The Early History of India

Chapter XII

The Gupta Empire (continued) ; and the White Huns, from a. d. 455 to 606

The Early History of India, Vincent A. Smith, 1924 · from page 318 · about 53 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

From A. D. 455 to 606

The general prevalence of Buddhism in Northern India, including Kashmīr, Afghanistan, and Suwāt, during the two centuries immediately preceding and the two next following the Christian era, is simply attested by the numerous remains of Buddhist monuments erected during that period, and a multitude of inscriptions, which are almost all either Buddhist or Jain. The Jain cult, which was closely related to the Buddhist, does not appear to have gained very wide popularity, although it was practised with great devotion at certain localities, of which Mathurā was one.

But the orthodox Hindu worship, conducted under the guidance of Brahmans, and associated with sacrificial rites abhorrent to Jain and Buddhist sentiment, had never become extinct, and had at all times retained a large share of both popular and royal favour. Kadphises II, the Kushān conqueror, was himself conquered by captive India, and adopted with such zeal the worship of Siva as practised by his new subjects that he constantly placed the image of that Indian god upon his coins, and described himself as his devotee. Many other facts concur to prove the continued worship of the old Hindu gods during the period in which Buddhism unquestionably was the most popular and generally received creed.

In some respects, Buddhism in its Mahāyāna form was better fitted than the Brahmanical system to attract the reverence of casteless foreign chieftains; and it would not be unreasonable to expect that they should have shown a decided tendency to favour Buddhism rather than Brahmanism; but the facts do not indicate any clearly marked general preference for the Buddhist creed on the part of the foreigners. The only distinctively Buddhist coins are the few rare pieces of that kind struck by Kanishka, who undoubtedly, in his later years, liberally patronized the ecclesiastics of the Buddhist church, as did his successor Huvishka; but the next king, Vāsudeva, reverted to the devotion for Siva, as displayed by Kadphises II. So the later Śaka satraps of Surāshtra seem to have inclined personally much more to the Brahmanical than to the Buddhist cult, and they certainly bestowed their patronage upon the Sanskrit of the Brahmans rather than upon the vernacular literature.

The development of the Mahāyāna school of Buddhism, which became prominent and fashionable from the time of Kanishka, about the beginning of the second century, was in itself a testimony to the reviving power of Brahmanical Hinduism. The newer form of Buddhism had much in common with the older Hinduism, and the relation is so close that even an expert often feels a difficulty in deciding to which system a particular image should be assigned.

Brahmanical Hinduism was the religion of the pundits, whose sacred language was Sanskrit, a highly artificial literary modification of a vernacular speech of the Panjāb. As the influence of the pundits upon prince and peasant waxed greater in matters of religion and social observance, the use of their special vehicle of expression became more widely diffused, and gradually superseded the vernacular in all documents of a formal or official character. In the third century b. c. Asoka had been content to address his commands to his people in language easy to be understood by the vulgar; but, in the middle of the second century after Christ, the satrap Rudradāman felt that his achievements could be adequately commemorated only in elaborate Sanskrit. It is impossible to go more deeply into the subject in these pages, and it must suffice to observe that the revival of the Brahmanical religion was accompanied by the diffusion and extension of Sanskrit, the sacred language of the Brahmans.1

Whatever may have been the causes, the fact is abundantly established that the restoration of the Brahmanical religion to popular favour, and the associated revival of the Sanskrit language, became noticeable in the second century, were fostered by the satraps of Gujarāt and Surāshtra during the third, and made a success by the Gupta emperors in the fourth and fifth centuries. These princes, although perfectly tolerant of both Buddhism and Jainism, and in at least three cases personally interested in the former, were themselves beyond question officially orthodox Hindus, usually guided by Brahman advisers, and skilled in Sanskrit, the language of the pundits.2 An early stage in the reaction against Buddhist condemnation of sacrifice had been marked by Pushyamitra's celebration of the horse-sacrifice towards the close of the second century. In the fourth, Samudragupta revived the same ancient rite with added splendour; and in the fifth, his grandson repeated the solemnity. Without going further into detail, the matter may be summed up in the remark that coins, inscriptions, and monuments agree in furnishing abundant evidence of the recrudescence during the Gupta period of Brahmanical Hinduism at the expense of Buddhism, and of the favour shown by the ruling powers to 'classical' Sanskrit at the expense of the more popular literary dialects, which had enjoyed the patronage of the Āndhra kings.

It is probable that the popular legend of Rāja Bikram of Ujjain, the supposed founder of the Vikrama era dating from 58 b. c., has been coloured by indistinct memories of the glories of Chandra-gupta II Vikramāditya, who certainly conquered Ujjain towards the close of the fourth century of the Christian era. Tradition associates nine gems of Sanskrit literature with Rāja Bikram, the most resplendent of the nine being Kālidāsa, who is admitted by all critics to be the prince of Sanskrit poets and dramatists. In my judgement it is now established that Kālidāsa lived and wrote in the fifth century, his literary activity extending over a long period, probably not less than thirty years. Although it is difficult to fix the dates of the great poet's career with precision, it appears to be probable that he began to write either late in the reign of Chandra-gupta II or early in the reign of Kumāragupta I. The traditional association of his name with Rāja Bikram of Ujjain is thus justified by sober criticism.1

The Gupta period, taken in a wide sense as extending from about A. D. 300 to 650, and meaning more particularly the fourth and fifth centuries, was a time of exceptional intellectual activity in many fields—a time not unworthy of comparison with the Elizabethan and Stuart period in England.1 In India all the lesser lights are outshone by the brilliancy of Kālidāsa, as in England all the smaller authors are overshadowed by Shakespeare. But, as the Elizabethan literature would still be rich even if Shakespeare had not written, so, in India, if Kālidāsa’s works had not survived, enough of other men’s writings would remain to distinguish his age as extraordinarily fertile in literary achievement.

The remarkable drama, entitled The Little Clay Cart, one of the most interesting of Indian plays, is now believed to date from the fifth or sixth century, if not from an earlier time. Another equally remarkable play, the Mudrā-Rākshasa, which tells the story of the usurpation of the crown by Chandragupta Maurya, probably is at least quite as old. Professor Hillebrandt is inclined to assign its composition to the reign of Chandra-gupta II (c. A. D. 400).

The Vāyu Purāna, one of the oldest of the eighteen Purānas, clearly should be attributed in its existing form to the first half of the fourth century, and the Laws of Manu, as we now know the book, may be dated from about the beginning of the Gupta period. Without going further into detail, and so trespassing on the domain of the historian of Sanskrit literature, it may suffice to cite Professor R. G. Bhandarkar’s observation that the period was distinguished by ‘a general literary impulse’, the effects of which were visible in poetry, as well as in law books and many other forms of literature.

In the field of mathematical and astronomical science the Gupta age is adorned by the illustrious names of Āryabhata (born A. D. 476) and Varāhamihira (died A. D. 587). Mr. Kaye, a competent authority, holds that ‘the period when mathematics flourished in India commenced about a. d. 400 and ended about a. d. 650, after which deterioration set in.’ 1

We have seen how Samudragupta practised and encouraged music. The other arts, too, shared the favour of the Gupta kings and prospered under their intelligent patronage. The accident that nearly the whole of the Gupta empire was repeatedly overrun and permanently occupied by Muslim armies, which rarely spared a Hindu building, accounts for the destruction of almost all large edifices of the Gupta age. But the researches of recent years have disclosed abundant evidence of the former existence of numerous magnificent buildings, both Buddhist and Brahmanical, which had been erected in the fifth and sixth centuries. A few specimens of architectural compositions on a considerable scale may still be seen in out-of-the-way places, which lay apart from the track of the hosts of Islam, and the surviving miniature shrines of the period are fairly numerous. Enough is known to justify the assertion that the art of architecture was practised on a large scale with eminent success.

The allied art of sculpture, usually cultivated in India as an accessory to architecture, attained a degree of perfection not recognized until recently. The best examples, indeed, are so good that they may fairly claim the highest rank among the efforts of Indian sculptors. Painting, as exemplified by some of the best frescoes at Ajanṭā and the cognate works at Sīgiriya in Ceylon (a. d. 479–97), was practised with equal, or, perhaps, greater success. Certain gold Gupta coins are the only pieces issued by Hindu kings entitled to rank as works of art.

It is apparent, therefore, that the rule of the able and long-lived monarchs of the Gupta dynasty coincided with an extraordinary outburst of intellectual activity of all kinds. The personal patronage of the kings no doubt had much effect, but deeper causes must have been at work to produce such results. Experience proves that the contact or collision of diverse modes of civilization is the most potent stimulus to intellectual and artistic progress, and, in my opinion, the eminent achievements of the Gupta period are mainly due to such contact with foreign civilizations, both on the east and on the west. The evidence as to the constant interchange of communications with China is abundant, and although the external testimony to intercourse with the Roman empire is less copious, the fact of such intercourse is indisputable. The conquest of Mālwā and Surāshtra or Kāthiāwār by Chandra-gupta II Vikramāditya, towards the close of the fourth century, opened up ways of communication between Upper India and western lands which gave facilities for the reception of European ideas. The influence of the Alexandrian schools on the astronomy of Āryabhata is undoubted, and the imitation of Roman coins by Gupta kings is equally obvious. In art and literature the proof of the action of foreign influence is necessarily more difficult, but in my judgement the reality of that action is well established. It is difficult, for instance, to deny the relationship between the sculpture of the Sleeping Vishnu at Deogarh and the class of Graeco-Roman works represented by the Endymion at Stockholm. It is impossible to pursue the subject further in this place, but the references in the note will enable any inquirer interested to follow up the cumulative proofs that the remarkable intellectual and artistic output of the Gupta period was produced in large measure by reason of the contact between the civilization of India and that of the Roman empire. Some critics have thought that Chinese ideas may be traced in the Ajantā frescoes, and they may be right.1

Comparison of the notes recorded by Fa-hien, the first Chinese pilgrim, at the beginning of the fifth, and by his great successor, Hiuen Tsang, in the first half of the seventh century, proves beyond question that Buddhism suffered a gradual decay during the Gupta period. But that decay was hardly discernible by people living in those ages, who saw a powerful and wealthy monastic order continuously wielding immense influence and housed in splendid convents. The discovery of the numerous remains of magnificent Buddhist monasteries of Gupta age has been one of the surprises of archaeological research. The Gupta kings, although officially Brahmanical Hindus with a special devotion to Vishnu, followed the usual practice of ancient India in looking with a favourable eye on all varieties of Indian religion. The first Chandra-gupta, who had been a follower of the Sānkhya philosophy, afterwards listened with conviction to the arguments of Vasubandhu, the Buddhist sage, to whose instruction he commended his son and heir, Samudragupta. At a later time, Naragupta Bālāditya, who erected handsome buildings at Nālandā, the ecclesiastical capital of the church, was regarded by Hiuon Tsang as having been a fervent Buddhist.1

The golden age of the Guptas comprised a period of a century and a quarter (A. D. 330–455), covered by three reigns of exceptional length. The death of Kumāragupta I, which can be fixed definitely as having occurred early in 455, marks the beginning of the decline and fall of the empire. Even before his death, his kingdom had become involved, about the year 450, in serious distress by a war with a rich and powerful nation named Pushyamitra, otherwise almost unknown to history.2 The imperial armies were defeated, and the shock of military disaster had endangered the stability of the dynasty, which was ‘tottering’ to its fall, when the energy and ability of Skandagupta, the Crown Prince, restored the fortunes of his family by effecting the overthrow of the enemy. A small detail recorded by the contemporary document indicates the severity of the struggle; for we are told that the heir-apparent, while preparing to retrieve the calamities of his house, was obliged to spend a night sleeping on the bare ground.

When Skandagupta came to the throne, in the spring of 455, he encountered a sea of troubles. The Pushyamitra danger had been averted, but one more formidable closely followed it, an irruption of the savage Huns, who had poured down from the steppes of Central Asia through the north-western passes, and carried devastation over the smiling plains and crowded cities of India. Skandagupta, who probably was a man of mature years and ripe experience, proved equal to the need, and inflicted upon the barbarians a defeat so decisive that India was saved for a time. His mother still lived, and to her the hero hastened with the news of his victory, ‘just as Krishna, when he had slain his enemies, betook himself to his mother Dēvakī.’ Having thus paid his duty to his living parent, the king sought to enhance the religious merit of his deceased father by the erection of a pillar of victory, surmounted by a statue of the god Vishnu, and inscribed with an account of the delivery of his country from barbarian tyranny through the protection of the gods.1

It is evident that this great victory over the Huns must have been gained at the very beginning of the new reign; because another inscription, executed in the year 458, recites Skandagupta's defeat of the barbarians, and recognizes his undisputed possession of the peninsula of Surāshtra (Kāthiāwār), at the western extremity of the empire. The king had appointed as viceroy of the west an officer named Parnadatta, the possessor of all the virtues, according to the official poet; and the viceroy gave the responsible post of governor of the capital city, Jūnāgarh, to his own son, who distinguished his tenure of office by rebuilding the ancient embankment of the lake under the Girnār hill, which had again burst with disastrous results in the year of Skandagupta's accession. The benevolent work was completed in the following year, and consecrated a year later by the erection of a costly temple of Vishnu.2

The dedication three years afterwards by a private Jain donor of a sculptured column at a village in the east of the Gorakhpur district, distant about 90 miles from Patna, testifies to the fact that Skandagupta's rule at this early period of his reign included the eastern as well as the western provinces.3

Five years later, in the year 465, the dedication of a temple to the Sun, in the country between the Ganges and Jumna now known as the Bulandshahr District, made by a pious Brahman in the reign of Skandagupta, described in the customary language as ‘augmenting and victorious’, indicates that the central portion of the empire also enjoyed a settled government.1 The conclusion therefore is legitimate that the victory over the barbarian invaders was gained at the beginning of the reign, and was sufficiently decisive to secure the general tranquillity of all parts of the empire for a considerable number of years.

But, about a. d. 465, a fresh swarm of nomads poured across the frontier, and occupied Gandhāra, or the north-western Panjāb, where a ‘cruel and vindictive’ chieftain usurped the throne of the Kushāns, and ‘practised the most barbarous atrocities’.2 A little later, about 470, the Huns advanced into the interior, and again attacked Skandagupta in the heart of his dominions. He was unable to continue the successful resistance which he had offered in the earlier days of his rule, and was forced at last to succumb to the repeated attacks of the foreigners; who were, no doubt, constantly recruited by fresh hordes eager for the plunder of India.

The financial distress of Skandagupta’s administration is plainly indicated by the abrupt debasement of the coinage in his latter years. The gold coins of his early and prosperous days agree in both weight and fineness with those of his ancestors, but the later issues, while increased in gross weight, so as to suit the ancient Hindu standard of the suvarṇa, exhibit a decline in the amount of pure gold in each piece from 108 to 73 grains.3 This marked lowering of the purity of the currency, which was accompanied by a corresponding degradation in the design and execution of the dies, evidently was caused by the difficulty which the treasury experienced in meeting the cost of the Hun war.

The death of Skandagupta, who assumed the title Vikramāditya like so many Indian kings, may be assumed to have occurred about the year 467. When he passed away, the empire perished, but the dynasty remained, and was continued in the eastern provinces for several generations. Skanda left no heir male capable of undertaking the cares of government in a time of such stress, and was accordingly succeeded on the throne of Magadha and the adjacent districts by his brother, Puragupta, the son of Kumāragupta I by Queen Ānanda.1

This prince, whose reign in Magadha possibly synchronized with that of Skandagupta, survived his brother for a very brief period. The only event which can be assigned to his reign is a bold attempt to restore the purity of the coinage. The rare gold coins, bearing on the reverse the title Prakāsāditya, which are generally ascribed to Puragupta, although retaining the gross weight of the heavy suvarṇa, contain each 121 grains of pure gold, and are thus equal in value to the aurei of Augustus, and superior in intrinsic value to the best Kushān or early Gupta coins.2

Puragupta was succeeded, about A. D. 467, by his son Narasimhagupta, who gave public proof of his partiality for Buddhism by building at Nālandā, in Magadha, the principal seat of Buddhist learning in Northern India, a brick temple more than 300 feet high, according to Hiuen Tsang, which was remarkable for the delicacy of its decorations and the lavish use of gold and gems in its furniture.3

The vigorous and successful action taken by Bālāditya to resist the tyranny of the Huns will be described presently.

Narasimhagupta was succeeded by his son, Kumāragupta II, to whose time the fine seal of alloyed silver found at Bhitarī in the Ghāzīpur District belongs.1 According to the chronology here followed, Kumāragupta II must have been very young when he came to the throne, and cannot have reigned for more than a year or two, in view of the fact that a prince named Budhagupta is acknowledged in a Sārnāth image inscription as the reigning sovereign in a. d. 476. The dominions of Kumāragupta II, like those of his father and grandfather, were evidently restricted to the eastern provinces of the empire of his earlier ancestors.

The precise identity of Budhagupta is as yet undetermined. He may possibly have been governor of Mālwā under Skandagupta, and after disowning allegiance to Narasimhagupta and Kumāragupta II, whose hold on Mālwā was doubtless precarious, have finally overthrown Kumāragupta II. It seems tolerably certain that his stronghold was in Mālwā, that his sway there lasted till a. d. 494, if not later, and that by a. d. 476 he was in possession of Benares.2

The imperial line passes by an obscure transition into a dynasty comprising eleven Gupta princes, who appear to have been for the most part merely local rulers in Magadha. These ‘Later Guptas of Magadha’, as they are called by archaeologists, shared the rule of that province with another dynasty of Rājas, who had names ending in -varman, and belonged to a clan called Maukhari. The territorial division between the two dynasties cannot be defined precisely, but the Maukhari dominion in the middle of the sixth century included Oudh. Their relations with one another were sometimes friendly and sometimes hostile, but the few details known are of little importance.1

The political decadence of Magadha never affected the reputation of the kingdom as the centre and head-quarters of Buddhist learning, which continued to be cultivated sedulously at Nālandā and other places under the Pāla kings up to the time of the Muhammadan conquest at the close of the twelfth century, when the monasteries with their well-stocked libraries were reduced to ashes. A good illustration of the reverence with which the Buddhist Holy Land continued to be regarded in the later Gupta age by foreign students of the doctrine of Gautama is afforded by the fact that, in the year a. d. 539, Wu-ti, or Hsiao Yen, the first Liang emperor of China and an ardent Buddhist, sent a mission to Magadha for the purpose of collecting original Mahāyānist texts and obtaining the services of a scholar competent to translate them. The local king, probably either Jīvitagupta I or Kumāragupta, gladly complied with the wishes of his imperial correspondent, and placed the learned Paramārtha at the disposal of the mission, which seems to have spent several years in India. Paramārtha then went to China, taking with him a large collection of manuscripts, many of which he translated. He arrived in the neighbourhood of Canton in a. d. 546, was presented to the emperor in 548, and died in China in 569, at the age of seventy. It was in the reign of the same emperor (502–49) that Bodhidharma, the son of a king in Southern India, and reckoned as the twenty-eighth Indian and first Chinese patriarch, came to China in a. d. 520, and after a short stay at Canton, settled at Lo Yang. His miracles are a favourite subject of Chinese artists.2

The most notable member of the Later Gupta dynasty1 was Ādityasena, who asserted his independence after the death of the paramount sovereign, Harsha, in a. d. 647, and even presumed to celebrate the horse-sacrifice in token of his claim to supreme rank. The last known Rāja of the dynasty was Jīvitagupta II, who reigned early in the eighth century. About the end of that century, or at the beginning of the ninth, Magadha passed under the sway of the Pāla kings of Bengal, whose history will be noticed in a subsequent chapter.

In addition to the records of Budhagupta, who seems to have belonged to the imperial line and to have acquired the sovereignty of the northern provinces, we find in the western province of Mālwā records of a Rāja named Bhānugupta, who at the beginning of the sixth century occupied a dependent position and presumably was subordinate to the Hun chieftains.

Towards the close of the fifth century, a chief named Bhatārka, who belonged to a clan called Maitraka,2 probably of foreign origin, established himself at Valabhī in the east of the peninsula of Surāshtra (Kāthiāwār), and founded a dynasty which lasted until about a. d. 770, when it is supposed to have been overthrown by Arab invaders from Sind. The earlier kings of Valabhī do not appear to have been independent, and were doubtless obliged to pay tribute to the Huns; but, after the destruction of the Hun domination, the lords of Valabhī asserted their independence, and made themselves a considerable power in the west of India, both on the mainland and in the peninsula of Surāshtra. The city was a place of great wealth when visited by Hiuen Tsang in the seventh century, and was famous in Buddhist church history as having been the residence of two distinguished teachers, Gunamati and Sthiramati, in the sixth century. I-tsing, a junior contemporary of Hiuen Tsang, tells us that in his time Nālandā in South Bihār and Valabhī were the two places in India which deserved comparison with the most famous centres of learning in China, and were frequented by crowds of eager students, who commonly devoted two or three years to attendance at lectures on Buddhist philosophy. This statement explains the assertion of Hiuen Tsang that Mo-la-p‘o, or Western Mālava, and Magadha were the two countries of India in which learning was prized, because Valabhī and Mo-la-p‘o were then politically one, both territories apparently being under the government of Dhruvabhata, the son-in-law of King Harsha, paramount sovereign of Northern India. After the overthrow of Valabhī, its place as the chief city of Western India was taken by Anhilwāra (Nahrwālah, or Pātan), which retained that honour until the fifteenth century, when it was superseded by Ahmadābād.1 The above observations will, perhaps, be sufficient to give the reader a notion of the way in which some of the fragments of the Gupta empire were apportioned among various native dynasties.

But the Huns, the foreign savages who shattered that empire, and dominated a large part of it for a short period, merit more explicit notice. The nomad tribes known as Huns, when they moved westwards from the steppes of Asia to seek subsistence for their hungry multitudes in other climes, divided into two main streams, one directed towards the valley of the Oxus, and the other to that of the Volga.

The latter poured into Eastern Europe in a. d. 375, forcing the Goths to the south of the Danube, and thus indirectly causing the sanguinary Gothic war, which cost the Emperor Valens his life in a. d. 378. The Huns quickly spread over the lands between the Volga and the Danube ; but, owing to chronic disunion and the lack of a great leader, failed to make full use of their advantageous position until Attila appeared, and for a few years welded the savage mass into an instrument of such power that he was ' able to send equal defiance to the courts of Ravenna and Constantinople '.1

His death, in a. d. 453, severed the only bond which held together the jealous factions of the horde, and within a space of twenty years after that event the Hunnic empire in Europe was extinguished by a fresh torrent of barbarians from Northern Asia.

The Asiatic domination of the Huns lasted longer. The section of the horde settled in the Oxus valley, and probably different in race, became known as the Ephthalites or White Huns, and gradually overcame the resistance of Persia, which ceased when King Fīrōz was killed in a. d. 484. Swarms of these White Huns also assailed the Kushān kingdom of Kābul, and thence poured into India. The attack repelled by Skandagupta in a. d. 455 must have been delivered by a comparatively weak body, which arrived early, and failed to effect a lodgement in the interior.2

About ten years later the nomads, having appeared in greater force, overwhelmed the kingdom of Gandhāra, or Peshāwar ; and starting from that base, as already related, penetrated into the heart of the Gangetic provinces, and overthrew the Gupta empire.3 The collapse of Persian opposition in 484 must have greatly facilitated the eastern movement of the horde, and allowed immense multitudes to cross the Indian frontier. The leader in this invasion of India, which, no doubt, continued for years, was a chieftain named Toramāna, who is known to have been established as ruler of Mālwā in Central India prior to A. D. 500. He assumed the style and titles of an Indian ‘sovereign of māhārājas’; and Bhānugupta, as well as the king of Valabhī and many other local princes, must have been his tributaries.1

When Toramāna died, about A. D. 502, the Indian dominion which he had acquired was consolidated sufficiently to pass to his son Mihiragula, whose capital in India was Sākala, the modern Siālkot, in the Panjāb.2

India at this time was only one province of the Hun empire. The head-quarters of the horde were at Bāmyin in Bādhaghīs near Herāt, and the ancient city of Balkh served as a secondary capital.3 The Hun king, to whose court, whether at Bāmyin or Herāt cannot be determined, Song-Yun, the Chinese pilgrim-envoy, paid a visit in A. D. 519, was a powerful monarch levying tribute from forty countries, extending from the frontier of Persia, on the west, to Khotan on the borders of China in the east. This king was either Mihiragula himself, or his contemporary overlord, more probably the latter. The local Hun king of Gandhāra, to whom Song-Yun paid his respects in the following year, A. D. 520, must be identified with Mihiragula. He was then engaged in a war with the king of Kashmīr (Ki-pin), which had already lasted for three years.4

With reference apparently to the same date approximately, the monk Cosmas Indicopleustes, who wrote a curious book in A. D. 547, describes a White Hun king, whom he calls Gollas, as being lord of India, from which he exacted tribute by oppression, enforcing his demands with the aid of two thousand war elephants and a great host of cavalry. This king, Gollas, certainly must have been Mihiragula.1

All Indian traditions agree in representing Mihiragula as a bloodthirsty tyrant, ‘the Attila of India,’ stained to a more than ordinary degree with the ‘implacable cruelty’ noted by historians as characteristic of the Hun temperament.2 Indian authors having omitted to give any detailed description of the savage invaders who ruthlessly oppressed their country for three-quarters of a century, recourse must be had to European writers to obtain a picture of the devastation wrought and the terror caused to settled communities by the fierce barbarians.

The original accounts are well summarized by Gibbon :—

‘The numbers, the strength, the rapid motions, and the implacable cruelty of the Huns were felt, and dreaded, and magnified by the astonished Goths; who beheld their fields and villages consumed with flames, and deluged with indiscriminate slaughter. To these real terrors, they added the surprise and abhorrence which were excited by the shrill voice, the uncouth gestures, and the strange deformity of the Huns. . . . They were distinguished from the rest of the human species by their broad shoulders, flat noses, and small black eyes deeply buried in the head; and, as they were almost destitute of beards, they never enjoyed the manly graces of youth or the venerable aspect of age.’1

The Indians, like the Goths, experienced to the full the miseries of savage warfare, and suffered an added horror by reason of the special disgust felt by fastidious, castebound Hindus at the repulsive habits of barbarians to whom nothing was sacred.

The cruelty practised by Mihiragula became so unbearable that the native princes, under the leadership of Yasodharman, a Rāja of Central India, appear to have formed a confederacy against the foreign tyrant.2 About the year a. d. 528, they accomplished the delivery of their country from oppression by inflicting a decisive defeat on Mihiragula.

Meanwhile, according to the testimony of Hiuen Tsang, Mihiragula’s younger brother had taken advantage of the misfortunes of the head of the family to usurp the throne of Sākala, which he was unwilling to surrender. Mihiragula, after spending some time in concealment, took refuge in Kashmīr, where he was kindly received by the king, who placed him in charge of a small territory. The exile submitted to this enforced retirement for a few years, and then took an opportunity to rebel and seize the throne of his benefactor. Having succeeded in this enterprise, he attacked the neighbouring kingdom of Gandhāra. The king, perhaps himself a Hun, was treacherously surprised and slain, the royal family was exterminated, and multitudes of people were slaughtered on the banks of the Indus. The savage invader, who worshipped as his patron deity Siva, the god of destruction, exhibited ferocious hostility against the peaceful Buddhist cult, and remorselessly overthrew the stūpas and monasteries, which he plundered of their treasures.

But he did not long enjoy his ill-gotten gains. Before the year was out he died ; and ‘ at the time of his death there were thunder and hail and a thick darkness, and the earth shook and a mighty tempest raged. And the holy saints said in pity : “ For having killed countless victims and overthrown the law of Buddha, he has now fallen into the lowest hell, where he shall pass endless ages of revolution ” ’. Thus the tyrant met the just reward of his evil deeds in another world, if not in this. The date of his death is not known exactly, but the event must have occurred in or about the year 542, just a century before Hiuen Tsang was on his travels. The rapidity of the growth of the legend concerning the portents attending the tyrant's death, though perhaps in a measure due to odium theologicum, emphasizes the depth of the impression made by his outlandish cruelty ; which is further attested by the Kashmīr tale of the fiendish pleasure which he is believed to have taken in rolling elephants down a precipice.1

Yasodharman, the Central Indian Rāja, who has been mentioned as having taken an active part in the supposed confederacy formed to obtain deliverance from the tyranny of Mihiragula, is known from three inscriptions only, and is not mentioned by Hiuen Tsang, who wrongly gives the sole credit for the victory over the Huns to Bālāditya, king of Magadha.2 Yasodharman erected two columns of victory inscribed with words commemorating the defeat of the foreign invaders. In these records he claims to have brought under his sway lands which even the Guptas and Huns could not subdue, and to have been master of Northern India from the Brahmaputra to the Western Ocean, and from the Himalaya to Mount Mahendra, which probably should be understood to mean the southernmost peak (Mahendragiri) of the Travancore Ghāts. But the indefinite, conventional expression of the boasts suggests that Yasodharman made the most of his achievements, and that his court poet was no stranger to Oriental hyperbole. Nothing whatever is known about either his ancestry, or his successors ; his name stands alone and unrelated. His reign may have covered roughly the first half of the sixth century, but its precise duration is unknown ; and his claim to fame rests solely upon his magniloquent inscriptions.1

The dominion of the White Huns in the Oxus valley did not long survive the defeat and death of Mihiragula in India. The arrival of the Turks in the middle of the sixth century changed the situation completely. The Turkish tribes, having vanquished a rival horde called Joan-joan, made an alliance with Khusrū Anūshīrvān, king of Persia, grandson of Fīrōz, who had been killed by the Huns in a. d. 484, and the allies at some date between 563 and 567 destroyed the White Huns. For a short time the Persians held Balkh and other portions of the Hun territory ; but the gradual weakening of the Sassanian power soon enabled the Turks to extend their authority towards the south as far as Kapisa, and annex the whole of the countries which had been included in the Hun empire.2

In later Sanskrit literature the term 'Hun' (Hūna) is employed in a very indeterminate sense to denote a foreigner from the north-west, in the same way as the word Yavana had been employed in ancient times, and as Wilāyatī is now understood. One of the thirty-six so-called 'royal' Rājpūt clans actually was given the name of Hūna.3 This vagueness of connotation raises some doubt as to the exact meaning of the term Hūna as applied to the clans on the north-western frontier against whom Harsha of Thānēsar and his father waged incessant war at the close of the sixth and the beginning of the seventh century. But it is unlikely that within fifty years of Mihiragula’s defeat the true meaning of Hūna should have been forgotten; and the opponents of Harsha may be regarded as having been outlying colonies of real Huns, who had settled among the hills on the frontier.

The Hūnas are often mentioned in books and inscriptions in connexion with the Gurjaras, whose name survives in the modern Gūjars, a caste widely distributed in North-western India. The early Gurjaras seem to have been foreign immigrants, closely associated with, and possibly allied in blood to the White Huns. They founded a considerable kingdom in Rājputāna, the capital of which was Bhilmāl or Srīmāl, about 50 miles to the north-west of Mount Ābū. In course of time the Gurjara-Pratihāra kings of Bhilmāl conquered Kanauj and became the paramount power in Northern India, as will be related in the fourteenth chapter. The minor Gurjara kingdom of Bharōch (Broach) was an offshoot of the Bhilmāl monarchy.

In this place I desire to draw attention to the fact, long suspected and now established by good evidence, that the foreign immigrants into Rājputāna and the upper Gangetic provinces were not utterly destroyed in the course of their wars with the native powers. Many, of course, perished, but many more survived, and were merged in the general population, of which no inconsiderable part is now formed by their descendants. The foreigners, like their forerunners the Śakas and Yüe-chi, universally yielded to the wonderful assimilative power of Hinduism, and rapidly became Hinduized. Clans or families which succeeded in winning chieftainship were admitted readily into the frame of Hindu polity as Kshatriyas or Rājpūts, and there is no doubt that the Parihārs and many other famous Rājpūt clans of the north were developed out of the barbarian hordes which poured into India during the fifth and sixth centuries. The rank and file of the strangers became Gūjars and other castes, ranking lower than the Rājpūts in the scale of precedence. Farther to the south, various indigenous, or ‘aboriginal’, tribes and clans underwent the same process of Hinduized social promotion, in virtue of which Gonds, Bhars, Kharwārs, and so forth emerged as Chandēls, Rāthōrs, Gaharwārs, and other well-known Rājpūt clans, duly equipped with pedigrees reaching back to the sun and moon. The process will be discussed further and illustrated in some detail when I come to deal with the mediaeval dynasties of the north.

The extinction of the Ephthalite power on the Oxus necessarily dried up, or at least greatly contracted, the stream of barbarian immigration into India, which enjoyed, so far as is known, almost complete immunity from foreign attack for nearly five centuries after the defeat of Mihiragula.1 The following chapters will tell how she made use, or failed to make use, of the opportunity thus afforded for internal development unchecked by foreign aggression.

Very little is known about the history of India during the second half of the sixth century. It is certain that no paramount power existed, and that all the states of the Gangetic plain had suffered severely from the ravages of the Huns and connected tribes; but, excepting bare catalogues of names in certain local dynastic lists, few facts of general interest have been recorded.

One of the many states into which India was divided during those troublous times deserves special notice, because the brief reference to its affairs by Hiuen Tsang has given occasion for much discussion and some misunderstanding. In a. d. 641, or early in 642, the pilgrim, after leaving Bharōch (Broach), travelled in a north-westerly direction for a considerable distance, apparently overstated in the Chinese text, until he arrived in a country called Mo-la-p'o, a name phonetically equivalent to Mālava. The unnamed capital, which was situated to the south-east of a great river, or, according to another reading, of the Mahi, has not been identified. If the 'great river' means the Sābarmatī, the capital may have stood at or near the site of Ahmadābād.1 Although it is impossible to reconcile all the data given in the pilgrim's text, and several details are open to controversy, it is clear that the kingdom or country of Mo-la-p'o essentially comprised the basin of the Mahi river, with the region to the east of the Sābarmatī and a portion of the hilly tract of Southern Rājputāna, perhaps extending as far east as Rutlam. Mo-la-p'o was bounded on the north by the Gurjara kingdom of Bhinmāl, on the north-west by the subordinate principality or province of Ānandapura (Varnagar), lying to the west of the Sābarmatī, and on the east by the kingdom (Avanti or Eastern Mālwa), of which Ujjain was the capital. Besides Ānandapura, two other countries, Ki-t'a or Ki-ch'a, and Su-la-ch'a or Su-la-tha were dependencies of Mo-la-p'o. The latter dependency certainly is to be identified with Soratha (Surāshtra), or Southern Kāthiāwār. The identity of the former is disputed—some good authorities holding the Chinese name to mean the Kaira (Kheda, Khetaka) District, while others believe it to mean Kachchh (Cutch).

The territory of Valabhī (Walā) in Eastern Kāthiāwār, which intervened between Mo-la-p'o and Surāshtra, had a king of its own, Dhruvabhata by name (Dhruvasena Bālāditya of inscriptions), who was the son-in-law of Harsha (Sīlāditya), paramount sovereign of Northern India. Some years before the pilgrim's visit, Dhruvabhata had been defeated by Harsha, and the matrimonial alliance seems to have been one of the arrangements made when peace was declared. In 643, when Harsha held the solemn assemblies at Kanauj and Prayāga (Allahābād), in which Hiuen Tsang took part, the Rāja of Valabhī attended as a vassal prince in the train of his father-in-law. The pilgrim does not say a word about the nature of the government of Mo-la-p'o and its three dependencies, Ānandapura, Surāshtra, and (?) Cutch, the reason apparently being that all these countries were administered on behalf of Harsha, whose father had fought the king of Mālava, perhaps Mo-la-p'o, at the close of the sixth century. The fact that Dhruvabhata is named as the Rāja or king of the Valabhī territory interposed between Mo-la-p o and its dependency, Surāshtra, can be explained by assuming that Harsha (Sīlāditya) purposely allowed his son-in-law to occupy a semi-independent position, governing not only Valabhī, but also Mo-la-p'o and its dependencies.

Study of the local records drew the attention of Hiuen Tsang to the history of Dhruvabhata's uncle, Sīlāditya, who had been king of Mo-la-p'o sixty years before. This prince was famed as having been a man of eminent wisdom and great learning, a zealous Buddhist, and so careful to preserve animal life that he caused the drinking water for his horses and elephants to be strained, lest perchance any creature living in the water should be injured. By the side of his palace he had built a Buddhist temple, remarkable for its artistic design and rich ornament, in which the images of the Seven Buddhas were enshrined. It was his custom to hold a grand assembly every year, at which the canonical dues and gifts were presented to the monks with liberality. This pious practice had been continued for successive generations to the time of Hiuen Tsang's visit.

M. Sylvain Lévi seems to be right in identifying this religious monarch with the Buddhist Sīlāditya I, surnamed Dharmāditya, 'the Sun of Piety', of the Valabhī dynasty, who reigned from about a. d. 595 to 610 or 615;1 for, although those dates do not agree with all the indications given by Hiuen Tsang, it is certain that Dhruvabhata, the reigning Rāja of Valabhī, was a nephew of Sīlāditya Dharmāditya, while Hiuen Tsang states that he was the nephew of the pious Sīlāditya, the former king of Mo-la-pʻo. The apparently necessary inference is that Sīlāditya Dharmāditya must have been king of Mo-la-pʻo by conquest in addition to his ancestral realm of Valabhī.1 Both territories subsequently were conquered by Harsha, and became subject to him as their suzerain.

The serious misunderstanding of the story above alluded to consisted in the erroneous belief held by Beal and several other writers that Mo-la-pʻo, or Western Mālava, was identical with the kingdom of Ujjain, otherwise known as Avanti or Eastern Mālava. Beal actually designated Sīlāditya of Mo-la-pʻo as ‘Sīlāditya of Ujjain’, forgetting that Hiuen Tsang described the territory of Ujjain as a separate kingdom equal in size to Mo-la-pʻo, and in his time ruled by a Brahman Rāja. Sīlāditya, the former Rāja of Valabhī and Mo-la-pʻo, was considered to be a Kshatriya, and there is no reason to suppose that he had anything to do with Ujjain.

Harsha (Sīlāditya), of Kanauj, is described by his friend Hiuen Tsang as being of the Vaisya caste, although he seems to have taken rank as a Kshatriya. The erroneous identification of Mo-la-pʻo with the kingdom of Ujjain has given rise to much confusion in the treatment of the history of Harsha’s period, and the main purpose of the observations made in the first edition of this work was the rectification of that embarrassing error. Those observations, which were themselves erroneous in certain respects, have now been corrected in the light of subsequent criticism and discussion.2

TBL-010 · FOLIO 389Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
DATE A. D.EVENT.REMARKS.
c. 271GuptaJain date for commence- ment of Gup- ta dynasty.
c. 290Ghaṭotkacha
c. 308Lichchhavi marriage of Chandra-gupta IFoundation of Gupta Era, of which year 1 began Febru- ary 26, 320
320Chandra-gupta I acc. to independent power
c. 330Samudragupta acc.
c. 330–6Campaigns in Northern India
c. 347–50Campaign in Southern India
c. 351Horse-sacrifice
c. 360Embassy from King Meghavarṇa of Ceylon
c. 380Chandra-gupta II acc.
c. 395Conquest of Western India
401Udayagiri inscriptionG. E. 82
405–11Travels of Fa-hien in Gupta empire” 86–92
407Gaṛhwā inscription” 88
409Silver coins of western type” 90
412Sāñchī inscription” 93
415Kumāragupta I acc.” 94
415Bilsaṛ inscription” 96
417Gaṛhwā inscription” 98
432Mathurā and Natore in N. Bengal inscrip- tions 1” 113
436Mandasōr inscriptionV.S. 493 (= G.E. 117)
”Bharadi inscriptionG. E. 117
440Silver coins” 121
443Silver coins” 124
447Silver coins” 128

senting P‘i-lo-mo-lo, the capital of Kü-che-lo (Gūjara), the Gurjara kingdom of Rājputāna; nor did it include Ujjain, N. lat. 23° 11′, E. long. 75° 47′, which was the capital of a separate kingdom (Avanti). Three texts of Hiuen Tsang give the name or epithet of the river as Mo-ha, = mahā, ‘great’; only the D text, which Lévi follows, reads Mo-hi, = Mahi (Watters). The bearings indicate that the river meant was the Sābarmatī rather than the Mahi. The identification of Ānandapura with Vaṛnagar is fully proved. Ki-t‘a or Ki-ch‘a is a good phonetic equivalent for Kheṭa (Kheṭaka, Kheḍa), the modern ‘Kaira’ District, but St. Martin, Julien, and Watters prefer to identify it with Kachchh (Cutch), and I am disposed to agree with them. The identity of Su-la-ch‘a or Su-la-tha with Soraṭha or Surāshṭra, Southern Kāthiāwār, is established by the mention of the hill Yüh-shan-to, or Yhu-shen-to, = Ujjanta (Ujjayanta, Ujjinta), = Girnār. Dhruvabhaṭa was the son-in-law of Harsha (Śīlāditya), not of his son (Watters, ii, 247). P‘i-lo-mo-lo = Bhilmala (Watters, ii, 250). For dates of Hiuen Tsang’s visits to Mo-la-p‘o, &c., see ‘Itinerary’ in Watters, ii, 335.

TBL-011 · FOLIO 390Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
DATE A. D.EVENT.REMARKS.
448Silver coins and Mankuwār inscription. Establishment of Huns in Oxus basin, and epoch of Hun eraG. E. 129
449Silver coins„ 130
c. 450Pushyamitra war„ 131
454Silver coins„ 135
455Silver coins„ 136
455Skandagupta acc. ; first Hun war„ 136
456Embankment of lake at Girnār rebuilt„ 137
457Temple erected there„ 138
460Kahāon inscription (Gōrakhpur District)„ 141
463Silver coins„ 144
464Silver coins„ 145
465Indōr inscription (Bulandshahr District)„ 146
467 c. 470–80Silver coins Puragupta (?) Narasimhagupta acc. Second Hun war„ 148 „ 151–61
473Mandasor inscription529 Mālava era expired
473Kumāragupta II acc.G. E. 154
476Budhagupta Āryabhata, astronomer, born„ 157
477Pāli inscription (Ep. Ind., ii, 363)„ 158
c. 480–90Partial break up of Gupta empire
484Fīrōz, king of Persia, killed by the Huns
c. 490 to 770Dynasty of Valabhī
500–2Toramāṇa in Mālwā
502–42Mihiragula
520Song-Yun visited White Hun king of Gandhāra
c. 528Defeat of Mihiragula by Yaśodharman
c. 535 to 720Later Gupta dynasty of Magadha
c. 595 to 615Śīlāditya of Mo-la-p'o and Valabhī

Notes

  1. 1. The reader who desires to pursue the subject should consult Professor Otto Franke's book, Pāli und Sanskrit, in ihrem historischen und geographischen Verhältniss auf Grund der Inschriften und Münzen, Strassburg, 1903.
  2. 2. The three cases referred to are those of Chandra-gupta I and Samudragupta, the patrons of Vasubandhu, and Naragupta Bālāditya, who erected buildings at Nālandā and was regarded by Hiuen Tsang as an earnest Buddhist. Chandra-gupta II must have been specially religious. His minister in the Vdayagiri inscription (Fleet, G. I., No. 6, p. 35) describes him as rājādhirājarshi, a combination of King and Rishi. So Rājā Bhīmasena in a. d. 601 describes himself as belonging to a family like, or equal to (tulya) the royal sages—rājādhirājarshi— scil. the Guptas (Hīra Lāl, Descr. List, p. 83).
  3. 1. Kālidāsa shows such intimate knowledge of small rivers and other details in Western Mālwā that in all probability he must have been a native of Mandasor (Dāsapura) or of some place in the immediate neighbourhood, and would thus have been brought into close touch with the court of Ujjain and the active life which centred in that capital (M. M. Haraparshad Shastri in J. B. & O. R. Soc., vol. i, pp. 197–212). The date of Kālidāsa has been the subject during recent years of much discussion, summed up, until November, 1911, by B. Liebich in his paper entitled ‘Das Datum des Kālidāsa’ (Indogerm. Forschungen, Strassburg, Band xxxi (1912), pp. 198–203). Among earlier references are : Macdonell, Hist. of Sanskrit Liter. (1900), p. 324, where Kālidāsa is assigned to the beginning of the fifth century ; Keith (J. R. A. S., 1909, pp. 433–9) who places the poet in the reign of Chandra-gupta II, though the mention of the Hūnas in Raghuvamśa iv makes it difficult to assign that work to a date so early. See J. R. A. S., 1909, pp. 731–9 ; and Ind. Ant., 1912, p. 265. The theory of Hoernle (J. R. A. S., 1909, p. 112), which places Kālidāsa's activity in the first half of the sixth century, has no defenders, and seems to me to rest upon erroneous premises. It is not unlikely that the early descriptive poems of Kālidāsa, namely, the Ṛitusamhāra and the Meghadūta, may have been composed before a. d. 413, that is to say, while Chandra-gupta II was on the throne, but I am inclined to regard the reign of Kumāragupta I (413–55) as the time during which the poet's later works were composed, and it seems possible, or even probable, that the whole of his literary career fell within the limits of that reign. It is also possible that he may have continued writing after the accession of Skandagupta. But I have no doubt that he flourished in the fifth century during the time when the Gupta power was at its height. For the order of composition of Kālidāsa's works, see M. M. Haraparshad Shastri in J. B. O. Res. Soc., vol. ii, pp. 179–89.
  4. 1. ‘The Gupta period is in the annals of classical India almost what the Periclean age is in the history of Greece’ (Barnett, J. R. A. S., 1917, p. 417).
  5. 1. For further information see G. R. Kaye, Indian Mathematics, Thacker, Spink & Co., Calcutta, 1915. H. P. Sāstri points out that Indian astronomers were in the habit of recording the date of their birth, and he shows good reason for believing that Varāhamihira indicates, without expressly affirming, a. d. 505 to be the date of his birth (J. & Proc. A. S. B., 1912, pp. 275–8).
  6. 1. The date of the Little Clay Cart (Mṛich-chhakaṭikā) is unknown. Prof. S. Lévi guesses that it may be posterior to Kālidāsa (Théâtre Indien, p. 208). I am disposed to follow older authors in assigning an earlier date. See transl. by Ryder in Harvard Or. Ser. Concerning the date of the Mudrā-Rākshasa, see Haas, ed. and transl., p. 39 (Columbia Univ. Press, N.Y., 1912) ; Hillebrandt, ‘ Ueber das Kauṭilīya-śāstra und Verwandtes ’ (86, Jahresber. der [p. 325] Schlesischen Gesellschaft für vaterl. Cultur, July, 1908, p. 29; Tawney in J. R. A. S., 1908, p. 910; 1909, p. 147. For the age of the Purāṇas see detailed discussion in Mr. Pargiter's book, The Dynasties of the Kali Age, and App. A, ante, p. 22. Mr. Kaye's observations on the relations between Indian and Greek mathematical science will be found in J. R. A. S., 1910, p. 759; J. & Proc. A. S. B., 1911, p. 813; and in 'Influence Grecque dans le Développement des Mathématiques Hindoues' (Scientia, vol. xxv, 1919, Bologna). For questions concerning art and architecture, see A History of Fine Art in India and Ceylon, and the references given in that work; and in the author's paper, 'Indian Sculpture in the Gupta Period' (Ostas. Zeitschr., April-Juni, 1914). The references to communications between India and China are collected in Duff, The Chronology of India, 1899. The Rāja of the Ka-p'i-li country sent an embassy in A. D. 428 (Watters, J. R. A. S., 1898, p. 540). Embassies, some probably only commercial ventures, number six from 502 to 515. There were also many journeys of pilgrims and missionaries. For communications with the Roman empire, see Priaulx, Indian Embassies to Rome (bound with Apollonius of Tyana), Quaritch, 1873; Reinaud, Relations politiques et commerciales de l'Empire Romain avec l'Asie orientale; and Duff, op. cit. The Roman influence on the Gupta coinage is discussed in my 'Coinage of the Early or Imperial Gupta dynasty', J. R. A. S., 1889. See also Sewell, 'Roman Coins found in India', ibid., 1904, pp. 591-637. The Gupta Buddhist monasteries at Sārnāth, Kasiā, &c., are described in the Annual Reports of the Archaeol. Survey since 1902-3.
  7. 1. See Appendix N, ‘Vasubandhu and the Guptas.’
  8. 2. Conjectured by Fleet (Ind. Ant. xviii, 228) to belong to the region of the Narmadā; but, more probably, in the north. Hoernle (J. R. A. S., 1909, p. 126) plausibly identifies the Pushyamitras with the Maitrakas under Bhatārka, who founded the Valabhī dynasty. The Purāṇas mention Pushyamitras and Paṭumitras among the miscellaneous dynasties, apparently foreign, who are enumerated just before the passage relating to the Guptas (Pargiter, Dynasties of the Kali Age, p. 73).
  9. 1. The column still stands at Bhitarī, in the Ghāzīpur District, to the east of Benares, but the statue has disappeared (Cunningham, Archaeol. Rep., vol. i, pl. xxix). The inscription on the column, which records the events related in the text, has been edited and translated by Fleet (Gupta Inscriptions, No. 13). The allusion to the Krishna legend is interesting. See J. R. A. S., 1907, p. 976.
  10. 2. Ibid., No. 14; ante, p. 140.
  11. 3. Ibid., No. 15, the Kahāon inscription.
  12. 1. Ibid., No. 16.
  13. 2. Sung-yun or Song Yun, Chinese pilgrim, a. d. 520, in Beal, Records, vol. i, p. c, and Chavannes’s revised version (Hanoi, 1903). But the name ‘Laelih’, given to this chieftain by Beal, who has been copied by Cunningham and many other writers, is purely fictitious, and due to a misreading of the Turkish title tégin (Chavannes, Les Turcs Occidentaux, p. 225 note).
  14. 3. The earlier Gupta coins, like the Kushān, are Roman aurei in weight and to some extent in design. The later pieces are Hindu suvarṇas, intended to weigh about 146 grains (9½ grammes) each, and are coarse in device and execution.
  15. 1. R. D. Banerji (‘The Chronology of the late Imperial Guptas’, Annals of Bhandarkar Institute, vol. i, pt. i, 1919) believes that Puragupta set himself up as a rival in Magadha, the home province of the Guptas, during Skandagupta’s absence at the time of the Hun invasion, and that Puragupta died about the same date, or very shortly after, Skandagupta.
  16. 2. An admitted difficulty in reconciling the testimony of the inscription on the Bhitarī seal (J. A. S. B., vol. lviii, part i, pp. 84–105) with that of other records is best solved in the manner stated in the text. The absence of Skandagupta’s name on the seal is accepted by R. D. Banerji (ibid.) as proof that he and his brother Puragupta were at enmity. For assays of the gold coins see Cunningham, Coins of Med. India, p. 16.
  17. 3. Chavannes, Religieux émin- [p. 330] ents, p. 94; Watters, ii, 170; Beal, ii, 173. For Tibetan account of Nālandā, see citation in Keay, Ancient Indian Education (Oxford Univ. Press, 1918, p. 105). Nālandā is now known as Bargāon (not Baṛāgāon), which is simply a modern name, meaning ‘village with a conspicuous banyan tree’, which stands there. Such names are extremely common in N. India (Bloch in J. R. A. S., 1909, p. 440).
  18. 1. J. A. S. B., part i, vol. lviii (1889), pl. vi.
  19. 2. R. D. Banerji, ‘The Chronology of the Late Imperial Guptas’ (Annals of Bhandarkar Institute, vol. i, part i, 1919). See also Panna Lal, ‘The Dates of Skandagupta and his Successors’ (Hindustan Review, January, 1918); and Romesh. C. Majumdar, ‘Revised Chronology of the Later Gupta Emperors’ (Ind. Ant., 1918, p. 166).
  20. 1. For these dynasties see Fleet, Gupta Inscriptions, and Dr. Hoernle's observations on the Bhitarī seal. For Maukhari coins, see Burn, J. R. A. S., 1906, p. 843; Ep. Ind., xiv, 114.
  21. 2. Bushell, Chinese Art, i, 24.
  22. 1. R. D. Banerji in his history in Bengali, Bāngālār Itihās, traces the descent of the Later Guptas from Govindagupta, second son of Chandra-gupta II (Thomas, in J. R. A. S., 1917, p. 855).
  23. 2. Hultzsch, Ep. Ind., iii, 320; correcting earlier interpretations. The original and more authentic form of the name is Bhaṭakka. Bhatārka is a Sanskritized spelling (Ep. Ind., xi (1913), p. 105). See N. G. Majumdar in Ind. Ant., vol. xlviii (1919), pp. 207–8 for reference to composition of Bhaṭakka's army.
  24. 1. The ruins of Valabhī at Walā, 18 or 20 miles north-west of Bhāonagar, are mostly underground. The history is given by Burgess in A. S. W. I., vol. ii, (1876), pp. 80–6, though his account is partly obsolete ; and by Bhagwān Lāl Indrajī and Jackson in Bomb. Gaz. (1896), vol. i, part i, pp. 78–106. The latest dynastic list is that in Kielhorn’s ‘ Supplement to List of Northern Inscriptions ’, App. B, p. 11 (Ep. Ind., vol. viii, April, 1905). For approximate date of destruction of Valabhī as a capital see Burgess, A. S. W. I., vol. vi, p. 3 ; vol. ix, p. 4. But certain traditions assert that the city was destroyed by Gūjars from Sind (J. A. S. B., part i, vol. lv (1886), p. 181). Valabhī even now exists as a country town (Bomb. Gaz., ut supra, p. 95, note 1).
  25. 1. Gibbon, ch. xxxv.
  26. 2. Hoernle (J. R. A. S., 1909, p. 128) denies the reality of the Hun invasion at the beginning of Skandagupta's reign, and dates the Bhitarī inscription as late as 468. But for the reasons stated (ante, p. 327) that inscription must have been recorded quite early in the reign. It mentions defeats of both the Pushyamitras and the Huns.
  27. 3. Ante, p. 328.
  28. 1. Three inscriptions naming Toramāna are known : namely, (1) at Ēraṇ, in Sāgar district, Central Provinces, dated in the first year of his reign (Fleet, Gupta Inscr., No. 36) ; (2) at Kura in the Salt Range, of which the date is lost (Ep. Ind., i, 238) ; and (3) at Gwālior, Central India, dated in the fifteenth year of Mihiragula, son of Toramāṇa (Fleet, No. 37). The silver coins of Toramāṇa, which imitate the Surāshtran coins of the Western Satraps and Guptas, are dated in the year 52, apparently reckoned from a special Hun era, probably beginning in A. D. 448 (J. A. S. B., vol. lxiii, part i (1894), p. 195).
  29. 2. The name of Mihiragula (‘Sunflower ’) also appears in the Sanskritized form of Mihirakula. His coins are numerous at Chiniōt and Shāhkōt, situated respectively in the Jhang and Gujrānwāla Districts of the Panjāb. The coins of Toramāṇa and Mihiragula are fully described in J. A. S. B., 1894, part i.
  30. 3. Chavannes, Turcs Occidentaux, pp. 224, 226. Gurgān (Gorgō), often asserted to be the Ephthalite capital, really was a frontier town belonging to Persia (Chavannes, op. cit., pp. 223, 235 note).
  31. 4. Beal, Records, vol. i, pp. xci, c. The name Lae-lih, given by Beal, [p. 336] is, as already noted, fictitious (ante, p. 328 note). In the time of Song-Yun Ki-pin usually signified Kashmīr, though at times it seems to have meant, or included, Gandhāra also. In the seventh century Ki-pin ordinarily, though not invariably, meant Kapiśa, or North-eastern Afghanistan (Chavannes, Song Yun, pp. 37, 39).
  32. 1. McCrindle’s translation (Hakluyt Society, 1897), p. 597.
  33. 2. Hiuen Tsang; Rājataraṅgiṇī. The Turushka king of Tāranāth (Schiefner, p. 94) may mean Mihiragula. There are some grounds for the belief that the horrible tales told about Mihiragula are to some extent Brahman inventions, due to the fact that he was a sunworshipper, who favoured Zoroastrian priests. The ‘Gandhāra Brahmans’ of Rājataraṅgiṇī, Bk. i, v. 307, apparently were ‘Zoroastrian Mobeds’ (J. J. Modi in Anthrop. Papers, vol. ii (1918), p. 340). Zoroastrianism seems to have had a great hold on the Panjāb and part of Rājputāna in the sixth century.
  34. 1. Gibbon, ch. xxvi.
  35. 2. See J. J. Modi, ‘The Early History of the Huns’ (J. B. B. R. A. S., vol. xxiv (1916–17), pp. 589–95). Panna Lall also rejects the legend recorded by Hiuen Tsang.
  36. 1. Hiuen Tsang, in Beal, Records, vol. i, pp. 165–72 ; Watters, I, i, 288. It is not easy to explain why the pilgrim alleges (p. 167) that Mihiragula lived ‘ some centuries ’ before his time. The Chinese words, sho-pih-nien-tsin, are said not to be capable of any other interpretation (Beal, Ind. Ant., xv, 345). Watters is inclined to think that the tale told by Hiuen Tsang refers to a Mihiragula of much earlier date. Fleet suggests that there may be an error in the Chinese text. K. B. Pathak in ‘ New Light on Gupta Era and Mihirakula ’ (Ind. Ant., xlvii, 1918) shows good reasons for discarding the pilgrim's statement as baseless, basing his view upon the evidence of Jain chronicles, supported by certain inscriptions and coins. He appears to me to be correct. Hiuen Tsang's travels extended from 629 to 645. For the Kashmīr legends see Stein, transl. Rājat., Bk. i, pp. 289–325.
  37. 2. The weight of evidence is now decidedly in favour of the rejection of Hiuen Tsang's story. The evidence in favour of the view that Yasodharman, king of Mālwā, was responsible for the final defeat of Mihiragula is summed up by J. J. Modi in ‘ The Early History of the Huns ’ (J. B. B. R. A. S., vol. xxiv (1916–17), pp. 594–5) ; and this view is accepted by other scholars, e. g. K. B. Pathak in J. B. B. R. A. S., vol. xix, p. 39.
  38. 1. Inscriptions Nos. 33, 34, 35 in Fleet, Gupta Inscriptions.
  39. 2. Chavannes, op. cit., pp. 226–9,
  40. 3. Bühler, Ep. Ind., i, 225 : Sylvain Lévi, Notes chinoises sur l'Inde, No. iii, 'La Date de Candragomin' (Hanoi, 1903), p. 25. See also Tod's Annals and Antiquities of Rājasthān (ed. Crooke, 1920, vol. i, pp. 131–3, and list facing p. 98). A Brahman poet of Southern India, writing about a. d. 1600, applied the term Hūna to the Portuguese, whom he described [p. 340] as ‘very despicable, devoid of tenderness, regardless of Brahmans, and careless of ceremonial purity’ (Burnell, cited by Morse Stephens, Albuquerque, p. 206).
  41. 1. Defeat of Mihiragula about a. d. 528; permanent occupation of the Panjāb by Mahmūd of Ghaznī, about a. d. 1023. The Arab conquest of Sind, in the eighth century, was an isolated operation, producing little impression on the rest of India. If any incursions by nomads occurred during the seventh, eighth, ninth, and tenth centuries, they have not been recorded.
  42. 1. The old Hindu name of the city represented by Ahmadābād was Asāwal.
  43. 1. A new copper-plate grant of 1920, p. 54). It records a grant of Śīlāditya I, dated a. d. 608–9, has land for the maintenance of a recently been deciphered by Mr. temple of the Sun-god. R. D. Banerji (Prog. Rep. A. S. W. I.,
  44. 1. Hoernle seeks to prove that the elder Sīlāditya should be identified with Yaśodharman, the conqueror of the Huns, but without success, in my judgement (J. R. A. S., 1909, p. 122).
  45. 2. It is impossible to discuss the Mo-la-pʻo problem fully within the limits of a note. References are: Hiuen Tsang (Beal, ii, pp. 260–70; Watters, ii, pp. 242–8); Cunningham, Anc. Geogr., pp. 489–94; Stein, transl. Rājatar., vol. i, p. 66; Max Müller, India, What can it Teach us? p. 288; Hoernle (J. R. A. S., 1903, p. 553); Vincent Smith (Z. D. M. G., 1904, pp. 787– 96); Burn (J. R. A. S., 1905, p. 837); Grierson (J.R.A.S., 1906, p. 95); Burgess (ibid., p. 220; Ind. Ant., 1905, p. 195); Sylvain Lévi (Journal des Savants, Oct., 1905, pp. 544–8). The text, which differs from that in the first edition, is based on consideration of all the above-mentioned publications. Some special points may be noted. Mo-la-pʻo did not include Bhinmāl (Bhilmāl, Bhinnamāla, Bhillamāla, also called Śrīmāl), repre-
  46. 1. The Natore inscription of A. D. 432 is the earliest copper-plate known (J. & Proc. A. S. B., 1911, Feb., Ann. Rep., p. xviii).