Appendix D

Extracts from Appendices to the Famine Commission's Report of 1880, regarding the influence of forests on rainfall and

An Essay on the Economic Causes of Famines in India, Satis Chandra Ray, 1909 · from page 75 · about 10 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

The disastrous effects of a general destruction of forests, on agriculture and pasturage, are generally known, and have been abundantly illustrated during the present century in south-eastern France; but it is still a question whether the total rainfall of a country is thereby diminished. Direct observations on the rainfall of forest-clad countries, large areas of which have subsequently been denuded, are unfortunately wanting; and it is perhaps open to question whether comparative rainfall measurements made in the forest and clearings of temperate countries which are still in large part covered with forests, and the clearings of which are either pasture land or under field cultivation, afford a criterion of the probable effects of a general denudation of forests in tropical and sub-tropical lands. A very elaborate series of comparative observations of the above kind, carried on for five years at eight pairs of stations in the forest and clearings of Bavaria by Dr. Ebermeyer, have led him to the conclusion that “ in plains of uniform character the influence of forests on the quantity of rainfall is certainly very small. With increa ed elevation above the sea-level, the influence of forests becomes more important, and it has, therefore, a greater value in mountain tracts than on plains. In summer the effects of the forests is much greater than in winter. In the cold season it is evanescent. In warm southern countries it is greater than in cold countries; and in the interior of continents, where the humidity of the air and the annual precipitation are diminished, and the summer heat is greater, it plays a more important part than in the neighbourhood of coasts. From what has been said above, the clearing of a large area of country—at least of plain country—produces no essential diminution of the yearly rainfall. In hill tracts, on the contrary, after denudation there will be, on the whole, less rain than before. In all cases the destruction of forests will affect the rainfall only in the warm season, i.e., during the summer months.”

From the above it may be inferred that in a country such as India the consequences of a general destruction of forests would be more important than in Europe, since the climate of India is essentially continental, and over a large part of its area the temperature, even of the cool season, is not very far short of the average summer temperature of the countries of which Dr. Ebermeyer writes . . . . Judging from the known effects of forests upon climates, more specially of the temperature and humidity of the ground and lower strata of the air in contact with the ground, I should anticipate that the effect of extensive denudation would be to render storms more violent and spasmodic in character, and perhaps to diminish the frequency of gentle and continued rainfall.

The facts then adduced seemed to justify the conclusion that the foliage of trees greatly influence the purity, the humidity, and temperature of the atmosphere, and the supply of water on the earth's surface, by attracting clouds and condensing the moisture in the atmosphere, diminishing local temperature, protecting the soil from the action of the sun's rays, and husbanding the rain by regulating its flow.

In 1863, Mr. N. A. Dalzell, Conservator of Forests in the Bombay Presidency, . . . . showed that the wanton destruction of forests had entailed barrenness and aridity on countries renowned in former times for their fertility ; that along with the woods, springs and rivulets disappear and cease to water the parched land ; that the actual temperature of the country is, by the destruction of its forests, very sensibly increased ; that the rain, gradually washing away the vegetable earth from the sides of the denuded hills, condemns them to sterility, while these latter, no longer able to retain and regulate the flow of water that falls on their slopes, are scored by deep gullies, formed by impetuous torrents, and the beds of rivers are at one time dry and at another filled by sudden and shortlived floods.

Mr. Robertson, the Superintendent of the Government Farms at Madras, . . . . found that during the last 30 years a large area of land had been denuded of trees, partly in view of an extension of arable culture, and partly to provide fuel for the railways and for domestic use. Seven hundred thousand acres, which were growing jungle scrub and coarse grass, had, during the preceding 18 years, been brought under the plough ; and, being now bare for two-thirds of the year, this must affect climate. The people unanimously declared that the rainfall had been gradually diminishing during the last 20 or 25 years, though it was not always referred to this cause.

Writing as to the future of the Peninsula (Madras), he (Sir Richard Temple) says : " . . . . The southern peninsula of India has been, or is being, denuded not only of its forests, but also of its jungle, its groves, its brushwood, its trees. The denudation has been, I understand, going on near the sources and in the upper courses of the many rivers which water the country . . . . If it were to proceed unchecked there would be imminent danger of the rivers running dry by reason of the catchment basins and the drainage areas near their sources being rainless . . . . The progress of the country causes the price of timber and firewood to rise. The introduction of railways has, in the absence of any coal mines, greatly augmented the demand for fuel. Strong temptations are thus inevitably offered to the people at large to fell, cut, and lop recklessly, to bring every log, stump and stick to the market, to dig out the very roots of the jungle, so stopping any chance of reproduction, without thought for the future . . . . Any thoughtful spectator must perceive that, according to all meteorological experience, and to the almost certain teaching of proved facts, these fine distr cts were not destined by nature to be the prey and sport of famine and scarcity, but have been rendered subject to these calamities by the thoughtless action of man."

Ebermeyer has deduced the following result from his meteorological observations : "If from the soil of an open space, 100 parts of water evaporate, then from the soil of a forest tree from underwood 38 parts would evaporate, and from a soil covered with brushwood only 15 parts would evaporate. This simple fact explains clearly why the cutting down of wood over tracts of country is always followed by the drying up of wells and springs."

Extract from a report on the U.S. Bureau of Forestry.

In the San Bernardino mountains, records of precipitation for several years at a large number of stations show that differences in forest cover are closely correlated with differences in rainfall. This correlation is so close that it is possible to judge the mean annual precipitation with a fair degree of accuracy from the appearance of the forest alone. In these mountains, forests cover the slopes wherever the mean annual rainfall exceeds 20 to 24 inches; however, on southern and western slopes forests of equal density represent a larger rainfall than on northern or eastern slopes.

That the excessive destruction of forests is followed by the drying-up of streams and springs, and by a diminution in the minimum flow of rivers, is a well established fact. The forest is the most effective agent known in regulating the disposition of the precipitation after it reaches the ground.

Extract from a report by Mr. D. Howitz on the re-afforestation of waste lands in Ireland. (Parliamentary Return No. 39 of 1884.)

There can no longer be any doubt that the forests on ranges prevent sudden floods to a very great extent and that by a judicious cultivation of slopes and high plateaux in a few years these calamities are avoided. Experience has also proved that cultivations ensure a steady flow of water during summer, and that the fertility of the agricultural low lands is considerably increased by them. Baron Von Mueller, the celebrated botanist, states that in forest-bare countries the productiveness of cereal fields increased 50 per cent. by the cultivation of forest belts—a statement never yet contradicted by experience. The work of re-afforesting will not only be a boon to the country at large by preventing the flooding of the low lands during heavy rains and fertilising them by a steady flow of water throughout the year, but it will have the great advantage of being a work eminently remunerative. That the planting of trees of even inferior quality will repay the trouble and thereby improve comparatively valueless land, you will grant when I refer you to the cultivation of Les Landes in France. Those localities, although so widely different from Ireland, are still a proof of what forest plantations can do. The Committee, which reported in 1857 on this work, predicted that the cultivation of the Landes, the low-lying lands near the Garonne, would add more than 1,000 million francs to the wealth of France—a prophecy which at that time was regarded as wild and foolish, but which has been more than fulfilled.

Extracts from the Evidence before the Select Committee on Forestry. (Parliamentary Paper 287 of 1885.)

[Evidence of Mr. Pedder, Secretary, Revenue Department, India Office.]

1. Yes, the destruction of forests was undoubtedly seriously affecting the water-supply in many parts of the country and seriously affecting the climate.

2. There are, no doubt, many instances in which it has been strongly suspected that the diminution of the water-supply of the streams has been caused by the cutting down of forests.

3. I ought to say that there is a great deal of evidence in India which tends to show that the denudation process has had an effect upon the water-supply in two ways: one in diminishing the moisture of the country in the way of falls of rain, and another in making the rain run away more rapidly, and causing floods.

4. In the north of the Punjab it has been represented by men, whose opinions are of great weight, that the denudation of some of the Himalayan forests has caused great destruction from the way in which the torrents have washed immense masses of sand and stone from the mountains into the plain.

5. Q.—And is it not well recognised that the growth of forests leads to the storage of water and its gradually being distributed in streamlets and rivulets to the streams which it ultimately supplies.

A.—I believe that is an unquestionable fact, and is the foundation of all forestry.

6. There is a district called Ratnagiri, south of Bombay; it is a rice district, which lies between the sea and the Western Ghats, which used to be considered to be the most productive of the rice lands of the west of India at that time—I am speaking of 50 years ago—and I know from the reports I have read of the officers who were employed to make the original trigonometrical survey that that country was covered by dense forests. The diaries of those officers show that in some cases they had to cut a base line at the rate of half a mile a day for miles through dense forest, whereas now the same district has been entirely denuded up to the crest of the hills. The hills are almost a bare sheet of rock, and people have complained, and complained bitterly, of the decreasing yield of the rice land below, which has been attributed, and I believe truly, to the destruction of the forests, which operates, of course, to prevent the water from being stored upon the hill sides; it runs away in violent floods instead of flowing gently over the country.

[Evidence of Col. James Michael, C.S.I.]

1. Q.—What is your opinion of the influence of the denudation of forests upon the rainfall and water-supply as derived from original observations ? A.—I personally have no doubt whatever upon the subject; in fact, I have seen myself the effects of the denudation of hill slopes. I have seen a well known perennial stream dried up completely upon the slopes of the Nilgiris undoubtedly from the fact that the timber all round it had been cut off for coffee planting.

2. Q.—Was that a stream which had been perennial ? A.—Yes, it had been perennial, and it had utterly dried up. I have seen several at the station of Ootacamund; I can quote a particular spring near the church of Ootacamund which used to be always the source from which most people got their drinking water; it was an excellent spring, and within my memory the wood which surrounded that spring was cut down, the result being that the spring has disappeared, and that there is no water there now.

I can mention many instances of springs being lost from a forest being cut away, but not of any spring being formed by the formation of a forest; though I have no doubt that would be the case in years to come.