Chapter IV

Indebtedness

The Economic Life of a Bengal District, J. C. Jack, 1916 · from page 96 · about 22 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

One of the subjects most often discussed in connexion with India is the burden of debt borne by the Indian cultivator. As one writer has put it ‘the cultivator is born in debt, increases his debt throughout his life and dies more hopelessly in debt than ever’. Many theories have been invented to account for this state of things and many remedies proposed to end it; but I believe that nobody has ever attempted to calculate or to estimate the total amount of debt in the whole of any province, of any district, or even of any village; or to base a campaign against it upon a comprehensive survey of the whole ground which it covers. Of late years, in connexion with the movement for co-operative credit, a good deal of information has been collected about individual villages and about the history of indebtedness of individuals in such villages; but I know that in my own province even the Registrar of Co-operative Credit Societies has no information of a comprehensive kind and no means of estimating the total amount of debt amongst the cultivators of the province which it is the business of his department ultimately to relieve. During the course of our economic investigations in Faridpur we paid a good deal of attention to the question of debt and we recorded the total indebtedness of every family, whether agricultural or non-agricultural. It was of course impossible to attempt any detailed enquiry into the history of the indebtedness of each individual, but much miscellaneous information could not fail to be obtained in the mere cross-examination necessary for the elucidation of the exact amount which each cultivator owed. Thus it was discovered that cultivators who borrow much rarely deal with a single moneylender. If they have mortgaged their fields to the hilt they will pledge jewellery with another lender to obtain more money for immediate necessities or if, as often happens in Faridpur, their land consists of two or more separate holdings under different landlords, they will mortgage each holding to a separate moneylender. They may borrow more money from a third moneylender on the security of the growing crop and they may pledge jewellery to fourth and fifth moneylenders to obtain fresh loans. The prudent cultivator who was little in debt usually dealt with a single moneylender and the amount of his debt was easily ascertained. The spendthrift, on the other hand, was in the nature of things careless of money and careless of accounts, and it was often difficult to find out his real position in his dealings with his many friends. But all information which was obtained concerning the history of indebtedness was collected as a result of enquiries into the total amount of indebtedness, as there was not time to make any detailed enquiry into the way in which the debt had grown up.

In the total population brought under review it was found that in the whole district the total amount of debt was £1,343,148, of which £943,729 was incurred by cultivators and £399,419 by non-cultivators. Including families which were omitted and allowing for the subsequent increase in population, the total indebtedness of the district may be estimated now at 230 lakhs of rupees or £1,500,000, of which the share of the agricultural population would be rather more than two-thirds. It was found that 55 per cent. of all cultivators were free from debt and that of the 45 per cent. who were in debt more than a half were in debt to a less amount than one-quarter of their annual income. The actual figures were as follows :—total number of agricultural families in debt 116,466, number in debt to the extent of a quarter of their income or less 60,146, number in debt to about a half of their income 33,760, number in debt to the extent approximately of a year's income 18,411, number in debt to the extent of more than a year's income 4,149. It will be observed that those who are hopelessly involved form only a small fraction of the agricultural population, only in fact 1½ per cent. Of non-agriculturalists 73 per cent. were free from debt. This is probably due to the fact that fishermen and unskilled labourers have little credit ; but the figures which might support this statement are in India, and the non-agricultural population is so diverse a body that generalizations are dangerous. Although the number of families in debt at all amongst non-cultivators was proportionately much smaller than amongst the cultivators, yet the number heavily involved was very much larger. This is certainly due to the distressed ‘bhadralok’, who is by virtue of his superior social position able to obtain loans far beyond the value of his securities. Amongst cultivators the average debt of each family in debt was about £8, or 121 rupees, while amongst non-cultivators it amounted to the much larger sum of 258 rupees or £17 4s. In the district as a whole the debt amounted to 11 rupees per head of the population and to 59 rupees for each family, or roughly to one-fifth of the annual income.

This sum is not perhaps unduly large, but it is clearly larger than any one had expected. The efforts of the co-operative credit societies to deal with debt seem very small when placed against these huge figures. In Faridpur, although the societies have been in existence ten years, they have not as yet touched one-hundredth part of the indebtedness of the district.

The problem of debt is very complex, as is sufficiently shown by the evenness with which debt is distributed amongst the more prosperous and the poorer classes of the community. This is most apparent amongst the cultivators, as they are a homogeneous class whose material circumstances are in general not very dissimilar. Nearly half the whole debt was incurred by cultivators who were classified as reaching a standard of comfort. As might be expected, however, very few of these were heavily involved, only one in a hundred being in debt to a greater amount than a year's income and only five in a hundred being in debt to more than half a year's income. Amongst cultivators classified as living in comfort 80 per cent. are either without debt or in debt only in a very small amount. Of the lowest class of all—the indigent—48 per cent. or nearly one-half are without debt, 3 per cent. are in debt to more than a year's income and 11 per cent. to more than half a year's income. These figures are at first view somewhat surprising, as it might have been expected that indebtedness would afflict the whole of this class much more severely. The truth is that most of these people are too poor to have any credit, and there is too much competition for loans to tempt the lenders to venture money with so little prospect of return. In the intermediate classes of those who live neither in comfort nor in actual want the percentage seriously in debt is very considerable, amounting to more than one-tenth of the whole body and to a much more formidable proportion of those who are indebted at all. It would be tedious to go into the figures in any further detail as they are reproduced in one of the tables appended to this book. They show that Muhammadans incur debt more eagerly than Hindus ; on the whole the Hindu cultivator is thrifty and when he borrows rarely rushes into ruin at the same headlong pace as his Muhammadan brother.

The great majority of agricultural debtors get into debt through improvident expenditure upon domestic ceremonies and in particular upon marriages. The sum spent upon the marriage of a son or daughter, both by Hindus and Muhammadans of the cultivating classes, is quite out of proportion to the incomes of the families. It is no uncommon thing for a whole or half a year's income to be spent, of which a great part goes upon entertaining the guests. Each cultivator, especially among Muhammadans, tries to make a greater display than was made at the previous marriage in the village, and in order to do so many have to borrow money on an extravagant scale. Apart from such extravagance debts are incurred to replace cattle which have died or to build houses which have been burnt down. From such enquiries as were made debts originally incurred for other causes are very few. Once a debt has been incurred it mounts with amazing rapidity. The interest is high, never less than 36 per cent., often 48 per cent. and more ; and the interest is added to the principal every year and sometimes every half-year, when it is usual for the moneylender to take a fresh bond for the increased amount. Perhaps half of the total debt throughout the district is really the result of compound interest. In almost every case in which an enquiry has been made the sum which the cultivator actually received from the moneylender is far smaller than the sum mentioned in the bond.

A great deal of the money which appears in these loan statements has been borrowed on the security of the family jewellery. As the cultivator invests his saving in a good year in jewellery, this form of borrowing is little different from realizing his investments, but it is very wasteful and involves a heavy reduction in his income, as the interest paid on these loans is usually very high, 36 per cent. compound being perhaps the normal rate.

Another wasteful form of borrowing is to borrow on the security of a sown crop. The repayment is usually made in kind, that is to say, a proportion of the crop, and a very undue proportion, is made over to the moneylender in liquidation of the loan. Loans of this type are contracted by the cultivator at the leanest periods of the year, when he is about to sow his crop and wants money to purchase seeds, or just before the harvest when his own food supply has run short. I have known cases of this kind in which the return to the moneylender after two or three months is produce to the value of three or five times the original loan. Such loans are always paid off in full at the time stipulated, as the moneylender sends a man to take away his share of the produce as soon as the crop is cut. Short-term loans of this nature are not included in the statements of indebtedness and no accurate estimate of their amount can be given. It is probable that one cultivator in five or one in ten contracts them and that in the total the sum borrowed does not involve an addition of more than 5 per cent. to the indebtedness of the agricultural classes.

In considering the problem of debt, it is more useful to view it in relation to the agricultural population as a whole, to ignore the effect upon the individual and to confine attention to the effect upon the mass. Upon the mass a debt which is equal to one-fifth of the annual income is not in itself a crushing burden, even when it bears so high a rate of interest as to involve the payment in interest alone of the earnings of one month in every year of the whole agricultural population. The heaviness of the interest would no doubt make repayment of the principal more difficult; but if the debt were divided amongst the cultivators proportionately to income, repayment within a measurable time might with thrift and organization be effected. Society is not however a charitable organization so that it is impossible to assume the pooling of the incomes of the solvent to liquidate the debts of the necessitous. As 55 per cent. of all cultivators are entirely free from debt and another 20 per cent. have borrowed very little, the income available for the reduction of debt is the income of only one quarter of the population, which already finds the earnings of four months in the year swallowed up in the payment of interest. With the greatest economy repayment or reduction of principal is clearly impossible. It would seem that the disturbing factor in the problem is not the amount which has been borrowed but the interest which is payable on the loan, and that the economic welfare of the district would be better secured by a general reduction in the rate of interest than by the repayment of principal, because the real injury to the cultivators lies in the curtailment of their spending power and therefore of their standard of living which is made necessary by the large payments of interest. Could the rate of interest upon all loans be reduced to 10 per cent., no extravagant proposal, the agricultural population as a whole would save three weeks' earnings for themselves and sacrifice only a single week's earnings to the moneylender, while the indebted quarter of the agricultural population would save three months' earnings in the year and sacrifice only one to the moneylender.

Any comprehensive campaign against debt in the interests of the district as a whole would necessarily have three distinct phases, of which the first and most important would be the reduction of interest, the second would be the repayment of principal, and the third would be the avoidance of fresh debt by the inculcation of thrift.

Although there can be no doubt of the importance of a general reduction in the rate of interest to the economic welfare of the district, there can be no hope of its being achieved in the ordinary economic way by the correlation of demand and supply. It is probable that all money in the hands of professional moneylenders is always out on loan and can only be obtained on competitive terms. In the scarcity of 1906 the moneylender was sucked so dry that no money was available for loan to cultivators with even the best security. If the rate of interest is to be reduced, it cannot be done through the agency of the moneylender. New sources must be tapped, which means in Indian conditions either a system of State banks or a system of co-operative credit amongst the cultivators. The Government of India has already rejected the Egyptian system of Land Banks financed by the State, on good and sufficient grounds, if Faridpur is any guide to debt in the rest of India or Bengal, as a capital of 200 millions sterling would be required in India and 40 millions sterling in Bengal, amounts which it would be impossible to raise now, even if it had been possible before the war. As an alternative the Government of India has initiated and encouraged a system of co-operative credit amongst the cultivators by forming co-operative credit societies in various villages and by organizing an official staff to inspect their accounts and to persuade other cultivators in the neighbourhood to form additional societies. Very little State money has been lent to the societies and no financial responsibility has been accepted by the State.

The first question which naturally arises in any consideration of this policy is whether the resources of the cultivators as a body are sufficient to meet the demands of the borrowers amongst them. This must remain a matter of opinion, as no information is available on the subject. Personally I have no doubt that they are substantially sufficient in the district of Faridpur. After all, the total debt is only one-fifth of the total annual income and therefore not beyond the reach of the accumulated profits of a few years, if those profits could be drawn forth and employed. The fact that 55 per cent. of the more prosperous cultivators in the district are without debt combined with the knowledge of the extent to which they now invest their savings in jewellery for their womenfolk shows that there is already sufficient capital amongst the cultivators themselves to meet all the needs for the year of their more necessitous brethren. No doubt co-operative credit societies would shrink from jeopardizing their resources in loans to cultivators who were heavily involved; but only 9 per cent. of the cultivators are indebted to the extent of a year's income or more. If the State could be induced to assist in the recovery of these cultivators by taking over some part of the loans, co-operative credit might be trusted to deal with the rest, while the liability of the State would be very small and would not extend in any case to more than 5 per cent. of the total indebtedness of the district.

The purpose of this study is the statement of economic fact and not the advancement of theory or the suggestion of reform. If I venture to make a few comments on the subject of agricultural indebtedness, it is only because they are suggested by the course of our own investigations and have not apparently been put forward by other workers in this field. The officers engaged in our investigations without doubt secured the confidence of the cultivators and had great influence with them. They obtained influence partly by the prestige of Government service and partly by their superior education, but chiefly by their knowledge of the agricultural world, and they inspired confidence partly because they were disinterested, but chiefly because they were personally known to every family. These happy results were only achieved by the rule which insisted that all enquiries were to be conducted in the homes of the people and by an allotment of time and space which made a strict observance of the rule possible. Those who know the Indian countryside will not need to be told that the agricultural peasant is prone to suspicion in all things and never more than when it is proposed to lay hands upon his savings. Nothing can be done with him unless his confidence be first secured and little can even then be done except by those who have acquired influence in his village or locality. It is not likely that the issue will be otherwise with co-operative credit. Indeed I venture to think that no real progress will be made with the movement until Government agents of an influential class are employed in sufficient number to enable them to know their agricultural world and the family and home of every inhabitant in their sphere of authority. In Faridpur this would involve the employment of about two hundred agents for inspection and control, who should in a well-organized scheme precede and not follow the establishment of co-operative credit societies in their spheres. At present only two or three men of the type required are employed in the district.

A staff of such quality and strength would make rapid progress possible in the introduction of co-operative credit, if rapid progress were desired; but however slowly co-operative credit is or is intended to be built up, it is still—I cannot but think—essential as a framework upon which to build. The Government policy in respect of the movement has been announced as a policy of slow and cautious expansion, aiming avowedly at a distant millennium. It is urged in favour of slow expansion that the virtues of the movement lie in teaching the cultivator co-operation and a sense of responsibility and that if the movement were pushed at a gallop, these virtues would be likely to be lost sight of in the cloud of dust. There is substance in these views no doubt, but a substance which it is sometimes difficult to separate from the shadow. Caution and slowness are comparative terms ; and it is not easy to say how many years of waiting and watching are needed to justify their use. In Faridpur at the present rate of progress, which has not enabled one hundredth part of the ground to be covered in ten years, it would require a thousand years to eliminate the professional moneylender by co-operative effort. Indeed the movement has not as yet got any real hold upon the district, nor is it likely to get any real hold until pioneer societies have been established far more widely than at present. If cultivators have to learn the value of the societies, they must at least see them in operation, which cannot be expected while societies are confined to ten centres in a district of four thousand villages, where communications are defective and the villagers rarely go far from their homes. Were a small society started on a comprehensive plan in every village or every group of villages, the advantages would at least be canvassed by every cultivator and the benefits of co-operation would have some chance of asserting themselves in every corner of the district. Such diffusion is not possible without a large staff for organization and control. If a staff of the quality and strength which I have suggested were already in existence, it would be their first duty to arrange the formation of these pioneer societies and to tempt out of the well-to-do cultivators their savings to finance them. At first the societies would need like all pioneer undertakings continuous care and attention, which it would be the second duty of the official staff to supply. To hope that men as ignorant as the Indian cultivator would be able at once to manage credit societies on co-operative principles in a businesslike manner without the help of advice and audit by some extraneous authority is to sigh for the moon. As soon as pioneer societies had been established and were working smoothly in each little group, it would be the third duty of the official staff to draw the attention of every cultivator in the group to their advantages in the course of friendly conversation and to encourage the formation of new societies. It is, I submit, much more likely that success will be achieved and that the benefits of co-operative credit will be widely appreciated by the cultivators in this way as a result of experience of societies in their own villages and amongst themselves than in watching them or hearing of their wonders in other villages amongst strangers.

Repayment of principal will naturally not begin concurrently with the formation of co-operative credit societies, although the reduction in the rate of interest places at the disposal of the cultivator some resources for the purpose. The experience of societies which have been already formed shows that the cultivator is inclined to display his appreciation of the value of cheap money by increasing his debt rather than by reducing it. This tendency has been accentuated by the lack of influential advice, as an ignorant cultivator can hardly be expected to realize that the more he borrows from his society, the less is available to rescue others from the moneylender or that repayment has a co-operative value in increasing the resources of his society and enabling it to extend its operations. In this regard more is to be expected from a competent and sufficient official staff than can have been hitherto attempted. Firmness is necessary and will be effective when the prestige of the official is combined with the solicitude of the friend. In the peculiar conditions of the Indian countryside there is another way in which the official staff can materially assist in reducing the dead-weight of the debt. The total debt of most of the cultivators includes much that they have never borrowed. As I have explained, it is the habit of the moneylender to add unpaid interest to the principal and to take a new bond for the increased sum every year and sometimes every half-year. A close examination into the origin and history of every debt is made before a cultivator can be admitted as member of a co-operative credit society. Already in many cases compositions have been arranged with the moneylenders, when they have been paid off by the society. With an official staff as influential as I have postulated these cases are likely to be much more numerous. To western eyes it may seem utopian to expect Shylock to forgo some of his pound of flesh; but in India it is no uncommon experience. During our investigations my officers and I have often arranged terms of composition and induced moneylenders to accept far less than their nominal dues. In the Central Provinces after the Famine such compositions were comprehensively arranged as a matter of policy on the inspiration of the local officials. It is not therefore extravagant to suppose that a large deduction can be obtained in the total indebtedness of the district, when nearly all debts are disproportionate to the sums which the borrowers have actually obtained ; but a staff of high quality is necessary for the purpose. If it is true that moral persuasion can always compel mitigation in the terms of an unconscionable bargain in Bengal, it is only true when the persuader is a person of influence, preferably an official, who is disinterested.

The third phase in the campaign against debt is the avoidance of fresh debt by the inculcation of thrift. There will always be borrowing ; but it should be borrowing for use and not borrowing for consumption. I have heard it asserted that a docile people like the Faridpur cultivators, pre-eminently willing to follow where the State leads, could be taught thrift in a generation. I have no such illusion. There will always be spendthrifts in Faridpur and the ordinary cultivator, especially the Muhammadan, is only too willing to spend when he has money in his pocket. Extravagance is particularly marked in marriage entertainments, which amongst a hospitable people is peculiarly difficult to eradicate. On the other hand there is no drink problem and no need to fight against the insidious demoralization which it carries in its train. In the inculcation of thrift success is more likely to be achieved indirectly, by an attempt to raise the general standard of living. The improvement of the homestead offers a great opportunity of diverting expenditure from wasteful objects. The cultivators take pride in their homes and could easily be induced to spend money upon them, to substitute masonry for mud plinths, tin roofs for thatch, timber for bamboo, and to fill them with better furniture. Exhibitions of model homesteads and of furniture would be very useful to help them, if held in many centres. It is hardly necessary to say that the co-operative credit staff with its knowledge of every home and every family would be able to give great assistance in raising the general standard of living and in directing the attention of the cultivators to the improvement of their homesteads and furniture and of the quality of their cattle and other livestock.

To sum up, of the debt incurred by cultivators in Faridpur 80 per cent. could be paid off in a reasonable period by the ordinary operation of land banks or credit societies, 13 per cent. is more serious, but might to a great extent be similarly dealt with after the close examination to which Government officers could subject it. The remainder, incurred by cultivators with small resources to a degree out of all proportion to those resources, must remain as a burden to the borrowers unless some public authority should step forward to take over the loan at a reasonable rate of interest. Put in another way, the cultivators of Faridpur may be divided into three classes, 55 per cent. entirely free of debt and making sufficient profit to free most of their indebted neighbours, 39 per cent. in debt but only to an extent which does not seriously cripple their resources, whose debts could in a short time be paid off by co-operative effort of the whole body of cultivators, and only 6 per cent. whose debts are far too large for any co-operative movement safely to deal with and must be tackled by public authority unless the cultivators are to be abandoned in the grip of their moneylenders. The sum to be found by public authority would not exceed ten lakhs of rupees and might in liquidation be reduced considerably below that amount.

Without an analysis by occupations of the non-agricultural classes no useful purpose can be served by examining the figures of their debt. Most of the comments made upon the indebtedness of cultivators apply no doubt also to non-cultivators; but their occupations and their conditions of life are so diverse that it would need a special study of a very difficult kind before any comments or any generalizations could safely be ventured. The figures at least reveal the dimensions of their debt and the economic condition of those who have incurred it.