The first deliberate and practical action was taken by Parliament in the year 1833.
All aspects of the question were then fully discussed by eminent men. And a Committee of the House made searching inquiry into the whole subject. I cannot here introduce the whole debate, but make a few extracts, and give in the appendix the speeches of the Marquis of Lansdown, Lord Ellenborough, Mr Macaulay, Mr. Wynn, Mr. Charles Grant and the Duke of Wellington at some length, as they are of some of the most eminent men who have discussed the question from opposite sides and reviewed all the bearings.
1830.—Mr. Peel, after expatiating on the vastness and variety of the subject, said:—“ sure I am at least that we must approach the consideration of it with a deep feeling, with a strong sense of the responsbility we shall incur, with a strong sense of the moral obligation which imposes it upon us as a duty to promote the improvement of the country and the welfare and well-being of its inhabitants so far as we can consistently with the safety and security of our dominion and the obligations by which we may be bound." * * * “in a word, to endeavour, while we still keep them under British rule, to atone to them for the sufferings they endured, and the wrongs to which they were exposed in being reduced to that rule; and to afford them such advantages and confer on them such benefits as may, in some degree, console them for the loss of their independence (hear). These, Sir, are considerations which, whatever may be the anxiety to extend British conquest and to maintain the rights of British subjects, must indisputably be entertained in a British Parliament."
Mr. Wynn said :—“How can we expect that the Hindu population will be good subjects unless we hold out to them inducenents to become so? If superior acquirements cannot open the road to distinction, how can you expect individuals to take the trouble of attaining them? When attained, they can answer no other purpose than that of showing their possessor the fallen condition of the caste to which he belongs. This is true of man in all countries. Let our own native Britain be subjugated by a foreign force, let the natives of it be excluded from all offices of trust and emolument, and then all their knowledge and all their literature, both foreign and domestic, will not save them from being in a few generations a low minded, deceitful and dishonest race."
Sir J. Macintosh.—“He had heard much, too, of the natural inferiority of particular races, that there was one race born to command and another to obey, but this he regarded as the commonplace argument of the advocates of oppression, and he knew there was no foundation for it in any part of India. This, he declared, he spoke upon due consideration, because he had observed boys of all races in places of public education. He had observed the clerks in counting houses, and even in the Government offices, for some were admitted to the subordinate situations and thus allowed to sit in contact, as it were, with all the objects of their ambition, though they were only tantalized by the vicinity of that which they could never attain."
“That he was convinced that the more the Hindus came into contact with English gentlemen the more they would improve in morality and knowledge. In this view he cordially concurred, and that improvement would be promoted by nothing so much as by abolishing all political and civil distinctions between the different castes. He, therefore, was ready to give the petition ( of the Indo-Britons ) his warmest support.”
Sir C. Forbes.—“He had been seventeen years in this country, after having been twenty-two years in India ; the more he saw of the Old Country, the better he liked the Natives.”
1833.—Mr. Buckingham:—“Above all, however, he approved of that great admission in the Bill which recognised for the first time the political rights of the Native population, which opened the door for their admission into office, and which, by elevating them in their own dignity, would enable them the better to elevate their children, and these again their future offspring, until every succeeding generation should have greater and greater cause to bless the hour when the first step was taken towards their political advancement, and gradual but certain emancipation from the treble yoke of foreign subjugation, fiscal oppression, and degrading superstition.”
Mr. Hume:—“If it was desired to make the Natives attached to the Government of this country, there ought to be a provision for allowing them to sit in the Councils of India. There ought at least to be one Native in each of those Councils.”
Mr. Stewart Mackenzie :—“That much had already been done, by internal regulations in India, to fit the Natives for the enjoyment of those privileges which the Honorable Member for Middlesex was anxious to see too suddenly communicated to them.”
Mr. Frederick G. Howard “enforced the fitness of employing Natives in different situations, not only on the grounds of economy and efficiency, but because it would tend to conciliate and to give a motive to others to qualify themselves for such posts.”
Now after an exhaustive debate in Parliament, and an exhaustive inquiry before the Parliamentary Committee, we see that Parliament in both Houses adopted the following enactment without any equivocation or reservation in definite and noble terms. They deliberately enacted our first great Charter:—
“That no Native of the said territories nor any natural-born subject of His Majesty resident therein shall by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, color or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company."
It should be remarked that, as it should be under the fundamental principle of the British rule—justice to all equally—the clause makes no distinction whatever between any classes or communities of Natives, Europeans or Eurasians. Next it should be remarked, and what is of great importance, that this great Charter is a spontaneous act of our British rulers. Macaulay says “gratitude is not to be expected by rulers who give to fear what they have refused to justice.” But this Charter is not wrested by the Natives on the field of battle, or at the point of the sword ; there was no heavy pressure from Natives, no important Native voice by way of agitation either in the debate or in the Committee, to influence the decision ; it was the deliberate, calm, well and fully discussed act and decision of a great people and Parliament. It is done with grace, and the glory is all their own. It is their love of fair play and justice, it is their deep sense of the mission which God has placed on them to lead and advance the civilization and prosperity of mankind, it is their instinct of freedom and their desire that, “free and civilised as they were, it was to little purpose if they grudged to any portion of the human race an equal portion of freedom and civilization,” which have impelled them to grant with grace this first Charter to us, which redounds to their everlasting credit as the greatest and best of foreign rulers. If ever a people can be reconciled to, satisfied with, and be loyal to the heart to a foreign rule, it can be only by such noble principles and deeds. Otherwise, foreign rule cannot be beneficial, but a curse.
Twenty years passed and the revision of the Company’s Charter again came before Parliament in 1853; and if anything was more insisted on and bewailed than another, it was the neglect of the authorities to give effect to the Act of 1833. The principles of 1833 were more emphatically insisted on. I would just give a few extracts from the speeches of some of the most eminent statesmen.
Lord Monteagle, after referring to some progress made by Lord W. Bentinck in the “uncovenanted offices,” says:—“Yet notwithstanding his authority, notwithstanding likewise the result of the experiment tried, and the spirit of the clause he had cited (that of 1833) there had been a practical exclusion of them (Natives) from all ‘covenanted services,’ as they were called, from the passing of the last Charter up to the resent time."
“Mr. Bright.—Another subject requiring close attention on the part of Parliament was the employment of the Natives of India in the service of the Government. The Right Hon. Member for Edinburgh (Mr. Macaulay), in proposing the India Bill of 1833, had dwelt on one of its clauses, which provided that neither colour, nor caste, nor religion, nor place of birth, should be a bar to the employment of persons by the Government; whereas, as matter of fact from that time to this, no person in India had been so employed, who might not to have been equally employed before that clause was enacted;” Mr. Bright quotes Mr. Cameron—“fourth member of Council in India, President of the Indian Law Commission, and of the Council of Education for Bengal”:—
“He (Mr. Cameron) said—‘The Statute of 1833 made the natives of India eligible to all offices under the Company. But during the twenty years that have since elapsed, not one of the Natives has been appointed to any office except such as they were eligible to before the Statute.’”
Viscount Jocelyn says :—“When Sir George Clerk, whose knowledge of the natives of India was, perhaps, greater than that of any other man, and who was in favour of giving employment to the Native population, was asked what was the grade in the service which he would propose should be assigned to the Native population, he said that, perhaps, in the courss of ten years they might look forward to being appointed to the office of Collector.”
Lord Stanley—“He could not refrain from expressing his conviction that, in refusing to carry on examinations in India as well as in England—a thing that was easily practicable—the Government were, in fact, negativing that which they declared to be one of the principal objects of their Bill, and confining the Civil Service, as heretofore, to Englishmen. That result was unjust, and he believed it would be most pernicious.” This was said in reference to continuing Haileybury College without providing a similar arrangement in India.
Lord Stanley.—“Let them suppose, for instance, that instead of holding those examinations here in London, that they were to be held in Calcutta. Well, how many Englishmen would go out there—or how many would send out their sons, perhaps, to spend two or three years in the country on the chance of obtaining an appointment! Nevertheless, that was exactly the course proposed to be adopted towards the natives of India.”
Earl Granville.—“ I, for one, speaking individually, have never felt the slightest alarm at Natives, well qualified and fitted for public employments, being employed in any branch of the public service of India.”
It is not necessary for me to go into any more extracts. I come now to the greater and more complete Charter of all our political rights and national wants, I mean that great and gracious Proclamation of our Sovereign, of 1858.
I quote here the clauses which refer to the present subject :—
“ We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects, and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil.”
“ And it is our further will that, so far as may be, our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified, by their education, ability and integrity, duly to discharge.”
“ In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward. And may the God of all Power grant to us, and to those in authority under us, strength to carry out these our wishes for the good of our people.”
Glorious as was the manner of the Charter granted to us by the Act of 1833, far more glorious still and magnanimous is the issue of the Proclamation. It was not that the Empire was on the brink of being destroyed, or that the fear of a successful Mutiny compelled the rulers to yield to any dictation,—no, it was at the moment of complete triumph over a great disaster. It was, as true to justice and humanity and to noble English instincts, that the nation held out this gracious Proclamation, and thus ten times enhanced its value.
What more can we want? When this glad message was proclaimed to India in the midst of the rejoicings of the hundreds of millions amidst illuminations and fireworks and the roar of cannons what were the feelings of the people? It was said over and over again : “ Let this proclamation be faithfully and conscientiously observed, and England would not need one English soldier to maintain her rule and supremacy in India. Our gratitude and contentment will be her greatest strength.” Since the Act of 1833, more than half a century has elapsed, and since even the glorious Proclamation, more than a quarter of a century has elapsed. Intellectual, moral, physical progress has gone on steadily under the blessed educational work of our rulers. Whatever may have been the justification or otherwise for the non-fulfilment of the solemn and public promises in the past, there is now no excuse to delay a faithful, honest and complete fulfilment of those promises, which in reality are our birthrights from the very circumstance of our having become British subjects—and that we are not British slaves.
As far as these promises have been neglected, so far has there been failure in the financial and economic prosperity of India and in the satisfaction of the people. Inasmuch as these promises have, even though grudgingly and partially, been carried out, so far the hopeful conviction of the people is maintained that justice will at last be done and that the good day is coming. That good day has at last come Let us loyally, respectfully and clearly ask for what we need and claim, and what has been promised us, as well as our birthright as British subjects.
The question of the loyal ty of the Natives, and especially of that of the educated classes, is now no longer a doubtful one. Our rulers are perfectly satisfied that the educated are for English Rule, that the very idea of the subversion of the British Rule is abhorrent to them. I need but give you only one testimony, the latest, clear and decisive, from our highest authorities in India.
Government of India’s letter to the Secretary of State, 8th June 1880, in reply to Mr. Caird’s minute, Parl. ret. [c. 2732] 1880 :
“To the minds of at least the educated among the people of India— and the number is rapidly increasing—any idea of the subversion of the British Power is abhorrent, from the consciousness that it must result in the wildest anarchy and confusion."
Our British rulers have rightly appreciated the true feelings of the Indian people generally, and of the educated particularly, in their above statement. It is simple truth. In 1833 the question of our capabilities and character was as yet somewhat open, our progress in education small, our feelings towards the British rule doubtful. Half a century has passed—our capacity, our loyalty, our progress in education and the integrity of the educated have stood the trial and are now undoubted. We have had 54 years of neglect, or a grudging partial fulfilment of the noble principles and promise of 1833. Let us have now a 50 years of a fair hearty trial of the promise. As long as such a fair trial is not allowed, it is idle and unjust and adding insult to injury to decide anything against us. The trial and responsibilities of office will and can alone further develop our capabilities. Let the standards of test, mental, moral or physical, be what they like, as along as they are the same for all—Natives and Englishmen,—all we ask is “fair field and no favour,” an honest fulfilment of the Act of 1833 and of the Proclamation of 1858.
If this is done, I have no hesitation in saying that India will improve financially, economically, commercially, educationally, industrially and in every way, with amazing rapidity, and will bring manifold benefits and blessings to England also. And last, though not least, India’s loyalty will be firmly rivetted to British rule for the best of all reasons—self-interest as well as gratitude.
This great, or rather the greatest Indian question,—of the Services,— has now come to a crisis. A Commission is appointed to consider it. And, says the Resolution appointing that Commission, that the Secretary of State for India intends that :—
“In regard to its object, the Commission would, broadly speaking, be required to devise a scheme which may reasonably be hoped to possess the necessary elements of finality, and to do full justice to the claims of natives of India to higher and more extensive employment in the public service.” The Natives have therefore well to realise the seriousness of the present crisis. Whatever is settled now will have to last, for weal or for woe, perhaps another half a century. This finality “and full justice” will be always opposed to any further demands or representations from us. It is practically good and essential for Government itself, that there should be some reasonable elements of finality, for the continuation and development of dissatisfaction is not only injurious to the current administration of the country, but most probably, productive of serious difficulties and troubles in the future.
Now is the time for the Natives to give their most serious consideration to the matter, to speak out freely and loyally and firmly, to represent to our rulers what ought to be done.
We must remember that Government does not ask us for a compromise. It distinctly offers reasonable finality and full justice to our claims. Our business is to ask, what we should have as full justice, and we may fairly hope that Government would act honestly by us. Our claims are clear and already settled. All we have to do is to ask for their fulfilment.
The statesmen of 1833 knew well that it was a true act of sovereignty and statesmanship for them to decide what the future policy of the British rule was to be,—whether of justice, freedom and fairplay, or despotism and subjection; whether the Natives were to be treated as British subjects possessed of all the rights of British citizens, or as British slaves—mere hewers of wood and drawers of water,—subject to an Asiatic despotism aggravated in all its evils by its being not even a Native but an entirely foreign domination and despotism. That policy was fully considered by those who were competent to do so. True to the English character and mission, a glorious policy was spontaneously decided and solemnly proclaimed to India and the world, by a deliberate Act of Parliament.
Far from entertaining the least desire to make the British rule a galling and debasing foreign domination, the wish of the great statesmen of 1833 was, in Mr. Peel’s words, “ to atone to them for the sufferings they endured and the wrong to which they were exposed in being reduced to that rule, and to afford them such advantages and confer on them such benefits as may in some degree console them for the loss of their independence.” And Mr. Macaulay placed the whole matter on the highest grounds to prefer India, independent and self-governing, to its becoming a British slave, to earn the glory of the triumphs of peace, and of raising a nation in freedom and civilization, instead of the infamy of degrading and debasing it. Can any Englishman read the speeches of those days without feeling a glow of pride and triumph for his race, and can any native of India read those speeches without high admiration, delight and gratitude? Again a second time, a great and extraordinary occasion arose, and it became necessary to declare unmistakeably once more the policy of the rulers, and by the mouth of the august Sovereign, England proclaimed in the most solemn and binding manner, before God and Man, what her high policy shall be towards India. Thus the contract and decision of our rights have been settled and sealed as solemnly and as effectively as the Magna Charta or the Petition of Rights—with only this difference, to the great credit and glory of the gracious sovereign and statesmen, that in the case of English rights, they were wrested from the sovereign by the people at the point of the sword, but in the case of India, her rights were granted spontaneously and with grace. Our position simply then is this:—
Here are our great Charter of 1833 and the still greater one of 1858. The half of a century since 1833 has developed every phase of the question and has brought it to a simple issue: that it is completely settled beyond all further question or discussion, that no distinction whatsoever should be made between the natives of India and any other British subjects. The gracious words, sealed by an appeal to “the blessing of Almighty God,” are these:—
“We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects, and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil."
Next, here are the two solemn promises and obligations of 1833 and 1858. Of 1833—“That no Native of the said territories, nor any natural born subject of His Majesty resident therein shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office or employment under the said Company.” Of 1858:—“And it is our further will, that, so far as may be, our subjects of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified, by their education, ability and integrity, duly to discharge."
The issue now is a simple one: how can these promises be “faithfully and conscientiously fulfilled” so that all the subjects of our gracious Empress “be freely and impartially admitted” in all the services? Fortunately for us, the exact question has been already considered and decided by a competent authority.
Not long after Her Majesty’s Proclamation of 1858, a Committee was appointed by the Secretary of State for India of the following members of the Council of the India Office:—
Sir J. P. Willoughby, Mr. Mangles, Mr. Arbuthnot, Mr. Macnaghten, and Sir Erskine Perry.
This Committee made its Report on 20th January 1860, from which I give the following extracts:—
“2. We are in the first place unanimously of opinion, that it is not only just, but expedient that the natives of India shall be employed in the administration of India to as large an extent as possible, consistently with the maintenance of British supremacy, and have considered whether any increased facilities can be given in this direction.
3. It is true that, even at present no pisitive disqualification exists. By Acts 3 and 4 Wm. 4, C. 85, S. 87, it is enacted “that no Native of " the said territories nor any natural-born subject of His Majesty resi- " dent therein shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, " colour or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office or " employment under the said Company.” It is obvious, therefore, that when the competitive system was adopted, it could not have been intended to exclude natives of India from the Civil Service of India.
4. Practically, however, they are excluded. The law declares them eligible, but the difficulties opposed to a Native leaving India and residing in England for a time, are so great, that, as a general rule, it is almost impossible for a Native successfully to compete at the periodical examinations held in England. Were this inequality removed, we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.
5. Two modes have been suggested by which the object in view might be attained. The first is, by allotting a certain portion of the total number of appointments declared in each year to be competed for in India by Natives and by all other natural-born subjects of Her Majesty resident in India. The second is, to hold simultaneously two examinations, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being finally classified in one list according to merit, by the Civil Service Commissioners. The Committee have no hesitation in giving the preference to the second scheme, as being the fairest, and the most in accordance with the principles of a general competition for a common object."
Here, then, are the solemn promises and their " fairest” solution before us on competent and high authority, and nothing can be reasonably final that is short of this solution.
The question of the Uncovenanted Services is also very important. There must be some right principle and system upon which admission to these services should be based, so that no class or community of Her Imperial Majesty’s subjects may have any cause to complain that the principle of the Act of 1833, and of the proclamation of 1858—of equal justice to all, is not fairly and fully carried out.
The first National Indian Congress of last year, which met at Bombay, very carefully considered the whole question of all the Civil Services, and passed the following resolution :—
“IV. That in the opinion of this Congress the competitive examination now held in England, for first appointments in various Civil Departments, of the Public Service, should henceforth, in accordance with the views of the India Office Committee of 1860, ‘be held simultaneously, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being finally classified in one list according to merit,’ and that the successful candidates in India should be sent to England for further study, and subjected there to such further examinations as may seem needful. Further, that all other first appointments (excluding peonships, and the like) should be filled by competitive examinations held in India, under conditions calculated to secure such intellectual, moral and physical qualifications as may be decided by Government to be necessary. Lastly, that the maximum age of candidates for entrance into the Covenanted Civil Service be raised to not less than 23 years."
With regard to the expenses of the visit to England, that will be a charge on the public revenues of India, because already the selected candidates get certain allowances in England during their residence. The only difference will be an additional passage from India to England. Moreover, such a charge will not be at all grudged by the natives of India, as it will be to improve the fitness and character of their own countrymen for their own service, and such charge will be amply repaid in the higher tone, character and efficiency of the services.
I am glad to say that in England this resolution has met with sympathy not only from non-Anglo-Indians but from many Anglo-Indians also. The only thing they desired particularly was, that the selected candidates of India should be made to finish their studies and reside for some time in England and pass necessary further examinations with the selected candidates of England. When they found that the resolution proposed such visit to England, they were satisfied. The best thing I can lay before you to show this, is a resolution embodied in a letter addressed to Members of Parliament by the Council of the East India Association. The sub-committee, which prepared this letter, and which unanimously proposed the resolution in that letter, consisted of 3 official Anglo-Indians, one non-official Anglo-Indian and one Native. The resolution I refer to was this :—
“9. The larger employment in the public services of the inhabitants of India irrespective of race or creed :—
(a) By arranging, in respect of superior appointments in all Civil departments of the service, that the examination for such appointments now held in England be henceforth held simultaneously in England and in India, the selected candidates from India being required to proceed to England and undergo the training and Examinations now prescribed.
(b) By introducing in respect to all Subordinate Civil Services for which educational training is required, the principle of competitive examinations, with such safeguards as may be deemed applicable to the particular circumstances of each Province."
The question now to be considered is, whether those gracious and solemn promises of 1833 and 1858 were made with the honest intention of being faithfully fulfilled or not? I do not think that any person acquainted with the English character, traditions and history, will for a moment hesitate to say that there was honest intention. My own conviction is now deeper than ever, that the British People and Parliament do mean to act justly by us, and to fulfil the gracious words which they have given to India before God and the World, by the mouth of our august Sovereign and by an Act of Parliament. Let us, therefore, respectfully and clearly place before the Commission our views as to how all the departments of the Civil Service in both superior and subordinate divisions should be hereafter recruited, and that as far as necessary, Parliament be solicited to give their legislative sanction thereto.
We should then respectfully submit to the Commission and to our Rulers, that the 4th Resolution of the National Congress of last year is what we ask.
I do not here discuss the question of the Native Services in their important relation to the economic and financial condition of India and as an absolutely necessary and chief remedy for the poverty of India, as I have already given my views upon this subject in my papers on the Poverty of India, my correspondence with the Secretary of State for India, and others.
DADABHAI NAOROJI.
Bombay, 7th December 1886.
Notes
- . I may here quote a similar passage from Macaulay’s History of England. After describing the usual assumption against the Irish, he says—“and he (the Englishman) very complacently inferred, that he was naturally a being of a higher order than the Irishman: for it is thus that a dominant race always explains its ascendancy and excuses its tyranny."
- . i. e. The Civil Service Commission appointed by the Government of India by a Resolution No. 34/1573-98, dated 4th October 1886.