In England and other European countries the study of the condition of the working classes has led to their improvement. A similar study of the condition of the Indian people is necessary to devise measures for their economic improvement. The Government were asked several times to hold such enquiries in villages exposed to frequent famines. But they thought that it would serve no useful purpose to do so. In England private individuals and public associations have aroused sympathy for the working classes and Government have readily adopted necessary reforms. It would be useful if similar work was undertaken by individuals and associations in India. A good example has been set in this direction by Mr. S. P. Patro, who read an interesting paper at the Madras Economic Association on the 11th instant. His Excellency the Governor presided. The enquiries were held in 15 villages of the Ganjam District and the places selected were those in which the conditions were alike as far as possible. The people living in the villages were asked certain questions regarding their income and expenditure as also their debts. And care was taken to prevent exaggerated or incorrect answers by verifications of facts supplied by others. After going through the details of assessment, population, number of agriculturists, the income of a typical family, the food consumed, etc., Mr. Patro found that in a particular village the budget of the ryot showed a deficit of Rs. 22–9–0 every year and it was not possible to obtain a full meal every day. Dealing similarly with a typical village in the Chicacolo division, Mr. Patro found that the annual income of a family of a typical zamindar, who had wet and dry lands, was Rs. 129–8–0, and that the expenditure, including cost of rice, oil, clothing, etc., was Rs. 181–8–0, leaving a deficit of Rs. 52 a year. For marriage and litigation the head of the family raised a loan of Rs. 380 in 1907 and discharged the same in 1913 by sale of rice and by living on inferior corn and the profits of rice-pounding. The family had full meals only from January to the month of May according to the statement of the ryot. In a zamindari village the annual income of a typical family was Rs. 316 and the expenditure Rs. 321–6–0 and there was a debt outstanding against the family. In another zamindari village, the income of a typical family was Rs. 786 and the expenditure Rs. 698–4, leaving a balance of Rs. 68 to the credit of the family whose affairs were conducted in a most economic way. That was not a profit, but it represented the wages which the members of the family earned for their personal labour on the land at Rs. 14 a head per year. On these facts Mr. Patro made the following remarks:
“I tried to place before you actual conditions observed in my investigation into some of the villages in the Ganjam district. The investigation commenced more than a year ago, and I do not attempt to discuss the many problems to which the studies give rise. Others will have to draw conclusions and advocate remedies. From the sketches it will be seen how the population is increasing and the actual cultivating owners are decreasing; how the holdings are split up, and the landless labourers are growing, how little improvement is made in agricultural methods and how little possibility there is for improving agricultural methods owing to the growing poverty, physical deterioration and indebtedness of the agriculturist; how the cultivation of the present holdings can never pay and the ryots are sinking lower and lower. The rations available for the agriculturist in some cases are poorer than the diet given to the prisoners in jails. That large number of agriculturists and labourers emigrated to Calcutta, Burma, Straits Settlements and other places is a common factor in all these villages. In the last named village about one hundred out of a population of about 878 have gone out in search of better wages and to work in non-agricultural work. There is therefore pressing need for full enquiry into the economic conditions of the agricultural population in this Province."
These enquiries are very interesting and show the desirability of conducting similar enquiries in other provinces and districts. Punjab is not much different from Madras in regard to the land tenure and general conditions of the agricultural population. We think that the enquiries made by Mr. Patro are of particular interest to us and the fact that the people are sinking lower and lower in poverty is particularly distressing. That some of them receive poorer diet than the jail population is a statement which should suggest the adoption of urgent remedies. Mr. Patro, it will be seen, does not want Government to accept his conclusions but invites further enquiries of the kind. Throughout India educated people are pressing for the reform of land laws so as to improve the condition of the masses, and experienced men have shown how deeply the ryots are sunk in poverty and indebtedness. Mr. Patro’s enquiries go to confirm these opinions and to contradict the official theory about the prosperity of the peasantry. In the typical village homes whose family budgets were examined the people had an annual deficit in three out of four cases — a fact which cannot but show the pitiable condition of the agriculturists. His Excellency the Governor expressed his appreciation of the enquiries made by Mr. Patro and admitted that the facts ascertained must be fairly accurate, though no general conclusion could be drawn from them alone.