Introduction

The English Factories in India, 1634–1636, William Foster, 1911 · from page v · about 68 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

At the commencement of 1634 President Methwold and his colleagues at Surat were chiefly anxious about the provision of a cargo for the Mary, which was preparing to return to England. As explained in the last volume, such a task was far from easy, owing to their great indebtedness, the small demand for the imported goods, the dearness of calicoes, and the agreement recently made with the Dutch to refrain from purchasing indigo (in order to break down the monopoly which had been established in that article). When, therefore, at the beginning of February, the Mary at last put to sea, she was laden chiefly with the indigo and saltpetre which had been bought at Agra long before and had been an unconscionable time in coming down from thence.

With the Mary departed the Reformation and the Intelligence, both bound for the West Coast of Sumatra, and four other vessels under Captain Weddell (the Jonas being the flagship) for Gombroon. This fleet returned early in April, and in the same month was dispatched on the usual cruise to the southwards. One of the four—the Hart—was, however, to quit the rest near Ceylon and proceed to the Coromandel Coast; while a second—the Discovery— was to be dispatched to the same destination at a later period of the voyage. The remaining two were to effect a junction at the Comoros with the fleet expected from England and return with them; but Weddell had orders to diverge from the rest to Gombroon, in order to pick up some silk which was expected to be lying there awaiting transport to Surat.

The Mary having been dispatched, Methwold and his Counci were at leisure to devote their attention to internal affairs. Their hopes of defeating the indigo monopolists by the joint abstention of the Dutch and English from making any purchases had been upset by some unfortunate proceedings on the part of the factors of the two nations at Agra. Before the news of the agreement reached that place, the Dutch chief bought from the monopolists a large quantity at a high price. On receipt of this intelligence his superiors at Surat 'with some shew of sorrow' informed the English merchants, at the same time tendering them the opportunity of sharing in the bargain. This offer the English declined; but, as there was now no hope of breaking down the monopoly for the present, they insisted on being released from the obligation not to ship indigo for native traders. Apparently they were not altogether sorry to think that their rivals had locked up so much capital in indigo bought at an unheard-of price; and it was with no little dismay that they learned, early in February, that Fremlen, the English chief at Agra, had agreed to take a third of the indigo purchased by the Dutch factors. The President and Council were very indignant; but there was no possibility of repudiating the bargain, and so they had to make the best of the situation. Fremlen's action in the matter was severely censured; and he was ordered to dissolve the factory at Agra and return to Surat. To the Company the factors wrote overland on February 21, narrating these occurrences and urging the dispatch of the necessary funds to free them from the 'vast debt' that embarrassed them.

The Intelligence got back from Bantam on September 7. At the beginning of October two ships from England, viz. the London and the Hopewell (a pinnace) arrived at Swally, accompanied by the Palsgrave of Weddell's fleet, which had met the other two at the Comoros, as arranged. A few days later the Reformation returned from Sumatra. This vessel was found to have on board a large quantity of pepper belonging to the officers and crew, and Methwold would no doubt have liked to seize it all; but it was no easy matter to enforce such a policy without raising a mutiny, and so it was judged wiser to purchase the pepper at an advance of about 30 per cent. on the cost. The Blessing (the third vessel of the new fleet) seems to have arrived some time in November; and in the same month Weddell brought in the Jonas from Gombroon. The Surat Council had thus seven vessels at their disposal, but in the middle of December the number was reduced by the departure of the Reformation for Gombroon with freight goods and a consignment of tobacco.

A long and interesting letter was written to the Company at the close of the year. Trade was still very bad, on account both of the high price of calicoes and of the small demand for European goods, and there was little hope of profitable employment for the ships now at Surat. The burden of debt, however, had been to a great extent lifted from the shoulders of the factors by the money brought by the new fleet, though the result was to leave them almost destitute of funds for investment; and private trade had been considerably diminished. Signs were not wanting that the indigo monopoly was likely to be broken before long, especially as the Governor of Surat, finding that the revenues of his port were suffering, had petitioned the Emperor to restore freedom of trade in that commodity. The Dutch, impatient of the unfavourable aspect of affairs, had reduced their establishments and transferred their capital to Persia.1 In compliance with a request from King Charles some Persian MSS. were forwarded, while some Arabic ones were promised later.2 By the King’s order a piece of white cloth had been sent out to be ‘staynd into severall colours’; the cloth was ruined before the dyeing could be undertaken, but some account is given of the process (p. 82). All other factories having been dissolved, Surat was ‘stuft’ with merchants; some of these, however, were being sent home, and for the rest the President and Council hoped to find employment shortly; nevertheless, they much needed factors who could speak Dutch and Portuguese, as the ‘Negro Portugese’ employed in conversing with the natives was useless for communication with Goa (p. 74).

Another topic dwelt upon in this letter is the long-debated truce with the Portuguese, to which we must now turn our attention. The steps previously taken, and the advantages expected to result from this pacification, were explained in the 1630–33 volume. There was a good deal of preliminary manœuvring for position, as neither party wished (in the event of failure) to be left exposed to the charge of having begged in vain for peace. When, therefore, the Portuguese sent a safe-conduct for one or more Englishmen to come to Damān to treat upon the matter, Methwold asked, as a preliminary, for information as to the view taken by the Portuguese of the bearing of the Treaty of Madrid upon the point at issue. In January, 1634, the Viceroy forwarded a second safe-conduct, this time for Goa. Replying at the end of February, Methwold expressed his readiness to send representatives thither to negotiate, provided that the Viceroy and his Council would undertake beforehand to agree to that Treaty being extended to the East Indies. The answer of the Viceroy (p. 22) was frank and explicit. He considered that clearly the Treaty did not apply to the Indies ; but he was willing to conclude a truce, pending reference to Europe, and to undertake that, should the agreement be disapproved there, a reasonable period should be allowed before hostilities were resumed. This offer was debated at a consultation held in Surat on April 15, and it was unanimously resolved to accept it ; whereupon the President wrote to the Viceroy to that effect and intimated that, as soon as the rains were over, he would come in person to Goa to conclude the negotiations. In November Methwold wrote again, saying that he was anxious to start at the earliest possible moment, but that he must first see to the lading of the ships destined for England, etc. He seems to have feared that the Governor of Surat (from whom, as also from the Dutch,1 these negotiations were kept secret) would be incensed at the idea of any such agreement and would manifest his anger by hindering the embarkation of the English goods. Moreover, he proposed to take with him the vessel intended for England, in order that she might carry home the news of the pacification. It was, therefore, the end of December before the final arrangements were made. Fremlen was to be left in charge at Surat as provisional President ; and Methwold was to proceed to Goa with the Jonas (bound for England under Captain Weddell), the Palsgrave and Intelligence (both intended for Bantam), and the Hopewell, which was to bring him back. Meanwhile the London and Blessing were dispatched on a voyage to Gombroon with freight goods.

A letter to the Company written by Methwold in Goa Road (p. 89) gives a full account of the visit. The English vessels reached that place on January 6, 1635, and were received with every sign of welcome. Next day the President went ashore, where he was met by the Viceroy’s son and the chief officials, and conducted with much ceremony to a stately house in Panjim (New Goa), where the English were to lodge during their abode on land. On the 8th the credentials of both parties were examined, and on that or the following day the wording of the agreement was settled to their mutual satisfaction. This provided for a cessation of arms until the Kings of England and Spain should denounce the Accord, in which case six months’ notice was to be given before hostilities were recommenced, in order to allow the merchants on both sides to secure themselves from loss. All being ready, on Saturday, January 10, the English representatives were conducted to the palace at Goa itself, and admitted to the presence of the Viceroy, who received them with much affability. He then, though far from well, held a private conference with Methwold of two hours’ duration, in the course of which he made many inquiries concerning the Dutch and their trade, and manifested a great desire for cordial relations with the English, offering them the use of all the Portuguese harbours, supplies of naval stores, and every other accommodation in his power. After this, the Accord was solemnly sworn and subscribed on both sides; and thus the attitude of hostility in which Portuguese and English in the East had stood for more than thirty years was changed into one of friendliness and mutual assistance. The pacification thus effected has lasted without a break down to the present time.

Another week was spent in business and recreation, and then, after a further interview with the Viceroy, Methwold and his companions embarked for Surat, while Weddell in the Jonas, accompanied by Nathaniel Mountney and other home-seeking members of the Surat factory, set sail for England, where they arrived at the beginning of August, 1635. In the letters which she carried, Methwold and his colleagues made some noteworthy suggestions. It was proposed to abandon Surat and transfer the English headquarters to Ahmadābād, as being a more convenient centre of trade, using Cambay and Goghā as the corresponding ports; in this way, it was pointed out, the expensive and dangerous land journey down to Surat would be saved. The Company was urged to send out annually four ships, two of which were to carry English goods direct to Goa and there lade Malabar pepper for the return voyage ; while the other two were to go on to Gujarāt, where, it was hoped, sufficient cargo could be obtained to dispatch that number of vessels to England yearly. A factor was to be stationed at Goa, and it was even thought that, once a permanent peace was concluded, the Company's 'cheife residency might be established' in that city. Further, it was suggested that, under the new conditions of trade, the Committees might find it advantageous to freight ships for India instead of building their own ; and this experiment was duly made a few years later (Court Minutes, 1635-39, p. xxix).

The letters in which the Conde de Linhares on his side announced to King Philip the conclusion of the truce have been printed in Biker's Collecçao de Tratados (vol. i. pp. 264, 269). Towards the end of 1635 the arrival of a new Viceroy, in the person of Pero da Silva, created some anxiety as to his attitude towards the agreement ; but, although he found much to criticize in the administration of his predecessor, he deemed it prudent to abstain from interference in this respect, since, as he explained to his royal master, it was undoubtedly better to have one enemy to fight than two (Lisbon Transcripts, Doc. Remett., book 33, ff. 61, 247). In point of fact, the aggressive attitude of the Hollanders did much to consolidate the Anglo-Portuguese understanding ; while private interests assisted materially. The fact that Portuguese goods in English vessels were generally safe from Dutch attacks was quickly turned to advantage ; and we find constant reference to ventures made in this way to various ports by the Portuguese officials, or goods demanded for their use.

In England the truce was warmly approved by the Company, who were only too glad to be rid of an expensive feud; and at their instigation King Charles directed his ambassador at Madrid to endeavour to obtain the ratification of the agreement. But in the Peninsula they seldom do things in a hurry ; and no positive decision had been reached when in 1640 the Portuguese nation relieved the Spanish King of any need of further attention to its affairs in the East Indies or elsewhere. Once the independence of Portugal was established, the desire for English support quickly brought about a treaty between the two countries (May, 1642), and by clause xii of this document the pacification concluded by Methwold and Linhares seven years earlier was formerly approved and continued.

Reverting to India and to 1635, we find the Hopewell dispatched in March to Gombroon with freight goods, and with instructions to proceed thence to meet the fleet from England; while in the same month the Reformation departed for Goa (where she was to leave some copper for sale to the Portuguese), Sumatra, and Bantam. Shortly afterwards the London started for Macao, in China, with Bornford and two other merchants as supercargoes. This voyage—the first English venture to China—was the outcome of the Anglo-Portuguese accord, and had in fact been suggested to Methwold by the Viceroy, who was willing to pay handsomely for the transport from Macao of a quantity of goods and ordnance which had long been lying there but could not be brought away in a Portuguese vessel, owing to the presence of a Dutch squadron in the Straits of Malacca. On this errand (which was naturally kept secret from the Dutch) she sailed on April 9. In the middle of the same month the Blessing left Swally for Bantam, carrying a quantity of silk for transmission to England from the latter port. She returned in November with a small cargo, and was then sent to Gombroon.

Another result of the Anglo-Portuguese entente was the building of two pinnaces—the Francis and Michael—at Damān, and two smaller boats—the Bassein and the Kit—at Bassein. These proved very useful for coasting voyages and river work, and may be said to have been to some extent the precursors of the famous Bombay Marine of later days. For similar purposes the President and Council asked the Company (p. 149) to provide them with two English-built pinnaces, armed with eight or ten guns, which they thought could be built at home for a third of what they would cost in India. An interesting project for employing vessels of this class in keeping the mouth of the Tāptī free of the Malabar pirates that infested it at certain seasons is mentioned at p. 312. Nothing came of it at the time, but it foreshadowed later developments of considerable importance.

On April 14, 1635, news reached Surat that the indigo monopoly had been dissolved and that the purchase of that commodity was consequently open once again to all comers. However, prices were still too high to tempt the English merchants to invest, especially as it would be many months before they could send a ship for England. Later in the year some purchases were made at Ahmadābād, but these were chiefly entered into for the purpose of interfering with the investments of the Dutch. The same unfriendly rivalry took place at Agra.

The changed attitude of the English towards the Portuguese, and Methwold’s schemes in relation to Ahmadābād and Cambay, excited both anger and apprehension in the minds of the Surat officials and merchants. Their port had benefited largely by the commerce of the foreigners, and the prospect of any portion of it being diverted to other localities was not to be contemplated with equanimity. Naturally, the Dutch did not miss the opportunity of pointing out the injurious effects likely to result from the Accord ; and, thus encouraged, Mīr Mūsā, the Governor of Surat, submitted a hostile report on the subject to the Emperor. But the latter needed no incitement ; the ambition he cherished of bringing the whole of India under his sceptre involved the subjugation at some time or other of the territory occupied by the Portuguese, and anything that tended to thwart this scheme was likely to be distasteful. He wrote, therefore, a reply (April, 1635) in which he expressed strong disapproval of the new alliance and directed Mīr Mūsā to inquire from the Dutch chief at Surat whether his superiors at Batavia were prepared to take the place of the English in India, if the latter were excluded from all trade both in the dominions of the Mogul and (by his influence) in those of the Kings of Golconda and Bījāpur ; and further, whether the Dutch would join in an attack on the Portuguese settlements at Diu and Damān. If they were willing to agree to these terms, he was quite prepared to give the English the alternatives of cancelling the treaty or of being expelled from his dominions. The King of Persia, he said, was likewise much disturbed by the news, fearing a Portuguese attack on Ormus. In forwarding to the Governor-General a copy of this letter, Pieterszoon made no secret of his own wish to see the English thus excluded from the commerce of India, though he recognized that awkward complications might ensue. The authorities at Batavia, however, were not inclined to allow themselves to be drawn into any entanglements of the kind. Obviously the English would retaliate upon Indian shipping and then the Dutch would be called upon to protect the latter, which could only be done at the risk of war. Pieterszoon was therefore instructed (August 21/31, 1635) to inform Shāh Jahān that the Dutch could not engage in hostilities against the English without permission from Holland, but the matter would be submitted to the home authorities. This indefinite postponement put an end to the scheme.1

The advantage of being able now to make use of the Portuguese harbours as places of shelter was strikingly demonstrated about this time. The Discovery and Speedwell, which had reached Gombroon on March 28, 1635, bringing passengers and freight goods from Masulipatam, left again in the middle of April; and as it was hopeless to expect to get to Surat at that period of the year, it was decided that the former should go into Bombay, where she was warmly welcomed by the Portuguese. The Speedwell, after visiting Goa for the purpose of obtaining a new mainmast, held on her voyage for Masulipatam. The Discovery remained at her place of refuge, snugly berthed at Trombay, during the whole of the rainy reason; while her men enjoyed themselves hugely on shore, though with fatal consequences to most of them. It was nearly the end of September when the ship took her departure for Surat, where she arrived a month later.

In order to provide calico for England and the Southwards, the factories at Baroda and Ahmadābād were reopened (with borrowed money) in September, 1635, the former under Thomas Thimbleby and the latter under Benjamin Robinson. Orders were also sent to an Indian broker at Agra to invest 10,000 rupees in the piece-goods of the neighbouring districts; while at Surat itself similar purchases were set on foot.

Towards the end of 1635 a particularly interesting experiment was entered upon by the dispatch of a couple of vessels to Lārībandar (termed by the Portuguese Diul-Sind), the port of Tatta in the Indus Delta. The first (and until the present venture the only) English ship to visit that port was the Expedition (260 tons), which, under the command of Christopher Newport, landed Sir Robert Sherley there in the autumn of 1613, but failed to obtain permission to trade, owing to the opposition of the Portuguese (Purchas His Pilgrimes, vol. i. pp. 495, 530). A further attempt was contemplated by Sir Thomas Roe, and Āsaf Khān promised his assistance; but the strength of the Portuguese in those waters was held to be an insuperable obstacle. Still, the project was always borne in mind; and in 1629, on receipt of some overtures from the Tatta merchants, a native broker was dispatched from Surat to investigate and report (see the 1624–29 volume, p. 326). After an absence of several months he returned with patterns of piece-goods, indigo, etc., which were sent to England for the information of the Company. It was probably in connexion with that venture that the royal farmān and the letters from Āsaf Khān referred to on p. 117 were obtained. Nothing, however, came of this at the time, though a Dutch vessel paid a visit to Lārībandar in 1631 (see the last volume, p. 207). Now that the agreement with the Portuguese had removed the fear of violence on their part, the scheme was revived; and letters were written to some brokers in Tatta, commissioning them to buy a quantity of calicoes in anticipation of the coming of an English ship later in the year. Shortly after arrived a parwāna from Āsaf Khān, who was Sūbadār of the province of Sind, guaranteeing the English the same privileges there as they enjoyed in other parts of the Mogul’s dominions; and in September a letter was received from the Company expressly directing that the attempt should be made. Thereupon it was determined to send thither the Discovery and the Bassein. The direction of the enterprise was entrusted to William Fremlen, assisted by two other factors; and the vessels sailed at the beginning of November. The Discovery, it was arranged, was to go on to Gombroon, after landing the merchants and taking in any freight that could be obtained.

On the 19th of the same month the William reached Surat from England. Another vessel, the Crispiana, had started with her for the same destination, but had met with baffling winds that finally obliged her to bear up for Masulipatam, where she arrived at the end of May, 1636, after a voyage of over fourteen months. Her failure to reach Surat was embarrassing, not only because she was suspected by the Indians of the piracies shortly to be related, but also because she had on board a considerable portion of the treasure intended for that place. The Hopewell had met the William at St. Augustine's Bay (in Madagascar), but lost company and did not arrive at Swally till November 21. On the same day a Dutch fleet came in from Persia ; and, finding that they were offering copper and redwood at a cheap rate, the English bought a considerable quantity of each. The latter commodity was dispatched to Sind in the Hopewell, while the copper was sent to Goa by the William, under the charge of George Peirson, who had come out in that vessel and had been appointed on arrival Warehousekeeper and Member of Council. The main purpose of his mission, however, was to fetch a quantity of pepper which the Portuguese had promised to provide ; in this he was unsuccessful, though he brought back hopes that half the stipulated quantity would be forthcoming later. The William was then (February 4, 1636) sent on to Gombroon with native merchants and their goods.

Towards the end of 1635 a change of Governors occurred at Surat. Mīr Mūsā (Muizz-ul-Mulk), who had occupied the post since the spring of 1629, was recalled and the Hakīm Masīh-uz-Zamān appointed in his place. In a Dutch letter of the time we have the following account of the new official : 'He is about sixty years of age, very grey, and of a grave and venerable aspect. A Persian by birth, he has served the late and the present King for many years as a physician, as well as in carrying His Majesty's offerings to the grave of the Prophet and in other offices. He is highly esteemed by the King, who has given him a jāgīr of five lakhs of mahmūdīs, out of which he is supposed to provide three or four thousand horsemen, though he really keeps only from two to three hundred in his service. He is a great friend of the Nawāb Āsaf Khān' (Hague Transcripts, series i. vol. x. no. 333 ; also Dagh-Register, 1636, p. 49). It was rather a bad omen for the English that the Hakīm had been one of the returning pilgrims captured by them in the Surat junks in 1623 (see the 1622–23 volume, p. 273) ; and there were other reasons for his maintaining an attitude of suspicion, if not of hostility, towards them. The recent expeditions to Tatta, Goa, Dābhol, etc., had increased the alarm felt at Surat regarding the intentions of the English ; and moreover it was known that they were in correspondence with the late Governor (who appears to have retained control of Cambay, Broach, etc.), and that Methwold was still bent upon embarking goods from Ahmadābād and up-country at Cambay, to the obvious detriment of the customs revenue of Surat. To keep the latter up to its normal figure, and if possible to increase it, was a matter of the utmost importance to the local officials; nor could the leading merchants view with equanimity the prospect of any diversion of trade from their port. A Dutch letter written from Surat in January, 1636, summarized in the Batavia Dagh-Register, 1636 (p. 49), declared that the new Governor had already obtained a farmān from the Emperor forbidding the use of Cambay or Broach as ports for the embarkation of goods. It appears, however, that the writer was misinformed; for no reference to the matter can be traced in the English records, and on the contrary we find Methwold dispatching the Kit to Cambay at a later date to fetch some goods. In any case, steps had evidently been taken to frustrate any measures of this kind; for in February the Dutch and English at Surat were summoned to hear the contents of two royal farmāns. The first repeated the announcement that the indigo trade was open to all comers. The second ordered each nation to deposit twelve lakhs of rupees at Surat: forbade their ships visiting that port to anchor elsewhere than in Swally Hole: prohibited the building of frigates in India: and required that the English and Dutch chiefs should remain permanently in the city until relieved by their successors. Methwold at once declared that for their part the English would never submit to any conditions of the kind; the Dutch, too, remonstrated strongly, though they were privately assured that the farmān was only intended to curb their rivals; and in the face of this joint opposition the demands were quietly dropped.

Meanwhile the Discovery, after much trouble, had with the opportune aid of some Portuguese frigates found her way to the mouth of the Indus, and on December 3, 1635, Fremlen and his companions landed at Lārībandar. They were well received by the officials and merchants, who were in hopes that by sending their goods to Gombroon in English vessels they would be able to escape the payment of the duty levied by the Portuguese on ships navigating those waters. In this, however, they were disappointed, for the President and Council had given strict orders that nothing should be done which would deprive their new allies of any dues they had hitherto received. After staying a few days at the port, the English factors proceeded to Tatta, where again they were cordially welcomed. However, the merchants could not be induced to put any goods aboard the Discovery for Persia, as they feared that by so doing they would expose themselves to reprisals at the hands of the Portuguese ; and Fremlen found himself forced to buy instead a quantity of rice and cotton wool for sale at Gombroon. With this merchandise the Discovery departed for Persia on January 6, 1636, leaving behind her the Bassein and also the Hopewell, which had arrived a week before Christmas. Meanwhile Fremlen had dispatched overland to Surat a letter (p. 126) giving a hopeful account of the trade of the district, and dwelling on the additional advantage of bringing goods from Agra by way of Multān and thence down the Indus. The Bassein was sent back to Surat with a few goods ; and was immediately dispatched again to Lārībandar with a quantity of lead, etc. She failed, however, to reach that port, owing to contrary winds, and returned to Surat on March 8. Fremlen mentions a project of employing the Hopewell, while waiting, in a voyage to Cutch 'for discovery'; but apparently this intention was not carried out. The factors, after placing the remainder of their goods and cash in the hands of an Indian broker, left Tatta on February 23, and embarked a few days later in the Hopewell. After a hazardous voyage they reached Surat early in April.

At the beginning of 1636 William Pitt started in the Francis for Dābhol with a stock of goods for sale and letters soliciting the grant of trading privileges from the King of Bījāpur. He returned early in February without the desired farmān, and was again dispatched to the same place a month later. At the end of April Joseph Downham was sent to assist him, and both factors were still there when the volume closes.

Another attempt made at this time to open up a fresh trading centre was a venture to Basrā, in the Persian Gulf. However, the Michael, which had been told off for this service, started too late in the season and, being also in a very leaky state, was forced to abandon the attempt (April, 1636).

In the middle of February news reached Surat that the London had got back to Goa from China. Of the events of the voyage an interesting account is given in a letter from Bornford printed at p. 226. Macao was reached on July 23, 1635. There had been no difficulty in securing a good freight at Goa, for every one, from the Viceroy downwards, was eager to profit by the opportunity of so safe a conveyance; nor was there any backwardness on the part of the Macao merchants in providing a return cargo. In fact, so anxious were they to send their goods to Goa that the English were unable to lade all they intended to carry on their own account. However, they did not lose any opportunity either of buying commodities or of making observations which might be useful at a later date. The Viceroy had been careful to take precautions in the latter respect, for strict orders had been given that the English were not to be allowed to land or to have any dealings with the Chinese except through the Portuguese officials. But it was easier to make regulations than to enforce them. Bornford and his companions had not come five thousand miles to act as carriers merely. Not only did they insist on living ashore, but they took every opportunity of communicating with the Chinese; and they even did their best to obtain permission from the latter to trade on a future occasion at some spot nearer Canton. This behaviour gave great umbrage to the Portuguese, and the new Viceroy wrote home censuring his predecessor for permitting the English to make such a voyage; while even Linhares himself expressed doubts whether it would be wise to repeat the experiment.1

Having spent close upon three months at Macao, the London sailed again on October 20, and after touching at Malacca (which was found to be ‘wholey ruined’ by the Dutch blockade of the Straits) reached Goa on January 27, 1636. The delivery of her goods and the recovery of the sums due for freight proved a tedious business; and when, in obedience to orders from the President and Council, the London quitted Goa for Swally, two of the merchants had to be left behind to clear accounts. The Portuguese had insisted on the customs of Malacca being paid, as well as those of Macao and Goa; and this considerably reduced the profit on the voyage. In the opinion of the Surat factors (p. 211) a second venture would not be worth making if they had to depend on freight alone; but if allowed to trade freely at Macao ‘it would be worth the following’. Bornford himself was optimistic on the point; but he thought that another time it would be desirable to ignore Macao and endeavour to open up trade at some place nearer to Canton (p. 228). However, Weddell's voyage in that direction, together with the opposition of the Portuguese, prevented the attempt being followed up by the Company's servants.

The President and Council had meanwhile been pushing forward their arrangements for lading the Discovery for her return voyage to England. Part of her cargo had been provided by the arrival of the Blessing from Gombroon on January 28, 1636, with a good quantity of silk; the rest was to be composed partly of the commodities the vessel herself was expected to bring from Persia and Sind, and partly of the purchases made in India. But the weeks wore on without news of her, and it was not until the middle of March that she put in an appearance. In the meantime the Blessing had made a voyage to Goa in quest of pepper, but only to be disappointed, as the Portuguese had still none to spare. The Hopewell had yet to be waited for and, as we have seen, she did not arrive till early in April. With the aid of her cargo and the caravan of indigo and saltpetre from Ahmadābād which was rapidly nearing Surat, the lading of the Discovery would be completed; and on April 6 Methwold returned from Swally to Surat to finish the letters which were to be sent in her to the Company. Little did he dream, as his coach bumped over the rough road between the two places, of what was in store for him on arrival.

For the beginning of the story we must look back to the summer of 1633, when, as related in the last volume, His Majesty's ship Seahorse returned to England after a marauding cruise in the East Indies, in the course of which some native junks had been plundered of all their more valuable goods. In spite of this, the financial result of the voyage appears to have been far from satisfactory; and, in addition, the fact that peace had now been concluded with Spain and Portugal removed the sole pretext under which a vessel of the Royal Navy could decently be sent to those waters for warlike purposes. Accordingly we hear nothing of any repetition of the venture on the part of the King. This, however, did not deter others from laying plans for a similar enterprise. Two young London merchants, Thomas Kynaston and Samuel Bonnell,1 provided the funds; while the task of obtaining a royal commission, without which it would be dangerous to infringe the East India Company's monopoly, was undertaken by Endymion Porter, an influential member of the royal household. Apparently the King made no difficulty in the matter. Trading was not the object of the expedition, and so it might plausibly be argued that no injury would be done to the Company's commerce. The constant warfare waged against all Christians by the Barbary corsairs, and the fact that hundreds of English captives were living in slavery in Northern Africa, would be held sufficient justification for attacking the subjects of any Muhammadan nation with whom this country had no settled commerce; whilst in the case where such relations existed the wording of the commission might be considered to afford the requisite protection. A wiser monarch would have reflected that men whose object was to plunder were not likely to be scrupulous in this respect; but apparently Charles gave the subject little attention and granted without demur the request of his favourite. Thereupon two small ships—the Samaritan (250 tons) and the Roebuck (100)—were hired and equipped with the greatest secrecy. As a blind, a royal commission was issued to Richard Ofield or Oldfield, master of the former vessel, authorizing him to 'range and discover' the coast of America; but a further commission, dated only two days later (February 27, 1635), made out in the name of William Cobb as commander of both vessels, widened the sphere of operations to 'all the wourld over', and warranted the capture of the goods of all 'infidells or of anie other prince, potentat, or state not in league or amitie with Us beyond the lyne equinoctiall' (p. 268).2 Both vessels were permitted to wear the colours of the Royal Navy, and all English subjects were commanded to render their commander any assistance he might require. With these powerful credentials, they sailed from the Thames in April, 1635, without the East India Company having the slightest inkling of their intentions.

Misfortunes soon befel the expedition, for the two ships got separated after passing the Cape, and the Samaritan went to pieces on the island of Mohilla, one of the Comoro group. The crew, however, reached the shore in safety, where Cobb set them to work to build a small sloop in which to get away. Meanwhile the Roebuck had continued her voyage, under the master, William Ayres. Early in September, 1635, she was in the Gulf of Aden and had taken and plundered an Arabian junk. On the evening of the fifth, she fell in with the Taufīqī of Surat, and at once attacked her; but the Indian vessel was provided with ordnance and maintained a spirited defence. Next morning the stranger hoisted an English flag, to the joy of the Indians, who little suspected her real character. The skipper of the Taufīqī at once went on board and exhibited his pass from the factory at Surat. Ayres and his officers appear to have been rather taken aback by this document; but an excuse was quickly found for disregarding it.1 They pointed out that it was not signed by Methwold and did not bear the seal of the factory; this was true, but it was merely due to the fact that the document had been issued during Methwold's absence at Goa. However, though a pretext was thus found for disregarding the pass, it is clear that some doubt was felt as to the advisability of plundering a vessel belonging to Surat. Probably the consideration that Cobb alone was named in the royal commission, and that Ayres had consequently no authority except as his subordinate, had some weight in the decision, which was to take the prize, without interfering with anything on board, to Filuk, on the Abyssinian seaboard, where it was hoped that the Samaritan would be found. On the day after the two set sail with this purpose, another vessel was overhauled, viz. the Mahmūdī of Diu. She was provided with a Portuguese pass; but this was pronounced to be out of date, and the vessel was ordered to accompany the Roebuck and the Taufīqī. At Filuk there was of course no sign of the Samaritan, and after some delay it was resolved to seek her at Socotra. First, however, the Taufīqī was overhauled and all her goods and valuables were taken on board the English vessel. Some show of regularity was kept up, for most of the things taken were registered, as also the names of the owners; but the sailors evidently got a considerable amount of plunder in addition. In case the Taufīqī should lose company during the voyage to Socotra and should fall in with Cobb's vessel, a pass was given to her, addressed to 'The Captain', and signed with a fictitious Dutch name. Naturally, she took the earliest opportunity of escaping; and when, after vainly essaying to reach Socotra, the Roebuck anchored at the neighbouring island of Abdulkūrī, she had only the Mahmūdī in company. A boat was sent to Socotra, and returned with the news that the Samaritan was not there; whereupon it was resolved to return to the coast of Arabia. Meanwhile, a minute inquisition was made on board the Diu junk for the money which was believed to be there; and failing to discover this, the officers of the Roebuck proceeded to more rigorous measures. They probably felt small scruple in dealing harshly with a vessel coming from a Portuguese settlement, for they were of course ignorant of the recent agreement between Methwold and the Viceroy. With scandalous inhumanity, they tortured the skipper and others until they revealed the place where the treasure was hidden. This appropriated, the junk was carried to the Arabian coast, and there released; while the Roebuck, after a further cruise, made her way to the Comoros.

A period of about six months elapsed before these outrages were known at Surat. The two junks put into Arabian ports, and from one of these the skipper of the Taufīqī, who had been carried to Abdulkūrī, and then put on board the Mahmūdī, wrote a long account of the piracies to Mīrzā Mahmūd, the principal of the merchants concerned (p. 197). This was received early in April, 1636, at a most unfortunate moment for the English factors, for (as already related) the Discovery was on the point of sailing for England, and the indigo and saltpetre which were to complete her lading had just reached Rānder, near Surat. Of the events which followed, we have a vivid description from the pen of Methwold himself (p. 232). On reaching Surat (April 6) he found the city in an uproar over the news. Thereupon he boldly went to the Governor, who was sitting in darbār with the chief sufferers around him, 'some lookeing thorough mee with eyes sparkling with indignation, others halfe dead in the sense of their losses.’ The President was closely questioned as to the whereabouts of the Company’s ships, particularly the Crispiana, which was known to have been for a long time expected by the English. His explanations were received with rage and incredulity; but he coolly pointed out the injustice of requiring compensation from the Company until it was ascertained that the piracy was committed by their shipping, and suggested that the arrival of the Taufīqī (which was expected every day) should be awaited before anything further was done. This appeared to be reasonable, and Methwold was allowed to depart to the English factory, though a strong guard was placed upon him there, and the English goods at Rānder were detained. In order to secure the release of these and the consequent sailing of the Discovery, Methwold agreed to deposit a lakh of rupees to meet any claims that might be established against the Company, should it be proved that one of their ships had been guilty of the outrage; and, for the purpose of settling the transaction, on the 8th he and Peirson (the only other Member of Council in Surat) proceeded to the Governor’s house. There it was suggested that the claims should be paid forthwith; but Methwold neatly countered this by declaring his readiness to do so, provided that the Governor, or some other man of substance, would undertake to reimburse the English, should they be found to be innocent after all. Of course no one was willing to incur this responsibility, and so the proposal was dropped. The Governor, however, professed himself dissatisfied with the amount of the deposit and demanded that it should be raised to three lakhs. This was refused; and thereupon the President and his companion were thrust into a dungeon filthy with vermin, where they were almost suffocated for want of air. Three days later, their sufferings were alleviated by the provision of a little ventilation; but they had still to endure the revilings and threats of the populace. On April 15 the Taufīqī arrived, and the story told by the crew increased the general indignation. Next day Methwold was summoned to the Governor’s presence and allowed to cross-examine the skipper, but without any satisfactory result, as the latter persisted that the men who had robbed his vessel were English; and the President was roundly told that he would have to make good all the losses, in accordance with the agreement concluded in 1624 (see the volume for 1624–29, p. 28), by which the Company's servants had undertaken full responsibility for any offences committed by Englishmen. For the present he was remanded to prison. That same evening he learnt from a friendly Dutch factor that the pass given by the pirates (the production of which he had vainly demanded from the Indian skipper) had been brought to the Dutch house for translation. By the help of the Shāhbandar, this document was traced and shown to the President; and an examination of it shattered the theory he had till then stoutly maintained that the piracy was the work of one of two French vessels which had been seen in Indian waters in the autumn of 1634. The claims of those who had been robbed were now investigated (though Methwold refused to take any part in the proceedings), with the result that the total was found to be 107,000 rupees.1 The English goods and money at Surat were estimated at 75,000 rupees, and this sum was made up to 125,000 rupees by drawing on the stock aboard the ships. Thereupon the claims were paid; and then the indigo and saltpetre detained at Rānder were released and put on board the Discovery. Methwold and Peirson were still treated as prisoners, pending the decision of the Mogul on the further claims arising from the capture of the Diu junk; but they were permitted to go daily under guard to the English factory to deal with current business. Meanwhile, at Ahmadābād, where the Governor and some of the principal merchants alleged that they were interested in the cargo of the Diu ship, Robinson, the chief factor, had been arrested and the factory placed under a guard, until security was given that the English would not leave the city before the arrival of orders from the Great Mogul. In addition, the Company's goods which were in the hands of native brokers at Agra and Tatta were inventoried and sequestrated until further orders.

The Discovery sailed for England on May 4; and with her went the Blessing, which had been ordered to search for and seize the pirates, in order to prevent their doing any further mischief. The Hopewell was also dispatched to the West Coast of Sumatra and the London to Masulipatam and Bantam; while the pinnace Michael was sent to Dābhol, to be laid up there for the rainy season.

A farmān from the Emperor reached Surat on May 4 (p. 256), which made no allusion to the claims on account of the Diu junk, but directed that the English should be kept under surveillance; however, Methwold's daily resort to the factory was stopped and he was once again kept in close confinement. The Governor was incensed by the news that the William, on her return from Persia, had put into Dābhol instead of coming to Surat, and had proceeded thence direct to Masulipatam, to the detriment of his customs revenue; while his anger was not lessened by the President's refusal to admit his personal claim for the repayment of a sum of money taken from him in 1623, at the time when he was a passenger on the junks seized by the English (see the 1622–23 volume, p. 273). However, the hour of at least formal reconciliation was near. Investigation showed that the Governor's claim was probably correct, and clearly it was not desirable to incur his continued resentment for a matter of about 850l. On the other hand, the Surat merchants had a number of ships ready for dispatch to various ports, and they were disturbed at the threats which Methwold had used of redressing the wrongs of the English by action at sea. On June 1, therefore, overtures were made for a settlement. Methwold was to be released, provided he would swear to two conditions: first, that he would not leave Surat without acquainting the Governor; and secondly, that no seizure should be made of the Surat shipping. He insisted that the latter restriction should not apply in the event of orders to the contrary arriving from England; and this being conceded, on the following day he took the required oath. Then he was conducted to the Governor, who professed pleasure at the termination of the dispute and distributed gifts to the English merchants and their broker. Finally, Methwold was escorted to the factory by the chief officials and merchants, and a salute was fired to announce the reconciliation. Thus, after eight weeks' imprisonment, he was once more a free man (p. 254).

Shortly after, a representative of those who had been plundered in the Diu junk applied to the Governor for redress; but the Suratīs, having recovered their own losses, were indifferent to those of others and did not intend to quarrel with the English on their account; the complainant was therefore referred to the Viceroy of Goa. Representations had already been made in that quarter, for on May 11 Methwold received from that official a bundle of attestations, with a demand for 117,000 rials of eight in compensation. For the present the Viceroy was put off with excuses; but the English were rather disturbed at the probable consequences, inasmuch as they had a large sum deposited in the hands of the Vedor da Fazenda at Goa and feared that it would be seized in satisfaction.

Methwold had entertained the idea of paying a visit to the Emperor in the Deccan, partly to place the position of the English on a more satisfactory footing, and partly in order to secure the payment of a sum claimed from the Rājā of Būndī for tapestry sold to his grandfather some years before. The events at Surat had put this out of the question; and so in the middle of May, 1636, John Drake was dispatched instead. His special errand was the recovery of the aforesaid debt—a matter with which he was already conversant, as he had been sent to Burhānpur for the same purpose in November, 1634 (p. 54), though without success; but the President and Council took the opportunity of writing to Āsaf Khān and Afzal Khān to complain of the treatment they had received from the Governor of Surat, whose predecessor, Mīr Mūsā, was (as they well knew) busily intriguing against him at court. Drake found the Mogul army encamped near Aurangābād (June, 1636). The Deccan campaign was practically over, for the King of Bījāpur had submitted and had agreed to pay a large sum as arrears of tribute (p. 263); and before long the Emperor proceeded to Māndū to shoot tigers (p. 287). Drake followed the army, which was moving thither more slowly. According to him, in the crossing of the Tāptī at Burhānpur over 2,000 lives were lost, besides a much valued elephant which had come from Bījāpur (p. 281). The English factor's negotiations dragged on very slowly. Āsaf Khān showed himself well disposed and granted parwānas for the release of the English goods at Tatta and other places; but he would not hear of their embarking goods at Cambay, nor would he listen to anything to the detriment of the Governor of Surat. As regards the tapestry debt, Drake was promised a farmān directing its payment, but later on he was told that the Emperor would be passing through the Rājā's territory and that it would be better to wait till then before taking any steps. Drake saw nothing for it but to follow the royal camp, and this he decided to do, while grumbling bitterly at the consequent hardships. Mention is made (p. 288) of a royal command procured by the Governor of Surat, prohibiting the English and Dutch from carrying weapons of any kind while within the city; Methwold and his colleagues determined not to submit to any regulation of the kind, but we hear nothing more on the subject. Towards the end of November Drake wrote from Ajmer, announcing his intention of departing for Agra. He had been unable to get any assistance from Āsaf Khān in the matter of the tapestry debt; and, although the Rājā's infant son had arrived in the camp with a present for the Emperor, no satisfaction could be obtained from the members of his retinue (p. 320). Evidently Drake carried out his intention before long, for he was at Agra in the early part of 1637, and it was just after leaving that city for Surat in March of that year that he received his death-wound in a brawl with some villagers.

In July, 1636, intelligence reached the Surat factory that the pirates, of whom the Blessing was in search, had been seen at the Comoro Islands by the Crispiana. That vessel reached Johanna on February 20 and Ayres arrived there with the Roebuck nine days later. He exhibited the royal commission, and Thomas Lee, the master of the Crispiana, though the doings of Ayres were common talk, preferred to follow Dogberry's method of dealing with a thief. However, there were other servants of the Company who were made of sterner stuff. In June the Swan, outward-bound, reached the same island. The Roebuck was still there, and Ayres had been joined by Cobb, who had come over from Mohilla with the survivors of his crew. John Proud, the young commander of the Swan, was at first satisfied (as Lee had been) by the terms of the royal commission; but, hearing afterwards of the captures that had been made, he took the opportunity of Cobb and Ayres coming on board for supplies to arrest them both. A boat was then sent ashore to fetch the money and goods of the Roebuck, which was being careened; but her crew stoutly refused to part with their plunder, and threatened to fire on the men of the Swan, who thereupon returned. Next day a fresh attempt was made, when David Jones,1 the mate of the Roebuck, declined to hand over anything except under the orders of his captain; and those orders Cobb refused to give. Proud thereupon offered to set the latter free, if he would give a written declaration that King Charles would be responsible for all damages accruing to the Company from the proceedings of his ships. To this Cobb at first assented; but on seeing that the draft made mention of the seizure of the junks he refused to sign, saying that Ayres must be responsible for his own actions. He was willing, however, that Ayres should be carried to India, together with the money taken from the Surat junk. This was agreed to, and on the following day Cobb and Ayres sent ashore a written order for the surrender of the plunder. Jones and his men, however, swore that they would part with nothing; and when Cobb went himself to enforce his order, they fired on him and his companions. This led to further negotiations, and in the end it was arranged that the money and goods taken from the Taufīqī should be handed over to Proud, on condition that, should it be found that they were after all lawful prize, they should revert to the promoters of the voyage. It was also agreed that, instead of Ayres, the recalcitrant Jones and another member of the Roebuck's crew should be taken to India as witnesses; but as the former flatly refused to go, Proud had in the end to be content with the coxswain, John Vincent. This settled, the pirates' booty, amounting to nearly 39,000 rials,2 was handed over to Proud, and by him carried to Masulipatam. The plunder from the Diu junk was, it would seem, left in the possession of the pirates.

Proud had acted with great vigour and courage, and on his return to England the Company presented him with 100l. in token of its appreciation. Some dissatisfaction was expressed in India that he did not seize the Roebuck as well as her ill-gotten booty; but he probably acted wisely in contenting himself with the latter. It would have been a risky matter to impound a vessel bearing a royal commission and sailing under the royal flag ; and, moreover, it is by no means certain that his crew would have supported him in attacking a band of desperate men.

The Mary from England reached Swally at the beginning of October, 1636 ; and a few days later the Blessing came in. She had arrived at Johanna too late to achieve her errand, for the Roebuck had sailed a fortnight before, bound for the Red Sea. White followed as far as Socotra, and then, finding no trace of the pirates, made for Surat. Ominous rumours were soon afloat that several more junks had been captured, including two of Diu ; and on the news being confirmed by a complaint from the Captain of that city, it was decided to send the Blessing once more to the Comoros—this time to Mohilla, where Cobb's stores were known to be deposited. On this errand she departed October 20. Mohilla was reached four days before Christmas. Learning that Cobb was at Johanna, White endeavoured next day to make that island, but was unable to do so, owing to contrary winds and currents. Cobb, however, put to sea in alarm, and soon placed a safe distance between himself and his pursuers. The chase was given up as hopeless, and the Blessing went to Mozambique to refit. There she remained for nearly three months, and then proceeded, by way of the Comoros, to Masulipatam, which was reached on June 12, 1637. Meanwhile, the Roebuck had made her way home and had arrived at Falmouth early in May, 1637.

On October 25, 1636, Bornford was sent to Goa to recover the money which had been left in the hands of the Vedor da Fazenda there. How far he succeeded in his errand is not stated in the documents here calendared ; but it appears from other sources that the authorities detained the money pending the result of an action which had been brought against the English for the losses consequent on the piracies. The Mary sailed for Persia on November 29, chiefly laden with freight goods—that ‘ very carriers trade ’ which the Company were denouncing about this time in a letter to Masulipatam (p. 317). Ten days later news came of the arrival of the Swan from Masulipatam. Towards the close of December she departed for Dābhol.

It was not until December, 1636, that the East India Company learnt (from letters brought by the Discovery) of the depredations of the Roebuck and the consequent imprisonment of the President at Surat. After some preliminary inquiries, a petition was presented to the Privy Council, praying for redress ; and the King thereupon consented to write a letter to the Great Mogul, disavowing this 'infamous piracie' and declaring his intention of punishing the guilty parties. The indignant Company pursued the matter with vigour and, disregarding all hints from court, brought an action in the Admiralty Court against Kynaston and Bonnell for promoting the voyage. The latter fled to France, but his associate was arrested and lodged in prison, until Charles (no doubt at the instigation of Porter) interfered and ordered his release on bail. Other devices were made use of for delaying the issue, and even when the Roebuck got back to England (May, 1637) with, it was said, 30,000l. or 40,000l. on board, no satisfaction could be obtained ; and gradually the case passed into the long catalogue of unredressed grievances.1

But long before they heard of the piracies of Cobb and Ayres, the members of the Company had been startled by a far more important development of the schemes of Porter and his associates, namely, the establishment under royal patronage of what was practically a rival trading body ; and this invasion of their privileges was all the harder to bear because the intention was largely to exploit the benefits obtained by Methwold's agreement with the Viceroy of Goa. As the reader will remember, Captain John Weddell and Nathaniel Mountney had accompanied the President to Goa on that occasion, and had then proceeded to England with the news, the one as captain and the other as chief merchant of the Jonas. Both—and especially Weddell—had grievances against their employers, and on the voyage home they seem to have framed a plan for using the new situation for their own advantage. The ship arrived in August, 1635, and Weddell evidently lost no time in getting into touch with Porter and his two City associates, to whom—as a large sum would be needed to launch the business on a sufficient scale—was soon added Sir William Courteen, one of the richest merchant-adventurers of the time. The King was easily induced to lend his countenance to the project. No doubt it was argued that the existing Company could hardly keep their present factories going, and certainly could not raise the necessary funds for a large extension of business : that their failure was due to faulty methods and lack of enterprise : that in any case there was plenty of room in the East for two English trading bodies : and that it was a patriotic duty to prevent the commerce of Portuguese India from being destroyed by the Dutch. By December, 1635, matters had so far advanced that a royal commission was issued to Weddell and Mountney for a voyage to Goa and elsewhere on the coast of India, and thereafter to Macao and possibly to Japan, notwithstanding any grant or patent formerly given to the East India Company or others; and in April, 1636, they sailed on this errand with six vessels—the Dragon (Captain Weddell), the Sun (Captain Richard Swanley), the Katherine (Captain John Carter), the Planter (Captain Edward Hall), and two pinnaces, the Anne and the Discovery. These four captains had all been in the service of the Company, as had also many of the factors employed in the expedition, including Nathaniel Mountney (cape merchant), John Mountney (accountant), Thomas Robinson, Edward Knipe, Anthony Vernworthy, Henry Glascock, and Peter Mundy. The equipment of the fleet is said to have cost over 120,000l.

Thus was initiated the so-called ‘ Courteen’s Association ’, which was destined to do a great deal of harm to the existing Company and still more to its own promoters. On the latter result the Committees confidently counted—‘ wee hope ’ they wrote (p. 261) ‘ the East India Companie maie stand and florish when these new undertakers maie bee wearie of what they have taken in hand, when they have (to their cost) well paid for the same ’—but meanwhile the blow was a severe one. The attitude of the King was especially discouraging. He knew very well the difficulties under which the Company was labouring, and the struggle they had had to find enough money to carry on a trade which was of great importance to the realm; yet he had not only allowed a powerful band of competitors to break the monopoly solemnly secured to the Company by a royal charter, but had further done everything in his power to secure the success of these interlopers. He had enrolled his name in the list of shareholders : had authorized their ships to use the royal flag : had written letters on their behalf to the Viceroy of Goa (to whom he at the same time sent a handsome present) and to the Dutch authorities at Batavia and elsewhere: and had ordered all British subjects to render them any assistance they might require. It was true that, upon complaining to His Majesty, the Governor and Deputy had been assured (through Lord Cottington), ‘upon the word of a King, and as hee is a Christian King,’ that no hindrance or damage was intended to the Company’s trade, and that Weddell’s fleet would not go to any place where the Company had commerce; but they had learnt by sad experience how little reliance could be placed on such assurances. As a matter of fact, Weddell’s commission permitted him to go to any place he pleased on the coast of India; and it is evident, both from the royal letters he carried, addressed to the President at Surat (p. 284 n.), and from a passage on p. 330, that a visit to the ports of Gujarāt was contemplated.1

Weddell’s fleet reached the Comoros in August, and the two principals wrote thence in friendly terms to Methwold and his colleagues at Surat (p. 284). To this letter replies were received at Goa, which was reached in October. The hand of Methwold is as visible in the official letter as in a private one which he addressed to Weddell at the same time; and his frank indignation with the promoters of the new venture roused the Captain’s wrath to boiling point. He answered in a furious epistle (p. 321), the tone of which contrasted oddly with the polite, yet sarcastic, reply which he signed in common with Mountney (p. 322). Methwold retorted briefly and forcibly on December 28 (p. 329); and there the correspondence ended.

The Agency of Masulipatam and its dependencies had reverted in 1633 to the control of the President and Council at Bantam, and it is therefore convenient once again to separate the transactions of the factories of the East coast from those of the establishments on the other side of India. We may premise that the records for the period now under review are regrettably meagre, especially as regards events in the new settlements in the Bay of Bengal. This is to some extent explained by the fact that all these were subordinate stations: so that the Bay factors gave account to the Masulipatam Agent, who in turn reported to the President at Bantam, whose business it was to advise the Company. In this filtration much of value was doubtless lost.

When, in April, 1633, Thomas Joyce was sent from Surat to Masulipatam as Agent, one of the matters specially commended to his attention was the proposal previously made 1 that the English should follow the example of the Dutch in compounding with the King of Golconda for all tolls and customs levied on their goods throughout his kingdom, both inland and at the port towns. The necessity of making a journey to the capital for this purpose postponed the attempt until the cold weather; and it seems to have been the beginning of 1634 when Joyce set out with a large train upon his mission to court. The letters describing the events of the embassy are no longer extant; but in a later one written to the Company on October 25, 1634 (p. 40), Joyce and Wyche referred to them as showing ‘how gratiosly His Majesty admitted us to his presence six severall times: what honour he did us in behalfe of our nation so longe as we remained in Gulcondah, and with what content and extraordinary freedome he gave us leave at last to depart from his royall citty, givinge us an ample firmaun for quiet trade in all parts of his kingdome without paying of any duties whatsoever’. They mention also the ‘unspeakeable courtesie’ received by them from ‘Elchibeague, a Persian borne, but now a chiefe peere of this kingdome’. ‘He entertaind us in his owne house (by the Kings leave, who had ordaind us a stately lodginge elswhere); tooke uppon him the pleading of our cause; continually accompanied us to His Majesties presence; gave us dyet for ourselves, servants, and cattell all the time that we were at court; saved the Company at least 5 or 600 pagodes, that was in a manner demanded as a due to the Kings officers at such times as we were invested; would never let us ride abroad without 50, 60, yea sometimes 100 of his owne horsemen to attend us; presented your Agent with a stately Persian horse, valued at 150l. sterling, and with an amberchee or necke jewell worth at least 50l. more, which were both the same day given to the King (beinge the second time that we saw him), who in leiw thereof returned a faire horse of this country breed of a farre inferiour price. . . . He alone was our mainest helpe we had for the procuration of those immunityes you are now possest of.’ In spite of this liberal assistance, the embassy cost the Company over 8,000 pagodas (p. 16); but the factors claimed that this amount was saved soon after in the duties that would otherwise have been paid on the cargo of a single ship (the Jewel).

The grant thus obtained, which was dated February 26, 1634,1 and was known as ‘The Golden Farmān’ from its bearing ‘the Kings great seale, impressed upon a leafe of gold’—possibly also with reference to the valuable nature of its contents—will be found on p. 14. It secured to the English complete exemption from all manner of duties in the Golconda kingdom, and only stipulated in return that the royal officials should be allowed the first opportunity of purchasing whatever horses and curiosities the English might bring from Persia or elsewhere.2 To compensate them for the consequent loss, the farmers of the Masulipatam customs were allowed to pay 800 pagodas (about 400l.) less per annum to the royal treasury. According to the Dutch (Dagh-Register, 1631–34, p. 366) the farmān was to lose its vaiidity if the duties payable by the English exceeded that amount; but although it was certainly provided that any such excess was to be reported to Golconda, and (as already noted) the limit was passed the same year, it is clear that the concession was not withdrawn in consequence. Still, the substantial preference thus given to the English over their trade competitors was viewed with considerable jealousy, and the loss to the customs revenues became also a matter of concern; the result will be seen later.

The grant of this concession greatly encouraged Joyce and his companions, who at once planned the establishment of factories at various inland centres, besides one at Golconda itself.3 By thus buying their goods in the country instead of at Masulipatam, now that transit duties were no longer leviable, they expected to make a great saving; and they were confident not only of establishing a lucrative trade with Persia but also of regularly dispatching ships direct to England laden with products of the Coast and of Bengal; and all this in addition to the normal supply of goods to ‘the southwards’ (i. e. Bantam and its dependencies). These dreams, however, were not to be fulfilled. The effects of the famine and the subsequent floods were still to be seen in the high price of piece-goods; the want of suitable vessels and the shortcomings of the factors employed made the Bengal trade a disappointment; the goods consigned to Persia came to a poor market; and on the Coast itself money for investment was none too abundant.

At first, however, the Masulipatam factors had no cause to complain of want of supplies. The President and Council at Surat responded to their call by dispatching to them a quantity of goods in the Hart (which was then to proceed to Bantam) and promised to send the Discovery later to carry the proceeds to Gombroon. On June 29, 1634, the Jewel arrived from England with a cargo invoiced at 25,033l.; and on August 12 the Speedwell came in from Bantam. Both vessels were sent on to Bengal, whence they returned in November. By this time the Discovery had arrived, and it was arranged that the Speedwell should accompany her to Persia. Of the inland trade we hear scarcely anything at this time, except that two factors had been sent to Golconda with a quantity of goods and had been well received. From this time forth—at least for some years—the English had continually a representative at the capital.

Turning our attention for a moment to the factories in the Bay, we infer, from an entry on p. 12, that the President and Council at Surat had, some time in 1633, instructed their subordinates at Agra to procure from the Emperor a farmān authorizing the English to trade in the ports of Bengal. On February 2, 1634, the desired grant was received at Surat. No copy of it is extant1; but we are told that it ‘gives libertye of trade unto us in his whole country of Bengala, but restraines our shipinge only unto the porte of Piplye’. No practical use, however, was made of this concession. The restriction to Pipplī would be reason enough for not exhibiting the document when the English had established a factory at Balasore; while the small value to be placed upon a royal command of this nature is evident enough from the caustic remarks made on p. 204.

Meanwhile, for information as to what was taking place in Bengal itself in 1634, we are chiefly dependent upon the Dutch records. If these may be trusted, Cartwright, the English chief at Hariharpur, had involved himself and his nation in a serious difficulty with the Nawāb. Cartwright, it is stated (Dagh-Register, 1631–34, p. 415), was detected in an intrigue with the wife of a Muhammadan dwelling next door to the new English factory; whereupon the Nawāb not only imprisoned the offender and fined him a thousand rupees, but also ordered the factory building to be pulled down. Probably means were found of averting this doom, for otherwise the Company would have had something to say on the subject. In later letters from the Coast (Ibid., p. 445) the statement is made that the Jewel had instructions to proceed to Hūglī and there establish a factory; but of this again there is no mention in the English records.

Of the transactions on the Coast and in the Bay during 1635 we can glean but little from English sources; and, as the Batavia Dagh-Register for that period is no longer extant, we are also deprived of the aid of that useful record. We learn, however, that the Speedwell on her arrival at Masulipatam from Persia was sent into the Bay, and returned from thence on June 2. Cartwright and Clark came back in her (p. 204), but it would seem that they went again to the Bay in the same vessel shortly after. As regards the Coast in general, we know that the President and Council at Bantam were very dissatisfied with Joyce’s proceedings. They complained particularly of his diverting to Bengal and Persia the stock which should have been sent to Bantam and England : of his detaining the Speedwell on the Coast, in spite of positive orders to the contrary : and of his delaying the Jewel to such an extent that she reached Bantam too late to be of any service that season. For these reasons they decided to dispatch John Hunter in the Coaster to supersede him ; but before the vessel started Hunter was appointed chief at Macassar, and so it was resolved to leave Joyce unmolested for another year. Gerald Pinson, however, was to go to the Coast to look into the accounts and see to the investments for Bantam, returning in the same ship. The vessel reached Armagon on July 26 and Masulipatam eight days later ; and she sailed again on her return voyage in the middle of September, leaving Pinson behind. At the close of the year (December 29) Joyce died, and Pinson succeeded to the post of Agent. Early in January, 1636, Cartwright and Clark returned from the Bay of Bengal in the Speedwell. According to the Dagh-Register, 1636 (p. 124) they had spent a long time at Balasore, looking after their own interests rather than the Company's. The capital remaining in the Bay at their departure was only about 1,000 pagodas (equal to 500l. : see p. 162). After being repaired, the Speedwell proceeded to Bantam with Cartwright on board. From the fact that his accounts were made up to December 17, 1635 (O. C. 1585) we gather that he gave up charge of the Bengal factories on that date. His successor, it seems, was John Yard (pp. 180, 329).

At the close of January, 1636, we find the President and Council of Bantam, in the course of a review of the state of affairs on the Coromandel Coast, protesting vigorously against the orders received from home to demolish the fort at Armagon and withdraw the factory. They assured the Company that the former was absolutely necessary to keep in awe ‘those imperious Moores that governe the kingdome of Golcondah’ ; while the factory was of the greatest service in facilitating the provision of the piece-goods required for Sumatra and Macassar. They had therefore ventured, they said, to defer the execution of these orders until the matter had been further considered in London. Reference may be made in passing to some troubles at Armagon with the Nāyak in the preceding November, which had necessitated Joyce's repair thither to compose them (p. 318). What these were is not clearly explained.

On May 20, 1636, the William arrived at Masulipatam from Persia, while at the end of the month the Crispiana came in from England, as already noted. The London from Surat anchored at the same place on June 6; and thus the Agent and Council, who had been complaining of lack of funds, found themselves amply supplied. On the 28th of that month they sent the Thomas to the Bengal settlements with a good supply of money and goods. They also used some of the money brought in the Crispiana for the purchase of piece-goods for Bantam; and these were dispatched in the London, which sailed in August.

A short time before, there had been serious trouble at Masulipatam with an ambassador from the Mogul. One of his attendants had burnt a piece of longcloth which was English property; and, as his master refused to pay for the damage, the offender was imprisoned by the factors for several days. In revenge, one of the chief servants of the factory was seized and beaten; and on a party of Englishmen being sent to demand his release, they were fired upon and driven back with some loss. However, by the mediation of the Dutch and others, a reconciliation was effected, and the ambassador apologized for his servants' behaviour (p. 277).

On August 10 the Expedition arrived from Bantam and after landing some goods proceeded to Bengal. On the 14th the Swan appeared from England with a good supply of money (nearly 30,000l.). This vessel, after taking in part of the cargo of the Crispiana, sailed for Surat towards the end of September, the William departing at the same time for Persia. The Expedition got back from Bengal on November 16, leaving the Thomas still in the Bay; but the returns by the former vessel were disappointing, and the result was that the Crispiana did not start for Bantam until the beginning of December. It is interesting to note that the English at this time had been making investments in Pondicherry and Porto Novo (p. 325); also that attention had been drawn to the fact that the English trade at Masulipatam was far in excess of that contemplated in the Golden Farmān, with the result that the factors, to stop any demands upon them, were proposing to imitate the Dutch in sending a present to Golconda (p. 326). We notice, too, that Francis Day was at this time chief at Armagon. He is mentioned as being there in December, 1634 (p. 86), but the date and circumstances of his appointment are not stated.

One or two miscellaneous matters remain to be noticed. Of the Emperor Shāh Jahān and his doings we learn far too little; but it is perhaps worth while to underline the references (p. 241) to his enmity towards Christianity, for he is generally spoken of as being of a more tolerant disposition. One interesting measure of internal regulation is mentioned, viz. the order that henceforth the seer in Gujarāt should be made twenty pice instead of eighteen. This measure took effect at Ahmadābād early in 1635, but was not adopted at Surat till a year later (pp. 143, 156). Some details are given on p. 151 of the wages paid to the Indian servants at the latter place; while the references to the Surat and Ahmadābād mints on p. 217, and to the coinage of mahmūdīs on p. 225, are worth noting. The extent to which Hindū merchants throve under Musalmān rule is shown by the allusions to the position of Sānti Dās at Ahmadābād (pp. 196, 259) and of Vīrjī Vōra at Surat (pp. 24, 218). The latter, be it noted, ‘even in the cheifest brunt of those broyles,’ offered to lend the English factors 200,000 rupees (p. 216).

Of matters more closely concerning the English factors, we are told (pp. 2, 66, 208, 224) that, up to the time of Methwold’s arrival, bonds given at Surat for money borrowed were signed only by the President or one of the members of Council, with the result that the debts of the Company were found to be inextricably mingled with the private borrowings of the individuals who had died while holding those posts. Methwold initiated the reform of requiring the signatures of the members of Council, as well as his own, to make valid any official obligation. In the same connexion we may note Methwold’s trenchant remarks on the neglect of the English merchants to make themselves acquainted with the Indian languages (pp. 208, 272).

The good health enjoyed by Methwold whilst in India lends point to his scepticism concerning the value of English drugs for diseases induced by the climate (p. 74) and to the opinion expressed that ‘in things indifferent it is safest for an Englishman to Indianize, and, so conforming himselfe in some measure to the diett of the country, the ordinarie phisick of the country will bee the best cure when any sicknesse shall overtake him’ (p. 210). Attention may also be drawn to the accounts given in his valuable diary of a slight earthquake at Surat (p. 300), of the stoicism with which a Brahman boy endured a painful amputation (p. 301), of the dramatic assassination of a prominent Hindū (p. 304), and of the burning of part of Surat Castle (p. 311). Finally, we may note the strong desire expressed (p. 222) by the Surat factors to procure permission from the Portuguese to use Goa, Bombay, Damān, or (better still) Diu, as a wintering place for the ships and the site of a magazine for stores, etc.; also the suggestion that possibly in the case of Bombay, leave might be obtained to build a ‘defencible house, with fitting storehouses’, and to rent one of the adjacent villages for the purpose of fattening cattle for supply to their shipping.

Notes

  1. 1. For an interesting account of the state of Dutch trade in India about this period see a report by Pieter Lukaszoon in the Hague Transcripts at the India Office, series i. vol. ix. no. 318.
  2. 2. A few were supplied in January, 1635 (see p. 97).
  3. 1. The Dutch, however, discovered what was going on from letters found on board a Portuguese vessel taken at the end of September (Hague Transcripts, series i. vol. x. no. 320).
  4. 1. Shāh Jahān's letter, and the one in which it was forwarded to Batavia, will be found in the Hague Transcripts, series i. vol. x. no. 324, and the reply in series iii. vol. iii. no. H 6.
  5. 1. See the Lisbon Transcripts at the India Office: Doc. Remett., vol. ix, book 33, f. 247; book 34, ff. 5, 41; book 35, ff. 261, 267.
  6. 1. As Bonnell was in the employment of Sir William Courteen, the East India Company had some justification for their belief that the expedition was really financed by the latter; but this was denied on oath by Kynaston and by Courteen's son, and King Charles confirmed the denial (Court Minutes, 1635-39, p. 226).
  7. 2. Ayres, the master of the Roebuck, told the Company that this commission was opened at Cape Verd, and that thereupon he and Ofield asked to be relieved of their posts and set ashore (Court Minutes, May 24, 1644).
  8. 1. Ayres afterwards declared that David Jones, his lieutenant, and one Franklin, forced him to agree to the robbing and torturing of the Moors; and in this he was corroborated by Glover, the surgeon of the ship (Court Minutes, as before).
  9. 1. At 2s. 3d. the rupee this would be a little over 12,000l. In 1638 the Company declared that the total of claims paid at Surat and Agra was 56,417 rials of eight, or 14,104l. (Court Minutes of the East India Company, 1635–39, p. 290).
  10. 1. Can it be that to this individual we owe the phrase 'Davy Jones's locker'? He was evidently a ringleader in the piracy, and he is quite likely to have advocated the scuttling of prizes and similar means of getting rid of inconvenient pieces of evidence; while the general interest of sailors in the doings of the Roebuck would assist in giving a wide currency to any apt saying of that kind.
  11. 2. See p. 270. The amount is given in Court Minutes of the East India Company, 1635-39, p. 290, as 9,712l. 10s.
  12. 1. For details regarding these and subsequent proceedings, reference should be made to the companion series of Court Minutes of the East India Company.
  13. 1. For a fuller account of the inception of Courteen’s Association see Court Minutes of the East India Company, 1635–39.
  14. 1. See the 1630–33 volume, p. 85. It was then suggested that, if the factors could compound for all dues for 1,500 pagodas per annum, the bargain would be a good one. The Dutch paid double that amount yearly (p. 45 of the present volume).
  15. 1. As explained on p. 19, a wrong date assigned in one of the translations misled Bruce into thinking that the grant was originally made in November, 1632, and only renewed in February, 1634, and his conclusion seems to have been accepted without investigation by all subsequent writers.
  16. 2. The great desire that existed in India for horses from Persia and Arabia is well known. It is evident from later references that the hope of a good supply of these valuable animals was the main motive of the concession made to the English.
  17. 3. See also a reference on p. 46 to negotiations, for ‘the sole government of a small [p. xxxv] towne’ [Mallavol], about five miles from Masulipatam, which had been rented by the English from May, 1634, and had in about six months ‘more then doubled itself in magnitude, soe fast doe the poore people flocke thither from the Moorish tirranny.’ The matter seems to be alluded to in a document of April, 1633 (p. 301 of the previous volume).
  18. 1. The late Dr. C. R. Wilson (Early Annals of the British in Bengal, vol. i. p. 12) roundly declared his belief that no such farmān was ever granted, and that the version given of the contents of the document was fabricated by a native interpreter. It is certain, however, that some of the English merchants at Surat knew enough Persian to detect any fraud of this character, which was in itself improbable.