Events at Bombay

The English Factories in India, 1665–1667, William Foster, 1925 · from page 180 · about 41 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

EVENTS AT BOMBAY, 1666

Oxenden’s correspondence with Lieutenant-Governor Cooke was continued on 12 January by a letter from the former, which contained a reference to the emissary from the Governor of Surat who was to proceed to Bombay to report upon the fortifications which were being constructed there (see p. 62).

Mamhood Syad . . . is still here in towne, waiting a second answer from the King about some things more that this Governour hath advised to court. . . . Wee very heartily thanke you for the kind invitation you make us,1 though we are not in a condition to accept it, being tyed up to orders which we may not deviate from, lett this Governour use his uttmost malice, soe long as we are not turnd out of the country.

To this Cooke replied on 27 January :

When Mahmud Syhad arrives here, he shall be received according to the message he brings. But if oppertunity offers, you [may] let him and the Governour know that, allthough you are resident in their countrey, it cannot at all hinder me from following His Majesties orders in fortifying this place, allthough you should write to me to the contrary ; and for their high words and threatning of you, that matters not at all. When he comes, I question not but to give him such a satisfactory answer that may please both him and his master.

The correspondence quickly lost its amicable tone, owing to Cooke’s arbitrary seizure of a Surat vessel. The story is thus told in the letter from the President and Council to the Company of 16 March.

Wee must now prepare your patience to read a very uncouth, rash, and irregular attempt committed by His Majesties Governour of Bombaym, such as strikes att the utter obstruction of your trade, the losse of all your priviledges, and the greate dishonour of the King, the Honourable Company, and the nation. The story is thus. Sir Abraham Shipman . . . sent His Majesties pinke Chessnutt on his private accomptt of trade laden with goods for Bantam, consign’d to Mr. Humphry Cook, his then secretary, for disposall. In December, 1663, he return’d from Bantam, laden with some deare bought spices, China roots, etc., which were landed privately in Surat and delivered into a Banians hands for sale. The 5 January following the famous rebell Sevagy surprizd the towne, and in the generall destruction he made, this Banians house was burnt and therein (as he say’th) most of Sir Abrahams and Mr. Cooks goods, amounting, as falsely pretended, to rupees 8,615. This losse Sir Abraham Shipman resented very hardly, as being not well able to beare it. However, he was too wise to attempt any unjust action to repaire himselfe, but rather apply’d himselfe to this Kings ministers in a civill manner for redresse. In Aprill following Sir Abraham dyed, leaving the government and iland to the aforesaid Humphrey Cook, from whom we have received such continuall trouble in his dayly importunities for money to raise souldiers, build forts, and we know not what other designes, that we have been weary of answering his letters; and upon our first denyall of his unreasonable demands we have received such indignities and opprobious termes, to the greate prejudice and dishonour of the Honourable Company and ourselves, that we want both words and leisure at present to expresse them, and him in his right colours. This man, finding that he could not prevaile on us to grasp any of the Honourable Companies money into his hands, resolv’d and declar’d publikely (as is attested by severall wittnesses) to doe the Honourable Company and us all the injury his malice could contrive, assoon as occasion did present, swearing by his unchristian oaths that the Company and we were the greatest enemies His Majestie had, and therefore soe he would deale with us, intending to involve us in all troubles imaginable. It hapned, to our greate grief, that a jounck belonging to this Governour and some merchants in Surat, which had the Companies passe, was bound from Callicutt, laden with pepper, cassia lignum, and two elephants, which, having mett with fowle weather off of Vingurla and spent their water, was forced to putt into Bombaym for water, little expecting soe rude and piraticall an entertainment, being the first Surat jounck that touched there. The aforesaid Governor Cook, apprehending this a fitt occasion to reake his malice on us, immediately seized on the jounck assoon as she came to an anchor, took her yards and sayles ashoare, abusing her pilot and people, pretending what he did was to repaire and recover the losse which His Majestie the King of England received at Surat in Sevagys robbery, which he affirms the Mogull ought to make good; to which import he dispatches pattamars to the Governor of Surat and to us, declaring in high and possitive termes that, unlesse the Governor doth send him downe 10,000 rupees and upwards, for the full import of his losse with intrest, he will neither part with ship nor goods, affirming further that he cares not how his money is raised for him, wheather the King of India, the Governor of Surat, or the Company pay it him; the money he is resolv’d to have, noe matter how. You may well imagin with what amazement and afflicting trouble we perus’d this first alarum of soe unparalell’d a peice of piracy (as we may call it), acted against all law or honesty, to the dishonour of His Sacred Majestie and your intrest here, and the involving your estate and the persons of your servants in endlesse embroyles and imprisonment. The Governor of Surat immediately summons the President to give him a reason for this strange illegall proceeding, demanding wheather we were friends or enemies: wheather he gave him his passe on purpose to betray his ship: and immediately calls for satisfaction. The President, being sick of the gout, could not attend him (and well it was soe, for otherwise he had been certainly imprison’d), but sends Gerald Aungier to acquaint him he knew nothing of it: that the seizure was done without his order or privity: that he was utterly ashamed of and disown’d it: that it was done by the Governor of Bombaim, who had a power independent of him: that neither he nor the Companies estate were lyable to answer it, but that he ought to demand satisfaction from the actors themselves, who ought to give him reason and justice therein, and that we were wholy unconcern’d in it. The Governor stormes at this answer, giving the Company and the President very abusive language, calling us pirates and theives, and sweares by his Mahomett that he will have satisfaction to a pice out of the Companies estate before any of our goods are laden, declaring this ship and goods were worth 70,000 rupees, and soe much he expects from us; and presently embargues all your goods and commands his Customer not to chopp any untill further order. The whole towne cry shame on us, and we ly under soe greate a scandall and reproach that none of your servants can stirr out about your businesse without publique affronts putt on us. The Dutch in the meane time, working on this advantage, have possessed the Governor with such prejudiciall thoughts of us that you are in danger to loose all your priviledges and freedome of trade, if some speedy course be not taken to repaire our lost reputation; to effect which, the President sends privately to the Governor, endeavouring by all faire and civill termes to convince him of our innocency herein, representing unto him the services which he and the Companies servants did the towne in Sevagys surprize: that he lent and sett out his ship at the Companies charge to convoy in the Kings jouncks from Mocha at his request: that the Company were honourable merchantts and had paid the Kings customes for above 60 yeares, and had often received injuries but had never offerr’d any to his people: and that it was unreasonable and unjust to dishonour them with any such unworthy termes, or force them to satisfy for the hostility done by others. His answer was that he did beleive in parte that the President was not guilty of it, but that would not satisfy his King, but that he and the Kings subjects must be indemnified and paid to the uttmost of their damage sustain’d, and therefore ord’red him to write to the Governor of Bombaym immediately to release ship and goods and send them for Surat; otherwise, whatever damage did accrew he would certainly make himselfe good out of the Companies estate, and in this he is possitively resolved.

A letter had accordingly been addressed to Cooke, begging him to release the vessel; but from previous experience the President and Council had little hope that he would comply. The Company was therefore urged to make representations to His Majesty to put a stop to such proceedings, as otherwise it would be impossible to carry on the trade. The letter continues :

Wee have not insisted on the Governor of Bombayms second letter, wherein he with a strange confidence demands the money from you, and an accomptt of what is graunted you by this King in your customes to be paid him for Sir Abrahams and his owne accomptt, but humbly referr it to your judicious deliberation how you please to proceed therein; resolving patiently to endure the utmost that his malice can impose on us, before we will part with any right or priviledge that justly belongs to you.

Cooke’s second letter, to which Oxenden refers, was dated 21 February. He pretended that he had only just heard that the Emperor had remitted the customs duties for a twelvemonth to compensate the merchants concerned for the losses they had sustained. The amount thus remitted, he said,

Doth not belong neither to you nor the Company, but to the English that sustained the losses, which was only Sir Abraham Shipman and my selfe; for, allthough you are Cheife for the Companies affaires, I never heard that you were so for the English nation since wee arrived in India, for that belongs to His Majesties Commander in Cheife. . . . What custome the Companies goods inward and outward amounted unto, the mony should have been deposited into the hands of the Cheife for the English nation, to have reparted it to those that had received the losses, to which intent it was given. . . . It is generally reported the Company received no losse at all, only three bales of course cloth that was wanting on [the] Castle Green, which afterwards was found and only wanted some odd pieces that might import at most about 200 rupees.

Had Oxenden informed him of the Emperor’s grant, as he ought to have done, Cooke would not (he declared) have seized the junk, and he must disclaim responsibility for any consequences.

The President and Council’s answer (dated 1 March) to Cooke’s two letters was moderate in tone but crushing in argument. It pointed out that his and Shipman’s losses were incurred in private trade and could not ‘be reveng’d by any single person, without the Kings consent first had and letters of mart to warrant him in the seizure of the estate of any nation or particuler person’. Cooke’s disparagement of Oxenden’s authority was answered by an appeal to the charter so recently granted by King Charles, and a belief was expressed that the latter would not approve of an act of aggression on such slender grounds. Cooke was reminded that he had not brought his claim to the notice either of the Emperor or of the Governor of Surat; and to have taken violent action in such circumstances was declared to be likely to ruin English trade and thereby to draw upon himself the displeasure of his royal master. The consequences, both to the factors themselves and to their employers’ estate, were next dwelt upon, and he was earnestly begged to release the vessel at once. If he would do this, the President and Council would draw up on his behalf a petition to the Emperor for compensation for his losses, and would do their best to secure a favourable reply. The Governor could not, and would not, pay any money to redeem the junk. The assertion that the Company had lost nothing was emphatically denied; while as to the half per cent. remission in the customs duties, it had not yet taken effect, and when it did, it would be ‘a nationall good, by which we make noe private advantage’. The suggestion that Cooke should be compensated out of the money saved by the Company, in consequence of the remission of a year’s customs, was scouted as unreasonable; and the statement that he had only just heard of the imperial grant was declared to be incredible.

This letter had the desired effect upon Cooke, and in writing to the Company on 4 April the President and Council were able to announce that the junk had been released and had reached Surat in safety. In a letter from Cooke to Oxenden (12 March) he had declared that this was done in consequence of an assurance received from the Governor of Surat that he would ‘see me satisfied the losse’; and he had rejected with scorn the President’s offer to assist therein. In complaining to the Company of Cooke’s attitude, the factors said:

This unexpected preferment of imputing himselfe Governor, and entitling himselfe Governor and Captain-Gennerall of all His Majesties forces by sea and land, hath soe swell’d him up that he is little better then distracted, doing nothing personally, but keeps himselfe mued up in a chamber (eating and drinking by himselfe), from whence ’tis said he hath not stirred out above twice since he came on the iland, being full of feares and suspitious of every body; that our doctor, and others that have lately seen him, report that he hath brought himselfe soe low in his body, and become soe frettfull and peevish, that hath made him not only very crazy in body but in mind also. What reason he hath to be thus malitiously bent towards you and us we cannot thinke, except it be because we furnish him not with unlimited summs of money. Otherwise, for peace and quietnesse sake, we have condiscended to him in all things reasonable, and passt by many of his peremptory and abusive letters, because we would avoyd all appearance of difference; and yet the more we beare with him, the worse he is. But we hope this next September at furthest will bring us a remedy of some honourable person, who will regulate all, and from whom we may expect protection when occasion shall require, in case His Majestie intends to continew the royalty of the iland. We have lately seen a letter to this Governor from the aforesaid Mr. Cook, wherein he most scornefully and slightingly speakes of you as the Company and us [as] your servants, upon freeing the vessail; telling them how inconsiderable we are and how that all the power and authority lyes in him; encouraging and perswading this Governor to force the said summe of 8,616 rupees, with its intrest from the time that Sevagy fired and robb’d the towne, from your President, Sir George Oxinden, and remitt it to him; and takes all opportunities to acquaint such that come on the iland from Surat that we have noe power to give passes (wittnesse the vessail he seized, notwithstanding she had our passe, which he slighted and made noe accomptt of), and therefore, if they would be secure, they must come to Bombaim and take them from him. And now we leave you to judge what a diminution this is in the management of your affaires, when our countrymen and His Majesties owne servants shall thus post us up everywhere to be of noe esteem, and, to shew their owne power and lessen ours, shall thus evill intreat this Kings subjects, in contempt of our passe given them; whereas it was wont to be to us in your affaires of greate use, and did keep all the merchants that traded in greate awe, as we have hitherto done the very Governors themselves, and likwise to give us great respect.

Cooke’s seizure of the Surat junk was referred to in a letter from Gary at Bombay, dated 29 March, of which the original and a duplicate are in the Public Record Office (C.O. 77, vol. x. ff. 48, 50). This gives the date of the seizure as 18 February, and says that it was made in spite of Cooke’s ‘promise past unto the commaunder for a kinde and freindly reception and usage of him’. Gary blamed the action as endangering English interests, and used it to prove that the appointment of a fresh Governor was urgently necessary.

We may perhaps assign to the same period an undated letter in the Public Record Office (Ibid., f. 73), addressed by John Stevens, commander of the Chestnut, to the Navy Commissioners in London. He referred to Cooke’s action in taking his officers and crew ashore and employing them as ‘private centinells’. Cooke had refused to permit Stevens to leave the island and had ‘this day’ called upon him to take charge of the vessel again; but it was doubtful whether she could be repaired sufficiently to enable her to return to Europe. The settlement was being fortified, and might stand ‘a small seidge’. They had thirty guns mounted, of which eight belonged to the Chestnut. Every one was looking forward to the arrival of a new Governor. Stevens hoped that means would be sent to help him to return home.

On 2 April Oxenden wrote to tell Cooke that Dutch ships were gathering at Swally and that an attack upon Bombay was not improbable. Cooke replied (8 April) that in such an event he would make the best resistance he could, though the garrison was in ‘a very sad condition’, owing to want of money (for which he blamed Oxenden) and consequently of victuals.

I have had in pay 40 Portugalls of Europe with our own men ever since December last, that I had the first newes of the Dutch assaulting of us; and now, if I had mony, question not but to procure many more.1

He therefore again solicited a supply of cash. To this (17 April) the President and Council answered that money would no longer be urgently needed, as the Dutch fleet had dispersed. The letter shows that the English and Dutch merchants at Surat were still on a friendly footing, in spite of the war.

Occasion’d by the late Commandores 2 widdow going to Batavia, we received a visitt from them in generall, which their suddain departure causd us speedily to repay. At which two meetings we had, over a glass of wine, various discourse, from whence we learnt that the report of their Gennerall Rickloffs coming hither was over, by reason of the latenesse of the yeare. His pretended businesse was to examin some wrongs done their Company by their brokers. And the 15 present went away six ships for Batavia; [so] that here is now but three remayning, and they making what hast they can to follow.

Oxenden and his colleagues took occasion to complain of Cooke’s ‘opprobious and unbeseeming language’; to which the latter retorted (19 May) that they had on their part spoken slightingly of him and the settlement to the Governor of Surat and other ‘persons of quality’.

The letters that passed between Surat and Bombay during the next few months call for no comment. On 10 September, writing to the Company, the President and Council said:

Wee finde wee have not wrote you any thing of Bombay; and beleiving you may expect it, and the rather because wee have not received any letters or pacquets from Mr. Humphry Cooke, the present Deputie Governour, though wee timely prepared him to it by advice when wee intended to dispeed the ship. They are still in possession of the island, in expectation of our Kings Majesties further commands and a recruit of men and moneys. They are but few in number, about one hundred surviving of those that came out of England; to which have been added some seamen that your President discharged upon the sale of his ships Royall Welcome and Hopewell. But the men enjoy their health much better, now that they are seasoned to the country; yet severall of them drop away by sickness and other casualities of ill life…. If His Majestie intends to keepe it [i. e. Bombay], wee hope you have been mindfull of our request made in our former in making some provission that wee may live peaceably with those that shall have the government of the place; for in the end it is you that will be the sufferers.

On this point the Surat factors were reassured by the letters brought by the Return, for in theirs of 7 March, 1666, the Company wrote:

Our Kings Majestie, haveing bin acquainted with what you have written concerning the proceedings of Mr. Humphrey Cooke and the rest of the soldiers at Bonbay, hath promised by the Secretary of State that effectuall directions shall bee given in letters… that a faire corespondency bee held with you and due respect given you, with comaundes that they act nothing tending to our prejudice or contrary to our charter by clashing with you or acting to the dishonour of our English nation. Soe that wee hope you shall receive noe further trouble or molestation from them.

Cooke’s position was a trying one. Short of money and stores, he had to pacify the discontented garrison as best he could, and at the same time to be on the watch for a possible attack by the Dutch; while any ships that might arrive from England with relief would probably bring some one to take his command from him. In point of fact, while he was squabbling with Oxenden and making enemies all around him, a new Governor was on his way to the island. As noted in the last volume (p. 334), the news of Shipman’s death reached London in July, 1665. No ship would be sailing for India until about the end of the year at the earliest, and there was therefore no need for hurry in making choice of his successor; while the confusion caused by the Great Plague probably helped to delay the appointment. Evidently the idea of confirming Cooke in the post was not entertained; nor was it likely that it would be, considering his antecedents. Whether there were many applicants we do not know; but eventually, towards the close of the year, the choice fell upon Sir Gervase Lucas. He was the third son of Anthony Lucas, of Fenton in Lincolnshire, and was baptized there 28 July, 1611. He was a zealous Royalist, and it was doubtless for his services to the cause that he was created a baronet on 20 May, 1644.1 Clarendon mentions him as having, in November, 1645, when Governor of Belvoir Castle, escorted King Charles during part of his journey from Newark to Oxford; and this is the only record that can be found of the part played by him in the Civil War. After the Restoration Lucas seems to have been employed for a time in connexion with the Crown lands; but this had soon ceased, and, having no wife or family to consider, he was probably glad to accept the Governorship of Bombay, though it was a post both dangerous and troublesome.

The appointment having been decided upon, Lord Arlington put into Lucas’s hands all the papers he had concerning the island, and on 18 January, 1666, the new Governor submitted his observations thereon (P.R.O.: C.O. 77, vol. x. f. 4). He thought that the garrison should be made up to its original strength of four hundred men, though this would entail a cost of 7,371l. a year for the wages of the soldiers alone, apart from the expense of a chaplain, storekeepers, &c. It would also be necessary to send out provisions for eighteen months, besides ammunition and other stores. The expenditure upon fortification could not be estimated beforehand. Finally, Lucas suggested that the salary allotted to Shipman was not sufficient to maintain the dignity of the post of Governor. The vista of continuous and heavy expenditure thus opened up, at a time when the national finances were strained to the utmost by the war with the Dutch, was evidently unwelcome to the King and his advisers, and must have suggested doubts as to the desirability of maintaining so distant an outpost. The matter was next referred to a Committee of the Privy Council, consisting of the Duke of Albemarle, the Earl of Arlington, and Sir William Coventry, whose report was dated 26 March, 1666 (Ibid., f. 35). They suggested that, as it was not certain whether Bombay still remained in the possession of the English, it would be unwise to incur more expenditure than was absolutely necessary; they thought, therefore, that it would suffice if a reinforcement of sixty soldiers, under a lieutenant, were sent. A ship and a ketch should be hired to carry them out; and this, with provisions for the recruits, would cost 7,752l., reckoning the voyage there and back to last one year. Pay for an establishment of 120 privates, five officers, and a drummer, for eighteen months, would add 2,746l. 16s.; while for guns and ammunition 1,000l. was allowed; total, 11,498l. 16s. No provision was made for the salaries of the Governor, Deputy Governor, or any other civil officials, nor for the cost of food, &c., for the garrison. Lucas, five days later (Ibid., f. 41), pointed out these omissions and further asked what sum would be allowed for fortification and contingencies, and what arrangements would be made for his return, supposing he should find the island in the possession of the Dutch. He suggested that expenditure at Bombay might be financed by means of letters of credit on the East India Company’s servants; and he asked for two suits of armour, six cases of pistols, and twelve carbines. The decisions on these points are noted on the back of the paper. The desired arms were to be issued from the Tower; Sir George Oxenden was to be asked to facilitate Lucas’s repair to Bombay and his return, if necessary:1 the cost of fortification might be defrayed from a credit of 1,500l. to be arranged with the East India Company: while as for Lucas’s pay, he might draw 1l. per day until the establishment was settled. The idea of sending out a special ship, as also of raising fresh recruits, was dropped, and it was resolved that Lucas should proceed in the Company’s ship Return. In another memorandum of the same date (Ibid., f. 42), Lucas asked for an order upon the Company to that effect, for his commission, and for detailed instructions as to civil government, particularly as regards claims to lands, &c., religious liberty, the right to navigate surrounding waters without interference from the Portuguese, and other matters.

A draft or copy (undated) of Lucas’s commission, together with an uncompleted draft, will be found at the Public Record Office in the volume already cited (ff. 7, 10). He is appointed ‘Our Governour and Commander in Chiefe of Our Port and Island of Bombaim’, and is given power to place and displace officers, to ordain ‘lawes and ordinances martiall’, and to punish offenders by death or otherwise. We have also (Ibid., f. 11) two drafts of his instructions (ff. 11–14). As soon as he was ready to embark, he was to cash a draft upon the East India Company for 1,000l. (to be paid out of money due to the King); half this amount might be spent on his expenses in the voyage, and the remainder should be reserved to pay arrears of garrison wages on arrival. He was directed to send home a full account of past expenditure on the island, with particulars of the existing establishment. In the event of the ship touching at any place where there was an English factory, Lucas should recruit any Englishmen he might find there unemployed, at the same time warning any others in the service of foreign princes to return home. Letters were handed to him, addressed by the Portuguese ambassador in London to the Viceroy at Goa, asking the latter to facilitate the recruiting of Portuguese for the garrison of Bombay, pending the dispatch of reinforcements from England; and in return Lucas was charged to be considerate in his dealings with the Portuguese inhabitants of the island. The task of fortification should be his first care; but when ‘well settled’, he should inform himself of ‘the true interest of Our trade in those and promising a grateful recognition of any assistance rendered to him, will be found at f. 43 of the same volume. parts, how at present managed, and what improvements it is capable of ’. A gracious message from the King was to be communicated to the officers and privates, thanking them for their past services and regretting the sufferings they had undergone. Cooke should be informed of ‘ the good satisfaction Wee have in his late services ’, particularly in securing possession of the island ; ‘ and as a marke of Our gracious acceptance of those services, you shall, if you find fitt, fill up the blanc commission 1 of Deputy Governor with his name preferably to any other ’. Gary was also commended, and Lucas was advised to continue his employment.

Evidently considerable uneasiness was felt as to the possibility of Bombay and its scanty garrison falling into the hands of the enemy, should a serious attack be made ; and in the same volume (f. 39) we find a letter from Sir William Thomson, Governor of the East India Company, to Lord Arlington (27 March), replying to inquiries as to the chances of obtaining help from the neighbouring princes. On this point the writer could see no grounds for confidence. The Great Mogul was not likely to render assistance, for his subjects stood in much awe of the Dutch power at sea. The Portuguese would be slow to involve themselves in hostilities which would only inflict further losses upon them ; and even if they were willing, their resources were limited. A league with Sivāji would embroil the English with the Great Mogul and possibly with the ruler of Bījāpur as well. In fact, should the Dutch send a strong force, it was doubtful whether any external aid could save the settlement.

From the public archives we turn now to the records of the East India Company. In their letter of 7 March, 1666, to Surat, the Committees had mentioned that the King was sending out a Governor to Bombay in a special ship ; 2 but on the 24th they wrote that His Majesty had since changed his mind, owing to the lateness of the season, and had ordered them to find accommodation for Lucas in the Return as far as Goa. They desired the President and Council to afford him any necessary advice and assistance, and expressed confidence that they would find him ‘to bee a person of that honnor and prudence as not to countenance or give protection to any of our refractory servants’. A letter sent to Captain Stanton at the same time ordered him to receive aboard the Return (then in the Downs) Sir Gervase and six attendants. We learn, moreover, from the Court Minutes that Stanton was authorized to buy about 25l. worth of fresh provisions and present them to Lucas in the name of the Company.

Another letter from the Committees, likewise dated 24 March, enclosed a copy of a recommendatory letter which had been given by them to Lucas,

Enordring your keeping a faire corespondency, and to shew him the respect becoming his quallity and imployment; which wee doubt not but you will readily comply with. But as for lending any monies, wee shall not give our directions or orders, there being nothing intimated or desired of us in relation thereunto.

A week later, however, yet another letter was written, stating that, at the request of Lord Arlington, the Company had agreed to allow Sir Gervase, in the event of his finding Bombay still in English hands, to draw upon the Surat factors for any sums required for the use of the garrison, up to a limit of 1,500l., giving bills of exchange in return at the rate of 6s. per rial of eight.

His more urgent needs being thus provided for, Lucas sailed in the Return, and duly reached Goa on 24 September. Here the duty of the Captain, in regard to his exalted passenger, ended, and Sir Gervase had to hire a small vessel to convey him to his post, Stanton (who had received an urgent summons to Surat) promising to keep company as far as possible. A letter from Henry Gary at Bombay, dated 30 November, now in the Public Record Office (C.O. 77, vol. x. f. 59), announced that Lucas had reached the island on the 5th of that month.

Hee having most miracolously escaped being taken by fower Mallabar fregatts; the captain and officers of the shipp Returne not haveing kept him company from Goa to this bay according to theyr promise.

Gary did not blame the captain, who was only obeying his instructions to lose no time; but he pointed out how serious the consequences would have been, had the new Governor fallen into the hands of the pirates.

From a courteous letter addressed to Oxenden by Lucas on 9 November, it appears that the latter had intended, had the Return kept company, to go straight on to Surat from Goa, in order to make the acquaintance of the President and his Council and arrange matters with them before proceeding to his post. This having failed, he had sent Richard Ball to receive the 1,500l. which the Company had authorized the Surat factors to supply. Lucas calculated that (taking the rupee at 2s. 3d. and the rial of eight at 2·14 rupees) he should receive 6,230½ rials, and in payment thereof he had delivered to Ball a bill of exchange1 on the Lord High Treasurer for 1,869l. 3s.; he intimated that the money might be delivered to Ball, but that the factors must bear the risk of its safe arrival at Bombay. Lucas assured his correspondent of his earnest desire to maintain the most cordial relations with the Company’s servants and said that he had promised as much to ‘severall worthy persons of that body’. He enclosed a letter for Gerald Aungier from his brother, Lord Aungier, and added:

Mr. Cooke hath writ to you about passing on the shipp Returne for Europe, in regard he hath not his health in these parts. I am very sorry to part with him so suddenly after my arrivall, in regard he is well accquainted with affaires in these parts; but being I must of necessity send one on board your shipp to give His Majestie an accompt of the condition of his affaires here, I am the willinger to let him goe, who is best able; and therefore desire you to give me timely notice when your shipp will be ready, that I may provide against the time.

This letter evidently crossed one from Surat of 13 November, of which no copy is extant. It seems to have conveyed the greetings of the President and Council to the new Governor, and to have intimated to him that, if he had any letters for England, he should send them at once to Surat, as the Return was to sail as soon as possible. To this Lucas returned an answer on 22 November, which plainly showed his annoyance. He could see no reason for haste in the dispatch of the ship, and the alleged danger from the Dutch appeared to him illusory. He thanked them for information concerning three mariners from the shipwrecked Love, and desired notice of any other unemployed Englishmen who had not come out in the service of the Company, as he had instructions from the King to ‘draw them hither’.

Meanwhile, on receiving Lucas’s letter of 9 November, Oxenden and his colleagues had written again (16 November). They expressed great regret that, owing to the Return losing company with the Governor’s vessel (‘for which the captain seemes to bee much aflicted and protest[s] his innocence’), they had missed the opportunity of making Lucas’s personal acquaintance. As regards the money, they were very willing to supply it, as desired, in ‘dollars, halfe Sevill and halfe Mexico’.

Onely wee find that the prizes of those species are misrepresented to you; for the standard of this towne and mint is very constant, admitting but one price, according to the specie, the Sevill yeilding but 214 and the Maxico rupees 211 per hundred dollars. . . . Another thing is, royals of eight being a comodity that all merchants are oblidged to bring into the mint (and indeed it is theire advantadge to have their mony coined with what expedition they can, to take them of from interest), wee have enquired and find it very difficult, if at all possible, to procure the said summe of royals of eight 6,230½ in that specie; wherefore we desire, in such case, you would please to accept of rupees, or chicqueens, if to be had.

They could find no warrant in the Company’s letter for their bearing the risk of the money in its transit to Bombay, and they hoped that Lucas would waive the point; but, if he insisted, they would be glad to be allowed to remit in three or more instalments, in order to minimize the risk. Ball would await Lucas’s answer on all these matters. Should the ship (‘which, soe soon as laden, wee dare not detaine’) start before the reply arrived, they would send the bill of exchange to the Company, guaranteeing to pay over the money to Lucas in due course.

Wee are very sorry wee cannot comply with Mr. Cooke, in appointing the shipp to call at Bombaim to take him in, not daring to stray soe far from orders in these perillous times; and wee very much feare hee will not bee able to arrive timely enough to us by land. Yet if he please to adventure it, wee will undertake he shall have the best accomodation the shipp can afford, though he hath not deserved it, neither from our masters nor our selves; but as a service to His Majestie, wee are readye to accomodate what we can.

A supply of medicines was promised, and the letter ended with ’the tender of our most cordiall and ready services’. The action taken was duly reported to the Company in the letter sent by the Return, which, as we have seen, sailed for England on 25 November.

The receipt of the Surat letter of 16 November caused Sir Gervase to indite a fresh one on the 24th, in a rather sharper tone. To the corrected rate of exchange for the rials of eight he made no demur; but he held stubbornly to the requirement that the factors should take the risk of the safe delivery of the money at Bombay, seeing that they were ordered to pay it to him, not to his assigns. Moreover, as the King was to repay at so high a rate, it would be manifestly unfair that he should bear any risks in the matter. The method of remittance he left entirely to their judgement. Their renewed yet indefinite hints that the Return might sail without his letters had much perplexed him, for surely they could have fixed an absolute date for her departure and then he would have ‘known what to trust to’.

Your uncertaine dealing with me in this point lookes as if you had a mind the shipp should be gone before my letters could arrive with you; by which not any accompt can be given into Europe but from your selves, and so His Majestie kept ignorant of the true state of his affaires in these parts, which more imports His Majestie and kingdome then you yet seem to understand. I will yet hope my dispatches will arrive with you in time; which I shall be very glad of. Otherwise, you will give me just cause to suspect you play not faire above board, whatever your pretences be; which is not the way to beget or preserve a good understanding, either betwixt our selves or His Majestie and the East India Company your masters (as you call them). And therefore let me desire you that in all things of concerne hereafter you deale clearely, freely, and positively with me; which is the most noble and fit for gentlemen, and you shall never find me faile in it…. I assure you I have honest, honourable, and just intentions to His Majesties service and my countreys advantage, and hope I shall on all occasions find the same in you.

The receipt of these two letters, together with a packet addressed to the King, caused the President and Council much uneasiness, since they had no wish either to be embroiled in a quarrel with the new Governor of Bombay or to be represented to the King as having wilfully obstructed the transit of Lucas’s letter to him. On 3 December they held a consultation,1 at which it was decided to accede to his demands concerning the money; and on the following day they sent, by Richard Ball, who was returning to the island, a humble letter deploring the fact that Sir Gervase’s packet had arrived too late to be forwarded by the Return, which, they intimated, had sailed before they had expected her to do so. They declared that they had received the most positive orders from the Company not to delay the vessel a moment longer than was necessary, in view of the risk of her falling into the hands of the Dutch; and,

Allthough the enemy are not yet come in, they have been dayly and hourely expected by their owne party resident here in towne. That which raised the greater feares in us was her riding in the open sea, more then three leagues of the shoare, incompassed with shoales, that there was not any means to preserve her.

They protested that it was impossible for them, when writing before, to fix any particular date for her departure; and they implored Lucas to believe that they had not been actuated by any sinister motive, but were really devoted to His Majesty’s service. They had given Ball bills of exchange on Bassein for 6,500 rupees, and had delivered the balance (6,833⅜ rupees) to the insurers to transmit to Bombay. The value, at an average of 212½ rupees to 100 rials of eight, would be 6,274½ rials. If Lucas cared to trust his letters to a conveyance overland, via Sind and Persia, they would make all the arrangements and defray the expense.

Six days later the President and Council sent, by another conveyance, a copy of the foregoing letter, adding a note of the news received that day from Aleppo that the English had obtained a ‘very bloody yet memorable victory’ over the Dutch (see p. 177). The sailors from the Love would be sent in a few days to Bombay.

The only information we have concerning the administrative steps taken by Lucas after his arrival comes from a small group of documents in the Public Record Office (C.O. 77, vol. x). The first of these (f. 56) is a copy of a proclamation he issued on 12 November, stating that certain disaffected persons were circulating reports that the island would shortly be returned to the Portuguese and that then any who had paid dues to the English might expect to be punished; a warning was accordingly given against the spreading of such rumours or any other tending to the discredit of the King’s authority or discouraging the payment of revenue. The next item (f. 57) is a signed duplicate (received 15 October, 1667), of a letter from Sir Gervase to the King, dated 22 November.1

I arrived at Your Majesties island and garrison of Bombaim the 5th November; where I found all things in an ill frame, which creates me every day more and more trouble, by the souldiers complaints against Mr. Cooke, who I doe not finde in any respect a person of parts, nor capable of that honnor Your Majestie intended him by the blanck commission I brought along with mee for the Deputy Governour. Nor will it looke well at the present to put in Mr. Henry Gary his name (though much a worthier and abler person), in regard of the differences which are before me. I neither doe, or will, have partiallity or prejudice, but will, to the best of my knowledge, doe that which is just and fitt for Your Majesties affaires. The businesse is so confused [that] it is not fitt to give Your Majestie an account of it; but so soone as I can see thorrough it, I will prepare it for Your Majesties perusall. Your Majestie hath here a most noble harbour and a fruitfull island, of which I have given the best account I can, for the time I have been in these parts, to my Lord Arlington, Your Majesties principall secretary. When I know better and have time (which an East India Companies ship will never afford us here), I will use all diligence to let Your Majestie understand it, as my duty obligeth me.

Lucas’s letter to Lord Arlington, unfortunately, is not forthcoming; and we go on (f. 59) to Gary’s letter of 30 November to an unnamed correspondent, of which a portion has already been quoted. He refers to

His Majestys affaires haveing been for some time before the Governours arryvall in a distracted condition. . . . But now all former irregularities and disorders have theyr periods, Sir Gervace Lucas haveing made soe good a progresse in all matters whatsoever that there is allready a wonderfull reformation uppon this island, unto the great content and satisfaction of all His Majestys faythfull and loyall subjects.

Gary then mentions a brief letter he has sent to Lord Arlington (not extant). Lucas has not yet intimated to him anything about the employment alluded to by his correspondent (evidently that of Deputy Governor); but as Cooke is going to England shortly, Gary hopes soon to be ranked among His Majesty’s servants, especially as he has now served four full years at his own charges and has given up both the Company’s employment and his own private trading. He begs that this may be represented to Lord Arlington.

Lucas’s investigation of Cooke’s past proceedings quickly produced a breach between them, and the latter seems to have been forbidden to leave the island until he had given a more satisfactory account. This led to a protest on his part, the terms of which are not on record; but of the Governor’s answer, dated 15 December, we have no less than five copies (P.R.O.: C.O. 77, vol. x. ff. 63–9). In this Lucas says that, having examined Cooke’s proceedings, he has found him guilty of unworthily extorting from several inhabitants of the island divers sums amounting to 12,000 zerafins and upwards,

And under your owne hand gave it to bee for the use of His Majestie, but never had the honesty to bring it to His Majesties credit; which, notwithstanding I had charged you therewith, you were soe bold, not to say impudent, as to denye the receipt thereof and appropriating it to your owne perticular accompt, and persisting by your sayd denyall untill I had proved and made evidently appeare that you had receaved it, and for the sayd money, I saye for the major part thereof, produced your owne hand as witnesse against you.

Lucas professes his willingness to ‘smother severall barbarities by you here perpetrated’; but he must demand an account of Shipman’s estate, on behalf of the latter’s daughter and executrix, Elizabeth Shipman, whom Cooke has ‘had the conscience’ to charge 15 per cent. ‘for commission and registring money’, amounting to 663l. 17s. 3d.1 Until he undertakes to pay this sum to the executrix, and gives a satisfactory account of the whole estate, he cannot be allowed to leave the island.

Lucas’s report upon his dealings with Cooke is contained in his letter to Lord Arlington of 2 March, 1667 (ibid., f. 98). In this he says that he found two items to object to in Cooke’s accounts. In the first place the latter had claimed pay as Governor (i. e. at 40s. a day) from the death of Shipman. Lucas refused to allow more than the 12s. a day which Cooke was entitled to draw as Lieutenant-Governor.

The other objection I had against his accounts was I discovered him to have received about 1100l. upon pretence of His Majesties service, which he converted to his owne use. He seemed much discontented at my proposition, but I assured him I could not allow of these two particulars, neither would I part with him till he had paid the 1100l. into His Majesties receipt, which after some debate he did; and on the 17th December tooke his passage for Goa, from whence he intended for Europe. I likewise received of him, upon account of fraight for His Majesties vessell, the Chesnut pinke, six hundred forty two pounds, for a merchants voyage he alleadgeth Sir Abraham sent to Bantum, and he chargeth the payment of it upon Mistress Elizabeth Shipman. I told him it was indifferent to me who paid it, so His Majestie did not loose it. So that in all I received of him 1,742l. in commodities for His Majesties use, and cut him of 1,300l. as debt he pretended upon His Majestie. . . . He is not without some hopes but His Majestie will allow him the 40s. a day; but when he arrives at Whithall, you will not finde him a person of parts or so much merit. And to speake truth, he hath much foiled and dishonoured His Majesties goverment here in its infancy, by takeing severall bribes to let His Majesties right passe unquestioned; 250l. of which money hee received I have paid back againe since my arrivall here, out of such commodities as I received of him; by which I have freed His Majesties just pretence to the title of fishing and other rights which I have taken into custodie and, I hope, will yeeld His Majestie three hundred pound a yeare.

Notes

  1. 1. This refers to Cooke’s suggestion (see p. 62) that, if the Governor of Surat proved too overbearing, the factors should remove to Bombay.
  2. 1. A letter from Consul Lannoy at Aleppo, 12 October, 1666, quoted in the Report on the Finch MSS. (vol. i. p. 438) says: ‘The Dutch reported at Surat that they intended to assault His Majesties island of Bombain, which hath made Lieut.-Governor Cooke and his souldiers (being in number not many more then a hundred) to put themselves in a posture of defence; who have taken a resolution to defend His Majesties interest to the last man, and were drawing a line for their security to the landward.’
  3. 2. Van Adrichem.
  4. 1. Lincolnshire Pedigrees (Harleian Society), vol. ii. p. 615.
  5. 1. The draft of a letter from the King to Oxenden, commending Lucas to his good offices
  6. 1. A copy of this commission, dated 23 March, 1666, will be found at f. 30 of the same volume. Of course nothing was as yet known in London regarding the charges made against Cooke by Gary and others.
  7. 2. In the Public Record Office (C.O. 77, vol. x. f. 121) is an unsigned and undated memorandum, evidently written in March, 1666 (possibly by Matthew Andrews), urging that the King should send out two ships of about 40 guns apiece to carry out reinforcements for the Bombay garrison and to prey upon Dutch commerce. It was suggested that the necessary sailors might be obtained ‘ to serve uppon the accomptt of noe purchase [i. e. booty], no pay ’. The writer added that the Dutch in the East were so confident that they guaranteed all merchants putting freight goods aboard their ships against capture by the English ; and that therefore no complications need be feared if such goods were confiscated.
  8. 1. Now in the Public Record Office (C.O. 77, vol. x. f. 55).
  9. 1. See Forrest’s Selections, Home Series, vol. i. p. 210.
  10. 1. Sent via Persia and Aleppo on 30 November.
  11. 1. At this rate Shipman must have left 4,425l. 15s. in India. Most of it was probably acquired by private trading.