drew his pen through the words “ heirs and successors,” and it is therefore argued that Lord Wellesley therefore intended the subsidiary treaty to be only a personal one. The question then naturally arises, whether any alterations made in drafts can affect the actual compact ultimately agreed upon ? Next, had Lord Wellesley any right to depart from the stipulations of the partition treaty, which is the sole authority for the subsidiary treaty ? The very draft of the subsidiary treaty goes to show that the drawer of the treaty naturally felt that the subsidiary treaty was to be an hereditary treaty. If we accept the argument now based upon the new discovery in the British Museum, we are driven to the necessity of casting a reflection upon the character of Lord Wellesley. For leaving aside, for the present, the consideration and proper interpretation of the words “ unnecessary and dangerous,” this discovery, as it is proposed to be interpreted, would mean that a British statesman, knowingly and intentionally, just left &lt;em&gt;in&lt;/em&gt; words enough to lull any suspicion, and left &lt;em&gt;out&lt;/em&gt; words enough for some private ulterior motives. Here are the words left &lt;em&gt;in&lt;/em&gt;: “ A treaty of &lt;em&gt;perpetual&lt;/em&gt;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-08-fn-001" href="#sec-08-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-08-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;*&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; friendship and alliance”—and, “ as long as the sun and moon shall endure ;” just sufficient to lull any suspicion, and yet, behind the back of the other contracting party, “ heirs” and such words are omitted, in order that when the opportunity came, advantage might be taken of the omission. I sincerely trust that the present English statesmen are not going to hold out this as an edifying and statesmanlike course of conduct to be learnt by the natives from their enlightened English teachers. No, I do hope that a more reasonable and satisfactory explanation may be given of the discovery which Lord William Hay has brought to light. I shall revert to this point again further on. It is urged that the words “ as long as the sun and moon shall endure” are only conventional &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-86" data-page="86" data-folio="61" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n85_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 61"&gt;[p. 61]&lt;/button&gt; terms; and in support of this, the following sentence is quoted from Sir T. Munroe :—" The terms employed in such documents, 'for ever,' 'from generation to generation,' or in Hindu grants, 'while the sun and moon endure,' are mere forms of expression, and are never supposed, either by the donor or the receiver, to convey the durability which they imply, or any beyond the will of the sovereign." On what authority or grounds this proposition is laid down I cannot say. If it means anything, it means that there are no such documents as were really intended to mean perpetuity by the donor and receiver. According to this proposition the British Government can make one clean swoop of all property possessed under any grants whatever; for even the words "generation to generation," and "for ever," are not safe from its grasp. Then again, were there ever perpetual grants made or not under the former rulers? and how could they ever be considered so if words like "for ever" and "from generation to generation" were meaningless? It is true that high-flown compliments, raising one to the seventh heaven, or becoming one's most humble servant or slave, are mere forms, but to say that words expressing the duration of an engagement mean nothing, is more than I ever knew among the natives. I wonder how such duration can or was ever expressed, if not by the words "during life," or "for ever," or "from generation to generation," &amp;amp;c. To me it appears that it is not correct to assume that both the receiver and the donor did not understand the words to mean what they said, but that the Hindu sovereign, being in the very nature of his position a despotic sovereign whose will &lt;em&gt;was&lt;/em&gt; law, and &lt;em&gt;above&lt;/em&gt; law, and at whose mercy lay, not only any grants, but even any property whatever of his subjects, as well as their lives, did sometimes confiscate by his will such grants, though originally intended to be perpetual. Such arbitrary exercise of power could not, however, make the contract the less binding, but there was no power above that of the will of the sovereign to compel him to abide by his contract; it was simply the power of might over right. But this treaty is not of a Hindu sovereign. It is drafted and made by Englishmen for an English sovereign. Is the English sovereign the same despotic ruler? Is it right for the Englishmen to boast of their superior political condition, in which the sovereign is no less subordinate to law and bound to good faith than the meanest subject, and yet, for a purpose like this, suddenly to sink down to the level of the despotic Hindu rulers? Whatever may have been the conduct of the Hindu rulers in such matters, certainly the English rulers ought to set a better example, especially in a case &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-87" data-page="87" data-folio="62" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n86_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 62"&gt;[p. 62]&lt;/button&gt; when they are parties to the words “as long as the sun and moon shall endure,” not only in the Mysore treaty alone, but quite pointedly again in another treaty of 1807, explanatory of the third article of this very subsidiary Mysore treaty : by the words, “these four additional articles, which, &lt;em&gt;like the original treaty of Mysore&lt;/em&gt;, shall be binding on the contracting parties as long as the sun and moon shall endure.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>V.—Admission of Educated Natives into the Indian Civil Service</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/09-v-admission-of-educated-natives-into-the-indian-civil-service/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/09-v-admission-of-educated-natives-into-the-indian-civil-service/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-100"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="100" data-folio="75" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n99_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 75"&gt;[p. 75]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;CHAPTER II.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;ESSAYS—(&lt;em&gt;continued&lt;/em&gt;).&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;V.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;ADMISSION OF EDUCATED NATIVES INTO THE INDIAN CIVIL SERVICE.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;(Read before a Meeting of the East India Association, London, Friday, April 17th, 1868. E. B. Eastwick, Esq., C.B., F.R.S., in the Chair.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Gentlemen&lt;/span&gt;,—Since our deputation waited on the Secretary of State for India with the Memorial&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-09-fn-001" href="#sec-09-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-09-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;*&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; relative to the Indian Civil Service, I find several objections urged from different quarters; and, as I see that Mr. Fawcett is going to move a resolution, I beg to submit for your consideration my views on those objections. They are, as far as I have met with, principally these:—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>VI.—The Wants and Means of India</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/10-vi-the-wants-and-means-of-india/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/10-vi-the-wants-and-means-of-india/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-122"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="122" data-folio="97" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n121_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 97"&gt;[p. 97]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;VI.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;THE WANTS AND MEANS OF INDIA.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;(The following paper, which had been previously circulated among the Members, was taken as read, in a Meeting at the Society of Arts, London, Wednesday, July 27th, 1870. Sir Charles Trevelyan, K.C.B., in the Chair.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Gentlemen&lt;/span&gt;,—After the able paper of Mr. Prichard, and the calm, earnest, and thoughtful address with which we have been so kindly favoured by Sir Bartle Frere, I intended to plead some justification for troubling you to meet a fourth time upon the subject of finance. I think, however, that now I need not offer any apology, as the occasion of this meeting will give us the opportunity of knowing the views of our Chairman, of whose long experience and ability you are already well aware. In order that he may have sufficient time for his address, I circulate this paper beforehand, so that all the time saved in its reading will be turned to much better account by him. I propose the following question : Is India at present in a condition to produce enough to supply all its wants ?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>VII.—On the Commerce of India</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/11-vii-on-the-commerce-of-india/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/11-vii-on-the-commerce-of-india/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-137"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="137" data-folio="112" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n136_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 112"&gt;[p. 112]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;VII.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;ON THE COMMERCE OF INDIA.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(Read before a Meeting at the Society of Arts, London, Wednesday, February 15th, 1871. Sir Bartle Frere, K.C.B., G.C.S.I., in the Chair.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;The&lt;/span&gt; commerce of India is one of the most important subjects that can engage the attention of the public of England. I do not think the audience before me needs to be told the reason why. They know well enough how the prosperity of this country, as of any other, depends chiefly upon its commerce, and how important it is to them that the vast continent of India, with its teeming population, should be opened up for their commercial enterprise. It is a calamity to India, and a great loss to this country, that the subject of the commerce of India is not fully considered by the public or press of England, aud that even the merchants and manufacturers do not give to it the attention it demands. I am constrained to say, after my residence in this country for fifteen years, that the knowledge of the public here about India is not only imperfect, but in some matters mischievously incorrect. But why should I blame the English public or others, when those who ought to know best, and upon the information furnished by whom the public must depend, the past India House itself has made statements entirely at variance with facts? I do not wish to blame anybody, but set it down with grief to the misfortune of India. The Parliamentary return No. 75 of 1858, gives “A Memorandum (prepared at the India House) of the Improvements in the Administration of India during the last thirty years.” This return, at page 11, gives a paragraph entitled “General Prosperity.” In the part referring to the commerce of India, after giving figures for exports and imports of India, at the interval of twenty-one years (from 1834 to 1855) the paragraph ends, in relation to the commerce of India for these twenty-one years, with the strange words, “The great excess of exports above imports (of merchandise) being regularly liquidated in silver.” It also states that the exports of merchandise increased 188 per cent., and imports 227 per cent., during the same twenty-one years.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>VIII.—Financial Administration of India</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/12-viii-financial-administration-of-india/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/12-viii-financial-administration-of-india/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-160"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="160" data-folio="137" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n159_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 137"&gt;[p. 137]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;VIII.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;FINANCIAL ADMINISTRATION OF INDIA.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;[Addressed to the Select Committee on East India Finance, 1871.]&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;A considerable&lt;/span&gt; number of the best informed and most influential Native and English inhabitants of India, together with others of Her Majesty's subjects of all ranks who have the welfare of that portion of the British Empire at heart, asked for Parliamentary inquiry. Parliament readily granted a Select Committee of the House of Commons, though for an inquiry which was to be limited to Financial Administration. It is, I think, due to Parliament and to the Select Committee that those who prayed for inquiry should say in time what they want, for it would be both unreasonable and useless for them to complain afterwards that the Select Committee did not do this or that. As a native of India, and one who joined in a petition from the East India Association, I most respectfully submit for the consideration of the Select Committee a few remarks as to what I hope and desire from it.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>IX.—Poverty of India, Part I</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/13-ix-poverty-of-india-part-i/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/13-ix-poverty-of-india-part-i/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-181"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="181" data-folio="160" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n180_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 160"&gt;[p. 160]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;CHAPTER III.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;ESSAYS—(&lt;em&gt;continued&lt;/em&gt;).&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;IX.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;POVERTY OF INDIA.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Part I.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(Read before the Bombay Branch of the East India Association on Monday, February 28th, 1876.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;While&lt;/span&gt; pointing out in these notes one of the unfavorable results of the present system of British administration, I do not for a moment mean to ignore the very bright side of British rule, and the many blessings of law and order which it has conferred on India. On the latter subject I have already expressed my sentiments on several occasions.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>Poverty of India, Part II</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/14-poverty-of-india-part-ii/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/14-poverty-of-india-part-ii/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-235"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="235" data-folio="218" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n234_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 218"&gt;[p. 218]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;PART II.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;(Read before the Bombay Branch of the East India Association, April 27th, 1876.)&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;As the first part of my paper is already in your hands, I need not trouble you with a recapitulation to-day. I place further notes before you.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Prices&lt;/span&gt;.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;We hear much about the general enormous rise of prices, and conclusions drawn therefrom that India is prosperous. My figures about the total production of the country are alone enough to show that there is no such thing as that India is a prosperous country. It does not produce enough for mere existence even, and the equilibrium is kept up by scanty subsistence, by gradual deterioration of physique, and destruction No examination, therefore, of the import of bullion, or of rise of prices and wages, is necessary to prove the insufficiency of production for the maintenance of the whole population. When we have such direct positive proof of the poverty of the country, it should be useless to resort to, or depend upon, any indirect evidence or conclusions. But as there appears to me much misapprehension and hasty conclusion from a superficial examination of the phenomena of prices, wages, and bullion, I deem it necessary to say something upon these subjects. I shall consider each subject separately. High prices may occur from one of the three following causes :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>Reply to Criticisms.. .:</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/15-reply-to-criticisms/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/15-reply-to-criticisms/</guid><description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span id="page-293" class="sec-page-anchor" aria-hidden="true"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;REPLY TO CRITICISMS.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(July 1876.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;(Before an adjourned Meeting of Bombay Branch of the E. I. Association, on Monday evening, 24th July 1876, in the Framjee Cowasjee Institute. Mr. R. N. Khote in the chair.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;I begin&lt;/span&gt; with Mr. Maclean. He has very much misunderstood my papers. As a first instance, when he asks me to deduct the exports of India (less the exports from Native States) from my estimate of the &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-294" data-page="294" data-folio="277" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n293_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 277"&gt;[p. 277]&lt;/button&gt; production of India, he does not see that my estimate is for the &lt;em&gt;total production&lt;/em&gt; in India, and that what is exported is not to be deducted therefrom.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;As a second instance, he asks me to add 15,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; for cotton manufactures. My estimate for production &lt;em&gt;includes&lt;/em&gt; all &lt;em&gt;raw&lt;/em&gt; cotton of British India, and I have already included in my estimate the additional value the raw cotton acquires by the application of industry in its conversion into cloth. Coal and foreign stores that are used in the mills are paid for from, and are therefore &lt;em&gt;included&lt;/em&gt; in, the production I have estimated. The only additional value is that of the labour employed. But even if we allow the &lt;em&gt;whole&lt;/em&gt; additional value acquired by raw cotton in its conversion into cloth, what will it be? Mr. Maclean’s “Guide to Bombay” (1875) (which is much later than the time of my notes) gives the number of the then working spindles as about 6 lakhs in the whole of the Bombay Presidency. Taking 5 oz. per day per spindle and 340 working days in the year, the total quantity of raw cotton consumed will be about 81,300 candies, which, at Rs. 150 per candy, amounts to about 1,220,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; The price of cloth is generally about double the price of raw cotton, as I have ascertained from the details of two or three mills of Bombay; so that the whole addition caused by the mills to the value of raw cotton is only 1,250,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, say 1,500,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; sterling to leave a wide margin. Then, again, there are, about the time of my notes, yarn imports into India worth about 2,500,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, per annum. This, of course, is paid for from the production of the country. The value added to it is its conversion into cloth. Now the cost of weaving is about 25 per cent. of the value of yarn, so that the value thus added is about 600,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, say 1,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, to include any contingency, making the total value to be added to the raw production of about 2,500,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; If deduction is made for coal and foreign stores, this amount will be much lessened. Again, we know that hand-spinning is much broken down, and there can be but a little quantity of cloth woven out of hand-spun yarn in India. Giving even 500,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; more for that industry, the outside total of addition to the raw produce would come to, as a high estimate, 3,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; instead of the 15,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; which Mr. Maclean asks me to add without giving a single figure for his data. Let him give any reasonable data, and I shall gladly modify my figures so far.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;As a third instance of misunderstanding my paper, when Mr. Maclean asks me to take 5,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; for gold and silver ornaments made in this country, he forgets that gold and silver are not produced in this country. All bullion is &lt;em&gt;imported&lt;/em&gt;, and is paid for from the produce of India; it therefore &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-295" data-page="295" data-folio="278" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n294_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 278"&gt;[p. 278]&lt;/button&gt; can add nothing to my estimate of production. The only addition is the industry employed on it to convert it int o ornaments. This industry for the ordinary native ornaments will be amply covered by taking on an average an eighth of the value of the metal, which will give about 625,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, or say 750,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; sterling, or even 1,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, while Mr. Maclean wants me to take 5,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;As a fourth instance : while Mr. Maclean tells me to add 15,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; and 5,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; when there should be hardly one-fifth of these amounts, he does not see that I have actually allowed in my paper for all manufacturing industrial value, to be added to that of raw produce, as 17,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;; and, further, for any omissions 30,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; more (&lt;em&gt;East India Association Journal&lt;/em&gt;, vol. ix., No. 4, page 257).&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;These four instances, I think, would be enough to show the character of Mr. Maclean’s criticism, and I pass over several other similar mistakes and mis-statements. I come to what is considered as his most pointed and most powerful argument, but which in reality is all moonshine. After contradicting flatly in my paper his assertion that the exports of the United States were in excess of imports, I had said that I had no reliable figures for the years after 1869. To this he replies, “Here they are;” and he gives them as follows. I quote his own words: “Mr. Dadabhai says he cannot get ‘authentic figures’ of “American trade for a later year than 1869; here they are for “him:—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-093"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-093 · FOLIO 295&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-093_p0295.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-093_p0295.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;thead&gt;&lt;tr&gt;&lt;th scope="col" colspan="2"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Imports—Merchandize and Bullion.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col" colspan="2"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Exports—Merchandize and Bullion.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/th&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/thead&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1869&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£87,627,917&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1869&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£99,330,735&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1870&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;97,779,351&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1870&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;117,534,993&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1871&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;112,552,770&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1871&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;138,084,908&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1872&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;117,259,889&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1872&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;128,337,183&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1873&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;132,709,295&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1873&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;142,240,730&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1874&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;119,172,249&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1874&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;130,582,689&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£667,085,481&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£756,111,238&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“The excess of exports over imports for the six years is therefore, “89,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; sterling, giving a yearly average of nearly 15,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; “against only 11,500,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; for India. The explanation of the deficit in “imports in the case of the United States is, of course, similar to that “which accounts for so much of the Indian deficit. The United States “form a favourite field for investment of English capital, the interest of “which is paid by America in the form of exports of produce. Yet we “never heard an American citizen complain that his country was being “drained of its wealth for the benefit of foreigners. He is only anxious &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-296" data-page="296" data-folio="279" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n295_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 279"&gt;[p. 279]&lt;/button&gt; “ to borrow as much English capital as he can, knowing that, invested “ in reproductive works, it will repay him a hundredfold the paltry rate “ of interest he has to send abroad.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;To these remarks of Mr. Maclean I reply, that he has taken his figures from the “ Statesman’s Year Book.” This book has made curious mistakes. It has &lt;em&gt;included&lt;/em&gt; bullion in the figures for exports of “ merchandize,” and &lt;em&gt;again&lt;/em&gt; given bullion separately; and it has &lt;em&gt;not&lt;/em&gt; converted the “ &lt;em&gt;currency&lt;/em&gt;” value of exports of “ domestic produce” from the Atlantic port into &lt;em&gt;gold&lt;/em&gt;. These two and some such other mistakes render this book’s figures for the years quoted above, taken by Mr. Maclean, utterly wrong. I give the following illustration of these mistakes in the figures for the year ending 30th June, 1871. The correct official&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-001" href="#sec-15-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; figures are :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-094"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-094 · FOLIO 296&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-094_p0296.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-094_p0296.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;caption&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Re-Exports (Gold Value)&lt;/span&gt;.&lt;/caption&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Merchandize&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$14,421,270&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Gold and Silver&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;14,038,629&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$28,459,899&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Exports.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-095"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-095 · FOLIO 296&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-095_p0296.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-095_p0296.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;caption&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Exports.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/caption&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Merchandize. From Atlantic Ports. Currency Value. $464,300,771 &amp;hellip; (equal to Gold Value) $414,826,393&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;From Pacific Ports. Gold Value. $13,712,624 &amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;Specie and Bullion (Gold Value). From Atlantic Ports. From Pacific Ports. $76,187,027 &amp;hellip; $8,318,229 Total&amp;hellip;$84,505,256&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total—Mixed Value, $562,518,651, equal to Gold Value, $513,044,273&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Total Exports.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-096"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-096 · FOLIO 296&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-096_p0296.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-096_p0296.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;caption&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Total Exports.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/caption&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Domestic Exports (Gold Value)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$513,044,273&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Re-Exports (Gold Value)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;28,459,899&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total (Gold Value)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$541,504,172&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now, instead of the above correct official figure of $541,504,172 as the &lt;em&gt;total&lt;/em&gt; exports from the United States (including bullion), the “ Statesman’s Book” makes “ merchandize” $590,978,550 and bullion $98,441,989, which I find to be made up as follows: It takes from the official returns &lt;em&gt;total&lt;/em&gt; mixed value of domestic exports, $562,518,651, and then adds to it the &lt;em&gt;total&lt;/em&gt; re-exports, $28,459,899, and makes the addition of these two figures as the total for “ merchandize”—viz., $590,978,550. It will be now seen by a comparison of these figures with the official &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-297" data-page="297" data-folio="280" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n296_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 280"&gt;[p. 280]&lt;/button&gt; ones, that the &amp;ldquo;currency&amp;rdquo; value of the domestic exports from the Atlantic ports is &lt;em&gt;not&lt;/em&gt; converted into gold, and that though in the two official totals of $562,518,651 and $28,459,899, bullion is &lt;em&gt;already included&lt;/em&gt;, the total of these in the &amp;ldquo;Statesman&amp;rsquo;s Book&amp;rdquo; is given for &amp;ldquo;merchandize&amp;rdquo; alone, and a further statement is given for bullion as $98,441,989, made up nearly of $84,505,256 of domestic exports and $14,038,629 of re-exports.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Maclean takes the total $590,978,550 of &amp;ldquo;merchandize&amp;rdquo; (which &lt;em&gt;already includes bullion&lt;/em&gt;) and bullion &lt;em&gt;over again&lt;/em&gt;, $98,543,885, and makes the exports $689,420,539, or 138,084,908&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. It will thus be seen that his figure for 1871 contains bullion to the extent of $98,543,885, or 19,889,198&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. taken &lt;em&gt;twice&lt;/em&gt;, and the currency value of domestic produce exported from the Atlantic ports is &lt;em&gt;not&lt;/em&gt; converted into gold value, making a further error of $49,474,378; or the total error in Mr. Maclean&amp;rsquo;s figure for exports for 1871 alone is $98,543,885 + 49,474,378 = $148,018,263, or nearly 31,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. sterling at 50d. per $.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I take 50&lt;em&gt;d&lt;/em&gt;. per $, as the Parliamentary Returns for Foreign States, No. XII., have taken this rate of exchange.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Maclean has given the figures for six years. I am not able to verify the figure for 1874, so I give a comparison of the &lt;em&gt;official correct&lt;/em&gt; figures and his figures for the years ending June, 1869, to 1873.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The &amp;ldquo;Statesman&amp;rsquo;s Book&amp;rsquo;s&amp;rdquo; wrong figures :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-097"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-097 · FOLIO 297&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-097_p0297.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-097_p0297.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;thead&gt;&lt;tr&gt;&lt;th scope="col" colspan="2"&gt;IMPORTS.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col" colspan="2"&gt;EXPORTS.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;Merchandize.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;Bullion.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;Merchandize.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;Bullion.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/thead&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1869&amp;hellip; $417,506,379&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$19,807,876&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1869&amp;hellip; $439,134,529&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$57,138,380&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1870&amp;hellip; 462,377,587&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;26,419,179&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1870&amp;hellip; 529,519,302&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;58,155,666&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1871&amp;hellip; 541,493,774&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;21,270,024&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1871&amp;hellip; 590,978,550&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;98,441,989&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1872&amp;hellip; 572,510,304&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;13,743,689&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1872&amp;hellip; 561,808,381&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;79,877,534&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1873&amp;hellip; 642,030,539&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;21,480,937&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1873&amp;hellip; 626,595,077&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;84,608,574&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-subtotal"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$2,635,918,583&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$102,721,705&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$2,748,035,839&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$378,222,143&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Add&amp;hellip; 102,721,705&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;Add&amp;hellip; 378,222,143&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total $2,738,640,288&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$3,126,257,982&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2,738,640,288&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-subtotal"&gt;&lt;td&gt;$387,617,694, Excess of Exports.&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-298"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="298" data-folio="281" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n297_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 281"&gt;[p. 281]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-098"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-098 · FOLIO 298&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-098_p0298.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-098_p0298.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;caption&gt;Official correct figures&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-002" href="#sec-15-fn-002" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-002" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; :—&lt;/caption&gt;&lt;thead&gt;&lt;tr&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;IMPORTS—INCLUDING BULLION. (GOLD VALUE.)&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;EXPORTS—INCLUDING BULLION. (GOLD VALUE.)&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;&lt;/th&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;Domestic.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;Foreign.&lt;/th&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/thead&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1869&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$437,314,255&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1869&amp;hellip; $318,082,663&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$25,173,414&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1870&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;462,377,587&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1870&amp;hellip; 420,500,275&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;30,427,159&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1871&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;541,493,708&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1871&amp;hellip; 512,802,267&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;28,459,899&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1872&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;640,338,706&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1872&amp;hellip; 501,285,371&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;22,769,749&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1873&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;663,617,147&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;1873&amp;hellip; 578,938,985&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;28,149,511&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-subtotal"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$2,745,141,403&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$2,331,609,561&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$134,979,732&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Deduct Exports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2,466,589,293&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Excess of Imports&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$278,552,110&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total&amp;hellip; $2,466,589,273&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Maclean&amp;rsquo;s total error for the five years, 1869 to 1873, is therefore $278,552,110 + 387,617,694 = $666,169,804 = 138,785,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;., at 50&lt;em&gt;d&lt;/em&gt;. per $; or $133,233,961 = 27,757,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. per annum.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In making, however, a comparison between the trade returns of India and the United States, there is one important matter to be considered, and when taken into account, as it ought to be, the imports of the United States will be some 16 per cent. more than they are above shown to be. In India the exports are declared at the value at the port of export. It is the same with the United States. The imports in India are declared at the “&lt;em&gt;wholesale cash price less trade discount&lt;/em&gt;”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-003" href="#sec-15-fn-003" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-003" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; at the &lt;em&gt;port of import&lt;/em&gt;, which means the value at the foreign port of export, &lt;em&gt;plus&lt;/em&gt; freight, insurance, and other charges to the Indian port of import, and also &lt;em&gt;plus&lt;/em&gt; 10 per cent. for profits. This is the principle on which the imports are declared in the Custom Houses in India when the tariff value is not already fixed, or the market price not agreed upon by the importer and the Custom House. But in the case of the United States the declared value&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-004" href="#sec-15-fn-004" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-004" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; of imports is only the value declared at the &lt;em&gt;foreign port&lt;/em&gt; from which the merchandize was &lt;em&gt;exported&lt;/em&gt;, which means &lt;em&gt;without&lt;/em&gt; adding the cost of freight, insurance and other charges, and 10 per cent. profits. Now Mr. Edward Young, the “Chief of the Bureau of Statistics, &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-299" data-page="299" data-folio="282" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n298_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 282"&gt;[p. 282]&lt;/button&gt; Treasury Department&amp;quot; of the United States, calculates 6 per cent.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-005" href="#sec-15-fn-005" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-005" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; as representing the freight from foreign ports to America.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This 6 per cent. for freight (without taking the further additional charges for insurance, commission, &amp;amp;c., into account), together with the 10 per cent. as calculated in India for declaration for imports, makes it necessary to add 16 per cent. to the imports of the United States, before the actual excess of imports of the United States, on the principle adopted in India, can be ascertained and compared with that of India. In that case the actual excess of imports over exports in the United States will be $717,774,734 = 149,536,403&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-006" href="#sec-15-fn-006" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-006" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; for the five years, 1869 to 1873, or $143,554,947 = 29,907,280&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. per annum. Thus the correct result about the United States (on the principle of the Indian Custom House) is that, instead of there being an excess of &lt;em&gt;exports&lt;/em&gt; of 15,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. sterling per annum, there is actually an excess of &lt;em&gt;imports of double that amount&lt;/em&gt;, or nearly 30,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. sterling; thus making a difference between Mr. Maclean&amp;rsquo;s and the correct figures of nearly 45,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. sterling per annum.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Maclean clearly admits my most important statements; he says: “It has been estimated that the amount of the annual earnings “of Englishmen connected with India which are thus transmitted “home cannot be less than 20,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;., and we should be inclined to “place it at a &lt;em&gt;very much higher figure&lt;/em&gt;.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-007" href="#sec-15-fn-007" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-007" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Again: “To decrease these (home remittances) by clipping establish- “ments, or rather re-framing on an economical basis, &lt;em&gt;by never employing “other than natives of this country&lt;/em&gt;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-007-2" href="#sec-15-fn-007" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-007" role="doc-noteref"&gt;‡&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; except when good policy and “public convenience demand it, and, if possible, by establishing some “check on the extravagant follies of the Secretary of State, should be “the task of the Indian Government.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-099"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-099 · FOLIO 299&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-099_p0299.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-099_p0299.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-006-2" href="#sec-15-fn-006" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-006" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Total Imports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$2,745,141,403&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Add 16 per cent.&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;439,222,624&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-subtotal"&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;$3,184,364,027&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Deduct Exports&amp;hellip;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2,466,589,293&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-300"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="300" data-folio="283" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n299_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 283"&gt;[p. 283]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This is just what I say, that there is an enormous transfer of the wealth of this country to England, and the remedy is the employment of Natives only, beyond the exigencies of the British rule. But for this single circumstance, his remarks about the United States would apply to India perfectly well—viz., “He (the American) is only anxious to “borrow as much English capital as he can, knowing that, invested in “reproductive works, it will repay him a hundredfold the paltry rate of “interest he has to send abroad.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The Indian will do &lt;em&gt;just the same;&lt;/em&gt; but while the American derives &lt;em&gt;the full benefit&lt;/em&gt; of what he borrows, the Indian, borrowing with one hand, has to give the money away to England with the other hand in these “home remittances” of Englishmen and “home charges,” getting for himself the &lt;em&gt;burden&lt;/em&gt; only of the debt. The very idea of comparing the circumstances and condition of the United States and India as being similar, is simply absurd; on this point another reason will be given further on.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I will now answer Mr. Shapoorjee, who says India is in the same boat with the United States. In support of his assertion, he says the United States have foreign debts of about 1,625,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; I requested him to show me any official or sufficiently reliable authority for these figures, and he shows me none.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Had Mr. Shapoorjee read my papers carefully, he would not have said a word about America’s public debt, for he would have seen that I have excluded from my total of imports and exports those very years in which the United States contracted nearly the whole of its public debt (1863 to 1866). Again, Mr. Shapoorjee tells us that the railways of the United States “could not have cost “less than 20,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; a mile,” while the “Railway Manual” for 1873-4, which he has kindly lent me, gives the average cost at $55,116, and the “Statesman’s Book” gives $50,000 a-mile. This is about 10,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; to 11,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, or nearly half of Mr. Shapoorjee’s figure; and thus nearly half of his “850,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, if not more,” of foreign capital for railways disappears. Now I give one more reason why Mr. Shapoorjee’s figure of 1,625,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; sterling as the present foreign debt of the United States cannot be accepted. Mr. Edward Young, whom I have already mentioned,—the highest official authority on the Treasury statistics of the United States,—calculates and gives (in his official “Monthly reports on the Commerce and Navigation of the “United States for the year ending June 30, 1874,” page 352) his &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-301" data-page="301" data-folio="284" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n300_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 284"&gt;[p. 284]&lt;/button&gt; own personal and unofficial estimate of the “aggregate foreign debts “of the United States.” He says; “Although there were no national “securities held abroad at the commencement of our late war, yet some “of the bonds of the commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and probably of “Massachusetts and other States, as well as railroad shares and securi- “ties, were owned in Europe. In the absence of accurate data on the “subject, it is believed that $50,000,000 is an ample estimate for these “&lt;em&gt;ante bellum&lt;/em&gt; securities. With this addition, our aggregate foreign debt “amounts to nearly &lt;span class="sc"&gt;twelve hundred million dollars.&lt;/span&gt;” Such is Mr. Young&amp;rsquo;s estimate of the aggregate debts, “national, State, municipal, and “corporation, held in foreign countries”—&lt;em&gt;i.e.&lt;/em&gt;, $1,200,000,000—when Mr. Shapoorjee asks us to take the figures nearly seven times larger;— 1,625,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; equal to $7,800,000,000. I trust I may be excused for not accepting his figures, and his conclusions based thereon. Again, Mr. Shapoorjee has been good enough to give me an extract from the &lt;em&gt;Westminster Review&lt;/em&gt; of January 1876. This extract gives (in 1875) the national production of the United Kingdom as 28&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; per head of population, of the United States as 28&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; per head, and of Russia as 7&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; 10s. per head; France, 22&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;; Austria, 18&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;; and Italy, 15&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;; while India hardly produces 2&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; a-head. The simple fact, then, that the United States is the second richest country in the world, and its people have &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; their revenues and resources at &lt;em&gt;their own&lt;/em&gt; command and for &lt;em&gt;their own&lt;/em&gt; benefit only, is enough to show that it is simply absurd and idle to compare it, in its circumstances and condition, as being in the same boat with the half-starving and ever-draining India. When the Americans are subjected to a “home remittance” to a foreign country of some “very much higher figure” than 20,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; sterling a-year, and “home charges,” and when a large number of foreigners engross all official and important positions to their own exclusion, causing thereby such heavy drain, &lt;em&gt;then&lt;/em&gt; will be the proper time to make a comparison between America and India.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The comparison with Russia and other European States is equally unreasonable. In spite of the inferior administration of Russia, and the great military expenditure, its national income is nearly four times as much as that of India, a nd that of the other European States is much larger still; and they have no “home remittances and charges” to remit, which India has to do from its wretched income of hardly 2&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; per head per annum.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="unclear" title="Uncertain reading in source scan"&gt;M&lt;/span&gt;r. Schrottky misunderstands me when he thinks that in the present ssion about the &lt;em&gt;material condition&lt;/em&gt; of India, I mention the necessity &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-302" data-page="302" data-folio="285" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n301_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 285"&gt;[p. 285]&lt;/button&gt; of the employment of natives as anything more than the only remedy by which the capital of the country can be saved to itself, to enable the agricultural as well as all other industries to get the necessary lifeblood for their maintenance and progress. If it were possible that every European coming to India would make it his home, so that the item of the “home remittances and charges” would be nearly eliminated, it would not matter at all, as far as the present question of the material prosperity of the country is concerned, whether the European or the Native is in office. The only remedy is, that either the Europeans must, like the Mahomedan conquerors, become Natives and &lt;em&gt;remain in&lt;/em&gt; the country, or remain &lt;em&gt;out&lt;/em&gt; of office beyond the exigency of the British rule. If not, then it is idle to hope that India can rise in material prosperity, or be anything else but a wretched drudge for England&amp;rsquo;s benefit. On the other hand, a natural and just policy would make India, with its teeming population, the best customer for England, and the best field for England&amp;rsquo;s enterprise, and its agriculture would derive all the aid which Mr. Schrottky could desire in the goodness of his heart.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;To Mr. Trant I have only to say that his political economy may be applicable to a Native-governed country, but when he takes the element of the “home remittances and charges” into account, he will not differ much from me.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In reply to Mr. Collett&amp;rsquo;s remarks, I have to request him to take several elements into account which he appears to have forgotten.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;1. To add 15 per cent.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-008" href="#sec-15-fn-008" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-008" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; profits to exports. (During the American War, the percentage of profits on the exported produce was very much larger.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-100"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-100 · FOLIO 302&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-100_p0302.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-100_p0302.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;The United Kingdom&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;25 per cent.&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;(1858 to 1870)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Australia&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;15 „ „&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;(1858 to 1868)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;British North America&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;29 „ „&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;(1858 to 1868)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;United States (as under)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;18 „ „&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;(1869 to 1873)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Imports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num" colspan="2"&gt;$2,745,141,403&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Add 6 per cent. Freight (leaving other charges)— Commission, Insurance, &amp;amp;c.—alone&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num" colspan="2"&gt;164,708,484&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-subtotal"&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num" colspan="2"&gt;$2,909,849,887&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Deduct Exports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num" colspan="2"&gt;2,466,589,293&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Excess of Imports or Profits—say 18 per cent. above Exports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num" colspan="2"&gt;$443,260,594&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-303"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="303" data-folio="286" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n302_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 286"&gt;[p. 286]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;ul class="editorial-list"&gt;&lt;li&gt;2. To deduct from import nearly 140,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. of foreign debt (public and railway) incurred during the eighteen years he has taken.&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li&gt;3. To remember that the profits of opium as well as of all India&amp;rsquo;s commerce are as much India&amp;rsquo;s property and resources as the profits in coal, iron, and all other exported produce and manufactures of England are England&amp;rsquo;s property and resources, though all such profits are derived from foreign nations; and that all the profits of opium and general commerce of India are included in my total production of India.&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li&gt;4. To remember that, notwithstanding that opium and the profits of commerce are legitimate property and resources of India, even after deducting these amounts, or that, in addition to these amounts being sent away to England, there is the further amount of about 200,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. in principal alone gone to England during the thirty-eight years I have taken; and that Mr. Collett has not pointed out any mistake in my calculations.&lt;/li&gt;&lt;/ul&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;For his eighteen years also, if he will take the items he has forgotten, his results will not differ from mine.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-101"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-101 · FOLIO 303&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-101_p0303.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-101_p0303.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;For 1858 to 1875 his figure for Exports is&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£910,995,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Add 15 per cent. Profits&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;136,649,250&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Total proceeds of Exports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£1,047,644,250&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;His Imports are&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£764,310,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Deduct Loans Imported, about&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;140,000,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Actual Commercial Imports (including Government Store)&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£624,310,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Excess of proceeds of Exports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£423,334,250&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Deduct Railway Interest&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;51,133,987&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-total"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Transfer to England from India&amp;rsquo;s resources (excluding Interest on Railway Loans)&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;372,200,263&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;This transfer is equal to the whole of the Opium Revenue&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£108,156,107&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;The whole of profits on Exports&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;136,649,250&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;And furthermore, from India&amp;rsquo;s resources&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;127,394,906&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;or nearly 130,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. in addition to the railway interest. The actual transfer is even larger than this, as will be seen further on.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mark, then, during Mr. Collett&amp;rsquo;s eighteen years &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; opium revenue, &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; profits of commerce and guaranteed interest on railways, are transferred to England, and 130,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;., besides making a total, in principal alone, of 424,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;., or 372,000,000&lt;em&gt;l&lt;/em&gt;. excluding railway &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-304" data-page="304" data-folio="287" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n303_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 287"&gt;[p. 287]&lt;/button&gt; interest. Moreover, it must be remembered that during the American War great profits were made, and this having to be added to the exports, is so much more transferred to England.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Thus, as Mr. Collett’s figures are imperfect, I need not trouble the meeting with any comments on the confusion into which he has fallen on account thereof. I have taken his own figures and shown what they lead to, as the best way of pointing out his mistake.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Thanks to my critics, they have led me into a closer examination of some points, and I find the case of India worse than what I have already made out, I have to modify some of my figures,&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-009" href="#sec-15-fn-009" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-009" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; which I now do.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I have shown that the imports into India (&lt;em&gt;including bullion&lt;/em&gt;) from 1835 to 1872 are 943,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; Now, in making out a nation’s balancesheet with foreign countries, the balance of profit should be taken between the price of exports at the port of export, and the price of imports as &lt;em&gt;laid down&lt;/em&gt; or costing at the port of import, and not the &lt;em&gt;market&lt;/em&gt; price at the place of import, which include the profit on the import obtained in the importing country itself.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I may illustrate thus: I laid out Rs. 1,000 in cotton and sent it to England. There it realized proceeds, say, Rs. 1,150. This may be remitted to me in silver, so that when the transaction is completed, I receive into my hands Rs. 1,150, in the place of Rs. 1.000 which I had first laid out, so that the country has added Rs. 150 thereby to its capital. But suppose, instead of getting silver, I imported, say, ten bales of piece goods which were laid down in Bombay for Rs. 1,150. The gain to the country so far is the same in both cases—an addition of Rs. 150. But any gain to me &lt;em&gt;after&lt;/em&gt; that in the sale of these piece goods in India itself is &lt;em&gt;no&lt;/em&gt; gain to India. Suppose I sold these goods for Rs. 1,300. That simply means that I had these goods and another person had Rs. 1,300, and we simply exchanged. The country has no addition made to its already existing property. It is the same—viz., the ten bales of piece goods and Rs. 1,300; only they have changed hands. Bearing this in mind, and also that the declared value of imports into India is not the &lt;em&gt;laying down&lt;/em&gt; price, but the &lt;em&gt;market&lt;/em&gt;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-010" href="#sec-15-fn-010" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-010" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; price, which means the &lt;em&gt;laying down price plus&lt;/em&gt; 10 per cent. profit, it is necessary, for ascertaining the &lt;em&gt;real&lt;/em&gt; profits from the &lt;em&gt;foreign&lt;/em&gt; commerce of India, to deduct 10 per cent. from the declared value of imports (merchandize). Doing this the &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-305" data-page="305" data-folio="288" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n304_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 288"&gt;[p. 288]&lt;/button&gt; total imports from 1835 to 1872 should be taken at 943,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, minus 62,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;,&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-011" href="#sec-15-fn-011" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-011" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; which will be equal to 881,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; In that case the real deficit of imports under what the imports ought to have been (1,438,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;) will be 557,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; in place of the nearly 500,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; I have given in my paper.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The figure of the amount, after deducting opium and profits of commerce, will be 248,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; instead of nearly 200,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;; or the total transfer of wealth to England in addition to the railway interest (40,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;) will be 517,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, instead of 453,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; given in my paper, and the yearly average of every five years of this amount of 517,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; will be proportionately larger—about 13 per cent. The averages will be about—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-102"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-102 · FOLIO 305&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-102_p0305.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-102_p0305.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1835 to 1839&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;£6,000,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1840 to 1844&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;6,600,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1845 to 1849&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;8,700,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1850 to 1854&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;8,400,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1855 to 1859&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;8,700,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-15-fn-012" href="#sec-15-fn-012" data-fn-target="sec-15-fn-012" role="doc-noteref"&gt;†&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; 1860 to 1864&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;19,000,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1865 to 1869&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;27,500,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;1870 to 1872&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;31,000,000&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This average during the American War would be much increased if the whole profits on the exported produce of the time could be ascertained.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In preparing this reply I have had to work out all the figures hurriedly, but I hope they will be found correct.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I have not seen the late Administration Reports, but I trust they give fuller details than the previous ones with which I had to deal, and if so, more precise results could be obtained as to the actual annual production of the country, which is the most important point to be settled to give us an accurate knowledge of the actual poverty or otherwise of this country.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Since I wrote the above I purchased a copy of the latest Administration Report of Bengal (1874–5) in the hope of obtaining from it some more definite statistics about production than I have been able to embody &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-306" data-page="306" data-folio="289" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n305_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 289"&gt;[p. 289]&lt;/button&gt; in my paper. Great was my disappointment when I read Sir R. Temple&amp;rsquo;s statement: &amp;ldquo;Again, the survey embraced only the exterior bound- &amp;ldquo;aries of each village or parish, and afforded no details of cultiva- &amp;ldquo;tion and waste, culturable or unculturable.&amp;rdquo; The question at issue is a simple matter of facts and science. Is there so much cultivated land or not? is there so much produce or not? and are such and such the prices or not? And then common arithmetic gives you certain results. No amount of indirect reasoning or assumption can falsify facts and arithmetic, and make 2 and 2 equal 5. So far as the official statistics are imperfect, it is the duty of the Government to give to the public full details. We know the national production of other countries, and there is no reason why the Indian Government should not be able to give us similar important information. That would be the best and surest guide and test of the actual condition of the people of India, and our rulers would see from them their way clearly to the most proper and effectual remedies. I have not the least doubt in my mind that if the English Government once clearly see the evil, they will &lt;em&gt;not shrink&lt;/em&gt; from applying the proper remedies. My estimate of 40s. a-head has been accepted and argued upon by an Under-Secretary of State (Mr. G. Duff) and a Viceroy (Lord Mayo), and another Viceroy (Lord Lawrence) has told us that the mass of the people are half-fed. It is not the question of the ordinary proportion of the poor in every country. Mr. Grant Duff, in his reply to Mr. Lawson, asked whether the &amp;ldquo;already poor population of India&amp;rdquo; was to be ground down to the very &amp;ldquo;dust&amp;rdquo; by the removal of the opium duty. So the margin between the present condition of India and of being ground down &amp;ldquo;to the very &amp;ldquo;dust&amp;rdquo; is only the opium revenne. Is this prosperity? I have been lately reading the expression, &amp;ldquo;balance in favour of India.&amp;rdquo; The writers evidently suppose that what they call the balance of trade in favour of India was something that India had to receive some time or other. They do not seem to understand that of all the &lt;em&gt;deficit&lt;/em&gt; of import against the proceeds of export, not a single pie &lt;em&gt;in cash or goods&lt;/em&gt; is to be received by India; that, similarly, of all the &lt;em&gt;excess&lt;/em&gt; of imports in all the other parts of the British Empire to the extent of 15 to 25 per cent. over exports, or 18 per cent. in the United States, not a single farthing has to be paid to any country. It is, in fact, the profit of their exports and the deficit of India is so much transfer of its wealth to England.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-307"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="307" data-folio="290" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n306_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 290"&gt;[p. 290]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Mr. Dadabhai concluded by thanking the meeting for extending so much indulgence to him, and the many gentlemen who had come forward to join in the discussion. When they first met in that hall, their fear was that they would have none to oppose or to criticise the paper; but he was agreeably surprised to find that it had been criticised by so many, and he was sure that this would bring out the real truth, and he hoped that in future his critics would exert their influence to make India some thing like the United States. (“ Hear, hear,” and cheers.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;THE REMEDY.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;When I wrote these notes in 1873, or read them in 1876, I little dreamt that they would so soon obtain such terrible confirmation as the present deplorable famines have given them.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The chief cause of India’s poverty, misery, and all material evils, is the exhaustion of its previous wealth, the continuously increasing exhausting and weakening drain from its annual production by the very excessive expenditure on the European portion of all its services, and the burden of a large amount a year to be paid to &lt;em&gt;foreign&lt;/em&gt; countries for interest on the public debt, which is chiefly caused by the British rule.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The obvious remedy is to allow India to keep what it produces, and to help it as much as it lay in the power of the British nation to reduce her burden of the interest on the public debt; with a reasonable provision for the means absolutely necessary for the maintenance of the British rule.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;For this purpose it is necessary, on the one hand, to &lt;em&gt;limit within a certain amount&lt;/em&gt;, the total of &lt;em&gt;every&lt;/em&gt; kind of expenditure (pay, pensions and every possible kind of allowance), for the &lt;em&gt;European&lt;/em&gt; portion of &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; the services both in England and India, directly or indirectly connected with or under the control of Government (including, therefore, guaranteed railways or other works, manufactures, local funds, &amp;amp;c.); and to guarantee the public debt; and on the other hand, for the important political object of maintaining the British rule, to reserve by law for &lt;em&gt;Europeans alone&lt;/em&gt;, such places of power as may be absolutely necessary for the purpose with a fair proportion of the army, within the limited amount of expenditure for the European portion of all the services.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Under some judicious arrangement of the kind I propose, the people of India, being allowed to keep most of what they produced, will rise in material prosperity under, what is upon the whole, a good system of administration, blessing the hand that gave such prosperity, and &lt;em&gt;increasing &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-308" data-page="308" data-folio="291" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n307_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 291"&gt;[p. 291]&lt;/button&gt; the benefit to the English people also manifold&lt;/em&gt;, by the extensive commercial relations that must necessarily be then developed between England and India: and all fears of any danger to the British rule will be dispelled, both from the gratitude, loyalty, and &lt;em&gt;self-interest&lt;/em&gt; of the people of India, and from the possession of important posts of power and a fair portion of the army by Europeans alone. Then will Macaulay&amp;rsquo;s words be verified to the &lt;em&gt;glory of England&lt;/em&gt;, as also to her &lt;em&gt;benefit&lt;/em&gt;:—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“We shall never consent to administer the &lt;em&gt;pousta&lt;/em&gt; to a whole community, to stupefy andalyse a great people whom God has committed to our charge;” and we shall not “keep a hundred millions (two hundred millions), of men from being our customers, in order that they might continue to be our slaves.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;section class="apparatus-zone" aria-label="Footnotes"&gt;&lt;h2 class="apparatus-heading"&gt;Critical Apparatus &amp;amp; Notes&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;ol class="apparatus-list"&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-001" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-001" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Monthly Reports on the Commerce and Navigation of the United States, by the Chief of the Bureau of Statistics, for the year ending 30th June 1871, p. 386.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-002" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-002" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Monthly Reports on Commerce and Navigation of the United States, by Edward Young, Ph. D., Chief of the Bureau of Statistics, for the year ending 30th June 1874, p. 177.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-003" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-003" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Customs Act (6) of 1863, section 180, also inquiry at the Custom House, gave 10 per cent. to be added on the importer&amp;rsquo;s invoice, or 20 per cent. on the manufacturer&amp;rsquo;s invoice.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-004" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-004" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Annual Report of Commerce and Navigation, 1873, says (p. 3) : “Import “entries : sworn specie values at foreign places of export.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-005" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-005" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Monthly Reports for the year ending 30th June, 1874, p. 352: “The value “of the imports of merchandize, as presented in the first table, being those at the “ports of shipment, it will be proper to add thereto the amount of freights to the “several ports of the United States . . . it is believed that 6 per cent. on the total “value of imports is an estimate of approximate accuracy.”&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-006" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-006" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Excess of Imports &amp;hellip;$717,774,734, at 50d., for five years = £149,536,403 Average per annum $143,554,947, at 50d. = £29,907,280.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-007" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-007" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;‡.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;The italics are mine.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-008" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-008" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;For the following countries the profits, or excess of imports over exports, are as under, subject to modification for foreign debts or loans :— (&lt;em&gt;East India Association Journal&lt;/em&gt;, vol. ix., No. 4, page 263.)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-009" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-009" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;&lt;em&gt;East India Association Journal&lt;/em&gt;, vol. ix., No. 4, p. 264.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-010" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-010" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;See the first note at page 149.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-011" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-011" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;Imports—merchandize, 1834-5 to 1872, 618,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, 10 per cent. of which is nearly 62,000,000&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-15-fn-012" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-15-fn-012" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;†.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;I could not find the amount of enfaced paper given for every year before 1860. I have, therefore, taken the whole amount in 1860, which increases the average for 1860-64, and correspondingly diminishes the average of the previous years, but not to a large extent.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;/ol&gt;&lt;/section&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</description></item><item><title>I.—India's Interest in the Genenal Election (1886)</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/16-i-india-s-interest-in-the-genenal-election-1886/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/16-i-india-s-interest-in-the-genenal-election-1886/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-309"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="309" data-folio="292" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n308_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 292"&gt;[p. 292]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;SPEECHES AND ADDRESSES.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;CHAPTER IV.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;I.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;INDIA'S INTEREST IN THE GENERAL ELECTION (1886).&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;(Before a meeting of the members of the Bombay Presidency Assiocation, held in the rooms of the Association on Tuesday evening, the 29th September 1885. Mr. (now Sir) Dinsha Maneckji Petit in the chair.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji proposed :—"That the following candidates, on account of their services and opinions publicly expressed by them on Indian questions, are deserving of the support of the Indian people :—The Right Honourable Mr. John Bright, the Marquis of Hartington, Mr. J. Slagg, Sir J. Phear, Mr. L. Ghose, Mr. W. Digby, Mr. W. S. Blunt, Mr. S. Keay, Mr. S. Laing, Captain Verney, and Mr. W. C. Plowden. That the views regarding Indian questions publicly expressed by the following candidates cannot be approved by the people of India, and these candidates cannot be accepted as representing Indian interests :—Sir Richard Temple, Mr. J. M. Maclean, Mr. A. S. Ayrton, Sir Lewis Pelly, and Sir Roper Lethbridge." He said :—I speak to the motion which is placed in my hands with a deep sense of its importance. Hitherto it has been, and it will be so generally, that the English people can mostly derive their information about India from Anglo-Indians, official and non-official, but chiefly from the former. But there are Anglo-Indians and Anglo-Indians. Some, but their number is small, have used their eyes rightly, have looked beyond the narrow circle of their own office, have sympathised with the natives, and tried to understand them and to find out their true wants and aspirations. Unfortunately the larger number of Anglo-Indians do not take such wide views, or such interest in the natives as would enable them to judge rightly of the actual condition of India. Now when we consider of what extreme importance it is to us that the people of England should have correct information of our condition and wants ; how almost entirely we have to depend upon the people and Parliament of England to make those great reforms which alone can remove the serious evils from which we are suffering, it is no ordinary necessity for us that we should take some steps, by which we may inform the great British public, on which sources of information they could rely with any confidence. As &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-310" data-page="310" data-folio="293" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n309_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 293"&gt;[p. 293]&lt;/button&gt; I have said, the number of those who have the necessary true experience and interest in the natives is very small. It is extremely necessary that such should be pointed out by us. We also find that several Englishmen visiting India, as impartial observers, without any bias or prejudices, have often formed a more correct estimate of the position and necessities of India than many an Anglo-Indian of the so-called experience of twenty or thirty years. Even some, who have not been here at all, form fair and just estimates. It is not always that we can approach the British people in a way so as to secure the general attention of the whole nation at the same time. The present occasion of the new elections is one of those rare occasions in which we can appeal to the whole nation, and especially in a way most useful for our purpose. It is in Parliament that our chief battles have to be fought. The election of its members, especially those who profess to speak on Indian matters, requires our earnest attention, and we should point out clearly to the electors, which of those candidates who make India a plank in their credentials, have our confidence. We do not at all intend to influence the electors in any way in matters of their choice of the representatives that suit them best for their local politics. What we desire to impress upon them is, that so far as the important element of the deliberations on Indian questions is concerned, we desire to name those candidates who are deserving of our confidence and support, and on whom we can rely as would fairly and righteously represent our real wants and just rights before Parliament. It is with this object that I ask you to adopt the resolution before you. The first name in our resolution is the bright name of The Right Honourable Mr. John Bright. Now I do not certainly presume that I can say anything, or that our association can do anything that can in the least add to the high position Mr. Bright occupies. What I say, therefore, is not with any view that we give any support to him, but as an expression of our esteem and admiration, and of our gratitude for the warm and righteous interest he has evinced on our behalf. I would not certainly take up your time in telling you what he is and what he has done. His fame and name are familiar to the wide world. I may simply refer to a few matters concerning ourselves. Our great charter is the gracious Pro clamation of the Queen. That proclamation is the very test by which we test friends or foes; and it is Mr. Bright who first proposed and urged the duty and necessity of issuing such a proclamation, at a time when the heads of many were bewildered and lost, in his speech on the India Bill in 1858. I should not tarry long on the tempting subject, &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-311" data-page="311" data-folio="294" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n310_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 294"&gt;[p. 294]&lt;/button&gt; for if I went on quoting from Mr. Bright's speeches, to show what he has done more than a quarter of a century ago, asking for us what we have been only latterly beginning to give utterance to, I might detain you for hours. I must, however, give you a few short extracts, showing both the earnestness and the intense sense of justice of the man. "The people of India," he said, "have the highest and strongest claims upon you—claims which you cannot forget—claims which if you do not act upon, you may rely upon it that, if there be a judgment for nations—as I believe there is, as for individuals—our children in no distant generation must pay the penalty which we have purchased by neglecting our duty to the populations of India." In his speech of 1853, on the occasion of the renewal of the E. I. Company's charter, referring to the miserable condition of the masses of India, he said:—"I must say that it is my belief that if a country be found possessing a most fertile soil and capable of bearing every variety of production, and that notwithstanding, the people are in a state of extreme destitution and suffering, the chances are that there is some fundamental error in the government of that country." When, may I ask, will our rulers see this "fundamental error?" I have purposely confined myself to his older utterances so far, that we may fully appreciate the righteous advocacy at a time when our own voice was feeble and hardly heard at all. You will allow me to make one reference to his later words, and you will see how he is yet the same man and the same friend of India. In his "Public Letters," in a letter written by him last year to a gentleman at Calcutta, he says :—" It is to me a great mystery that England should be in the position she now is in relation to India. I hope it may be within the ordering of Providence that ultimately good may arise from it. I am convinced that this can only come from the most just Government which we are able to confer upon your countless millions, and it will always be a duty and a pleasure to me to help forward any measure that may tend to the well-being of your people." The Marquis of Hartington also occupies a position to which we can hardly add anything. But as we have during his State Secretaryship of India observed his disposition towards a due appreciation of and fulfilment of the noble principles of the proclamation, and his emphatic identifying himself with the righteous Ripon policy at a time of crucial trial—during the excitement of the Ilbert Bill—we cannot but take this opportunity of expressing our thanks and our confidence in him. To assure you the more fully of this duty upon us, you will permit me to read a few words on this very topic from his speech of 23rd August, 1883. After pointing &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-312" data-page="312" data-folio="295" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n311_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 295"&gt;[p. 295]&lt;/button&gt; out the insufficiency of the administration, and the inability of India to afford more for it, he said :—"If the country is to be better governed, that can only be done by the employment of the best and most intelligent of the natives in the service. There is a further reason, in my opinion, why this policy should be adopted, and that is, that it is not wise to educate the people of India, to introduce among them, your civilization and your progress and your literature, and at the same time to tell them, they shall never have any chance of taking any part or share in the administration of the affairs of their country except by their getting rid, in the first instance, of their European rulers." I cannot refrain myself from expressing my deep regret that we are not able to include in our present list a name that stands pre-eminently high as one of our best friends—I mean Mr. Fawcett. But I trust you will allow me to give a few short extracts, as a warning and a voice from the grave, of one who had the welfare of the poor and dumb millions at heart. Though he is dead his spirit may guide our other friends, and our rulers. I give these extracts as specially bearing on the present disastrous move of imposing a permanent additional annual burden of some two to three crores of rupees upon us, and on the whole Indian problem. With reference to the Afghan policy he said in 1879 :—" It cannot be too strongly insisted upon that in the existing financial condition of India, no peril can be more serious than the adoption of a policy, which, if it should lead to a large additional expenditure, would sooner or later necessitate an increase of taxation. . . The additional taxation which must be the inevitable accompaniment of increased expenditure will bring upon India the gravest perils." Again—"The question, however, as to the exact proportion in which the cost of pursuing a forward policy in Afghanistan should be borne by England and India respectively will have again to be considered anew, now that it has become necessary to renew hostilities in Afghanistan." These words apply with equal force to-day when we are threatened with a large unnecessary additional burden. On the subject of the whole Indian problem, he said:—"Although there is much in the present financial condition of India to cause the most serious apprehension, yet there is one circumstance connected with it which may fairly be regarded as a most hopeful omen for the future. Until quite lately, India was looked upon as an extremely wealthy country, and there was no project, however costly, that India was not supposed to be rich enough to pay for. Now, however, juster ideas of the resources of the country and of the condition of the people prevail. The recurrence of famines. . . . have at length led the &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-313" data-page="313" data-folio="296" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n312_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 296"&gt;[p. 296]&lt;/button&gt; English public to take firm hold of the fact that India is an extremely poor country, and that the great mass of her people are in such a state of impoverishment that the Government will have to contend with exceptional difficulties if it becomes necessary to procure increased revenue by additional taxation.” “Without an hour’s delay the fact should be recognised that India is not in a position to pay for various services at their present rate of remuneration. A most important saving might be effected by more largely employing natives in positions which are now filled by highly paid Europeans, and from such a change political as well as financial advantages would result.” “The entire system in which the Government of India is conducted must be changed. The illusion is only just beginning to pass away that India is an extremely wealthy country.” “The financial condition of India is one of such extreme peril that economy is not only desirable but is a matter of imperative necessity.” “No misfortune which could happen to India could be greater than having to make her people bear the burden of increased taxation.” “In order to restore the finances of India and prevent them drifting into hopeless embarrassment, it is absolutely essential that the policy of ‘rigid economy in every branch of the public service’ which has been recently announced by the Government should be carried out with promptitude and thoroughness.” This policy was announced by the Conservative Government, and now all this is forgotten and the Conservative Government are proposing to burden us with additional expenditure of two or three millions, or may be more! We cannot too strongly protest against this. In all the extracts I have read you will perceive the kind of policy which our friends have urged, and this test, or as I may shortly call, the Royal Proclamation policy, is the principal one by which we may discriminate friends from those who either from ignorance or narrow-minded selfishness advocate a different policy. Judging by this test, I may say that all the other names in the first part of the resolution are fairly entitled to our confidence and to an appeal from us to the constituencies to return them to Parliament as far as our interests are concerned. Their writings show that they have a good grasp of our position and wants. I may refer to Mr. Slagg’s views and efforts to abolish the India Council. Nothing can be more absurd than that in the nineteenth century and in England itself, the first home of public and free discussion upon all public matters, there should exist a body to deliberate secretly upon the destinies of a sixth of the human race! It is an utter anachronism. Mr. Slagg’s laudable and persistent efforts to get an inquiry into the Government of &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-314" data-page="314" data-folio="297" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n313_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 297"&gt;[p. 297]&lt;/button&gt; India promises to be successful. Messrs. Slagg, Digby, Keay, Blunt, and Verney's writings show that they understand us and have done us good service. About Mr. Lal Mohun Ghose I need not say more than that he is the only one through whom the Indians will now have a chance of speaking for themselves. I have every hope that he will do justice to himself, and fulfil the expectations which India has rested on him by honest and hard work for the welfare of his country. We must feel very thankful to the electors of Greenwich for giving him such welcome and sympathy as they have done. They have shown remarkable liberality, vindicated the English spirit of justice and philanthropy, have held out a hand to us of equal citizenship, and nobly confirmed the sincerity of the Royal Proclamation, by their action as a part of the English nation. Mr. Laing has, I am afraid, some incorrect notions about the balance of the trade of India, but we know that he understands India well and will continue to be useful in promoting our welfare. Sir John Phear and Mr. Plowden are known to us for their sympathies with us. Sir John Phear's book "The Aryan Village," shows much sympathetic study of the country and its institutions, and he proved our friend at the time of the Ilbert Bill. He said :—"We have a higher duty to India than to consult the prejudices of this kind of a few thousands of our own countrymen, who are there to-day, but may be gone to-morrow. We have to govern that vast empire in the interest of the millions who constitute the indigenous population of the country." Mr. Plowden says, with reference to Lord Ripon's policy :—"I know it to be just, I know it also to be honest and earnest, I believe it to be sound and thoroughly practical." I next come to our second list. As I have already said, we do not ask the constituencies not to return them if they are suitable to them on other grounds. We only ask that whatever weight the electors may give to their other qualifications, they would not take them as fair exponents or trustworthy interpreters of India's wants and just wishes, and as favouring us by electing them. With regard to Sir R. Temple I need say nothing more than that he endeavours to produce the wrong and mischievous impression upon the minds of the English people that India is prosperous and increasing in prosperity, in the teeth of the early and latest testimony of eminent men and in the teeth of facts. Mr. Fawcett told that the illusion was passing away, while Sir Richard keeps it up ! I do not advert to some of his acts in India, such as the strange contrast of 2 lbs. rations in Bengal and the disastrous 1 lb. ration famine policy here, probably to please higher authorities—his high-handedness, his treatment of the local funds, &amp;amp;c. &amp;amp;c. I confine myself to an &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-315" data-page="315" data-folio="298" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n314_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 298"&gt;[p. 298]&lt;/button&gt; utterance or two of his after leaving India. It is strange that a quarter of a century ago Mr. Richard Temple was able to take and express a remarkably intelligent view of the Indian problem. In connection with the Punjab he expounded the causes of Punjab's poverty and revival in his report of 1859 in these significant and clear words :—“ In former reports it was explained how the circumstance of so much money going out of the Punjab contributed to depress the agriculturist. The native regular army was Hindustani, to them was a large share of the Punjab revenue disbursed, of which a part only they spent on the spot and a part was remitted to their homes. Thus it was that year after year, lakhs and lakhs were drained from the Punjab, and enriched Oudh. But within the last year, the native army being Punjabee, all such sums have been paid to them, and have been spent at home. Again, many thousands of Punjabee soldiers are serving abroad. These men not only remit their savings, but also have sent quantities of prize property and plunder, the spoils of Hindustan, to their native villages. The effect of all this is already perceptible in an increase of agricultural capital, a freer circulation of money and a fresh impetus to cultivation.” Now, gentlemen, am I not justified in saying that it is strange that what Mr. Richard Temple of twenty-five years past saw so intelligently, about Punjab, Sir Richard Temple of the present day does not or would not see about India, whence, not merely “ lakhs and lakhs” but hundreds and hundreds of lakhs—thirty hundred or so lakhs are drained to England. He cannot, it appears, now grasp the problem of India as he did that of the Punjab. I cannot undertake to explain this phenomenon. What may be the reason or object? He alone can explain. As he is presently doing mischief by posing as a friend, I can only say “save us from such a friend.” We cannot but speak out, however unwillingly, that Sir Richard Temple is not a safe and correct guide for the people of England for India's wants and wishes. While Bright in '53, Lawrence in '64 and '73, Fawcett in '79, the &lt;em&gt;London Punch's&lt;/em&gt; grand cartoon of &lt;em&gt;Disillusion&lt;/em&gt; in '79 pourtraying the wretched Indian woman and children, with the shorn pagoda tree over their heads, begging alms of John Bull, Hunter in '80, Baring in '82, deplore the impoverishment of the masses of India, Sir Richard in a fine phrenzy talks in '85 “ of their homes becoming happier, their acres broader, their harvest richer.” “ India is prospering, that there is no lack of subsistence, no shrinkage of occupation, no discontent with the wages at home, and in consequence no searching for wages abroad.” And yet some light-hearted people coolly talk of sending him as a &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-316" data-page="316" data-folio="299" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n315_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 299"&gt;[p. 299]&lt;/button&gt; Viceroy here ! No greater misfortune could befal to India ! About Mr. Maclean I need not say much as you are all well aware, that he has been throughout his whole career in India a thorough partisan and an avowed and determined anti-native, with a few rare intervals of fairness. He can never be a fair and trustworthy interpreter of our views and wishes. He off-handedly says in his letter in the &lt;em&gt;Bombay Gazette&lt;/em&gt; of 9th June last : "Mr. Slagg recited the usual rubbish about the deplorable poverty and overtaxation of the Indian people." So you see, gentlemen, who Mr. Maclean is. He is a great man before whom the views of such persons as Bright, Fawcett, Lawrence, the &lt;em&gt;Punch&lt;/em&gt;, and Baring are all mere rubbish ! Mr. Ayrton's whole policy can be summed up in a few words—treat natives gently, but give them no posts of power or responsibility, have no legislative councils with non-official element, and if you have, put no natives in them. He says :—" The power of governing must remain, as it had hitherto been, solely and exclusively in the hands of British subjects going out of this country." " Why were we to teach the natives, what they had failed in discovering for themselves, that they would one day be a great nation." This un-English narrow-mindedness and purblindness is the worst thing that can happen to England and India both, and according to it all that the best and highest English statesmen, and even our Sovereign have promised and said about high duty, justice, policy, &amp;amp;c., must become so many empty words, hollow promises, and all sham and delusion. My personal relations with Sir L. Pelly at Baroda were, as you know, friendly, but the reason of his name appearing in this list, is that he was an instrument of Lord Lytton's Afghan policy, and that as far as his views may have coincided with the Lytton policy, he cannot fairly represent our views against that policy. About Sir Roper Lethbridge, I was under the impression that when he was Press Commissioner, he was regarded as one sympathising with the natives. But when the day of the crucial trial came, the Ilbert Bill and the Ripon policy, he was then found out that his views were anything but what would be just, fair and sympathising towards the natives of India. In addition to the names I have mentioned, I am required to mention Sir James Fergusson, and I cannot but agree to do so though with some reluctance. I have personally much respect for him, and I do not forget that he has done some good. In the matter of the native princes he enunciated a correct principle some eighteen years ago when he was Under-Secretary of State for India. Presiding at a meeting of the East India Association, 1867, he said :—" It is earnestly to be hoped that the princes of India look upon the engagements of the British &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-317" data-page="317" data-folio="300" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n316_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 300"&gt;[p. 300]&lt;/button&gt; Queen as irrevocable," and I believe he consistently carried out this principle when here with the princes of this Presidency. We cannot also forget that when acting upon his own instincts he did good in matters of education and social intercourse, and nominated to the Legislative Council our friends the Hon. Budroodeen and the Hon. Telang as representatives of the educated class, retaining also the Hon. Mandlik. You can easily conceive then my reluctance to speak against him, notwithstanding some mistakes and failures in his administration as Governor under official misguidance. But when I see that after his arrival in England he has made statements so incorrect and mischievous in results, in some matters most vital to India, it is incumbent upon us to say that he does not know the true state of India. Fancy, gentlemen, my regret and surprise when I read these words from the latest Governor of Bombay :—" At the present time her (India's) people were not heavily taxed, and it was a great mistake to suppose that they were." This is a matter of easy ascertainment, and the heaviness of taxation is repeated by acknowledged eminent men. Here are a few figures which will tell their own tale. The income of the United Kingdom may be roughly taken at £1,200,000,000 and its gross revenue about £87,000,000, giving a proportion of about 7½ per cent. of the income. Of British India the income is hardly £400,000,000 and its gross revenue about £70,000,000, giving 17½ per cent. of the income, and yet Sir James tells the English people that the people of India are not heavily taxed, though paying out of this wretched income, a gross revenue of more than double the proportion of what the people of the enormously rich England pay for their gross revenue. Contrast with Sir James's statement the picture which Mr. Fawcett gives in his paper in the &lt;em&gt;Nineteenth Century&lt;/em&gt;, of October, 1879 :—"If a comparison is made between the financial resources of England and India, it will be found almost impossible to convey an adequate idea of the poverty of the latter country * * an consequently it is found that taxation in India &lt;em&gt;has reached almost its extreme limits.&lt;/em&gt;" Again he says : "It is particularly worthy of remark that the Viceroy and Secretary of State now unreservedly accept the conclusion that the &lt;em&gt;limit of taxation has been reached in India&lt;/em&gt;, and that it has consequently become imperatively necessary that expenditure should be reduced." (The italics are mine.) Now, gentlemen, mark this particularly. When in 1879 the Conservative Viceroy and Secretary of State had, as Mr. Fawcett says, unreservedly accepted that the limit of taxation had been reached in India, the gross revenue was only £65,000,000, while the budgetted revenue of &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-318" data-page="318" data-folio="301" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n317_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 301"&gt;[p. 301]&lt;/button&gt; the present year is already £72,000,000, and we are now threatened by the same Government with an addition of £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 more permanently. This is terrible. Change the entire system as Mr. Fawcett says, substitute far the present destructive foreign agency, the constructive and conservative native agency, except for the highest posts of power, and you can have a hundred millions or two hundred millions with ease for purposes of government or taxation. This is the difference between Fawcett and Fergusson. Both are gentlemen, but the former speaks from careful hard study, the latter without it. Mischievous as such statements generally are, they are still more so when delivered before a Manchester audience, who unfortunately yet do not understand their own true interests, and the interests of the English workmen. They do not understand yet that their greatest interest is in increasing the ability of the Indians to buy their manufactures. That if India were able to buy a pound worth of their cotton manufactures per head per annum, that would give them a trade of £250,000,000 a year instead of the present poor imports into India of £25,000,000 of cotton yarn and manufactures from all foreign countries of the world. Sir James, I think, has made another statement that all offices in India are occupied by the natives except the highest. I am not able to put my hand just now upon the place where I read it. But if my impression be correct, I would not waste words and your time to animadvert upon such an extraordinary incorrect statement, so utterly contrary to notorious facts. Why, it is the head and front, the very soul of all our evils and grievances that the statement is not the fact or reality as it ought to be. This is the very thing which will put an end to all our troubles, and remedy all our evils of poverty and otherwise. Let Sir James bring it about, and he will be our greatest benefactor and England's best friend. In concluding, I may lay down a test for our appeal to the electors, that whichever candidates are not in accord with the Royal Proclamation, and with the lines of the Ripon policy, they are those whom we ask to be not regarded as trustworthy and fair interpreters of our views and wishes. The resolution has Mr. Blunt's name in the first list and Mr. Aryton's in the second. This will show that we are not actuated by a spirit of partisanship. Whoever are our real friends, be they Liberal or Conservative, we call them our friends. Differences of opinion in some details will no doubt occur between us and our friends, but we are desirous to support them, because the broad and important lines of policy, which India needs, such as those of the Proclamation and the Ripon policy, and the broad and important facts &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-319" data-page="319" data-folio="302" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n318_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 302"&gt;[p. 302]&lt;/button&gt; of our true condition, are well understood and adopted by those friends for their guidance in their work for the welfare of India. (Applause.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>I.—The Baroda Administration in 1874 (Reply to Parliamentary Blue Books)</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/17-i-the-baroda-administration-in-1874-reply-to-parliamentary-bl/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/17-i-the-baroda-administration-in-1874-reply-to-parliamentary-bl/</guid><description>&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-401"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="401" data-folio="382" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n400_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 382"&gt;[p. 382]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;CHAPTER V.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;I.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;THE BARODA ADMINISTRATION IN 1874.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;(A Statement in reply to Remarks in the Baroda Blue Book of 1875, concerning Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji and his Colleagues, submitted to the Secretary of State for India, to be published as a Blue Book, Bombay, November 25, 1875.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Blue Book&lt;/span&gt;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-17-fn-001" href="#sec-17-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-17-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;*&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;No.&lt;/span&gt; 1.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;On reading all the Numbers of the Baroda Blue Book of this year, I find the amount of misunderstanding, misrepresentation and falsehood regarding me and my colleagues as something awful. To attempt to explain or refute them all in detail would be like trying to cut down a swarm of mosquitos with a sword. Moreover it will be now an utterly unprofitable thing to enter into a minute examination of the details of every day work of administration, and for which, besides, I should have the Baroda Records before me. It will be sufficient for me to say, as it will be apparent hereafter, that from the very beginning, Colonel Phayre has taken a jaundiced view of my and my colleagues' motives and actions. I confine myself to an exposure of only the most glaring misrepresentations and falsehoods, leaving as to who is guilty of them, to be settled between Colonel Phayre and his "highly respectable" and "honorable" informers on whom he relied. It will also be for Colonel Phayre to say whether the various messages from and reports about him which I have given hereafter require any correction.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;</description></item><item><title>III.—Admission of Educated Natives into the Indian Civil Service (a memorandum on)</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/18-iii-admission-of-educated-natives-into-the-indian-civil-servi/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/18-iii-admission-of-educated-natives-into-the-indian-civil-servi/</guid><description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span id="page-509" class="sec-page-anchor" aria-hidden="true"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;CHAPTER VI.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;WRITINGS—(&lt;em&gt;continued&lt;/em&gt;).&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;III.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;ADMISSION OF EDUCATED NATIVES INTO THE INDIAN CIVIL SERVICE.&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(A Memorandum respectfully submitted for the consideration of Sir Stafford Northcote, May 2, 1868.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“There is only one other point included in the Bill which I must mention, and it is one of considerable importance and interest. I am sorry I do not see the member for Brighton in his place, who has given a notice with reference to the subject—it relates to the admission of the natives into the Civil Service of India. It was always felt by the old Court of Directors, by the Indian Council, by all the Home authorities, and, indeed, by the Indian authorities also, that it was most desirable, as far as possible, to make provision for the employment of the natives of India; but the difficulty has been in what way it could be accomplished. &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-510" data-page="510" data-folio="491" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n509_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 491"&gt;[p. 491]&lt;/button&gt; When the member for Brighton brings forward the motion for which he has given notice, that competitive examinations should be held in India, I shall feel it my duty to state the reasons why I cannot assent to that proposal. I do not think it would be at all suitable to the condition of India, that the Civil Service should be thrown open to anybody who can pass the best competitive examination among the natives of India; for, although I am a strong advocate for competitive examinations in this country, I do not think they apply to such a country as India, where you require, not the cleverest men, but various other qualifications, which you are not so well able to test by competitive examinations.—&lt;em&gt;Extract from Sir Stafford Northcote&amp;rsquo;s Speech in the House of Commons, 23rd April.&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It is said in the above extract :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“ It was always felt by the old Court of Directors, by the Indian Council, by all the Home Authorities, and, indeed, by the Indian Authorities also, that it was most desirable, as far as possible, to make provision for the employment of the natives of India; but the difficulty has been in what way it could be accomplished.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This comes rather strange, at this time of day, in the thirty-fifth year of a statute, and tenth year of a Royal Proclamation, as if proving that those suspicious natives, who regarded the statutory and Royal promises as never intended to be fulfilled, were in the right. Or otherwise, why should there have been any difficulty ? Parliament and our gracious Sovereign have declared that race or creed should make no difference between her Majesty&amp;rsquo;s subjects, and why should not, then, the natives of India have been, or be even now, allowed a door similar to that by which the English enter the service ?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Further :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“ For although I am a strong advocate for competitive examinations in this country, I do not think they apply to such a country as India, where you require, not the cleverest men, but various other qualifications, which you are not so well able to test by competitive examinations.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I do not suppose that Sir Stafford Northcote does not require cleverness as one of the necessary qualifications. And next, it does not appear how, if those “ various other qualifications ” cannot be tested by compe titive examination in the natives, they can be tested in the Englishmen.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;How is the cleverness to be tested ? Competition is the means adopted for the English candidates. Why should it not be for the &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-511" data-page="511" data-folio="492" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n510_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 492"&gt;[p. 492]&lt;/button&gt; natives? No doubt it is the opinion of some that competitive examinations are useless. Be the worth of that opinion what it may, you &lt;em&gt;have&lt;/em&gt; adopted the system, and till you abolish it, there is no reason why it should not be equally applicable to all candidates. However, be the test of cleverness that Sir Stafford Northcote may consider best what it may, it is necessary that, whatever that test may be, it should be clearly laid down, so that the natives may know what is required of them, endeavour to qualify themselves accordingly, and may get admission if so qualified.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-18-fn-001" href="#sec-18-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-18-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; Next comes the question of the “various other qualifications” which Sir Stafford says are necessary. These may be divided in two classes, personal and adventitious. Every one will admit that besides education and integrity, there must be also in the servant, tact, judgment, good temper, zeal, industry, and general administrative powers. I do not suppose that Sir Stafford requires that a candidate must first show that he is a Canning, a Lawrence, or an Elphinstone, before any opportunity is given him. About ability and integrity, I have given ample testimony to show that the educated natives, and even others (according to Sir F. Halliday and others) now in the public service, have generally proved themselves able and trustworthy. As to tact, judgment, &amp;amp;c., the very fact of the success and efficiency with which these servants have performed their duties, is sufficient to prove that these servants must have shown those other qualifications, or otherwise they could not have performed their duties with efficiency. How are these qualities tested in the English candidates? and why should there be any other method adopted for the natives of India, especially when they have shown, by actual service, so far as limited opportunity is afforded them that they possessed the “other qualifications” also. If it be said that out of those employed in the public service only few have shown any very &lt;em&gt;great&lt;/em&gt; administrative abilities, it is simply because they had &lt;em&gt;very&lt;/em&gt;, little opportunity. If they cannot rise above the deputy-collectorships, or assistant-commissionerships, how can they show whether any of them have &lt;em&gt;great&lt;/em&gt; abilities and qualifications? But even under every drawback, in the very narrow opportunity the natives have had, some &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-512" data-page="512" data-folio="493" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n511_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 493"&gt;[p. 493]&lt;/button&gt; “ capital administrators” have risen among them. We know what is thought of Sir Salar Jung, or Sir Dinkar Rao, or Sir Madava Rao by Government officials themselves.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Sir Richard Temple, in his letter on the Comparative Merits of British and Native Rule, says : “ Further, in justice to native rule, it should be said that within the century of our supremacy, there have not only been good sovereigns who are too well-known to require mention here, but also good ministers, &lt;em&gt;really capital administrators&lt;/em&gt;” (the italicising is mine), “ who have adorned the service to which they belong ; such as Purnea of Mysore, and Tantia Jogh of Indore, in the past, and Sir Salar Jung of Hyderabad, Sir Dinkar Rao of Gwalior, Sir T. Madava Rao of Travancore, in the present.”&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-18-fn-002" href="#sec-18-fn-002" data-fn-target="sec-18-fn-002" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; The latter have not merely been declared as able administrators, but have been for that reason considered deserving of being knighted by our sovereign.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It cannot be fairly urged that natives have not in them elements of success and greatness if they get the opportunity. It must also be re- • membered that, notwithstanding thousands of English civilians during the past century, the great names cannot be counted by scores ; and these were, of course, attained according to opportunity and ability of the individuals. More cannot be, and ought not to be, expected from the natives. If a certain method is adopted for the selection of the Englishman, there is no reason (except for some exceptional circumstances to which I shall refer hereafter,) that a different one should be adopted for the natives.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The adventitious qualifications are those of caste, or riches, or birth. I certainly do not wish to say a word against the proper respect and position due to these in state or society. But to say that for public service any of these is absolutely necessary, is not only unreasonable, but detrimental to the State. It may be said that Hindus of high caste may not respect those of lower castes in the service. Is it for the British to maintain and encourage such distinction and feeling ? or is it the mission of Britain (and to which several of the comparers of the &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-513" data-page="513" data-folio="494" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n512_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 494"&gt;[p. 494]&lt;/button&gt; British and native rule referred with pride) to teach the natives of India that before law the high and low are equal, and that merit, and not caste, will carry the day. However, be this as it may, is it a fact that the higher caste people will not respect power and merit in a person of the lower caste? Are the Gaikwar, and Scindia, and Holkar of high caste? Are there not several princes and nobles, and men high in public service, or wealthy, who are not of high caste; and are they for that reason treated with less respect than if they had been Brahmins or Kshutrees?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Again, among the Mahomedans there can be no such distinction and disinclination arising from ‘caste.’ In connexion with this question of caste, there is one exceptional circumstance, to which I shall refer hereafter.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The same remarks apply to riches. No doubt, when a man rises, whether from a low caste, or from poverty, there will be many found, quite as much in this country as in any other, who would first look down upon him with superciliousness, and call him an upstart; but when he is in power, or influence, and has stamped his character, we know how those very sneerers will turn round and admire the ‘self-made man.’ Is it for the English rulers to teach the people of India that riches are the passport to service and honour? I cannot persuade myself that Sir Stafford meant riches as a necessary qualification, that a young man may be a mediocre, or a dunce, and yet, if he is born with a silver spoon in his mouth, he is qualified to serve the State; while another, no matter whatever his personal qualifications may be, is to be cast aside because his father is a poor man, and maintains his family by honest industry. Riches shall always have its due influence and respect, but that it should be a necessary qualification for State service will, I dare say, be not seriously urged by any. Is birth, again, a necessary passport for respect by the people? As the present matter relates to India, I would draw my illustrations from that country. What birth could the late Sir Jamshedjee Jeejeebhoy boast of, and yet is there a man more universally respected and admired than he? Are not the natives of India proud of that name? Did the late Hon. Shumbhoonath, to whose high character and qualifications the Governor-General and the Chief Justice of Calcutta have borne high testimony— &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-514" data-page="514" data-folio="495" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n513_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 495"&gt;[p. 495]&lt;/button&gt; claim high birth? He was a &amp;quot; self-made man,&amp;quot; and yet we learn on the highest authority that he was respected by his countrymen.&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-18-fn-003" href="#sec-18-fn-003" data-fn-target="sec-18-fn-003" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In fact, it is only human nature, whether here or in India, that the man of merit, and in power, will command respect, be his origin humble or high, or rather the humbler origin will command the greater admiration. Mountstuart Elphinstone says, the first Nawab of Oude was a petty merchant, the ancestors of Holkar were goatherds, and those of Scindia slaves, the first Peshwa a village accountant.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Many other highly respected natives can be named who have not claims to high birth, or at most of a generation or two, and that under British auspices.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Are the natives so far an exception to human nature, that while a Disraeli becoming a Premier may be admired and praised, not only in the United Kingdom, but all over the world, more than if he had been born with a coronet on his head, the people of India would be so lost to a feeling of natural pride in similar cases, that they would be sorry to see any among themselves rise from the ranks? I am certainly the last person not to allow to birth its due. It has its advantages to the political and social condition of a country, which it is impossible to ignore. It is, therefore, highly desirable that this element should have its due strength and position in society. But it must not be forgotten that there is no family of birth but that it had an humble origin. When a family has once risen, it is capable of doing a great deal of good (if it has the will and ability), acting from a certain vantage-ground of position and influence, which the one which has yet to raise itself does not possess. But if free scope is not given to others, who have energy of character and nobility of soul and intellect, and thus fresh blood is not introduced from time to time, the aristocracy of a country may gradually sink. It will suffer the worst consequences of &amp;ldquo;caste,&amp;rdquo; as capacity and character are not the monopoly of the high-born. Every age, while proud of those that left their marks in former times, must leave, and very properly &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-515" data-page="515" data-folio="496" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n514_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 496"&gt;[p. 496]&lt;/button&gt; aspires to leave, its own mark also, and this mark of one Disraeli is worth a great deal more than that of other equally good and great men &lt;em&gt;born&lt;/em&gt; with power and influence. Such a result, however, can only be possible when there is a fair field for all. These remarks apply to India with special force, as I shall show hereafter, when treating of the few exceptional circumstances connected with the question of Indian Civil Service.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;At first, want of education and integrity was urged, and very justly too, as a bar to the service of the state. Committees of Parliament repeatedly questioned witnesses with regard to these necessary qualifications. And, up to the present time, it was considered that, if these qualifications could be proved to be possessed by the natives, their eligibility to high service in the State, and their right to similar treatment with Englishmen, would be complete. When, however, not only in abstract discussion or theory, but by actual facts of service rendered with efficiency and integrity, these qualifications are proved, &amp;ldquo;other qualifications&amp;rdquo; now come to light, to be necessary for the natives of India, as if those other qualifications were not as equally necessary for the English servants; as if those &amp;ldquo;other qualifications&amp;rdquo; were, in the case of the English candidates, proved by competition alone; and as if the test of these other qualifications in the Englishman will not be made as much in his actual service as in the case of the native.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It is proposed that the uncovenanted service be made native. Then the question naturally arises, do not these uncovenanted offices also require those &amp;ldquo;various other qualifications?&amp;rdquo; If they do, and if the natives can be supposed to possess them, so as to be fit for the uncovenanted service, on what grounds can they be debarred from competing for the covenanted service, and showing in actual service, as they would do in the uncovenanted service, that they possess the &amp;ldquo;various other qualifications&amp;rdquo; also?&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;There are, in the case of India, as I have said above, some exceptional circumstances, and it is, I fully admit, necessary to bear them in mind, and to make proper provision for them. These are political and religious.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;If India wants England to rule it for a long time, for its own regeneration and benefit, it stands to reason that the English service must be in the majority, and that certain places of high executive power should remain in their hands only. Let the English boldly and straightforwardly say that, for the interests of both countries, as they must be the predominant people, they must have the larger share in the service; and let them say that two-thirds or three-fourths of the service must be English; &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-516" data-page="516" data-folio="497" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n515_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 497"&gt;[p. 497]&lt;/button&gt; that, moreover, all positions of the highest executive power, such as Governors, Executive Councillors, and any such others, which must be distinctly described, must remain at the disposal of the Government, and, if necessary, for Englishmen only. Such a straightforward avowal, though it may, perhaps, prove a little distasteful to some natives, will at least command their respect and also the acquiescence of all reasonable natives. Both the rulers and the subjects will know clearly their position, and mutual satisfaction, contentment of the natives, and sure stability of the British rule will be the result.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The next special circumstance is that the survivors of the old power displaced by the British should be as far as practicable drawn into the service, and made to feel an interest in the British rule, or at least to be reconciled to their change of fate. For this purpose, it would be no doubt an important act of policy, to make some arrangements by which the scions of these old great families might be brought into the service. If it be contended that such scions would not condescend to stand competition with other people (whether it may be desirable or not, as far as possible, to encourage such a feeling), as such a feeling does exist, and will for a generation or two naturally exist; and as, at the same time, the exceptional circumstances of the case require that some concession be made to them, if these scions otherwise follow the advice of the rulers and qualify themselves for the service, let a portion of the one-third or one-fourth of the service that may be fixed upon to be native be reserved for such appointments, at the discretion of the Viceroy. But there is no reason whatever that, because some exceptional provision of this nature is required to be made for these scions, the just rights of the whole population should be kept in abeyance. There is another very important reason, both arising from policy as well as justice, that the rising educated generation should be enlisted in the cause of the British rule. The higher classes in general, and especially those who have lost power, have still kept themselves aloof from educating their sons, and are hardly quite reconciled to the loss of power and influence they have sustained. There is no blame to them in this state of affairs. They do not see quite yet what they have to do with &lt;em&gt;English&lt;/em&gt; learning, or what its character is. What they understand as learning is their Shastras or their Koran, and other Oriental literature, and this learning they are accustomed to leave to the Brahmin or Molvi. When they want the advice of learning, they can have it from these depositories. In such circumstances it is a puzzle to them, when they think about it at all, what English learning may be, and why they should &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-517" data-page="517" data-folio="498" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n516_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 498"&gt;[p. 498]&lt;/button&gt; want it. Moreover, the want of a career adds to their indifference. If some such plan as I have suggested before can be adopted, by which these scions can be drawn into English service, and made to feel their interest in its continuance, no doubt it will be a great advantage. I do not mean to cast the least suspicion on the probable loyalty or gratitude of the fallen great of the past, and admit fully the necessity of reconciling them to the revolution in their fortunes. It would not be, however, surprising if the good feeling towards the British rule ended with this reconciliation, and did not develop into thorough loyalty or deep gratitude. They may consider that the share given to them in the administration was their due, and an act of policy. Be this view right or wrong, at least. several of the comparers of the British and native rule have expressed in no encouraging terms, the present or possible feeling of these fallen great. Supposing, however, this view to be wrong, and as I sincerely hope and believe the native chiefs and noblemen, when they are once led to understand and feel an interest in the English rule, would prove loyal and grateful, a foreign government like the English in India cannot afford to depend upon this contingency only. This government also needs an aristocracy, a native power,—an influence of its own creation. It only stands to reason that those who would owe their rank, position, in short their all to the British Government, and who would strongly feel their interest in the preservation of the order of things in which they rose, would naturally be its best supporters, both from gratitude and interest. A power of no mean order is now rising in the State. Say what you will, the native press does, and will exercise its influence. It gradually passes into the hands of the educated, and the talent of the country. The feeling of loyalty in this body is at present undoubted. The sentiment that they owe their education and elevation as men to the British is very strong, and it is high time that, by reasonable concessions, they must be &lt;em&gt;enlisted&lt;/em&gt; in the English cause. They understand and appreciate the genius and spirit of the British rule most, and they are its best exponents at present. Enlist this rising power created by yourselves on your side, and, coupled with a bold system of public works for the prosperity of the mass, you may well defy any internal revolution or external invasion. The opening therefore of the competition in India, and making the native feel an equality with his English fellow-subjects, instead of the humiliation of a conquered people, and thereby making them sure of a proper share in the administration, has now become not only an act of justice, but of great state policy. It would be a great pity to let this power feel dissatisfactior &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-518" data-page="518" data-folio="499" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n517_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 499"&gt;[p. 499]&lt;/button&gt; and brood over its wrongs. It will afterwards be useless, when mischief arises, to charge the natives with ingratitude. You cannot destroy a power, whether physical or moral. You can only regulate it. If you stop a current, it will overflow its barriers. If you stop a moral force, it will as surely break through its barriers.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The third special circumstance to be considered with regard to India is the position of the people of some of the lowest castes, whom the higher castes do not touch even. Government has from a wise policy of toleration thought proper not to hurt the feelings of the natives, by compelling association of these people among them, so in all Government schools these people are not allowed admission. In missionary schools there is no such prohibition. The consequence is that some of them may offer themselves at the door of the examination room. Now, however unwilling Government may be to cast out any man for his caste, the same consideration which has induced it to exclude them from Government schools must prevail also for their exclusion from the service ; at least for some time, because this exclusion will not last long. On the one hand, the educated rising generations are gradually divesting themselves of such social bans ; and on the other, new influences, the rail and steam, are effectually breaking down these unfortunate distinctions.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Lastly, there is some provision necessary to be made for several meritorious persons already in the service. They cannot now enter the covenanted service by competition. If powers properly defined, so as not to be suffered to be a dead letter, be allowed to the Viceroy, these meritorious servants may also be admitted into the covenanted service, within the limit that may be allotted for the native service, in addition to promotions in the uncovenanted service. With the exception of the above-stated four exceptional circumstances, I do not know that there is any other to be specially provided for, and there is no reason that, beyond this, any difference should be made in the mode of admission of the English and native subjects of her Majesty into the covenanted service. The strangest part of the whole thing is, that on the one hand we are told that competition is not applicable to India, and, on the other, we have taunts thrown into our teeth by others, that we wish to escape competition, and to get into the service without passing the ordeal to which Englishmen submit. While competition is here declared to be inapplicable to India, the Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal finds it necessary to adopt it, to some extent, as a first step for the subordinate service.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;As Sir Stafford has not stated what the “other qualifications” are to which he alluded, I am obliged to work in the dark at present. I therefore &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-519" data-page="519" data-folio="500" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n518_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 500"&gt;[p. 500]&lt;/button&gt; earnestly request in simple fairness that no adverse decision be come to on Mr. Fawcett&amp;rsquo;s resolution, so that a fair opportunity be given to discuss the merits of Sir Stafford&amp;rsquo;s objections and provisions at the second reading of the bill.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The reply of Sir Stafford Northcote to the deputation which waited on him in August last, was an approval of our two prayers, and I hope that this approval may now be carried into effect.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;section class="apparatus-zone" aria-label="Footnotes"&gt;&lt;h2 class="apparatus-heading"&gt;Critical Apparatus &amp;amp; Notes&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;ol class="apparatus-list"&gt;&lt;li id="sec-18-fn-001" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-18-fn-001" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;It is sometimes said that intellectual education is not enough. Now it is a mistake to suppose that the education of the English schools and colleges of India is only intellectual. With the exception of not teaching the principal dogmas of Christianity, their education is as moral as can possibly be. The whole range of the English literature in which the native is educated is full of the high moral and religious tone of the nineteenth century. It is giving very scanty credit to this literature, and to the efforts of English educationists, that the result is not &lt;span class="unclear" title="Uncertain reading in source scan"&gt;p&lt;/span&gt;oductive of moral good, but thanks to both such is not the fact.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-18-fn-002" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-18-fn-002" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;In a note, Sir Richard Temple, with natural pride, says that both Sir Salar Jung and Sir T. Madava Rao owed to British training. Why, excepting some faults, both of omission and commission, it will be difficult to deny that almost all good that India now enjoys is owing to British rulers, or their presence, advice or example. The real question now to be studied from time to time is, how far does any native state approach the English standard, and how far the English rule in India approaches the English rule in England.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-18-fn-003" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-18-fn-003" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;The father of Baboo Dwarkanath Mittra, the present Judge of the Bengal High Court, was a clerk at Rs. 5 per month; Baboos K. M. Chatterjee and S. Sirkar, both occupying high positions in the service, began as cooks. Baboo Digumbur Mittra, lately a member of the Legislative Council of Bengal; Pundit Vydiasagur, late Principal of Sanscrit College; the present Principal of the same College; Molvi Abdool Lalif, lately a member of the Legislative Council of Bengal; Moonshi Ameer Ally, also a member of Council, and several other worthies of Calcutta, claim no high birth. The father of Mr. Maneckjee Cursetjee, the second Judge of the Small Cause Court of Bombay, was a &amp;ldquo;self-made man.&amp;rdquo; Messrs. Dosabhoy Framjee and Nana Morojee, Magistrates of Bombay, are highly respected.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;/ol&gt;&lt;/section&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</description></item><item><title>IV.—Indian Civil Service</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/19-iv-indian-civil-service/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/19-iv-indian-civil-service/</guid><description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span id="page-519" class="sec-page-anchor" aria-hidden="true"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;IV.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;THE INDIAN CIVIL SERVICE.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;strong&gt;Revised Memorandum on the most important Reforms needed by India.&lt;/strong&gt;&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;&lt;em&gt;(Submitted for the consideration of the late and present Viceroys, and some other high Officials in India in 1884.)&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The whole Indian problem in all its aspects, material, moral, industrial, educational, political, &amp;amp;c., will be solved only when means are adopted to check the annual disastrous drain of the produce of India and to bring it within reasonable and moderate limits. I have gone into the details of this subject in my papers on “ The Poverty of India,” and in the Correspondence with the Secretary of State for India on the “Condition of India.” I shall add here only one more testimony of the highest financial authority, the late Finance Minister, Sir E. Baring, on the extreme poverty of India, and corroborating my calculation of the very low income of this country as compared with the worst European country—Turkey. Here is this emphatic testimony in addition to the opinions given in my “Poverty of India,” Part I., especially of Lords Lawrence and Mayo, and of Mr. Grant Duff as Under Secretary of State for India, with regard to all India, at page 278. Sir E. Baring in his Budget speech of 18th March, 1882, says :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“ It has been calculated that the average income per head of population in India is &lt;em&gt;not more than rupees&lt;/em&gt; 27 &lt;em&gt;a year&lt;/em&gt;,&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-19-fn-001" href="#sec-19-fn-001" data-fn-target="sec-19-fn-001" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt; &lt;em&gt;and though I am not prepared to pledge myself to the absolute accuracy of a calculation of this sort, it is&lt;/em&gt; sufficiently accurate to justify the conclusion that the tax-paying community is &lt;em&gt;exceedingly poor&lt;/em&gt;. To derive any very large increase &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-520" data-page="520" data-folio="501" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n519_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 501"&gt;[p. 501]&lt;/button&gt; of revenue from so poor a population as this is obviously impossible, and if it were possible, would be unjustifiable.&amp;quot;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Again, in the discussion on the same Budget, he said, after repeating the above statement of rupees 27 per head per annum :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;“. . . But he thought it was quite sufficient to show the &lt;em&gt;extreme poverty&lt;/em&gt; of the mass of the people. In England the average income per head of population was £33 per head; in France it was £23; in Turkey, which was the poorest country in Europe, it was £4 per head. He would ask honourable members to think what rupees 27 per annum was to support a person, and then he would ask whether a few annas was nothing to such poor people.”&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This was stated in connection with salt duty. It must be remembered that rupees 27 (or my rupees 20) is the average income, including that of the richest, or all various disproportionate distribution that takes place among all grades of people, while the average of the lower classes only will be very poor indeed.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The whole problem of India is in a nutshell. &lt;em&gt;Never&lt;/em&gt; can a foreign rule be anything but a curse to any country, except so far as it approaches a native rule.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Hoping that my papers will be carefully studied, I confine myself here to the remedy of the evil in its practical form. I may explain here that a part of the drain I complain of is not to be laid &lt;em&gt;directly&lt;/em&gt; at the door of Government. It is in the hands of the natives to prevent it if they could and would. I mean the employment of non-official professional agency, such as barristers, solicitors, engineers, doctors, &amp;amp;c. Though not &lt;em&gt;directly&lt;/em&gt;, the English official agency &lt;em&gt;indirectly&lt;/em&gt; compels natives to employ such European non-official agency. English officials in power generally, and naturally, show more sympathy with and give greater encouragement to English professional men. The result is that the portion of the drain caused by the non-official Europeans is as mach, though indirectly, the result of Government or official action, as the other portion of the drain. The remedy, therefore, I am proposing, will influence the whole drain.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This remedy is in the power of the English Parliament only. It is (though at first sight it is not so readily apparent) the transference of examinations to India for services in all the civil departments—civil, medical, engineering, forest, telegraph, or any other. Canada, Australia, or the Cape, are not compelled to go to England for their services. Over India alone does England impose its despotic will in this one &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-521" data-page="521" data-folio="502" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n520_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 502"&gt;[p. 502]&lt;/button&gt; respect. This, in fact, is &lt;em&gt;the&lt;/em&gt; one important act of the British nation, which is now un-English and unjust, and which mars and nullifies all the other blessings (which are not few) conferred by it upon India. Let England be just to India and true to itself in this one respect, and honestly, according to the Queen’s proclamation, and declarations of British statesmen, and Acts of Parliament, let the natives have free scope to serve in their own country, and every other measure for the purposes of good government and administration, or for improving the material and moral condition of India, which at present generally fails or produces poor and doubtful results, will be crowned with success. Every matter will then fall into its natural groove, and the effect on everything will be marvellous. Private efforts will receive natural and immense impetus for providing all higher education, leaving Government to devote itself, with far ampler means than at present, to primary education as in England. So will railways and all public works and all private enterprise receive a rapid and successfu ldevelopment. And, above all, will be this most important result—that the growing prosperity of India will lead to a &lt;em&gt;truly great and extensive trade between England and India&lt;/em&gt;, far outweighing the present benefit to England at the sacrifice of and misery to India.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Of course when examinations for &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; the higher services in &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; the civil departments are transferred to India, the ruling and controlling offices should be mainly reserved for Englishmen, such as the Viceroy, the Governors and their Councillors, the Chief Secretaries, and Board of Revenue (if such boards be of any use) and chief heads of departments. Admission of any natives to any such appointments should be entirely in the gift of the Government, as a special reward for some high and exceptional services and deed of loyalty. In the military department, the English should have the chief share, leaving some fair scope for the warlike races, to draw and attach them to the side of the British rule. It will never do to repress all military ambition altogether. This will be a great mistake.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The subject of the confidence which our British rulers ought to show towards their subjects, and thereby beget and acquire the sincere confidence of the subjects in response, both by trusting them with reasonable military position, and by allowing and encouraging volunteering, under some well-considered principles and rules, is too important and extensive to be adequately treated in a short space. I can only say that it deserves our rulers’ serious consideration. The open want of confidence by the British rulers is a weakness to them, and cannot but in time lead to evil.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-522"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="522" data-folio="503" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n521_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 503"&gt;[p. 503]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;If the examinations, as a first step, are not altogether transferred to India, simultaneous examinations at least ought to be held in India for &lt;em&gt;all the services&lt;/em&gt;. This great reform and justice to India is absolutely necessary. This alone will be a fair fulfilment of the promises of the Act of 1833, of the gracious proclamation of 1858, and of the various declarations made from time to time by English statesmen and Governments. At least, for simultaneous examinations in India and England, the India Office itself has unequivocally admitted its justice and necessity. I give below an extract from a Report of a Committee of the India Council (consisting of Sir J. P. Willoughby, Sir Erskine Perry, Mr. Mangles, Mr. Arbuthnot, and Mr. Macnaghten) made to Sir C. Wood (Lord Halifax) on 20th January, 1860. The Report says :&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot; 2. We are in the first place unanimously of opinion that it is not only just, but expedient, that the natives of India shall be employed in the administration of India to as large an extent as possible, consistently with the maintenance of British supremacy, and have considered whether any increased facilities can be given in this direction.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot; 3. It is true that, even at present, no positive disqualification exists. By Act 3 and 4, Wm. IV., c. 85, s. 87, it is enacted &amp;rsquo;that no native of the said territories, nor any natural born subject of His Majesty resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company.&amp;rsquo; It is obvious, therefore, that when the competitive system was adopted, it could not have been intended to exclude natives of India from the Civil Service of India.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot; 4. Practically, however, they are excluded. The law declares them eligible, but the difficulties opposed to a native leaving India and residing in England for a time are so great, that as a general rule, it is almost impossible for a native successfully to compete at the periodical examinations held in England. Were this inequality removed, we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot; 5. Two modes have been suggested by which the object in view might be attained. The first is, by allotting a certain portion of the total number of appointments declared in each year to be competed for in India by natives, and by all other natural-born subjects of Her Majesty resident in India. The second is to hold, simultaneously, two examinations, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-523" data-page="523" data-folio="504" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n522_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 504"&gt;[p. 504]&lt;/button&gt; finally classified in one list, according to merit, by the Civil Service Commissioners. &lt;em&gt;The Committee have no hesitation in giving the preference to the second scheme as being the fairest and the most in accordance with the principles of a general competition for a common object.&lt;/em&gt;&amp;quot;&lt;sup class="fn-ref"&gt;&lt;a id="ref-sec-19-fn-002" href="#sec-19-fn-002" data-fn-target="sec-19-fn-002" role="doc-noteref"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/sup&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This principle ought to apply to &lt;em&gt;all&lt;/em&gt; the services.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now I say let Government lay down &lt;em&gt;any&lt;/em&gt; test—mental, moral and physical—and the natives cannot and would not object being on equal terms with the English candidates. It may also be arranged that every successful candidate in India be required to go to England and study for two years more with the successful candidates of England in their respective departments; or any other arrangement may be adopted by which the successful candidates of India may derive the benefit of two years&amp;rsquo; residence and study in England in the department in which they have competed successfully. India will be but too happy to have a portion of its revenue devoted to this purpose.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Till this most important, &amp;ldquo;just and expedient&amp;rdquo; and &amp;ldquo;fairest&amp;rdquo; measure is adopted, England can never free itself from the charge of &amp;ldquo;&lt;em&gt;keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope&lt;/em&gt;,&amp;rdquo; and India can never be satisfied that England is treating her justly and honestly.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;But I earnestly submit that this is not merely a question of &amp;ldquo;justice and expediency,&amp;rdquo; though that is enough in itself for this reform, but that it is absolutely necessary for the &lt;em&gt;far larger necessity&lt;/em&gt; of the material and moral prosperity of India—for the chief remedy of the present &amp;ldquo;&lt;em&gt;extreme poverty&lt;/em&gt;&amp;rdquo; of India—if English rule is really and honestly meant to be a just rule and a blessing to this country. My earnest desire and intense interest in this great reform to hold examinations in India, solely, or, at least, simultaneously, for all the services in the Civil Departments (with some fair scope in the military) do not arise simply from the motive of seeing an opening made for the gratification of the natural ambition of educated natives to serve in their own country, but more for the solution of the great question—the question of questions— whether India is to remain poor, disloyal, and cursing England, or to become prosperous, loyal, and blessing England.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Coming to the uncovenanted services, both higher and lower, they must also be reduced to some system of examination, based upon some clear and just principles. The system worked by the Civil Service Commissioners in England for subordinate servants for all the different &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-524" data-page="524" data-folio="505" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n523_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 505"&gt;[p. 505]&lt;/button&gt; departments of State may well provide a model for these examinations, according to the higher and lower wants of all the departments for their uncovenanted servants. It will be the best way to secure servants &lt;em&gt;most fitted&lt;/em&gt; and &lt;em&gt;best prepared&lt;/em&gt; for their respective departments, and to give to every subject of Her Majesty a free and fair scope and justice according to his merits, relieving Government from the obloquy that is often cast upon it for injustice or favouritism in its appointments.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Next to this great reform for examinations solely or simultaneously in India for all the covenanted services, and for all the uncovenanted in India alone, is the important question of introducing due representation and reform in the Legislative Councils in India. But I consider the first reform as of such &lt;em&gt;paramount importance&lt;/em&gt; that I do not mix up the second and some others with it here.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;DADABHAI NAOROJI.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;section class="apparatus-zone" aria-label="Footnotes"&gt;&lt;h2 class="apparatus-heading"&gt;Critical Apparatus &amp;amp; Notes&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;ol class="apparatus-list"&gt;&lt;li id="sec-19-fn-001" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-19-fn-001" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;I make not more than rupees 20. I requested Sir E. Baring to give me his calculations, either to correct mine or his, but I am sorry he declined. However this difference is a matter of not much consequence, as it makes but very little difference in proving the &lt;em&gt;extreme poverty&lt;/em&gt; of India. The italics are mine.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;li id="sec-19-fn-002" class="apparatus-item" role="doc-endnote"&gt;&lt;a class="fn-backlink" href="#ref-sec-19-fn-002" aria-label="Return to text"&gt;&lt;/em&gt;.&lt;/a&gt; &lt;span class="fn-body"&gt;The italics are mine.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/li&gt;&lt;/ol&gt;&lt;/section&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</description></item><item><title>V.—Indian Exchanges</title><link>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/20-v-indian-exchanges/</link><pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://akshara.ink/books/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/chapters/20-v-indian-exchanges/</guid><description>&lt;p&gt;&lt;span id="page-524" class="sec-page-anchor" aria-hidden="true"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;h2 class="sec-h1"&gt;V.&lt;/h2&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;INDIAN EXCHANGES.&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;1&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(&lt;em&gt;From the&lt;/em&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;Times&lt;/span&gt;, &lt;em&gt;9th September&lt;/em&gt; 1886.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Sir&lt;/span&gt;,—I hope you will kindly allow me to make a few observations upon Indian exchanges. I shall first describe the mode of operation of an export transaction from India. In order to trace the effect of the exchange only, I take all other circumstances to remain the same—&lt;em&gt;i.e.&lt;/em&gt;, any other circumstances, such as of supply and demand, &amp;amp;c., which affect prices.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I take an illustration in its simplest form. Suppose I lay out &lt;strong&gt;Rs. 10,000&lt;/strong&gt;, to export 100 bales of cotton, to England. I then calculate, taking exchange into consideration, what price in England will enable me to get back my &lt;strong&gt;Rs. 10,000&lt;/strong&gt;, together with a fair profit—say 10 per cent.—making altogether &lt;strong&gt;Rs. 11,000&lt;/strong&gt;. Suppose I take exchange at &lt;strong&gt;2s.&lt;/strong&gt; per rupee, and find that &lt;strong&gt;6d. per lb.&lt;/strong&gt; will bring back to me in remittance as much silver as would make up &lt;strong&gt;Rs. 11,000&lt;/strong&gt;, I then instruct my agent in England to sell with a limit of &lt;strong&gt;6d. per lb.&lt;/strong&gt;, and to remit the proceeds in silver, this being the simplest form of the transaction. The result of the transaction, if it turned out as intended, will be that the cotton sold at &lt;strong&gt;6d. per lb.&lt;/strong&gt; will bring back to me &lt;strong&gt;Rs. 11,000&lt;/strong&gt;, and the transaction will be completed.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-525"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="525" data-folio="506" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n524_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 506"&gt;[p. 506]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now, I take a transaction when exchange is 1s. 4d. instead of 2s. per rupee. I lay out Rs. 10,000 for 100 bales of cotton, all other circumstances remaining the same. I calculate that I can get back my Rs. 10,000, and 10 per cent. profit, or Rs. 11,000 altogether, if my cotton were sold at 4d. per lb. Then I instruct my agent for a limit of 4d., which being obtained, and silver being remitted to me at the reduced price, I get back my Rs. 11,000.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The impression of many persons seems to be that just as I received 6d. per pound when exchange was 2s. per rupee, I get 6d. also when exchange is only 1s. 4d. per rupee, and that, silver being so much lower, I actually get Rs. 16,500, instead of only Rs. 11,000. This, however, is not the actual state of the case, as I have explained above. When exchange is at 2s. per rupee and I get 6d. per lb. for my cotton, I do not get 6d. per lb. when exchange is only 1s. 4d. per rupee, but I get only 4d. per lb.; in either case the whole operation is that I laid out Rs. 10,000 and received back Rs. 11,000. When exchange is 2s. I get 6d. of gold; when exchange is 1s. 4d., I do not get 6d. of gold but 4d. of gold, making my return of silver, at the lower price, of the same amount in either case—viz. 11,000.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I explain the same phenomenon in another form, to show that such alone is the case and no other is possible. Supposing that, according to the impression of many, my cotton could be sold at 6d. per lb. when exchange is only 1s. 4d., that is to say, that I can receive Rs. 16,500 back for my lay-out of Rs. 10,000, why my neighbour would be only too glad to undersell me and be satisfied with 40 per cent. profit in place of my 50 per cent. profit, and another will be but too happy and satisfied with 20 per cent., and so on till, with the usual competition, the price will come down to the natural and usual level of profits.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;The fact is no merchant in his senses ever dreams that he would get the same price of 6d. per lb. irrespective of the exchange being either 2s. or 1s. 4d. Like freight, insurance, and other charges, he takes into consideration the rate of exchange, and settles at what price his cotton should be sold in order that he should get back his lay-out with the usual profit. This is what he expects, and he gains more or less according as the state of the market is affected by other causes, such as larger supply or demand, or further variation in exchange during the pendency of the transaction. &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-526" data-page="526" data-folio="507" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n525_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 507"&gt;[p. 507]&lt;/button&gt; Taking, therefore, all other circumstances to remain the same, and the exchange remaining the same during the period of the completion of the transaction, the effect of the difference in the exchange at any two different rates is that when exchange is lower you get so much less gold in proportion, so that in the completion of the transaction you get back in either case your cost and usual profit. In the cases I have supposed above, when exchange is 2s. and price is 6d. per lb., then when exchange is 1s. 4d. the price obtained or expected is 4d. per lb., in both cases there is the return of Rs. 11,000 against a cost of Rs. 10,000.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;I stop here, hoping that some one of your numerous readers will point out if I have made any mistake. It is very important in matters of such complicated nature as mercantile transactions that the first premises or fundamental facts be clearly laid down. If this is done, a correct conclusion will not be difficult to be arrived at, I have therefore confined myself to simple facts. If what I have said above is admitted, I shall next explain the operation of imports into India, and then consider in what way India is actually affected by the fall in exchange or in the value of silver.—Yours faithfully,&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;National Liberal Club, Sept. 2.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;DADABHAI NAOROJI.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;2&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(&lt;em&gt;From&lt;/em&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;The Times&lt;/span&gt;, &lt;em&gt;16th September&lt;/em&gt; 1886.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Sir&lt;/span&gt;,—In reply to “R. L.’s” letter in &lt;em&gt;The Times&lt;/em&gt; of yesterday, I may first explain that I made no reference to actual prices in the market, as such prices are the resultant of many influences—supply, demand, bulling and bearing speculations, present stocks and future prospects of supply, every day’s telegraphic news from all parts of the world, political complications, Bank rate of interest, and various other small and temporary influences. I therefore explain again that what I am considering at present is the effect of only the fall and rise in exchange, leaving all other circumstances that affect prices as uninfluenced or unaltered.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;“R. L.” says:—“As a matter of fact, when exchange was 2s. per rupee, the price of cotton was about 3d. per lb., and now, with the exchange at 1s. 5d., it is about 4d. per lb.” I do not find this to be a fact. Even were it fact it would not matter at all, as all other circumstances of supply, demand, &amp;amp;c., have to be taken into account therewith. But what “R. L.” states does not appear to be a fact. I shall confine myself to cotton, though I could give similar decline in other principal commodities.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="page-rail-marker" id="page-527"&gt;&lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger" data-page="527" data-folio="508" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n526_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect scan for page 508"&gt;[p. 508]&lt;/button&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Exchange began to decline about the time when Germany demonetised its silver, about 1873. The statistical abstract of the United Kingdom, 33rd number, gives the “average price” of raw cotton as follows:—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-block" id="tbl-138"&gt;&lt;div class="table-toolbar"&gt;&lt;span class="table-id-badge"&gt;TBL-138 · FOLIO 527&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="table-csv-links"&gt;&lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tables/tbl-138_p0527.csv" download&gt;Diplomatic CSV&lt;/a&gt; · &lt;a href="https://akshara.ink/downloads/essays-speeches-addresses-writings-naoroji-1887/datasets/tidy/tbl-138_p0527.tidy.csv" download&gt;Tidy CSV&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="ledger-table-wrap" role="region" aria-label="Statistical table" tabindex="0"&gt;&lt;table class="ledger-table"&gt;&lt;thead&gt;&lt;tr&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;—&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1873&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1874&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1875&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1876&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1877&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1878&lt;/th&gt;&lt;th scope="col"&gt;1879&lt;/th&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/thead&gt;&lt;tbody&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Per cwt. £&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;4·01&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;3·62&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;3·47&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;3·02&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·93&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·80&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·76&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-header"&gt;&lt;td&gt;—&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1880&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1881&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1882&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1883&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1884&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;1885&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;—&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;tr class="row-data"&gt;&lt;td&gt;Per cwt. £&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;..&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&amp;hellip;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·94&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·92&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·93&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·91&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·85&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td class="num"&gt;2·86&lt;/td&gt;&lt;td&gt;&lt;/td&gt;&lt;/tr&gt;&lt;/tbody&gt;&lt;/table&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;This shows a fall of nearly 30 per cent.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now Mr. Furrell&amp;rsquo;s letter. He is right in supposing that the ship per’s instructions mean not to sell below the limit. I have been a merchant and an agent in the city for some 25 years, and, knowing full well what my shipper meant, I sold at the best price I could get. He is also right in saying that the price is determined by the whole of the conditions affecting the market at the moment, and that is just the reason why, as I have said above, I did not refer to actual prices. So far we agree, but Mr. Furrell’s fallacy begins in this sentence:—“Other things being equal, the instant effect of a sudden fall in exchange is to increase the exporter’s margin of profit.” Here he first forgets the “whole of the conditions,” to which he referred in the previous paragraph, as determining the price at any moment, and next he forgets that the increase of the margin takes place in the case of those exporters only who have already entered into their transactions, and those transactions at the moment are uncompleted, so far as the remittances of the proceeds are concerned. But those exporters who have yet to begin their transactions, have no such increase in their margin of profit, as they have not yet had any transaction or margin of profit, pending or existing. I took the simplest instance of an exporter entering into a transaction at a particular rate of exchange, and described the process of the operation of that transaction from its initiation, as far as exchange alone was concerned, independent of “the whole of the conditions.” And then I further explained that any fluctuation in exchange during the pendency of the transaction was the exporter’s further chance of profit or loss.. But I may go further, and now explain that even in the case of transactions, already entered into, the fluctuations in exchange do not affect the exporter in the bulk of the trade. The bulk of the shipments from India are drawn against, and as soon as this is done, the exporter has no further interest at all in any subsequent fluctuations in exchange &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-528" data-page="528" data-folio="509" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n527_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 509"&gt;[p. 509]&lt;/button&gt; beyond his little margin above the amount of his bill, and thus it will be seen that in most cases there is no instant effect to increase the exporter&amp;rsquo;s margin of profit.—Yours faithfully,&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;National Liberal Club&lt;/span&gt;, Sept. 14.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Dadabhai Naoroji&lt;/span&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(&lt;em&gt;From the&lt;/em&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;Times&lt;/span&gt;, &lt;em&gt;27th September&lt;/em&gt; 1886.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Sir&lt;/span&gt;,—Mr. Furrell&amp;rsquo;s letter, published in &lt;em&gt;The Times&lt;/em&gt; of to-day, concludes :—&amp;ldquo;The fact is Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji and myself are in agreement except on one point, to which he makes no reference in the letter under reply. He contends that competition operates by reducing prices in England proportionally to the fall in exchange. I contend that competition operates by concurrently reducing prices in England and raising them in India.&amp;quot;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now what Mr. Furrell says in his first letter is this :—&amp;ldquo;Competition as your correspondent points out, immediately sets in to reduce profit to its normal level. But in what way is it that competition operates to produce this effect?&amp;rdquo; And then he answers himself by begging the whole question :—&amp;ldquo;Surely by inducing an increase of supply.&amp;rdquo; And he goes on, &amp;ldquo;Other things being equal&amp;rdquo; (though he does not allow among the &amp;ldquo;other things&amp;rdquo; supply to remain equal), &amp;ldquo;it is in virtue of such an increase of supply alone that the price of the cotton in London can be lowered.&amp;quot;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now, as an independent fact, an increase of supply may, no doubt, lower prices. But it is not in virtue of an increase of supply alone that prices can be lowered in London. What I am pointing out is, how the competition and the lower price are the direct result of lower exchange or higher value of gold only, without any increase of supply being at all induced or made, and any rise in price being caused in India. The fact simply is that, because gold is of higher value, cotton is sold at as much less gold as would suffice to bring back to the exporter his actual outlay and profit. Or, putting it in another way, the manufacturer of England may send his order direct to India to buy at the silver price there, and pay his gold for it at the rate of exchange, without a single ounce of additional supply or any increase in price in India being necessitated.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;What I mean, then, is simply this. To treat the subject in its simplest form, I take every other circumstance—&lt;em&gt;i.e.&lt;/em&gt;, supply, demand, &amp;amp;c.—to remain the same, and consider the effect of exchange only, and I show that from this simple cause—viz., the lower exchange only—if &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-529" data-page="529" data-folio="510" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n528_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 510"&gt;[p. 510]&lt;/button&gt; price be 6d. when exchange is 2s., the price will be 4d. when exchange is 1s. 4d., irrespective of or without causing any increase whatever in the supply or in the price in India.—Yours faithfully,&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;em&gt;National Liberal Club, Sept.&lt;/em&gt; 20.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Dadabhai Naoroji&lt;/span&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;4&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(&lt;em&gt;From the&lt;/em&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;Daily News&lt;/span&gt;, &lt;em&gt;24th September&lt;/em&gt; 1886.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Sir&lt;/span&gt;,—I now state the mode of operation of an import transaction into India. Taking all other circumstances to remain the same, suppose I am willing to lay out Rs. 10,000 for importing, say, 50 bales of grey shirtings—supposing that 2s. per rupee being the exchange—I find that I shall have to pay 6s. per piece in order that, at the market price in India, I should be able to realise Rs. 11,000 on the sale. Now, when exchange goes down to 1s. 4d., I see that, unless I am able to buy in England at 4s. a piece (instead of 6s.), either I cannot send the indent from India, or the market price must rise in India as much as I may have to pay more than 4s. in England. Under the ordinary operation of economic laws, it is not necessary that I should be obliged to pay more than 4s. per piece in England. Gold having appreciated here—in other words, prices of all commodities having proportionately fallen— the cost of production to the manufacturer will be so much &lt;em&gt;less&lt;/em&gt; gold. What cost him 6s. in gold before now costs him only 4s. in gold, and he is able to sell to me at 4s. for what he formerly charged 6s., the value of 4s. now being equal to that of the 6s. before, and I am able to sell at the same number of rupees now in India as I did before, when exchange was 2s. per rupee, and the price of the shirting was 6s. per piece. Sup pose in England the produce of a farm is worth 100&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, and that the land lord, the tenant, or farmer, and the labourers divided it equally, or 33⅓&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; each. Now suppose gold having risen, the same produce is worth only 75&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; The share of each should then be 25&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, which, at its higher value or purchasing power, is equal to the former 33⅓&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; But the landlord thinks he must still have his 33⅓&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;, and the wage-earners ask for the same quantity of gold as before, and a struggle arises. But whatever the struggle between them (into the merits of which I need not enter here) the produce fetches 75&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt; only (equal in value to the former 100&lt;em&gt;l.&lt;/em&gt;) The manufacturer thus gets his raw produce, whether home or foreign, at the depreciated price. The manufacturer also has his difficulty with the item of wages, which, if not proportionately reduced according to the rise in gold, prevents the cost of the manufactured article being fully reduced. But the market price of the article falls in accordance &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-530" data-page="530" data-folio="511" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n529_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 511"&gt;[p. 511]&lt;/button&gt; with the appreciation of gold, and the indentor from India gets what he wants at such reduced gold price. Articles produced in limited quantities or of reputed makers, or of some specialities, may and do command their own prices, and Indian importers may be, or are, obliged to pay some higher price for the same, but for the great bulk of the articles of trade the Indian importer has not to pay generally much more than he did before, except so far as any fluctuations in exchange during the course of the transaction may necessitate any higher or lower payment. All other circumstances remaining the same, the indentor from India pays more or less gold according to the state of the exchange, paying less gold when gold is high or exchange and silver low, or paying more gold when gold is low and exchange or silver high; the result being that the importer pays the same amount of silver whether exchange is low or high. He lays out his Rs. 10,000 and gets the goods in England at such varying prices in gold, according to exchange, as enable him to get Rs. 11,000 on sale in India.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;To sum up, for the bulk of the trade, other circumstances remaining the same, India does not get for her exports more silver for her produce, but less gold at lower exchange; and she does not pay for her imports more silver, but less gold at lower exchange. In actual operation the result of course is not quite so rigid. Various influences affect the course of the market. What I mean is, that taking the simple element of appreciation of gold and fall in silver or exchange, the course of trade is not much affected in prices in India. Were India concerned merely in the fall in exchange and nothing else, that would not have mattered much to her, beyond making the owners of gold so much richer in proportion to the fall in silver, as compared with gold, and introducing an additional element of the chances of profit or loss, in the fluctuations in the rate of exchange during the pendency of the transactions. But even in that case, the exporting merchant protects himself from this risk by selling his bills against his produce to the Indian Banks, whereby the rate of exchange for his transaction is fixed. The proceeds of his produce have to pay a certain sterling amount to the bank here. As far as the banks are concerned, they are dealers in money. For every bill that they buy in India in order to receive money in this country, they sell also in India a bill to pay in this country. The two operations are entered into at the same time at different rates of exchange, and the difference of the rate is their profit of the day, all selling and buying transactions covering each other. Those exporters who do not draw against their produce or shipment, and wait for returns from England, &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-531" data-page="531" data-folio="512" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n530_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 512"&gt;[p. 512]&lt;/button&gt; undertake the additional chance of loss or gain of the fluctuation of exchange, just as they take the chance of loss or gain from fluctuations in price from other causes. The importer of goods into India is not so well able to protect himself against the fluctuations of exchange when he cannot buy ready-made goods, and must wait for some time for the execution of his order by the manufacturer. But by telegraphic communications and by selling bills forward here, much protection is secured. Upon the whole, as I have said above, fall in exchange would not matter much to India if her trade alone were concerned. She can control her wants by taking more or less. But the direction in which India really suffers, and suffers disastrously, from the fall in exchange or silver is a different one. I shall state my views upon that subject in my next.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;National Liberal Club.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Yours faithfully,.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Dadabhai Naoroji.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;5&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;h4 class="sec-h3"&gt;(&lt;em&gt;From the&lt;/em&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;Daily News&lt;/span&gt;, &lt;em&gt;28th September&lt;/em&gt; 1886.)&lt;/h4&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Sir&lt;/span&gt;,—I would give a few details of the transactions of trade between England and India to make the effect of fluctuations in exchange a little clearer. Resuming the illustration of my first letter of Rs. 10,000 laid out for 100 bales of cotton, I first take the case in which the exporter does not draw against his shipment, but waits for remittance of proceeds of sale from England. Suppose he has based his transaction on an exchange of 1s. 4d. per rupee to sell at 4d. per lb. to get back his Rs. 11,000. Suppose before the cotton is sold exchange falls to 1s. 2d. This fall in exchange (all other things remaining the same) lowers the price to 3½d. per lb., and suppose the cotton is so sold. To the exporter this fall will make no difference, as though his cotton, sold at ½d. less, he gets the difference made up by the lower exchange of 2d., and thus gets the same amount of silver as he had calculated on. The same will be the result if exchange rose and price rose with it. Though he will get more gold from the rise in price, he will get as much less silver owing to the rise in exchange, the result being the original amount of silver. Suppose again that exchange falls or rises after the cotton is sold, but before the proceeds are converted into silver, by the purchase of silver or bill of exchange. In that case, if the exchange falls, it is so much profit to the exporter, as he will get more silver for the gold already secured by the sale when exchange was higher; and if exchange rises he loses, as he gets so much less silver at the higher exchange. Next I take the transaction in which the exporter draws against his cotton, so that he gets his silver back at once from &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-532" data-page="532" data-folio="513" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n531_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 513"&gt;[p. 513]&lt;/button&gt; the Bank that buys his draft at the exchange he has calculated on, and undertakes that the Bank shall have a fixed amount of gold paid to it in England out of the proceeds of the sale. In other words, the exporter converts his outlay from silver into gold—&lt;em&gt;i.e.&lt;/em&gt;, instead of Rs. 10,000 in silver, it is now fixed to a certain amount in gold to be paid to the Bank in England.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Now, suppose exchange falls before the cotton is sold. With the fall in exchange there is a corresponding fall in price, and the exporter realizes so much less gold. But as he has already engaged to pay a fixed amount of gold to the Bank on the basis of a higher exchange, he suffers as much loss as the proceeds are shorter than the amount of the draft. A fall in exchange in such a case is a loss and not a profit to the exporter. In that case it is the rise in exchange before produce is sold that is profitable to the exporter. Next, suppose that exchange rises or falls after the cotton is sold, that would not matter to the exporter at all, because he has not to receive any remittance, but the gold of the proceeds is to be given away to the Bank, excepting only such surplus or deficit that the proceeds may leave after the payment to the Bank. It will be seen from the above that in the two different kinds of operations,—viz., clear shipments and draft shipments, the results from the fluctuations of exchange are entirely the reverse of each other. In the second case, in which the shipment is drawn against, and which forms the bulk of the actual export transactions, a fall in exchange before the goods are sold is a loss, and not profit, to the shipper. In considering, therefore, the result of the fall in exchange, it is necessary to bear in mind whether the particular transaction is a free shipment, or a draft shipment, for in each case the result is quite different. And as the bulk of the export trade of India is of draft shipments, the result of a fall in exchange is a risk of loss, and not a chance of profit. The shipper who draws against his shipment does not desire a fall in exchange, but a rise, before his goods are sold; for such rise, by raising the price, will give him so much more gold to leave a balance in his favour after paying the Bank the amount of gold already contracted for and fixed by the draft. The surplus gold will go back to him as so much more profit than he had calculated upon. The general idea that a fall in exchange is somehow or other always a gain to the exporter of produce from India, is not correct. As shown above, in the case of shipments against which bills are drawn (and which is the case with most of the export business), a fall in exchange before the cotton is sold is actually adverse and a loss to the exporter. Once exchange becomes &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-533" data-page="533" data-folio="514" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n532_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 514"&gt;[p. 514]&lt;/button&gt; settled, subject only to the usual small trade fluctuations, it is no matter at all whether a rupee is 2s. or 1s. The price of produce will adapt itself to the relations of gold and silver, and the exporter will get back only his outlay and usual profit, whatever the exchange may be.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;In the case of imports into India, in a certain way the importer is able to be free from any risk of the fall in exchange. He telegraphs his order to his agent here to buy at a certain price at a certain exchange. The agent manages, if the market allows it, to buy at the limit, and sell a bill at the same time at the required exchange. If the goods are ready made, the agent sells his bill at once. If there is delay in the manufacturing of the goods, he sells the bill forward, so that when the goods are ready, the Bank engages to buy the bill at the stipulated rate of exchange, no matter whether the rate of the day is the same or more or less. As in the case of the exporter, it is also the same with the importer, that when exchange is normally settled, it does not matter to him whether it is 2s. or 1s. per rupee. The price and the trade adjust themselves, and settle down into a normal condition, according to the relation between gold and silver. As a further elucidation of the fact that fall in exchange brings down proportionally a fall in the price of the produce exported from India, I may mention that if the holders of cotton in England did not sell their cotton in accordance with the relation between gold and silver, or in other words according to exchange, the cotton manufacturers can send their orders to Bombay to buy there at the silver price, and then pay in gold according to the exchange, &lt;em&gt;i. e.&lt;/em&gt;, remit from England silver or bank bills according to the price of silver or rate of exchange. The manufacturers in England know every day what the prices are in India, and can, and often do, buy there by telegram as readily as in Liverpool or London. As this letter has already become long enough, I postpone the consideration of the actual and permanent injury to India caused by the fall from 2s. per rupee, to my next letter.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Yours faithfully,&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;National Liberal Club, Sept. 24.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Dadabhai Naoroji&lt;/span&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;h3 class="sec-h2"&gt;(&lt;em&gt;From the&lt;/em&gt; &lt;span class="sc"&gt;Daily News&lt;/span&gt;, &lt;em&gt;5th November&lt;/em&gt; 1886.)&lt;/h3&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Sir&lt;/span&gt;,—To understand fully how India is seriously injured by the fall in exchange below 2s. per rupee, it is necessary to bear a few facts in mind. Were it not for these facts, it would be, as I have already explained in my former letters, of no material consequence to the Indian trade, whether gold and silver settled down in the relation of 2s., or 1s., or 3s. per rupee. The peculiarity of the present position of India does not arise so much from economic as from political causes, and as long as &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-534" data-page="534" data-folio="515" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n533_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 515"&gt;[p. 515]&lt;/button&gt; these continue, no mere change in currency will avail. I cannot here enter into a discussion of these political causes. I confine myself to the facts as they exist at present. India has to remit about £14,000,000 in gold value every year, not as trade exports, but as a remittance for which there is very little return in the shape of any imports of merchandise or treasure, except for Government stores. This remittance has to be made through the channel of trade exports, and gives a false appearance to the extent of the true trade of India. When exchange is 2s. per rupee, India has to send produce worth 14 crores (140 millions) of rupees. When exchange falls to say 1s. 4d. per rupee, India has to send half as much more produce to make up for the fall. This result is disastrous to &lt;em&gt;British&lt;/em&gt; India. To realise fully the seriousness of the evil to &lt;em&gt;British&lt;/em&gt; Indian subjects, it is necessary to consider the nature and extent of their true trade exports. I take the exports of all India as 83 crores (830 millions) of rupees for last year. But of these exports a portion belong to the Native States. I take the figures roughly, as there are no official figures to be guided by. The population of the Natives States is about 22 per cent. of the whole population of India. At this percentage, and deducting 70 lacs of tribute which they pay to British India, their portion of the exports will be about 17 crores. The exports of the European producers in India of coffee, tea, &amp;amp;c., may be roughly put down at 10 crores. Some portion of the exports belongs to other parts of Asia, which I do not take into account. The remittances for home charges take up say about 21 crores; and private remittances of Europeans (official and non-official) may be roughly taken as 10 crores. A further portion of the exports is for getting back goods suitable for the consumption of Europeans only. This may be roughly taken as one crore. Deducting these various items from the exports of India, there remain only about 24 crores of rupees&amp;rsquo; worth, which are the true trade exports of British Indian subjects. Taking even 25 crores, to be quite on the safe side, there is hardly 2s. worth of exports per head per annum. With the above analyses of the exports of India, it is necessary to mention a few other facts. Lord Lawrence said in 1864 that the mass of the population enjoyed only a scanty subsistence. In 1873 he repeated this opiniion—that the mass of the people were &amp;ldquo;miserably poor.&amp;rdquo; The late Finance Minister (Sir E. Baring) and the present Minister (Sir A. Colvin) have similarly declared the tax-paying community as exceedingly poor.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;Bearing all these facts in mind, the present situation is this. The &amp;ldquo;miserably poor&amp;rdquo; people, in addition to having to remit produce worth &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-535" data-page="535" data-folio="516" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n534_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 516"&gt;[p. 516]&lt;/button&gt; 140 millions of rupees at 2s. per rupee for home charges, have to remit another 70 millions or so worth more to make up the fall in exchange, say at 1s. 4d. This to be done from &amp;ldquo;scanty subsistence&amp;rdquo; may well appal our British rulers, as disastrous to the people and dangerous to the rulers. No wonder, then, that the Government of India express anxiety and embarrassment in their letter of 2nd February last : &amp;ldquo;This state of affairs would be an evil of the greatest magnitude in any country in the world; in a country such as India, it is pregnant with danger.&amp;rdquo; But the Secretary of State for India probes the whole evil and points out its true cause in the following significant words. Till this cause is fairly faced and removed, there can be no hope for India. The letter of the Secretary of State for India to the Treasury, of 26th January last, says :—&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;blockquote&gt;&lt;p&gt;&amp;ldquo;The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of public revenue is very peculiar, not merely . . . but likewise &lt;em&gt;from the character of the government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices and form so large a part of the army.&lt;/em&gt; The impatience of taxation which would have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country, and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside the country, would constitute a political danger, the real magnitude of which, it is to be feared, is not at all appreciated by persons who have no knowledge of or concern in the government of India, but which those responsible for that government have long regarded as of the most serious order.&amp;rdquo; (The italics are mine.)&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/blockquote&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;It is a matter of great congratulation for India that there is now the declaration and confirmation of the highest authority that the root of all Indian difficulty is &amp;ldquo;the character of the government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices, and form so large a part of the army.&amp;rdquo; The first most vital question therefore to be faced by the Government and the Silver Commission is this &amp;ldquo;peculiar position&amp;rdquo; of India. When this difficulty or evil is removed, fall in silver would not be of any consequence beyond the ordinary risks of international trade, and the whole Indian difficulty will disappear, with benefit and blessing both to England and India. Some Anglo-Indians urge that they should be paid on the basis of 2s. per rupee. I sympathise with them for any loss that is caused to them. But if rightly considered, though in their remittances they get less gold, that gold is of higher purchasing power. Excepting for any fixed liabilities in gold, there is no loss to them. If a contract is made, it should &lt;button type="button" class="folio-trigger folio-turn" id="page-536" data-page="536" data-folio="517" data-scan="https://archive.org/download/essaysspeechesa00paregoog/page/n535_w1400.jpg" aria-label="Inspect original scan for page 517"&gt;[p. 517]&lt;/button&gt; no doubt be faithfully performed. But this is a simple fact that every Englishman going to India knows very well, that the services are paid in rupees, no matter whether the rupee is 2s., or more or less; that he has never declined to receive the rupee when it was &lt;em&gt;above&lt;/em&gt; 2s.; and that if by some new discovery the rupee became worth 2s. 6d. or 3s., he will still receive and insist on receiving his rupee. In all cases, therefore, in which pay or pension has been hitherto always paid in rupees, it is idle and unjust now to claim to be paid in gold or at 2s. In addition to this equitable side of the question, there is the moral one that the “miserably poor” people cannot bear the additional burden. These gentlemen can afford to lose something, even if they did really lose so; but to the wretched British Indian taxpayers it will be sheer cruelty. If these gentlemen would ponder over the words of the Secretary of State, they would see that at bottom (though no blame to them, but to “the character of the government”) they themselves are the cause of the Indian troubles.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;To sum up—1. Fall or rise in exchange does not matter much in international trade, beyond introducing one more element of chances of profit or loss during the currency of any transaction. 2. When the relation of gold and silver is settled, subject only to the ordinary fluctuations of trade, it will be of no consequence whether a rupee is 2s., or 1s., or 3s. 3. Any other silver-using country which is not peculiarly politically situated like India by “the character of its government,” will not be affected by any evil similar to that of British India by the fall in silver. 4. The real and lasting remedy for all British India&amp;rsquo;s evils does not lie in any artificial devices or manipulation of the currency, but in removing the true causes to a proper extent, and then no question either of “extreme poverty” or troubles from fall in silver, or any evil or fear of political dangers of any magnitude to the British rule will ever arise, but both England and India will be benefited and blessed.—I am, &amp;amp;c.,&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;&lt;span class="sc"&gt;Dadabhai Naoroji&lt;/span&gt;.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;div class="prose-unit"&gt;&lt;p class="prose-p"&gt;National Liberal Club, Nov. 3rd.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;/div&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</description></item></channel></rss>