If we trace it (this measure) to its ultimate origin we shall find that it embodies an endeavour to redeem a pledge which was given at the time of the Permanent Settlement, and which has never been adequately redeemed. If we examine its immediate causes, it will be easy to show that, for the last 20 years, there has been a persistent demand for a revision of the existing law, not merely on points of detail, but on points of principle; not merely as to procedure, but as to substantive rights; that this demand has grown in urgency with each succeeding year; that the subject has occupied the attention of successive Lieut.-Governors of Bengal; that attempts have, at various times, been made to dispose of it by legislation in the Bengal Legislative Council; and that each unsuccessful attempt has shown the futility of any settlement which should deal only with procedure, and should leave the substantive rights of landlord and tenant untouched. What, then, are the facts with which we have to deal, and what are the evils for which legislation is required? Broadly stated, they are these. We have a population of some 60 millions mainly deriving their means of subsistence directly or indirectly from the soil; the great majority, directly, as cultivators; a small minority, indirectly, as rent-receivers. The mutual rights of these two classes, the rent-receivers and cultivators, are uncertain and obscure; the machinery for ascertaining and enforcing those rights is insufficient and defective; and the result is friction, which has taken different forms in different parts of the province. In Bihar, where the landlords are strong and the tenants are weak, we have rack-renting and acts of lawless and high-handed oppression on the part of the landlords; in Eastern Bengal where, comparatively speaking, the landlords are weak and the tenants strong, we have combinations of the tenants to resist the payment of rent. This is what Sir Ashley Eden said a few years ago of Bihar in a letter which he wrote as Lieut.- Governor, pointing out the urgent necessity for some reform in the law.
“In Bihar what is most wanted is some ready means of enabling the ryot to resist illegal distraint, illegal enhancement, and illegal cesses, and to prove and maintain his occupancy rights. Apart from the backwardness and poverty of the ryot, there are many points in the existing system of zemindari management in Bihar which seem to call for speedy amendment. The loose system of zemindari accounts, the entire absence of leases and counterparts, the universal prevalence of illegal distraint, the oppression incident to the realisation of rents in kind, the practice of amalgamating holdings so as to destroy evidence of continuous holding, are evils which necessarily prevent any possible development of agricultural prosperity among the tenant class, and place them practically at the mercy of their landlords or of the lessees, to whom, ordinarily, their landlords from time to time transfer their rights.”
I said just now that the ultimate origin of the present measure might be traced back to the time of the Permanent Settlement. At that time, as now, there were three main classes interested in the soil of Bengal—the State, the revenue-payers or zemindars, and the cultivators or ryots. I am omitting, for the sake of simplicity, the persons holding intermediate interests between the zemindar and the ryot. Much learning has been devoted to ascertaining the precise position and rights of the zemindars and ryots at the time of the Permanent Settlement; but amidst the controversies which have for the last century raged, and are still raging on this subject, one point may be taken as conclusively proved, namely, that the great mass of the Bengal ryots were, at the time of the Permanent Settlement, in the enjoyment of certain customary rights which, at least, included the right of occupying the land conditionally on the payment of the rate of rent current and established in the locality, and I may add, the right of having that rate of rent determined by the State. Now, what the authors of the Permanent Settlement did was this: They settled and defined the mutual rights of the State and the revenue-payers or zemindars. They did not settle, define, or ascertain, the mutual rights of the zemindars and the ryots. They settled and defined the mutual rights of the State and the zemindars by declaring that the amount of revenue payable by the latter, which had formerly been fluctuating, or fixed for short terms of years, should be fixed for all time, and should not be increased by reason of any increase in the area under cultivation. And, at the same time, as part of the same settlement, they formally declared that the zemindars should be deemed to be the proprietors of the soil whatever that expression might mean; in other words, ... they transferred to the zemindars those indefinite proprietary rights in the soil which had formerly been claimed by the State. But they did not settle or define, they did not even ascertain, the rights of the ryots or occupying cultivators. The legislation of 1793 left those rights outstanding and undefined, and by so leaving them, it tended to obscure them, to efface them, and, in too many cases, ultimately to destroy them. That both the Court of Directors in England, and the Governor-General in Council here, were aware of the possible consequences of their legislation, we well know. Immediately before the Permanent Settlement was made, the Court of Directors, in conveying instructions to the Government here, with respect to it, wrote as follows:—
“In order to leave no room for our instructions being at any time misunderstood, we direct you to be accurate in the terms in which our determination is announced .... You will, in a particular manner, be cautions so to express yourselves as to leave no ambiguity as to our right to interfere, from time to time, as it may be necessary, for the protection of the ryots and subordinate landlords, it being our intention, in the whole of this measure, effectually to limit our own demand, but not to depart from our inherent right, as Sovereigns, of being the guardians and protectors of every class of persons living under our Government.”
Extract from a leading article in the “Statesman,” dated 19th March, 1902.
Then came the most disastrous portion of his (Sir R. Temple’s) career—disastrous, that is, to the people of this country. Early in January, 1874, he was appointed to superintend the relief operations in the famine-stricken districts of Bengal. Lord Northbrook, who was Viceroy at that time, was guided by the humane principle that the saving of life should be the first object of a British Government armed with absolute power, and therefore responsible for the lives of its helpless subjects. Up to that time the stereotyped official view had been that it was not the business of the Government to save the people alive in time of famine; that it was Utopian to attempt to do so, and that, in fact, so far from the State being called upon to combat the calamity, famine was a sort of God-send to clear off the surplus population. Lord Northbrook, to his lasting honour, was the first Viceroy of India to repudiate this abominable theory, and to recognise to the full the obligation of the State to do its utmost to keep the people alive in time of famine. But, unfortunately, he had, for his lieutenant, in 1874, Sir Richard Temple, who, readily adapting himself to the views then in the ascendant, proceeded to travesty the Viceroy's policy by instituting relief measures of such wasteful extravagance as to cover it with ridicule. Without taking the trouble to satisfy himself as to the true extent of the calamity— which as a matter of fact proved itself to be little more than temporary, though at the time severe, scarcity—he chartered ships by the dozen to bring rice from Burma and distant Saigon, and the Hooghly was filled with vessels laden with cargoes of grain amounting, in the aggregate, to 600,000 tons. with which the authorities were quite unable to deal.